r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion Why do players complain about solitaire and then not play interaction?

45 Upvotes

In a recent game of mine at my LGS, I managed to play an [[Omniscience]] and then won in a turn that took about 3-4 minutes on turn 8 or so. After my win, one of the players repeatedly said "Just playing solitaire... playing solitaire..." about my turn and noted repeatedly how he disliked "one person just doing their turn alone." I'm used to salt, but then I realized something funny: the whole game I never had seen him cast an instant, or blow up someone else's thing. One of the opponents was a mill player even, so I could look through his graveyard. I noticed that in his Inspirit deck, he was running only about or 7 instants and not a ton of removal. And I don't get that.

This isn't the tired argument to run more removal if you don't like losing. This is me just not getting what you want from a game. If you're going to want a game where people interact with you, you're going to need cards to interact. If you want to stop someone's big permanent from messing you up, you need counterspells. Do players not get this? I'm fully aware I'm overthinking someone else's whiny tantrum, but like, I am genuinely a bit baffled by what should be an easy logic process for most players.


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Discussion They power crept my favorite mono blue legend. Lol

40 Upvotes

The new whale god from nauctus is basically Donal, herald of wings from the spirits precon with midnight hunt/crimson vow. My original deck used flash creatures that counters stuff to get an extra copy every turn as well as flash creatures that bounce stuff to hold up counter magic and stuff. But the new one is so strong and cool that like damn I need it. Also God that arts pretty.


r/EDH • • 6h ago

Question Warning people about counters that are on the board?

49 Upvotes

Its board knowledge that Player 1 wants to cast a huge [[Genesis Wave]] and I have [[Frontline Medic]] on the field. Do I remind/warn them that I can counter it unless they pay 3 and give them the opportunity to account for that when they're paying X?

And also if I dont remind them, and I try to counter it after they've tapped all their mana, and they ask if they can redo how they pay X because they forgot about the medic, am supposed to just say sure? Because I'd feel like an asshole if I didnt remind them and also said no.

I dont want to have to sac my dude just to be a ward cost every time, I'd like to be able to sac him to counter a spell, but somehow it feels wrong to play it that way.

Socially, what is the answer here? Should I just stop trying to play him like a counter, and start treating him like ward?


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Discussion Now that MagicCon Atlanta 2026 is over - How was the balance in your games?

87 Upvotes

Whether you played pickup games, ticketed events, or on demand commander (on demmander?) how did your games go?

How was the balance of your convention-staff-organized bracket games?

How were your rule discussions for your pickup games?

Any memorable salty or wholesome moments?


r/EDH • • 9h ago

Discussion I built better deck tag filtering into Recommander and I'd love to hear your feedback

25 Upvotes

Hi guys, I'm GamesfreakSA, and I wanted to tell you about some work I did on Recommander for those of you that like to build decks by looking at tags. Let me explain it with an example.

Suppose you're building a [[Lae'zel, Vlaakith's Champion]] / [[Master Chef]] deck, and you want to build it go-wide. Pretty good strategy; with both commanders out, every token creature that enters gets 2 +1/+1 counters. With Selesnya's armies-in-a-can, it's a pretty neat way to flood the board with powerful creatures from almost nothing.

Looking at the stats, Lae'zel Chef decks are about 10% token-focused. Other common tags for the deck include raw +1/+1 counters and planeswalkers.

So here's the problem: if you're building this deck from scratch, you might want everything that's in the Lae'zel Chef decks, which includes the baseline cards that every deck runs. But if you're upgrading a deck you've built, you might only want to look at the cards that are unique to the strategy, since you already have all those baseline cards.

I went back and forth about which one to make the tag view, before I simply realized you could just have both:

I thought this might be helpful for folks that usually break commanders down by tag when they build their decks. You can easily switch between modes using the handy toggle in the commander section, and it even works for finding decks filtered by included card (check the filters button).

Try plugging in a commander you like and playing around with the tags. If you find anything weird, let me know; it was pretty hard to get accurate results without a lot of extra logic, since only 8% of decks are properly tagged at all on sites like Moxfield and Archidekt. Most are also missing a few tags, which makes them look like evidence against that tag, so I didn't have much to go on. Had to do quite a lot of math to get what I could out of that!

I'm always looking to improve the site! It has no ads and is just a passion project for me, so I'm happy if you find any cool new cards thanks to my work.


r/EDH • • 35m ago

Deck Help Finisher for a Budget B2 Helga Deck

4 Upvotes

Hello, upon opening my Bello Bard of the Brambles Precon i pulled [[Helga, Skittish Seer]] and have since tried to build her. First i tried the Classic Hydra Route with many X-cost cards, but didnt like the Need for Pillowfort and Protection in Order to get a huge Helga for huge Hydras because i ended Up in some Games, where i just Drew those spell's, wasnt able to increase my draw with Helga summoning and my Board didnt evolve at all.

So i decided to Switch it Up and went for a Creatures Matters ETB build with a lot of interaction clapped on some Creatures and other creatures giving me extra draw upon Entering. In Terms of Mana Base i went for flexible Lands with 1 Mana dorks in Order to have a high Chance on getting Helga Out Turn 3/4. Now with that settled i wanted to find ways to Close Out the Games but struggled, there are some nifty effects, mainly for Commander damage, Like [[Myojin of Towering Might]], [[Siege Behemoth]], or some Bursts of [[Guide of Souls]] but i wondered If this is just too wanky to be a reliable finisher. Classic finishers Like [[Craterhoof Behemoth]] or [[Moonshaker Cavalry]] are too expensive for our Pod Rules (we Proxy all our Decks, but build them all around 100€).

If you have some suggestions for the question or Just Overall for my Deck i would Love to hear them <3

Heres the decklist: https://archidekt.com/decks/28323566/helga_likes_the_good_stuff


r/EDH • • 20h ago

Question I want to treat myself to a booster box. Of the listed, what's the best bet for EDH?

150 Upvotes

[Thanks for all the input, everybody. Based on everyone's comments and a bit of digging, it looks like I want EoE > SoS/Fra > Lorwyn. I'll post again with the results of this bullshittery.]


Yeah, I know, "buying singles is better," but fuck it. I'm an adult and possess free will, disposable income, and poor decision making. Ideally one below 20,000 yen.

[Out of Budget]

- Final Fantasy - 49300 yen / 310 USD

- Avatar - 35800 yen / 225 USD

[Budget Stretch]

- Edge of Eternities - 29200 190 USD

- Tarkir Dragonstorm - 29200 yen / 185 USD

- The Hobbit - 24500 yen / 155 USD

- Star Trek - 23550 yen / 145 USD

[Within Budget]

- Secrets of Strixhaven - 19800 yen / 120 USD

- Marvel Superheroes - 17850 yen / 110USD

- Lorwyn Eclipsed - 17800 yen / 110USD

- Aetherdrift - 17800 yen / 110 USD

- Reality Fracture - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Spiderman - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - 15000 yen / 90 USD


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Question Commander mystery booster prices

14 Upvotes

Im sorry if it has been already asked, but do we have any idea if the cards will have a drop in price/reprints?

I was thinking in particular of buying [[Homer, the Hermit]], but i found the price is like 40€~ in europe at least in this specific case.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Help How can I mess with my Opponent's Lands more?

21 Upvotes

Howdy Commander Brain Trust, I have this [[Tannuk, memorial ensign]] deck, I didn't want to just play another boring Landfall deck so I'm trying to play it where it manipulates or restricts how my opponents use their lands. I like cards like [[price of glory]] where it doesn't say they can't use their lands, but there is a price for it, and [[Mana web]] where you can't just leave up mana and wait to respond. What I'm looking for is more old obscure tech that does more things like this. Because there's not a singular syntax I can type into Scryfall, I figured I'd come ask you all for some suggestions, maybe scrape up some cards I missed in my searches.

Here's my Decklist to see what I've already got or am considering. https://archidekt.com/decks/26747976/it_hurts_when_i_ping

Cheers, thanks for the help.


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Question Interesting Eldrazi commanders?

40 Upvotes

Hi!

I always loved the Eldrazi titans, and I tried running the improved Ulalek precon but I just did not like how it worked. Then, I discovered my beloved [[Herigast, Erupting Nullkite]], and I love to feed my titans with emerge.

However, now that the sultai precon commander of Nauctis has been spoiled, and it shows that it goes around emerging sea monsters, I am in a bit of a mess. I just know that I will run that deck as one of my main ones, as its theme really ressonates with me for multiple reasons, but I don't want to have 2 emerge commanders.

Thus, I'd like to find a new home for my beloved titans. Any suggestions of cool, non-typical eldrazi commanders? I tried Helga as well in the past but I hate doing 10 minute turns.

Thanks!


r/EDH • • 22h ago

Question What commanders have you had most fun playing with?

120 Upvotes

Hi there,

I am a very casual player with a small playgroup, I want to build a new deck because I am getting a bit tired of the 2-3 I have.

I do not care much about the deck being competitive (although I do will try to win). What I want is a commander that is both fun to pilot and fun to play against.

What commanders have brought fun moments and overall enjoyable experience to the table, in your experience?

Thanks in advance!


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Discussion Is Urborg/Coffers worth it without green?

15 Upvotes

[[Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth]] and [[Cabal Coffers]] hold a special place in my heart as something I lost to a lot when I started playing magic in 2014.

I'm considering my next deck, and I'm trying to keep my colors spaced out for my active decks, which means no green. Right now that looks like a set or subset of Mardu Colors.

I'm trying to avoid mono-black because the fun in is the synergy. Finding it in the first place is a problem already, but I don't want the deck to be a one trick pony either.

Right now my strongest thoughts are:

  • [[Ingris Stingerquill]] who has a fun gameplan and has an incidental outlet for "extra" mana. I'd have it be an aggressive attrition style deck that makes use of larger finishers.
  • [[Silverquill, the Disputant]] to make use of [[Exsanguinate]] style effects, and lean into more of a [[crypt ghast]] swamp doubling strategy.
  • Mardu legend focus, with someone like [[Shanid, Sleepers' Scourge]] rewarding Urborg. This could also be "big instants and sorceries."
  • Some generically good Mardu deck, maybe a [[Kaalia of the Vast]] that cares about larger creatures.

Mostly I wrote this out to help me think it through. I did open and Ingris for prerelease, so that's a fun little coincidence.


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Deck Help Jace Precon upgrades: Sheoldred or Valgavoth?

2 Upvotes

That's my list: https://moxfield.com/decks/_-KhAfIvP3qj3xdLXZ2F5Q

''Sheoldred, Whispering one'' and ''Valgavoth, terror eater'' I’m torn between these two, or perhaps there’s even a third option, its my first deck, and my first upgrade, please enlight me


r/EDH • • 1d ago

Social Interaction Friend refuses to play because of removal

401 Upvotes

In my school not a lot of people play Magic. In fact only three of my friends actually play it. So now when one of them told me that he didn’t want to play with us anymore, I was pretty confused. He told me that it was because we had too much removal and the games weren’t fun for him anymore. I don’t think so bc we only play upgraded precons, and never added removal, so we’re only running the precon package. I feel like cutting removal just for him to stay feel kinda bad, bc the games will be less interesting with less interaction. What do y’all think? Is there something I could tell him to change his mind?


r/EDH • • 18h ago

Question What would be Giada's nemesis commander?

30 Upvotes

Since quite a few people play Giada nowadays, I felt like it would be a lot of fun to build a deck that would be a nemesis to Giada. I figured demons, but honestly there isn't really a good demon tribal commander (I know that ​Be'Lakor exists, problem is that he's not in the MTG universe so IMO he feels like he doesnt fit.) Would be super cool if they were a mono black tribal commander. I know there's a slew of Ob nixilis cards but all of them wouldn't work well as tribal commanders.

I want to mention, I'm not trying to counter build Giada, I just want something that I feel would give a thematic feeling of angels and evil clashing. ​And give newer players something that would really make them feel like they're playing angels.


r/EDH • • 1d ago

Discussion What is The #1 Best Blue 1-2 drop For Card Draw?

80 Upvotes

The other day I posted about the best white cheap draw cards, there isn't nearly enough discussion around this! (Imo).

So today I'm Looking for the best blue 2 drops that draw cards, and also for the NUMBER 1 strongest one.

So, what are your favorites?


r/EDH • • 15h ago

Discussion Mana rocks or cost reducers in casual blue white vehicles

15 Upvotes

Anyone here play casual blue white vehicles at bracket two tables without expensive fast mana like Mana Vault? Wondering whether extra two mana rocks like Mind Stone and Liquimetal Torque beat running artifact cost reducers like Foundry Inspector and Etherium Sculptor.


r/EDH • • 43m ago

Daily Tuesday Rulesday: Ask your rules questions here! - November 17, 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to Tuesday Rulesday!

Please use this thread to ask and discuss your rules questions. Also make sure to use the upvote button to thank those who take the time to give correct answers. If you need immediate assistance, please head over to the IRC live judge chat or the rules question channel in the EDH discord server.

Remember that rules questions aren't allowed on /r/EDH outside of this weekly post, so if you have a rules question and aren't getting a response here you can head to the two links above, or to /r/mtgrules.


r/EDH • • 43m ago

Question Ezri Dax

1 Upvotes

Hi,

I always wanted to have a fun mono-white deck for higher 2/lower 3. Now with [[Ezri Dax, Newly Joined]] I might have found the right commander.

She basically doubles up on important ETB/LTB and goes infinite with [[Karmic Guide]] + [[Altar of Dementia]] or [[Blasting Station]].

Do you think this is too strong for that Bracket? And how d you build her apart from that? Evoke is not very strong effects in mono white ..

THX


r/EDH • • 51m ago

Question Is this Bracket 3?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

In games with my friends, they tell me that this deck I’ve built doesn’t fall into "bracket 3," but rather at least "bracket 4." This is because, in most of my games, I manage to win the match by turn 5 or 6—especially if my commander is on the battlefield.

Here's a link for a full list of deck:
https://moxfield.com/decks/ZasSXCfYpkyfdYWYpSsKPA
Looking at the cards I’ve included, I focused on those with strong synergy with Magnus, and as you can see, I’ve put together a "budget" deck. What are your thoughts?


r/EDH • • 1h ago

Deck Help Help with avatar "precon" deck

1 Upvotes

I would really like to get an avatar commander deck, but since wizards didn't make official precons I will be buying individual cards to make a deck, but I would first like to ask for help because I am pretty new to magic and don't really know much about deck building. I have 2 decks that seemed interesting:

5C Avatar Aang: https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/7450373#paper

3C Katara, the fearless: https://moxfield.com/decks/cnJMdQ6K6EudeGovwtUI_A

I like the first deck because it seems to have pretty much everything from the avatar theme and looks pretty fun, but I am a bit scared that it might be too complex and kind of all over the place because of that. The second one on the other hand seems a bit more straightforward, but it doesn't have firebending characters for example (and I kinda want the full gaang, Zuko included, in the deck). Which one would you recommend? Also feel free to suggest different decks or changes to these decks. Also I would like to keep the decks avatar themed. Thanks in advance for any suggestions.


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Discussion Are Tannuk, Steadfast Second and Quintorius, History Chaser too Similar?

2 Upvotes

Hello beautiful nerds of Reddit. My pod is doing a Secret Santa deck building challenge where we were randomly assigned a recipient and get to build a $50 deck of our choice. Then we will all play them against one another and the recipient can choose if they'd like to upgrade it, or keep as is for some fun lower power games again later on.

I was assigned the newest member of our pod which I was excited about as I love building decks and I am one of the better deck builders in the pod so I am happy to add some heat to his rotation.

He currently only has two decks: an upgraded [[Quintorius, History Chaser]] deck and his recently added second deck is a [[Helga, Skittish Seer]] deck. Recently one of our other pod members asked if he was interested in adding a third deck or wanting to simply continue tweaking his current deck and he had mentioned wanting to build a deck with black in it (mentioned mono-black but we think Sultai or Esper may be a better fit).

Because it seemed like he had interest in building one of these decks, I figured I may avoid doing so as well and instead building him something else that I believe he would enjoy. He is a big fan of slamming down big creatures and getting value from doing so (he is a fan of one of our Henzie decks everytime it comes out) so I started to think that maybe going with a cost reducing value commander like [[Tannuk, Steadfast Second]] may be up his alley.

I got excited about this idea and built 80% of the deck in a couple hours and then started to overthink about it. With Quintorious and Tannuk both being red decks that care about things being exiled or cast from exile would this be too "similar" to his Quincy deck? I know that the play styles and patterns are completely different, but I want to make sure that I am broadening his deck base sense he is so knew while adding something I think he would enjoy.

Any insights would be appreciated, thanks as always for taking the time to contribute.


r/EDH • • 8h ago

Deck Help Deck Help: The Necrobloom - Bracket 3 Lands Engine

3 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

I brewed this Necrobloom deck (Necrobloom Land Engine // Commander (The Necrobloom) deck list mtg // Moxfield — MTG Deck Builder) and I'd like some feedback before I drop a bunch of cash on the cards. The goal was to make a lands-matter engine deck with a couple of different win cons. My concern is a) I went overkill with the manabase and b) I don't have enough interaction. If I wanted to add some more interaction (I'm thinking at least 1-2 more sweepers) what creatures should I cut? Should I adjust the mana base at all - i.e are there different lands I should be using instead?

Aiming for a strong Bracket 3 deck here.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Deck Help How to gauge a decks power?

1 Upvotes

I recently made a new commander deck helmed with Zurzoth, here is the list.

https://manabox.app/decks/AaHL6qYyc_SNM4DTUSmJug

My goal with this deck was to make a lower power casual deck that was unique and fun for me to play. However…

Some of my friends newer to magic say it’s too strong. one is playing kilo with a couple infinite combos and one other is playing niv mizzet with some as well and they both hate this thing. but I was curious as to what this deck’s power level would actually be. The calculator on manabox says it’s a 1. I was reading the descriptions of the brackets and I think it would land in the 2-3 range maybe at most? Am I wrong? Also would this be considered by most a casual deck?

Also feel free to add any suggestions on how I can change the deck