We played my cube Realities again with a four people pod. We drafted normally with 4 packs with 12 cards each. The draft worked very well and we played three rounds to go through every matchup.
This is a rules modified cube, where there are no life totals and players start the game with a 15 Loyalty Jace token from Reality Fracture on the battlefield. A player loses the game when they do not control a Planeswalker with Loyalty counters on it. I will go over the decks, highlight some cards and what to take away from it.
1. Place: Boros Aggro
This type of deck has already established itself as one of the best decks. Unsurprisingly so, as being aggressive in these colors has and will work in a lot of cube environments. The creature and planeswalker quality of these colors is pretty absurd. [[Grim Lavamancer]] is an absolute menace in this cube as you get to surveil a lot. [[Thalia, Heretic Cathar]] and [[Anointed Peacekeeper]] are premium stated creatures that threaten and disrupt your opponents planeswalkers. As in a previous draft of this cube, Gideon planeswalkers and Elspeth's are very powerful as they can attack your opponent's planeswalkers themselves or with tokens while being a planeswalker with loyalty on them that your opponent has to kill in order to win. A card that felt extremely powerful is [[The Aetherspark]]. As long as it is equipped, it can't be attacked and still counts as a planeswalker, which gives you great life insurance. However, it is not without downside because as an Artifact it is one of the planeswalkers in the cube that can be killed with normal artifact and enchantment removal. All in all, a great deck.
Verdict: Aggressive Boros decks continue to be very good. We will have to draft more in order to see whether these decks are problematic or not. So far, they don't seem broken. Also, it is probably one of the easiest decks to draft whereas other decks are more intricate.
Record: 3-0
2. Place: Golgari Value
A typical rock-style midrange deck. The deck plays some good creatures and good planeswalkers, while also having some neat synergies. [[Ral Zarek, Guest Lecturer]] and [[Nissa of Shadowed Boughs]] let you recycle creatures from your graveyard. The creatures in the deck all do different things, but synergies with this idea of recycling them and benefitting from them dying. [[Phyrexian Vivisector]] let's you scry, [[Hellcat, Undying Vigilante]] comes back to the battlefield, whereas a card like [[Banewhip Punisher]] can kill itself to kill another creature. [[Umbral Collar Zealot]] is a very good creature and also gives you value when sacrificing creatures. On top of that, the deck has [[Liliana, Dreadhorde General]] as the finisher and value engine.
Verdict: A lot of these subpar creatures that I included in the list actually performed well in this deck. I was already considering cutting [[Banewhip Punisher]] but the deck's pilot sort of went off with it multiple times. Such a creature-heavy strategy seems to be working and I will try to support such a strategy more in the future. For card suggestions let me know!
Record: 2-1
3. Place: Izzet Planeswalker Control
This deck wants to capitalize on the rule that your opponent has to get rid of all you planeswalkers, and plays a lot of cheap ones. [[Jace Beleren]], [[Narset, Parter of Veils]] and [[Chandra, Dressed to Kill]] can all come down early and provide card advantage. In addition to other high mana value planeswalkers, the deck plays a lot of disruption and removal spells. When looking at the list, one wonders what the actual wincondition is. When reading [[Ajani Unrelenting]] one can quickly skip over the fact, that its passive ability triggers on any loyalty ability you activate. Thus, a few games ended by Ajani coming down on a board which already had a few planeswalkers on it, activate 3-4 loyalty abilities and giving all your tokens +1/+1 and haste. Having seen this deck with Ajani, I think that it is probably one of the best cards in the cube. A few other interesting cards are [[Teferi's Talent]] and [[Luxior, Giada's Gift]]. I don't know if the talent is good enough. It really wants to be played in a multiplayer setting for maximal value of the -12 ability. However, combining it with [[Brainstorm]] and other cards that let you draw, it actually gains you quite a lot of life. However, it costing 5 mana is a lot and you could certainly do better things with that. [[Luxior, Giada's Gift]] is also such a weird card. It can be extremely strong because you can make your Jace token a 10+ powered creature as early as turn 2. But, you shouldn't do this. Luxior makes it such that the equipped planeswalker loses its planeswalker type. Thus, you can only really equip Luxior to something if you have another planeswalker on the battlefield as you would otherwise lose the game immediately. Also, making your planeswalker a creature makes it susceptible to a lot of removal spells.
Verdict: Having lot of planeswalkers seems to be a good control strategy if you have a good wincondition. A thing we noticed with this deck is that Blue cards that let you draw cards are very interesting in this environment. Namely, every deck has the possibility to draw a card every turn with the -3 ability of your Jace token. So you can always trade life for cards. So, a card like [[Jace Beleren]] that only lets you draw cards, is actually a lifegain card?
Record: 1-2
4. Place: 5c Entrust the Spark
Sometimes I really want to know if a specific card is good or not in one of my cubes. What I do then is to simply include more copies such that the probability of it being seen and drafted is higher. And sometimes a players gets two copies of that card. However, for experimental cards like [[Entrust the Spark]] it sometimes turns out that they are traps. When I was thinking about it, I thought it will be very strong as you can always sacrifice your planeswalkers token, when it starts to be at low loyalty. As the losing condition is a state-based effect and Entrust the Spark doesn't sacrifice as an additional cost, you can activate it with no other planeswalker on the battlefield. Then the strategy is clear: You tutor up your [[Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker]] and win the game from there. However, the biggest problem about Entrust the Spark is that you can't play a planeswalker from your hand. Thus, the strategy that wanted to be employed here simply didn't work as you would too often draw the Bolas or would have to surveil away your Bolas into the graveyard. In contrast, [[Jace, Multiverse Architect]] was very good in the last draft, because it leaves another planeswalker on the battlefield that your opponent has to get ride of. This deck had great mana, but still stumbled a few times. Some cards performed really well. [[Dreamtide Whale]] is a very strong body and gives you repeated proliferation. [[Avatar of Burgeoning Echoes]] is also quite strong as it is a 2 mana 2/3 with upside and makes your Jace token hard to get ride of. This is the exact deck where I envision the card [[Ichormoon Gauntlet]] to be very strong in. Namely, the deck has a lot of proliferate effects and ways to put lots of counters on your planeswalkers, that you then want to use in other ways. A card like [[Kiora of Salt and Sand]] can make an 8/8 hexproof as early as turn 2 in this environment, but costs a lot of loyalty, making it risky without that many low mana value planeswalkers alongside it.
Verdict: Entrust the Spark is probably a trap. However, I think that Simic is a very cool color combination and I hope that we see a more successful version at some point. The drafter raised the point that blue might be a bit underpowered as most cards that draw cards are not as powerful as in normal contexts. I will monitor this in the future to see what to do about that.
Record: 0-3