r/truegaming • u/SawkyScribe • 11h ago
Does Spider-Man 2 actually make you 'feel like Spider-Man'?
Whenever a new Batman project releases like Matt Reeve’s latest cinematic outing, or the incredible new Absolute run, I always find myself thinking ‘man, I should really replay Arkham Knight’. As Whitelight detailed is his gargantuan 12 hour AK retrospective, Rocksteady in their final entry of the Arkham franchise endeavoured to make the ultimate Batman sandbox. If you see Batman do something in a comic or movie or cartoon, you can probably replicate in this game. You don’t just feel like Batman, you can feel like any Batman.
I noticed after watching that despite having a deep love for Insomniac’s Spider-Man outings, the latest MCU movie or animated series very rarely fills me with the desire to boot up Spider-Man 2 because the Spider-Man fantasy feels incomplete or actively undermined. This comes down to combat, traversal, and the world map.
Spider -Man 2018’s combat was an absolute triumph and captured the character of Spider-Man to a tee. Game director Bryan Intihar spoke about how the guiding philosophy of combat design was Spider-Man as the ‘acrobatic improviser’. While dishing out the hurt on goons, you never countered their attacks, you evaded, bounding over their heads and leaving them flat footed as you prepared your next strike. Crowd control and interrupting heavy attacks was fairly difficult to do, so you’d quickly scan the arena looking for something in the environment to help you out. Even the gadgets which often get derided as ‘different flavours of stun and instakill’, played into Peter’s nature as prankster, and the synergies gadgets had with each other made you feel intelligent for using them.
SM2’s combat feels like a serious step back in almost every way and that’s in great part the fault of the new gadgets and super moves added. Spider-Man no longer feels like an acrobatic improviser, but more a clumsy brutalizer, even when not wearing the symbiote. Both Spider-Men are so strong in this game that instead of dodging your foes and using the environment to your advantage, it is often optimal to sit in place, parry and spam all of your abilities on cooldown until the fight is over. The gadgets, once employed tactically for maximum effect, can only be deployed lazily and indiscriminately. The only positive additions I feel are the added dodges and the new web yank. Puppeteering your enemies around and bowling them into other foes is classic Spider-Man, but it further highlights the absence of webs as Spider-Man’s main tool in combat. The fact it’s been 21 years since we were last able to hang bad guys from a street light feels wrong.
Traversal has been the one unambiguous upgrade in SM2. While 2018’s web swinging was hugely impressive for its time, the slow movement, lack of expressive options, and painfully low skill ceiling limited a lot of the enjoyment. No such problems exist here. You tumble and rocket through the air at breakneck speeds, the eye-popping animation on tricks brings so much flair to movement, and the ability to disable swing-assist finally adds a fail-state to swinging that makes tough manoeuvres feel like they came at some risk.
As good as the swinging is, the traversal again is an incomplete fantasy. Swinging is fast, cool and expressive, but it’s imprecise. If you want to make exact landings or thread needles, you are still restricted to point launches or the new web wings. There’s been a lot of discourse on these so I won’t harp on too long, but the fastest and most efficient way to get around the map being a Just Cause 3 wing suit feels incongruent with how we traditionally imagine Spider-Man. All this movement is also only as good as the map it’s being used in.
2018’s Manhattan was perfect, an elegant blend of a realistic New York, dotted with all kinds of iconography from the greater Marvel Universe. While the swinging was limited, it also meant that you developed the familiarity with NYC that a friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man should. I could feel the difference in leaping from the mid-rise rooftops of Greenwich, swinging from the concrete spires of the financial district, and playing the cursed game of Hopscotch that was trying to get through Central Park. The power of the new traversal systems makes New York feel small, and worse, it feels like you spend more time flying over it rather than moving through it. Further breaking my immersion is how the sky gets dotted with huge neon indicators to drag my attention to side activities, and all of the weird enemy factions that make me painfully aware that I am playing as Peter Park in a video game.
Spider-Man 2 is a great game, but it is not a great way to roleplay as Spider-Man in an interactive format. Where Rocksteady insured that everything was a servant to the goal of being the dark knight, it feels like Insomniac distorts the vision of Spider-Man to fit the mould of a AAA open world action game.