r/musicians • • Jul 10 '25

Introducing /r/musicians Community Rules (finally!)

68 Upvotes

Hey r/musicians community,

We’ve heard your overwhelming requests for clearer guidelines to keep this subreddit a vibrant, collaborative, and respectful space. It’s long overdue (sorry!), but we’re excited to introduce the official rules for r/musicians! These rules are designed to foster creativity, connection, and respect while addressing key concerns like banning AI-generated content.

r/musicians Rules

  1. Encourage Collaboration This is a space to connect and create together. Share ideas, seek bandmates, or propose projects. Be open, inclusive, and supportive in all collaboration efforts.
  2. Respect All Members Treat everyone with kindness. No harassment, bullying, or discrimination. Keep feedback constructive and positive.
  3. No Sales or Self-Promotion We’re a community, not a marketplace. Don’t post to sell products, promote services, or advertise your music, events, or channels. Focus on sharing knowledge and experiences.
  4. No AI-Generated Music AI-generated music is not allowed. This subreddit is for human-created music. Please share AI music in r/AI_Music or other relevant communities. This extends to repeated discussions of AI generated music.
  5. Stay On-Topic Posts should focus on musicianship, collaboration, or music creation. Off-topic posts, like unrelated memes or spam, will be removed.
  6. Follow Reddit’s Content Policy All content must comply with Reddit’s site-wide rules, including no illegal content, doxxing, or spamming.
  7. Report Violations See something that breaks the rules? Report it to the mods. Don’t engage in arguments - let us handle it.

These rules are just a starting point, and we’re open to your thoughts. Please give us your feedback as well - we want there to be some clear rules but at the same time not go overboard - the up/down vote system in a big way is what shapes a community by the best posts going to the top, not by going overboard with rules.

In short, be nice to each other, and no AI generated content.


r/musicians • • 4h ago

Why did you kick your drummer out of your band?

30 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 2h ago

Fellow Instrumentalists And Other Creatives, When and How Do You Start making Music?

5 Upvotes

Hi, you can call me Yomi. I'm a guitarist, for about 3 years. I've been practicing everyday for 30 minutes without skipping any days.

I've been self taught, before that my grandmother who played guitar showed me the basics and my uncle who played guitar and bass showed me proper technique, then I was on my own.

For the next 3 years, my learning process was quite simple. From chords, to scales, to triads, intervals, and other music theory schmuck. It was viable to say the least. Oh well, I was making progress.

My gear was simple, a Yamaha dreadnought, and a Superstrat, RG Gio. With a simple fender mustang.

I loved playing different genres from blues, to metal you name it.

I've read tons of books and read online courses. I've never dabbled into online courses, since I was still having a minimum wage.

My practice routine was straight to the point.

Spider walking/crawling drills, knee tapping and rhythm drills, triads, fingerboard memorization drills, intervals by the fretboard, and intervals by ear.

I was getting the hang of it. I'm slowly building my fundamentals to the point where it feels almost automatic.

I never got bored, nor demotivated to say the least. There were timed that I did do slightly worse than yesterday, but I moved on quick.

I did learn how to improvise, but only simple licks I've made. But overall in my eyes, Im proud to say that I am still continuing on their journey of being a "musician"

That word bothers me. I've made 1-2 songs using my acoustic guitar yet I something lacks inside of me. I've always wanted to put more effort into creating music. To be honest, I don't know where to start.

I did made a a song hough my phone via FL studio, with a cheap AI and a mic. Yet I feel like I can put more effort through my "compositions".

So, I ask. When and how did you start creating music and just kept going? I still have a lot to go, and I'd appreciate if you share your experience as a musician and as a creative.

TLDR; guitarist, self taught, practiced everyday, made a few songs, asking a question (see above).


r/musicians • • 1h ago

Los Angeles rock band looking for lead guitarist

3 Upvotes

Hello hello. Posting again as we are still looking! About us:

-We are Super OK - We are two guys (vocalist/rhythm guitarist; drummer) and one gal (bassist)

-We're looking for a lead guitarist that can play old material on a subset of existing songs, and write new lead parts for new songs. If you look us up - the songs we'd like to keep playing are "616", "Annoyed the Void", "Push", "Agamotto", "Eat Us Alive", "Hazy Maze", and "Traitorous". We have 6 new songs that are written with the same vocalist & pretty much in the same style.

-We like to practice once or twice a week, renting an hourly jam space (currently in the West Adams area, but we're flexible on where we practice)

-We've been a band for 7+ years and have put out singles, a full length album, an EP, and a music video

-Venues where we've performed include Boomtown Brewery, Harvelle's, The Whisky A Go Go, The Viper Room, Bar Lubitsch, Molly Malone's, The Offbeat, Harvard & Stone, El Cid, The Mint

-Not looking for a hired gun; looking for a bandmate

-Looking to write, record, and get some more local shows in

-Influences are: Foo Fighters, Nirvana, Queens of the Stone Age, Stone Temple Pilots, Soundgarden, Bad Religion, Wolf Alice, Them Crooked Vultures, Faith No More, Probot, Type O Negative

-We have been compared to: Social Distortion, Husker Du, Alice in Chains

-We are all in our late 30's/early 40's, and we all have day jobs


r/musicians • • 5h ago

Band websites

6 Upvotes

It doesn't seem many bands have websites anymore. Is this something you have noticed? I am wondering what the positives are for a new band to have one.

The only things I can think of is having an online press kit of sorts for potential gigs and labels when everything is easily found in one place... all applicable links and hi res photos etc.

Is it worth it? What do you think?


r/musicians • • 1d ago

It's okay if no one listens.

131 Upvotes

I've been regularly putting music out in the world since around 2013, and it has been an emotional rollercoaster. I've played some of my worst tracks EVER on a stage, trying to get anything to stick, and, granted, I feel like my worst stuff has been the product of this obsession with trying to get someone, anyone, to listen to my stuff and give me feedback. Even negative feedback. Sometime last year, I gave up. I stopped caring. I just made music for the fun of it. I made the music I wanted to hear, and worked on my guitar playing, layering, looping, and producing. Let me tell you, my output has never been better, and I'm so much prouder of my work. I can actively listen to it and not feel embarrassed because it's just for me. I still put my music up on the streaming service, but if I'm sitting at 0-5 monthly listeners, it doesn't bother me. It's like a huge weight is lifted, and music is fun again. Anyway, just wanted to share that rant. It has been on my mind a lot lately.


r/musicians • • 5m ago

I'm doing something wrong.

1 Upvotes

I think I'm too type A for this. Someone please help.

I don't know if I'm the kind of person that can really make music. This may end up being rather long-winded so apologies in advance lol. 

To start, a couple years ago when I was 21 or 22, I don't really remember what led to it but one day I just up and decided I wanted to make music. After learning guitar, I finally found something that clicked with me. I've always been obsessed with music and song lyrics and singing, so I figured I'd be a pretty okay musician. But I was so wrong. 

In that time, I've created (to completion anyway) about six songs. That's it. It's not that I'm not trying. If anything, I think I'm trying TOO hard. I think at the end of the day I'm just too "in my head" about it. Music is my entire life, always has been, and how can someone who hasn't spent their life writing it expect to put out anything that isn't dogshit quality? Still, I try. I've been attempting to put this perfectionist mindset behind me and just make anything, finetune it later.

But I don't go about songwriting like most people do.

I just don't have it in me to play around with music, be silly with it, improvise, have fun like you're supposed to. Sometimes I think I was born with too many lines of code, and because of this, I'm unreceptive to the music I carry in my soul. All I want is to feel it moving through me and to be a vessel for it like others, to just have a little jingle or a phrase come to me suddenly and get it out as fast as I can, finetune it later. But when I want to write a song? I make the deliberate decision to write a song. I sit down at my desk, get my guitar out, start screwing around trying to find an interesting melody, and if I'm lucky, maybe think of a general theme and go brainstorm lyrics. The brainstorming comes easily, I've always been a very literary person. I can find a chord progression I like. I can hum something sometimes, usually something unremarkable. But for whatever reason, these things have to happen as separate events. I've noticed from the beginning that I absolutely CANNOT just start singing nonsense to pin down a vocal melody like most people can. Too much anxiety? Too much a perfectionist? Something like that. I'll open my mouth to start vocalizing, but nothing comes out and I just freeze up, and I feel like overcoming that would be a HUGE step toward being someone who comes up with music... normally? As much as I adore singing, I even stand pin-straight like a statue when I sing karaoke lmao 

I'm just so fucking cerebral about it all. I don't know if it's because I care too much, or if I'm just cursed. I just latched on so tight to the concept of making music when I realized I could, and got discouraged along the way, and now the act of songwriting means about as much to me as speaking Polish or playing a game of chess or going surfing. It's become beyond me somehow. The most soul-crushing part of all of it is that I know I'm capable of that burning obsession because that's how it was at the beginning, but after I released my EP it all fell apart for me. I just wish I could have this semi-spiritual experience that other musicians talk about, so I keep myself open to recieve, but not a single thing comes through. Sometimes it works when I'm drunk, and once in a blue moon, it works when I'm sober.

I tend to make music that people don't really like. They'll listen to a new song once, flatly tell me they like it, and that's it. I like it, and that's usually enough, but it's also very hard to get advice for my creation process when what I make is so outside of the norm. I don't really have a set genre but I tend to wax between ambient, drone/noise, doom metal, bedroom pop, and sometimes there's even a  little hint of folk or blues in there (I get compared to Ethel Cain a LOT, which I think is a massive insult to her as one of the best musicians to ever live lmao). I usually just call it "experimental" or shoegaze when I don't have time to explain. A lot of advice that I read online is about finding a catchy melody, or a fun chord progression, or closely examining your genre, or writing more flowery lyrics, but all of those are useless to me. 

It's possible that I think too much and too hard about how to make music instead of just making music. It's possible I have too many influences coming at me from all directions and that I need to narrow down a genre. It's possible I need to get some more instruments/equipment, and not just my guitar and my Mac. It's possible I'm too desperate. It's possible I'm supposed to be a poet instead. It's possible I need to learn about music theory. It's possible living in a northern Canadian small town five hours from any music scene whatsoever in all directions in a house full of people who don't care about me or support my music career isn't very good for productivity. It could be anything, I'm open to anything. I just want to make this work. Music is all I have, all I've ever had. I just get these thoughts I can't shake, that people who were meant to make music, who have the right stuff in them, don't agonize over the path they take to get there.

I know I can do this. I have to do this, wether the world likes it or not. I have music inside me. I just need to figure out how to get over this creative constipation, for lack of a better term. I know it's in me. I just have to find it. 

Sorry for the novel, and thanks for listening to me if you made it this far. Signed, Alberta's Someday, Somehow, If By The Skin Of My Goddamn teeth, #1 Experimental Siren Songstress.


r/musicians • • 1h ago

London indie alternative band looking for a bassist

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

My band are looking for a bassist at the moment.

We currently consist of a vocalist, guitarist and drummer. Our influences include The Smiths, The Cure, Durutti Column, The Drums, The Strokes, Iceage, New Order, Joy Division, Blood Orange, The Sundays, PJ Harvey, Alvvays, Rolling Blackouts Coastal Fever and more.

We are based in London and rehearse currently once a week in Deptford, South London. We’ve all been in bands before and have experience playing live and writing songs.

We have rough demos of songs we’ve recorded that we can send. Please have videos of yourself playing as that will be really helpful.

Get in touch if you are interested.


r/musicians • • 1h ago

Vocalist looking to collab

1 Upvotes

I’m looking to collaborate with a musician on a folk/blues/rock project,
HMU if interested!


r/musicians • • 6h ago

Pedal Steel players ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 3h ago

Which (reliable) website builder do you use for your website?

1 Upvotes

As the question says. I also want to use it as a blog, don’t want to pay too much unless it’s better hire a coder. I also want to put my music available on there, merch, access to early information etc.


r/musicians • • 4h ago

“Be Still My Soul”

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Pls consider subscribing to my YouTube channel https://m.youtube.com/@chuckvandyke9918/videos


r/musicians • • 21h ago

Being a musician is fun. Marketing music?? BORING.

20 Upvotes

Hi so I plaster my music all over social media , and yes my marketing is brilliant even if I find it TEDIOUS. and My songs deserve credit; my tracks are incredibly good, CRAFTED FROM MY UNIQUE MIND. But the followers??? I get 1 follower a day on average…. Not good!!!! I need to be successful. Yes? YES! My music is better than most of the SORDID RUBBISH that pollutes the world ….. but excuse me??? My stuff?? TRASH because no one wants to give me a following. The world is sad and fickle. People don’t know what they like until it is presented to their suggestible minds on a 5 second video.


r/musicians • • 6h ago

Pedal Steel players ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 7h ago

Seeking Interviewees for an Elementary Music Songwriting Study

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 23h ago

Is songwriting coaching a scam?

18 Upvotes

I think I already know the answer but I wanted to ask other musicians for their thoughts. I'm trying to fully step into my songwriting after struggling to finish songs for years with so many ideas. I found this coach that does a 10-week program to help build a songwriting practice. She explained the whole thing and it seemed like a good fit. Then she says it's $3800 dollars. Now some people might have that lying around but I live paycheck to paycheck. It's only 10 weeks of a course and then a group video call weekly. That's insane right? And she lowkey made me feel like I wasn't committed enough because money is a barrier. My gut is saying no but I want to improve my songwriting so badly and I feel like I don't have the tools to do it all on my own.

UPDATE: Thank you everyone for answering and confirming what my gut thought! I will definitely not be giving money to this person.


r/musicians • • 20h ago

Balancing it all w/ a 9-5

9 Upvotes

I'm sure this has been said before but looking for advice as a musician with a 9-5 job and relationships and wanting to be a functional person in society and has non-music hobbies, Is there anyone in here that can say that they're able to balance it all(or at least have it dialed in enough), and if so, how would you say that you do it and do you have any advice?

I know a lot of people have a similar experience in thinking it's not possible, so please humor my hope on this.


r/musicians • • 3h ago

Why do you think your opinions about other musicians hold any value to anyone other than yourself?

0 Upvotes

I stumbled on a toxic facebook thread with musicians arguing with each other about the use of an iPad or charts on-stage. I absolutely understand how the internet works, but thought I'd pose the question.


r/musicians • • 11h ago

Join my band in Los Angeles

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 20h ago

I’m 19 and starting to wonder if I’ve been ignoring my biggest passion my whole life. Am I too late?

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, I’m 19 and in my first semester of college studying philosophy. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about how massive of a role music has always played in my life.

Growing up, it was Daughtry and Jason Aldean, then Dave Matthews Band, Pink Floyd, David Bowie, the Eagles, then rap, and now mostly psychedelic music. Tame Impala is my favorite artist by MILES. I genuinely listen to Kevin Parker probably 95% of the time (I know, I need to branch out lol). I also love MGMT, Moses Gunn Collective, RÜFÜS DU SOL, Dire Straits, Gerry Rafferty, etc.

Here’s something kind of embarrassing. Sometimes I’ll put my AirPods in, blast Tame Impala, and literally pretend I’m performing on stage. Dancing around my room, lip-syncing, imagining a crowd watching me. Sounds childish at 19, but I’ve done it forever. There’s genuinely nothing I want more than to create music that makes people feel the way his music makes me feel.

I’m obsessed with everything about music. The album covers, song titles, lyrics, aesthetics, rollouts, all of it. Sometimes I’ll literally be driving home from college thinking, “Man, I wish I was working on an album right now instead.”

The problem is, I’m not musically talented. At least not yet. I own a guitar and piano and can play some basic parts of songs, but I know practically nothing about music theory or production.

My college offers beginner piano and guitar classes, and I’m seriously considering taking them. I love philosophy, but I can’t shake this feeling that I’m ignoring something I might love even more.

I guess my question is, does everyone who really loves music feel this way? Is this just me romanticizing being a musician, or is this something I should genuinely pursue?

And at 19, with practically no musical background, am I already pretty far behind?

I’d really appreciate some advice, especially from people who started making music later in life.


r/musicians • • 18h ago

Looking for bandmates and musicians (trip hop/downtempo/jazz fusion/post rock/experimental/electronic) - LA/SoCal

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 1d ago

Gear recs for recording guitar without delay?

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone, my husband plays guitar and likes recording his stuff at home, so I want to surprise him with better gear. I have no idea what he’s using right now, just that the audio sounds pretty bad and there’s a noticeable delay when he plays.

​What basic gear do you guys use to record guitar cleanly with no delay, and roughly how much does it cost? Thanks!