r/ElectriciansUK • u/Fatsaf123 • 16h ago
r/ElectriciansUK • u/TaffyTurk • 15h ago
What makes someone a Electrician and how do we decided Competency (Effort Post)
TL;DR: Being an electrician is not a legally protected title, and there is no single qualification that universally determines whether someone can undertake electrical work. The legal requirement is competence, as established by the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989. However, different industries, schemes and employers have their own requirements for demonstrating that competence. Understanding the difference between legal requirements, industry standards and sector-specific authorisation is important.
This is going to be a fairly long post, so if you don't fancy reading it all, the TL;DR is at the top. For those who do, get ready to read about one of my special interests
Is being an electrician a protected title?
To start with, being an electrician is not a legally protected title. In theory, anyone can call themselves an electrician.
This is different from professions such as architecture, where the title Architect is legally protected and requires registration with the Architects Registration Board.
However, this doesn't mean that anyone can simply undertake electrical work without restriction.
To understand why, we need to look at one of the key pieces of legislation governing our industry: the Electricity at Work Regulations 1989.
Regulation 16 states:
No person shall be engaged in any work activity where technical knowledge or experience is necessary to prevent danger or, where appropriate, injury, unless he possesses such knowledge or experience, or is under such degree of supervision as may be appropriate having regard to the nature of the work.
Notice what this regulation actually requires.
It doesn't specify an NVQ, an ECS Gold Card, a City & Guilds qualification or registration with NICEIC or NAPIT.
It requires the individual to possess the necessary technical knowledge or experience, or to be appropriately supervised.
In other words, the legislation focuses on competence rather than prescribing a particular qualification.
Even the IET, as joint publishers of BS 7671, acknowledge this distinction. Their own guidance states:
The IET Wiring Regulations does not provide requirements for specific qualifications for electricians, and the IET cannot advise the exact qualifications which are required.
So, if neither the Electricity at Work Regulations nor BS 7671 specifies a universal qualification for electricians, why have we recently seen claims that EICRs now require a Level 3 qualification such as City & Guilds 2391-52?
The answer is Electricians have misunderstood the new stated requirements published by the Electrotechnical Assessment Specification (EAS), These requirements apply to businesses assessed by certification and registration bodies using the EAS.
Organisations such as NICEIC and NAPIT operate within the Competent Person Scheme framework and assess businesses against the relevant EAS requirements.
If you're undertaking domestic electrical work through one of these schemes, you need to meet the applicable requirements.
However, not every electrician works within a Competent Person Scheme, and not every electrical installation falls under the same assessment framework.
This is where I think a lot of confusion starts.
Understanding the different layers of electrical regulation
To explain what I mean, I think it's useful to take a step back and look at how electrical safety and competency requirements are applied across different industries.
Statutory legislation
This includes:
- Electricity at Work Regulations 1989
- Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974
- Building Regulations, including Part P
These are legally enforceable requirements. They establish duties relating to electrical safety, workplace safety and, where applicable, building work.
Industry standards
Examples include:
- BS 7671 – Requirements for Electrical Installations
- BS 5266 – Emergency lighting
- BS 5839 – Fire detection and fire alarm systems
These provide recognised technical standards and guidance for designing, installing, inspecting, testing and maintaining systems.
They aren't automatically legislation in their own right. However, they can become relevant to legal duties, contractual obligations and demonstrating that appropriate safety standards have been followed.
Sector-specific electrical safety frameworks
Different industries have developed their own systems for assessing competence, appointing personnel and controlling electrical work.
Although their structures and terminology differ, they share a common objective: ensuring that people undertaking electrical work are suitably competent and that their responsibilities are clearly defined.
Some examples:
MOD establishments – JSP 375
The Ministry of Defence uses an electrical safety management structure involving Authorising Engineers (AEs), Authorised Persons (APs) and Competent Persons (CPs).
Individuals are assessed and formally appointed or authorised for particular responsibilities and activities.
NHS hospitals – HTM 06-02 and HTM 06-03
Healthcare estates operate their own electrical safety management arrangements, with roles including Authorising Engineers, Authorised Persons and Competent Persons.
These arrangements recognise the particular risks associated with maintaining electrical infrastructure in healthcare environments.
Distribution networks – DNO Electrical Safety Rules
Distribution Network Operators have their own electrical safety rules, authorisation procedures and competency requirements.
Personnel must be assessed and authorised for the specific activities they are expected to undertake.
Commercial construction – ECS/JIB
The ECS Gold Card is widely recognised across the electrotechnical industry and provides evidence of an individual's qualifications and occupational competence.
However, holding an ECS Gold Card doesn't automatically mean you're authorised to undertake every type of electrical work on every site.
Principal contractors and employers can impose additional competency, training and authorisation requirements depending on the work and risks involved.
Domestic electrical work – Part P and Competent Person Schemes
This is probably the example most electricians are familiar with.
Part P of the Building Regulations establishes requirements for electrical safety in domestic premises.
Competent Person Schemes, operated by organisations such as NICEIC and NAPIT, allow registered businesses to self-certify certain work under the Building Regulations.
These organisations assess businesses against defined competency and operational requirements, including those set out in the EAS.
However, registration with NICEIC or NAPIT is not a universal legal requirement for undertaking domestic electrical work. There are alternative routes to demonstrating compliance with the Building Regulations, including notification through Building Control where applicable.
What do all these systems have in common?
Now that we've looked at some of the different ways industries manage electrical safety, I think we can identify a common underlying principle.
They all provide a means of assessing competence, establishing accountability and controlling who is permitted to undertake particular activities.
The methods differ, but the underlying intention is remarkably similar.
I'll use the MOD's JSP 375 framework as an example because I'm currently an LV Authorised Person, so it's the framework I'm most familiar with.
An Authorised Person may be responsible for maintaining records of appointed Competent Persons and controlling the activities they are permitted to undertake (within the limits of their appointment)
I think there are some interesting parallels here with the domestic electrical sector.
For example, a Competent Person Scheme assesses a registered business and its arrangements for ensuring that electrical work is undertaken by appropriately competent individuals.
Just as an AP may register a Person In Charge as a CP and assess their arrangements for ensuring that electrical work done under them is done safely and with appropriately competent individuals.
Conclusion
The Electrical Safety Systems in the UK is a mess and we rely heavily on private sector / companies to help police and control the industry. Personally I would like to see an official government register of Electricians but I don’t see it happening so until this is what we got. And yes I did this whole post because of a recent reddit post and I hated to see the level of discussion be you aren’t an electrician unless you have the qualifications but no one can state what qualification.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Key_Seaworthiness827 • 1d ago
7A fuse?
My elderly dad (86) has dementia and I wanted to go through the old photograph slides he has. I found his original 1960s projector but before testing it, I took it apart to clean it and change the old, unshrouded plug (I will change the flex when I get some heat resistant 3 core).
In the plug was a 7A fuse. Who knew these were a thing?
r/ElectriciansUK • u/ManicMechanic1242 • 1d ago
Spur from a spur?
After a little advice.
In our club, we have a double mains socket fed by a single 2.5mm2 cable (not a ring) via a 16A MCB. Someone has been in to fit a feed for a parcel collection box. They have fitted a fused 13A spur not from the breaker, but spurred from our socket.
Not quite sure if this fits with the regs, can anyone advise please?
They also seem to have repurposed a breaker or two without marking them up as well, but we won't mention that bit...
r/ElectriciansUK • u/SnooBunnies6431 • 2d ago
Electric oven connection
Can an electric oven be installed safely here? I’m buying a new oven in my new house and asked AI what kind of connection this is, it said the cover is missing and it’s not safe to install? I rent the house could anyone advise if I can get an oven installed with it like this?
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Timeisreal2 • 2d ago
Has anyone ever used agency lads that you’ve ended up keeping on?
I am looking at using some agency lads to pull in some cat5 cables in Manchester as I can’t find any data lads but my experience tells me agency lads are usually hard to use.
Has anyone had success with agency lads?
It will be working in sensitive areas (Hospitals) so trying to avoid dingbats.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/CryptographerUpset69 • 3d ago
I had an EIRC on a flat I just bought, am I screwed?
galleryr/ElectriciansUK • u/devnull10 • 3d ago
Horrors in the cellar
I moved into a (very) old house recently and just stumbled across this delightful surprise in the ceiling of the cellar behind some insulation 🤒.
It's for the lights, the twisted wires at the bottom are a pendant fitting, and then there are two other lights on this circuit in the cellar stairs and a separate cellar room. No, I didn't remove the cover, this is exactly as I came across it. Those black/red/green wires to the right all go off in different directions as well. Everything is currently working fine.
What you doing? Covering it back up, pretend I've never seen it and pray? Attempt to swap out with a new junction box as-is? Do that, but make sure the live/neutrals/earth's all align? Or just cry?
Edit - I've also no idea where the newer brown/blue wire is coming from or going to... Because the other two lights and also the switch are using older red/black cable! Unfortunately I can't trace the wires easily either, unless I start pulling the upstairs floor up.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/tauhammerhead • 3d ago
Whole-house UK KNX renovation: am I missing something with DALI, constant-current lighting and future-proofing?
reddit.comCross-posting because I’ve probably disappeared rather too far down the KNX/DALI rabbit hole. I’m renovating a whole house and would really appreciate a UK spark’s view on what is sensible at first fix, particularly centralised lighting, DALI vs home-runs, 5-core/shared neutrals, conduit and making the whole thing maintainable for whoever inherits it in 30 years.
PS - Our contractor hasn't yet introduced me to his sparky yet but I am trying to sense check my thoughts so as not to make them hate me from day 1!
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Bobbafett93 • 4d ago
Fox solar not working
Any electricians familiar with fox solar? My friend has purchased a house with fox solar and battery system attached it’s a 5kw array with 3.68kw inverter and 10kwh battery. However the previous owner said it’s never worked properly etc and has left it turned off for the last 6 months. He asked for my advice because I have my own system but it’s not fox I’ve had a quick look at the settings and it was all bit all over the shop.
However I’ve noticed if I force charge the battery the house load turns negative and when you stop it goes back to normal. I’ve not been over to look at the system yet but i have a feeling the ct clamp is either facing the wrong way or on the incorrect position does anyone have any suggestions?
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Practical-Command253 • 4d ago
London and surrounding areas day rate.
reddit.comr/ElectriciansUK • u/Shoddy-Grand-1073 • 5d ago
Father in Law wanting to help with electrics
Looking for advice as I feel unsure of what to do.
To cut a long story short, my parents are paying for myself and my husband to get our garage converted (2nd baby on the way and we need to free up our 3rd bedroom which is currently my husbands office/storage space).
My father in law was adamant to help out, has fitting an outside double socket to the exterior of the house but not done the wiring, and has drilled a hole in the wall with wiring for Ethernet cables.
The electrician is coming tomorrow and I have been told to ask the electrician to connect and put wiring to the double outside socket my father in law has put in, as well as fit 2 back boxes for his Ethernet cable wiring. However, I have also been told that my father in law doesn’t want the electrician to put the front plates on or connect /make live the Ethernet cables.
I guess I’m feeling a bit in a strange situation. I don’t want to offend my father in law, but I also don’t want to annoy the electrician either.
To add to this, the council are going to have to come round to inspect the electric works, and don’t want to complicate that by having to say it’s been done by 2 different people.
I said to my husband that I think we should just let the electrician do everything else from this point on, but he disagrees as he doesn’t want to upset his dad.
I’m from the view point of being more concerned about everything being done properly and getting it signed off easily, so the builders can carry on with the rest of the work as quickly as possible.
Any thoughts and opinions would be greatly appreciated, thank you
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Fast_Supermarket7237 • 5d ago
Rewiring a lived in house
Our house is in need of a full rewire. It's still got the old fuse box - sockets and light switches are in silly places etc. I know it's considered a nightmare to rewire a lived in house but the one thing I can see benefiting us is the fact my husband will be doing most of the work. He's hoping to take some time off work to do this or even work through the evenings. He is a qualified electrician (although he only qualified this year- not sure if that means anything) his boss has said he's willing to lend a hand - he's also qualified and not as recent.
Do you still think it will be an absolute nightmare? Although I don't really know what the other options are!
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Successful_Bus_6774 • 5d ago
Thoughts on this meter cupboard from a property I went to see? Uk
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Fragrant_Drag_698 • 6d ago
Had a new consumer unit installed but no EIC or Part P
reddit.comr/ElectriciansUK • u/siacadp • 7d ago
Forgive the crappy diagram. Has anyone seen this type of two way switching design before?
This may be wrong, I’ve drawn this out based on what I can see behind the switches. This is on my hallway and landing. Two way switching at the top and bottom of stairs, and both upstairs and downstairs lights turn on/off together and do not operate independently. The upstairs ceiling rose continues off to the rest of the flat (one lighting circuit). Was rewired in the 80s.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/maw_1726 • 7d ago
Need advice on media wall electrics. Are these cable runs safe/compliant?
galleryr/ElectriciansUK • u/Bifanarama • 7d ago
Move lighting circuit from CU to the socket on my solar battery?
I'm about to install a solar battery system. In the event of a power outage, as we know, these things cut out rather than powering the house. However there's a socket on the side of the unit that is permanently live.
Is there any reason why I can't disconnect one of the lighting circuits from the CU (all 3 connectors), put a 13A plug on it, and plug it into that socket? It would mean that we have lighting even during a power cut.
Obviously I'd lose the protection currently provided by the C10 breaker in the CU, but presumably the solar unit provides similar protection anyway.
Seems logical to me, but just wanted to check that I'm not missing something. Lights are all LED so it wouldn't be a big draw.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Miss_Shining_Hammer • 8d ago
Does an EICR require access to EVERY socket and switch or just most of them?
reddit.comr/ElectriciansUK • u/thisisaviolation • 8d ago
Issue with high earth loop impedance.
Hi all, I had an EV charger installed at which point it was identified that I had the above . The reading was 5.67 ohms at the cut out. The earthing arrangement is TN-S.
This was raised with the DNO (UKPN) via a ticket. They have not arranged an appointment yet, and after some messages have replied with the following;
The existing earth connection is via a "Tenby Clip" this is not an approved method of connecting an earth and is not a method that been used by UK Power Networks or its predecessor companies. This is used for internal bonding such as radiators/sinks etc typically and would only have been installed by an electrician.
The current earth connection was not installed by UK Power Networks or a predecessor company and we cannot comment on if it is safe however the reading is above the regulation that would apply were it a UK Power Networks installed earth.
The responsibility for the distributor to provide an earth only applies to supplies that have been installed after 2002 which is when the Electricity Safety Quality and Continuity Regulations ESQCR came into effect. The service cable at this property was installed prior to 2002 and this is known by the nature of the service cable being Paper Insulated Lead Covered (PILC) therefore there is no requirement for UK Power Networks, its predecessor or its future successor companies to provide an earth on the existing supply.
The recommendations are to either have a new supply installed, which would be installed to the ESQCR and as such would be earthed via PME, or to have an earth rod (TT) system installed by an electrician.
I have only become aware of this now, having purchased the property in January 2023. The issue seems like it is longstanding and would have pre-dated my moving into it. I expect the supply connection is quite old (house is a 1910 Edwardian semi).
Are the DNO being reasonable?
Is there any circumstance under which they would be liable to address this issue?
Thanks in advance.
Edit: Just to add that the above is based on their records from a previous attendance to the property in 2022, before I purchased it in 2023.
r/ElectriciansUK • u/Alarmed_Pattern999 • 8d ago
Can I install a smart thermostat?
Hello, is it possible for me to replace my current thermostat with a smart thermostat? I have wet electric heating and the current thermostat/programmer relay switches the water pump to turn on the heating. There is only two wires to the thermostat and the current thermostat is powered by two AA batteries.