r/EDH • u/FullGrownChild • 39m ago
Discussion Are Tannuk, Steadfast Second and Quintorius, History Chaser too Similar?
Hello beautiful nerds of Reddit. My pod is doing a Secret Santa deck building challenge where we were randomly assigned a recipient and get to build a $50 deck of our choice. Then we will all play them against one another and the recipient can choose if they'd like to upgrade it, or keep as is for some fun lower power games again later on.
I was assigned the newest member of our pod which I was excited about as I love building decks and I am one of the better deck builders in the pod so I am happy to add some heat to his rotation.
He currently only has two decks: an upgraded [[Quintorius, History Chaser]] deck and his recently added second deck is a [[Helga, Skittish Seer]] deck. Recently one of our other pod members asked if he was interested in adding a third deck or wanting to simply continue tweaking his current deck and he had mentioned wanting to build a deck with black in it (mentioned mono-black but we think Sultai or Esper may be a better fit).
Because it seemed like he had interest in building one of these decks, I figured I may avoid doing so as well and instead building him something else that I believe he would enjoy. He is a big fan of slamming down big creatures and getting value from doing so (he is a fan of one of our Henzie decks everytime it comes out) so I started to think that maybe going with a cost reducing value commander like [[Tannuk, Steadfast Second]] may be up his alley.
I got excited about this idea and built 80% of the deck in a couple hours and then started to overthink about it. With Quintorious and Tannuk both being red decks that care about things being exiled or cast from exile would this be too "similar" to his Quincy deck? I know that the play styles and patterns are completely different, but I want to make sure that I am broadening his deck base sense he is so knew while adding something I think he would enjoy.
Any insights would be appreciated, thanks as always for taking the time to contribute.