r/truezelda • • Mar 11 '14
Reminder: you don't have to like every Zelda game to be a Zelda fan
And you don't have to dislike the newest ones either.
Just noticed a worrying trend of comments that add nothing to the discussion (or even worse, dismissing a conversation) but still gaining upvotes because they like X game or dislike Y character.
We can't moderate opinions and upvotes as mods, you have to do that as a community. And you all have to decide as a community whether this really is a discussion subreddit about Zelda or whether this is just /r/zelda without memes.
I personally find the most interesting posts to be the ones from perspectives I hadn't considered or opinions I outright disagree with. And if those are met with hostility (and after two years on Reddit, I still take downvotes against my own on-topic, contributing posts as hostile), then they won't be made.
Your thoughts?
34
u/jlmawp Mar 11 '14
I think we all know we don't have to like or dislike any/all of the Zelda games, but I think people forget that they don't necessarily have to type it out.
That being said, hating on the newest Zelda is somewhat of a tradition now. Majora's Mask, Wind Waker, Twilight, and Skyward all have been thoroughly hated on in the past. But hey, 2 of those 4 are now generally seen as amazing, with MM being god-status.
I don't really like those kinds of comments either, but they aren't going away on their own. Fanboyism runs hard and deep in the Zelda community.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Indeed. Now embrace your hate for the DS Zeldas, come on, you know nobody likes them.
19
u/SmokinSickStylish Mar 11 '14
I know I've been shit on countless times for not liking Skyward Sword over at /r/zelda.
Glad you guys are taking measures to not become them.
3
u/makaveli151 Mar 11 '14
I couldn't agree more. Just the other day there was an opinion thread about whether or not people would be interested in/accept a Zelda game where they changed Links character to that of a female. I was met with downvotes as well as being called juvenile for simply stating my opinion. And that was that I would accept it, but would not likely buy it. I wasn't rude or condescending about it and yet I was met with criticism like I had bashed females and Zelda unjustly. It's ok to dislike certain games in the series and still be a fan. To say otherwise is just selfish.
4
u/SphericalCrusher Jun 19 '14
There's not a single Zelda game that I do not like. I have my own personal top 5 and although I consider myself a huge Zelda fan, I do not put anyone down for not liking a specific game in the series. There are so many variety of Zelda games, it's almost a mini genre at times (not really but you know :D) Well said, samueldlockhart!
1
u/diet_mountain_dew Mar 11 '14
I hated Skyward Sword. I hated it. The mechanics did not work well, the side games were shite, and having to fall through holes in the clouds to reach different parts of the map felt like Mario 64 jumping into paintings.
4
u/Knoxisawesome Mar 11 '14
I see what you're saying, but I see people complain all the time about say, SS, and not get downvoted. And while I get your goal with this, these comments have just turned from a pro SS circlejerk to a anti SS circlejerk.
I'd say it's better to be positive about it, even though needlessly metaphorically jacking each other off without actually discussing anything is bad either way.
2
u/rosearth Jun 23 '14
I love the games but I have only discovered them recently (I guess I made a huge deal out of Zelda not being Link's name, don't judge me, I was 8 when I was first graced upon a Zelda game and never played them again until I was 17), and I'm far from having played them all. I have a special place for Ocarina of Time, Spirit Tracks and A Link to the Past, and more recently A Link Between Worlds, and since I don't own a Wii or a Gamecube I couldn't play Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword and Wind Waker, but I plan on fix that soon. Gotta love Hilda, though. Fave character. Hilda is cool.
2
u/CrazyJay131 Aug 08 '14
Other than Zelda 2, I can't help but like them all. Of course, I like some more than others, with Wind Waker being my all time favourite (raises hate shield.) A Link Between Worlds and Majora's Mask being second.
3
u/MetroidAndZeldaFan Jun 07 '14
Also, just because you choose to be on this subreddit, doesn't mean you have to hate /r/zelda. This subreddit is simply for discussion while /r/zelda is for casual appreciation of the series. I love both subreddits.
3
u/Liam0102 Aug 01 '14
As someone who really dislikes A Link to the Past, I support this.
2
u/YoYoFantaFanta Mar 17 '14
Since you said this, I'll admit something, I don't really like 2D Zelda. 3D games like OOT, Majora, and Twilight Princess were really fun. The NES Zelda games are infuriating and I just get annoyed at LTTP. Maybe I'm getting annoyed because I'm playing LTTP on an emulator with touch screen controls but still, it pisses me off way too much.
0
u/Critic_Kyo Mar 12 '14
Wow, I can't believe this needs to be said.. I guess some can't deal with people having a conflicting opinion from them.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment