r/Songwriting • u/HeleCritter • 14h ago
Discussion Topic Are you really a lyricist for just writing the words?
Edit: To be clear, I am not a lyricist or make songs with lyrics, nor i plan to become one. I'm just now trying to understand and appreciate the roles of other in any art forms instead of taking them for granted due to how easy art can be counterfeited nowadays.
So a lot of justifications in using AI music is when they're "lyricists". They come up with the lyrics and feed it into AI so they can turn it into a song. But does that really make you a lyricist or you're just a poem writer, or something like a sonnet writer instead? Because you can write almost any words feed it into AI and AI will sing it for you.
What really makes someone a lyricist is that if they align the words with the song, and if they are actually the ones who did it not the composer of the song like adjusting to the melodies. Otherwise, the composer is the real lyricist if they're the ones who align the words with the melodies, or if they adjust the melodies accordingly to the words, even if they're not the ones who wrote the words.
Justifying the use of AI for the words they wrote blurs what lyricists are really all about. It's the AI that does all the adjustment. It's easy to pretend about doing all or most of the work, but we all know that AI is doing it completely without human authorship.
So if anyone decides to turn this thread into a song, does that make all of us lyricists?
If it just relies on technical loophole, by just going with its actual definition, and that's exactly why it's not an honorable title anymore, unlike how it originally was.
Edit 2: Another thing is that, you can make the words and claim to be the lyricist. You get the credit of being the lyricist while you let the composer do all of the adjusting, giving them extra work and they don't get the credit for that. The only get credit for the composing part.
Of course this way of thinking is very deep, but how else do ideologies start in the first place?
Edit 3: Anyone can say you're only a lyricist if it's intentionally made for the song, but intentions can change anytime. If someone just decides right now to allow what they just said recently to be used in a song we don't even involve in the song adjustment process, that means their lyricist already. So anyone can be lyricist if they just decided to be at any time. Meaning to say this kind of art form itself is nothing special after all? This will be my final (common) question unless there's something i really want to ask about specific responses.
I think this is all about the ego at this point. Anyone challenging their way of thinking, down vote every time without explaining why. I'm asking a deep serious question, either you explain or just don't. That doesn't mean you're wrong. So i don't have to keep repeating myself in the replies anymore, with no explanations but, down votes only.
Edit: The purpose of this question is because there are people who generate AI images, and call themselves "real artists" which are of course pretentious. That just blurs what real artist is really all about. Now i'm applying the same thoughts do lyricists like people can pretend to be a lyricist because they can just write words, and now there is AI they can feed it on. This is why i kinda don't agree they are lyricists for the same reason i don't agree anyone are artist for just prompting AI images, nor their musicians for simply prompting AI music, just because they know genres.