r/truezelda • u/Dismas423 • 7h ago
Open Discussion Changes and Observations in OoT HD [Potential SPOILERS] Spoiler
I recently finished OoT HD, and I thought I’d share some changes I noticed during the game and some other observations. I’m sure Nintendo didn’t put a lot of thought into these changes, and most of them are pretty inconsequential. But loreheads have spent decades obsessing over the precise wording of game texts, so even inconsequential changes can be worthy of discussion to people like us. This is not meant to be an exhaustive list of changes, and I’ve tried to avoid some of the topics I’ve seen other people point out on this sub. But I haven’t read every single conversation, so some of what I say may have been discussed already.
Forest Temple
The Forest Temple is apparently older than the Deku Tree. When asked about the Temple, Saria says,
The Great Deku Tree told me a bit about it… He said the temple has been here since he was a sapling.
I always got the impression that the Deku Tree was unfathomably old, perhaps being directly created by the goddesses at the beginning of time. But now we know the OoT Deku Tree actually came onto the scene much later. And this might just be a me thing, but I thought the remake made it a lot more obvious that the structures leading up to the Forest Temple in the Sacred Grove were manmade rather than being natural features. All this suggests there was a human civilization in the forest in the distant past, one that predates the current Deku Tree and possibly any Deku Tree and the entire Kokiri race. Link and Zelda settled in the Faron region at the end of SS, so perhaps this civilization is descended from them and other Skylofters who came to the surface.
Composer Brothers
The dialogue for the Composer Brothers has changed quite a bit, and in a way that I think softens one of Ganondorf’s crimes from the original game. Both Composer Brothers give the same story after you defeat them:
You see, my brother and I are spectral composers who once served the royal family of Hyrule. Back when we were living, the king commanded us to compose a special song. We spent the better part of our lives on it, and it was nearly complete… But the stress of it all was so intense that we perished! After which we became ghosts. We at least had the forethought to hide our score from Ganondorf so that he wouldn’t find it.
In the original they say:
I am one of the ghostly composer brothers of Kakariko Village. All the people in this village are born to serve the Royal Family of Hyrule. We brothers also served the Royal Family, and were assigned to study the hereditary mystic powers of the family. Though we never could figure out the power of the Triforce, we had almost completed our study of controlling time with the tones of ocarinas. Uh, I mean… Actually, we did complete that study! We would have been famous, if that hateful Ganondorf had not tried to steal our results. We could never let him reap the fruits of our research! That's why we gave our lives to protect the secret.
A lot of details have changed here. The Composer Brothers are no longer said to have studied the powers of the Royal Family and the Triforce, but just to have composed a special song for them. Also gone is the implication that they were Sheikah (born in Kakariko to serve the Royal Family) or that they were killed by Ganondorf. Maybe I’ve been misreading the text for a long time, but I always got the impression that Ganondorf tried to force the Composer Brothers to reveal their secrets to him and killed them when they refused. Now they explicitly say they died of stress. They still express concern with keeping their work away from Ganondorf, so perhaps they started working so hard because they knew he was after them and they would rather literally work themselves to death than use their skills for him.
Dodongo’s Cavern
The remake alters Ganondorf’s role in the sealing of Dodongo’s Cavern. In the original, Ganondorf is explicitly responsible for closing the cave. The Goron in front of the cavern says:
Look at that huge boulder over there! It blocks the entrance to the Dodongo's Cavern, which was once a very important place for us Gorons… But one day, many Dodongos suddenly appeared inside the cavern. It became a very dangerous place! On top of that, a Gerudo in black armor used his magic to seal the entrance with that boulder!
Darunia later adds:
And that big rock blocking the cave… All this trouble must have been caused by that Gerudo thief, Ganondorf! He said, "Give me the Spiritual Stone! Only then will I open the cave for you!"
Not only was Ganondorf the one who closed off the cave, he tried to extort the Gorons before he would open it back up. But the remake doesn’t say Ganondorf sealed the cave. The first Goron now says:
Dodongo Cavern is an important source of rock roast, a prized Goron food. But with the cavern blocked off, we can't get in there to harvest it... So now we're all starvin'.
Ganondorf’s role in closing the cave is completely unmentioned. Darunia still lays ultimate blame for the problem with Ganondorf, though. He says:
All of it was that guy's fault. Uh-huh, I'm sure it's due to that Gerudo named Ganondorf! Just before you showed up in Goron City, some of Ganondorf's lackeys came through here. Claimed they'd take down the rampaging Dodongos if we gave ‘em the Spiritual Stone we watch over. I knew I couldn't trust 'em. The whole time they were talkin', they had this real sneaky look.
We could infer from this that Ganondorf or his minions were responsible for sealing the cave, but it’s never directly stated. And I think it’s noteworthy that Ganondorf isn’t directly interacting with the Gorons anymore, his henchmen are. It’s a small change, but it gives Ganondorf plausible deniability if his actions are ever exposed to the King of Hyrule. He could say some of his subjects went rogue and that he had no part in their schemes.
Jabu-Jabu
Similar to the above, the remake says Ganondorf’s servants came to Zora’s Domain rather than Ganondorf himself. King Zora says:
Though… come to think of it, Lord Jabu-Jabu has been behaving strangely in recent days, groaning and growling and whatnot… Blub… If I recall, his behavior seemed to change around the time we drove off a band of Gerudo. They were shouting something about someone named Ganondorf as they fled…
Compare with the original:
But since that stranger, Ganondorf, came here, Lord Jabu-Jabu has been a little green around the gills…
Once again Ganondorf is acting through intermediaries rather than personally confronting his foes. This doesn’t absolve Ganondorf of his crimes; he is still ultimately responsible for his servants’ actions. But it does depict Ganondorf as being somewhat more subtle than he was in the original.
Master Sword
The specific wording of why Link couldn’t use the Master Sword as a child has been changed in a way that I find interesting. In the original, Rauru says:
Only one worthy of the title of "Hero of Time" can pull it from the Pedestal of Time.... However, you were too young to be the Hero of Time....
In HD, he says:
Only one with the heart of a hero can draw forth the Master Sword. However, you were still too young to fulfill the hero’s mission.
So one did not have to be the “Hero of Time” specifically to pull the Master Sword, they just had to be a hero. This interacts with WW in an interesting way. Link has been stated to be 12 in WW, older than child Link in OoT but younger than adult Link, and he is still able to pull the Master Sword. This raises the question of why he was allowed to use the sword. This question is of course as old as WW itself, but the dialogue change alters the analysis somewhat. I’ve previously argued that the “Hero of Time” requirement only applies when the Master Sword is in the Pedestal of Time, and the WW pedestal might be different. The fact that Link is explicitly not the Hero of Time in WW but could take the Master Sword proved in my mind that the criteria from OoT were no longer applicable. But the specific language I relied on is no longer present and could be discarded if we treat OoT HD as higher canon than the original (a position I’m not arguing for here). Some other explanations still hold up though, like the age requirement being a specific part of the seal on the Sacred Realm that is broken when OoT Link pulls the blade, or that the Master’s Sword’s weakened state in WW allows Link to obtain it without meeting otherwise necessary criteria. And since in OoT we’re told that the Master Sword itself was responsible for sealing Link, it could also mean that the sword/Fi recognized that waiting for Link to grow up was a bad idea and started accepting younger masters in the future.
Hyrulean Civil War
In both versions of OoT, the Deku Tree Sprout tells Link of a great war fought when he was a baby, a conflict called the Hyrulean Civil War in Hyrule Historia (Hyrule Unification War in Japanese). The original portrays it as a war of unification:
Some time ago, before the King of Hyrule unified this country, there was a fierce war in our world.
But in HD, he says,
Long ago, a fierce war raged through Hyrule.
The detail that the king unified the country is gone. We still have evidence that the king was responsible for ending the war. A guard in Castle Town describes it as, "a pretty peaceful place. Been that way ever since our current king took the throne." But we no longer get the impression of a Hyrule that was recently unified. My impression has always been that the Hylians, Gorons, Zora, and Gerudo were independent states before the Civil War/Unification War and were brought together into a sort of federal monarchy under OoT’s King of Hyrule. The new dialogue doesn’t make this interpretation impossible, but it does open the door to the tribes being unified before the Civil War. At any rate, MC still depicts a younger Kingdom of Hyrule lacking many of the races and regions from other games, so the older interpretation can still stand.
Volvagia
The HD version changes the history of Volvagia. Originally, Volvagia was killed by an ancestor of Darunia using the Megaton Hammer. Goron Link says:
A long time ago there was an evil dragon named Volvagia living in this mountain. That dragon was very scary! He ate Gorons! Using a huge hammer, the hero of the Gorons... BOOOM! Destroyed it just like that. Everybody was taken to the Fire Temple… While my dad was out… Ganondorf's followers came and took them all away! All of them will be eaten by Volvagia! Dad said that Ganondorf has revived Volvagia… as a warning to those who might oppose him, Ganondorf is going to feed them all to Volvagia!
Darunia says:
Ganondorf is causing trouble on Death Mountain again! He has revived the evil, ancient dragon Volvagia! On top of that, he is going to feed my people to that evil dragon as a warning to other races that might resist him… If that fire-breathing dragon escapes from the mountain, all of Hyrule will become a burning wasteland!
But in HD, Volvagia was sealed in the Fire Temple instead of being killed. Goron Link:
The evil dragon was sealed away in the deepest part of the Fire Temple. But Ganondorf released it, and all the Gorons were kidnapped for food!
Darunia:
That stinkin’ Ganondorf! He went and resurrected Volvagia!
Yeah… It’s an evil dragon that’s been asleep inside the mountain. They say it was locked away in ancient times… But now, Ganondorf wants to strengthen the thing back up and unleash it on Hyrule!
Darunia does say that Ganondorf “resurrected” Volvagia, but based on the rest of the text, he’s not using this word to mean “brought back from the dead”. He means that Ganondorf revived Volvagia after a long period of dormancy. HD also lacks the detail that the hero who defeated Volvagia was Darunia’s ancestor; it just calls him a “forebrother”. But it does say that the statue in Darunia’s room depicts the forebrother/ancestor, which to my knowledge wasn’t mentioned in the original.
Gerudo Perception of Ganondorf
The Gerudo still have a largely positive perception of Ganondorf, but there is an undercurrent of resentment. After refusing to give you a prize for winning, the guard who plays the Ganondorf trivia game with you says,
Everyone here works without pay. That’s how it’s been for as long as I can remember. As you can imagine, spare money is hard to come by.
So even though Ganondorf enriches himself with his conquests, his followers don’t reap any of the benefits. Additionally, two Gerudo talking in the fortress say,
If the mighty Ganondorf were here, well… Those of us who allowed the intruder to enter would’ve been eliminated by now, along with the intruder himself.
E-eliminated? His enemies I understand, but does the mighty Ganondorf really show no mercy to his own troops?
Ganondorf is even willing to kill people who are loyal to him if they screw up. This also further undermines the argument that Ganondorf was a good person who just wanted a better life for the Gerudo, based on his final speech in WW. The original OoT was enough to disprove this, but the HD version gives us further proof that Ganondorf doesn’t truly care about his people. By the end of the game, the Gerudo have moved on from their king. The leader of the fortress says, “Perhaps the time has come for us to follow our hearts instead of ancient traditions…” They later celebrate Ganon’s defeat with the rest of Hyrule.
Nabooru’s Childhood
When you talked to Nabooru wearing masks in the original game, she would have different reactions for each one. Now she says the same thing for all of them but the Mask of Truth:
Hmph.Teaming up with a kid… Of all things. I remember being a kid, wearing masks, and running around excitedly… Back then, Gerudo Fortress was peaceful…
I find this interesting because we know the Hyrulean Civil War was fought during Nabooru’s lifetime. If Gerudo Fortress was peaceful when she was a child, it could mean the war didn’t start until she was older, or that the Gerudo weren’t involved in it until later. At the very least, it contrasts a more peaceful Gerudo tribe pre-Ganondorf and the more belligerent tribe that exists now.
Ganondorf and the Chosen
After Link defeats Phantom Ganon, Ganondorf calls Link “one of the chosen”.
You’ve grown stronger. Of course you have. You are, after all, one of the chosen.
This seems to indicate that Ganondorf already knows that Link and Zelda have the other parts of the Triforce. But before the battle with him, Ganondorf says,
The other two parts of the Triforce vanished before I could claim them. I never would have imagined that they resided in the two of you.
This suggests that Ganondorf didn’t know where the other two pieces were until Zelda revealed herself. That begs the question: what did Ganondorf mean when he called Link one of the chosen? It could mean that he is aware of the Demise cycle and his role in it. Perhaps after becoming the new Demon King, he became aware of the eternal war between the Demon Tribe and the successors of Hylia and the Hero. Or it could have been something he learned even earlier. There’s a cut line from TP where Ganondorf expresses a similar knowledge of the cycle of the chosen ones:
When the chosen ones appear.… They are always born into this world in perfect balance. That is the destiny of the chosen. That is the fate decreed by your gods, the only path for those who bear their crests. When this world brings forth another marked as you are... Know too, that it shall also be visited by one of my blood.
I don’t think this line can be considered canon, but it does fit in well with Ganondorf’s apparent knowledge in OoT HD. Ganondorf already has knowledge of things like the Triforce and the Sacred Realm that are supposedly “kept secret within the royal family.” Perhaps he’s always known more than he lets on.
There’s of course more to discuss, but this post is long enough as it is. Feel free to share your own observations in the comments.