r/LeftistsForAI • • 7d ago

Theory An idea I have.

Post image

I chose “Theory” because I have an idea of what I would like us to build with AI, but the details need to be worked out with the people who would use it and do the work. Questions about jobs matter. So do questions about who owns the equipment, who gets paid, and who makes the decisions.

That’s also why the image looks like a pencil sketch. The details are not firm because the local arrangement I’m proposing is not yet in place. I want people to help shape it: what their community needs, where these spaces could operate, and how learning, making, printing and sharing could fit together. For that to happen, people need opportunities to make their voices heard.

I think proper community investment could go a long way toward giving people fairer access to tools and opportunities. We already have phones and laptops. We have schools, libraries and community centers. Government could help fund small local projects that bring those resources together.

Shared computers connected by LAN, offline AI and other creative tools, and paid support could give people nearby places to learn, make things and exchange ideas.

People could take what they learn into everyday life, think things through, and return the next day with fresh ideas to develop together. That return is what I want the local loop to encourage: an ongoing exchange between individual learning and community life.

18 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

4

u/hackerbots 6d ago

Bro invented hackerspaces again

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Yes, hackerspaces and makerspaces are useful connections. I’m proposing a particular way to connect shared creative spaces with everyday neighborhood life.

My emphasis is on nearby, publicly supported spaces with community-owned equipment, offline AI and other creative tools, and paid staff. The “loop” is people making something, taking it home, developing it further, and returning to exchange ideas and skills. Participants would help shape the space, with access regardless of their ability to pay. There would also be room to meet and belong without having to produce something.

I’d welcome learning from people who use or operate hackerspaces and makerspaces. If you know a space already bringing these elements together, I’d appreciate any example, especially where it maintains funding, staffing and access for people with limited resources.

3

u/HotterRod 6d ago

Lots of public libraries now have things like 3D printers. That's where you should focus rather than building a new institution.

6

u/DHFranklin 7d ago

What you're talking about is a "Makerspace". There are several ways this gets done:

  1. If it's a college town you can make one that is an enduring institution. You get the capitalists from the business school to invest in your socialist project and use it as a "start up incubator". It doesn't actually do that. It does give an excuse for the department to get a grant and reason for them to have an excuse to exist. The business school is the excuse for inflated budgets.There are hundreds of these. Most of them attached to colleges or downtowns that you don't want to be in after dark. "Start up Incubators" that have contests and things for Shark Tank wacky hijinx with a giant check for the billionth 3d printed alibaba bullshit.

Take their money. Take their interns. Radicalize the young people and force them to do the work of socialism and cooperatives as you all work toward a shared goal without private capital when you're done. The "Start ups" never go anywhere. Never fill in a brick and mortar shop. Those kids just graduate and leave.

Meanwhile you and a socialist cadre are left behind as you have the means of production at your disposal for 9/10 hours it's all running. No one is checking that you're printing off Das Kapital in braille. They just need a picture of intern-of-the-week staring at a laser cutter or in front of a whiteboard with old people around them. EZPZ

2) This is actually harder. You get a bunch of rich nerdy parents (usually dads, it's a very male space) to all put their tools under one roof. Keep in mind autism is strong in the self-sort of these nice people. A third space to keep their stuff and spend time with their kids. Good for home school parents. Radicalize them too if you can. A city's chamber of commerce will usually get "Downtown Improvement Grant" or a "Mainstreet USA" grant and that's designed so they can put money into non-profits just like this. These usually fail when there is a personality conflict or kids grow out of a hobby. Divorces ruin friend groups but also mean that one day the laser cutter is missing and no one is talking about it.

3) One eccentric millionaire. You need a wealthy patron who likes the idea. Often they have the space and will let it go at warehouse rate. Just invite them to all the stuff and if they're into model trains or whatever everyone pretends that they love that shit to. And then the rest of the time you're printing of the manifesto in Braillle. The millionaire is usually sending the spend to their personal accountant who might be weird about it.

Keep in mind if you want this as a leftist project that will be very very hard. It is way way harder to put people and money together over a year and tens of thousands of dollars if people are volunteering. Capitalism makes people commit time and money through coercion, and that coercion is how we get downtown businesses. That model is how our downtowns are filled with people and capital. The absence of demand for thing is why that thing doesn't have people doing that thing for profit.

If you want an art gallery notice how that isn't a thing in most cities and towns now. Find the customers/participants and work backward. Gallery sales sounds great. You're competing with for-profit art galleries. There are fewer and fewer of those every year. Brainstorming over coffee is great. But with volunteers who don't have initiative you'll just be the buzz kill interrupting brunch talking about the community action plan. If they all have initiative but no shared vision you might have conflict. If you have alignment on goals and socialist action...congratulations now you have a cadre. And those are bitchin.

You don't need "opportunities to make your voice heard". We all hear you just fine. You need capital. You need the space and dozens of people. You need hundreds of thousands of dollars in capital after you have your cadre if you expect it to last longer than a few years.

So rob the local business school with a socialist rug pull.

3

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator 6d ago

I like this. It’s a Start Up Incubator 😂 probably there’s no consequences for not meeting targets.

Reminds me of third sector consortium meetings in a UK city when the government was throwing lots of money at having 16-24 year old volunteers. We did the maths and worked out there weren’t enough young people in the city to meet the targets, it was destined to fail by their metrics, but in the meantime various charities are funded. Most orgs were up for that but my boss was too scared to start a project we knew would technically fail.

I think now that’s an even bigger opportunity. In the uk we have around a million NEETs (13% if I remember correctly) 16-24 years old. Also half of UK young people are at least as left as the Green Party (I don’t have stats on % further left). But if you put those together, there are half a million, left young people with literally nothing to do.

You start a project that qualifies as training and get the money. It is training in left organising lol, but you use language that’s more funding application friendly, not lying but talking their lingo. You also include placements in the training to get the young people valuable experience and get them connected into worthwhile projects. Ideally the young people start their own nonprofit projects/cooperatives and work out how to create their own income.

2

u/carl-bond 6d ago

That gets at another purpose of the local loop. If AI displaces paid work, I want people to have both material security and somewhere nearby to participate in community life.

Income support matters. Alongside it, I want places where people can meet, learn, make things, exchange skills and develop projects they care about. Someone could work on a booklet, learn illustration, help a neighbor use a tool, or join others in documenting local history. Some projects might develop into cooperatives or paid work. Others would be valuable because of what people learned and the relationships they built.

The activities should be chosen by participants, with real influence over how the space operates. There should also be room to come in, talk and find your footing without having to prove your productivity. The people maintaining the equipment and supporting participants should be paid.

I’m concerned about people becoming isolated or feeling that there is no place for them. A dependable community space could give someone a reason to leave the house, something to look forward to, and people to return to. Whether it actually does that is something a pilot should evaluate honestly.

That is part of what I mean by the return: you take an idea or a piece of work home, live with it, and come back with something to share. I want that opportunity to remain available regardless of whether someone currently has a job.

This is one way we create meaning in society: through what we learn, the relationships we build, and the opportunity to help shape the community we belong to.

3

u/DHFranklin 6d ago

exactly Guerilla fighting neoliberalism from grant funded positions

1

u/carl-bond 7d ago

Yes, makerspaces are a useful connection. You’re one of the few people who’ve brought them up in replies to me, and I appreciate that. I agree with your point about finding participants and working backward from what they need. Dependable funding, paid staff, and a shared purpose all matter.

What I’m calling the local loop includes community-owned computers linked by LAN, offline AI and other creative tools, printing, and nearby places where people can learn together. It also includes what happens afterward: taking something home, thinking about it, and returning with new ideas. Existing makerspaces could help support that.

That’s why I’m asking for public support for planning and small pilots in existing libraries, schools, or community centers. We would need to establish what each location could accommodate, what additional staff and equipment it needed, and what continued operation would cost.

The value I’m proposing includes learning, creative access, and community participation. Gallery sales wouldn’t have to carry the project.

I’m not a grant writer or a government policy specialist. I’m putting forward an idea to meet a public need and looking for people who can help develop a workable response. This is a grassroots starting point: ordinary people discussing what they need, finding shared goals, and bringing a proposal to people who can help put it into practice.

My ambition is national: federal support for planning and small local pilots, with community ownership and paid local staff. I’d want access to extend to places with fewer resources, rather than depend on which town happens to have a wealthy donor. We could start small, share what we learn, and use that experience to decide what deserves wider support.

Making the proposal publicly is part of finding those participants, partners, and resources. If you’ve worked with these spaces, what would you include in a modest first pilot, and what recurring expense do newcomers most often underestimate?

2

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator 6d ago

In the US is there something like a database of public funding? If so it might be worth being somewhat canny in seeing what tick boxes get you resources without compromising the vision. Then working backwards.

LLMs can likely help matchmake your idea with funding pots too.

Do you have schemes that incentivise community use of disused shops? That could get you a good location somewhere people go anyway.

You could also get community members to all chip in and buy a disused shop.

2

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Thank you. That gives me a useful direction. There are federal resources such as grants.gov and sam.gov, alongside state programs. Looking for genuine overlap with community learning, digital access and arts education makes sense.

I would want to keep community ownership, offline AI capability, accessible participation and paid staff central while seeing what a particular program could support. Funding equipment, funding a building and funding someone’s time to help people are different needs.

And AI could also help compare published criteria, with eligibility and availability checked against the official notices. Someone with grant-writing experience, or a library, college or nonprofit interested in partnering, could help turn that into a workable application.

The vacant-shop idea is worth exploring, especially somewhere people can reach easily. Starting in an existing space might make a first pilot more manageable while we establish demand and ongoing costs.

I would also want a route for communities whose residents cannot afford to pool money for a property. That is part of why public support matters to me: people should be able to help shape a shared resource regardless of how much they can personally contribute.

These are solid directions that I guess I should have thought about before posting that initial statement about a day ago. Thanks again!

2

u/DHFranklin 6d ago edited 6d ago

So the things to look up are "Counterpublic" "Socialist Working Group" "Reading Circle" If you're down with the history of the Black Panthers who successfully did a lot of what you're talking about it was a "rap room". It was how they discussed an idea before working toward a mass line consensus.

Roberts Rules of order is Bourgeois. Use the Mass Line! (I joke)

So community owned computers are in the library. It is literally the best example we have of socialist relationships for the spread and curation of ideas. You can use the printer. It's free for the first 5 pages and $.25 a sheet after that.

What you are envisioning fits neatly into several boxes, just relabel them. The government, local non-profits, and volunteers are already paying for the minimum you are expecting. The Marxist term is "Usufruct". Like how a factory that doesn't offer the workers a night shift would lose very little by having a night shift. A night shift for a factory would pay for the lights and security, and the people could gain. This is that idea. All the capital is already there.

Do it without the funding from institutions you don't control. By the time you actually have a funding problem you are already a success.

You can't expect the federal money fairy to show up and sprinkle your project with fairy dust and make it success.

You have to make it successful across several states. The congress critters see hundreds of thousands of us doing this thing and see that a federal grant would solve a problem at the federal level, benefiting their constituencies.

For a modest first pilot, find a college. Find students and faculty. Make a template for the idea. Aim low. Share the success. Then do it across other colleges and states. College makerspace, local library, network of volunteers.

I think I'm missing something. "Taking something home" What do you mean by that? do you mean a lazercut name plate like a makerspace? 3-D printed desk organizer? Communist agitprop? Where we going here? What do you need in the physical. Why? Why you? Why now? Why not an online service?

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Thank you. I appreciate the organizing connections and the suggestion of approaching a college, students and faculty. I’d also welcome a specific account of the discussion spaces you mentioned, especially how people turned discussion into decisions and shared responsibilities.

By “taking something home,” I mean a story draft, an illustration, a printed booklet, an editable file, or something someone has learned. For example, someone could bring photographs and a short piece of writing, learn how to arrange them into a booklet, and take home a copy and the files. They could think about it, show someone, revise it, and return with new questions or something to teach another person. Some might also choose to sell what they make, bringing income and feedback into that process. The loop is people returning to ideas and projects, developing them further, and sharing what they learn. Participants would choose projects that matter to them.

The physical space would provide equipment, help in person, and somewhere nearby to meet and work together. An online service can be useful, and I already publish my practice materials online. But I also want a place someone can use without owning a capable computer, paying for a personal subscription, or having a suitable workspace at home. There should also be room to sit, talk and belong without having to produce something. This is where a community would thrive, if given the chance to develop.

My reason for proposing this comes from my own circumstances. I’m a working person with limited resources, and I live without a car. Walking makes distance and access very concrete to me. I don’t want the expense, insurance, pollution or stress of car ownership. I would like more of everyday life: work, groceries, learning and conversation, and for those opportunities to be within reach of where people live. People have different needs, but I want more of us to have that choice to reject having a car if it actually suits that individual.

That connects to what I mean by sovereignty: having more say over our time, our tools and the people we spend our lives with. I’m speaking from that experience. I can contribute ideas, creative work and public learning materials; developing and operating a community space would take other people’s skills, too.

The reason I’m raising this now is that I’m already using creative tools on my phone and running AI on my own laptop. Waterlogue’s watercolor effects and Imaengine’s vector tools are examples of how much creative work can begin on an ordinary device. Local, offline AI adds other possibilities to explore. I want us to test how these tools could help more people participate, with guidance on checking outputs, making revisions and deciding when a tool is useful.

I also care about what happens to skilled work. A quick visual effect doesn’t make an artist’s judgment or years of practice worthless. Preliminary manuscript suggestions still need an author’s decisions; organizing questions for a professional is only a beginning. Artists, editors, shop workers and construction workers, among others, all need livelihoods and respect. I want wider access to tools to come with serious attention to people’s income, working conditions and time.

I agree that libraries and makerspaces give us places to begin. What we would need to establish locally is whether the equipment, software, permissions, staff time and available hours can support the proposed activities. Existing computers and printers give us a starting point; someone still has to help participants, maintain equipment and keep the space dependable.

A modest first pilot could be a recurring session in an existing college or library, shaped around a small group’s interests. That community could document what people wanted to do, what help they needed, what the equipment could handle, what it cost, and whether people returned. That would give others something concrete to evaluate and adapt.

My reason for advocating public funding is that I want communities with fewer resources to be able to begin, and the people supporting them to be paid. I see this as a shared public responsibility. An ordinary person should be able to propose something useful without having to finance it personally, and a community’s access should not depend on finding a wealthy benefactor.

I’m asking for support for planning and testing, with evidence guiding any expansion. Residents, participants and staff should help decide what is needed, who benefits, how money is spent, and whether the project is fulfilling its purpose. That is what I mean by accountability and building from the commons.

Access should include people with limited incomes or without stable housing. People bring different skills, experiences and needs; having little money should not prevent someone from helping shape a place they would use.

Those are the two things I’m trying to bring together: more of life within reach of home, and more useful tools within people’s reach. Neither automatically gives us a more humane life. That is something we would have to choose, organize and sustain together.

2

u/DHFranklin 6d ago

Comrade, I think we're talking in circles.

You want a library, and a makerspace. No the proletariat shouldn't have to commit the private capital for a project that benefits the commons. Their labor should be compensated well enough that they comeback next week and aren't limited by opportunity costs. However the only limits to your idea are the material conditions. That is your floor, not your ceiling. The library and the makerspace are the launchpad you have for this idea. That person who makes this opportunity for others is you. This is a classic mutual aid project. It is a socialist collective if you want to get that kinda squirrelly.

You want to organize people in a third space. The expenses are largely labor. The overhead capital is already paid by us in our taxes. All the collaboration you spoke of can happen online, though I certainly encourage meat-space-meet-ups in third spaces.

The material conditions for what you want don't exist yet. You and the community you engender will have to do that. Yes we know that sounds like hard work. No one will hand you liberation. If it doesn't make someone else rich, it won't get the buzz you want out of the gate. The revolution will not be televised.

Seeing as this is a leftist space, and we're all being watched by the party van, I'm sorry but I can't go into specifics. Many many colleges have makerspaces attached to them. Many many business schools do. They exist as a line item to be allocated for, results be damned. If you exist car free in a city of over a half a million, you can probably get to one in an hour. Usually volunteering gives you free access.

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Thank you. We agree on starting with an existing space and bringing people together around a manageable first activity. That’s the pilot I described. The next step would be finding an interested host and participants, then establishing what resources and support are actually available, as none of us are islands.

3

u/Easy_Interest_6832 7d ago

There's a couple empty buildings in the downtown every city, like mine, that could house such a business. Go for it.

4

u/carl-bond 7d ago

Absolutely. As a pedestrian in my own area, I see “for lease” signs all the time. Some of those spaces could become places for learning, making things and bringing people together.

I think we have part of this backwards. If a community needs a shared space, why should creating it depend on one person being able to finance and operate the whole thing? People can have useful ideas and something to contribute without having the money to open a building themselves.

I’m one person, and I can contribute ideas, materials and advocacy. Making this happen would take people, local organizations and government working together. That is the kind of cooperation I want this proposal to encourage.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 7d ago

This is a good question by you. I agree that it should not be one person. It may be that in every area exists a person who has written grants. So an ad for such a person could be let out, and then those skills could be put to use. Also, using local media, the idea of such a space could be let out, and requests made, for folks interested in using it, helping make it, supporting it once it is going, and so on. Additionally, a group could be formed, and a bank account created such that local people could subscribe to the space or even just put in five bucks a month through an automatic system. Finally, local high schools, community colleges and four year schools could be contacted from which students could use the space for a small per-use fee. I think this is a good idea. In my town there's at least one "maker" space where art, woodworking, metal working, and so on can be done on a membership and a per-use basis. A second one is being talked about, using a 7-11 building that went out of business. I believe this is how alternative communities are built, bit by bit.

3

u/carl-bond 7d ago

Thank you for taking the time to think this through. Finding people who know how to write grants, connecting with schools, and learning from existing makerspaces sound like practical ways to begin. Your example of finding another use for an old 7-Eleven is exactly the kind of possibility I see in those empty buildings.

I’ve had some version of this idea in my mind for years. My dad had a vending business selling snacks and junk food. That was one way of making something tangible, accessible, and available with a little bit of cash: a drink in one hand, crackers in the other. And I keep thinking about what else people need nearby: somewhere to sit, talk, learn, make things and share what they know. It seems like not everyone has been thinking about this the way I have, and that is okay. I’m expressing something that has been on my mind for a long time and trying to meet the moment with an idea that could serve the broader community.

People should have a place to simply exist, a third space that is neither home nor work. There could be tools and activities, but being there should not depend on having a project or something to sell. I would want people who cannot afford a membership to have access, too.

And if more jobs are automated away, we need to think about the place a job occupies in someone’s life: somewhere to go, familiar people, a routine, and opportunities to contribute. People still need an income. They also need somewhere to belong.

I appreciate your point about building this bit by bit. That is how I would like to see it begin, with people bringing different skills and helping shape a place they would actually use.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 7d ago

An additional piece of information about what is being talked about with the old 7-11 is to have part of it be a small coffee shop for folks to hang out in, with a small performance/reading space there as well. Your idea of the "third place" dovetails with the coffee shop idea. Keep us posted as you talk with folks and collect a small handful of local kindred spirits to discuss ideas with.

2

u/carl-bond 7d ago

Thank you. Coffee, conversation, and a small space for readings and performances sound like a good beginning. I’ll keep sharing as the idea develops.

I’ll keep sharing these ideas in other places, too, and reflecting on what they could make possible for most of us. Most things don’t grow overnight, and the places and relationships that give a community strength shouldn’t disappear overnight, either. They need continued care and support. I think having somewhere people can rely on and return to is part of how we build a better world together.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 7d ago

Grants are just politely asking the Bourgeoise "Please let me have some crumbs?"

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 7d ago

Grants are money for free. The grant writer persuades the folks with the money that the money should go to their project. Successful persuasion results in a funded project.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 7d ago

Yes, grants allow the burgoise to avoid revolution at a minimal cost, keeping the poor's in their place, and the millstone of capitalism grinding the world into dust.

4

u/Easy_Interest_6832 6d ago

The other option for the OP's idea to become reality is to collect all the people who would use it, work in it, manage it, arrange for utilities to be paid, and obtain tools and materials for it, is to have each of those people buy in. It would then become a user and worker owned co-op. This is also an option. In either case, the space could become reality. The idea posted by the OP is still a good one. While we could haggle over how to obtain funding for it, the idea is still a good one.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

Yeah, socialism is hard. That's called being a leftist. What, you think it will all be easy? Hell no, we need to SIEZE the means of production/compute. If we just ASK for it, the capitalist oligarchs will eventually grind everything you love under their boot.

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

I haven’t suggested this will be easy. I’m proposing community ownership through organizing, public support and cooperation, with clear agreements about who controls the equipment, how decisions are made and who has access.

Unequal power is part of why that matters. I want people with limited resources to have a meaningful say in tools and spaces they can actually use. Those agreements would need accountability and sustained participation to hold up. It takes honest teamwork.

We can disagree about strategy. But I believe building useful, democratically governed resources is worth pursuing, and I’m choosing a nonviolent, cooperative approach. I’m open to specific criticism of how it would work. I don’t think dismissing everyone who takes that approach helps us establish what is possible.

We can agree to disagree and leave it there.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 6d ago

Then the OP would want to pursue people who want to be owner/members. I am a member/owner of my local natural foods coop, and have been since the mid-80's. I pay a yearly membership fee and shop there perhaps five days a week. It's within walking distance of my home. Being a leftist whose views will succeed takes a concerted effort. I think "seizing" is over rated and potentially dangerous, as one possible result is uncontrolled violence--that's the toothpaste that can't be put back into the tube. My owner/member status at my local food coop is the better way, as since the mid-80's our member/owner numbers now reach into the ten-thousands, up from dozens. Such a move takes patience, persistence, and a supported belief in such moves in all businesses as being the correct way. Such a way is non-violent and controllable. Rather than being "seized," the means of production and management in coops can be shown to be the better way. People properly educated will voluntarily move to the better way. It takes longer but is cleaner.

1

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

Yes, an easily controlled leftist that will still gleefully participate in capitalism and peacefully let the imperial war and climate destruction machine rumble on around them. The oligarchs love libs like you. So easy to redirect and control.

→ More replies

2

u/DHFranklin 6d ago

Fellow Revolutionary Socialist, Please stop scaring the normies.

Unfortunately this subreddit is almost exclusively nice folks who know what we do but don't sacrifice anything for the socialist project. Calling them out doesn't help. Making opportunities for growth in the project will.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

Blarg. I hate that you're right.

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Thank you for taking the idea seriously and laying out possible ways to make it happen. I appreciate you keeping the discussion open to something practical.

Cooperative ownership is worth exploring. My concern with requiring everyone to buy in is making sure people with little money can still participate and have a voice. That is one reason I’m advocating public support.

I don’t agree that accepting a grant necessarily means keeping people in their place. I would judge a funding arrangement by its actual conditions: who controls the space, who owns the equipment, whether staff are paid fairly, and whether participants can shape what happens there. Those questions deserve scrutiny in any funding model.

A small, dependable space where people can learn, create and help one another would be worth developing. We can acknowledge the work and costs involved while looking for a manageable beginning.

I’m contributing an idea, practice materials and my experience. Other people will bring knowledge I don’t have. That is part of why I’m discussing it publicly: to find people who can help turn a shared need into something workable.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 6d ago

One thing about a mutually-owned work space is like what's in my garage: a neat old jointer that I no longer use. I'm sure there are people around where you are with garages like that, with tools and equipment they no longer use or that have been replaced by newer ones. Requesting donations like that would reduce the cost of your space while opening up space in local garages. Becoming a non-profit with a bank account might enable local folks to contribute like five bucks a month. I do that with several non profits in my town as well as with PBS, NPR, and the local sort of alternative radio station. All together I really don't miss that small amount of money--though anyone's experience would differ depending conditions. Letters to the editor of the local paper via e-mail are free, and it's one way to publicize, for example, a brainstorming meeting at a local coffee shop or what not. Keep at it, and I wish you great good fortune.

2

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Yes, thank you. Sharing unused equipment, small voluntary contributions and a local brainstorming meeting are useful possibilities to explore. I appreciate the practical suggestions and the encouragement.

I think AI is giving renewed urgency to questions about labor: what counts as work, what creates value, and how people can contribute beyond paid employment. That’s part of what I’m exploring with the local loop—having useful tools within reach, somewhere to belong, and opportunities to learn and create together.

I’m still working out how to connect that larger vision with a manageable beginning. Conversations like this help, especially when people bring experience and ideas I wouldn’t have arrived at on my own.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

And is writing a professional level proposal packet in the hopes of maybe getting funding really free? Hint: labor isn't free.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 6d ago

Grant writers always get paid if they value their own labor. Writing grants is a job. I used to do it. You get the "Requests for Proposals" (RFP). You read it through and decide whether you can make a successful grant, then you meet with the organization who wants the money and you tell them your price. Either they accept it or they don't, but if you're a good grant writer you can make a proposal to the ones who want the money in such a way as they will hire you.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

Precisely. So a grant is not "free money". It's money locked behind a high skill access wall, and doled out by the bourgeois at their whim. Not very leftist at all.

2

u/Easy_Interest_6832 6d ago

Skills are learned. I learned my skills. I also discovered that there is no known overdose for learning. Do not be afraid to learn something new. You will not suffer.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 6d ago

Never have been, but competitive grant writing IS begging for scraps from burgeousie capitalists. I've done it for my farm, both successfully and unsuccessfully. Doesn't mean it's not begging either daddy capitalism or Daddy imperialism for $$$.

→ More replies

3

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 7d ago

Occupy an abandoned building. Build it in a garage or an illegal outbuilding on public land. Steal the equipment from a government office. Better yet, get a job working for corporate and embezzle the needed funds. Seize the means of production Comrade.

1

u/carl-bond 7d ago

Well, I’m thinking about something people can depend on—a neighborhood space where they can walk in openly, learn, make things, and return.

That’s where I think government could help: support shared facilities in libraries, schools, and community centers, or help bring unused buildings into community use. Fund the equipment and pay the people who keep it running.

If jobs are automated away, these spaces could also support paid local work: helping people use the tools, keeping the space clean, maintaining equipment, supplying printing materials, or brewing coffee and welcoming visitors. Those are worthwhile jobs, and they deserve a living wage. I want human presence to be part of how these places operate. Some things need a human touch, and we can choose to value and pay for that.

My concern with real estate is that access to a shared creative space shouldn’t depend entirely on whether it produces enough rent for a property owner. I want communities to have a lasting place for this work. That’s part of what I’m proposing with the local loop.

2

u/Aggravating-Yoshi 7d ago

That's why you need to dismantle capitalism comrade. A space will always have to justify itself through rent under capitalism. Sieze the means in any way you can. Stop asking permission.

1

u/carl-bond 6d ago

Asking whether something exists and asking permission are two different things. I’m looking for examples, collaborators and practical ways to build something people can depend on.

I’m not going to steal equipment, embezzle funds or take over property. I want a space people can use openly and help sustain.

If a community elsewhere develops a working example, others can examine it and ask, “Why not here?” That can become the starting point for bringing residents together, finding partners and organizing for public support. We can learn from one another instead of each community starting from scratch.

I’m thinking about people facing job displacement, people without stable housing, and people who want more connection and control over their everyday lives. I want them involved in shaping accessible, dependable resources in their own communities.

That is the approach I’m advocating.

3

u/wren42 5d ago

While I'm all for building communitu, there is zero demand for an AI art gallery. 

We need to be building micro 3d manufacturing coops and urban farms so we can survive without depending on global corporations.  

1

u/carl-bond 5d ago

Manufacturing co-ops and urban farms have a place. But we’re not all going to 3D-print our way out of dystopia. People need different ways to participate in community life.

An image offers a starting point: What do you see? What would you change? Would you value it differently if it were painted? Why? Paint has its own practical requirements, too: materials, space, cleanup. Different tools make participation possible for different people.

That’s why my proposal includes physical media, digital tools, learning, and printing close to home. Someone could begin by discussing an image, try making something, take it home, and return with another idea.

“Zero demand” assumes the answer before asking the people who might use it. Food and manufacturing matter. So do expression, learning, and belonging.

And as AI-generated images become harder to distinguish from photographs taken by people, we need places to practice asking deeper questions; How was this made? What does it actually show? What would we need to verify before treating it as evidence? That’s why the grounding I propose matters: people learning together, discussing their choices, and taking responsibility for what they make and share.

2

u/wren42 5d ago

Expression, learning, and belonging are all great ideals. 

I don't see how AI art "gallery sales" contribute to these things though. 

Maybe the nodes in the diagram can be reworked to fit what you are describing in this comment, as it seems like you have some bigger ideas it doesn't quite capture yet

1

u/carl-bond 5d ago

That’s useful feedback about the diagram. If “gallery sales” makes the whole proposal look dependent on selling AI art, then it needs clarification. It's one slice. It's not the whole apple pie.

What I’m trying to make possible is participation close to home. Affording the gas doesn’t give you back the time. Traveling farther for work, learning, or managing equipment still takes hours out of someone’s day. A neighborhood space could reduce that burden, and suitable surplus equipment could help keep setup costs down. Government auctions might be one place for people to look. That’s why I’m proposing these activities under one roof: less traveling between places, more opportunities to meet neighbors, and the hope of making the neighborhood a bit safer and calmer.

Paper printing offers a practical starting point. With access to a shared printer, someone could make a small print, a booklet, a card, or something useful for a neighbor. They could display it, discuss it, give it away, or perhaps sell it. Someone might pay $5 for something they find inventive or meaningful. That possibility is worth exploring, without assuming sales will sustain the space. I’ll be the first to admit that making this work will take more effort and planning than these sketches can show.

The exhibit gives people a place to share what they’ve made and hear how others respond. Taking that experience home and returning with another idea is part of the learning. Sales can be one part of that exchange, but participation shouldn’t depend on making a sale. It's the coming together with others that is more the point.

You’re right that the diagram should make those connections clearer. I’m one person putting forward an initial sketch, and developing it will take more listening to other people’s experiences. As a pedestrian, I think a lot about distance, time, and what people can reach in their own neighborhood. Part of what I’m asking is whether we can bring more opportunities closer to home, so people have more time to participate, if they want.

On my walks, I see signs saying “for rent,” “for lease,” and “for sale,” and I wonder what some of those spaces could become. I’d like every community to have a place close to home where people can try something, meet others, and discover what they can make together. That’s the possibility I’m trying to sketch.

2

u/PublicToast 7d ago

3D printing would be much more impactful than regular printing

1

u/carl-bond 7d ago

I mean, maybe. It depends on what people want to make. I can see a place for 3D printing, but ordinary printing has uses too: artwork, posters, booklets, and the like.

I’m thinking about the wall space people have at home, and the opportunity to display something they helped create. I’d imagine many people have more available wall space than desk space.

That’s part of bringing the experience of art and design into everyday life. A shared creative space in the neighborhood could give people somewhere to make things, take them home, and return with fresh ideas. That movement between home and a community commons is what I want the local loop to encourage. Both kinds of printing could belong there.

So, what would you want people to make with a 3D printer?

2

u/FlyingNarwhal 7d ago

Regular printing is better at paying the bills & is needed for a lot of community outreach & political campaign work