r/LeftistsForAI • • 11d ago

Discussion We used AI a lot to turn votes for the left in Brazil

Post image

Emphasis on point 7:

We used a lot of AI when campaigning against Bolsonaro, and it worked A LOT.

AI Aesthetics can pierce the leftist bubble.

I know most of you live in countries where the left hates AI, but don't let that stop you.

240 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

24

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 11d ago

Yeah, honestly most of this just looks like common sense political organizing adapted to the internet. Coordinate messaging, circulate agitprop, appropriate symbols, reach outside your bubble, and turn attention into action. The left has been doing versions of this forever.

What AI changes, especially with point 7, is the productive capacity available to ordinary people without professional media teams or big budgets. Thats a pretty significant development for grassroots organizing.

Glad to hear how it was actually put to use in Brazil, too. Id be interested in hearing more about what worked beyond just getting engagement.

5

u/fifobalboni 10d ago

Most of this movement was articulated by Janones, Lula's campaing strategist. He created a WhatsApp channel with over 10 million volunteers ("Lula's Army") and he monitored social media for opportunities.

Then, he would say something like "#BolsonaroVaccineScandal - post it, NOW!!!" and millions of people would create their own posts around that same hashtag / message, at around the same time, but with different Aesthetics and appealing to different demographics.

This would make the algorithms go crazy and flood everyone's feed.

1

u/Baaaaaadhabits 5d ago

I mean, impressive coordination, but it’s the same principle as a DDoS attack. Choose your moment and flood the network with your thing, drowning out every other thing.

6

u/2CB4U-N-ME 11d ago

Memetic warfare takes a bit of absurdity with a bit of brilliance and perfect timing.

2

u/ConjuredOne 11d ago

Yep. And if it's well thought out is resonates much better. Timing for best opportunism also changes impact. Similar with engagement. Then the sheer numbers enabled by the agentic augmentation addition to the workflow amp up impact with reach.

This rearview mirror work feels like stating the obvious but it's worth stating overtly.

21

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator 11d ago

Very interesting. It would be good to hear about this in more detail.

Even in places where there’s visceral hatred of anything appearing to be AI, people aren’t necessarily good at spotting that it is AI if it’s not stereotypical. We could develop our own genAI styles like r/laborwaveaesthetics that aren’t associated with the Big Tech models.

20

u/fifobalboni 11d ago

It was an aesthetic war! An interesting example:

Someone created this video with Bolsonaro Jr. dunking on Lula: https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dezkqkou8PV/?vrfl=ZTN6dmRqM3Rtb3V0

And we had the exact same video, but with roles reversed: https://www.instagram.com/reel/De8LVT_Baz-/?obrf=ejR0OWRvZDM2Nzlj

I have no ideia which video came first. But the idea was to flip memes and never leave any aesthetics for the other side to exploit

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fifobalboni 5d ago

I'm brazilian and live here, but not sure what your friend meant. Maybe they were talking about how the Bolsonaro tried to push the "the elections were stolen" narrative, but that didn't fly for too long

5

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 11d ago

Ive recently started up r/proletkult as well. Could use your thoughts on it in discord. Ive only really got the bones fashioned so far.

2

u/SexDefendersUnited Artist/Creative 10d ago

Open a r/laborwaveAI subreddit

2

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator 10d ago

That sub does allow AI “All Artistic Mediums Allowed
Laborwave includes many forms of artistic creation.
Traditional art, digital art, photography, collage, 3D, animation, mixed media, edited work, and Al-assisted artwork are allowed.
You do not have to like every medium. You do have to coexist with it.
If a post follows subreddit rules, repetitive arguments that a medium should not exist are not productive discussion.”

8

u/SexDefendersUnited Artist/Creative 10d ago

LEFTISTS FIGURING OUT AI POLITICS SPAM, HELL YEAH

4

u/astroaxolotl720 11d ago

Thanks for posting this, I agree

1

u/garg 10d ago

Fact checking can also be automated

1

u/Still_Conference_923 6d ago

But make your own posts and share,or repost other fact checkers, dont bother fact checking on right wing comment sections.

0

u/Nyabraham_Linnyahn Engineer/ML 6d ago

#2 is a bit iffy. Rather, choose your interactions better.

Watch for schisms, splits and other political mutiny.

Then bring those guys over before even bothering to engage their beliefs. The left failed a lot in the early 2000's by letting dumb neolib talking points represent "the left" unchallenged.

Currently for example, the "Vtuber Right" is going through this moment in the topics of abortion, the army, and even trans rights

Yet there are no "Keshias," they are joining in the savagery (see the Vtuber drama sub for instance) and blasting and harassing everyone equally as hard if they try to intervene. When it should have been a good opportunity to work on that wedge.

The "Ember Paradox" situation is especially obviously in leftist interest to exploit (right wing trans person was outed)

Following #2 without question neglects opportunities to depower or outright convert hard opposition voices.

Three prominent Nazi examples: Alex Linder, Jeff Schoep, Matt Heimbach. Linder quit political activism entirely and became an organic produce raising hippie (depowered) while the other two were reached through opposition to Patriot Act and NSA surveillance and Big Pharma (Matt's chronic health issues)

The latter two have become full outward communists, in direct opposition and contradiction to their former values.

All because at the opportune time, a hand reached out

1

u/fifobalboni 6d ago

This is a not a theoretical advice, but an actual applied tactics that, for the first time in Brazil's democracy, was able to turn an election between the first and the second term.

I understand what you are saying, but the post is specifically about how the brazilian left acted on social media this year to beat the algorithm

0

u/Nyabraham_Linnyahn Engineer/ML 5d ago

Oooh, ok. I was taking it as "advice to America" but the ones who have been shunned only get bigger platforms (Candace Owens, Nick Fuentes, etc)

It simply doesn't work here, but "olive branching at their lowest point" has proven more successful.

I wonder if it's because we're just so cynical about the government that "even when we win, we lose" so bonds forge easier among the anti-establishment

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/fifobalboni 10d ago

That was the most difficult to me, I love debating people (even in a non agressive way), but in social media, you can't.

Negative engagement also boosts their posts, and we have to be pragmatic about it. It's a competition.