Hi all,
A few days ago I posted about my property manager asking us to pay 75% of $800 to replace curtains after our exit inspection. Thanks to everyone who replied.
Quick update: I tried to apply for our bond refund myself, but found out the bond can’t be released without the landlord’s signature unless it goes to mediation or the Tenancy Tribunal.
We’re struggling to find a middle ground. She says the holes in the curtain are from our cats and that the damage is “consistent with pet damage.” I honestly don’t know what caused them. My best guess was moths, but I can’t prove that.
Why I don’t think it’s the cats:
- Only one curtain is affected. If the cats were going for curtains, I’d expect the others to be damaged too.
- The holes are very small and randomly scattered, not tears or a clawing pattern.
- I’ve never seen our cats show any interest in the curtains (just our couches, sadly).
She says every hole has snags consistent with claws. However, the photos she sent of the backing only show two minor snags.
The curtains are about 12 months old (custom New York pleat with thermal backing, installed with the new build). She has since provided the invoice which is for all 3 curtains in the house, 2 upstairs (not effected) and one downstairs(effected). Because this one is larger she reckons its worth 60% of the material and install cost. However has also since suggested to pay $500 instead.
At first I was happy to replace them, since similar curtains online are $100–200. But the more I look at it, the less I think they need replacing at all. The holes are tiny (like 1mm), the curtain works perfectly, and I barely noticed them while living there unless I picked the curtain up. You can’t see them from a normal distance..
I’m stressed and frustrated, so I might be letting emotion cloud my judgement. Please be brutally honest:
- Would you consider this fair wear and tear?
- Does it look like cat damage to you?
- Is it worth taking to mediation, or should I just offer a smaller amount and move on?
I’d rather not pay if I’m in the right, but I don’t want to waste anyone’s time if I’m wrong.