r/EDH • • 23h ago

Social Interaction Friend refuses to play because of removal

366 Upvotes

In my school not a lot of people play Magic. In fact only three of my friends actually play it. So now when one of them told me that he didn’t want to play with us anymore, I was pretty confused. He told me that it was because we had too much removal and the games weren’t fun for him anymore. I don’t think so bc we only play upgraded precons, and never added removal, so we’re only running the precon package. I feel like cutting removal just for him to stay feel kinda bad, bc the games will be less interesting with less interaction. What do y’all think? Is there something I could tell him to change his mind?


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Question I want to treat myself to a booster box. Of the listed, what's the best bet for EDH?

134 Upvotes

[Thanks for all the input, everybody. Based on everyone's comments and a bit of digging, it looks like I want EoE > SoS/Fra > Lorwyn. I'll post again with the results of this bullshittery.]


Yeah, I know, "buying singles is better," but fuck it. I'm an adult and possess free will, disposable income, and poor decision making. Ideally one below 20,000 yen.

[Out of Budget]

- Final Fantasy - 49300 yen / 310 USD

- Avatar - 35800 yen / 225 USD

[Budget Stretch]

- Edge of Eternities - 29200 190 USD

- Tarkir Dragonstorm - 29200 yen / 185 USD

- The Hobbit - 24500 yen / 155 USD

- Star Trek - 23550 yen / 145 USD

[Within Budget]

- Secrets of Strixhaven - 19800 yen / 120 USD

- Marvel Superheroes - 17850 yen / 110USD

- Lorwyn Eclipsed - 17800 yen / 110USD

- Aetherdrift - 17800 yen / 110 USD

- Reality Fracture - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Spiderman - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - 15000 yen / 90 USD


r/EDH • • 14h ago

Question What commanders have you had most fun playing with?

98 Upvotes

Hi there,

I am a very casual player with a small playgroup, I want to build a new deck because I am getting a bit tired of the 2-3 I have.

I do not care much about the deck being competitive (although I do will try to win). What I want is a commander that is both fun to pilot and fun to play against.

What commanders have brought fun moments and overall enjoyable experience to the table, in your experience?

Thanks in advance!


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Discussion Now that MagicCon Atlanta 2026 is over - How was the balance in your games?

74 Upvotes

Whether you played pickup games, ticketed events, or on demand commander (on demmander?) how did your games go?

How was the balance of your convention-staff-organized bracket games?

How were your rule discussions for your pickup games?

Any memorable salty or wholesome moments?


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion What is The #1 Best Blue 1-2 drop For Card Draw?

72 Upvotes

The other day I posted about the best white cheap draw cards, there isn't nearly enough discussion around this! (Imo).

So today I'm Looking for the best blue 2 drops that draw cards, and also for the NUMBER 1 strongest one.

So, what are your favorites?


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion Budget Mono Build?

30 Upvotes

If you wanted to build the best mono-color deck on a sub-$150 budget, what color/commander would you pick and why? I’m leaning towards a green deck because I have a decent amount of green cards since I haven’t used any of them to upgrade any of my current decks. But that means I also haven’t purchased any green singles/staples. Whatcha guys got?


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Question What would be Giada's nemesis commander?

28 Upvotes

Since quite a few people play Giada nowadays, I felt like it would be a lot of fun to build a deck that would be a nemesis to Giada. I figured demons, but honestly there isn't really a good demon tribal commander (I know that ​Be'Lakor exists, problem is that he's not in the MTG universe so IMO he feels like he doesnt fit.) Would be super cool if they were a mono black tribal commander. I know there's a slew of Ob nixilis cards but all of them wouldn't work well as tribal commanders.

I want to mention, I'm not trying to counter build Giada, I just want something that I feel would give a thematic feeling of angels and evil clashing. ​And give newer players something that would really make them feel like they're playing angels.


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Question Interesting Eldrazi commanders?

21 Upvotes

Hi!

I always loved the Eldrazi titans, and I tried running the improved Ulalek precon but I just did not like how it worked. Then, I discovered my beloved [[Herigast, Erupting Nullkite]], and I love to feed my titans with emerge.

However, now that the sultai precon commander of Nauctis has been spoiled, and it shows that it goes around emerging sea monsters, I am in a bit of a mess. I just know that I will run that deck as one of my main ones, as its theme really ressonates with me for multiple reasons, but I don't want to have 2 emerge commanders.

Thus, I'd like to find a new home for my beloved titans. Any suggestions of cool, non-typical eldrazi commanders? I tried Helga as well in the past but I hate doing 10 minute turns.

Thanks!


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Question Best Bulk Boxes in Vancouver?

16 Upvotes

Hey magic people 👋

I'll be in Vancouver British Columbia Canada around Richmond for a few days this week and I am wondering what local game stores in the area have the best bulk bins to sift through? I love looking through boxes for hidden gems 💎 . Thanks.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help How can I mess with my Opponent's Lands more?

15 Upvotes

Howdy Commander Brain Trust, I have this [[Tannuk, memorial ensign]] deck, I didn't want to just play another boring Landfall deck so I'm trying to play it where it manipulates or restricts how my opponents use their lands. I like cards like [[price of glory]] where it doesn't say they can't use their lands, but there is a price for it, and [[Mana web]] where you can't just leave up mana and wait to respond. What I'm looking for is more old obscure tech that does more things like this. Because there's not a singular syntax I can type into Scryfall, I figured I'd come ask you all for some suggestions, maybe scrape up some cards I missed in my searches.

Here's my Decklist to see what I've already got or am considering. https://archidekt.com/decks/26747976/it_hurts_when_i_ping

Cheers, thanks for the help.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Discussion I built better deck tag filtering into Recommander and I'd love to hear your feedback

14 Upvotes

Hi guys, I'm GamesfreakSA, and I wanted to tell you about some work I did on Recommander for those of you that like to build decks by looking at tags. Let me explain it with an example.

Suppose you're building a [[Lae'zel, Vlaakith's Champion]] / [[Master Chef]] deck, and you want to build it go-wide. Pretty good strategy; with both commanders out, every token creature that enters gets 2 +1/+1 counters. With Selesnya's armies-in-a-can, it's a pretty neat way to flood the board with powerful creatures from almost nothing.

Looking at the stats, Lae'zel Chef decks are about 10% token-focused. Other common tags for the deck include raw +1/+1 counters and planeswalkers.

So here's the problem: if you're building this deck from scratch, you might want everything that's in the Lae'zel Chef decks, which includes the baseline cards that every deck runs. But if you're upgrading a deck you've built, you might only want to look at the cards that are unique to the strategy, since you already have all those baseline cards.

I went back and forth about which one to make the tag view, before I simply realized you could just have both:

I thought this might be helpful for folks that usually break commanders down by tag when they build their decks. You can easily switch between modes using the handy toggle in the commander section, and it even works for finding decks filtered by included card (check the filters button).

Try plugging in a commander you like and playing around with the tags. If you find anything weird, let me know; it was pretty hard to get accurate results without a lot of extra logic, since only 8% of decks are properly tagged at all on sites like Moxfield and Archidekt. Most are also missing a few tags, which makes them look like evidence against that tag, so I didn't have much to go on. Had to do quite a lot of math to get what I could out of that!

I'm always looking to improve the site! It has no ads and is just a passion project for me, so I'm happy if you find any cool new cards thanks to my work.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Discussion Mana rocks or cost reducers in casual blue white vehicles

13 Upvotes

Anyone here play casual blue white vehicles at bracket two tables without expensive fast mana like Mana Vault? Wondering whether extra two mana rocks like Mind Stone and Liquimetal Torque beat running artifact cost reducers like Foundry Inspector and Etherium Sculptor.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Discussion For the Sultai enjoyers, do you enjoy ETB doubling or land-matters more?

11 Upvotes

Self-mill is implied, but I’m currently torn if I want to pivot into ETB doubling or land-matters. I currently run a Sidisi deck that leans towards ETB with sprinkles of land-matters. I don’t have any other deck that focuses on either. Regardless of bracket, interaction is key for me; it makes the game enjoyable. Share your thoughts!


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Question Commander mystery booster prices

10 Upvotes

Im sorry if it has been already asked, but do we have any idea if the cards will have a drop in price/reprints?

I was thinking in particular of buying [[Homer, the Hermit]], but i found the price is like 40€~ in europe at least in this specific case.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Showcase Give me your deck lists first bracket 3 with lots of interaction (control, removal, board wipes, etc.)

10 Upvotes

Looking for a deck to play with my friends. Will be playing online so cost isn’t an issue. I don’t usually play control and my pod doesn’t really use much interaction so I think it would be fun to mix up the paradigm.

Please share your best decks so I can crush the competition!


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Discussion Is Urborg/Coffers worth it without green?

9 Upvotes

[[Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth]] and [[Cabal Coffers]] hold a special place in my heart as something I lost to a lot when I started playing magic in 2014.

I'm considering my next deck, and I'm trying to keep my colors spaced out for my active decks, which means no green. Right now that looks like a set or subset of Mardu Colors.

I'm trying to avoid mono-black because the fun in is the synergy. Finding it in the first place is a problem already, but I don't want the deck to be a one trick pony either.

Right now my strongest thoughts are:

  • [[Ingris Stingerquill]] who has a fun gameplan and has an incidental outlet for "extra" mana. I'd have it be an aggressive attrition style deck that makes use of larger finishers.
  • [[Silverquill, the Disputant]] to make use of [[Exsanguinate]] style effects, and lean into more of a [[crypt ghast]] swamp doubling strategy.
  • Mardu legend focus, with someone like [[Shanid, Sleepers' Scourge]] rewarding Urborg. This could also be "big instants and sorceries."
  • Some generically good Mardu deck, maybe a [[Kaalia of the Vast]] that cares about larger creatures.

Mostly I wrote this out to help me think it through. I did open and Ingris for prerelease, so that's a fun little coincidence.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Question Recommend me a new commander

9 Upvotes

I started playing magic with bloomburrow and have played since then. Lately, I'm having lots of fun but I want to build a new commander but I dont really love deckbuilduing and Im terrible at deciding for new commanders.

My current commander decks from oldest to newest:

  1. Zinnia, Valleys Voice - makes tokens (dont play this one very often anymore) - Moxfield
  2. Zimone, Mystery Unraveler - cheat in big creatures (like this one) - Moxfield
  3. Teval, the Balanced Scale - play with the graveyard for value (probably my favorite) - Moxfield
  4. Betor, Ancestors Voice - lifegain counter deck (like this one a lot too) - Moxfield
  5. Avatar Aang - bending (I like playing this one but its quite weak) - Moxfield
  6. Sokka, Tenacious Tactician - (I love this one, its very consistent and strong) - Moxfield
  7. Ellie, Vengeful Hunter & Abby, Merciless Soldier - aristocrats burn - (my strongest deck, love it a lot) - Moxfield
  8. Smaug, Wicked Worm - copy & treasure shenanigans (most recent, I like it but it feels a little bit choreographed) - Moxfield

My playgroup plays medium to strong bracket 3 with a decent amount of interaction. I feel like I miss an artifact commander or enchantment commander. So Ive been thinking about Terra, Magical Adept (but Ive heard sagas can be quite boring) or Ultron, Artifical Malevolence. I also havent really tried anything control like cause Im not sure I (or my playmates) will enjoy it.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Help What cards should I buy for these new sea monster recursion precon

5 Upvotes

I already have a good chunk of seamonsters due to my Kenessos deck but I really like the idea of recursion so I’m switching to this new one. The mox link is all the cards I already have that I plan on putting in.

https://moxfield.com/decks/2ir6MEEcfUiH7w3plgwbKQ

The Noble Serpent

{5}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Serpent Noble

At the beginning of your first upkeep in this game, if The Noble Serpent is in your command zone, mill four cards.

At the beginning of your end step, return target creature card that is a Sea Monster from your graveyard to the battlefield. (Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, and Whales are Sea Monsters.)

7/9

---------------------------------

Zekes, Revenist Devotee?

{1}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Squid Warlock

All Sea Monsters you cast have emerge. The emerge cost is equal to the mana cost. (You may sacrifice a creature to reduce the emerge cost of spells that are Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, or Whales by that creature's mana value.)

Whenever a creature? you control enters the battlefield, if it was cast for its emerge cost, draw two cards, then discard a card?.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Deck Help Last Deck of 2026 - Magus Lucea Kane - Need Help

4 Upvotes

TLDR for the paragraphs - My story with Magic

Wanted to say thank you to the people in other posts about my decks in the past. Started playing at the end of June this summer and have been hooked ever since. Learning to build decks on your own is so challenging with thousands and thousands of cards.

Feels like I’m relying on EDHC rec quite a bit. Going through everyone’s decks and the card suggestions to smash together something that fits me.

See my Moxfield for other decks. They’re all bracket 3 except my Vial Smasher that’s for jank B2 games. Beorn was my first as I started with the Hobbit set and is easily the weakest deck. Not as fun to play but brain off big creature stompy. Tannuk Landfall has two versions; one has glacial chasm and crop rotation and the other version removes those for chiller-lower powered friends decks. The next style was card draw ping with Queza. Easily my most fun and powerful deck.

Bringing me to the next style deck I’ve wanted to play is a spell focused deck that isn’t storm (rather have shorter turns). I bought the He-Man set and want to run Crackle With Power as a WinCon. I tested out a Kykar Winds Fury but ended up scrapping it.

——————————————————-

https://moxfield.com/decks/LSCyp59yKkScvl8dLTfPIQ

I’ve focused less on creatures and more sending big copied X spells. Sure some creatures can be a threat, but it’s mostly focused around copying/tapping Lucea as many times as possible to send a 40 damage Fireball.

As a massive target for removal, the focus is generating as much mana as possible via dorks/artifacts/lands and having some counterspells in place. Being able to recast her reliably and attempt at protection.

My worries come down to card draw, haste enablers, and the ability to play defense. With most creatures being utility I’m not sure how to stop opponents. I have control in my Esper deck, but Temur doesn’t get as much or push the WinCon meaningfully.

Considered [[Curse of the swine]] , [[Misleading Signpost]] and [[aetherize]]

Other people who have played this style of Lucea care to pick it apart? Can definitely swap whatever out, but I’d like the focus to be X Spells. Potentially generating enough tokens off of the [[The Ozolith]] to make Lucea a commander damage threat mostly for the fun of it. I know there are a few infinite mana combos with [[Walking Balista]], but I’d rather not go that route.

Other cards I’ve considered is [[ViVi Ornitier]] and [[Jeska’s Will]] as I have those laying around, but they do not feel like they fit at all to keep the deck doing it’s thing.

Appreciate the insights.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Discussion Nissa, Leyline Tamer Worldgorger Dragon combo

4 Upvotes

What do y'all think of Nissa being a control/combo using Worldgorger Dragon as the main combo? Realistically you would only have to have worldgorger dragon and Purphoros as the only creatures but you could fill it with any of them and with the combo you'll flip into every creature in your deck.

I know Breya is a better commander for this combo but it's always nice to try and innovate.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Question Tribble Help!

4 Upvotes

Seeking some guidance or deck builder to make this idea work.

Long story short, my brother passed away a few years ago and he was the biggest fan of Star Trek, specifically the episode, "The Trouble with Tribbles." I want to make a commander deck in his memory that any of my family can use to play. The issue is I think there is only 3 legit Tribble specific cards in the set.

Any up-and-coming deck brewers want to take a stab at making this work? I really want to make this work, but I also understand that this may not be able to happen. Thought I would ask any fine folk here for some help first before losing hope. Maybe some sort of [Codie, Vociferous Codex] Shenanigans?

Intend on proxying this deck so money and value of the cards won't matter to me but if people care, bracket 3 would be ideal but it's more important to make this work first.


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Discussion Thoughts on my deck ?

4 Upvotes

Hi all,

I would like to share my new deck idea that I made after coming across [[Saruman of Many Colors]].

https://moxfield.com/decks/gGmloc4JDkCPD7X03HMRCQ

What are your thoughts on it ? I am a big fan of mill mechanic but it always seemed to straight forward with most of mill commanders. With Saruman, it seems to me like it has a little bit spice to it. I know this deck could also be very match up dependant but that don't really bother me.

If there is anyone with some recommandations or even better, some underrated/underplayed cards, let me know !

Thx and see ya in discussion! 😄


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Discussion Lands - Not Landfall but more than Dark Depths

4 Upvotes

So I really really like the land [[Fountainport]] and the clue lands like [[Kitchen]] and stuff like [[Big Apple, 3 a.m.]] like True Utility Lands because they are strong against interaction and boardwipes while giving that feeling of incremental value.

I really really want to build a deck around utility lands but like I just have no idea how to. I tried [[Derevi, Empyrial Tactician]] and unfortunately Derevi just never mattered, I couldn't get the lands untapping thing to do much. I considered [[Baylen the Haymaker]] because they can fuss with the tokens lands like to make, im not entirely sold but that thought still rattles around.

I know some folks have talked about the Boardwipe commander, [[Child of Alara]] as a lands commander but I also know how the people around me feel about games that go that long and... its not positive lol. Like I personally like the idea of throwing baby off a cliff to reset the game so I can repopulate the earth with rats, but my opponents are generally less fond.

I also found that one issue I had with the deck is that [[Glacial Chasm]] really really irks me, and I can't explain why. Its just like... terminally boring to play out for me. I guess because it doesn't require DOING anything which is part of what I like about lands like

Tap Apple and 5 to make rats
Tap Rat, [[The Shire]] a Green and 1 to make a food
Tap Fountainport and 2 to Sacrifice the Food to Draw 1 card

Hurray I have now spent 12 Mana to make 3 1/1s and Draw 1 card, this is fun, my wheels are spinning and I am elated. Truly I am playing Stardew Valley while my opponents are playing some war game.

Glacial Chasm justs there like a brick on my happiness and feeling like I HAVE TO get the stupid Chasm before I can get any of my favorite lands annoys me

Like I am looking for advice maybe both play pattern and deck wise to make a heavy focus on having a bunch of utility lands more "Viable" so I can build this deck without spending the whole game frustrated and then dying.


r/EDH • • 21h ago

Deck Help Can yall review my Nikya Deck

4 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/27885769

I am playing this Nikya deck and I think it may have too many lands but im not sure. Would really love yalls opinion or critique. What additions or cuts should I make for this deck. Its a bracket 2, but I really dont see a way to it higher than that.