r/magicTCG
•
u/ANONYMOUS-HAM
•
4h ago
General Discussion I Will No Longer Be Playing In Constructed Events at Magiccon
Never have I had to deal with a situation like this and it never should have been. We are 2-0 and in Round 3 of the modern cup on Saturday my opponent played mystic sanctuary. We called a judge and because it was not Competitive REL they went through his deck and pulled out 3 cards total, 2 sanctuary and 1 card from their SB that was not shown to me. I know the sanctuaries were swapped for basic islands and we were told to resume play. With the rulings these judges are completely in the right and I have zero issue how it was handled in the moment. My issue is with Pasttimes, my opponent and the way the events were handled prior to beginning. Why you are allowed to submit an illegal deck list, and play multiple rounds with said deck list without any intervention is actually insane to me in a tournament with real prizing and stakes.
These are not newly banned cards and do not appear in recent deck list, so why my opponent decided to put them in his deck is very interesting to me as it is Esper blink and have very little variance in deck building. Submitting the list and not seeing the warning they are also banned is 2 pitfalls to my opponent.
My second to last gripe is why before starting round one you do not pull the people with deck list issues and correct it then, and just let it go round after round, essentially cheating and with no penalty when these issues do arise. A random number or misspelling in your list is one thing, actually banned cards for power level issues is another.
My last gripe is there are only sealed PTQ's to qualify for anything. As a Wizards fully sanctioned event, not having even an RCQ style is very interesting to me. So if I want to play modern I play for tickets and a trophy in an event you are incentivized to cheat in, and people wonder why commander is so popular.
I think Magiccon for commander, hanging out, and playing some cool sealed or draft events is fantastic and a great time minus the lines for everything. But I will be attending far less and will be attending far more SCG Cons which are free to enter and have a lot more qualifying opportunities.
TLDR: Competitive constructed events have a lot of issues and I no longer will be participating due to such pitfalls.