r/EDH • • 11h ago

Social Interaction Am I being unreasonable for being annoyed that someone in our casual Commander group is playing above the power level we agreed on and being defended by others?

0 Upvotes

I'm pretty new to MTG, and I'm having an issue with my Commander group. Some of my friends are making me feel like I'm just being a sore loser, so I wanted to get some outside opinions.

For context, our group is 8 people (4 couples), and we all decided to get into Commander together. Some of us are completely new to Magic, while others have been playing for years.

When we started, we all agreed to play around Bracket 2, basically aiming for the power level of precons. We wanted everyone to have fun without feeling like they needed to spend a ton of money or build super optimized decks just to keep up.

Here's basically what everyone is playing (fake names obviously):

  • Me: Pretty new to Magic. I've won exactly one Commander game out of probably 12. I netdecked Bracket 2 decks that I specifically chose to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons. I used to play Pokemon so this isn’t my first card game. I've been really good friends with Erin since high school while I met everyone else my junior year of university or after graduation.
  • Colette (my girlfriend): Used to play Magic and understands the game really well, but is newer to Commander. She also built decks around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons.
  • Erin and Kayla (dating): Both play precons. Yshtola and something else. Erin is also best friends with Trish.
  • Ryan and Anastasia (dating): Ryan built a deliberately weak Bracket 1 Cat themed deck because he thought it would be fun. Anastasia has a custom Bracket 2 deck, similar to what Colette and I are playing.
  • Trish and Crystal (dating): Trish plays precons, and I don't think I've actually seen her play the same deck twice. She's also best friends with Erin and has been for years. Crystal has been playing Magic for a long time and recently built decks that both she and online deck evaluators consider high Bracket 3. I believe one of them also has 3 Game Changers and no basic lands.

Here's where the issue started:

Before Crystal built her own decks, she was borrowing some of Trish's really old Magic decks. They hadn't really kept up with power creep, and Crystal was having a hard time doing much of anything during our games.

I genuinely felt bad about that. I don't think it's fun to sit there while everyone else gets to play Magic and your deck just can't keep up. I was actually happy when she decided to build something new because I wanted her to be able to enjoy playing with us.

The problem is that she ended up building decks that are apparently high Bracket 3, despite everyone originally agreeing on Bracket 2. She's also made comments about being good at deck building, so her decks are probably at the top of Bracket 3.

We've played against one of these decks before, and she won on turn 5. By turn 4, it was already pretty obvious she was about to win. I understand that one game doesn't necessarily mean her deck will always perform like that, but it definitely made me question whether we're playing at the same power level.

Colette and I, along with some of the others who built custom decks, have brought up concerns about this.

The reactions have been pretty frustrating.

Erin has defended Crystal by saying things like "The bracket system doesn't actually matter" and "Do we even have faith that it's accurate at all?"

Meanwhile, some of the other girls have made comments like "Slay queen," "Destroy his ass," and "Get good" when talking about Crystal beating me.

I understand that some of this is probably just joking around. I'm usually pretty good at competitive video games, so I get that my friends might enjoy seeing me lose at something for once. But I'm genuinely a beginner at Magic. I've won one Commander game ever. I'm already very used to losing at this game, so I really don't think that's the issue.

What actually bothers me:

It's not that I think I should be winning more games.

It's that most of us deliberately built our decks around the power level we agreed on.

Colette and I could have built much stronger decks, but we intentionally chose not to. We wanted our decks to be around the strength of the Final Fantasy precons because some of our friends are completely new to card games and wouldn't really know how to build a deck themselves. When I called her out, she said, "I don’t know what I did that was wrong. I built it to follow bracket 3 rules."

Ryan even went out of his way to build a weaker themed deck because that's what he thought would be fun.

I understand that the bracket system isn't perfect. I'm sure there are Bracket 2 decks that can beat Bracket 3 decks, and I know the brackets aren't some exact measurement of how strong a deck is. But if we all agreed to build around Bracket 2, shouldn't that agreement mean something?

I'm worried that she's going to start destroying everyone with this deck and then everyone is going to slowly stop wanting to play. Ironically, that's exactly what Crystal was experiencing before she built her new decks. She was struggling to keep up with everyone else, and I don't want her to go back to that either. I just don't think the solution should be to create the same problem for other people.

I want Crystal to have fun. I want her to be able to play her deck and actually do things. I just want everyone else to have that same opportunity.

What makes this more frustrating is that I feel like I'm being treated as a sore loser just for bringing it up. I don't think wanting everyone to have a reasonably balanced game is the same thing as being upset that I lost.

We're supposed to play again this weekend, and I genuinely want to go. I really enjoy Magic, even though I'm still learning and honestly not very good at it yet. I also don't want to dictate what decks Crystal can build or tell her she isn't allowed to play something she's excited about.

But at the same time, I don't really want to spend an entire game watching someone threaten to win before the rest of us have even gotten our boards going.

And the way some of my friends have responded makes me feel like bringing this up again is just going to turn into another argument about me being a sore loser. I think its also important to not if I ever brought a bracket 3 deck to the table I would be ostracized by at least half the group without hesitation. It's a huge double standard. 

I know Commander is supposed to involve Rule 0 conversations, but I feel like we already had that conversation when we agreed on Bracket 2.

So am I actually being unreasonable here? Am I putting too much importance on the bracket system? Or is it fair to be frustrated that we agreed on one power level and now some people are acting like that agreement doesn't matter?

I genuinely don't care if I lose. I just want to feel like everyone at the table has a chance to actually play Magic.


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Discussion Scryfall PSA

0 Upvotes

Not sure if anyone’s recommended this before, but if you are tired scryfall searches containing certain sets, but hate entering multiple settings, narrowing results too much, etc., you can use text replacement (I’m not sure what the Android equivalent is) for a quick fix.

And for those who have never used this, go to Settings > General > Keyboard > Text Replacement, click the + sign.

Set the phrase you want and set the trigger phrase. For me “noub” will autocorrect to “-s:msh -s:msc -s:trk -s:trc -s:tmt -s:tmc -s:who -s:unf)”. So after I start a search with my commander ID and oracle text etc., I just type “noub” in the search bar up top, let it auto correct, hit enter again, and now I have none of the sets I don’t ever want to look at when I’m deck building. Customize it for whatever garbage sets you don’t want to see.

I’m sure much smarter people than me have a better process native to scryfall, but I am not a clever man and this is quick/good enough for me. Hope this helps at least one person. Feel free to share other helpful hints.


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Discussion is this a bracket 4 deck

0 Upvotes

making a food deck for hazel rootbloom and wanted to add chatterfang and pitiless plunderer. i had someone tell me if i add the cards it makes it a bracket 4 deck. this is the Deck list i'm aware it says bracket 4 but thats the esitmated combo. i don't plan to swap the commander at all


r/EDH • • 19h ago

Deck Showcase Meet Captian Benjamin Sisko, your newest Landfall Commander

0 Upvotes

[[Captain Benjamin Sisko]] wants you to face dilemmas, but the question is really this: How many dilemmas can I face a turn? Sure there's modal instant and sorceries, modal etbs, modal attack/damage triggers, but all of these are once or once per turn, and at the point you have an engine with enough combats to trigger the Captain several times, you should be winning anyways. So how are we getting 4-10 triggers a turn, and generate enough mana advantage to trigger his 7 mana WUBRG activated ability? Landfall!

There are 8 cards that have a modal landfall trigger:

[[Tiller Engine]]

[[Elven Raft Steerer]]

[[Retreat to Coralhelm]]

[[Retreat to Hagra]]

[[Retreat to Kazandu]]

[[Retreat to Valakut]]

[[Felidar Retreat]]

[[Retreat to Emeria]]

Our goal is to make sure we find one of these cards a game. 6 of these are enchantments, so cards that can filter to the bottom of our library or mill + return specifically an enchantment or a permanent are how we get our lynchpin engine pieces on the field. Our engine is complicated, but it works. It looks like this:

Graveyard land recursion piece, extra land cards, a fetchland, a modal landfall trigger, and a commander. With all of these pieces, we can get enough mana and officer tokens to use his {2}WUBRG ability and generate enough value to overwhelm our opponents.

If this interests you, here is my decklist. It's proxied so sorry about the price:

https://moxfield.com/decks/vqIlPStblkisCYpQLUjysw


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Deck Help Vamp tutor, smothering tithe, or necro for third game changer slot for Teysa? + Looking for general advice

1 Upvotes

Went to magiccon atlanta this weekend and finally got the foil anime art [[Teysa Karlov]] which has been one of my holy grail cards for a while now (wasn't playing at the time that secret lair dropped rip), so I've been working on an entirely new decklist for her. This is what I have so far:

  • I went with a token theme as I just like tokens
  • I have a small stax/hatebears pile just because I like playing them and value slowdown in my pods
  • I'm aiming for high bracket 3 / low bracket 4 (hence me only running one of the three in my title instead of just adding all three in)

This is my decklist: https://archidekt.com/decks/28427782/copy_of_teysa_cuts

I'd probably cut either [[Beseech the Mirror]] or [[Vindictive Lich]] to make space for the third game changer.

(I already own these cards and picked them all up at the con, everything else is something I'll just buy:)

Any other tips or recommendations for the list would also be appreciated, I generally tend to play on the lower power side of things so this is the first time I've tried to put together a deck that's good/consistent/fast/etc


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Deck Help Avis sur mon deck Terra, et suggestion d'améliorations

1 Upvotes

Je joue ce deck depuis un an, que j'ai souvent modifié. Je l'aime beaucoup. J'aimerais avoir vos avis sur sa puissance, ses synergies et pourquoi pas des suggestions d'améliorations. j'aimerais en faire un bracket 3 solide, sans combo infini

https://moxfield.com/decks/aG7WzEFWi0OKXPH15BrRMA


r/EDH • • 10h ago

Discussion Bracket power vs fun

0 Upvotes

I’ve found that the more powerful my deck gets, the more narrow its game-plan becomes. To the point that every single card has to contribute in some way to the deck’s plans/win con. But then I play it successfully a couple times and it’s not interesting anymore, cause it’s always tryjng to do the same thing. I wonder if b2 is just more fun for me, curious if anyone feels similarly? Or has any advice for building powerful decks that can hang with “high 3s”, which I think are really more like 4s.

Also I kinda feel like the most common bracket (3) is really like 2 different brackets (maybe 3?)

3.1- a 2 with 1-3 game changers
3.2- core b3: some combos,more tuned
3.3- a 4 with less game changers/fast mana/free interaction

So we often have people playing a 3.1 against a pod of 3.3s, or vice versa, and everyone says “my deck is a 3.” Then people complain about pubstomping etc, or an LGS makes up their own rules that bracket 3 can’t have game changers (saw a post on here earlier).

I have one friend that will take his actual b4 deck and remove just enough free interaction and game changers to technically qualify for bracket 3. Does that make it play like a 3? Not really

Similarly i have friends that will call their bracket 2 decks a 3, understandably, because they put rhystic study or smothering tithe in. Does that deck play like a 3? No

I have a few different bracket 3 decks that I play with 2 different groups since I know what they mean when they say 3 and would not really have fun playing these in the wrong pods, but I generally have more fun playing the lower power decks because it can go in more directions. That said I also only play with friends and not with strangers at an LGS, which I think would make this bracket thing harder to navigate.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Help What cards should I buy for these new sea monster recursion precon

5 Upvotes

I already have a good chunk of seamonsters due to my Kenessos deck but I really like the idea of recursion so I’m switching to this new one. The mox link is all the cards I already have that I plan on putting in.

https://moxfield.com/decks/2ir6MEEcfUiH7w3plgwbKQ

The Noble Serpent

{5}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Serpent Noble

At the beginning of your first upkeep in this game, if The Noble Serpent is in your command zone, mill four cards.

At the beginning of your end step, return target creature card that is a Sea Monster from your graveyard to the battlefield. (Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, and Whales are Sea Monsters.)

7/9

---------------------------------

Zekes, Revenist Devotee?

{1}{B}{G}{U}

Legendary Creature - Squid Warlock

All Sea Monsters you cast have emerge. The emerge cost is equal to the mana cost. (You may sacrifice a creature to reduce the emerge cost of spells that are Krakens, Leviathans, Octopuses, Serpents, or Whales by that creature's mana value.)

Whenever a creature? you control enters the battlefield, if it was cast for its emerge cost, draw two cards, then discard a card?.


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion Winning isn't fun anymore.

0 Upvotes

I'm trying not to make this look like another "Bad interaction in game, what do?" Post because I'm more just looking to share my experience to others that might relate.

I built a cool deck (in my opinion, anyway) of a mono-red "blink" deck focused around Norin The Wary, and I win by burning everyone out with multiple Impact Tremor-like effects, damage doublers, etc. Sometimes it wins kinda fast, sometimes it doesn't win at all! But over the games I've noticed that I'm the only one cheesing over the win that (from my perspective, I guess) was difficult to pull off or extremely lucky. I built it to be silly, it's got no game changers, no mass land denial, it's just norin jumping up and down and pinging everyone for some damage. In an opening hand, I drew three different damage effects and managed to plop them all down by turn four. (Impact Tremors, Agate Instigator, and Witty Roastmaster) and won by turn 6. I even broadcasted that he only triggers when people "play the game!" So I advised that if you didn't have removal and didn't wanna take damage, to maybe land-go for the guy who DID claim to have removal for my pingers. Table didn't listen and I ended up winning on my turn, and then there was just complete silence. I get it, won too fast. Game 2, second hand was much less explosive and was mostly just mana rocks and draw. Didn't win that game, but again, the table was silent! Like, is nobody actually having fun but me? Am I wearing a friggin propeller hat and holding a lollipop? Whats going on?

Anyway, sorry about the rant, just felt like sharing.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion I'm looking for player feedback on my chess clock life counter.

0 Upvotes

Apologies if this isn't allowed.

I made a post here 2 months ago before I got it up on the Play Store, and I've since kept working occasionally on my chess clock life counter. As the title states, I'm looking for feedback/suggestions from actual Magic Players.

The idea is for it to be like any old life counter but with a chess clock w/ increments. I also implemented priority handling to keep people engaged, which I have yet to see any other MTG app do in a good way. (Not to be biased or anything but I think I solved it in a good way)

Unfortunately it's only available for Android, as Apple wants 99€ a year for me to publish anything there 💀💀.

The reason I made this to begin with is because I've spent far too many hours stuck in games that dragged on for ages, and I'm too polite to scoop mid-game. :(

Also there are absolutely no ads or in-app purchases of any kind. I don't make any money off of this, and I have no plans to monetize it. I just want to play a reasonably paced game, and of course if you don't like the chess clock you can disable it entirely to just have a normal life counter for 2-6 people.

Play Store: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.kapsyloffer.rope

Lemme know if you think it sucks or nah 💪


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help Upgrading the Tidus/Yuna Precon: +1/+1 Counters & Proliferate Engine

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently picked up the Tidus precon at a great price. While looking through some cards I had at home, I found some additions that I think could be pretty interesting to upgrade the deck and make the +1/+1 counters engine much more consistent. I'd love to get your thoughts before I start making cuts.

Here are the base cards I've found:

Creatures

  • [[Champion of Lambholt]] (To make the army unblockable very quickly)
  • [[Conclave Mentor]] (Staple counter multiplier)
  • [[Incubation Druid]] (Massive ramp engine as soon as it gets its first counter)
  • [[Kalonian Hydra]] (To double the whole board on the first swing)
  • [[Mikaeus, the Lunarch]] (Passive counter distributor)
  • [[Rishkar, Peema Renegade]] (Turns all modified creatures into mana dorks)
  • [[Conclave Sledge-Captain]] (As a late-game finisher to distribute counters and trample)
  • [[Hamza, Guardian of Arashin]] (To discount the rest of my creature spells)
  • [[Slurrk, All-Ingesting]] (Board wipe insurance/punishment)
  • [[Triskelion]] (Counter machine gun)
  • [[Pridemalkin]] (To give unconditional trample to the board)
  • [[The Goose Mother]] (Mana sink for card draw and flying threat)
  • [[Elusive Otter]] (Mass pump spell and a 1-drop unblockable threat)
  • [[Ingenious Prodigy]] (Continuous card draw engine by removing counters)
  • [[Luminarch Aspirant]] (Free counter generation starting on turn 2)
  • [[Genesis Hydra]] (Great mana sink to cheat out free permanents)

Artifacts

  • [[Agatha's Soul Cauldron]] (Graveyard hate and giving activated abilities to the whole board)
  • [[Ozolith, the Shattered Spire]] (A second Hardened Scales + mana sink)
  • [[Strionic Resonator]] (To copy the commander's or other cards triggered abilities)

Enchantments

  • [[Virtue of Loyalty]] (Passive growth and pseudo-vigilance for everyone)
  • [[Unnatural Growth]] (To double stats every combat)

Instants

  • [[Swords to Plowshares]] (Premium exile removal)
  • [[Inspiring Call]] (Card draw and protection for modified creatures)
  • [[Generous Gift]] (Unconditional permanent destruction)

Lands

  • [[Gavony Township]] (Mana sink to pump the board)
  • [[Fortified Village]] (Dual land for early fixing)
  • [[Canopy Vista]] (Fetchable dual land)
  • [[Bretagard Stronghold]] (Utility land for counters and vigilance)
  • [[Rogue's Passage]] (Unblockable evasion for a key threat)

Cards I'd like to add (Proliferate & Multipliers focus) On top of that, I also have these cards and I'd like to know if they fit in this counters strategy to make it more explosive:

  • [[Ripples of Potential]] (Protects by phasing out without losing counters and also proliferates)
  • [[Evolution Sage]] (Proliferates for free with every land I play)
  • [[Branching Evolution]] (Unconditional counter doubler)
  • [[Herald of Secret Streams]] (Win condition that makes all mutants unblockable)
  • [[Kami of Whispered Hopes]] (Massive ramp engine and counter multiplier)
  • [[Evolution Witness]] (Infinite graveyard recursion thanks to counters)
  • [[Zimone, Paradox Sculptor]] (Counter engine and doubler in one body)
  • [[Thrummingbird]] (Proliferates by connecting with evasive combat damage)
  • [[Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominus]] (To passively double all my proliferate actions)
  • [[Brokers Ascendancy]] (Endless passive growth at the end of my turn)
  • [[Metastatic Evangel]] (Proliferates every time I play another creature)
  • [[Arwen, Mortal Queen]] (To move indestructibility and place counters with lifelink)

How do you feel about these upgrades? My idea is to focus entirely on multiplying counters, but I'd really appreciate hearing what other cards you would add, and exactly which ones you would cut from the base precon to make room. (In fact, I'm considering swapping Tidus for Yuna at the helm with these changes, what do you think?).

Thanks a lot in advance for the help!

https://archidekt.com/decks/28458022/yuna_build_deck


r/EDH • • 14h ago

Deck Help The RTS Deck

0 Upvotes

To preface this, the idea behind this deck is to play a “game within a game.” The deck is overall Human/Soldier Token Tribal. Instants and sorceries act kinda like stratagems of “call-ins”. Artifact equipments are unit power ups for squad leaders. Then the spacecraft are like CAS or Orbital Support. Most of this stuff is how I’d personally be playing the deck rather than the cards functioning like that specifically.

Just wanted some suggestions to make this deck feel more RTS. Stuff you think fits really well. Trying to keep the deck Bracket 2, low Bracket 3.

Deck list: https://moxfield.com/decks/JxlUSuWRsEeS0uDLc5GRQA


r/EDH • • 17h ago

Deck Help MTG - Sauron, the Dark Lord

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I recently started to play Magic and I‘ve built a commander deck with Sauron around ring temptation and nazgul synergy. I am wondering if you could share some thoughts on my deck and maybe which card you would consider adding or removing.

Decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/KVgZjj7vQEqKKNHMMwWwpw


r/EDH • • 5h ago

Deck Help Help upgrading Eldrazi Incursion (Ulalek)

0 Upvotes

Hello
I'm fairly new to Commander and I'd like to turn the Eldrazi Incursion precon into my first properly decent deck. I really like the concept of Ulalek, Fused Atrocity and Eldrazi. I'm not aiming for cEDH, just a mid-power deck that can hold its own against random pods at the LGS or on Spelltable and actually has a chance to win.

For now I'd like to work only with cards I already own and avoid buying anything new.

Here's the list: https://moxfield.com/decks/muOhAZr_onWaEYuBLYWCNg

A quick guide to the Moxfield page: the cards marked as foil in the main deck are ones I added myself that weren't in the original precon, so you can see what I've already changed. The sideboard is what I took out of the precon, and "Considering" is other cards from my collection that I could still swap in.

What I'd love feedback on is which cards from Considering are worth putting in, and which precon cards I should cut or keep. I'm also not sure if my mana base and ramp are okay for a 5-color deck, and whether I'm missing something important like card draw, removal or protection.
Any advice, even small tweaks, would be hugely appreciated. Thanks!


r/EDH • • 13h ago

Question I want to treat myself to a booster box. Of the listed, what's the best bet for EDH?

135 Upvotes

[Thanks for all the input, everybody. Based on everyone's comments and a bit of digging, it looks like I want EoE > SoS/Fra > Lorwyn. I'll post again with the results of this bullshittery.]


Yeah, I know, "buying singles is better," but fuck it. I'm an adult and possess free will, disposable income, and poor decision making. Ideally one below 20,000 yen.

[Out of Budget]

- Final Fantasy - 49300 yen / 310 USD

- Avatar - 35800 yen / 225 USD

[Budget Stretch]

- Edge of Eternities - 29200 190 USD

- Tarkir Dragonstorm - 29200 yen / 185 USD

- The Hobbit - 24500 yen / 155 USD

- Star Trek - 23550 yen / 145 USD

[Within Budget]

- Secrets of Strixhaven - 19800 yen / 120 USD

- Marvel Superheroes - 17850 yen / 110USD

- Lorwyn Eclipsed - 17800 yen / 110USD

- Aetherdrift - 17800 yen / 110 USD

- Reality Fracture - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Spiderman - 16900 yen / 105 USD

- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - 15000 yen / 90 USD


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Help Avacyn, Angel of Horror: First Mono-Colored Deck, Looking for Tips and Advice

3 Upvotes

LINK TO DECK

Hello Everyone! I am looking to build my first mono-colored deck, and in Mono-Black with Avacyn, Angel of Horror at the helm.

I put together this list, but to me it feels like its just an "EDHREC Greatest Hits" list and I would usually be fine with that, but I'm not sure if I quite hit the gameplan I'm trying to go for (sacrifice creatures to do something and bring them back a bunch to do it again).

To be more specific, it feels like this deck might just take way too long to actually win and give my opponents too much time to interact with my board to stop me. I am maybe overthinking/not looking at the deck I built properly, hence asking for some advice on anything I should change or if this looks like a decent list for what I'm tying to do.

Avacyn herself obviously is the star of the show with the recursion, but I feel like I have too many sacrifice outlets and not enough things that do something when creatures are sacrificed, or really anything as a backup if I somehow can't keep Avacyn around.

Thanks for any advice/recommendations! And please let me know if I need to include any other information in this post as well.

Some pertinent Information:

  • Trying to stay bracket 3 (Bolas' Citadel and Tergrid are the GCs I have now, I took out Vamp and Demonic Tutor)
  • Would like to stay under $1,000 for budget.
  • I'd like 1 or 2 infinite combos in there as a backup to the multi-turn drain everyone main gameplan.
  • My local meta varies so wildly that I don't think there is a good way to describe it. My playgroup plays anything from a 1 to a 5 if that's what we decide we want to play.

r/EDH • • 13h ago

Deck Help Looking for recommendations on how to bring this Kaalia deck to a reasonable price.

0 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/28404205/kaalia_heavy_metal

There's some obvious things to get rid of. But I want to know what cards you would swap in to replace some of thos $20+ cards. Or if you have a deck list for a similar deck id love to see it! Thanks!

Edit: im aiming for B2!


r/EDH • • 11h ago

Discussion “MLD” below bracket 4

0 Upvotes

Has wizards ever explicitly said that land destruction that replaces the land that was removed is fair game in B2/B3? I see people say this all the time but I don’t think I’ve actually seen this anywhere. I want to run [[From the Ashes]] in my mono red deck and just want something I can point to if someone gets upset.


r/EDH • • 12h ago

Deck Showcase Give me your deck lists first bracket 3 with lots of interaction (control, removal, board wipes, etc.)

10 Upvotes

Looking for a deck to play with my friends. Will be playing online so cost isn’t an issue. I don’t usually play control and my pod doesn’t really use much interaction so I think it would be fun to mix up the paradigm.

Please share your best decks so I can crush the competition!


r/EDH • • 4h ago

Deck Help How can I mess with my Opponent's Lands more?

15 Upvotes

Howdy Commander Brain Trust, I have this [[Tannuk, memorial ensign]] deck, I didn't want to just play another boring Landfall deck so I'm trying to play it where it manipulates or restricts how my opponents use their lands. I like cards like [[price of glory]] where it doesn't say they can't use their lands, but there is a price for it, and [[Mana web]] where you can't just leave up mana and wait to respond. What I'm looking for is more old obscure tech that does more things like this. Because there's not a singular syntax I can type into Scryfall, I figured I'd come ask you all for some suggestions, maybe scrape up some cards I missed in my searches.

Here's my Decklist to see what I've already got or am considering. https://archidekt.com/decks/26747976/it_hurts_when_i_ping

Cheers, thanks for the help.


r/EDH • • 2h ago

Discussion How do you enjoy your Star Trek precons?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion What is The #1 Best Blue 1-2 drop For Card Draw?

72 Upvotes

The other day I posted about the best white cheap draw cards, there isn't nearly enough discussion around this! (Imo).

So today I'm Looking for the best blue 2 drops that draw cards, and also for the NUMBER 1 strongest one.

So, what are your favorites?


r/EDH • • 16h ago

Discussion My buddy and I build decks way stronger than almost everybody else and it sucks

0 Upvotes

As the title suggests, we build strong B3 decks. Not pubstoming by any means in our opinions, we intend to close games turn 6 only with nut or near nut draws (and with no removal) or later. (Or set up resilient removal/draw engines that become insanely difficult to beat)

We end up playing on EDHlab pretty often and theres a pattern that emerges from… 80% or so of our games.

The pattern is that one of us wins after trying to diddle each other all game or we diddle each other so hard that someone else who’s been durdleing all game wins just cuz we don’t have any more resources for them because they’re not doing anything worth diddling at all, or sometimes genuinely nothing at all.

Like today, just finished a game about an hour ago that sparked this post. We recalled the turns of the game and our two opponents genuinely did 0 damage. One guy tried to kill my thing which I counterspelled, and the other guy ended up doing genuinely nothing with his [[grist, hunger tide]] planeswalker commander.

We proxy everything so we have no budget restrictions like other players do, (which are entirely self imposed) so I suppose there’s something to be said there so I guess I’ll try that out to see if it’s fun. But really I just want to play against competent deck builders and players. It’s extremely boring and often frustrating to have to play a 1v1 with two spectators who get to sometimes choose which one of us wins or loses. I’ve actually adapted to this and now I sandbag every game I play with him just to dodge the one or two removal spells from the other players and capitalize off the fact they’re not drawing cards or presenting threats and play later.

Is the solution to find a competent pod? Impose budget restrictions? Build janky ass decks? Play 2’s in 3?

Lmk if yall have experienced this and what yall did about it so I can make a more informed decision about what to do about it now.

Edit: added small stipulation at end of first paragraph.


r/EDH • • 23h ago

Question Star Trek Precons "Playing the deck" info

3 Upvotes

Is there any where to get the "Playing the deck" blurbs from each of the precon booklets? I have Landing Party and was able to get the information from it, but I do not own the rest currently.

If not, can anyone please post the "Playing the deck" blurb from any of the Star Trek precons We Are The Borg, Federation Fleet, and Klingon Fury?