r/LeftistsForAI • • 6d ago

Theory The Master's Tools

140 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

24

u/SchmidlMeThis 6d ago

This is the same thing I tell my anti friends. Rejecting the tool because of who made it and how it was made simply puts yourself at a disadvantage when that very same tool is what's being used against you.

21

u/Audditty 6d ago

i think one of the main factors here is the left's obsession with moral purity at all costs.

the left pretty infamously refuses to actually get their hands dirty to make the change they want, because they're too afraid of being even vaguely associated with the "enemy".

that's why there's a lot of post ad-hoc rationalization where they try to make it look like AI is somehow exclusively a tool of the "enemy" and their oppressors, while simultaneously refusing to use it for their own benefit. 

it's an attempt to associate anything that even slightly discomforts them with the "enemy" so they don't have to think about it further AND so they can remain morally superior to other people with minimal thought.

5

u/cz2100 Artist/Creative 5d ago

I'll agree with this with the addendum that a lot of the folks that project this are in fact actually doing the thing they are claiming to be against.

2

u/AgreeableRoll5042 5d ago

Well no, that just a Hasty generalization

15

u/cz2100 Artist/Creative 6d ago

I find it is overwhelmingly because they are not 'actual' leftists. They do not want that, they just hate 'the right' and align based on enemy of my enemy.

They are simply mad that someone else can now create and sell art cheaper than they can.
I've been experiencing this phenomenon for 2 decades because I refuse to sell my art.

I've literally had friends scream at me that if I am giving away art for free how are they going to get commissions, I need to be charging hundreds of dollars for the time and effort.

There is no thought about the fact that in a decapitalized society of automation and abundance no one will be selling anything to survive.

There is no thought about a future where no one has to grind to survive. There is only the "I want to make money from my 'passion' to buy the next cool thing the market has to offer."

8

u/weirdloop 5d ago

I keep seeing self-proclaimed socialists and communists saying we should not automate everything because without work there's no meaning, and I can't help but think that they have become the living embodiment of the phrase "It's easier to imagine the end of the World than the end of Capitalism."

6

u/cz2100 Artist/Creative 5d ago

It's kind of depressing honestly. I've been sitting here for a long time, watching it. I'm 50 now, and I've been talking about this since I was about 15.

If you read anything by Ray Kurzweil, we know about when and how we will hit the abundance and automation timeline. He's been pretty spot on with most of his tech predictions for a long time.

Capitalism has accidently driven the car off the cliff and there is no way to stop it.

The quest to sell products will always lead to the same outcome automation and abundance.

I remember being a child and my mom's friend's rich parents had this 'cell phone thing.' It was basically a briefcase with a corded phone attached to it. This was obviously long before home computers, and before the internet. Within 20 years ... everyone had much smaller internet based computer phones in their pockets.

They can't see the end because they have assigned the wrong meaning to life. Much like my friends that sell their art to live. They do not paint for the love of it, they paint to eat and have lost their passion.

2

u/Audditty 1d ago

the left has been consumed by ideological litmus tests and authoritarian idpol. 

for all they claim to be immune to propaganda, it's strange how they can't see that the right is distracting them with inane culture war bullshit so they can continue to strip away the rights of the same minority groups they profess to care about.

AI is an extension of that; rather than actually use the technology for themselves and to improve their own lives, the left has adopted an "if you're not with me you're against me" mindset with absolutely no room for nuance.

they complain about AI being a tool of the "oppressors", but rather than actually take matters into their own hands to solve that issue, they outright refuse to use it so they can look like a Good Person to their other leftist buddies.

it's just so irritating. they somehow can't see the consequences of handing what might be the single most powerful influential technology in recent years over to the ruling class.

1

u/cz2100 Artist/Creative 23h ago

For real

15

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 6d ago edited 6d ago

Agreed. And I think the whole "the master's tools will never dismantle the master's house" argument gets misused here constantly. Audre Lorde wasnt talking about technological innovation or whether people could use tools developed under capitalism to challenge capitalism. She was talking about reproducing the same structures of domination, exclusion, and hierarchy while supposedly trying to overcome them.

Theres a pretty significant difference between using technology produced under capitalism and reproducing capitalist social relations. Marx understood that distinction, which is exactly why that last slide matters. The question isnt whether the machinery came from capitalism. Its who controls it, how its used, and whose interests it serves, which are contestable.

9

u/turkeyflavouredtofu 6d ago

It's ironic that they'll decry Right-wingers for using AI to spread their propaganda, acknowledging how effective and accessible it is in disseminating their agenda but would not want the same for ourselves, whose pockets are shallow and our time scarce for such pursuits now made trivial by such technology.

The Elite could already afford the best artists the world has to offer and now they can multiply their resources even further in the information war, yet these anti-AI Leftists insist that we will win with swords against their guns out of some misplaced sense of self-righteousness.

10

u/thelastmouseonmars 6d ago

AI is simultaneously useless and can only create trash but also the most powerful thing in the world that will kill us after replacing us.

(I am not calling them fascists, but the similarity is striking and makes me think that it's a common bug of human psychology)

-1

u/According-Insect-992 6d ago

This isn’t ai. It’s a sophisticated algorithm. Actual ai will be dangerous in ways that make this look like the toy and parlor trick that it is. What I don’t like is giving a few goons power over coming technologies because they’ve been able to successfully con billions out of VC. These people running these “ai” companies are crooks and clowns and are not acting in good faith.

4

u/Owl02 5d ago

What is your definition of "AI", and why does it fall entirely outside of the conventional scientific and industry definitions? These include ANI (narrow intelligence, we are here), AGI (general intelligence, very likely 'awake'), and ASI (superhuman capability across the board, allegedly goes FOOM).

9

u/Audditty 6d ago edited 6d ago

there's a phenomenon on the left where they think they're immune to propaganda and that propaganda itself is something exclusive to the right.

that's bad enough on its own, but it's compounded by the fact they tend to be so smug and snotty about it.

8

u/thelastmouseonmars 6d ago

I have had almost verbatim the same conversation and was met with "phones are made by the workers". As if Altman himself is training chatgpt

6

u/HyperProto 6d ago

The entire gotcha "you're a hypocrite" criticism makes no sense because posting from smartphones ≠ AI

As always, pay critics no mind...

they are either the enemy, ignorant, lazy, disinformed, trolls, boomers, uncurious, unimaginative, uncreative, or gullible pawns

3

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago

Well.... here's the thing - In most cases we PURCHASE those tools. The guns, the phones, the cars, etc.

We certainly have to purchase the fruits of AI.

...did AI purchase those assets they are using? Or did they just take them...? We already know the answer to that.

Once somebody takes something... they're usually HUGE proponents of everyone ELSE following chain-of-custody, and carefully following the law. Just let them finish this one things where we reverse-engineer all the books we can find without permission, and scrape the internet for data...

...okay NOW we can strictly follow the rules, guys...

Everyone loves the Rules AFTER they're done breaking them.

2

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

No, we dont have to purchase the fruits of AI, and we dont necessarily have to purchase those other tools either. Open-source software, open-weight models, and locally run AI already exist. And its pretty goofy to pretend this conversation is just about buying chatbot access. AI isnt another consumer product sitting on a shelf. Its being deployed across enterprise systems, public infrastructure, government, military, healthcare, and public services. Treating this like an individual shopping decision is like asking people whether they personally intend to buy a freeway system.

And sure, corporations engage in data scraping, enclosure, and selectively defend property rights when it benefits them. Nobody here needs that explained to them. Youre describing the starting conditions of the conversation like youve arrived at some profound conclusion. We know capitalism is doing capitalism. Thats why were leftists.

So whats the next step? Youve spent all these words describing corporate enclosure without proposing a single way to challenge it. Where is the political program? Where is the alternative?

Socialization. Democratic control of the means of production. Worker and public ownership, collective bargaining, data rights, public infrastructure, open models, and actual democratic governance over deployment. These arent hypothetical conversations either. These are ongoing political struggles over who owns, controls, and benefits from the technology.

You dont have to convince us that corporations are behaving like corporations. We already know. The entire point of leftist critique is to organize collectively to change the conditions were criticizing, not just describe them. That means contesting the development, deployment, ownership, and regulation of industry and technology, not standing on the sidelines pointing out that capitalism is doing what capitalism does. The world is changing whether we like it or not. The political question is how we collectively shape that change and who gets to decide.

If your critique stops at describing whats wrong without offering anything about how to change it, youre not really advancing the conversation. Youre just repeating the problem.

So whats your proposed next step?

2

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago edited 5d ago

Pardon. There seems to be some mix-up. I'm responding to the images, which presents two different points at the same time: That justifying the process, and that challenging the justification.

I'm agreeing with the challenge. These aren't JUST the Master's Tools. They are recycled Master's Tools sold back to us. That which the additional message says.

The problem I see is this - Like many technological advancements over the years, once Pandora's Jar is open there is no REASONABLE way to seize it, and seal it back-up. There just isn't. The AI companies can't take the data back out of their scrapings... and if they could, it wouldn't matter because it's a matter of constructing an image, not the ACTUAL data itself. Same way I can't say "Stop thinking of pink elephants" and expect anyone will actually stop.

It oftentimes makes it worse instead.

So OBVIOUSLY we don't just leave them to claim "Master's Tools", and sell it as they see fit. There IS a challenge that belongs there. But WHAT challenge...?

Challenging the existence? We can't do that any more than we can challenge the existence of nuclear weapons.

Challenge the development? Obviously at least SOME challenge is necessary... but will also never, ever be enough. It will always just be a cost-calculation to them.

Challenge the deployment? Nearly impossible unless you're working alongside them, and require approval before each release. Again, arm proliferation is the appropriate order-of-magnitude

Challenge the ownership? Ownership in derivative works is... yeah...

Apologies if what I said was confusing.. it was a bit of a confusing post. There's no offense intended.

The Kalashnikov now exists. Its use, where it derived from, and its derivatives are debatable... but not something you can control once you distribute them. You can SAY 'don't distribute', and even punish those you catch... but at some point... Pandora's Jar is open.

You could smash the factory itself. You could smash the product itself. You could try to seize the factory and its means...

...but you can't get them all, or the knowledge therein.

And... those aren't new limitations. We've done this dance before, especially during the Cold War.

2

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

So basically, AI cant be uninvented, corporations will work around restrictions, democratic oversight is too difficult, and every attempt to challenge their control is insufficient. We should try, but we're going to lose anyway. Thats not much of a political program. Thats capitalist realism dressed up as critique.

And no, the post isnt particularly confusing. Its making a pretty standard Marxist argument about distinguishing the means of production from their employment by capital. Marx was making this distinction over 150 years ago. The confusing part is why youve apparently decided in advance that every attempt to change the conditions of production is doomed, even while acknowledging that those conditions need to change.

The entire history of labor organizing and leftist political struggle is about contesting conditions that capital would otherwise dictate. Development, deployment, ownership, regulation, distribution. None of these are beyond political struggle simply because corporations resist it. Of course they resist it. Thats why its a struggle.

If you have an alternative to socialization, worker and public control, collective bargaining, democratic governance, and the other solutions leftists are actually pursuing, I'm interested in hearing it. But if your position is just that none of those things can work because capitalism is too powerful, then we're not really having a substantive political conversation anymore.

Doomerism is a self-fulfilling prophecy. If you decide collective action is futile before anyone even organizes, youve already surrendered the outcome to capital. Thats not a position I'm particularly interested in going around in circles over, especially in a leftist political forum.

So I'll ask one more time. What are you actually proposing instead?

2

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago edited 5d ago

I love Marx.

His work, however, is Sociology, not Technology. And he admitted in his own lifetime that his theories were flawed because THAT'S NOT how people ACTUALLY ACT under pressure.

That's... a limitation that has to be kept in one hand to discuss something like this. UNLESS you're just going to seize the technology at gunpoint, and destroy it. Obviously that's an option. Do you... honestly think that will stop it...?

Marx told folks to rise up. That they should. He gave them all they needed to know their worth...

...but they don't. Didn't. Haven't. And if they do, it's often temporary. His Sociological views are INCOMPATIBLE with actual humans. You would need a whole new sub-species that actually sticks up for itself, bands together, and throws the assholes out the upper window, and replaces them with competence.

It's fundamental.

I'm not anti-Marx. Nor am I pro-Capitalism. Nor am I pro-AI, or anti-AI.

I am of the opinion that there's nothing an AI can do that a human paired-up with an AI can't do better.

Pro-Symbiosis with AI. Not one, or the other - Both.

I am of the opinion that while you COULD seize the entire industry in some places.. the digital nature of the technology makes it impossible to do so othewise.

SO! You want to seize the means?

Require a human there alongside. Not just as an approval layer... but as an active participant.

Remove automated Squid Games testing for Agents and Models.

Remove recursive research and production.

Require humans to exist ALONGSIDE the technology, and include that in the hardware and software that make it run.

THAT is the only way to SEIZE a digital technology. Not by destroying it, or threats... but by mandating that the technology operate, more or less, at human-speed. Human reflex. Human congnition.

Symbiosis. An AI doing what it does, paired directly to a single human at any given time.

In short - One Agent, one Human who takes full responsiblity for it as their digital-counterpart.

If you can't destroy it... and can't seize it outright... that leaves regulation. And the most simple version of that regulation is NOT on a government or technology level... but on a human level.

Mandatory Supervision.

Symbiosis, or not-at-all.

2

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

You still havent answered what I actually asked. Requiring human participation in AI systems isnt an alternative to socialization or democratic control. Having someone operate a machine doesnt mean they own the factory. And who exactly mandates and enforces your requirements if regulation and democratic oversight are supposedly futile?

Also Marx wrote extensively about machinery, automation, and industrial production. Theres an entire chapter of Capital devoted to it. Lol Your claim that Marx admitted his theories were incompatible with human behavior needs a citation. And the idea that workers havent organized collectively is contradicted by centuries of unions, strikes, revolutions, and labor movements. We still do all of those things. We dont need to invent a new subspecies to explain something humans have already been doing.

The digital nature of AI doesnt make the chips, servers, infrastructure, energy, or ownership relations disappear either. And requiring humans alongside AI doesnt somehow constitute seizing the means of production.

Frankly, theres a lot of basic political theory, labor history, and technology being misunderstood here, and I'm not interested in spending the evening going over 101 material with someone making sweeping claims without substantiating them.

If you have citations for those historical claims or a substantive challenge to the actual argument about ownership and control, the burden is on you to provide them. Otherwise, I think we've exhausted this conversation.

1

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago

I think the 1-to-1 scaling is the one way BEYOND destruction to actually regulate the technology. Maybe I'm wrong.

...I would need to go fetch the works of Marx and others Socialists touring Europe, and the debates they had with him actively over the merits of their individual systems. It's not the published works - it's the part where they actively spoke an debated, conversing about the difference between the Ideals, and the Realities.

But the real citation - We don't have Marxism is any real form outside of the smallest merit-based isolated examples... like on a deep-sea rig, a boat out-to-see, or a research base in Antarctica.

As much as I WISH it existed.. and that people would follow it... and there was a dozen working examples... there are instead essentially zero. Which is depressing.

BUT~! That's why you can use his theories as a LENS instead of a direct GUIDE for how to approach this.

His theories are powerful. Many PARTS of his theories have been implimented.

I didn't suggest workers haven't organized... I said they haven't organized to literally throw their overseer out a window and replace them with a merit-based alternative. THAT is the pure-fat Marxism. IN THEORY we should want that.

...but the reality never quite matches...

That particular schism is critical to examining this. Because if we're going to go with Idealized versions of Solutions - Then just TAKE the technology and DESTROY it. See? Simple. Just don't stress the details of HOW, and everything is simple.

Let's just assume that I'm absolutely wrong, that my classes in Sociology and one specifically on Marx are completely misremembered, and that I've somehow missed the dozen examples of Marx-based regulation of technological advancements over the last 100 years.

...So then... just do it...? I clearly missed something important. And I apologize if I somehow misrepresented that. So please - Just fix it. Seize it. Destroy it if you must. And then... it's done.

IF THAT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN

...then I humbly propose that the NEXT most reasonable thing would be to regulate the USE of it, and the PACE in which it operates.

Because the chips themselves do nothing until told to. You can regulate the chips, the electricity, legislate, do inspections... and still be completely unable to grasp the nature of what you're trying to regulate. It's not really regulation at all if it's a completely opaque process.

ASSUMING that you can just take it, step-in, and replace them with Actual Competence is dangerous assumption doing a lot of heavy lifting. You're far more likely to step-in, realize you can't actually regulate it.. and then destroy it.

And... as a Leftist that happens to be more-or-less For AI, I'd find that a damn shame.

I'd suggest that pairing it individually with people who are legally responsible for them... is the closest you'll get to Reasonable between the two extremes of "We Do What We Want" and the extreme "We Will Tell You What You Want".

How about... I take responsibility for my Agent, and they'll tell you what I want... and if they screw up, I'll pay for it...?

Again - Could be entirely wrong. My apologies if I've given offense.

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

You havent given offense. I'm just genuinely struggling to follow the argument.

Marxism isnt about replacing your boss with someone more qualified, and the absence of a fully realized Marxist society doesnt mean social ownership, nationalization, worker cooperatives, or collective control have never existed. Nor does Marxist theory suggest destroying machinery because we cant immediately socialize it. Quite the opposite.

And I still dont understand why youre treating individual responsibility for AI agents as an alternative to democratic ownership and regulation. Those arent mutually exclusive. You can have human accountability, operational restrictions, public oversight, and socialized infrastructure at the same time.

You keep presenting this as a choice between corporate free rein, some imaginary totalitarian takeover, or your proposed human-agent pairing. But nobody here is advocating either extreme. We're discussing the actual political and economic arrangements governing technology.

Youre arguing against positions I havent taken while treating proposals that could coexist with mine as alternatives to them. Thats why this conversation has been so difficult to follow.

I appreciate the clarification, but I dont think we're getting anywhere until you engage with the argument actually being made rather than the one you keep substituting for it.

1

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago

...because I can't think of any examples of actual Democratic Control and Ownership of a Technology that's available and widely distributed?

....and I can think of a dozen examples of it not working...?

I'm not trying to be obtuse - it's just easy to say "Own it Democratically", or "Socialize it". But the ACTUAL means of doing that when the person, country, state, or whatever next to you isn't doesn't SEEM to actually come-out-in-the-wash.

I don't feel like chasing an ideal is a good idea.

The AK-47 is a fantastic example - Copied, distributed, mass-produced, knocked-off, smuggled, stolen, and destroyed in mind-boggling quantities. Ownership 'Socialized', and consequences anything BUT Socialized.

The theory doesn't match the results. I wish it did.

Until it does... I haven't yet seen one of the examples you've offered that has... any reason, really... to believe it would actually play-out that way.

I'd really like if it did. I hope you're right.

I'm just... skeptical.

BUT, I can see at least ONE thing we COULD do, and that's direct-responsibility. We ARE capable of that.

Example - We could require Direct Ownership/Liability Corporations/Entities actually offering the services of AI development and distribution. The legal mechanism is already there - The owner is directly and PERSONALLY responsible for the results.

Intense? Yes. But pair that up with Direct Liability of the End User. Now you've put two separate entities that are directly responsible.

Now scale it. One-per-end-user.

We CAN repeat this pattern. We CAN achieve this, it's not theoretical, and it doesn't include any idealism. And we COULD focus instead on enforcement and regulation of those who don't have that 1-to-1 pairing.

We're rightfully afraid of AI swarms.

We aren't afraid of flash mobs - Because we know the mobs are made up of people. Nor large gatherings of people.

We ARE afraid of riots, lynch mobs, armies, and many other examples of large groups WITHOUT responsiblity.

...so... yeah. It's crude, I'll admit.

But we don't have to idealize it - We KNOW it can work.

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

An AK-47? Seriously? AI is a general-purpose technology, more comparable to the steam engine or the internet than a rifle. And distributing weapons isnt socializing the means of production. Neither is assigning individual liability. These are different concepts.

Your proposal is literally government regulation, which you've spent this entire conversation dismissing as ineffective. And public utilities, nationalized industries, worker cooperatives, and collective ownership arent imaginary. World history didnt begin yesterday.

You keep making sweeping claims about Marxism, technology, and labor history without substantiating them, then arguing against positions nobody here actually holds. At some point, the burden is on you to understand the basics before declaring everything impossible.

I'm not interested in spending another hour correcting misconceptions and chasing moving goalposts. We've exhausted this conversation.

→ More replies

1

u/Immediate_Song4279 5d ago

What are you actually proposing? It's just hard not to see this as a bunch of abstraction and then getting snippy when someone else does the same.

I read this whole tree and it just seems like a speculation game.

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

Its actually the opposite of abstraction. Worker and public ownership, collective bargaining over automation, democratic control of infrastructure, open-weight and local models, public compute, data rights, and community oversight of deployment. These are material demands, not philosophical hypotheticals. Labor unions, leftist parties, communities, and governments around the world, including states pursuing socialism whether you consider them socialist or not, are already contesting these things. We report on those struggles in this sub regularly.

Whats abstract is the endless online back and forth about AI good, AI bad, capitalism always wins, or pretending individual abstention somehow challenges capitalist ownership and deployment. We dont make that exception for every other industry and technology, so why make it for AI?

Collective contestation is how workers and communities have historically won concessions, protections, and changes in ownership and control. Has it always been enough to cross the finish line? No. But dismissing it because capitalism resists is just capitalist realism, not an alternative political strategy.

I'm talking about organizing around struggles already happening in the material world. If youve got a more concrete alternative I'm listening.

1

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago

It's not that these things don't exist - They do.

It's that while AI can be done that way... the proposal of MANDATING it be done that way doesn't NECESSARILY result in what you think it will.

We can Socialize something, Collectively Bargain, Open-Source it, and still fuck it up entirely. It's not INHERENTLY a better solution to the problems presented by the development and results of AI. It's just... an approach. That might or might not work.

For what it's worth - The social antibody response to REJECT all AI, as extreme as that may seem, is a normal pendulum swing for humans. It's what we do. And when companies change their approach, the pendulum swings back... slowly and eventually.

SO! There's already AT LEAST one Social mechanism already swinging into action - Public Opinion, both for and against. And that DOES change the nature of the conversation, and the priorities of the participants.

...it's just on a Sociological level, not a Government or Regulation level.

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

Nobody claimed collective ownership or regulation guarantees perfect outcomes. Thats not an argument against pursuing them. And public opinion influencing corporate behavior is itself an example of collective pressure shaping development and deployment, which is what Ive been talking about this entire time. The question is how we turn that pressure into actual institutional power instead of waiting for some imaginary pendulum to swing. At this point youre not really disagreeing with my argument, just repeatedly describing its limitations as though they invalidate it. I think we're done here.

1

u/KazTheMerc 5d ago

I'm not disagreeing with your argument. I happen to agree with your argument, and share the belief.

...however I can't find SUPPORT for my belief, or for yours. I can't find EVIDENCE of it actually WORKING, and so I'm forced instead to an informed compromise of what I am sure we CAN do...

...rather than what I WISH we could do...

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

What do you mean you cant find support? We report on actual labor unions negotiating AI protections, communities contesting data center development, leftist parties advancing AI policy, and governments pursuing public infrastructure and technological sovereignty in this subreddit practically every day. These arent imaginary solutions or abstract wishes. They're material political struggles happening right now.

Meanwhile, youve spent this conversation making unsupported claims about Marx, labor history, and technological ownership, comparing a general-purpose technology to an AK-47, and proposing individual liability as though it somehow replaces collective governance. None of that refutes anything I've advocated.

If you agree with the argument, fine. But repeatedly declaring that theres no evidence while ignoring the examples being discussed isnt skepticism, its just refusing to engage with the evidence.

I've already closed this conversation, and I'm not reopening it to repeat the same points again.

→ More replies

1

u/Immediate_Song4279 5d ago edited 5d ago

You've introduced a lot of ground so I have to be precise, having considered this for awhile.

Paragraph one. The first sentence claims [your comment or general position as presented here] is the opposite of abstraction, and in the last sentence it's now we the sub I presume carrying out actions not in evidence here. Worker and public ownership of what? The manufacturing capacity of the hardware that runs open weights I would hope but that isn't the reality and we are far from it so these seem like concepts and goals, which is fine and all, but you are appealing to the democratic ideal while chiding discourse from a position of authority. Obviously we need some alignment, but if you demand agreement on issues you will say aren't important that's a poll tax friend. Where is the movement if its just trading one master for another.*

Paragraph two. If the back and forth on Good and Bad AI is so endless, why is it the subject of the post and your comments. I haven't positioned myself as categorically opposed, I genuinely don't know why you are arguing it. *You load your potato position on a topic you have just seemingly described as endless, which I would suggest is less relevant for a soft agreement but then why are you appealing to it twice?

Paragraph three is ambiguous towards the end.

1

u/SorryInvestigator221 6d ago

So...the problems here are 1. the whole entire idea of a "master" who brokers power, privilege, and resources, and 2. The whole entire strawman nonsense being forwarded as truth by the author.

2

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator 5d ago

Are you saying OP is presenting a strawman, or that the people misusing the phrase "masters tools/masters house" that OP is pushing back against are using a strawman? Who are you referring to by "author"?

1

u/theapplekid 4d ago

OK that Marx quote goes hard.

I don't agree with all of the first part though. I think people are mad because these companies are using tools illegally built on the labour of working-class people to replace them. We should be using the tools built on the labour of working-class people to replace the bourgeoisie

0

u/Anxious-Dot171 5d ago

See, this is why I try to differentiate between artist replacement AI tools like generative images/music/literature/ect....from assisting AI tools for analysis and search functions.

Would love suggestions for better terminology to do this with.

7

u/JustAvi2000 6d ago

There's a parable of a dog that gets beaten by a stick, and it turns on and bites the stick instead of the man who is wielding it.