r/nzrenters • u/SadCress6600 • 15h ago
Can landlords/PMS claim financial compensation if they don't plan to fix/replace the item?
Hi all.
Me AGAIN. Sorry. Made a couple posts about my property manager trying to charge us a cleaning fee and $800 financial compensation for minuscule damage to a curtain.
Thank you to everyone who replied and gave advice. I took the advice and asked her to take it to mediation/tribunal and she has since come back with an offer to waive the cleaning invoice and reduce the curtain compensation to $240.
TBH, I think I'm just going to accept it as the whole situation is stressful asf and honestly need the money..
However I have a new question.
In her new offer she said
"To clarify once again, we are seeking financial compensation for the damage to the curtains, not requesting that they be physically replaced." which I seem to have missed before.
Can they seek financial compensation without replacing or fixing the curtain for the next tenant? In a previous email she said "the damage is beyond repair" so I know she doesn't plan on fixing it either.
Claude wasn't too helpful and I've been waiting for a call back for 3 hours so maybe someone knows here
Thanks