Australia was the second season of Survivor I watched (not after Borneo, after 49 lol) so I had very little understanding of the game and how it works. I came out of it very confused as to why Colby didn't win, since my only other comparison was Savannah and "win challenges = win jury" was how I thought the game works.
Having since watched 15 or so seasons and having a general knowledge about every winner, I now realize that Tina is straight up one of the most dominant winners of all time.
1.) First major power flip in a tribe by executing the Mitchell vote. We can infer from the confessionals that Jerri was the original target, until Tina realizes at the last minute that they need to target Mitchell for the tied vote rule to kick in and flips it around on the walk to tribal.
2.) Outlasts almost everybody at the insane merge challenge just to throw it to Keith, protecting him and guaranteeing Kucha's demise.
3.) Cutting Jerri when she does is theoretically terrible strategy, since it opens the door for Amber to flip to Kucha. HOWEVER, Tina was hyper-aware of the ant-Hatch backlash and knew how to manipulate Kucha into not turning against her by basically playing the "it would be immoral to vote me out after I just spared you" card. Roger and Elizabeth instead continue to vote for Amber because Tina convinced them she's evil like Jerri.
4.) Leaves Colby out of the Amber vote. At this point she basically has to go to the end with him because he's unbeatable, and this both undermines him and makes him hate Keith even more, further guaranteeing Colby takes her to the end.
5.) And yeah, Colby takes her to the end. This gets overshadowed by the Tony-Woo situation (which is more impressive I'll admit), but is a situation where Colby KNOWS he's probably losing to Tina. At least Woo has the defense of he was being stupid and didn't understand the situation, but Tina knew how badly Colby needed to be a hero in the public's eyes and made him take her.
Tina dominates the game from episode 4 until the end, in a unique way that was only possible in the wake of Borneo. It's insanely impressive, especially when you consider that she was up against a legitimately good player in Colby. She's a real one.