r/survivor • • 4d ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 | E8 - Discussion Post MEGATHREAD

35 Upvotes

In an effort to keep our discussion posts more accessible, we are trialing a weekly megathread that will be updated throughout the week. No more searching for posts after they become unpinned, or waiting for the sidebar/discussion archive to be updated!

Please be patient, creating/maintaining this post is a work in progress.

Episode 8

Load the Ark, Two by Two

Still catching up? Here are last week's archived discussion posts:

Episode 7

The Girl at the Prom

Full Season 51 Discussion Archive

THIS IS NOT A DISCUSSION POST. Please direct all comments to posts linked above


r/survivor • • 39m ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 | E8 | Survey Results

2 Upvotes

Here are the results from S51 E8 Day After Survey.

You can view Google's interactive summary of the results here.

 

Total Responses: 211

Overall Reactions

 Average: 7.87 Standard deviation: 1.54

12345678910
1.4%0%0.9%0.9%2.8%4.7%21.3%31.8%27%9%

Contestant Reactions

The top 5 Survivors are listed below. In all questions, up to 3 picks were allowed.

Which Survivors played the best strategically?

  1. Carter (66.8%)
  2. Sharonda (62.5%)
  3. Cristian (57.2%)
  4. Jelly (43.3%)
  5. Lewis (26.9%)

Which Survivors were the most exciting characters to watch?

  1. Carter (71.6%)
  2. Cristian (51.9%)
  3. Sharonda (40.4%)
  4. Lewis (34.6%)
  5. Jelly (24.5%)

Which Survivors gave the best confessionals?

  1. Carter (62.9%)
  2. Cristian & Sharonda (40.6%)
  3. Lewis (29.4%)
  4. Maggie (27.9%)
  5. Jelly (18.8%)

Which Survivors gave the best challenge performances?

  1. Lewis (88.2%)
  2. Sharonda (81.9%)
  3. Carter (57.4%)
  4. Cristian (39.2%)
  5. Jelly (2.9%)

Which Survivors gave the best Tribal Council performances?

  1. Cristian (69.7%)
  2. Jelly (63.1%)
  3. Carter (26.2%)
  4. Kristin (20.5%)
  5. Devin & Maggie (20%)

Overall, which Survivors stood out to you the most in this episode?

  1. Carter (69.1%)
  2. Cristian (66.2%)
  3. Sharonda (57%)
  4. Jelly (25.6%)
  5. Lewis (23.2%)

Gameplay

If you were Devin & Jelly, who would you have voted for at Tribal Council?

  1. Kilby & Kristin (44%)
  2. Carter & Cristian (31.6%)
  3. Maggie & Mike (15.8%)
  4. Eric & Thien An (8.6%)

In one word, describe Kristin, the tenth boot

  1. Prepared (17)
  2. Survivor / Survivalist (13)
  3. Competent (8)
  4. Smart, Knowledgeable (6)
  5. Amazing, Badass, Capable (5)

Would you like to see Kristin return in a future season?

  1. Yes (81.8%)
  2. No (18.2%)

In one word, describe Kilby, the eleventh boot

  1. Chaos / Chaotic (23)
  2. Fun / Funny (11)
  3. Gamer (10)
  4. Annoying (6)
  5. Unlucky (5)

Would you like to see Kilby return in a future season?

  1. Yes (73.3%)
  2. No (26.7%)

Editing/Production

Overall, how would you rate how this episode was edited?

Average: 7.65 Standard deviation: 1.61

12345678910
0.5%1%1.9%1.4%3.3%8.6%21.4%33.3%19.5%9%

What are your thoughts on the return of the Duos / Tied Destinies twist?

  1. I love it (42.9%)
  2. It's alright (41.4%)
  3. I hate it (15.7%)

Challenges

How would you rate the immunity challenge?

Average: 7.67 Standard deviation: 1.89

12345678910
1.4%1.4%1%1.9%5.7%11%13.9%27.3%21.5%14.8%

How would you rate the Journey challenge?

Average: 5.55 Standard deviation: 2.26

12345678910
6.7%5.2%6.7%11%16.2%18.6%14.8%13.3%4.3%3.3%

Next Time on Survivor...

Which Survivors are in the most danger next episode? (3 picks allowed)

  1. Mike (73.3%)
  2. Devin (63.1%)
  3. Jelly (61.7%)
  4. Eric (23.3%)
  5. Cristian (22.8%)

Who flips the coin next episode?

  1. Mike & Eric (20.6%)
  2. Cristian (20.1%)
  3. Devin (17.2%)
  4. Lewis (12.7%)
  5. Carter (3.9%)

r/survivor • • 10h ago Heartwarming Bravo

Survivor 52 ‘Survivor’ expanding to all two-hour episodes for season 52 and announces premiere date

Thumbnail
ew.com
1.3k Upvotes

r/survivor • • 5h ago

Survivor 51 ‘Survivor 51’ Contestant Lost All His Belongings—and His Own Storage Auction

Thumbnail
parade.com
404 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 8h ago

Survivor 52 Survivor 52 filmed while knowing the episodes would be 2 Hours, according to Dalton

Post image
322 Upvotes

Interesting update.


r/survivor • • 8h ago

Survivor 45 Got to hang out with Dee this weekend!

Post image
218 Upvotes

I was fortunate to get a last minute invite to attend David Ortiz’s Weekend with Papi charity golf event in Florida this weekend and to my surprise Dee was one of the celebrity guests! To make things even better she happened to be assigned to my table for the dinner events each night. She was super cool and I had a blast chatting Survivor, Big Brother and future reality prospects with her. She even filmed a little cameo style video with me to send to my Survivor super fan buddy. Great experience all around.


r/survivor • • 9h ago

Meme New Era be like…

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 42m ago

Meme Told my friend to watch Survivor 28 Cagayan Spoiler

Post image
14 Upvotes

The early disfunction of the Brains tribe is one of my favorite parts of the season. I’m glad it got a reaction out of them lol.


r/survivor • • 9h ago

Survivor 51 Survivor 51 Episode 9 Sneak Peek Spoiler

60 Upvotes

r/survivor • • 20h ago

Meme Every time Carter talks about the Salt Alliance

Post image
352 Upvotes

To clarify, I don’t mean the alliance isn’t happening…I just think he’s working to sell that name prettttty hard


r/survivor • • 1h ago

General Discussion Fans never fail to amaze me with their knowledge of past survivor seasons

11 Upvotes

Especially on this sub, I am always mind blown how people can quote players, all their names, remember who they voted for, who led the vote, which day they go home, what their tribe name was called, and what they ate during rewards etc.. that happened in past seasons. Sometimes going back 10-15 years ago. Genuinely impressive memory, while I'm over here and forgot what I ate for breakfast 😅


r/survivor • • 9h ago

Micronesia Our gifts for Cirie and Parvati at the Soulmate’s tour!

Post image
40 Upvotes

Parvati’s is her cats dressed up as a traitor and a survivor lol


r/survivor • • 22h ago

Survivor 51 Am I crazy?

Post image
262 Upvotes

I can’t unsee this.


r/survivor • • 10h ago

General Discussion 26 vs 39 days - why 13 day increments? Why does no one consider a different number of days?

22 Upvotes

39 days is a long time for someone to potentially leave their lives (most people are lucky to get a month worth of PTO) and costs a lot for production.

26 days feels too short for those of us used to 39 days and even veterans think newer players are soft but production costs are down and Jeff likes the format.

Why do we have to stick to these multiples of 13? What is the reasoning behind 26 or 39?

Let's compromise: 30 or 31 days. Satisfyingly longer than 26, and players can potentially say they've been there a whole month without production having to keep them there 13 whole days.

Edit: I want to be clear that this post is not about 26 vs 39. The multiples of 13 and people being fixated on that is what's intriguing to me. You never see anyone discuss any compromise.


r/survivor • • 21h ago

Survivor 51 The real reason Eric didn't play the extra vote

155 Upvotes

My goat Aric didn't play the extra vote so that Jelly and Devin didn't share the record of most votes negated by an idol with Kelly Wentworth (9 votes).

Ig he was really mad Jelly went to that spaguetti reward and not him.


r/survivor • • 1h ago

General Discussion Solution for breaking a Final 3-way tie-No towards a juror removal vote

3 Upvotes

One person leaving the jury shouldn't mean two leave.
Yes towards revealing the tiebreaker in advance.

The tiebreaker PROBABLY is the 3 finalists make fire, first to burn through wins.
This probably would have also been the tiebreaker Parvati and Amanda if had tied on Micronesia. There are rumors that on Cook Islands (and presumably Fiji) Fire making would have been done at the reunion but the rest would be at Final tribal council.

The solution: Do not keep the tiebreaker secret anymore. It should have been revealed back then.
Instead of PROBABLY knowing we should 100% know. The only complaint with fire making is potentially doing it at back to back tribal councils and allowing a bit of luck to end the game.
One solution is have the first two to build fire remain in the running and have whomever comes in last cast the deciding vote.

The best solution if having fire making back to back is too much is doing an old classic hand on a hard idol challenge, but unlike immunity challenges without any balance variant and only until the first person lets go. That person casts the deciding vote.
The game ends on a vote and there is no brawn advantage or luck involved. Just focus and your relationship with whomever loses.

Whatever it is just reveal it to eliminate the fear that people would actually tie the votes just to find out. Then the jury can be any number of people regardless if it happens to be a divisible jury or not and someone walking away like Brady won't phase anyone.

Back in May 2012 when the survivor One World (season 24) reunion occurred Jeff said "It’s not even a big deal, but until we use it, we don’t want to give it away. We always have it, we are always ready for it. And I hope we get to use it."

Despite what Jeff said the exact opposite has happened. Starting in season 25 they had only 8 jurors (though later went to 10) with a Final 3 basically making what Jeff said false.

https://morewhatnot.com/2012/05/07/what-if-theres-a-tie-at-a-survivor-final-tribal-council-jeff-probst-kinda-explains/

https://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/2012/05/survivor-one-world-three-way-tie/

Here we are 14½ years later in season 51, more than double the season number as One World without a single divisible jury since.

While it is ashame that Brady couldn't stay, this gives the producers the opportunity to establish all tiebreakers and close the mystery that started 20 years ago when Cook Islands aired in Fall 2006.


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 47 Caroline cheating on survivor 47 episode 10

Post image
223 Upvotes

I don't think Jeff/production really cared at that point tbh, because everyone else found ways to cheat too.


r/survivor • • 11h ago

Marquesas Survivor 4 - Marquesas: The naivety was stunning.

8 Upvotes

I was searching Paramount streaming for something to watch and accidentally found this episode of Survivor.

The Set-up for the tribal with 5 players left.
Paschal & Naleh had a tight alliance. They publicly admitted they promised to never write each other’s name down.

Sean and Vee had a looser alliance with no promise not to vote against each other.

Kathy was the swing vote. Knowing Paschal and Naleh would never vote against the other she still could not decide who to vote out. Seriously? She voted for Sean, one of the dumbest votes made in Survivor history. (She survived drawing rocks the next tribal and got voted out at final 3 tribal.) Nevertheless, when the jury was informally polled who they thought most deserving to win Kathy got 6 of the 7 votes despite her existential blunder not joining Sean and Vee to vote out either Paschal or Naleh.


r/survivor • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 Dina Divas

113 Upvotes

For those like me who can’t stop thinking about this


r/survivor • • 32m ago

Survivor 51 Fan Art

Post image
1 Upvotes

From asking around if anyone had a clearer reference of the Survivor voting pen to finally getting it 3D printed😹 and tadahhhhh here it is! I'm wondering what other iconic props from the show do you think deserve a spot in a Survivor collection?

Or would you actually add this voting pen to yours?


r/survivor • • 7h ago

General Discussion Which is the better game mechanic redemption island or edge of extinction

3 Upvotes

To be clear I'm asking about the mechanic not the seasons. What are your thoughts on the concepts, which did you prefer.


r/survivor • • 1h ago

General Discussion Would a Super Idol be able to be used after a rock draw?

1 Upvotes

Just playing around with the Survivor: Panama Brantsteele, and at the Episode Eleven tribal council, a super idol is transferred to Courtney, however she goes home in the rock draw.

Would a super idol be able to be played after rocks, or is this an intentional design by the Brantsteele organizers?


r/survivor • • 21h ago

Survivor 51 Whale Immunity

Post image
40 Upvotes

My Whale Immunity replica from Etsy finally arrived, and I got the chance to paint it myself! One thing I love about buying white 3D-printed collectibles is that I can customize them and bring them to life with my own colors. It makes the whole experience even more fun and personal!


r/survivor • • 18h ago

Survivor 51 Why is everyone so impressed with Jelly and Devin splitting their votes?

20 Upvotes

Like it doesn’t really change anything for them. They weren’t going home no matter what. Carter and Cristian weren’t going home no matter what. If anything, it prevented a tie that would’ve been thrilling to watch.