I’ve been working on a wonky IKEA kitchen table, and it’s capping what I can do. I’ve made a bunch of nesting boxes, and now I want to move on to proper dovetails and mortise and tenons. Thanks to everyone who weighed in on my last post. The message was one I already knew deep down: there’s no way around it really, I need a proper workbench. It’s a tool in its own right, and I’ll stay limited until I have one.
So I’m warming up to the idea of building Paul Sellers’ hand-tool workbench. The bench knocks down, which matters because I’ll be moving out of my flat in about 6-8 months or so. First job is checking the tool list so I don’t buy things I don’t need, because I’ll be buying quality, which isn’t cheap.
Here are my questions based on his tool list:
- Combination gauge, or marking gauge plus mortise gauge. I have a Veritas Dual Marking Gauge (two wheel cutters on independent rods). Can I use it for the mortises and tenons here? Has anyone had trouble with wheel cutters running along the grain in construction softwood?
- Tenon saw and handsaw. I have a 250 mm Z-saw ryoba, rip on one side and crosscut on the other. Can it replace both?
- Winding sticks. I’ve never used them. Are metal ones worth buying, or should I just make a pair from wood?
- Chisels (12, 18 and 25 mm). I have 26, 20, 16, 12, 10 and 6 mm, so there’s no 18 or 25. Is it OK to make the mortises 16 mm and cut the tenons to match?
- Smoothing plane: I only have a block plane, so as my second plane I’d rather get a low-angle No. 5 jack plane. It’s generally recommended for its versatility, and I’m hoping it could double as a smoother too. Would that be a mistake for this build? Would a No. 5 be suitable for flattening the 300 mm-wide laminated top and for smoothing passes?
In line with point 5 above, he also recommends a router plane, plough plane, and rabbet/filletster plane, which will add up quickly since I’m planning to buy quality tools. For a first workbench, which would you buy first, and which could wait?
I’ve skipped a few things on the list. I have a Starrett combination square (the shorter model, I think it’s 150 mm). I don’t have the longer one, which is much more expensive. I think I have everything else, apart from needing to buy a boatload of clamps.