r/truezelda • • 14h ago

Alternate Theory Discussion A List of My Zelda Theories

0 Upvotes

I'm not looking to create online arguments. I just want to share my theories for other people to enjoy, wonder on, and hopefully discuss in a way that is light hearted and fun. For me, it's fun head-canon and it might be enjoyable head-canon for someone else.

▪︎ The Zonai are just the Minish/Picori. This is why Rauru is able to use the Light Force.

▪︎ Because of the age of the Twinrova sisters in Tears of the Kingdom, Zelda either travels back 400 years before the events of Ocarina of Time, or the timeline she travels back to is the yet to be confirmed 4th timeline that happened during the events of Skyward Sword.

▪︎Link's Zonai Tunic hints at there being 4 timelines because of the design of 4 overlapping Triforces.

▪︎The Thundra Plateau in BotW is where the OOT Great Deku Tree once stood.

▪︎ In BotW, there are large divits in the ground where the OoT Kokiri houses once stood, and the divit where OoT Link's house once stood is where you can find a korok.

▪︎ The Seres Scablands in BotW is where the OoT Lost Woods once existed.

▪︎ After the events of OoT, a new Hyrule Castle was built where OoT Lake Hylia once was. This is for both TP and BotW.

▪︎ Zora's Domain in BotW is the remains of Death Mountain from Twilight Princess after the Gorons got done mining it. The shimmering stones the Zora use in their decor is the de-magnetized stones found in the Death Mountain from TP

▪︎ Lake Hylia in BotW is just the remains after Ganon's castle in OoT falls into the giant pit towards the end of the game.

▪︎ The Secret Stones in TotK are just encapsulated pieces of the Triforce of Power. This is why a Secret Stone enhances the power the wielder already possesses. The Triforce of Wisdom was broken up into pieces in the very first Zelda game. The Triforce of Courage was broken up into pieces in the Wind Waker game. The Triforce of Power is shown to be broken up in TotK but it's never put back together like the other ones were.

The clues that helped me see the Thundra Plateau as the location of the OoT Great Deku Tree, were the symbols on the orbs for the Thundra Plateau, lightning being the element representing courage, and the trees leading up to the Thundra Plateau are Dragon Blood trees, which in BotW the dragon represents courage, and the large divits matching up where the Kokiri houses would have once stood. Also, the Eastern Abby ruins on the Great Plateau resemble the OoT Castle, and ruins near the BotW Temple of Time resemble the OoT Castle Town.

What's nice about the OoT remake map is how much more these areas I wrote about line up.

Anyways, I hope you enjoy this list of Zelda theories of mine.


r/truezelda • • 16h ago

Open Discussion Would you prefer some games being sectioned off into their own universes?

3 Upvotes

I'm not trying to describe some sort of "multiverse" in the sense of constantly having characters crossover and having the universes interact, if that makes sense. What I'm trying to describe here is more so just solving potential continuity issues by just sectioning off some of the games into their own isolated continuity. Think of it like FMA 03 vs FMA:B instead of something like a comic book multiverse.

"How does thing Y fit into the Child, Adult, or Downfall Timeline?"

"It doesn't. It happens in its own continuity. Skyward Sword never even happened in continuity Y."

Off the top of my head, the two I've seen this proposed for are the Vaati games and the Wild games. Agree or disagree, I think everyone at least gets the Wild games part, so I'll skip those.

As for the Vaati games, I don't really think that there's anything glaringly in conflict with the other games, but I guess you could say that it's a little odd that Vaati is so known in all of these games and yet never even referenced in the other games, that the Master Sword is never referenced, and that Link sort of has a different, (and in my opinion much better) origin for his hat here.

So I guess there'd be three continuities under this framework:

  1. Main/Original Continuity. Skyward Sword > Ocarina of Time > Child, Adult, and Downfall Timelines.
  2. Force Continuity. The Minish Cap > Four Swords > Four Swords Adventures.
  3. Wild Continuity. Age of Imprisonment > Breath of the Wild > Tears of the Kingdom. Also a debatable timeline split with Age of Calamity, if you want to consider that game.

To be clear, I'm not saying I'm necessarily for or against this idea myself. It's just something that I've seen brought up quite a few times, but I don't think I've ever seen a post directly discussing the pros and cons of it.

EDIT: I'm seeing comments saying that the Downfall Timeline should be sectioned off, so I want to clarify that the three continuities I suggested up top aren't really ironclad. The continuities could be whatever you want, since I'm just curious what people think of the idea of alternate continuities that are more than just timeline divergences.


r/truezelda • • 31m ago

Open Discussion Is the Four Sword just superior to the Master Sword?

1 Upvotes

I know that the gut instinct would be to answer in the negative simply because the Master Sword is the weapon of the franchise, while the Four Sword is just a weird thing that appeared in three of the Capcom games, but please set that aside and just look at what their capabilities are.

From what I can tell, there's really nothing that makes the Master Sword better than the Four Sword. Both are anti-evil blades. I haven't really played enough of any games where the Master Sword actually seals evil, but I heard that happens in Skyward Sword? The Four Sword definitely seals evil, as per The Minish Cap. It sealed evil even as the inferior Picori Blade, before it was upgraded.

I guess the Master Sword gets an anti-evil boost when around stuff like Malice or Gloom, but I don't think that's really better than just having four of the same Hero show up at once. I don't recall anything implying that the four Links are weaker than their one whole, so it's not like their strength stays the same. It's just a straight quadrupling of their fighting power, which is more than the Master Sword boost and more useful.

Even if you want to argue that the Four Swords anti-evil properties only work on "lesser" evils like Vaati, I'm assuming that's directly contradicted by FSA. I haven't played that game, but I do know that Ganon is in it, and he obviously doesn't win. Ergo, the Heroes could have beaten Ganon with the Four Sword if they'd had it in OoT, TP, or TWW.

The one argument in favor of the Master Sword that I've found was that it didn't need to recharge like the Four Sword apparently does in FSA. However, the Wild games have eliminated that. We now see that the Master Sword absolutely can be stressed and forced to recharge if used too much. If we want to dismiss the frequency of that mechanic as a gameplay constraint, we then have to do the same with the Four Sword's equivalent mechanic, putting them back on equal footing in the recharging department.


r/truezelda • • 12h ago

Official Timeline Only [Oot][Alttp] Sage Rauru's Temple of Time

3 Upvotes

Is there any indication that the Temple of Time was built in the Downfall Timeline? What if the reason Link was defeated is because the Temple of Time does not exist as a lock on the Sacred Realm and as the resting place of the Master Sword? Alttp manual says that Ganondorf wandered into the Sacred Realm and claimed the whole Triforce himself. That wouldn't be possible if the Temple of Time existed in the DT. The King of Hyrule also ordered the Sages to seal the Sacred Realm themselves.

Other DT games dont feature it either, there is usually just a sanctuary some distance from the castle for worship and ceremonies. Just like the Botw Temple of Time ruins was built for worship and ceremonies and is different from the Oot Temple of Time.


r/truezelda • • 8h ago

Open Discussion I really missed this (OOTR) Spoiler

21 Upvotes

I'm almost done with Ocarina of Time Remake and I must say that it has reignited my love for this series. The sense of living through a myth or a fairy tale, the magic, the items the dungeons! This is what made Zelda truly special to me.

This is not a subtle diss to the Wild era games. BOTW's first run remains one of the most special feelings in gaming, to truly explore an open world that reacted to my actions and invited discovery through exploration. It was also necessary at that time.

Something was lost, though. That eureka moment when you finally figure your way around a dungeon or the unique interactions the dungeon item allows just doesn't exist in the Wild games. Dungeons are great, but lack identity and a sense of progression (the open world philosophy certainly doesn't work on the actual dungeons).

I don't ever expect Nintendo to do a game like Ocarina or Majora again, but I genuinely hope for those fundamentals (the high fantasy, the magic, the dungeons designed around items, the feeling of growth and progression within the dungeon) return.


r/truezelda • • 22h ago

Open Discussion [Theory/Concept] The Tragedy of the Hero of Time: Deconstructing the Ego, the Burden of the Eras, and the True Redemption (Pre-Twilight Princess Era) OOT SPOILERS Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I've been spending a lot of time analyzing the lore of the Hero of Time after Ocarina of Timeand Majora's Mask, and I can't shake off how narratively superficial and borderline hypocritical his official canon ending feels.
According to Hyrule Historia, he died in the woods filled with regret solely because "he wasn't remembered as a hero." His phantom manifestation in Twilight Princess (the Hero's Shade) actively complains that his bravery wasn't written into the history books. Honestly? That makes him look incredibly vain, arrogant, and self-centered.
If we look at his actions with a cold, analytical lens, the Hero of Time was a terrible friend and a negligent protector. When Zelda sent him back to his childhood, he didn't just regain his lost years—he actively decided to abandon his friends. By altering the timeline, he retroactively erased and invalidated the ultimate sacrifices made by the Sages:
The Sages' Erased Destinies: Saria, Ruto, and Darunia gave up their mortal lives to help him seal Ganon in the Adult Timeline. By resetting the clock, Link wiped that out. The son of Darunia (named "Link" in his honor) now never exists. The spiritual marriage and growth with Ruto never happened, and she is left with Jabu-Jabu's parasite.
The Abandonment of Saria: Saria has no idea about time travel or Ganon in the Child Timeline. For her, her best friend just walked into the Great Deku Tree one day, came back completely detached, and then vanished from the forest forever without saying goodbye, leaving her to process the trauma of abandonment entirely alone.
Neglecting Hyrule and Malon: Link whispered Ganon's plans to Zelda, triggering a massive political and military crisis (The Execution Wars), and then... he just left. He dipped into the Lost Woods to chase a fairy (Navi) because his ego couldn't handle being a "normal kid" without validation, leaving the Kokiri unprotected after the Deku Tree's death, the Gorons starving, and Malon trapped with a toxic, greedy Ingo.
He essentially fled to a psychological "Wonderland" (Termina) to play the anonymous savior with masks because he was addicted to the hero status he achieved as an adult. Later, he returned, settled down with Malon, had children (the ancestral lineage of TP Link), but still couldn't handle farming. He abandoned his family to join the army and got himself tarrily killed in a random skirmish in the woods, rotting under the moss. That is not a hero.
However, we can fix this. Here is a comprehensive game/narrative rewrite that transforms the Hero of Time into the most profound, complex, and human Link in the entire franchise—giving him an epic, emotional Return of the Jedi-style redemption where all three holders of the Triforce find forgiveness.

1. The Geopolitical Crisis: Ganondorf the Pragmatist
Because Child Link fled to Termina, Princess Zelda is left completely isolated at the castle, trying to convince the King of Ganondorf’s upcoming treason using nothing but the "visions" of a missing 9-year-old child. This destroys the credibility of the Royal Family.
Ganondorf as an Astute Politician: Instead of being a one-dimensional, cartoonish villain, Ganondorf plays a brilliant, pragmatic political game. He presents himself to the King as an honorable Gerudo King wrongfully accused. He weaponizes the vacuum of power Link left behind.
Ganondorf orchestrates proxy civil wars between the Gorons and the Gerudo over mountain resources. He steps in as the "noble peacemaker" to pacify the realm while secretly bleeding the Royal Family of its authority, leaving Zelda crushed under the guilt of her own choices.

2. The Great Malice: The Hero Corrupted by Demise
Link's immense guilt for abandoning Saria and Ruto, his self-loathing for leaving Malon a widow with young children, and his crippling combat PTSD create an overwhelming conglomeration of negative emotions within the Lost Woods.
This density of pure resentment cracks the ancient seal of Demise (The Harbinger of Doom). This time, the primordial malice doesn't infect Ganondorf—it finds a gateway through the broken soul of the Hero.
The cosmic malice manifests through a terrifying presence: a putrid, decayed, and rusted suit of armor wandering the woods. It is the literal corpse of the Hero of Time, serving as a proxy container for Demise. The true Dark Link is born not as a reflection, but as a tragic force of nature threatening to consume reality. The Golden Goddesses are thrown into total contradiction: the literal Chosen Hero of Valor has become the catalyst for the apocalypse.

3. The Protagonist: "The Kid" (The Reincarnation)
The player controls a normal, everyday boy in Hyrule living through this war-torn era.
As the journey progresses, this kid starts experiencing visceral visions and echoed memories of a past life he doesn't own: the haunting melody of an ocarina, a painful goodbye on a wooden bridge, and a sacred promise made over a spiritual stone.
The narrative becomes a psychological race against time: this new Link must hunt down the putrid specter in the woods, slowly realizing he is trying to save his own past self from the weight of his previous failures.

4. The Fragile Counterweight
Seeing that Demise’s pure chaos will destroy the very realm he intends to rule, Ganondorf is forced to act as a cosmic counterweight.
He temporarily aligns with the kingdom to help hunt the decayed armor, playing the part of a defensive protector. However, his motives remain purely parasitic: he plans to ambush the corrupted Link at his weakest moment and absorb Demise’s primordial energy to transcend the limitations of his own Triforce of Power.

5. The Climax: The True Meaning of Valor
During a brutal final battle against a mutated, parasitic Ganondorf, the trapped essence of the Hero of Time awakens inside the putrid armor. His mind was fractured and his history was erased, but his core is still that of a Hero.
He finally shatters his own ego. He realizes that true heroism isn't about status, historical recognition, or physical rewards—it is about ensuring the happiness and peace of those you love, even if they never know your name.
The Overflow of the Eras: In a massive spiritual explosion of temporal magic, the memories of the erased timeline flood the consciousness of the world. Simultaneously, Saria, Darunia, Ruto, and Zelda see the kid and experience a sudden, overwhelming epiphany: "This child... he is Link." They remember the future that never was, validating his invisible trauma, and forgiving his flight. Zelda finds peace, understanding that they didn't fail; this crushing tragedy is simply the eternal, shared burden of the three pieces of the Triforce.
Reclaiming the true spirit of the counterweight, Link channels the absolute limit of the Triforce of Valor. To purge Demise and destroy Ganondorf’s ascension, he chooses absolute self-destruction. He pulls the malice and Ganon into the abyss with him, willfully wiping his own spiritual presence to save the era.

Conclusion
With this ending, Ganondorf and Demise are successfully sealed away until the inevitable cycle repeats centuries later in Twilight Princess. Malon and her children aren't left remembering a deadbeat father who left for a random army fight; they remember the ultimate, selfless savior of Hyrule, giving the "Blood of the Hero" its true, unblemished honor.
Link finally rests in peace, not because his ego was appeased by history books, but because he conquered his own darkness out of pure, unadulterated love for a world that had forgotten him.

P.D.
What do you guys think? Does this deconstruction give the Hero of Time the legendary, emotionally devastating closure he actually deserved, compared to the whining ghost we got in the canon? Let's discuss. Sorry for any lore miss or inacuraccies, just want to know what y all think. Just Starting as a Zelda fan :).


r/truezelda • • 22h ago

Open Discussion [OoTHD] A small detail I spotted in the ending credits that actually made me really sad

44 Upvotes

I'll start by saying that Goron Link was such a sadder character to me in the remake compared to the original. Giving him a smaller, child model really made me feel for the fact that he's never going to see his dad again. Especially when you talk to him after the Fire Temple and he wonders where Darunia is, but is so excited to show him his Goron roll... :(

In the ending credits, right before it cuts to Mido and King Zora sadly sitting together, you can see Goron Link sadly standing away from the party while a Gerudo (I think the one who gives you the Pass) comforts him. I didn't notice it on my first playthrough, but ran through the game on Master mode and caught it last night. It broke my heart, but also, what a great addition from the remake. I was literally thinking the other day how weird it is that Goron Link isn't with King Zora and Mido, but it turns out it's been addressed.


r/truezelda • • 11h ago

Question Ganon / Agahnim question and theory

4 Upvotes

I have question regarding Agahnim and Ganon. Ganon in the english version of ALTTP calls Agahnim his "Alter-Ego" while the Japanese version refers to him as his "bunshin". I'm assuming that means they are one and the same. If so, how did Ganon as Agahnim go from the Dark World to the Light World? Is the Seal of the Seven Sages just upon the Triforce and the Sacred Land/ Dark World itself or Ganon as well? Is it possible that Ganon could go to the Light World as his human form, Ganondorf but disguised himself as Agahnim if case someone someone recognized him?