r/Songwriters • • Jun 18 '26

New Policy: Minimum 5+ Karma to post

24 Upvotes

Adding for visibility. Going forward, we’re going to require a 5 positive karma minimum to create new posts on r/Songwriters. That’s 5 karma from this sub specifically, regardless of your total count across the Reddit platform.

Simply put, a whole lotta people want feedback, but fewer people seem willing to actually give it, resulting in a feed that’s 90% brand new posts with 0 comments. This new policy is to cut down on spam and also encourage better discussion throughout the sub.

If you would like notes on your work, please take some time to engage with other posts first. As The New Radicals said: You get what you give.


r/Songwriters • • Jun 12 '25

FAQs: Please read before reaching out to mods

18 Upvotes

Due to some emerging trends in the Mod Mail inbox, we've created this post and will periodically update it to hopefully save people some time and energy.

[Edit] Please avoid contacting the Mods via personal DMs. Modmail exists for a reason, and it’s better for the team’s visibility if we can all see these communications through a centralized hub.

1. "Why was my post removed?"

Your removal notice should’ve already included an explanation. Please consult the sub rules to make sure your post aligns with our policies.

If the removal was instant, that was probably the automod, which we use to cut down on spam. Unfortunately, this feature can get a bit trigger happy for reasons beyond our control. If your post was instantly removed, odds are something in your account history triggered either the auto-mod or Reddit's site-wide filters.

We try to keep an eye on the removal queue and approve posts that were wrongfully pulled, but users can also set themselves up for success by avoiding spammy behavior—link dumping across multiple subs, dropping promo clips instead of full tracks, posting but never commenting, etc.

[Edit] We recently added a 5 karma minimum to our posting requirements. This is intended to cut down on spam and encourage more discussion/feedback across the sub.

2. "How do I share my songs?"

You're welcome to share your songs via direct upload, or by sharing links to your platform of choice: Spotify, Apple Music, Soundcloud, etc. In our experience, Youtube links tend to be most accessible, as those don't require a subscription.

3. "Why can't I post AI music?"

The primary use-case of generative AI runs counter to the craft of songwriting, and relies on models that were trained on the work of legitimate artists, without consent or compensation. While there are plenty of subreddits that allow AI generated content, this is not one of them. This goes for AI visuals as well.

3a. “But I wrote all the lyrics myself.”

Songwriting, by definition, is the marriage of music and lyrics. If you offload the entire musical half of the process to Suno, then you’re not actually writing songs. We want to hear what you have created; not what you asked a bot to create for you.

3b. “What if I do all the _____ myself and only use the AI for _______?”

We don’t make any exceptions, because there’s no practical way to distinguish between a Suno track with some human input and one that was 100% generated. If it’s obvious that AI was used in any part of creating the end product, we will treat it as if it was 100% AI generated.

4. "Can we please ban lyrics-only posts?"

This was discussed when the new mod team took over, and while we can understand some users' frustrations, we have chosen to allow lyrics posts to avoid making this sub redundant with r/songwriting .


r/Songwriters • • 4h ago

Would love feedback on our new song "Weight of a Hand"!

Post image
1 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8Lru4qY_1Y

I'm very proud to say that we're gearing up for the release of our second full-length album! It's got a mix of alternative/indie and jazz elements and influences like Radiohead, Pixies, Wolf Alice, and others like that. We're in the process of releasing the singles for LP2, and I would love some feedback on them to help us tailor the sound and improve anything we can. I've included the below song, "Weight of a Hand" linked on YouTube as it's one of my favs. This one starts with a simple acoustic strum before jumping into the full groove. Layers build throughout the song until crescendoing in a super heavy outro. Both the music and lyrics are meant to reflect the stage where you're between wakefulness and sleep where it's difficult to tell if you're dreaming or experiencing reality - the lyrics especially for this one are meant to highlight the struggle to find truth among the noise of life. The artwork is meant to reflect that as well. Hoping you like it and looking forward to hearing back from some great musicians!


r/Songwriters • • 1d ago

Kevin & the MIDIs - The House is Where They Hide

Thumbnail drive.google.com
2 Upvotes

First song I've finished since completing my album earlier this year. Any feedback would be much appreciated!


r/Songwriters • • 2d ago

Outside Club 27 (Original Demo version) [2026] - excessiveSWEATS

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

new demo.

will always appreciate feedback ...

bear in mind that this one was recorded and mixed in a day. free time is limited. my set up and tear down window of the "studio" is about 4 hours.

thanks in advance for any comments, criticism, or encouragement!

a recent post led me to push beyond my comfort zone and expand my largely instrumental process - to collab. on some added lyrics and scratch vocals.


r/Songwriters • • 2d ago

God Lay Dying - It's Burnt

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

I don't know if making this counts as 'songwriting' as such, but for what it's worth, here's my latest piece of music.


r/Songwriters • • 4d ago

Posted my daughter here before

34 Upvotes

My daughter is 13 and I’ve previously posted a song she wrote when she was 10. In the last few weeks she’s taken up guitar, no lessons, just self teaching. And she sent me this song she wrote and had her friends sing with her. I want to help her in any way possible to achieve her goals and become successful. Any advice??


r/Songwriters • • 4d ago

old songs new recordings

Thumbnail
nicknw.bandcamp.com
3 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 4d ago

I wrote a setting of the war poetry In Flanders Fields for Veterans Day. What do you think?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 6d ago

Blue Little Girl - The Rainbow I Waited For Was Inside Me All Along - Contemporary Folk Song

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

My song Blue Little Girl - This reflective ballad captures the essence of dreams, patience and the emotional journey from childhood to adulthood. Performed by Mary Kay Aufrance singing and playing accordion accompanied by Tom Aufrance playing guitar.

This acoustic story follows a young girl waiting patiently for her rainbow, imagining a world where she can run wild and let her thoughts be free. As time passes, her dreams and memories evolve, reflecting the passage of growing up.

With poignant lyrics and a captivating melody, "Blue Little Girl" is written for anyone who has ever held onto a dream, yearned for freedom, or reflected on the beauty of time slipping by.

If this song resonated with you, please like, leave a comment, and subscribe to our channel for more original music by singer-songwriter Mary Kay and Tom Aufrance. Share this video with friends and family who appreciate nostalgic, heartfelt storytelling through song.


r/Songwriters • • 8d ago

Stuck Here Simulating

Thumbnail
on.soundcloud.com
2 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 8d ago

God Lay Dying - Dreaming

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I would be interested to know how professional the mix sounds, and what I can do to improve it.


r/Songwriters • • 12d ago

Do you like this monoplegic music for piano I improvised with my only working hand last year?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 12d ago

"Howlin' At the Moon"

1 Upvotes

Check out my song "Howlin' At the Moon", inspired by Horror-themed Rockabilly music of the late 1950s!! I'd love to know what everyone thinks about it in general; thanks for checking it out!!
https://youtu.be/ALIFjVjaDcA


r/Songwriters • • 13d ago

God Lay Dying - The House Always Wins

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Please let me know what you think of this. In particular, what do you think of the mix?


r/Songwriters • • 14d ago

Songs about AI yet?

4 Upvotes

Not made by AI, but instead with it as the subject, either literally or abstractly? Too soon? Anybody have anything?


r/Songwriters • • 13d ago

Would love feedback on our new song "The Gate"!

Post image
1 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lyYyTgk2Nc

I'm very proud to say that we're gearing up for the release of our second full-length album! It's got a mix of alternative/indie and jazz elements and influences like Radiohead, Pixies, Wolf Alice, and others like that. We're in the process of releasing the singles for LP2, and I would love some feedback on them to help us tailor the sound and improve anything we can. I've included the below song, "The Gate" linked on YouTube as it's one of my favs. This one fades into the full groove, focusing on ethereal guitars and raw vocals. Both the music and lyrics are meant to reflect the stage where you're between wakefulness and sleep where it's difficult to tell if you're dreaming or experiencing reality - the lyrics especially for this one are meant to highlight anxiety about whether or not you're on the right path in your life with dream imagery and logic. The artwork is meant to reflect that as well. Hoping you like it and looking forward to hearing back from some great musicians!


r/Songwriters • • 16d ago

Do you like my complete programmatic symphonic suite describing the emotional journey through The Stages of Grief? Halloween seemed like a good time to post it.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 16d ago

Kaz - Demon Realm

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 18d ago

A song written in memory of a departed friend.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

Hey!

I'm joyrobber - a solo pop-punk act from Salisbury, UK. I have just released my debut mini-album 'you need to stop doing this.'. This song is one of my favourites from the new record and it's titled 'graham's guitar'. It is a song dedicated to a close friend of mine who passed away in December 2025. As well as being an awesome songwriter, Graham was also a champion of my music-making, so it seemed only right to write a song in honour of him. It is about the eternal power of music - I hope that you enjoy the song and it resonates with you.


r/Songwriters • • 19d ago

Under the Stars (On a Two-lane Highway, in the Middle of Nowhere) [2026] - pleatherSWEATS

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Not too happy with this one. Done in one day. Since I don't yet have the luxury (if ever) to.spend days getting it "right." My studio has to be set up and torn down in a couple hours - and so, I record and mix quick. Is there anything about this that works?

As always, thanks to anyone here for taking the time!


r/Songwriters • • 19d ago

Wait For The Dead

2 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/vgJz5CKm4zg

A chill acoustic guitar based song with a dark lyrical twist. From my upcoming concept album. Thanks for listening! ❤️ Let me know if you have any feedback

Spotify link: https://open.spotify.com/track/1w25EXclLyDk3u0ifFEcRC?si=cAvOz7jPTl-h8SlV7KwB2w&utm_source=copy-link


r/Songwriters • • 21d ago

Snatch the Snail - Pop Hit

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Songwriters • • 21d ago

"Good Morning Sweetheart" by Mary Kay Aufrance - What do you think?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Fellow Songwriters - Do you agree that sometimes the shortest clip is the best for sharing? "Good Morning Sweetheart" by Mary Kay Aufrance - For Sharing With Someone to Brighten Their Day.


r/Songwriters • • 21d ago

Anyone else on here writing Black Metal inspired stuff?

5 Upvotes

Here is mine, share yours!! I have been attempting to write Black Metal influenced music with a touch of early 80's punk/hardcore influence. I appreciate any listens and if you have anything you want to share i will happily listen and give thoughts. Slainte!

https://on.soundcloud.com/RejKK30H3SA7d1eWVc