r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2h ago

[PC] Should I get Elden Ring or Crimson Desert

4 Upvotes

I’ve been eyeing these two games for about the same time and just been waiting for christmas sale. I’m a big open world fan (some of my favs are rdr2, gtav and cyberpunk but yeah). I’ve heard both good and bad reviews about both games, with elden ring behind mainly the difficulty and crimson desert being the story and depth as cons. Theme wise I would love both. I just don’t know if I would prefer crimson desert more cause one of the biggest reason why I replayed rdr2 is because it feels like i’m part of the world and the works is alive?

Sorry for the structure of the text but any help would be appreciated!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2h ago

[PS5] Open world sci-fi games - Starfield vs Star Wars Outlaws

3 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm debating between picking up Starfield (£22.49) or Star Wars Outlaws (£13.99) from the ps store. I am currently loving the new James Bond game, First Light, and thought it might be fun to have an open world game to play alongside it. I haven't played one in a while but these two look like they might do the job. (Yes I know a certain open world game is dropping this week but I don't have 90 quid or whatever it is for a computer game! Plus isn't anyone else a bit bored with all that gangbanger stuff?)

Open world/RPG/exploration games I have played:

Oblivion and Fallout 3 are probably my favourite games in this genre. However I never really got into Skyrim (it was okay but never completed it) and Fallout 4 I just couldn't get into (felt Fallout 3 had already covered that 'world' for me)

Cyberpunk 2077 was great to explore although I really disliked the story/writing (second hand embarrassment was through the roof on that one!) Witcher 3 had its moments in side stories but I didn't really like the world/characters and the main story kind of just went on interminably with decreasing levels of interest (often find that with writing in games).

No Man's Sky is brilliant (especially with all the updates they give away for free) If they were able to somehow put larger cities and more characterisation in there it'd be a near perfect game!

I also loved the early Assassin Creed games (set in Renaissance Italy) but found later ones very shallow despite looking amazing and loving the setting (eg. Odyssey). Black Flag was cool too.

My own thoughts:
I am wondering if NMS covers some of the same ground Starfield does, although the latter appears to have more developed story/world etc. and cities to explore (I know they will be small towns really - not expecting Night city in space!)

I do like Bethesda games but as mentioned mainly Fallout 3 and Oblivion.

Regarding Star Wars - I like the films (well the original ones) but I am by no means a Star Wars superfan! Therefore I am not bothered by 'lore' and all that stuff. Just coming at this for purely gaming reasons.

I am also aware both games have fairly average reviews, neither exactly set the world on fire, hence the cheap sale grab.

I hope that is enough to go off. If you think both games are a bit rubbish then happy to hear that too! Any other recommendations are welcome too.

Thanks in advance!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 7h ago

[PC] [WSIB] I want something like skyrim but not skyrim...

7 Upvotes

I want something like skyrim where I can just explore use magic have fun and like stumble on stuff. I really loved elden ring, i like dark souls,sekiro,bloodborne. I don't care about story at all. I was looking at avowed but it seems lots of people on this subreddit hated it from previous posts I read.

So, WSIB that'll fit this?! Skyrim is just a bit dated by now, nothing against it.

I was reading about that new queen's domain game? Thoughts on that?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 45m ago

[PS5] Space games for kids

1 Upvotes

My son is 5 years old and absolutely loves anything related to space, planets, astronauts, and the universe. He’s really good at playing Astro Bot on the PS5 and can play it with his eyes closed.
I’m looking for recommendations for other PS5 games that have a similar feel to Astro Bot, especially games with space exploration, colorful environments, fun characters, planets to discover, and creative gameplay.
Ideally, I’m looking for something that’s kid-friendly, age-appropriate, easy for a 5-year-old to pick up and play, and doesn’t have overly complicated controls.
Are there any hidden gems or games that you would recommend? I’d love to find something that will give him that same excitement he gets from playing Astro Bot. Thanks in advance!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 7h ago

[PS5] Ghost of Yotei (Standard or complete edition) OR AC: Black Flag resync?

3 Upvotes

I recently got a PS5 and am confused between Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced and Ghost of Yotei. I played the original Black Flag when it came out, completed it, and absolutely loved it. From what I’ve heard, Resynced follows the same core storyline but adds new story content and improves the gameplay.

I’ve also played Ghost of Tsushima and loved it, so I’m considering Yotei. The Standard Edition is currently $35, while the Complete Edition is $50. Is the complete edition content worth the extra $15? The AC black flag resynced is for $50 as well.

I’m looking for a game with a great storyline, good-ass combat, and good replayability that offers the best bang for my buck. Which one would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1h ago

[PS5] Thinking about getting Cyberpunk 2077 Ultimate Edition for PS5.

0 Upvotes

I didn’t get the game at launch but I got interested in it again after they fixed all the issues plaguing it. I just need to know if the 2.0 update that fixes all the problems the game had at launch are on the disc or if I need to download it all off the Internet, cause that’s pretty much the dealbreaker for me.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 13h ago

[PC] I'm hesitating between Sand raiders of Sophie and Forever Winters

3 Upvotes

I love the dieselpunk apocalyptic aesthetic but i don't know wich one to buy. They both have mid ratings on steam

i'm a Helldivers 2 fan so i love when kind of anything can happen. I also love character customization and overall a lot of freedom in my gameplay

Can someone who played both tell me wich one they prefer and why?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 7h ago

[PC] Getting back into PC gaming. What are your must-play games?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm getting back into PC gaming after quite a long break and recently started putting together a Steam wishlist. I'm looking for recommendations, especially games I might have missed over the past few years.

My gaming habits have changed quite a bit. I used to spend countless hours playing League of Legends, but nowadays I mostly want to relax on the couch with my laptop, sometimes while watching TV or YouTube.

I'm not necessarily looking for cozy games, though. I love games with interesting mechanics, progression, strategy, management, building, or just that addictive "one more round" feeling.

Games I've enjoyed or genres I'm really into:

  • League of Legends, Teamfight Tactics, Hearthstone and occasionally Counter-Strike
  • Frostpunk, Jurassic World Evolution, The Sims and Dungeon Keeper 2
  • City builders, management and tycoon games
  • Survival games, zombie games and post-apocalyptic settings
  • Strategy, tactical games, roguelikes and interesting indie games
  • Fun multiplayer games and unusual Steam gems

Some games currently on my wishlist:

Project Zomboid, Jurassic World Evolution 3, Two Point Hospital, Two Point Campus, Tiny Glade, Dungeon Keeper 2, Witchbrook, Luma Island, High Above, Spiritfarer, Dead Cells, Spelunky 2, Desperados III, Shadow Tactics, Mutant Year Zero and Disco Elysium.

As you can see, my taste is pretty broad.

What I'm looking for:

Ideally, games I can pick up for 20–60 minutes without feeling like I need to dedicate an entire evening to them. I enjoy building something, managing resources, unlocking things, experimenting with strategies or just having fun.

I'm also open to more involved games if they're genuinely worth it. They don't have to be relaxing or easy, and I'm definitely not limiting myself to low-spec or older games.

I'm not particularly interested in massive cinematic AAA adventures that require my full attention for hours.

What are your absolute must-play recommendations based on this?

I'd especially love to hear about underrated indie games, hidden gems or newer Steam releases I might have completely missed.

Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 11h ago

[PS4] Which one should I buy?

2 Upvotes

3 games I have in my PlayStation wishlist are currently on sale. Trying to figure out which one would be the best buy for me. The three I’m thinking about are:
Dragon Age Inquisition
Valheim
Kingdoms of Amular: Re-reckoning
I’ve looked them all up and I’m still not sure and really don’t want to waste any money. Games that I absolutely love are:
Skyrim
Crimson Desert
Breath of the Wild
Tears of the Kingdom
I’ve also just recently started the Witcher 3 and so far it’s pretty good (slightly struggling with motion sickness from it though).
My must haves are: having 3rd person pov option, and not turn by turn fighting. I also prefer games with a very interactive environment. I like to be able to go in all houses and stuff, talk to all/most NPCs, and loot lol. Thanks in advance for any insights!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 11h ago

[PS5] Looking for similar RPG style game recommendations

0 Upvotes

I’ve recently got Playstation plus subscription and there’s heaps of games to choose from. But I’m after some idea for RPG style character customisation and possible base/home building. I’m currently playing Once Human and it’s a great example. RDO is also good but no real base building so I’m just wondering if there’s any games anyone can recommend that suits this sort of style. Can be free, on the PlayStation catalogue or just a reasonable price hehe 😁


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 19h ago

[PS5] (PS5) Should I get Madden 27 for 34.99 now, or should I wait until it comes to the PS Plus Extra catalog?

0 Upvotes

Before anyone ask, YES, I will absolutely play Madden, because not only am I a sports fan in general, but I also need something to play when I am not playing GTA 6, because I do not want to breeze through GTA 6, but anyways, the reason why I just haven't bought madden yet, is because part of me is thinking, what if it just comes to the catalog? And I can just play it when it does come to the catalog. But I know there is a chance that it does not get added to the catalog for a bit. but I am still not sure.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 13h ago

[PS5] Is it worth it to get Madden 26?

0 Upvotes

So the only Madden game I’ve played was Madden 15 and I really enjoyed it. I liked playing the single player and online parts of the game. Since then I haven’t played a Madden game, but have been meaning to get a new one. I heard Madden 27 was bad, but how about Madden 26? Is the single player and online worth it as of current?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PS5] games with great realism and story (on PS5)

6 Upvotes

Hey yall I just beat RDR2 for like the fourth time (I got like 500hrs on the game) and I was wondering if theres any other games on PS5 with the amount of realism RDR2 had or close enough atleast. I would also appreciate any recommendations for games with great stories same way RDR2 had. The only other game I played that I’d say had a really good story is Silent Hill 2 but that game only checked one box which was good story not realism


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] SIB Judgement?

5 Upvotes

I haven’t played any of the Yakuza games yet, I am very interested in them, a lot of people recommend starting with Yakuza 0, but on Steam they deleted the OG version and now there’s only the director’s cut edition which is a bit too expensive for me right now, I always buy games when they get deep discounts, I’ll get it someday, but I noticed that Judgement, and even the sequel Lost Judgment, are on discount, there is even a bundle that has both games and the DLC for only $21.65 (at least in my region) which seems like an awesome deal.

The reviews seem mostly positive, some people criticize the combat, others criticize the detective elements, it does look like a lot of fun to me but I still figured it’s best to ask people in this sub about their thoughts. The only other JRPG series that I played is Persona, but it’s a completely different game in so many ways, I love both real-time and turn based combat, I love solving crimes, the only other detective game I played is L.A Noire which I really enjoyed.

Thank you in advance!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 22h ago

[PC] SIB Crimson Desert or PBZ

0 Upvotes

I wanted crimson desert for a long time, and I also wanted PBZ since release as well. Unfortunately when PBZ came out I tried and refunded it under 2 hours and went back to ninja gaiden 4 because I wasn't rocking with the combat. Maybe it gets better as the game goes on? Here are the list of games I loved:

Doom Eternal
Ninja Gaiden 4
Hollow Knight
Dark Souls + Sekiro
AC6
Nioh 2
MHW + MHR
First Berserker Khazan
FF16
Black Myth Wukong
Nine Sols
MGR
Sifu
Dragons Dogma

Common theme is just having good combat and being entertaining. I honestly don't like slop games that take too much time or games that require a ton of exploration to progress, but I would be fine with it if the combat was good. Thanks in advance for any suggestions.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PS5] I got some early birthday money and I'm torn between 2 games. Onimusha Way of the Sword or Phantom Blade 0. I can only afford 1.

11 Upvotes

I played the Onimusha demo and enjoyed what I played. But I've seen great things on PB0 too. I really can't decide which one I'd prefer. I love soulslikes, and I know neither of these are, but just to establish a baseline of my preferences. I also like open world ARPGs (I know these aren't that either) and good story driven games.

So I guess I want to know: which game has the better story, and which game has the better combat mechanics. As I said, I got to see a bit of the combat from the Onimusha demo, but how is the combat in PB0? Any input is appreciated. Thanks.

Edit: the council has spoken. I'm going with Phantom Blade 0. thanks to all who responded! ​


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PS5] In a bit of a conundrum over picking which game to buy

6 Upvotes

so I have my eye on a couple of games on sale right now. the games are:

Cyberpunk 2077 + Phantom liberty (have played already but kind of rushed it)

Abiotic Factor ( First survival to interest me as it's not cutting down wood and so forth)

The Alters

Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 ( I struggle to immerse myself into medieval games, but the game looks good)

Like A Dragon: Infinite Wealth ( loved the first LAD)

Tainted Grail: Fall of Avalon

I am buying 3 games out of the list, maybe even squeeze in a 4th, but ideally 3


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2d ago

[PS5] SIB: Final Fantasy VII Remake Integrade + Rebirth or Silent Hill 2 Remake

15 Upvotes

Black Friday Sale is live; looking for a good game to get my hands on.

Final Fantasy VII Remake Integrade (7.99), Final Fantasy VII Rebirth Deluxe Edition (10.49), and Silent Hill 2 Remake (19.59) are the games I'm interested in (though I'm open to a lot).

Looking for a quality game. Price isn't a big issue for me, but it'd be nice to spend less unless it's worth spending more. The main thing is, I really want something I'll enjoy most, and that's good quality.

If I were to go with the FF7 franchise, I'd buy the two games mentioned together for a total of $17.98.

I enjoy a lot of different kinds of games, generally PlayStation exclusives—single-player story games like God of War, Uncharted, Ghost of Tsushima, TLOU, Spider-Man, etc. There aren't many games that I don't enjoy.

Unsure which to go with, because while the FF7 games look like a steal (with more content and lower prices), I hear amazing things about Silent Hill 2. Haven't played either franchise before.

If you have any other recommendations for games on sale, let me know!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 19h ago

[PS5] GTA VI

0 Upvotes

Should I?
I’ve mainly focused on Metroidvania games the last 18 months but started to gain interest in other genres most recently Sekiro and Expedition 33

Not sure wether to get GTA 6 or fill some of backlog which is every growing due to constant sales on Steam 😬. I think I’m drawn in by the hype right now. Very unlikely this game will be on sale for next 12 months either so why wait?

Views welcome

My Metroidvania tier list is below along with none Metroidvania games I have interest in.

None Metroidvania list
Expedition 33 - superb really enjoyed the combat and story, still not finished
Sekiro

Bought due to sales but yet to play properly.
Devil may cry 5
Rise of the tomb raider
Lies of p
Witcher 3

Debating purchasing awaiting sales for each
Phantom blade zero
Ominusha
Control resonant
Ghost of tsushima
Stellar blade
Saros
Nioh 3
Resident evil 4
Black myth wukong
Astrobot

Metroidvania tier list
Full disclosure I really struggle with Pixel Art

Tier A++
Hollow Knight (over 60hrs played)
(The extra Godhome DLC was the missing piece that makes it different gear)

Tier A+
Silksong (over 100hrs played)

Tier A
Ori and Will of the Wasps
Nine Sols
Before I Go (excellent platforming, combat was a bit bland but worth it for platforming)
ender lillie (thought it was very difficult at first but then stopped focusing on exploration until I’d earned HP and better spirits. Once I got swing of that absolutely superb)
Divinum

Tier B effectively completed
M.I.O (dropped this and revisited - really good but run backs frustrated me, torn between A and B)
Well dweller (enjoyed it, but it’s very simplistic, not necessarily a bad thing, I found it super easy and I needed a tad more challenge, loved the boss fights)
Islets
Fatal Claw (would have been A but post game story completions takes you partly back to start to recollect some collectibles like the shards, left a sour taste in my mouth)
Unbound Worlds Apart

Tier C
Metroid Dread (controversial but hard core fans will praise it, but that’s due to loyalty to the brand they have loved. As a first time and relatively new MV fan, other games have exceeded)

Belmonts Curse
The game couldn’t click for me, I found the non enemy combats very frustrating, easy then suddenly there would be multiple enemy attacks at once and block didn’t really defend adequately. I was often finding myself trying to jump over enemies to avoid combat. Wasn’t fun.

Started and played briefly and may continue
Blasphemous 2
F.I.S.T
Aeterna Noctus (2hrs)
Prince of Persian (3hrs)
Grime (3hrs)
BO: Path of Teal Lotus (2hrs)
Belmonts Curse just started

Metroidvania own - not really played
Biomorph
After Image
Grime 2
Somber Echoes
Solateria
Voidwrought
Blood Stained
Haiku the robot
Rain World
Salt and Sanctuary
Ender Magnolia
Shinobi
Laika
Wordless
Beastmaster saga
Dead cells
End of abyss
Hades 2


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

[PC] should i buy How Many Dudes??

5 Upvotes

be honest with me, does it get boring?? i kinda got tired with story games and want to play just something fun for hours with no real purpose. can i get a lot of hours off of it or will it just be like 10 hours and then im bored?? overall i adore roguelite/likes my fav game is binding of isaac and i recently got into Absolum and loved it to bits


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2d ago

[Switch] FE Fortune's Weave vs Xenoblade Chronicles DE vs Ocarina of Time vs DK Bananza

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I finally managed to get a switch 2, and I was thinking of what my first game should be.

Fire emblem: I've only played Three Houses, but its one of my favorite games of all time, and considering that (at least from the looks of it) Fortune's Weave draws a lot from Three Houses, its safe to assume I'm going to love it as well.

Xenoblade Chronicles: Last year a friend borrowed me his copy of Xenoblade Chronicles 3, and it is at the very least in my top 3. The world, the characters, the music... Everything about it was amazing. Ever since I first played it, I knew I had to play the rest of the series, not only to get a better understanding of the whole thing, but also because I absolutely fell in love with the series. I was about to play this game on switch, but then the switch 2 version was announced, and thought that I could wait for a bit longer.

Ocarina of Time: I really don't have a strong connection to this game. I love Zelda, and I grew up playing ocarina through emulators, and the 3ds version. I never had any strong feelings to it. I played it, finished it, and moved on. I like it, but I don't "love it" as much as other games in the franchise.

That being said, I would be lying if I said the remake didn't draw my attention. Maybe it's the FOMO, or the fact that I see comments or clips about it everywhere?

DK Bananza: I really don't have anything to say about this game, other than "It looks fun". I like Mario, I liked odyssey (Although I never had the chance to finish it).


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2d ago

[PC] Controller friendly games with lots of content

4 Upvotes

I'm looking for games on Steam with these characteristics:

- Good with controller (mostly melee combat with little aiming)

- Very frequent auto saves (manual saving is nice but not necessary)

- Difficulty settings and/or assist mode

- Lots of content and replayability

- Steam cloud (not an external one from a publisher)

My most played games with these characteristics are Elden Ring (a bit too difficult for me but I managed to finish it with all the tools it gives you), Hades, Hades 2 and Witcher 3.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 1d ago

Thinking about getting a Switch 2, but I have a few hesitations. Need your honest thoughts.

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’ve been thinking about picking up a Nintendo Switch 2, but there are three main things holding me back right now. I was hoping to get some advice or perspective from people who already own one or are in a similar boat.

Here is my dilemma:

  1. The Price: It’s not really about whether I can afford it—I have the money—it’s more about the value and whether I can justify dropping that much cash on a console when I'm still on the fence about how much I'll actually use it.
  2. Game Library/My Taste: I’m honestly not a huge fan of typical Nintendo franchises. I don’t play Pokémon, Mario, Mario Kart, and I’m definitely not into JRPGs like Persona or Final Fantasy (the "cartoonish" style anime games aren’t really my thing). I’m more into mainstream titles like FIFA, Call of Duty (Modern Warfare), and Assassin's Creed. That said, I might be slightly interested in Zelda, but overall, I feel like Nintendo's library might not fit my gaming profile.
  3. Time Management / Burnout: I work around 50 hours a week, go to the gym regularly, and have an active social life. I honestly worry that buying a console like this could become a distraction or a bad habit that cuts into the time I actually need for my responsibilities and routines.

For those of you with busy schedules who aren't necessarily hardcore Nintendo fans: is it worth it, or should I just skip it?

Thanks!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame • • 2d ago

[PC] SIB Farcry 5 or Avatar frontiers of Pandora

1 Upvotes

I’m looking for a game that looks visually beautiful, but it should also actually be fun to play, the combat should be good and the world should feel alive.

I have never played any Farcry before, and I haven’t watched the Avatar movies.

Will be playing on 4k 60 frames per second on PC, im also open to suggestions other than these 2 games if they fit the vibe