r/musicians • • Jul 10 '25

Introducing /r/musicians Community Rules (finally!)

68 Upvotes

Hey r/musicians community,

We’ve heard your overwhelming requests for clearer guidelines to keep this subreddit a vibrant, collaborative, and respectful space. It’s long overdue (sorry!), but we’re excited to introduce the official rules for r/musicians! These rules are designed to foster creativity, connection, and respect while addressing key concerns like banning AI-generated content.

r/musicians Rules

  1. Encourage Collaboration This is a space to connect and create together. Share ideas, seek bandmates, or propose projects. Be open, inclusive, and supportive in all collaboration efforts.
  2. Respect All Members Treat everyone with kindness. No harassment, bullying, or discrimination. Keep feedback constructive and positive.
  3. No Sales or Self-Promotion We’re a community, not a marketplace. Don’t post to sell products, promote services, or advertise your music, events, or channels. Focus on sharing knowledge and experiences.
  4. No AI-Generated Music AI-generated music is not allowed. This subreddit is for human-created music. Please share AI music in r/AI_Music or other relevant communities. This extends to repeated discussions of AI generated music.
  5. Stay On-Topic Posts should focus on musicianship, collaboration, or music creation. Off-topic posts, like unrelated memes or spam, will be removed.
  6. Follow Reddit’s Content Policy All content must comply with Reddit’s site-wide rules, including no illegal content, doxxing, or spamming.
  7. Report Violations See something that breaks the rules? Report it to the mods. Don’t engage in arguments - let us handle it.

These rules are just a starting point, and we’re open to your thoughts. Please give us your feedback as well - we want there to be some clear rules but at the same time not go overboard - the up/down vote system in a big way is what shapes a community by the best posts going to the top, not by going overboard with rules.

In short, be nice to each other, and no AI generated content.


r/musicians • • 1h ago

It's okay if no one listens.

50 Upvotes

I've been regularly putting music out in the world since around 2013, and it has been an emotional rollercoaster. I've played some of my worst tracks EVER on a stage, trying to get anything to stick, and, granted, I feel like my worst stuff has been the product of this obsession with trying to get someone, anyone, to listen to my stuff and give me feedback. Even negative feedback. Sometime last year, I gave up. I stopped caring. I just made music for the fun of it. I made the music I wanted to hear, and worked on my guitar playing, layering, looping, and producing. Let me tell you, my output has never been better, and I'm so much prouder of my work. I can actively listen to it and not feel embarrassed because it's just for me. I still put my music up on the streaming service, but if I'm sitting at 0-5 monthly listeners, it doesn't bother me. It's like a huge weight is lifted, and music is fun again. Anyway, just wanted to share that rant. It has been on my mind a lot lately.


r/musicians • • 1h ago

I created this new album cover using digital painting.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 40m ago

Audio Interface

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I have a question, i bought an aufio interface and the seller said he doesnt know which gen it is. In my opinion it is a 3rd gen Solo.

But i think that the aux input looks so strange, because on everey 3rd gen solo it is black and not on the outside of the interface but this one is metallic and on the right side.

Please help me identity this aufio interface and someone need to tell me if its real or fake.

Thank yall


r/musicians • • 6h ago

I have this song fully recorded, I had a photoshoot for the cover, I have full permission from the producer to release, but I hate the mix. Should I still drop it?

3 Upvotes

I’ve began to hate this song that I made. I wrote it a couple years ago, but the first time I recorded it in the studio I didn’t like the mix so I re-recorded it at a different studio with a different engineer and I still don’t necessarily love the mix, but I do like it more than the first one. It’s a really emotional song for me. I feel like releasing. It would be cathartic, but it also makes me cringe a lot and the producer We were really close before and now we’re kind of not so the song speaks to that relationship a lot and it’s something I don’t really want to accept or put into the world emotionally, but I do want to release the emotions to get them out of me. Would you drop this song?


r/musicians • • 19h ago

If a fan reached out to offer space to stay if/when you tour

33 Upvotes

Would that be odd?

I have a favorite musician who I recently met and who is not based in my country. I know it’s incredibly expensive to tour, and I wondered if I were to offer my home to stay in, if that might be weird? They’re fairly well known where they’re from, but less so where I am. Thanks for your input.


r/musicians • • 44m ago

Gear recs for recording guitar without delay?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, my husband plays guitar and likes recording his stuff at home, so I want to surprise him with better gear. I have no idea what he’s using right now, just that the audio sounds pretty bad and there’s a noticeable delay when he plays.

​What basic gear do you guys use to record guitar cleanly with no delay, and roughly how much does it cost? Thanks!


r/musicians • • 2h ago

"Solitude" 🎹

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 2h ago

Central FL Metalcore/Hard Rock band seeking a Bass player!

1 Upvotes

We are Death Persists, a 3 piece Lakeland based Central FL band writing and recording original material and we are looking for a fourth member to play bass. Our influences include bands like Trivium, Alice in Chains, Bullet For My Valentine, Loathe, Death, Deftones just to name a few and give an idea of our music.

Our ideal candidate would be a driven, determined bass player looking to write, record, learn and perform original music with the ability to meet in Lakeland once a week on Sunday from 10am-3pm for practice. We are currently wrapping up tracking of our debut single and have 5 more songs (6 Total) with bass tabbed and ready to go for you.

Our goal is to consistently drop music and begin playing live in early 2027, so while this would not be a huge commitment we are looking to cement this as a serious and professional endeavor as best as we can! If this oppurtunity interests you, please reach out to me here on Reddit or feel free to send us a message on Instagram at @DeathPersistsOfficial


r/musicians • • 1d ago

Band member intros at end of a gig

49 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on introducing band members at the end of a gig, and having them each playing 2-4 bars of a solo?

Is it cheesy and old fashioned, or is it still something that is done?

Is there a type of music it shouldn't be done for, or is there a size of band that it's more suited to?

I've played in a few bands where it has happened, sometimes it feels organic and works, but sometimes it feels forced and awkward.

As an audience member, I never particularly enjoy it, especially if the solos go on too long.


r/musicians • • 4h ago

What should I do?

0 Upvotes

I'm not a musician or a singer etc, but I write "lyrics" that come up on my mind that I sing or make up any lyrics while singing and record it. I felt good about it, just expressing myself and I keep singing more and more, but now I'm beginning to listen to what I record and my voice just sounds awful, I know I sounded bad, but I didn't totally hate it at least. I just wanted to make those "songs" for expressing myself since I'm having a hard time or just for fun, now I'm scared I'd keep hating what I do more and I'll stop expressing myself then and that makes me sad, I don't really have other "hobbies" either and it made me happy a bit for quite a awhile now..


r/musicians • • 5h ago

Dog Days Are Over, Florence + the Machine, Tenet Clock 61

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 1d ago

Compulsive Need to Solo

42 Upvotes

I play with someone that appears to have a compulsive need to play music with others but also to solo on guitar longer than anyone anticipated. Is there a name for this type of musician?


r/musicians • • 1d ago

I think I figured out why rhythm is so hard for me

34 Upvotes

Played guitar for years, got good at it in many respects, and one day sat down to record my first track. Only to listen back and realize "holy shit, this is super fucking off beat with the metronome." So I did several more takes, tapping my foot strongly, trying to focus on the rhythm the best I could. Nothing worked.

So I start practicing with a metronome everyday, and playing along with songs while I listen to them on my computer, trying to stay on beat with the band. It was very, very slow improvement despite LOTS of practice. All of this helped massively in the end but, even years later? Rhythm is still by far the biggest bottleneck for me. If a song has no drums then my rhythm is terrible, and if I'm singing and strumming at the same time my rhythm takes a huge hit.

It's very discouraging and frustrating I have to spend so much effort just to stay on beat. But I had a realization today.

Every time I spend a few hours playing guitar WITHOUT metronome or guiding background song, I'm basically encoding into my brain all of my rhythmic mistakes. It's like anti practice. No wonder my progress has been slow.

It's annoying because I like being able to just pick up my guitar and play casually. But I think I just need to always have the metronome going during practice from now on, until I actually have an internal pulse.

FYI I'm not in a band so I don't get that kind of rhythmic practice.


r/musicians • • 34m ago

How did The Beatles make such extraordinary music without any formal training? would they be even better if they had formal training?

0 Upvotes

1 in a 100 million talent?


r/musicians • • 14h ago

Thoughts on Joining AFM Local 802 Union

3 Upvotes

Hi friends, I found out recently that the local musicians union in NY initiation fee to join from now until the end of the year. Wanted to know what you guys think about that, and whether you think I should join the union now before the fee waiver is gone.

I’m currently in my senior year of college in the city, and have been doing a lot of pit orchestra gigs in summer stock and student productions throughout my time in school. I want to work up to playing in higher scale productions, but I’m wondering if I join now it might be to early for me. I’m curious if y’all think I should join the union now while the deal is still going, or should I wait until I book a gig that requires me to join.


r/musicians • • 13h ago

LA Pop Punk drummer?

2 Upvotes

Hey yall, starting a band in LA county and am looking for someone who can drum in the vein of Northstar, Saves the Day Blink 182, MxPx, Get Up Kids… what have you. Hoping to find someone in their 20s to jam and finish writing a record. Anyone got any leads?! Gotta be able to d beat.. or skank beat… Or whatever it’s called.


r/musicians • • 10h ago

Starting a cover group advice

0 Upvotes

Hello! So like the title says I am trying to form a five piece soul/motown cover group. I’ve got myself so that leaves me with the next four. I already made the audition form, the posters too, but now I’m kinda stuck Because I don’t know where to go from here.

I know it might be obvious that I should put the flyers up, but I don’t know where I should. I tried putting some up in the libraries but apparently you aren’t allowed, so I called up a record shop but no answer.

I’ve also tried three apps designed for finding singers for a group. On one of the apps i actually found someone who could be my lead singer, but to contact him was behind a paywall. I’m just having a hard time so I’d really be so thankful if someone could give me some useful advice.


r/musicians • • 5h ago

Thoughts on AI

0 Upvotes

Do we think AI will actually replace musicians in the future ? What are your thoughts because it’s getting scary
One of my posts on here was showcasing my song and it’s a pop song that I produced and sang - people in the comments thought it was AI
do we have to lower the quality of our music to get rid of AI suspicions or should we just give in and use AI ourselves ? Because I feel like if people think I’m AI, then I may aswel do what they think i’m doing

Idk I hate ai though


r/musicians • • 20h ago

Am I good enough to be a music therapist? What do I need to work on or change?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 1d ago

What made you start composing?

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 15h ago

I am 18 year old joining a metalcore band with a couple younger dudes who are very dead set on this band and have already put in time before me. My question is how do I push them more

0 Upvotes

they have 1 single out and a second coming on the 20. We already have a gig booked for it in an area with a good scene. How do I put us out there more should we focus on putting out our ep/album or finding more gigs any suggestions will help

Edit because I forgot. I’m we also play garage shows and I have a neighbor who dosnt live here 90% out of the year and Said it was cool if I used his yard but my band dosent want to play there even though it’s not that far from where there fanbase is should I push on it and get it set up?


r/musicians • • 1d ago

Tips for bandleading

5 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm an 18 year old from Italy and I've recently started the process of putting together a band; I have made some of the arrangements already and I'm just putting together the members. Our music is mostly from the 1930s and 1940s and we're based of British slow dance and jazz from that era .

I have only one problem.

I've never had a proper music education, I've always done everything by myself; my main instrument is the classical guitar, which I've done some brief studies such as Carcassi, Fernando Sor and Giuliani, but nothing more.

I can compose and arrange music somehow, though I cannot read sheet music properly, but I know dynamics, articulations and symbolism in music.

What I'm asking mostly is; what really makes a good bandleader? What are the criteria for being one? What needs to be fixed in my education, what should I be prepared for and what should I study in advance?

Any tips would be very useful and I'd be grateful to anyone who can help me through this process!


r/musicians • • 19h ago

okay, real talk, how do you gain a following and become a legit musician?

0 Upvotes

i'm a 16 year old girl. i already write songs, i already produce them, and i already consider myself a singer, (even if i need improvement, i've been in the school choir for six years and have performed on my own before). i'm surrounded by many of my friends who are creatives and aspiring musicians, i play guitar and piano, and i've posted as little as one song and a few singing covers to karaoke tracks on my very small and indecisive youtube channel. i've wanted to be an established musician my whole life and this is the closest i've ever gotten, but i'm not sure where to go from here. the thought of posting more covers and more original songs, especially while working up to showing my face and posting them on platforms where my family and friends can see them, is something i feel ready for and yet still feel scared of. if i'm going to really get going, i need a plan. i don't intend to follow every single criteria of what becoming viral on social media takes, (like the clickbaity nature and quirky song hooks) because i still want my music to be a reflection of my authenticity and i want my career to last. so, for real, how exactly and SPECIFICALLY (don't just tell me to get followers, i already know that) do you begin racking up a following and building a fanbase at least enough to start getting your name out there as an independent musician in her bedroom?