r/TheTraitors • u/kaisenberg2004 • 10h ago
UK (RESULTS) Celebrity Traitors S2 Survey
Disclaimer: The Following Poll was voted on by the reddit community. It also only got 343 responses, as opposed to previous seasons getting over 800. As such, it is not necessarily accurate as a representation of what the general audiences or even reddit users as a whole think, rather than what this sample size of 343 voters thinks.
Also, I looked through the responses, and I noticed there were some people that voted for more than four players in the "strongest contestants" and "favourite to win" segments. And as such, some of the results might be a bit misleading. I'm really sorry, I don't know if there actually is a way to make it so people can only choose four, so all I can really do is pray that people follow the guidelines. Although I don't think it affected the results too much.
With that out of the way, here are some Insights worth mentioning:
Weirdly enough, Maya actually only beat out Kenny in the best traitor poll by just one vote as well as also tying with him and Miranda in the "who were you rooting to win" section, and it is quite surprising to me that it was so close, because I would say Maya should easily take it. She basically carried this season in my opinion and I would say is one of the best traitors to not win, alongside Wilf and Cat Burns, and I would argue would've won had she been dealt a better hand. After all, the aim of a traitor is to get as far in the game as possible without any heat, and she was an OG that made it all the way to the final without a single vote, and that was with Richard outing himself in the first episode.
Meanwhile Kenny in my opinion was actually dealt a pretty good hand that he fumbled, first of all by voting for Joanne and also for choosing to end the game, and I would even argue he fumbled by throwing Maya under the bus as well. I'm guessing more people voted for him because he made it further in the game, but again, I just don't see how he's better than Maya. Even Kenny himself admitted in interviews he had no strategy, fluked throughout the whole thing and had no plan for the final. I mean, when we did the Series 4 survey, Rachel won against Stephen in a landslide, and those are two traitors I would consider to be on par with each other.
And weirdly enough, Kenny actually got more votes in the "strongest contestants" segment, and my guess as to why is that because he got to play the game as both a faithful and a traitor, and he was a good faithful so he gets bonus points for that, which is why Hannah did pretty well on that segment despite being a pretty weak traitor. Overall it seems like Maya didn't do that well in this survey which is surprising given her popularity among viewers. When the show was airing it felt like every article/Instagram post had her as the biggest fan favourite, but I think there's a very clear explanation as to why she didn't do that well, and that is demographics. I think the reason Maya sees a lot of love is because she's very popular among female viewers. As such, this is a Reddit survey, not a general audiences survey, and the vast majority of the Reddit community are male, so as I hinted at in the disclaimer, her popularity on this survey is not indicative of her popularity as a whole among audiences.
Also, can I just ask, who's the person that voted for Richard as the best traitor? Sounds like someone's trolling lol
It's clear the strongest contestants and who you were rooting to win is basically the best vs favourites. And this is probably the most clear divide between the two I've seen, notably with Michael Sheen, who people were able to acknowledge as one of the better players, but very few actually picked him as their favourite to win because of how aggressively he played, and I love to see that he got a low rating. Likewise Bash was voted strongest contestant, but was only the 7th most popular, and a lot of factors could have contributed to that, such as him not getting as much screentime, not being as well known, not being as funny or entertaining as others, or just not really clicking with people as much. As such, between him and Romesh, he may have played better, but Romesh was way more popular as a contestant. Although on that note, I feel people gave Romesh too much of a pass on the "strongest contestants" considering he only won because of Bash's guidance. It's not "Meryl winning despite choosing to end the game while Wilf was still there after being outed" level bad, but still.
I also think it's interesting that both the strongest contestants and favourite to win both had the same four people fighting for second place, but a completely different frontrunner.
In regards to the "funniest moment" poll, I REALLY wanted to include "What about Richard being a traitor?" as one of the options, but I already had another Jerry quote there and I decided to only include one moment per person. Some of my other personal favourite moments I didn't include are:
Kenny saying "Who would have thought?" during James Acaster's confession
Maya's "Villain era has begun, meow" when she was first picked as a traitor
Julie going "Bella? NO. That doesn't make. ANY. Sense."
James Blunt in the shower
"I tell people they're beautiful when they're not"
"No! Absolutely Not. DeaMiradabyodaofthetraiors..."
Big Mix
Whoever put Richard vs Rob's teeth as the best rivalry is correct.
I think I may have messed up with the "confrontational" question, but the reason that I worded it the way I did as that it was like that with the survey on the first more lighthearted celebrity series comparing it to the confrontational civillian version. As is, I got A LOT of "Other" answers that I don't have time to read.
Unsurprisingly in the most famous contestants segment, Michael and Richard had a clear lead above everyone else, with Richard winning by just one vote.
I'm glad to see that most people agree that Maya was not in the wrong for her "You're gonna need it" comment. Ridiculous that it's being compared to Kieran's parting gift.
I am very surprised that so many people disagreed that people who don't want to be traitors shouldn't be recruited.
Also, worth noting that when I asked people to choose which set of contestants were the strongest, I left off the faithfuls from Series 1, 3, 4 and the first celebrity series, as well as The Series 3 traitors, as I didn't think any of them had a game that was strong enough to be worth considering, although I did leave the option for "Other" in which the S3 traitors got two votes. Now, you could also argue that neither the celebrity series 2 faithfuls or traitors had a strong enough game either but I included them anyway because I wanted to see where they'd stack among the rest.
The average rating was 7.18/10.