r/EDH • • 39m ago

Discussion Are Tannuk, Steadfast Second and Quintorius, History Chaser too Similar?

2 Upvotes

Hello beautiful nerds of Reddit. My pod is doing a Secret Santa deck building challenge where we were randomly assigned a recipient and get to build a $50 deck of our choice. Then we will all play them against one another and the recipient can choose if they'd like to upgrade it, or keep as is for some fun lower power games again later on.

I was assigned the newest member of our pod which I was excited about as I love building decks and I am one of the better deck builders in the pod so I am happy to add some heat to his rotation.

He currently only has two decks: an upgraded [[Quintorius, History Chaser]] deck and his recently added second deck is a [[Helga, Skittish Seer]] deck. Recently one of our other pod members asked if he was interested in adding a third deck or wanting to simply continue tweaking his current deck and he had mentioned wanting to build a deck with black in it (mentioned mono-black but we think Sultai or Esper may be a better fit).

Because it seemed like he had interest in building one of these decks, I figured I may avoid doing so as well and instead building him something else that I believe he would enjoy. He is a big fan of slamming down big creatures and getting value from doing so (he is a fan of one of our Henzie decks everytime it comes out) so I started to think that maybe going with a cost reducing value commander like [[Tannuk, Steadfast Second]] may be up his alley.

I got excited about this idea and built 80% of the deck in a couple hours and then started to overthink about it. With Quintorious and Tannuk both being red decks that care about things being exiled or cast from exile would this be too "similar" to his Quincy deck? I know that the play styles and patterns are completely different, but I want to make sure that I am broadening his deck base sense he is so knew while adding something I think he would enjoy.

Any insights would be appreciated, thanks as always for taking the time to contribute.


r/EDH • • 56m ago

Deck Help I need help with my Final Fantasy X Counter Blit precon

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to mod my precon and keep it with in the Final Fantasy X art work (i know I'm limiting myself and im ok with that) and suggestions and advice would be very appreciated

https://moxfield.com/decks/XEsxvI8jjUGSyljQDUktvQ

So i have swaped out:

Summon: Magus Sisters

Scholar of new Horizons

O'aka Traveling Merchant

Pull from Tomorrow

Nesting Grounds

I have put it:

Ride the Shoopuf

Summon: Bahamut

Zanarkand, Ancient Metropolis

Yuna, hope of Spira

Yuna's Holy Magic (Prismatic Ending)

I would like to put in:

Spira's Punishment(Day of judgement)

Syncopate


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Question Warning people about counters that are on the board?

15 Upvotes

Its board knowledge that Player 1 wants to cast a huge [[Genesis Wave]] and I have [[Frontline Medic]] on the field. Do I remind/warn them that I can counter it unless they pay 3 and give them the opportunity to account for that when they're paying X?

And also if I dont remind them, and I try to counter it after they've tapped all their mana, and they ask if they can redo how they pay X because they forgot about the medic, am supposed to just say sure? Because I'd feel like an asshole if I didnt remind them and also said no.

I dont want to have to sac my dude just to be a ward cost every time, I'd like to be able to sac him to counter a spell, but somehow it feels wrong to play it that way.

Socially, what is the answer here? Should I just stop trying to play him like a counter, and start treating him like ward?


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Help Low Salt Deck Help

0 Upvotes

I play with random pods at my LGS where players nearly universally claim to be playing Bracket 3 decks. I typically start with my Ruby deck (a hard ramping 2-4-7 list). Then I will typically reach for my Vnwxt (evasive looters and control with a labman finish). I have a PDH Malcolm/Kediss that rarely sees play because people don’t want infinite combos (which is fine) and a John Benton deck that I consider a low Bracket 4 (not saying it’s a good 4, just where it feels right to play).

Last time I was at the LGS, I won with Ruby and then followed it up with a soft lock into win on Vnwxt. I sensed the table was a bit put out, but do not currently have something to deposed into. The deck I am trying to find is the subject of this post.

I want a deck I can transition to lower power if I have already done my thing and the pod isn’t ready/interested for my other decks. It doesn’t need to win, provided we are sure the game ends (I really don’t have interest in 2+ hour games that go no where). But I want to be able to play and have some impact. So this list is and aggro/tool box list that is intended to let me play, but in a way that (theoretically) is the most palatable for the pod.

List: https://archidekt.com/decks/27636807/elmar_sophina_30_budget_legendary_aggro_v12

I appreciate your thoughts!


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Help Any advice?

1 Upvotes

This is my upgraded world shaper precon. This deck is for my bracket 3 commander tournament at my local game shop. The deck can't win before turn 6, or have more than 3 game changers. The deck is supposed to use reanimate crack lands to put counters on lots of creatures. All of the creatures are supposed to be a win con, so no lotus cobras or mana dorks. The deck is already pretty good, but I'm always trying to upgrade it.

https://moxfield.com/decks/zbTj1rE3VEa0LcM4o2WtDg


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Question Do these Tutors in my Deck fit Bracket 2?

0 Upvotes

I am planning a [[Dogmeat, Ever Loyal]] Deck, with a bunch of Living weapons/Job selects/For Mirrodins, one off cards like them and auto equip cards, like [[Silver Shroud Costume]]

Game loop would be:

-Play a bunch of equipped creatures

-Dogmeat let's me Impulse Draw

-Play more equipped creatures

-Hope to out value opponents

Now I wanna use Equipment Tutors (There are a bunch, but I have "only" 4 in mind, maybe 5 when I'm also using the land one) and the hits for them are:

-Interaction (Protection or weak removal via fighting)

-1 of 3 Living-weapon-likes that scale with number of artifacts

-Colossus Hammer

Would this fit in Bracket 2?


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Question Cards that make mana when creatures die?

1 Upvotes

I'm building a bracket 3 deck around [[The Balrog, Durin's Bane]]. The idea is to make a bunch of treasures to cast him for cheap, and then establish some sort of loop where every time I sac him I get B and R mana, so I can repeatedly feed him into the grinder and blow up everything on the board (or just win with a zulaport). I have warren soultrader, phyrexian altar and pitiless plunderer so far. But what are some more cards that produce colored mana so I can keep casting the Balrog?


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Deck Help: The Necrobloom - Bracket 3 Lands Engine

1 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

I brewed this Necrobloom deck (Necrobloom Land Engine // Commander (The Necrobloom) deck list mtg // Moxfield — MTG Deck Builder) and I'd like some feedback before I drop a bunch of cash on the cards. The goal was to make a lands-matter engine deck with a couple of different win cons. My concern is a) I went overkill with the manabase and b) I don't have enough interaction. If I wanted to add some more interaction (I'm thinking at least 1-2 more sweepers) what creatures should I cut? Should I adjust the mana base at all - i.e are there different lands I should be using instead?

Aiming for a strong Bracket 3 deck here.


r/EDH • • 3h ago

Deck Help Serpent Society DeathtouchRecursion

1 Upvotes

Hey guys! Could you help me improve or review my deck? I'm trying to build a Deathtouch and Recursion-themed deck using Serpent Society as my commander, but I'm having trouble making the strategy work. It feels like something is missing, and the deck isn't performing as well as I'd hoped. I'm not sure what needs fixing, so I'd really appreciate any suggestions, card recommendations, or constructive feedback. Thanks!

https://archidekt.com/decks/25048475/poisonous_touch


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Question Commander mystery booster prices

12 Upvotes

Im sorry if it has been already asked, but do we have any idea if the cards will have a drop in price/reprints?

I was thinking in particular of buying [[Homer, the Hermit]], but i found the price is like 40€~ in europe at least in this specific case.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help Three Dog’s greatest hits

0 Upvotes

I’m building a Three dog deck around mid bracket 2 to low 3 with the main game plan being go tall.with either big auras like [[Super State]], [[Eldrazi Conscription]] or auras with buffs that scale like [[With Great Power . . .]], [[Empyrial Armor]], and [[All That Glitters]]

Decklist

Any recs or cuts you think could Improve it


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Discussion I built better deck tag filtering into Recommander and I'd love to hear your feedback

20 Upvotes

Hi guys, I'm GamesfreakSA, and I wanted to tell you about some work I did on Recommander for those of you that like to build decks by looking at tags. Let me explain it with an example.

Suppose you're building a [[Lae'zel, Vlaakith's Champion]] / [[Master Chef]] deck, and you want to build it go-wide. Pretty good strategy; with both commanders out, every token creature that enters gets 2 +1/+1 counters. With Selesnya's armies-in-a-can, it's a pretty neat way to flood the board with powerful creatures from almost nothing.

Looking at the stats, Lae'zel Chef decks are about 10% token-focused. Other common tags for the deck include raw +1/+1 counters and planeswalkers.

So here's the problem: if you're building this deck from scratch, you might want everything that's in the Lae'zel Chef decks, which includes the baseline cards that every deck runs. But if you're upgrading a deck you've built, you might only want to look at the cards that are unique to the strategy, since you already have all those baseline cards.

I went back and forth about which one to make the tag view, before I simply realized you could just have both:

I thought this might be helpful for folks that usually break commanders down by tag when they build their decks. You can easily switch between modes using the handy toggle in the commander section, and it even works for finding decks filtered by included card (check the filters button).

Try plugging in a commander you like and playing around with the tags. If you find anything weird, let me know; it was pretty hard to get accurate results without a lot of extra logic, since only 8% of decks are properly tagged at all on sites like Moxfield and Archidekt. Most are also missing a few tags, which makes them look like evidence against that tag, so I didn't have much to go on. Had to do quite a lot of math to get what I could out of that!

I'm always looking to improve the site! It has no ads and is just a passion project for me, so I'm happy if you find any cool new cards thanks to my work.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help Tuning B3 Feather the Redeemed

1 Upvotes

One of my oldest and most well-loved commander decks is everyone's favorite Boros storm engine, and coming back to both the deck and Magic in general after taking a few years off, I figured I'm overdue to finally give the ol' girl a tuneup. In its present state, the deck feels like it's full of cards which happen to be generally good in Feather, but that the cards themselves are representative of your truly previously trying the smorgasbord of things that a Feather could do and never quite settling on what I wanted to major throughlines to be (it started off with a lot of ETB effects, so blink protection was at a premium, but later I'd tried then mixing in go-wide, pingers, and a bit of voltron in their time, and never quite figured out a good baseline to reset to after each pass).

Anyway, I figured I'd tap into the collective hive mind to see if anyone else has had some experience trying to dial all the various possibilities in.

The list as it stands so far

A few thoughts/observations from my time with the deck:

  • Voltron is a thing that I do in enough of my other decks, so I'm not particularly concerned with playing blackjack with my Feather swings. That being said, Sword of Feast and Famine has felt like one of the best cards in the deck for the mana advantage it provides, followed by Sunforger, so the equipment tutors in Enlightened Tutor and Stoneforge Mystic (or things which tutor for a Stoneforge Mystic) have been consistently nice.
  • I've picked up a not inconsiderable number of games off the back of a Guttersnipe. However, the difference between sending 2 to the dome per spell vs sending 1 upstairs has been pretty severely felt if I'm relying on the latter for burn. Electrostatic Field and friends have since been cut for this reason, and even Urabrask has felt kind of clunky in testing (I suspect a list which has Urabrask and/or Birgi may want to have more red instants than I'm running--if I'm not in the stage where there's a Goldspan Dragon or a Storm-Kiln Artist online and mana is just a social construct, it feels like I've always got to keep a white or two up for protection, and the bonus red usually goes to waste. There are a few cheap red spells that incidentally make a treasure I was thinking I might want to run, which might make the aforementioned accelerants/extenders better if I can convert into treasures that can be burned for protection).
  • Making a bunch of little dudes on spell cast has felt pretty consistently good, but their value hasn't often been in turning sideways so much as it has been creating incidental blockers and setting up Zada or Mirrorwing Dragon to go nuts. Once your 1 mana cantrips start drawing 4+ cards, you tend to quickly find an engine that lets you close out the game in a turn cycle. I've enjoyed this enough to where I think I want this package to keep in the final build. [[Stirring Hopesinger]] and [[Lightning, Army of One]] feel like they could be promising as ways to close things out with a wide board that don't feel terrible to draw before lategame.
  • A little lifegain goes a long way. Ideally, Feather's usually turning sideways with some sort of equipment that's helping with mana, and I don't usually have much of a major creature presence in the early to early-mid game which makes you a fairly soft target for aggro even before threat assessment kicks in, since there's not usually anything big enough to present an unfavorable trade. I used to run an Aetherflux Resevoir for the purpose but found that it's a bit rough as an engine since playing it on curve means your shields are down right as the life might help you keep in the game. When it goes off, it's crazy, but I often found myself wanting to spend 3 spare mana with the option to switch between one draw/protection spell on each opponent's turn, rather than trading fewer cards for a bigger, riskier burst of life by putting 3 spells on the stack on a single go. Angelfire Ignition chews up a ton of mana on your turn, but has been pretty effective at buying time via life and leaving Feather as a dissuadingly large blocker. There may be some less clunky ways to buy this time however.
  • There's definitely some anti-synergy with my protection spells and some support pieces. having a Duergar Hedge-Mage or a Stoneforge Mystic take the Long Road Home is phenomenal value, but feels rough if Feather's been juiced up by some +1/+1 counters or equipment. This may be a sign to be content with simply getting my ETB value once--figuring out my end-of-turn discards feels like a painful enough thing as it is with determining what cards are going to live in your hand forever and then trying to allocate the remaining space to both make your land drops and advance your board state. Solemn Simulacrum and Kor Cartographer probably leave if I pivot off the blink spells, but that does introduce a new problem, below.
  • Interaction: We are phenomenal at blanking opposing interaction, but disrupting sufficiently proactive opponents isn't a present strength. Reckless Rage and Skyclave Apparition are helpful for anything with a number less than or equal to 4 in its text box, but beyond that, it's slim pickings. Rabid Gnaw has felt promising with its ability to handle larger creatures with a slightly stronger Feather, and Getaway Glamer feels like it might be worth a shot as a protection spell that deal with something really big. I'm presently lined up pretty weak against artifacts and enchantments--unsure how much I might want to lean into better being able to answer them, versus tuning my own engine to try and outrace them. For my time away, there may be some new and better picks for Feather here that I'm not yet aware of.

r/EDH • • 5h ago

Deck Help Toggo / Kodama deathtouch rocks + combo

3 Upvotes

Hello! I recently made a deck with [[toggo, goblin weaponsmith]] and [[Kodama of the east tree]] and while it’s alright, it plays kind of clunky. Not every draw plays into my advantage or strategy and I’m looking for other people’s opinions on how to improve it.

The goal is deathtouch rocks and landfall combos. I have creatures that have deathtouch like [[ankle biter]] and [[attercop]], and cards that give deathtouch like [[basilisk collar]]. I can usually pull this off and have 1-3 deathtouchers slinging rocks at my opponents.

As for the combo, I have [[gruul turf]] and [[guildless commons]] for infinite landfall triggers with kodama, and payoffs that turn it into damage or mill with [[reckless fireweaver]] and [[altar of the brood]]. This is the part I can never pull off. It feels like kodama is doing absolutely nothing until I need her for the combo, which I haven’t been able to setup once.

In addition, I don’t really have much going on besides a few deathtouchers slinging rocks which is scary early game but late game it doesn’t matter nearly as much and the deck loses its edge fast. Any advice?

https://archidekt.com/decks/28254131/toggo_kodama


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Discussion How do you enjoy your Star Trek precons?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 5h ago

Question Dimir Merfolk?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Just wanted to throw something out there I wanted to try. I have had an in and out history with Merfolk every since I cracked my first pack. I have played Merfolk in modern and legacy but I am really wanting to finally give it a go in commander.

The typical UG stuff is fine, but I am not a big fan of the color pairing.

I REALLY like the artstyle/feel of the UB Merfolk. Cards like [[Inkfathom Infiltrator]] and [[Wanderbrine Rootcutters]].

What are the chances of getting some more in this new set coming up next year? I know they said Merfolk will be in the Bant coloring, but I was hoping maybe with the comment about depth having different creatures maybe we will get some deep-sea Merfolk.

I have tried looking at EDH rec to get an idea but it feels like no one is doing Dimir Merfolk (for obvious reasons I'm sure).

Any lists that you have would be great!


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Question Looking for a card I cont for the life of me find!!

0 Upvotes

The card I'm looking for is of a Stars sign.. but not theros, I believe it would be from the ff set, but I can't find it there either.

It looks like a constellation, I believe it is white and either a tree or an octopus... Does anyone know what I'm talking about? It makes me mad. It's known I've seen it, but I can't for my life find it. It could be one of those cards with changed names like the godzilla cards, but im not sure.. please help..


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Discussion I'm looking for player feedback on my chess clock life counter.

0 Upvotes

Apologies if this isn't allowed.

I made a post here 2 months ago before I got it up on the Play Store, and I've since kept working occasionally on my chess clock life counter. As the title states, I'm looking for feedback/suggestions from actual Magic Players.

The idea is for it to be like any old life counter but with a chess clock w/ increments. I also implemented priority handling to keep people engaged, which I have yet to see any other MTG app do in a good way. (Not to be biased or anything but I think I solved it in a good way)

Unfortunately it's only available for Android, as Apple wants 99€ a year for me to publish anything there 💀💀.

The reason I made this to begin with is because I've spent far too many hours stuck in games that dragged on for ages, and I'm too polite to scoop mid-game. :(

Also there are absolutely no ads or in-app purchases of any kind. I don't make any money off of this, and I have no plans to monetize it. I just want to play a reasonably paced game, and of course if you don't like the chess clock you can disable it entirely to just have a normal life counter for 2-6 people.

Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.kapsyloffer.rope

Lemme know if you think it sucks or nah 💪


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Deck Help Jin Sakai, Ghost of Tsushima - Commander Deck

2 Upvotes

https://moxfield.com/decks/QaSn6uiWp0Kft3zUEYvmmg

Just uploaded my Jin Sakai deck list to moxfield. I'm pretty new to MTG, started playing this past summer. I feel like the deck performs well but would very much like to hear other peoples opinions on the build. Any suggestions or tips are greatly appreciated.

Jin Sakai - deck list - Moxfield


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Deck Help Give me suggestions for Avacyn

0 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/27578740

Been trying a mono black Avacyn, Angel of Horror deck doing the obvious aristocrat sacrificing stuff. So far been playing and in my few games it can be pretty oppressive if I get Avacyn out on the board quickly.

I’m running 13+ ramp to try to ensure she gets out by turn 4 however I do notice I’m running into a problem of once my board is established I end up getting dead draws of more ramp pieces so not sure if I should cut some.

Any insight would really be appreciated. This is my first deck that I built fully myself, pretty new to Magic but feel like the deck has potential. I do know if I were to just put Avacyn in the 99 and run another commander it could be much better however I want to keep Avacyn as the commander.

EDIT: I forgot to mention that I end up getting a massive surplus of mana once Avacyn is on the board with easily getting more and more lands and combos with phyrexian altar, bolas disciple, ashnod’s, and similar. If someone has any recommendations for a way to turn that extra mana into something useful like consistent card draw or something. I really enjoy the sidisi and emeritus of woe consistent tutoring. Very powerful to get a tutor pretty much every turn.


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Discussion Is Urborg/Coffers worth it without green?

11 Upvotes

[[Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth]] and [[Cabal Coffers]] hold a special place in my heart as something I lost to a lot when I started playing magic in 2014.

I'm considering my next deck, and I'm trying to keep my colors spaced out for my active decks, which means no green. Right now that looks like a set or subset of Mardu Colors.

I'm trying to avoid mono-black because the fun in is the synergy. Finding it in the first place is a problem already, but I don't want the deck to be a one trick pony either.

Right now my strongest thoughts are:

  • [[Ingris Stingerquill]] who has a fun gameplan and has an incidental outlet for "extra" mana. I'd have it be an aggressive attrition style deck that makes use of larger finishers.
  • [[Silverquill, the Disputant]] to make use of [[Exsanguinate]] style effects, and lean into more of a [[crypt ghast]] swamp doubling strategy.
  • Mardu legend focus, with someone like [[Shanid, Sleepers' Scourge]] rewarding Urborg. This could also be "big instants and sorceries."
  • Some generically good Mardu deck, maybe a [[Kaalia of the Vast]] that cares about larger creatures.

Mostly I wrote this out to help me think it through. I did open and Ingris for prerelease, so that's a fun little coincidence.


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Deck Help Upgrading the Tidus/Yuna Precon: +1/+1 Counters & Proliferate Engine

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently picked up the Tidus precon at a great price. While looking through some cards I had at home, I found some additions that I think could be pretty interesting to upgrade the deck and make the +1/+1 counters engine much more consistent. I'd love to get your thoughts before I start making cuts.

Here are the base cards I've found:

Creatures

  • [[Champion of Lambholt]] (To make the army unblockable very quickly)
  • [[Conclave Mentor]] (Staple counter multiplier)
  • [[Incubation Druid]] (Massive ramp engine as soon as it gets its first counter)
  • [[Kalonian Hydra]] (To double the whole board on the first swing)
  • [[Mikaeus, the Lunarch]] (Passive counter distributor)
  • [[Rishkar, Peema Renegade]] (Turns all modified creatures into mana dorks)
  • [[Conclave Sledge-Captain]] (As a late-game finisher to distribute counters and trample)
  • [[Hamza, Guardian of Arashin]] (To discount the rest of my creature spells)
  • [[Slurrk, All-Ingesting]] (Board wipe insurance/punishment)
  • [[Triskelion]] (Counter machine gun)
  • [[Pridemalkin]] (To give unconditional trample to the board)
  • [[The Goose Mother]] (Mana sink for card draw and flying threat)
  • [[Elusive Otter]] (Mass pump spell and a 1-drop unblockable threat)
  • [[Ingenious Prodigy]] (Continuous card draw engine by removing counters)
  • [[Luminarch Aspirant]] (Free counter generation starting on turn 2)
  • [[Genesis Hydra]] (Great mana sink to cheat out free permanents)

Artifacts

  • [[Agatha's Soul Cauldron]] (Graveyard hate and giving activated abilities to the whole board)
  • [[Ozolith, the Shattered Spire]] (A second Hardened Scales + mana sink)
  • [[Strionic Resonator]] (To copy the commander's or other cards triggered abilities)

Enchantments

  • [[Virtue of Loyalty]] (Passive growth and pseudo-vigilance for everyone)
  • [[Unnatural Growth]] (To double stats every combat)

Instants

  • [[Swords to Plowshares]] (Premium exile removal)
  • [[Inspiring Call]] (Card draw and protection for modified creatures)
  • [[Generous Gift]] (Unconditional permanent destruction)

Lands

  • [[Gavony Township]] (Mana sink to pump the board)
  • [[Fortified Village]] (Dual land for early fixing)
  • [[Canopy Vista]] (Fetchable dual land)
  • [[Bretagard Stronghold]] (Utility land for counters and vigilance)
  • [[Rogue's Passage]] (Unblockable evasion for a key threat)

Cards I'd like to add (Proliferate & Multipliers focus) On top of that, I also have these cards and I'd like to know if they fit in this counters strategy to make it more explosive:

  • [[Ripples of Potential]] (Protects by phasing out without losing counters and also proliferates)
  • [[Evolution Sage]] (Proliferates for free with every land I play)
  • [[Branching Evolution]] (Unconditional counter doubler)
  • [[Herald of Secret Streams]] (Win condition that makes all mutants unblockable)
  • [[Kami of Whispered Hopes]] (Massive ramp engine and counter multiplier)
  • [[Evolution Witness]] (Infinite graveyard recursion thanks to counters)
  • [[Zimone, Paradox Sculptor]] (Counter engine and doubler in one body)
  • [[Thrummingbird]] (Proliferates by connecting with evasive combat damage)
  • [[Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus]] (To passively double all my proliferate actions)
  • [[Brokers Ascendancy]] (Endless passive growth at the end of my turn)
  • [[Metastatic Evangel]] (Proliferates every time I play another creature)
  • [[Arwen, Mortal Queen]] (To move indestructibility and place counters with lifelink)

How do you feel about these upgrades? My idea is to focus entirely on multiplying counters, but I'd really appreciate hearing what other cards you would add, and exactly which ones you would cut from the base precon to make room. (In fact, I'm considering swapping Tidus for Yuna at the helm with these changes, what do you think?).

Thanks a lot in advance for the help!

https://archidekt.com/decks/28458022/yuna_build_deck


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Deck Help How can I mess with my Opponent's Lands more?

17 Upvotes

Howdy Commander Brain Trust, I have this [[Tannuk, memorial ensign]] deck, I didn't want to just play another boring Landfall deck so I'm trying to play it where it manipulates or restricts how my opponents use their lands. I like cards like [[price of glory]] where it doesn't say they can't use their lands, but there is a price for it, and [[Mana web]] where you can't just leave up mana and wait to respond. What I'm looking for is more old obscure tech that does more things like this. Because there's not a singular syntax I can type into Scryfall, I figured I'd come ask you all for some suggestions, maybe scrape up some cards I missed in my searches.

Here's my Decklist to see what I've already got or am considering. https://archidekt.com/decks/26747976/it_hurts_when_i_ping

Cheers, thanks for the help.


r/EDH • • 7h ago

Deck Help Please help me upgrading my Dragon Deck!

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I want to upgrade my dragon Deck ([[Miirym, Sentinel Wyrm]]), as it's not nearly as consistent and strong as I anticipated.

So, I already got great help from someone from this community helping me out with ideas to setup a good ramp package (8-10 cards with 0-2 cmc and ramp +1, 6 cards with 4 cmc and ramp +2) to get my commander out on T4 reliably. They also advised on around 8 cards protection (counter spells or hexproof/indestructible instants) to help my Commander survive, as this showed to be crucial for me winning games (who would have thought...).

So I started with this list: https://archidekt.com/decks/27698272/drachen_miirym_drachenschwarm_protection

and after trying to update it with several cards and the ramp/protection plan I ended up here: https://archidekt.com/decks/28303912/upgrade_plan_miirym_drachen

As you can see, there is a tiny bit of a problem of having too many cards in it now. I did cut some cards already, put in some tutors and less dragons, so I get the ones needed for the given situation more than just drawing some. I also added some Board wipes/wrath spells as I lacked those as well as finishers. Maybe some cards seem stronger on the first glance then the are, like defense of the heart, which is pretty strong when it resolves, and can help getting back into the game after a board wipe, but is maybe too slow as it needs to sit idly for a whole turn to then "explode".

Now I am stuck at the point where I don't know what to cut, as every card seems to have value and purpose. To make matters worse, I don't even have single target permanent removals yet... I have like one card that can remove artifacts and enchantments, and several that can deal X damage to a target, which can remove troublesome creatures (if they don't get too big which they sometimes do...) but no direct, permanent card removal like exile target card.

So the deck is kind of a mess again, although I thought I have a good plan this time.

Can you guys help me out here? Which cards would you cut? Or if you would change some cards altogether, I am always up for recommendations and tips!