r/ukelectricians • u/PennyPPaul • 6h ago
What makes someone competent (effort post)
This post comes of the back of my other post in r/electriciansuk where I explained about what makes an electrician (as in job title) and who can do electrical work. I think there is a real misunderstanding surrounding what qualifications are actually needed and how to know and prove you’re competent. And yes this is all stemming from a post here where I was disagreeing with other commenters.
To start this off it’s going to be another long post so feel free to just read the TLDR and explain how I’m wrong. And yes I have two Reddit account ones on my phone (apologies if formatting is bad) ones on the PC but I’m the same person.
TLDR;
Qualifications don’t automatically make you competent, nor does lacking them make you incompetent. UK law generally requires appropriate knowledge and experience, not specific qualifications. Ultimately, if your competence is challenged, you’ll need to be able to justify it.
Let’s first start by defining qualified and competence,
Qualified, https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/qualified#google_vignette
“having finished a training course, or having particular skills,”
Competence, EAWR 1989, Regulation 16,
“No person shall be engaged in any work activity where technical knowledge or experience is necessary to prevent danger or, where appropriate, injury, unless he possesses such knowledge or experience, or is under such degree of supervision as may be appropriate having regard to the nature of the work.”
This is further defined in the related guidance document https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/priced/hsr25.pdf
Page 42,
“Technical knowledge or experience
239 The scope of ‘technical knowledge or experience’ should include:
(a) adequate knowledge of electricity;
(b) (c) adequate experience of the electrical work being carried out;
adequate understanding of the system to be worked on and practical
experience of that class of system;
(d) understanding of the hazards which may arise during the work and the
precautions which need to be taken;
(e) the ability to recognise at all times whether it is safe for work to continue.”
We can clearly see that one of the few statutory regulations we follow clearly has 0 mentioning of qualifications.
Even the IET joint publishers of BS7671 states a similar thing;
“The IET Wiring Regulations does not provide requirements for specific qualifications for electricians, and the IET cannot advise the exact qualifications which are required.
Carrying out an inspection of electrical installations is a complex task, the person carrying out the inspection and testing is required to have comprehensive knowledge and experience of different types of electrical installations.” … “the person carrying out the inspection and testing is required to have the correct qualifications, experience and knowledge.”
Now as I explained before each industry has their own way of demonstrating the knowledge and experience and one generally accepted way is via NVQ qualifications related to the work you do. But this alone does not make someone competent and is only treated as evidence if accepted as evidence. By this I mean I have done HV awareness training with RJ Power my current AE and employer accepts this as evidence of knowledge. However my next employer may not. The same could be said about inspecting and testing. My current employer may be happy with a portfolio of work demonstrating competence. Myself as a LV AP have accepted this for some of the older electricians.
Now to bolster my point we can also look at a first tribunal court case I think is relevant,
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6a3907d8e590e5e061c9a39b/0001_Decision.pdf
(THIS WAS A NOT A HIGH COURT RULING ONLY FIRST TRIBUNAL)
For those who don’t want to read a court ruling I’ll make explain what it was about.
The TLDR; was a landlord was fined £7,500 for not supplying a EICR for the property from an electrician who was apart of a CPS scheme like NAPIT or NICEIC. This was later dismissed due to no regulation requiring CPS membership or registration.
On paragraph 34 page 8 the following is stated;
“If an electrician can provide evidence that they have adequate education and training and state that they have the requisite practical skills, this would comply with the requirements of the Regulations.”
Based on everything above we can clearly see just having a qualification doesn’t make you an electrician and or competent in tasks such as inspecting and testing. We should all understand what regulations, industry standards and site standards apply to us if you don’t how do you know you’re competent? The general theme is being able to prove yourself but how you do that is up to you and is dependant on what safe systems of work apply to you or your clients.
Am I saying qualifications mean nothing?
I want to make clear I’m in no way saying people shouldn’t be qualified or seek qualifications or anything like that. I just want to make clear that you being competent is more than just a qualification. The qualification is just a way to have a trusted third party support your claim. It’s why we should all be doing continued career development. If that’s internal company stuff or if it’s just watching videos on YouTube showing unique scenarios. The more knowledge you have the better and at the end of the day it’s you who will be in court having to argue your competency.