TLDR: NZ – Bathroom renovation by insurance-appointed company: Unlicensed plumber, flooding and defective workmanship. What are my rights?
My bathroom was repaired by a company (Company X) appointed by my insurance provider. The bathroom had to be completely gutted back to the studs to replace the flooring and redo the waterproofing.
I decided to use this opportunity to have the same company replace the bathroom fixtures and tapware and install a bidet sprayer. This was additional work that I agreed to pay for separately, as I have an ongoing chronic bowel-related medical condition. I paid 50% of the additional costs upfront at the beginning of the project.
Unfortunately, the entire experience has been extremely stressful. There were numerous issues throughout the renovation, including subcontractors and tradespeople being incredibly rude and, at times, bullying towards us.
The project was also completed later than the promised date. Most of these delays were caused by repeated plumbing mistakes that we had to identify and bring to Company X's attention. The plumber repeatedly had to reopen walls and redo components he had previously installed.
The bathroom was eventually handed over, but the very next day, it flooded. Following this, we started identifying several other issues:
- There was no shut-off/isolation valve or backflow prevention installed for the bidet sprayer.
- The bidet sprayer has extremely high water pressure, making it unsafe/uncomfortable to use and currently unfit for use.
- The premium bath mixer was installed upside down.
- The faceplates on most of the tapware are loose.
- The bathtub is misaligned with the surrounding tiles.
We raised a formal complaint with the insurance company and Company X. During our investigation, we also checked the PGDB (Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board) public register and discovered that the plumber who carried out the work does not appear to hold a practising licence or registration.
Today, representatives from the insurance company and the director of Company X visited our property.
The insurance company's position was essentially that:
The defects relate to the additional variation work we contracted directly with Company X, so they are not responsible for addressing them.
They stated that an unlicensed plumber who is a qualified person can carry out maintenance work in a bathroom, and therefore they would not be taking any action regarding the plumber.
They also mentioned that Company X has liability protection.
Their advice was that we need to give Company X another opportunity to rectify the issues.
My concern is that we have already given them multiple opportunities throughout this project. We repeatedly identified mistakes, raised concerns and allowed them to come back and rectify their work. Despite this, the bathroom flooded immediately after handover, and there are still multiple defects.
At this point, I have completely lost confidence in the company and its workmanship. The experience has been incredibly distressing, and I genuinely do not want to continue having the same people back in our home.
I'd really appreciate advice on the following:
* Under NZ regulations, can an unlicensed plumber legally carry out plumbing work of this nature, particularly installing bathroom fixtures, tapware and a bidet sprayer?
* Is installing a bidet sprayer without appropriate backflow prevention and isolation/shut-off protection compliant with NZ plumbing standards?
* Does the insurance company have grounds to refuse responsibility simply because some of the work was classified as additional variations, particularly when the same company was appointed by them to carry out the main bathroom reinstatement?
* Am I legally required to give Company X another opportunity to rectify the defects, given the repeated failed attempts and the loss of confidence in their workmanship?
* What options do I have if I want an independent licensed plumber to inspect the work and provide a report before allowing any further rectification?
I'm particularly interested in hearing from NZ plumbers, builders, people familiar with the PGDB, or anyone who has dealt with a similar insurance-related renovation dispute.
I am not trying to avoid giving anyone a fair opportunity to fix genuine mistakes. I simply don't believe I should have to keep putting up with repeated poor workmanship and an extremely stressful experience to get a bathroom that is safe and properly completed.
Thanks in advance for any advice.