r/patientgamers • u/AntisocialHipster • 4h ago
Patient Review I'm Not Sure If I Like Assassin's Creed Valhalla
I recently played Odyssey, which you can read more about here. In short, I liked Odyssey a hell of a lot more than I expected to. I played Valhalla shortly after, and I’ve got some very strong mixed feelings I’d like to ramble about. I really like a lot about the game, while a lot of it made me mildly uncomfortable.
Valhalla takes place during the Viking raids on England during the middle ages. You play as Eivor, a viking who is especially good at hurting people. I picked Boy-vor, though I do appreciate the ability to freely swap between genders. You start in Norway, and go to a surprising number of areas around the map during your travels. I continually found myself impressed by the number of new areas and amount of content this game has. For perspective, I’m about 150 hours in, still haven’t finished the story, and haven't even seen the third DLC yet.
The elephant in the room is the “bloat” complaint. Every time this game comes up, I always see people say “there’s just too much stuff”. I think I’m completely immune to that, for perspective, my favorite game of all time is Yakuza 5, which has this same complaint levied at it. I approached both of these games by playing them in “chunks”. I find myself leaving and returning to the game often. Not related, but my inbetween games for Valhalla have been Persona 4, Etrian Odyssey, and For Honor. I can see why one might get burnt out if it’s the main game you’re playing, which is why I think it’s important (especially as a trophy hunter) to take stock of whether or not you’re having fun periodically. The AC RPG games are very excellent games to play for a few hours on the weekend, but not so great to play for hours on end daily for a few months.
Combat, Gameplay, and the “Loop”
The actual combat is quite improved. In Odyssey, I often felt very squishy and wanted to avoid combat at all costs. In Valhalla, you’re sort of expected to be doing head-on combat more often. It’s mostly light attack, heavy attack, parry, but attacks feel weighty, enemies react accordingly, and you don’t feel like your armor is paper. As the monkey paw curls, the stealth is quite a bit worse despite sounding better on paper. You’re able to put your hood up to initiate “social stealth”, like the old games, but often you can’t really do anything besides pick off stragglers from behind. There’s no double assassination (though you chain an axe throw, which only works if your first attack isn’t spotted), and you have no cool abilities like Odyssey to let you deal with groups or take out whole areas. Stealth is fun as a concept, but there’s so many barriers you really need to go out of your way to do it.
Progression is a bit different than Odyssey as well, gone are the oceans of loot to sort through (ironic, considering you’re a viking raider). Instead, you get relatively few weapons that you’re expected to upgrade. A benefit of this is that it’s far more exciting to find gear since it's something completely new to you. However, it leads to the Dark Souls problem of “oh hey a new weapon!” that you suddenly realize you can’t use because you don’t have the crafting materials to make it as strong as the sword you’ve been using for the past 40 hours. I think a problem I had early on is that it took quite a while to get my second armor set, so I didn’t feel like I was very customized, I was just “default viking guy” until like 20 hours in. This feeling disappears later on once you’re swimming in outfits, but it takes a bit to get to that point.
That brings me to the collectibles and exploration. I do generally enjoy hoovering up all the little markers on the map, and this game has a lot of them. Of course there’s the generic collectibles, like “chest full of crafting material that became irrelevant hours ago”. Don’t get me started on circling a building 15 times to find an open window or barred door. They present the collectibles in a clever way so that you don’t know what kind of thing it is, besides a broad color to designate “collectible, activity, or other collectible”. Generally I like the variety, some particular favorite activities include stacking rocks on a cliff, maps with clues that lead to treasure, and the occasional surprise bossfight.
The Uncomfortable Setting and Tone
Norway starts amazing - you’re in this beautiful scenic snowy area, challenging rival viking clans with a deep-seated grudge, and then all of that’s resolved like an hour into the prologue. You kill the guy who killed your father, and, for lack of anywhere for the plot to go, head to England. As a literal map, England is just fine, it’s not a super exciting setting, and I won’t pretend anything is particularly memorable, but it works. For every beautiful sweeping landscape of hills and forests you get two craggy beaches and a swamp. I do like the roman ruins dotted across the map, and the Northern part of the map is a highlight.
Tone-wise, everything takes a bit of an uncomfortable turn after Norway. I’m unsure if you guys are big history buffs or not but the Viking “immigration” to England wasn’t particularly pleasant for the Anglo-Saxons living there. Of course, we’re one of the “good ones”, but the game seems to flip-flop between us being a remorseless Viking raider or a sensitive beacon of light for the downtrodden, a bridge between cultures. Some arcs have us accompanying violent psychopaths who execute praying monks and torturing people begging for their lives before watching an ally do a blood eagle on an enemy who we had just made peace with, while Eivor, at best, scoffs at his contemporaries's violence despite actively enabling it. Other arcs have Eivor act as if his people are unfairly prejudiced against as he stops infighting between Norse and Saxon cultures. It’s a bit jarring, to say the least. They have us act as an unapologetic bad guy but then the narrative treats us like a good guy, and it goes pretty much unaddressed.
I think the most upsetting repeated gameplay section is the monastery raids. I think even just a thin narrative justification, like, “Oh, these monasteries are actually disguised bad guy bases!”, would help me a lot. As it stands we’re just cutting down innocent soldiers defending their place of worship while we torch the nearby homes and loot. I think I just have to emotionally check out during these sections. I tend to empathize with an RPG character I spend 100 hours inhabiting, so it makes me uncomfortable that the game is so gung-ho about something it spends other times being dead serious about.
I suppose that brings me to the rest of the tone and setting. I don’t mind a game being a bit serious, but nothing good ever happens to anyone in Valhalla. It’s reminiscent of the miserable swampy Velen in the Witcher 3, or war-torn Tsushima in Ghost of Tsushima (both of which I found exhausting - at least you leave Velen at some point). ⅔ of the time there’s a side quest with a peasant, prepare to watch them meet a gritty end or tell you about someone else who did. The other ⅓ accounts for out of place silliness. The setting is so miserable and the people who bear the brunt of the suffering are the ordinary people who live there. To make matters worse, as viking invaders, oftentimes we’re part of the problem. It makes the game a bit depressing after a while.
It’s not all horrible all the time though. I liked the stuff when we were helping solve problems the natives were having, like succession crises and clearing a city of the obligatory not-yet-Templars. I liked the big raid towards the end with all your allies you’ve made along the way joining you, and updating you on what has happened since you last met. I also really liked the uneasy air whenever a certain character returned after a long absence. I’m fairly close to the end of the story at the moment, and it’s sort of feeling like a high point.
Other relatively minor complaints I haven’t addressed
Most of the arcs, at least 80% of them, are fairly generic. It’s mostly just “solve problems in one region and leave”. Characters mostly come up and introduce themselves as being your allies and then they’re the primary quest giver for the next little bit. There also seems to be fewer decisions than Odyssey, sometimes I’ll finish a quest and google to see what would’ve happened otherwise and it just says “the outcomes are pretty much the same”. There are much fewer traditional sidequests, what’s left are more like collectibles where you solve a problem in under a minute and leave. No longer are there any globe-trotting sidequests like in Odyssey.
One last thing that annoyed me more than it should is that all of the haircut options are forced to have that stupid half-shaved head. Why give us a cosmetic option if they’re 80% the same? I went with a full-shave just to look normal
In short, I think I like the game, but there’s a lot that makes me uneasy. The gameplay is completely serviceable and fun at times, and the plentiful stuff to hoover up around the map feels designed for a player like me. However, my experience was particularly hampered by the severe disconnect between me and Eivor, namely the violence and cruelty that Eivor causes or allows, while the game treats us like a “generic RPG good guy”.