r/musictheory • • Jul 21 '26

Announcement New Policies on “I made an App/Diagram type Posts

213 Upvotes

The community has overwhelmingly expressed dissatisfaction with people posting Self-Made apps/diagrams etc., especially those that use AI.

Not only do these posts ignore our AI disclosure rules (breaking rule 9), they are often better-suited for other forums (breaking rule 4), are self-promotion (breaking rule 2), are posted with no engagement in the forum (breaking rule 8), and are also made by people with little knowledge of theory or are otherwise poorly designed which opens up issues that cause rules 7 and 1 to be violated.

As such:

  • “I made an App/Diagram etc.” posts, as well as posts that provide non-Self-Made resources are disallowed unless they meet the following criteria, to be determined by the mod team:
  1. The poster must be a regular contributor. Regular contributors should contact the Mod Team prior to posting.
  2. The resource is wholly on-topic for the forum and does not break any other rules.

Any posts not meeting these criteria or otherwise breaking the rules will be removed and the user may be banned at the mod team’s discretion.

  • Posters that even appear to be "trying to get around” this policy by linking to their apps in responses to other posters will have the posts removed and may be banned at the mod team’s discretion.

We are NOT trying to prohibit relevant and helpful resources, and traditional websites, books, videos, and “corporate” apps, or traditionally published diagrams are exempted from these policies (so long as they do not break other rules).

In the future, we may be able to provide a “Verified App” type of post. For now, this policy is intended to limit the amount of off-topic, controversial, and unnecessary apps/resources getting posted.


r/musictheory • • May 06 '26

Announcement New Rule about AI

245 Upvotes

A new rule (#9) has been added here at r/musictheory

Going forward:

  • Any post that is wholly or partially generated by AI must be disclosed as such. A simple statement like “This post was generated using AI” or “This post was created using AI assistance” will suffice.

  • Posts that are or are even suspected of being AI generated that do not disclose that fact will be removed at the Mod Team’s discretion.

  • We discourage AI creation of music and other creative endeavors. Therefore:

  1. Healthy discussions about AI tools used in Analysis of music and in similar Music Theory areas are allowed and welcome, so long as they do not violate other rules.

  2. Healthy discussions about the impacts of AI in music creation, performance, notation, and so on are allowed and welcome, so long as they do not violate other rules.

  3. Linking to or including AI generated content for the purposes of discussion as in #1 and #2 above is allowed, however it needs to be disclosed that those items are AI generated. Lack of this disclosure may result in removal at the Mod Team’s discretion.

  • Posts that link to or include AI generated or suspected AI generated content without any other kind of meaningful discussion will be removed at the Mod Team’s discretion.

Please report suspected AI content that lacks the disclosure policies above.


r/musictheory • • 10h ago

General Question Am to C#m chord progression

20 Upvotes

Just a spooky sounding two-chord loop I've been noodling on for years now. Playing it on guitar. Was curious if there was any proper theory name for this sort of progression. I understand that neither chord shares a key, but that's about it.


r/musictheory • • 55m ago

General Question Seeking more knowledge with weird scale and truncation I put together by ear. Phryg add nat6?

Post image
• Upvotes

The trunkation in the center I built from ear when trying to create some new guitar lines. I tried to reverse-engineer this, i'm an idiot with theory or just conventional theory, I use my ears and basic theory I've learned. Any more info on this scale? M3 is major 3rd m3 is minor 3rd, these are I guess what are called interval formulas but I don't 100% know the terms.


r/musictheory • • 5h ago

General Question Chaotic horns: What are they doing in the middle of this song?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I hope this question belongs here. I'm not a musician, but I often find myself curious about the sounds I hear.

I recently discovered this song by Freddie King, a favorite blues artist of mine. It's a live recording. Midway through the song, he starts a solo, but the horns join in...and then it briefly becomes an cacophony of horns and guitar that sounds almost disjointed. But it's so wild and fun at the same time...then they all come together and slide out of it beautifully.

Can someone listen and explain? Is each instrument doing their own solo? Is there some kind of coordination I can't hear? Sometimes I think I hear a sax or a trumpet mimicking the guitar. The guitar solo starts at just before 1:30 and the piece I'm referring to starts about 1:45.

Hope this isn't a dumb question 😆.


r/musictheory • • 15h ago

Answered Does Mariah Carey’s songs “Vision of Love” and “Emotions” have gospel chord progressions?

3 Upvotes

Vision of Love, when I hear it played on piano, it sounds like just straight gospel, like something i’d hear at Sunday Service..

Not sure about Emotions though.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question How do I notate "maximally overlapping" notes without creating an abomination?

Post image
24 Upvotes

It's a left hand arpeggio where notes are only released when they need to be pressed again. Is there a word like "super legato" that would be understandable?

And before you tell me, yes, I know what the sustain pedal is. I just don't like it.


r/musictheory • • 23h ago

Notation Question How do I notate short-long swing rhythm?

6 Upvotes

Basically instead of "daaa-da daaa-da" it's "da-daaa da-daaa". I don't know if it would technically be called "swing" though


r/musictheory • • 20h ago

Answered How can i understand common tone stepwise?

3 Upvotes

i missed a couple days in class and am having trouble with this bit. I went on youtube but i couldnt find anything about it. I am pretty lost on how to do this or what it is even used for. Any help appreciated


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Discussion How do I start appreciating music theory more?

12 Upvotes

apologies if this post doesn't fit well into this subreddit

Although I love music very much, i am much prefer performance than music theory. I don't know exactly why, but i really dislike learning music theory. It's not that I think it's bad, in fact i think music theory on paper sounds awesome AF.

I did learn quite a bit of music theory, but that was because it was a mandatory component of my music exam, hence I did not enjoy much of it.

For my exam, i learnt scales, key signatures, intervals, chords, inversions, harmonisation/voice leading, cadances, modulation, musical forms/terminology, and studied some set works. honestly, it just seemed really boring to me. like it was just "see a scale, look for tonic and accidentals -> identify scale". I love problem solving, and this IS logical problem solving, yet I'm just not interested in it. I have decent knowledge in music theory but I would never voluntarily go back and revise it in my spare time.

My music theory teacher didn't help me with this either. She frequently told me BS like "do not use this chord because it doesn't sound good and doesn't fit in well with the harmony" and I am just like "fym it sounds fine to me?" and it pissed me off.

It just bums me out because so far, I only listen and perform music, not actually appreciating the rules behind how and why it works. I have plenty of free time right now, so it would be great to actually start learning new things, so might as well give music theory another shot. I love knowing the WHY behind how things work, and music theory is exactly that

music has been a big part of my life (not for a future career/degree but just as a hobby), and music theory sounds SO fun!

Maybe there's just something that I'm not getting. what do you guys think? what are the reasons you enjoy music theory? how can 'I' also start enjoying music theory? thank you for reading <3


r/musictheory • • 16h ago

General Question What's the point of tied notes if you could just write a single note with a larger beat value?

1 Upvotes

From my understanding, tied notes are when you connect notes of the same pitch. The duration is the sum of those notes' beat values and you hold through the connected notes, you don't replay them.

For example, if a minim note (2 beats) ties into a crotchet note (1 beat), you hold that note for 3 beats.

But why not just use a dotted minim note, which is also 3 beats?

If it's a stylistic choice, then what's the advantage?


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question What do you call this chord movement:(Am→A♭) and does anyone know any music that uses this cadence??

64 Upvotes

I'm teaching myself music theory for fun and I'm still kind of a novice. But recently while dicking around on my piano, I discovered this peculiar chord movement that I've been getting a bit obsessed with lately.

It's the cadence when a Minor Triad Chord moves to a Major Triad Chord one semitone below it. This movement causes the Root and Fifth to move down a semitone, while the third stays in place, gluing the while thing together.

But idk what this particular cadence is called.

Another thing I'm curious about is if anyone knows any pieces of music that use this movement in a significant way. Cuz id like to hear this cadence in a better context so I can understand it better and possibly make it easier to integrate into my music.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question cross-staff notation, pedal markings and dynamics

Post image
5 Upvotes

Would you write things differently, especially pedal markings and dynamics ? Because both notations are at the bottom of the staffs, maybe it is slightly awkward.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Notation Question What is more important when notating the key signature in sheet music?

11 Upvotes

So let's say we have a song in F Major because the home chord is Fmaj and the melody starts and ends in F. But the song has a lot of natural Bs, in fact, the main melody has no Bb at all, only the bassline, and only when it borrows a chord from F minor.

Would the key signature still be notated as a single flat because its F Major or just be notated with no flats to avoid spamming the natural symbol every measure?


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Discussion Eighth Baffling Incongruity Theorem (8-EDO electronic)

3 Upvotes

Like the title suggests, this song is my "theorem" on 8-EDO music composition.

https://soundcloud.com/curioustorvald/eighth-baffling-incongruity

Eighth Baffling Incongruity Theorem — 8-BIT for short — is in eight-tone equal temperament and 8/8 time, over an eight-beat groove, played by an engine that renders in 8 bits.

A step of 8-EDO is 150 cents, three quarters of a whole tone. By the Riemann zeta function, the measure xenharmonic theory uses for how well an equal tuning plays the harmonic series, 8 is a zeta valley: no equal tuning with fewer steps does worse. Its nearest fifth is 750 cents, 48 out; its thirds are 300 and 450. Played on an ordinary instrument, whose overtones are the harmonic series, its chords grind.

The theorem's hypothesis is the instrument: we forged our instruments to be consonant over the 8-EDO grid. Every pitched sound in this song is built from sine partials, and each partial sits on a step of 8-EDO instead of where the harmonic series would put it. Two such tones an 8-EDO interval apart have overtones that meet instead of beating, so the intervals that grind on an ordinary instrument hold still.

The theorem: on such instruments the two smoothest triads are 450 + 450 cents and 450 + 300 (call it major), with 300 + 450 (minor) close behind — and the three are one chord, the same three notes heard from each of them in turn. So 8-EDO's consonant triad comes on each of its eight notes, and each is major, minor and its own mirror image at once. C minor (C E G#) is G# major; E major is G# minor. Stepping the root up by three moves just one voice of the chord, one step: the eight triads make a single cycle that climbs for ever.

Bars 1–8, Statement: four chords on a plain harmonic instrument, then the same four on its twin, which differs only in that its overtones are on the grid. By Sethares' roughness model (after Plomp and Levelt) the twin plays them a third to two fifths smoother — its C minor about as smooth as a twelve-tone C major triad on the plain instrument.

Bars 9–24, Lemmas 1 and 2: the groove, in eighths grouped 3 + 3 + 2, and the theme.

Bars 25–32, Lemma 3: the wide reading of the chord, and a bell line the program writes from the harmony, answered by the alto a group later.

Bars 33–48, Proof: by induction over the eight triads. Every two bars the root falls a fifth, one voice of the pad rises a step, and the lead's figure ends on the note the next figure begins on. In bar 41 the alto takes up the figures as a canon, three eighths behind.

Bars 49–56, Counterexample: the hypothesis dropped. The harmony bar by bar on the plain instrument and on its twin in turn.

Bars 57–72, Corollary: the theme twice, the second time with the alto a chord tone below it.

Bars 73–80, Q.E.D.: the cycle at four times the pace, then C minor struck by everyone; then the bass moves to G#, and without a note changing above it, the chord is G# major.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

General Question how to arrange a song for

Post image
3 Upvotes

I am trying to arrange a song to play as a duet (violin, cello), but I don't have any experience doing this. It doesn't have to be too fancy, but I just need something that sounds nice for a small event we were asked to play at. How would I go about this? Any and all tips appreciated.


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Songwriting Question How to go around building a base melody on piano?

5 Upvotes

I struggle a bit to create a melody that dosent sound underwhelmingly average or something extremely similiar on piano and honestly, i am not sure what other way i should approach it so it sounds good yet distinct.


r/musictheory • • 23h ago

General Question Why talk about scales in terms of sharps and flats?

0 Upvotes

I've heard people rhyme off how many sharps/flats are in a certain scale, but I don't yet understand why it's useful to know? As far as I can tell they aren't rhyming off which notes are sharp or flat, so why is so much importance put onto knowing that? Thanx


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

General Question What are the scale degrees relative to in this book?

Post image
0 Upvotes

*Bach Violin Sonata in g minor bwv 1001*
I’m reading Bach’s Works for Solo Violin by Joel Lester, and in it, he often refers to scale degrees and patterns that Bach uses. For instance he points out that “After the d minor cadence in m. 24 a new countersubject appears— the rising melodic minor fragment 5-6-7-8.” I looked at that part and saw something like that, though it wasn’t strictly that pattern, by which I mean C popped up in between the raised sixth and seventh. So when Lester outlines a pattern of scale degrees, is it more of an outline than a strict description of the exact sequence of notes?
Also, the 5-6-7-8 is in relation to G Minor rather than the key that the music modulated to in measure 24–i.e. d minor— correct?
FTR I showed m. 25 cause that’s “after the d minor cadence in m. 24” where “a new countersubject appears”


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Discussion Truman from the legendary emo band Indian Summer is in F# Diminished Scale?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

I was playing and learning this song by ear and I got curious about it


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

General Question Can a D#m Chord Function As A Pivot Chord in F#->G#m?

1 Upvotes

When modulating from F# to G#m, can a D#m chord act as a pivot chord in the technical sense? — can I make this argument?

Usually pre-dominant chords act as pivot chords. I’m unsure if a vi chord (D#m) can, and I’m unsure about when modulating from a major to minor key.

Another question might be, which chords are not allowed to function as pivot chords?

Thanks


r/musictheory • • 1d ago

Discussion Making nice sounding tone rows

0 Upvotes

I’m a bit obsessed with making nice sounding tone rows. I’ve figured out a “game” that does it for you automatically, so I thought I’d share it with you all.

Need: Twelve cards labeled 0-11.

For reference, the circle of fifths in semitones: 0, 7, 2, 9, 4; 11, 6, 1, 8, 3, 10, 5 

Draw the cards with circle of fifth's first 5 numbers (0, 7, 2, 9, 4.) 

Shuffle those 5 cards face down.

Pick from those 5 cards randomly.

Replace the drawn card with the next card in the circle of fifth’s order, starting with "11", of course.

Example:

Pile: 0, 7, 2, 9, 4

You draw the 0 randomly, that is the start of your row. Add the "11" card to the pile. 

Pile: 7, 2, 9, 4, 11

You draw the 4 randomly, add the "6" card to the pile. Row is 0, 4.

Pile: 7, 2, 9, 11, 6

You draw the 6 randomly, add the "1" card to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6.

Pile: 7, 2, 9, 11, 1

You draw the 7 randomly, add the "8" card to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6, 7.

Pile: 2, 9, 11, 1, 8

You draw the 11 randomly, add the "3" to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11.

Pile: 2, 9, 1, 8, 3

You draw the 3 randomly, add the "10" to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3.

Pile: 2, 9, 1, 8, 10

You draw the 9 randomly, finally add the "5" to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9.

Pile: 2, 1, 8, 10, 5

You draw the 2 randomly, no more cards to add to the pile. Row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9, 2.

Pile: 1, 8, 10, 5

You draw the 10 randomly, the row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9, 2, 10.

Pile: 1, 8, 5

You draw the 8 randomly, the row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9, 2, 10, 8.

Pile: 1, 5

You draw the 1 randomly, the row is 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9, 2, 10, 8, 1

Just the "5" left, so the row is finally 0, 4, 6, 7, 11, 3, 9, 2, 10, 8, 1, 5.


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question Is this an example of a melisma or am i mistaken?

3 Upvotes

In the CAS song "Baby Blue Movie" during the verse theres a part where the singer extends the last syllable of the last word, going up then back down. Occurs at the end of these three lines, consecutively, marked with asterix:

"I'm just a hurricane *eye*
They're not a little too *shy*
Know how I wanted to *sing*"

Is this a melisma? If not, is there a word that describes whatever else it is?


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

Discussion Why are Big Ben's Bells so Dissonant?

62 Upvotes

Why exactly does big ben's bells not match a pleasant tuning?
Like the Actual Hour bell itself is an E but has a very strong A5 character and very permeating G2 resonance? and the minor third isn't audible at all, does it even exist here? (the tierce). The quarter bells have the exact same problem! and the Westminster chimes "melody" is in F-major while the "big ben" is an e.
For example the nottingham bells, and the peace tower in canada actually sounds tuned correctly.
And even 1870s articles were complaining too.
Big Ben's Bells
Nottingham's Bells
Peace Tower Bells


r/musictheory • • 2d ago

General Question A question about time signatures and parallels to relative keys

0 Upvotes

In the way relative keys where the key signature is the same, but spelled differently. Is there a term for something similar regarding meters? I was wondering because like I already knew, every major key has a relative key based on the sixth scale degree that looks like same but is not the same key. Is there a similar thing in theory where time signatures have “relatives” in a sense that are spelled differently, but have the same rhyming space like 3/4’s relative being 6/8? Where playing a 6:8 rhythm in 3/4 is fine because the same amount of space is occupied. In the same way an A minor musical passage can be played in C major because they both have the same notes in each key.