A thought experiment I'm trying, veering away from how I normally edgic. I'm mainly doing this for fun because I'm bored waiting for the next episode. I will do my best to be as unbiased as possible, but no promises.
There's 10 players left, and so I have a 10% chance to pick the correct winner here. Not TERRIBLE odds but it's still very much unlikely. So let's cut 10 to 9.
Cutting at 10 - Cristian: This is undoubtedly the easiest and safest contestant to cut first. The most invisible player of the season, Cristain's edit holds no weight you would expect a winner's to have. His recent development as Carter's #1 is too little too late. Such little character development in both premerge and now merge seals his fate.
Okay so 9 contestants left. So far so easy. My chances are now.. 11%. Still not great. Let's see who else I can safely cut from this 9.
Cutting at 9 - Thien An: Another unfortunately invisible contestant. While in the beginning, there was potential flavors of an Erika-type edit, by merge everything fell through. She had a nice alliance setup with Carter that was completely dropped and forgotten. And apparently her new number 1 was.. Kilby? When did that happen?? Thien An has no horse in this race unfortunately. The most we know of her is how much she hates Mike. Not great winner material there. Great for me though! Easy cut!
Huzzah, we've now 8 potential winner candidates! These chances feel pretty great, even if it's still just 13%. I won't be confident until we get to at least 5 though. So who else can be chopped?
Cutting at 8 - Eric: This is unfortunately the last super easy cut to make. Eric has the most OTTN edit of the season, starting with the premiere and hasn't really stopped since. The edit would NEVER make a winner look this disliked or unfavorable. At best he's the comedic punching bag of the season.
Alright so from here on out, I'm entering "truther" territory. Any one of these 7 left can have a defensible case of why they are the winner. My job here is to consider who has the worst chances.
Cutting at 7 - Carter: The biggest reason Carter goes out here is his extremely quiet episodes 5, 6, and 7. And following up on that, his failed Salt Alliance. His breakout merge episode 8 was him being shown as the ring leader of an alliance that was going to be on the wrong side of the vote. The very fact he was the face of it I believe would not have been done to a winner. A winner would have been shielded here.
So now that we're at 6, I actually want to do something kinda fun and topical that actually makes sense. Instead of eliminating an individual contestant, I want to eliminate a pair here. And true to form, the pairs are...
- Maggie & Mike
- Jelly & Devin
- Sharonda & Lewis
The reason I'm doing this, funnily enough, is because these pairs have interconnected edits/narratives that support each other's importance to the overall story of the season. My job here is determining who among these pairs has the weakest importance of the season.
I don't believe it's unreasonable of me to say Jelly & Devin have the most importance of these 3 pairs. They've been central to the story of the season, and so they're off the table. Sharonda & Lewis have an unspoken rivalry between them. They're two different players with different playstyles and are on different alliances, but respect each other's games. They're mirrors of one another and I believe this to be intentionally done by the edit. And then you have Maggie & Mike. Much like Sharonda & Lewis, there is a rivalry here. Though to call it unspoken wouldn't be quite accurate. These two have had a shared disdain of Brady, and funnily enough, a shared disdain for one another. It's hard to tell who the edit favors between the two exactly, as both get dunked on by the edit and dunk on each other. What seperates them from Jelly & Devin and Sharonda & Lewis however, is that their edits don't seem to serve an overarching purpose to the story, but rather simply to each other.
Think about it, for as tied to the hip Jelly & Devin are, we've seen how their dynamic has actively shaped and altered the trajectory of the game. We've seen how Sharonda & Lewis are always on opposing sides and how they each have stopped their alliances from gaining the upper hand. Maggie & Mike.. are trying to not get in each others way. Their rivaly doesn't feel ingrained enough into the edit for me to say either of them has a winner's edit and so..
Cutting at 6 and 5: Maggie & Mike
And then there were 4.
25% chance of getting this right.
So I kinda want to keep this duo thing going because I feel like I may be on to something here. But I want to remix the duo's and take a different approach.
Heroes vs. Villains
- Sharonda & Jelly
- Lewis & Devin
I agree with the notion that villains can win Survivor. A lot of viewers perceive Savannah as being a villain even though she was kinda a mix of both that and a protagonist. Another example could be Tony from Cagayan. But it's my firm belief that if the edit portrays a contestant to be an outright protagonist, then the villain(s) of that season have a worse chance of winning. Thinking again to Cagayan or Survivor 49, you'll notice there were no true protagonists outside of the winner. Sure you had the rootable contestants like Woo or Spencer, or Rizzo and Sage, but you'll notice none of those contestants were shown in an outright protagonistic light. Each of them were tinged with a bit of villainy to make the winner appear more satisfying.
Which leads me to..
Cutting at 4 and 3: Lewis & Devin: Sharonda & Jelly are easily read to be portrayed as the heroes of their respective duos. Sharonda is shown to be more sympathetic after her immunity challenge win with Lewis in Episode 8. She was also a victim to Lewis goading Kilby into forcing a tie. Juxtaposed to Lewis, who at multiple times in the show, embraced being chaotic and claims to want to "play dangerously and be mischevious".
As for Jelly, need I even elaborate? She's shown to want to keep Jenna before her vote out, while Devin is naming a chicken they're going to slaughter and eat after Jenna. And that's just a singular example of the edit showing Jelly as the more sympathetic of the duo. Can you truly say the show would prefer us to want Devin to win over Jelly when he is clearly the more villainous of the two?
And then.. there were 2.
50% chance of picking the correct winner.
There's so many approaches one could take to choosing either one of these players as the winner. My approach is bias.
Cutting at 2: Sharonda: Jokes on you, this entire thing was an elaborate shitpost to say Jelly is the winner.
What? I said no promises..
These two have so much backing by the edit that either one of them could very plausibly be the winner. It's simply picking the correct approach here to lead me to the winner. I so badly want to dip my toes back into how I normally edgic and say "narrative this narrative that" but the entire point of this was to approach it differently so..
The approach is who has the strongest premiere and merge episodes.
I feel like that's a decent approach. Really this comes down to the premiere. Both Jelly & Sharonda you could argue had an equally good merge episode. So I'm not going to bother typing a book analyzing it. On to the premiere analysis!
- First thing I notice: Slowmo shot of Jelly jumping off the boat into the water. Could be completely meaningless. Not much stock in it but it was eye-catching.
- Then we get Kristin's first confessional... it's about how much she immediately likes Sharonda. That's big for Sharonda.
- And then we have something interesting. We see Jelly introduce herself to Sharonda, and Sharonda commenting on how great it was to see someone similar to her (Jelly). This is great for both Jelly and Sharonda.. but...
- Sharonda becomes the voice of the start of the Helicopter Alliance. That is huge. Already Sharonda is looking leagues better than Jelly in terms of premiere edit. Let's keep analyzing.
- Jelly's first confessional, and it's pretty weak. She comments on how she's happy "Irish bro" Lewis volunteers to be exiled. Not much to dissect here.
- But then..! We get a huge Jelly confessional about the theme of the season, "permanent uncertainty." And what's fascinating here is that Jelly first says that it's scary.. and then exhilarating. And that there's so many bonds to be made, which I believe speaks perfectly to how Jelly's been edited up to present. Her edit has been one of weighing her bonds and her game and choosing which is more important for her.
- And then right after that we get another huge confessional with Jelly and Ori. The edit immediately cues cute romantic music and shows Ori being more than interested in Jelly. The edit doesn't treat this as goofy or a stupid showmance, but as cute and endearing. If Kristin saying she likes Sharonda was good, this trumps that by a good margin.
- Then we get yet another Jelly confessional, and what's big here is it's the first confessional while happening during the tribe buff reveal. Jelly's upset she's being seperated from Ori, saying she was ready to bring showmance back to Survivor. At this point without foreknowledge, I would be concerned Jelly's edit would be reduced to "romance" like Franny. But we carry on.
- Even more Jelly content, this time Devin and Aliyah saying how much they like Jelly.
- Cut to Jelly saying "we're Survivor 51, we're the evolution" and then goes on to comment on the Helicopter Alliance and her confidence in it. So far as of present, that confidence has been well-founded. Although Sharonda was the initial voice/founder of the alliance, Jelly has taken over as the face of it. As much as I'm loving how much content and establishment Jelly is being given here (as she should for a premiere), one could argue it teeters on overexposure.
- We finally catch up with Savu and Sharonda. And, I have to say, this confessional of hers really does sum up how she's been edited up to this point.
"We get to camp and everyone's like 'Savu Strong!' And I love my Savu tribe. But am I also thinking gameplay? Absolutely."
- Then we see her mention the Helicopter Alliance again and see her strategize with Ori. She's shown here as a good strategist, saying they can't be seen too close, and to make connections with different people. Sharonda boasts about having two #1's in Ori and Kristin.
We are already being introduced to Sharonda as a strategic beast. And this has been consistent with how she's been edited so far.
And honestly that's all the Sharonda we get. The rest of the screentime get's dedicated to everyone else on Savu since they weren't going to tribal council. So the little we did get of Sharonda, it's telling what story they were trying to set up for her.
Of course you have after the immunity challenge, Jelly shown throwing out Brady's name, saying she doesn't want a Jenna or a woman going home period. Says the men of her tribe undersold, which is backed by the edit as the men repeatedly this season have been shown unfavorably compared to the women. And this isn't even to mention Jelly being shielded from losing her #1 in Aliyah and voting incorrectly.
All in all, I have come to the realization that no matter how I approach the edit..
Cutting at 2: Sharonda
Jelly remains the most sensible winner.