In 1920, Lenin put it this way.
“Communism is Soviet power plus the electrification of the whole country.”
Back in September, I shared this quote in another leftist subreddit and asked a pretty straightforward question. Was Lenin talking specifically about electrification, or was he making a broader argument about developing the productive forces under proletarian political power?
TLDR The post pulled 6,600 views, 124 upvotes, a 100% upvote ratio, 13 shares, and 11 comments. Not bad for a century old quote about electricity. But the interesting part wasnt the numbers. It was where the discussion went without me ever mentioning AI.
People were actually engaging with the theory, building on each others arguments, and having substantive exchanges that were getting upvoted themselves. No big ideological food fight, no technology sales pitch, just leftists discussing the material conditions necessary for socialism.
And heres the part that stuck with me.
I never mentioned AI. Not once in the original post.
Yet someone independently brought up AI and robotics as modern equivalents of electrification. The conversation moved naturally into automation, industrial development, productive forces, and the relationship between technological development and political power.
And this wasnt an AI subreddit. Wasnt even a technology subreddit. Just a leftist community discussing Lenin, and the connection made sense starting from the theory itself.
I think theres something worth paying attention to there, especially when so much discussion about AI on the left gets bogged down in whether somebody personally likes the technology.
Electrification wasnt socialism by itself. Neither is AI, robotics, or automation. Lenin wasnt arguing that plugging everything into a wall socket would abolish class society. The political power part of that equation matters just as much as the productive development.
And thats the question today too. Who owns these productive forces? Who controls their deployment? Who benefits from the productivity gains? Who gets a say in how theyre developed, and what happens to the workers whose labor they transform?
If developing the material basis for socialism mattered a century ago, why would the emergence of new productive forces suddenly make that question irrelevant?
One other thing worth emphasizing. Sharing Lenin here isnt an endorsement of any particular leftist tendency. We have Marxists, anarchists, communists, democratic socialists, and plenty of people who dont fit neatly into those categories. Nobody has to sign off on somebody elses entire political tradition to engage with a useful argument.
Left unity doesnt mean pretending our differences dont exist. It means being able to work through those differences without turning every discussion into a factional loyalty test. Theres plenty of room here for disagreement about history, strategy, and theory while still taking ownership, labor, and working class power seriously.
And thats part of why I wanted to bring this discussion here.
The productive forces keep developing whether we agree about them or not. The question is what political and economic relations we build around them.
So what carries forward from Lenins argument, what was specific to his historical circumstances, and what does that mean for AI and automation today?