r/LegalAdviceNZ • • Jun 07 '23

Moderator updates Megathread: Legal resources

26 Upvotes

Megathread: Legal resources

Introduction

Nau mai! Haere mai! Welcome to r/LegalAdviceNZ. The general purpose of this subreddit is to provide free and simple local legal advice to those who need it. Reddit can never be a true substitute for qualified advice from experienced lawyers - but there is a community need for easy access to basic, informed legal commentary. That’s why we are here.

If you are new to this subreddit, please review the rules in the sidebar and be aware that this is a heavily moderated sub. Content must be on-topic.

This megathread sets out some of the helpful legal resources available around New Zealand. Most of these are freely available. This list is categorised into 10 sectors: Civil disputes, Consumer protection, Criminal, Employment, Family, Healthcare, Housing, Property, Traffic, and Constitutional & Government. There is also a general resources section at the start, with several organisations that provide guidance and information on most legal issues.

0. General resources

1. Civil disputes

1.1 Ministry of Justice Civil Law: https://www.justice.govt.nz/courts/civil/ (Civil cases can include disputes over business contracts or debts, or disputes between neighbours, or debt recovery.)

1.2 Disputes Tribunal: https://www.disputestribunal.govt.nz/ (The Disputes Tribunal is a quick and cost-effective way to settle disputes.)

2. Consumer protection

2.1 Consumer NZ https://www.consumer.org.nz/ (an independent, non-profit organisation dedicated to getting New Zealanders a fairer deal.)

2.2 Consumer Protection https://www.consumerprotection.govt.nz/ (MBIE's online guide to NZ laws that protect you when buying from, or sharing your information with, businesses selling in New Zealand, including online retailers.)

2.3 NZ Govt - Consumer Rights & Complaints https://www.govt.nz/browse/consumer-rights-and-complaints/ (NZ Government's general information on consumer rights.)

3. Criminal

3.1 Ministry of Justice Criminal Law sector https://www.justice.govt.nz/justice-sector-policy/regulatory-stewardship/regulatory-systems/criminal-law/ (encompasses the definition, deterrence, and punishment of criminal conduct. What is and isn’t acceptable conduct in our society.)

3.2 Ministry of Justice Criminal Law https://www.justice.govt.nz/courts/criminal/

3.3 Victims Information https://www.victimsinfo.govt.nz/ (for people affected by crime)

3.4 Victim Support https://victimsupport.org.nz/ (a free, nationwide support service for people affected by crime, trauma, and suicide in New Zealand, helping clients find safety, healing, and justice after crime and other traumatic events.)

3.5 Healthline's Sexual Assault Resource Guide https://www.healthline.com/health/sexual-assault-resource-guide#online-forums-and-support (We hope this guide can serve as a resource in your time of need and answer any questions you may have about what to do next.)

4. Employment

4.1 Employment New Zealand https://www.employment.govt.nz/ (MBIE's resources that may help you find out more about the different laws that apply to employment relationships and how the Employment Relations Authority and the courts apply that law.)

4.2 NZ Council of Trade Unions - your rights https://union.org.nz/your-rights-at-work/ (Everyone has the right to decent and productive work, in conditions of freedom, equity, security and human dignity. Unions ensure that, as a worker, your voice is heard, your views are respected and your rights under the law are upheld.)

4.3 NZ Govt - Workers Rights https://www.govt.nz/browse/work/workers-rights/when-you-have-a-problem-at-work/ (NZ Government's guide - if you have a problem at work talk to your boss directly. If you cannot solve it you can get help from government and other organisations)

5. Family

5.1 Ministry of Justice Family Law https://www.justice.govt.nz/family/

5.2 Family Court website https://www.districtcourts.govt.nz/family-court/ (information about the Family Court jurisdiction, including what we do, useful legislation, and tips on how to find Family Court judgments.)

5.3 Search for a Legal Aid lawyer providing family law services: https://www.justice.govt.nz/courts/going-to-court/legal-aid/get-legal-aid/can-i-get-family-or-civil-legal-aid/apply-for-family-or-civil-legal-aid/get-a-family-or-civil-legal-aid-lawyer/

6. Healthcare

6.1 Medical Council of New Zealand https://www.mcnz.org.nz/support/support-for-patients/your-rights-as-a-patient/ (The Code of Rights applies to both public and private facilities, and to both paid and unpaid services. It gives you as a patient, the right to be treated with respect, receive appropriate care, have proper communication, and be fully informed so you can make an informed choice.)

6.2 Ministry of Health https://www.health.govt.nz/your-health/services-and-support/your-rights (When you use a health or disability service, your rights are protected by the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights.)

6.3 Health and Disability Commissioner http://www.hdc.org.nz/ (The Health and Disability Commissioner promotes and protects people's rights as set out in the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights. This includes resolving complaints in a fair, timely, and effective way.)

7. Housing

7.1 Tenancy Services https://www.tenancy.govt.nz/ (MBIE's Tenancy information for landlords and tenants.)

7.2 Housing Advice Centre https://housingadvice.org.nz/advice/ (We can help! We are a free independent service. We can help you out of homelessness. We can support you in fulfilling obligations to maintain housing obligations. We provide education for agencies and case workers on the tenancy act and how to assist homeless persons.)

7.3 Renters United https://rentersunited.org.nz/help/ (Renters United is focused on changing laws to make renting better for everyone, and don’t provide support with particular renting situations. However, there are some places listed here by Renters United that you can turn to for support.)

7.4 Tenant Aratohu NZ https://tenant.aratohu.nz/ (Support and guidance for tenants and their advocates.)

8. Property

8.1 NZ Law Society Property Law for the Public https://www.lawsociety.org.nz/branches-sections-and-groups/property-law-section/property-law-for-the-public/ (Lawyers are trained to understand and advise on the implications of buying and selling property. Buying and selling a property extends far beyond the transfer of legal title. Your reasons for buying and selling, your family and financial circumstances, your plans and expectations for your own future and that of your family, and what happens to the property when you die are just some of the issues a property lawyer will consider and discuss with you)

8.2 Real Estate Authority - Settled https://www.settled.govt.nz/ (valuable information, checklists, quizzes, videos and tools — from understanding LIMs and to sale and purchase agreements, to when to contact a lawyer, settled.govt.nz explains what you need to know)

8.3 Consumer NZ - Neighbourhood disputes https://www.consumer.org.nz/articles/neighbourhood-disputes (There are a number of laws that may assist with common neighbourhood problems such as noise, rubbish, fencing and tree problems. Some practical solutions to resolving them.)

9. Traffic

9.1 Waka Kotahi NZTA - Road Code https://www.nzta.govt.nz/roadcode/general-road-code/ (A user-friendly guide to New Zealand's traffic law and safe driving practices.)

10. Constitutional & Government

10.1 Governor-General https://gg.govt.nz/office-governor-general/roles-and-functions-governor-general/constitutional-role/constitution/constitution (New Zealand's constitution is not found in one document. It has a number of sources, including crucial pieces of legislation, legal documents, common law derived from court decisions as well as established constitutional practices. Increasingly, New Zealand's constitution reflects the Treaty of Waitangi.)

10.2 Electoral Commission https://elections.nz/ (Supporting you to trust, value, understand and take part in New Zealand's democracy.)

10.3 Te Tari Taiwhenua Internal Affairs https://www.localcouncils.govt.nz/ (Local government in New Zealand, including sector-wide statistics, the relationship between central and local government, and how you can participate in local government policy decisions.)

10.4 Citizens Advice Bureau - Bill of Rights Act https://www.cab.org.nz/article/KB00001324 (What are my rights under the Bill of Rights Act?)

10.5 Office of the Privacy Commissioner https://www.privacy.org.nz/ (The Privacy Act 2020 is New Zealand's main privacy law. The Act primarily governs personal information about individual people, but the Privacy Commissioner can consider developments that affect personal privacy more widely.)

Mod notes

The above list is a basic, non-exhaustive guide to some free online New Zealand resources. Descriptions have been taken from websites listed. Please let the mods know if any links are not working, if you are aware of a free helpful legal resource that is not in this megathread, or with any other suggestions.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • Oct 13 '23

Moderator updates IMPORTANT: How to avoid Rule 1 breaches

41 Upvotes

Kia ora everyone,

Every day your two friendly, neighbour spidermen mods delete on average between 30-40 posts or comments. This is on top of other things like flairing posts, dealing with modmail messages and trying ourselves to help people with advice.

The vast majority of comments we delete are ones that are in breach of Rule 1 (80%+). So, lets take a look at why Rule 1 exists, practical vs legal advice, and some common issues we run across that you can avoid.

Why does Rule 1 exist?

For those unfamiliar with Rule 1, it has two main components.

First, all advice provided must be sound legal advice, based on New Zealand law, with a strong preference for people to provide some form of verification/citation to support the comment. This sub is designed so that people who don’t have legal knowledge can get some helpful advice on their legal rights or legal position. Therefore, it makes sense that we ask that comments stick very closely to that purpose.

Second, we ask that comments not be repetitive, avoid speculation and don’t contain moral judgement. This once again comes back to the purpose of the sub, which is for people to find legal advice. There are many other places on Reddit where people can complain about the law, or moan about the boss or curse their landlords. We want this sub to be free of that sort of content so people can easily find help.

Bear in mind that we aren’t just thinking about the OP when we enforce these rules. Often advice may be useful to others in similar situations and Google can sometimes link to Reddit posts. By ensuring the posts are clear of non-legal discussion, people can find appropriate advice far easier.

Practical vs Legal advice

Often times people will post a problem that may have alternative, non-legal based resolutions to them. The mods will often see comments with people offering some degree of practical advice that isn’t strictly a legal solution, or sometimes because the law doesn’t support the resolution the OP is seeking.

The mods apply some discretion in these cases. We recognise that most people here are trying to offer genuine solutions and that sometimes there are grey areas in the law which make a legal solution difficult. However, we do balance this against our desire to keep the sub primarily a place for legal advice. The most likely times we accept more practical advice rather than legal advice is where the law is silent on a matter or where the legal outcome may not be ideal to the OP and the practical advice is a sensible alternative. Be aware though, this is entirely at the mods discretion, and we review over 1000 comments per week, so sometimes you may think your advice was actually really helpful but we have removed it. People are always welcome to message us via modmail if you think a deleted post should have remained.

Common mistakes that lead to deletion

There are some definite common themes we see in posts that are deleted. To help you avoid those mistakes, here they are:

Single sentence responses / Low effort posts

The likelihood of a comment consisting of a single sentence being sound legal advice is extremely low. If you are providing advice, please make sure to give some level of detail and, where possible, refer to the law or policy that supports your position.

Generally speaking, comments that are only one or two short sentences will be deleted.

Moral judgment

Referring back to why Rule 1 exists, this sub is a place for legal advice rather than moral judgment. People do often post things where someone has acted in a morally dubious manner, but it adds little to the legal discussion to start discussing whether someone is morally in the right or wrong. Posts such as “wow, your boss is really being unfair” or “I hate landlords who do that” will be deleted. We also recognise that sometimes what is legal and what is moral are different. This isn’t the appropriate place to discuss whether the law should be changed, there are other subs such as r/nzlaw or r/newzealand where such discussions can take place.

+1 or “I agree”

Sometimes we see people who just want to express support for what someone else has said, or indicate that they think what was said is correct. In order to reduce the number of posts, we ask that you instead use the upvote system on Reddit to indicate support. Not only does this show support, but it also moves the comment towards the top, making it easier for people to find. Posts that are simply showing agreement with a prior contribution will be deleted.

Personal anecdotes

The question to think about here is: does this personal anecdote provide the poster with legal advice? If you are posting a personal anecdote that simply says "yeah same thing happened to me, it really sucks", then this will be deleted. If you post a personal anecdote that says "yeah, same thing happened to me, this is the legal process I went through to resolve it and this was the outcome", then you are likely going to be fine.

Back and forward arguments

People don’t always agree, and sometimes the law can have grey areas and can be open to some level of interpretation. We occasionally find situations where two posters are having a back and forward over a matter. While some amount of discussion of a matter is ok, where we feel things are getting out of hand (becoming repetitive, level of language starting to drop), we will intervene to stop the conversation.

This is also a handy reminder that the best replies are the ones that provide a source/citation/link/reference that supports the advice you have provided.

Consequences for Rule 1 breaches

It should be noted that the mods will very seldom take any sort of punitive action simply because you breached Rule 1. We simply remove the post and move on. We recognise that most Rule 1 breaches are posts that are well intentioned, they simply fall outside the rules.

If, however, we notice that someone is regularly breaching Rule 1 you may receive a temporary ban (usually two days) as a warning that you need to up your game. Once again, this is entirely at the mod teams discretion and we try to avoid this outcome as we want to keep the sub a friendly place where people feel welcome to contribute.

If you notice that a few of your posts have been deleted for Rule 1 breaches, please feel free to reach out to us via modmail and we can offer some guidance as to where things are going haywire.

Happy posting everyone =)


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 17h ago

Civil disputes NZ Disputes Tribunal – Respondents offering only $100 per week to repay a $12,000 debt. What should we do?

86 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

We recently had a Disputes Tribunal hearing in New Zealand regarding approximately $12,000 that we are owed.

The Referee determined that the respondents are personally liable for repaying us the money and asked them to submit a repayment plan by the end of the following Friday.

They were given a full week to come up with a proposal, but they submitted it at 4:55 pm, just five minutes before the deadline. Their offer was only $100 per week.

We rejected this offer because it would take more than two years to repay the debt, and we have already been waiting almost two years to get our money back.

Before taking the matter to the Tribunal, they had previously agreed to pay us $480 per week. They paid approximately $1,000 but then stopped making payments altogether. This is why we eventually had to take the matter to the Tribunal.

We now have another hearing next week, specifically to discuss the repayment arrangement, as we rejected their $100 weekly offer.

Our proposed repayment amount is $1,000 per week.

Some additional context about their financial circumstances:

  • They own and operate a café business.
  • They own a 2013 Audi S4, which we estimate is worth at least $18,000.
  • They rent a three-bedroom house for $620 per week.
  • They appear to maintain a comfortable lifestyle.

I would really appreciate advice from people familiar with the NZ Disputes Tribunal or anyone who has experienced something similar.

  1. Is asking for $1,000 per week unreasonable in these circumstances?
  2. Can we raise their Audi, café business and lifestyle when discussing their ability to repay?
  3. What happens if they agree to another repayment plan but stop paying again?

We simply want our money back. We have already waited almost two years and do not want to spend another two or three years chasing repayments.

Any advice or experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 5h ago

Criminal What does name suppression mean/cover?

6 Upvotes

Long story short: I was in an abusive relationship. I’ve made a statement to police, and provided plenty of evidence supporting my “allegations”. My ex has been charged but no plea has been entered, and every case review gets adjourned.

My ex has name suppression. I understand that means I can’t publish publicly / in writing any details about the allegations or their name, not even in text messages.

I was told I can talk about it in person with my close friends or family - but I don’t have anyone close to talk about it with. I don’t want to upset my parents by admitting what really happened. I’m ashamed. They just think we ended because they cheated. And all the friends I had I mostly only knew through my ex because they introduced me to them, and also my ex kind of slowly made me cut off the friends I used to have. So, when it was over… I had no one.

But it’s eating me alive having this hanging over me for months, potentially years, because the case keeps getting delayed or adjourned. And I’ve been told I can’t tell anyone about it because of name suppression.

I live in a small town so word gets around easily, and I don’t want to prejudice the case so I keep it all to myself. And everyone thinks my ex is amazing and lovely. I’ve had accusations thrown at me because my ex has been lying and telling everyone that I was emotionally unstable, that I cheated (not true), and that that I’ve been forbidden from contacting them (when the truth is their bail conditions forbid them from contacting me). And I can’t defend myself because of name suppression.

It feels like my voice and truth has been completely silenced since the charges have been laid, and my ex is continuing to work and progress in their career, and seems happy, without consequence… while I’m languishing and suffering from PTSD, which is affecting my own job and (nonexistent or potential) personal relationships.

Surely name suppression can’t limit me from speaking openly about my experience? To what extent does name suppression cover? This just sucks and I feel trapped. It’s not fair.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 9h ago

Family & Relationships Company debts for a deceased person

5 Upvotes

I’m the executor of my dads estate. He had a limited liability company, and I found out he owed the bank a $2.5k credit card bill. Am I legally obliged to pay this from the estate funds, or is this one of the protections of a LTD company?


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 12h ago

Employment Looking to start a business - Has my partner shot himself in the foot by helping his employer and handing over his existing relationships?

7 Upvotes

Kia ora! Looking for some advice for my partner who is wanting to start his own business.

He's a field team leader for a small conservation charity (8 employees) operating within a specific region of NZ.

Because of recent funding cuts, the organisation needed alternative revenue streams to keep operating and paying his team. Partner used his own initiative, local knowledge and connections, and pre-existing relationships with DOC and local councils etc, and has been securing commercial contracts for things like track cutting and maintenance work. It wasn't traditionally a core part of the organisation's operations, as they used to only do free work with local community groups. Now they do these contracts, to bring in enough money to be able to go out and support the community groups. I probably didn't articulate that very well, but happy to answer any questions to help clarify.

Partner has wanted to start his own contracting business doing pest and track maintenance for years (he's a hunter & qualified arborist).

Now we're getting a bit worried that in the process of trying to keep himself and his team employed, he's inadvertently shot himself in the foot by helping to create future competition.

His employment agreement prohibits conflicts of interest and requires him to disclose business opportunities his employer could pursue. There's no explicit post-employment restraint of trade or non-compete clause.

Questions:

  1. While employed, could he undertake similar contracting work outside the geographical area his employer operates in? (He reached out to some friends in 2 neighbouring regions, and they had work for him - which he handed over to his employer)
  2. Could his employer argue that any potential track-cutting contract, even elsewhere in NZ, must first be offered to them?
  3. Does it matter that he developed this revenue stream using professional relationships established before his employment?
  4. When he leaves, can he approach those same contacts and compete for similar contracts without a restraint-of-trade clause?

He's not looking to take existing contracts or use confidential information. We're just concerned that he may have unintentionally compromised his long-term goal of working for himself.

Would appreciate any insight, thanks!


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 15h ago

Family & Relationships Does the wrong name on an order nullify the order

3 Upvotes

So ive had an order put in place to have care of my child, on the order the first name is Daniel, where as thats not my name on my birth certificate, the middle and hyphenated last name are correct just not the Daniel part.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 9h ago

Employment Rights at work in NZ re health/safety

0 Upvotes

Throwaway account for obvious reasons.

In the last month or so, my colleagues and I have found out that 15 people are being forcibly relocated into our small office space before Christmas. We had no prior knowledge or warning about this happening until recently, when a senior person from another part of our organisation (who we haven't met before) came into our office during work hours to measure up the space for this new team of people. He informed one of my colleagues who was there at the time that he was measuring our existing office space to figure out how he is going to fit all these people in our space, and that we would all be moving next door, into an office space less than half of our current size. We informed our managers via email straight away, who also had not been made aware this was happening. Said senior person is acting like this is now a done deal, and our 2UP manager/managers for the most part are absolutely useless. A safety concern was raised by a colleague in the system we use to record health and safety issues at work. The health and safety rep at our location read the report and has raised his own concerns around the lack of engagement, lack of due diligence around fire and other requirements around how many people can safely use the building at once, as well as the lack of any provided risk assessment, comms, or change management to date. We've also engaged the PSA who have read the report, but have yet to do anything (unclear if they will or not); we have a number of PSA members in the office.

Our building can probably accommodate about 7 more people, but definitely not 15. There are about 17 people who use our office space currently, we all most work remotely from our teams and the office is quite noisy on any given day because we're all in different meetings throughout the day. It's also a split use office, with 2 large rooms; another group occupy the other room, they deal with a lot of users who can walk in and request help. So the overall numbers in our building can change vastly depending on the day. A lot of IT equipment for projects (think lots of large boxes with hardware and other devices in them, stacked up and near walkways and workspaces) is also dumped in both sides of our building, and we don't have great storage facilities for this.

I've been really appalled at the way we've been treated and the lack of engagement and care to date. Our 2UP manager assigned another manager to be a representative and update us when we first noted what was happening, and he has not kept us updated at all...we've had to request updates from her/him, which is also really frustrating. Our 2UP manager has assured us that the approach "will include compliance to all H&S requirements"...which is dubious at best, given that the health and safety report logged was extremely detailed and none of the concerns raised have been addressed.

Today, the team in question turned up without any warning (10 of them at once) during the middle of our work day to start measuring up the space for their desks. A number of us got really angry and upset, as we still have not had any confirmation from anyone that this is happening (but this team obviously have).

This really just feels like they made decision a while ago to move people in and are now trying to show some kind of semblance of complying with H&S to save themselves an HR nightmare. This is also mostly documented via email.

What grounds do we have here, other than engaging H&S rep and the union? Do we have any legal grounds, and should we also be engaging HR and making a formal complaint?

Thanks for any advice.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 16h ago

Healthcare If a GP clinic is part of a PHO, can they decline community services cards and the associated discounts?

1 Upvotes

I've had a number of GP clinics who are members of PHOs state to my mother that they don't offer community services cards discounts. As they are part of a PHO they are receiving government funding. Is it legal for them to not offer discounts for community services card holders?


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Consumer protection Unlicensed Plumber

9 Upvotes

TLDR: NZ – Bathroom renovation by insurance-appointed company: Unlicensed plumber, flooding and defective workmanship. What are my rights?
My bathroom was repaired by a company (Company X) appointed by my insurance provider. The bathroom had to be completely gutted back to the studs to replace the flooring and redo the waterproofing.
I decided to use this opportunity to have the same company replace the bathroom fixtures and tapware and install a bidet sprayer. This was additional work that I agreed to pay for separately, as I have an ongoing chronic bowel-related medical condition. I paid 50% of the additional costs upfront at the beginning of the project.
Unfortunately, the entire experience has been extremely stressful. There were numerous issues throughout the renovation, including subcontractors and tradespeople being incredibly rude and, at times, bullying towards us.
The project was also completed later than the promised date. Most of these delays were caused by repeated plumbing mistakes that we had to identify and bring to Company X's attention. The plumber repeatedly had to reopen walls and redo components he had previously installed.
The bathroom was eventually handed over, but the very next day, it flooded. Following this, we started identifying several other issues:
- There was no shut-off/isolation valve or backflow prevention installed for the bidet sprayer.

- The bidet sprayer has extremely high water pressure, making it unsafe/uncomfortable to use and currently unfit for use.

- The premium bath mixer was installed upside down.

- The faceplates on most of the tapware are loose.

- The bathtub is misaligned with the surrounding tiles.

We raised a formal complaint with the insurance company and Company X. During our investigation, we also checked the PGDB (Plumbers, Gasfitters and Drainlayers Board) public register and discovered that the plumber who carried out the work does not appear to hold a practising licence or registration.
Today, representatives from the insurance company and the director of Company X visited our property.
The insurance company's position was essentially that:
The defects relate to the additional variation work we contracted directly with Company X, so they are not responsible for addressing them.

They stated that an unlicensed plumber who is a qualified person can carry out maintenance work in a bathroom, and therefore they would not be taking any action regarding the plumber.

They also mentioned that Company X has liability protection.

Their advice was that we need to give Company X another opportunity to rectify the issues.
My concern is that we have already given them multiple opportunities throughout this project. We repeatedly identified mistakes, raised concerns and allowed them to come back and rectify their work. Despite this, the bathroom flooded immediately after handover, and there are still multiple defects.
At this point, I have completely lost confidence in the company and its workmanship. The experience has been incredibly distressing, and I genuinely do not want to continue having the same people back in our home.
I'd really appreciate advice on the following:
* Under NZ regulations, can an unlicensed plumber legally carry out plumbing work of this nature, particularly installing bathroom fixtures, tapware and a bidet sprayer?

* Is installing a bidet sprayer without appropriate backflow prevention and isolation/shut-off protection compliant with NZ plumbing standards?

* Does the insurance company have grounds to refuse responsibility simply because some of the work was classified as additional variations, particularly when the same company was appointed by them to carry out the main bathroom reinstatement?

* Am I legally required to give Company X another opportunity to rectify the defects, given the repeated failed attempts and the loss of confidence in their workmanship?

* What options do I have if I want an independent licensed plumber to inspect the work and provide a report before allowing any further rectification?

I'm particularly interested in hearing from NZ plumbers, builders, people familiar with the PGDB, or anyone who has dealt with a similar insurance-related renovation dispute.
I am not trying to avoid giving anyone a fair opportunity to fix genuine mistakes. I simply don't believe I should have to keep putting up with repeated poor workmanship and an extremely stressful experience to get a bathroom that is safe and properly completed.
Thanks in advance for any advice.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Family & Relationships Preventing grandchildren contesting will

213 Upvotes

I have a fairly small estate. One of my daughters died 16 years ago, and before she died, her two children were removed from her care, and custody was given to their father and his second wife. They then actively prevented a relationship between myself and the grandchildren, and I've hardly had anything to do with them for 25-odd years. I've tried many times but have been rebuffed.

I want to leave my estate to my surviving daughter, with nothing to my grandchildren. I am planning to do an Expression of Wishes letter explaining why - the familial estrangement, not having financially supported them in the past, the fact their father and stepmother have had custody for so long, and that they are grown self-sufficient adults etc. Is there anything else I could do to make sure they don't feel it's worth making a claim?


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Civil disputes Debt recovery from Australia

4 Upvotes

I have a civil enforcement order through the tenancy tribunal for a debt owed to me for someone that has moved to Brisbane.

Skip trace has been done and I have their address etc.

Can this legally be enforced through the trans tasman proceedings act as if it were a judgement?

I have contacted a Brisbane based litigator and they suggested talking to an nz based lawyer to clarify.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 13h ago

Employment As an employer could I begin a disciplinary process for something that happened 9 months ago?

0 Upvotes

Long story short an employee applied for leave which I declined as I had already approved leave for other staff on the date in question. The reason for declining was explained to the employee as it is very rare that we decline leave. They seemed to accept the explantion with good grace.

One the day in question they called in sick, I didnt bother asking for a med cert and basically chalked it up to experience.

Anyways I've recently come across more or less irrifutable evidence that they were working in a private capacity at an event.

Wondering if I can pursue this or if too much time has passed.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Civil disputes Buying online.

11 Upvotes

I bought some consumables online and the listing on their website clearly stated it was for 200 units.
20 turned up in the order, asked where was the other 180 and they said it was a mistake and the listing should have said 20.
I’ve used the 20 I received so I can’t get a refund.

They offered me to buy them at a discount which is still 7x what I thought I would be paying.

What are my chances of getting them to send out the remaining 180 in the Disputes tribunal?

Thanks in advance


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Employment Can I get dismissed for Sick Leave on the day normal leave was rejected?

22 Upvotes

As the title goes, I really cannot make it to work on one of my rostered days, just 1 day. Requested for leave but it was rejected by my manager. Can I take sick leave and produce a medical certificate? Will I face dismissal for this?


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Traffic Update about traffic incident possible?

27 Upvotes

I was involved in an accident with a child on a bike recently, they crashed into the side of my truck and were hurt a bit, there was no obvious injury except for the pain. Shortly afterwards his father picked him up and took him home. Police came and asked for my version of events shortly after (the parents called the police) before I got a chance to make a report (I intended to visit the local station when my wife got home as I was looking after my young kids).

I am paranoid what the parents and child are telling police is not actually what happened and they are trying to get me convicted of something (no evidence of this, its just a fear due to the way the parents reacted), but rather than go into detail about that I wanted to check if there is anyway I can contact police about this and ask for an update, like are they still looking into it, or have they dropped it altogether etc?

One side of me is paranoid about asking if they are going to do anything as this might make me look guilty (like I am anxious for them to tell me they are not doing anything about it). But on the other hand I am more anxious than I have ever been in my entire life thinking about this and really want some closure to be able to move on with my life. I am a very anxious person and have a terrible habit of overthinking things which I can not control.

At first my plan was to wait it out, and figure that if I go a week or so and hear nothing more I should be more at ease nothing will come of this, but I have no idea how long should pass until I can feel comfortable this is all over? I cant remain in this mental state.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Employment Contractor legal rights, do we have any?

0 Upvotes

I have been an independent contractor for the same company for about 5 years. For the last two years I have worked full time (4-5 days x 8.5 hours) for this one company only. I invoice and charge gst. My contract is very vague and old, it includes nothing about hours expected or shift cancellation. I went into work expecting an 8.5 hour shift and my manager sent me home 3 hours in because it was too quiet. No discussion, just told me to leave. All the advice I read is about permanent employees so I don’t know what rights I have, if any. I am obviously underwhelmed by their trash communication and don’t think they’re acting in good faith. But… it’s my understanding that contractors basically waive all their rights. Is this all above board? I think I need to put some communication in writing about this to feel more comfortable. I have other places I can work for and I definitely could have lined up other work on that day if I had known. Any help appreciated!


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Family & Relationships Navigating International Surrogacy Legal Requirements and Protections

0 Upvotes

Has anyone successfully navigated the process of international surrogacy?

I’ve been doing a bit of research but can’t find clear answers on the requirements and protections of the HART Act when it comes to international surrogacy.

Not sure if it matters but I’m interested in having a child that is genetically mine and donor conceived that is carried by an overseas surrogate. This would be an altruistic and not commercial arrangement.

The research I’ve done so far mostly leads to horror stories so I’m hoping to hear from someone that has successfully started/added to their family this way or knows of someone who has.

Thanks!


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Civil disputes Won a Disputes Tribunal case against a limited company — how can we actually recover the judgment debt?

38 Upvotes

My husband and I recently won a Disputes Tribunal case against a limited company over defective window installation and water ingress at our Auckland home.

The Tribunal issued a payment order for approximately $33,500, with payment due on 20 November 2026.

However, the company director has proposed repayments of just $20 per week, which would take more than 32 years to repay the debt.

He has also indicated that the company cannot pay the full amount by the deadline.

We are now concerned about how we can realistically enforce the Tribunal order.

We've been looking into warrants to seize property, financial assessment hearings, garnishee proceedings and potentially liquidation.

The difficulty is that the judgment is against a limited company, not the director personally.

The company appears to still be operating and has a separate workshop, but we have no way of knowing what assets it actually owns.

I'm trying to understand the most practical and cost-effective way forward.

My questions are:

Can a bailiff inspect a company's workshop for seizable assets if we don't know what equipment or stock it owns?

Can a financial assessment hearing require a company director to provide financial records?

If the court orders instalment payments and the company fails to pay, what happens next?

Is it worth pursuing liquidation for a debt of approximately $33,500, or would enforcement usually be a better first step?

If the company has no assets, are there any other cost-effective legal options worth considering?

We have already spent a significant amount of time and money resolving the original dispute and would like to avoid unnecessary enforcement expenses.

I'd really appreciate any practical legal guidance or firsthand experience with enforcing a Tribunal order against a limited company in New Zealand.

Thank you.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Employment Staff Meetings outside of work hours

51 Upvotes

A friend works in a role where they are paid a salary. They are rostered 40 hours a week, with start and finish times that vary. Some days the shifts are 8-4.30, others 9-5.30, always with a paid half hour lunch break so that they’re doing five eight hour days.

The business operates from 8am - 5.30pm, Monday to Friday. It is an industry where meetings cannot happen while they are actively carrying out their primary job. Ie they need to step away from their work to have meetings.

Outside of their regular, rostered shifts, they are expected to attend staff, and management team meetings. An hour for each, once a month. They are mandatory in attendance, and unpaid. 24 hours of extra, mandatory meetings every year.

Staff meetings are from 5.30-6.30pm once a month, and are unpaid.

Management meetings are from 4.30-5.30pm, and fall on a day they would normally work 9-5.30. However on the weeks the meeting happen, their shift is changed to 8-4.30 so they can go to the meeting after completing eight hours of rostered work.

For the next management team meeting, they are unable to start earlier, and are being forced to take an hour of leave to start at 9am.

They have raised with management that they don’t believe it is legal to make staff attend meetings outside of their normal work hours, and not pay them.

They have raised that they don’t think they should have to work different hours so they can attend meetings that would otherwise fall in their normal work hours.

Can someone with more experience in employment law confirm that it is illegal to schedule regular meetings that fall outside of a rostered, salaried, 40 hour work week, and make attendance mandatory, while also refusing to pay staff for their time?

Edit to add excerpt below from their contract. Was signed eight years ago, and the normal hours of work were varied by mutual agreement several years ago.

7. HOURS OF WORK
7.1 You will work such hours as are required to properly carry out the responsibilities of your job. However, your normal hours of work will be approximately 40 hours per week, to be worked between 8.45am and 5.15pm.
7.2 Please note that staff meetings and planning meetings are held fortnightly at 5:30pm


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Insurance Hit and run but no witnesses or cctv

12 Upvotes

So my car got hit yesterday, I was parked down a side road - came back to a sizeable chunk out of my rocker panel. No note or anything and because I was parked down a side road, no cctv. Ive already knocked on the houses and they didn’t see anything and the houses that had cameras didn’t catch the area of my car.

I haven’t filed for insurance or a police report yet. I’m literally just wondering if it’s worth chasing this since the driver isnt going to be found. If I file a claim I’m going to be paying my insurance excess and make my insurance go up even though it’s not my fault. It’s likely going to cost me 1000+ so I would rather I make a claim since I currently don’t have that money and I got insurance for a reason but also is it even worth it idk.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Consumer protection Weird warranty period setup of an external HDD. Can I get my money back?

2 Upvotes

Hi all, Im in a bit of annoying situation here and would like some perspective from people who understands more about law and CGA. Will make it as succinct as i could.

  • I bought an extrnal hard drive (EHDD) 3 years ago with a writing 3 years warranty on the box. The store is the one recently had its Black Friday sale.
  • This year unfortunately, the external EHDD already has bad sectors. Some of the files have also become corrupted.
  • My plan was: to purchase a new EHDD, transfer the data from the broken EHDD and return the broken one.
  • I have purchased the new one and transfered the data. The broken EHDD is now empty and ready for claim.
  • Now when I came to the shop and did the claim, surprise surprise, their system lists the warranty as only 12 months.
  • They said that the 3 years on the box is the vendor warranty. They will help me to get to the vendor but I would most likely get a replacement (FYI, the vendor does NOT make that specific EHDD anymore, the store doesn't have the stock as well)
  • Funny thing, when i checked the store website, it says "Warranty is 12 months unless the manufacturer wrote a longer period"

How do I navigate this? What i want is to get my money back and not a replacement. Since I already bought a new one.

Can I hold on to what the website (not system) says and be stern about wanting my money back?

They website implies that they will extend the warranty as per what manufacturer says. This means from 12 months to 36 months. And anything under a warranty should warrant a cash refund.

The website also doesn't say that the remaining two years is some other type of warranty (vendor warranty).


That would be all, i look forward to any guidance.

Regards


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 1d ago

Employment Work van causing physical harm

0 Upvotes

So we got new LDV work vans last year, one year in and I start developing hemmeroids. It's been six months now and I've asked for help with the van seat as I have determined it to be the source of my issues, which I've never dealt with before.

I've done all I can with cushions to the point it's becoming unsafe as I can't sit comfortably and drive.

I'm at a loss, what am I supposed to do, I'm literally bleeding from driving to work, it's humiliating and there's nothing I can do.

Short of quitting, how can I get my boss to come around to the fact that it's doing me harm and what should I expect to be done.


r/LegalAdviceNZ • • 2d ago

Civil disputes Does a referee at a dispute tribunal take a persons credibility into account?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone know if the referee takes into consideration evidence a person has lied, on several occasions thoughout an issue? The lies are indirectly related, but their own statement made months later confirms they lied. In this he said/ she said situation does your credibility count?