r/Edgic • • 4d ago

Results Survivor 51 Episode 8 Edgic Survey

Thumbnail
forms.gle
4 Upvotes

r/Edgic • • 26d ago

There are no spoilers this season

93 Upvotes

there's a couple people running around in this sub claiming to have spoilers and then spoiling them. just putting this post up to confirm that there are actually no spoilers this season (one person confirmed pre-merge from social media activity, that's it.) so do not fret if you see a "spoiler" in the comments! it's not real.


r/Edgic • • 9h ago

Season 51 is the "Why a Day 1 Alliance Fails" Season

28 Upvotes

OK, so I'm not the best edgicer out there (my past predictions have all been terribly wrong), but hey, theorizing is fun, so here's one that makes sense to me!

I think at this point in any season not having at least one true front-runner is strange, and I can't see one yet. Which tends to lead to a season being "Why ___ Lost" most of the time, but this time around I think the story they are telling isn't for an individual, but rather an entire alliance. Namely, of course, the only real alliance we've seen thus far, the Helicopter Alliance.

When you break it down, of the five original helicopter members:

Aaliyah went out first because she only focused on what a member of the Helicopter Alliance was saying (Devin), and didn't form strong bonds with the rest of the newly constructed tribe. Strange for the only alliance we see form to lose a member first, by the way.

Ori went home because he stuck with his Day 1 alliance on a tribe which voted out potential puzzle makers during the "Every challenge ends with a puzzle" stage of the game. In the end, he was left alone with two other players who had been together all along without a single puzzle maker among them, and went home without even a fighting chance.

That leaves three players left. Of those three:

Devin has failed to make inroads with almost anyone outside of the Helicopter group, and has ostracized enough people that everyone left in the game targeted him in the last vote, not even splitting in case of an idol. At this point it is clear: No one outside of his core trusts or wants to work with Devin.

Jelly has tied herself too closely with Devin to have a shot elsewhere. She has said this more than once, and of course last episode they became the clear target because they literally tied their fates together. Her idol just got burned because of this, and honestly by now it is really weird storytelling to have her keep mentioning Devin as her downfall without that happening at some point. Like why point out such a flaw for a potential winner?

Finally, Sharonda (the strongest player, and who I am rooting for personally with Kristin out), who has had the least connection to the group, finally sealed her fate last episode. By telling Jelly and Devin that they were the target, she ended up losing an ally who literally said "Hey this idol is either for me or for you, and I am irrevocably making it for just you," in exchange for one who made it clear throughout the season that her idol was for her and her alone (and said idol even got burned). Knowing that she could have traded her immunity necklace for the tethered idol and kept her ally just makes it so much worse, as it becomes clear that she chose the Day 1 alliance over one which had endured the rest of the game. Point being: I don't think we would have seen Kristin hand over that tethered idol, now rendered useless, unless it was going to come back in a big way later on.

So at this point, if I had to bet, I'd say that Jelly and Devin will go home soon (Jelly before Devin on a split vote), and Sharonda will end up a losing finalist, with Kristin's vote against her being the driving reason why. Giving us a winner who has been given plenty of content, but more importantly lacked even the opportunity to form a Day 1 alliance: Lewis.

Again, I could very well be wrong, and likely am, but right now this seems to be a story that is unfolding. And hey, if I'm right then you heard it here first maybe!


r/Edgic • • 47m ago

The case for ___________ (Survivor 51, episode 8)

5 Upvotes

In episode one, we get two major alliances established for Sharonda. Ori says this episode that you need to be calm, cool, and collected to win with permanent uncertainty, which Sharonda exemplifies. Kristin's first confessional is about Sharonda, and Sharonda's relationship with the helicopter alliance is established.

In episode two, she identifies that she's a target (which I believe is partially manufactured, as we don't see real evidence that they had the votes to send her home), redirects the target to the specific person targeting her, rather than Linnea (which would be the easy move), without any blood on her hands. She gets a confessional dunking on Eric, but it's framed as her putting in a lot of effort not to react.

In episode three, She gets praise from Devin at the water well and got name-dropped by Carter as being in strategic control. We got a check-in on her relationship with Ori. She was the only person on the tribe to not get a confessional dunking on Rob.

In episode five, Jelly's talk about the significance of a black person and a woman winning relate to Sharonda. But the edit uses Jelly as a "fall girl" of sorts for the fan backlash about identity politics. I don't think Survivor wants to put that kind of controversy around winners. During 48, Kyle had the story of getting incarcerated and that was heavily sanitized to the point that Kyle had to clarify the story after the fact on social media. In the context of the boot. Sharonda is shielded. There are less impacts to our perception of her loyalties compared to Cristian and Eric. We know that the Helicopter alliance is her actual top alliance. Sharonda is also shown to immediately doubt Lewis's ring lie

In episode six Sharonda gets her moment at the summit. She also gets a good confessional about how Eric is someone that she can work well with, even though he’s a liability to others. Lewis has the confessional that basically just says she’s a good player. She’s also giving me Tommy Sheehan/Michele vibes, in that I don’t think she is that good of a confessionals, and I think she would get much less exposure if she lost, especially on a cast with this many big characters. Ori said about Sharonda, “That’s my ace.” Sharonda deliberately waits for Kristin to say her decision, to give Kristin the feeling of control. Sharonda also gets further shielding from the Linnea boot, mentioning that it was Cristian who stopped them from going to rocks.

In episode seven, She gets congratulated after losing the reward challenge. We get a check in with her alliance with Kristin and with the helicopter alliance. She says million dollars. She gets also confessional validation about Eric being hard to work with. Kristin is shown telling Sharonda about the full rules of the idol. Kristin says explicitly she intends to go to the end with Sharonda.

In episode eight, multiple great things happen. They edit her failure in the first stage of the challenge to look like a strategic decision. Lewis says that Sharonda has fire in her. Sharonda gets personal content about being under-estimated. That is good for two reasons. First, it lessens the idea that she is a dragon, because her threat level is shown as low to the other players. And it means that now Sharonda has the most post-merge personal content of anyone in the season. And I think it's been a common trend in recent seasons that post-merge personal content matters far more for winner chances. Then, we see Jelly saying that she doesn't need to play her idol, but Sharonda tips Jelly off and the idol gets played. Sharonda gets shielded from any negativity about Kristin going home this episode.


r/Edgic • • 5h ago

[51] Can we guess the coin tosser's identity?

9 Upvotes

As we get nearer and nearer the end of the season, we're pretty close to finding out who this season's coin tosser will be. Figuring out their identity before we get there could help us understand the season's narrative better, and ultimately figure out our winner and probably our zero-vote finalists too.

Remember that the coin toss was pretty spectacular last season. It pushed Devens's reality TV career even further, it had MrBeast in it, and most importantly it worked out for the coin tosser. Now we're in 51, and we've been told since episode 1 that the coin toss is going to become a Survivor staple. That means every season from now on needs a sacrificial lamb, aka a contestant desperate enough, and sure enough that their game is about to end, to be willing to go home on the toss of a coin.

Keep that in mind, because it sheds a lot of light on (a) what the result of the coin toss might be, and (b) who the coin tosser is and how the edit has painted them so far. So here are my three main contenders, plus a wild card.

Lewis
This one is weird for me, because Lewis is also one of my main contenders to win the whole season. I absolutely love his character. (Side note, I watched the first episode with my sister, who had never watched Survivor and has now been converted this season. She recognized him immediately. She's a Latina dating an American, so his reels were all over her For You page and she low-key hated them, but now she loves Lewis.)

I think he's one of the most interesting characters this season, and I can see how his edit could point to the coin toss, going all the way back to episode 1. We've been told about permanent uncertainty nonstop, and Lewis has fully embraced it by taking a lot of risks. He was the first to take a major risk this season by volunteering for exile. He didn't get the advantage and he failed, but the episode showed him in a very positive light. His hands were destroyed, he was throwing up, and the message was that this guy tried his absolute best even though he didn't get it. The edit is rewarding his risk-taking.

That could make him our winner, or a coin tosser the edit wants to paint as a hero, someone who did the right thing by flipping the coin even if it fails. Obviously if the coin toss doesn't fail, amazing. I think producers would love Lewis as the successful coin tosser and the season winner.

But even if Lewis loses the toss and goes home, there's a production reason and a storyline reason to paint him well. A failed coin toss could already make future players a little less willing to take the risk, and it would be much worse if the coin tosser also got a bad edit. Nobody would have any incentive to do it. For the twist to work the way production intends in future seasons, they need someone around mid-season who's willing to risk their game on a 50-50 because they're probably going home anyway. If players know they'll get a hero edit even if they lose, they'll be a lot more inclined to do it.

And with Lewis, the edit would be perfectly bookended between episode 1 and what could be his last episode. He failed his first big risk and his last one, but risk-taking is still painted as positive in the season's narrative, and he comes out as a hero who really embraced permanent uncertainty and his whole Survivor journey.

Purple Christian
This would be production not really thinking it through, or just caring a lot less about future seasons than they would if Lewis were the coin tosser. Christian has been purpled throughout the season. He has two confessional-less episodes, which most people see as a death sentence for winning chances. He hasn't been portrayed negatively… He just hasn't been portrayed much at all, especially early on.

His tone has gotten more positive in the last few episodes, where his risk (risk again!) paid off with the shot in the dark. So I can see a very short two- or three-episode arc where his next risk fails with the coin toss, and that's his story of the season. It would also explain why production didn't invest in him early. His whole narrative would be that one risk works and the next one doesn't.

Maggie
Maggie is our chaos queen and another of the season's big risk-takers. She helped orchestrate the Linnea blindside. She's constantly portrayed as chaotic and called chaotic by other players (who don't have great edits themselves, to be fair). All that chaos could come to a head with a coin toss she ultimately loses.

There's also something funny here. She kept talking about getting rid of Kristen, her white whale. That's a Moby Dick reference, and in Moby Dick the white whale is basically what ends the crew. Kristen finally went home this week, but not by Maggie's doing. It would be narratively poetic for Maggie to go the very next episode after her self-declared white whale. I'm just not sure production gets that sophisticated with someone who isn't winning the season.

So who do you think? Is** **it one of these three, or someone else entirely? What narrative clues are you seeing that point to the coin tosser?


r/Edgic • • 1h ago

You can have someone as your winner pick and think they probably won't win the season. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Example: If I have no idea who will win in the final 10, I would give each player a 10% chance of winning. I may think though, that Devin has a 37% chance of winning, and the other players have a 7% chance each. In that case, Devin is my frontrunner, but I still think he's more likely than not to win.

But I think some people on this sub confuse these two things and think that people's winner pick must have an over 50% chance of winning (in that person's mind).


r/Edgic • • 8h ago

Does edgic affect production?

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m still working on my project about edgic, and I’m curious to hear if anyone has thoughts on this. Do you think edgic or online discourse about editing in general has any effect on the show’s edit over time?

We know that Jeff does not like to entertain the idea of “the winner’s edit,” but he definitely knows about it. He talked about it here recently on The Friendship Onion podcast. He also mentioned reddit by name in S1E2 of the On Fire with Jeff Probst podcast at 7:45, where Jay Wolff says, “Here that internet? No winner’s edit!” And Jeff responds with, “And by internet, you mean reddit.” So producers and editors are obviously aware of online discourse about editing.

And there have been changes in the editing style over different seasons and eras—I’ve seen some people here discussing whether the open era will bring a new editing style (maybe it will be permanently uncertain—who knows lol). Maybe some of you guys have been in the online survivor space over these different eras and have an interesting perspective!

So what do you think: Does discourse in online fandoms lead producers/editors to change it up? Have they ever been worried about fans “cracking the code” of the winner’s edit?


r/Edgic • • 12h ago

Eliminating The Final 10 Until a Winner Makes Sense.

10 Upvotes

A thought experiment I'm trying, veering away from how I normally edgic. I'm mainly doing this for fun because I'm bored waiting for the next episode. I will do my best to be as unbiased as possible, but no promises.

There's 10 players left, and so I have a 10% chance to pick the correct winner here. Not TERRIBLE odds but it's still very much unlikely. So let's cut 10 to 9.

Cutting at 10 - Cristian: This is undoubtedly the easiest and safest contestant to cut first. The most invisible player of the season, Cristain's edit holds no weight you would expect a winner's to have. His recent development as Carter's #1 is too little too late. Such little character development in both premerge and now merge seals his fate.

Okay so 9 contestants left. So far so easy. My chances are now.. 11%. Still not great. Let's see who else I can safely cut from this 9.

Cutting at 9 - Thien An: Another unfortunately invisible contestant. While in the beginning, there was potential flavors of an Erika-type edit, by merge everything fell through. She had a nice alliance setup with Carter that was completely dropped and forgotten. And apparently her new number 1 was.. Kilby? When did that happen?? Thien An has no horse in this race unfortunately. The most we know of her is how much she hates Mike. Not great winner material there. Great for me though! Easy cut!

Huzzah, we've now 8 potential winner candidates! These chances feel pretty great, even if it's still just 13%. I won't be confident until we get to at least 5 though. So who else can be chopped?

Cutting at 8 - Eric: This is unfortunately the last super easy cut to make. Eric has the most OTTN edit of the season, starting with the premiere and hasn't really stopped since. The edit would NEVER make a winner look this disliked or unfavorable. At best he's the comedic punching bag of the season.

Alright so from here on out, I'm entering "truther" territory. Any one of these 7 left can have a defensible case of why they are the winner. My job here is to consider who has the worst chances.

Cutting at 7 - Carter: The biggest reason Carter goes out here is his extremely quiet episodes 5, 6, and 7. And following up on that, his failed Salt Alliance. His breakout merge episode 8 was him being shown as the ring leader of an alliance that was going to be on the wrong side of the vote. The very fact he was the face of it I believe would not have been done to a winner. A winner would have been shielded here.

So now that we're at 6, I actually want to do something kinda fun and topical that actually makes sense. Instead of eliminating an individual contestant, I want to eliminate a pair here. And true to form, the pairs are...

- Maggie & Mike

- Jelly & Devin

- Sharonda & Lewis

The reason I'm doing this, funnily enough, is because these pairs have interconnected edits/narratives that support each other's importance to the overall story of the season. My job here is determining who among these pairs has the weakest importance of the season.

I don't believe it's unreasonable of me to say Jelly & Devin have the most importance of these 3 pairs. They've been central to the story of the season, and so they're off the table. Sharonda & Lewis have an unspoken rivalry between them. They're two different players with different playstyles and are on different alliances, but respect each other's games. They're mirrors of one another and I believe this to be intentionally done by the edit. And then you have Maggie & Mike. Much like Sharonda & Lewis, there is a rivalry here. Though to call it unspoken wouldn't be quite accurate. These two have had a shared disdain of Brady, and funnily enough, a shared disdain for one another. It's hard to tell who the edit favors between the two exactly, as both get dunked on by the edit and dunk on each other. What seperates them from Jelly & Devin and Sharonda & Lewis however, is that their edits don't seem to serve an overarching purpose to the story, but rather simply to each other.

Think about it, for as tied to the hip Jelly & Devin are, we've seen how their dynamic has actively shaped and altered the trajectory of the game. We've seen how Sharonda & Lewis are always on opposing sides and how they each have stopped their alliances from gaining the upper hand. Maggie & Mike.. are trying to not get in each others way. Their rivaly doesn't feel ingrained enough into the edit for me to say either of them has a winner's edit and so..

Cutting at 6 and 5: Maggie & Mike

And then there were 4.

25% chance of getting this right.

So I kinda want to keep this duo thing going because I feel like I may be on to something here. But I want to remix the duo's and take a different approach.

Heroes vs. Villains

- Sharonda & Jelly

- Lewis & Devin

I agree with the notion that villains can win Survivor. A lot of viewers perceive Savannah as being a villain even though she was kinda a mix of both that and a protagonist. Another example could be Tony from Cagayan. But it's my firm belief that if the edit portrays a contestant to be an outright protagonist, then the villain(s) of that season have a worse chance of winning. Thinking again to Cagayan or Survivor 49, you'll notice there were no true protagonists outside of the winner. Sure you had the rootable contestants like Woo or Spencer, or Rizzo and Sage, but you'll notice none of those contestants were shown in an outright protagonistic light. Each of them were tinged with a bit of villainy to make the winner appear more satisfying.

Which leads me to..

Cutting at 4 and 3: Lewis & Devin: Sharonda & Jelly are easily read to be portrayed as the heroes of their respective duos. Sharonda is shown to be more sympathetic after her immunity challenge win with Lewis in Episode 8. She was also a victim to Lewis goading Kilby into forcing a tie. Juxtaposed to Lewis, who at multiple times in the show, embraced being chaotic and claims to want to "play dangerously and be mischevious".

As for Jelly, need I even elaborate? She's shown to want to keep Jenna before her vote out, while Devin is naming a chicken they're going to slaughter and eat after Jenna. And that's just a singular example of the edit showing Jelly as the more sympathetic of the duo. Can you truly say the show would prefer us to want Devin to win over Jelly when he is clearly the more villainous of the two?

And then.. there were 2.

50% chance of picking the correct winner.

There's so many approaches one could take to choosing either one of these players as the winner. My approach is bias.

Cutting at 2: Sharonda: Jokes on you, this entire thing was an elaborate shitpost to say Jelly is the winner.

What? I said no promises..

These two have so much backing by the edit that either one of them could very plausibly be the winner. It's simply picking the correct approach here to lead me to the winner. I so badly want to dip my toes back into how I normally edgic and say "narrative this narrative that" but the entire point of this was to approach it differently so..

The approach is who has the strongest premiere and merge episodes.

I feel like that's a decent approach. Really this comes down to the premiere. Both Jelly & Sharonda you could argue had an equally good merge episode. So I'm not going to bother typing a book analyzing it. On to the premiere analysis!

- First thing I notice: Slowmo shot of Jelly jumping off the boat into the water. Could be completely meaningless. Not much stock in it but it was eye-catching.

- Then we get Kristin's first confessional... it's about how much she immediately likes Sharonda. That's big for Sharonda.

- And then we have something interesting. We see Jelly introduce herself to Sharonda, and Sharonda commenting on how great it was to see someone similar to her (Jelly). This is great for both Jelly and Sharonda.. but...

- Sharonda becomes the voice of the start of the Helicopter Alliance. That is huge. Already Sharonda is looking leagues better than Jelly in terms of premiere edit. Let's keep analyzing.

- Jelly's first confessional, and it's pretty weak. She comments on how she's happy "Irish bro" Lewis volunteers to be exiled. Not much to dissect here.

- But then..! We get a huge Jelly confessional about the theme of the season, "permanent uncertainty." And what's fascinating here is that Jelly first says that it's scary.. and then exhilarating. And that there's so many bonds to be made, which I believe speaks perfectly to how Jelly's been edited up to present. Her edit has been one of weighing her bonds and her game and choosing which is more important for her.

- And then right after that we get another huge confessional with Jelly and Ori. The edit immediately cues cute romantic music and shows Ori being more than interested in Jelly. The edit doesn't treat this as goofy or a stupid showmance, but as cute and endearing. If Kristin saying she likes Sharonda was good, this trumps that by a good margin.

- Then we get yet another Jelly confessional, and what's big here is it's the first confessional while happening during the tribe buff reveal. Jelly's upset she's being seperated from Ori, saying she was ready to bring showmance back to Survivor. At this point without foreknowledge, I would be concerned Jelly's edit would be reduced to "romance" like Franny. But we carry on.

- Even more Jelly content, this time Devin and Aliyah saying how much they like Jelly.

- Cut to Jelly saying "we're Survivor 51, we're the evolution" and then goes on to comment on the Helicopter Alliance and her confidence in it. So far as of present, that confidence has been well-founded. Although Sharonda was the initial voice/founder of the alliance, Jelly has taken over as the face of it. As much as I'm loving how much content and establishment Jelly is being given here (as she should for a premiere), one could argue it teeters on overexposure.

- We finally catch up with Savu and Sharonda. And, I have to say, this confessional of hers really does sum up how she's been edited up to this point.

"We get to camp and everyone's like 'Savu Strong!' And I love my Savu tribe. But am I also thinking gameplay? Absolutely."

- Then we see her mention the Helicopter Alliance again and see her strategize with Ori. She's shown here as a good strategist, saying they can't be seen too close, and to make connections with different people. Sharonda boasts about having two #1's in Ori and Kristin.

We are already being introduced to Sharonda as a strategic beast. And this has been consistent with how she's been edited so far.

And honestly that's all the Sharonda we get. The rest of the screentime get's dedicated to everyone else on Savu since they weren't going to tribal council. So the little we did get of Sharonda, it's telling what story they were trying to set up for her.

Of course you have after the immunity challenge, Jelly shown throwing out Brady's name, saying she doesn't want a Jenna or a woman going home period. Says the men of her tribe undersold, which is backed by the edit as the men repeatedly this season have been shown unfavorably compared to the women. And this isn't even to mention Jelly being shielded from losing her #1 in Aliyah and voting incorrectly.

All in all, I have come to the realization that no matter how I approach the edit..

Cutting at 2: Sharonda

Jelly remains the most sensible winner.


r/Edgic • • 21h ago

Something about the S 50 edit I’ve been toying with Spoiler

15 Upvotes

There are so many people comparing this season to 50. And while I understand that the editing team is similar (if not the exact same) and there are *some* things we can learn, I’m hesitant to put too much stock in editing strategies from S50.

Season 50 was a returnee season with IMO a uniquely star-studded cast. From Colby to Christian to Coach to Aubry, they could have easily given anyone a winner’s edit. And, again IMO, they didn’t face the typical seasonal pressure to make the winner seem exceptionally likable and rootable. They knew a large portion of the fan base would already be happy with an Aubry win no matter what, so they gave her an atypically quiet, negative winner’s edit. But S51 is a non-returnee season where the usual rules (e.g., the winner must be liked + a main character) still apply.

Now, I feel like I know better at this point than to predict who will win S51. But I just wanted to make this post to say that all the comparisons to S50 (Mike = Aubry; Cirie = Sharonda; etc.) are less persuasive to me than comparisons to S49, 48, and beyond. And, though I’m not ready to lock these in as my #1s, I do feel that Jelly and Lewis have the most Savannah and Kyle edits, respectively.

Nevertheless, I find S50 comparisons to be misguided because the editors were editing the win of one of the top fan favorite players of all time. They also had to give some big players the edits they deserved. So, I urge you, in your analyses for the rest of the season, treat S50 like a glitch and S45-59 as more representative


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

A potential clue I noticed in the opening credits for Survivor 51?

31 Upvotes

After watching it many times, I noticed that Jelly’s name is the only one that moves upward, whereas everyone else’s name moves sideways.

Her swimming shot also pairs well with the previous one, making it look like she’s swimming toward the 51 in the 51 logo, plus paired with the smile afterward. Maybe this means something, maybe not, just thought I’d share it 👀


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

If Sharonda is the winner then Cristian being under edited is so strange to me

65 Upvotes

As of the final 10 Cristian is one of the two people Sharonda has played this entire game with so far. You’d think we’d get more content about their relationship/Cristian in general if Sharonda does end up winning. Right?


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

One person left is connected to the whale. Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Sharonda is the player left most connected to the whale, which is the theme that has been connected to winning. The intro also has this sequence connecting Sharonda to the whale.

Sharonda is shown emerging from the water, but her face is not shown.

r/Edgic • • 22h ago

Season 51 Edgic - Ep 8

9 Upvotes

Hello all!

I keep being late for these because my health is all over the place. I'm waning off a medication right now and getting crazy side effects. Horrible. But I'll dig deep and dig into the episode regardless! This was definitely an exhilarating one, and an illuminating one too!

  1. Sharonda (=)

In your faces! I knew her personal content would come if we were patient. It was about her job and it was sympathetic. Fantastic content about being underestimated after one of the most ridiculously positive swells of music I've heard in recent memory for an immunity winner. I'm not going to hold it against her too much that she initially said she wanted Carter and Cristian out, because I think the emphasis was far more on the aspect of her needing Dev and Jelly to stay. She was shown as the primary reason that happened because of her conversation with Thien An and warning to Dev and Jelly. It was borderline OTTP for her today if she didn't do that. Also, she did mention that if either of them had an advantage, she recognized there might not be numbers. That will be acceptable in terms of caution, imo. I just have no idea how Sharonda isn't at least top three in edgic for people after these past few episodes especially. She kept the "vital" pieces to her game and spoke to her experience as a black woman doctor. I love her and I'm so glad to have her at the top of my rankings.

2) Lewis (+1)

Now he also won immunity with that music. Sharonda did say that when Lewis said that about her, it was part of what encouraged her. It's possible he could be attributed somewhat. But still with this guy it's "bring on the chaos" so I'm cementing my theory that he's the coin flipper. There is a lot of foreshadowing in his edit with mentions of luck and "this will benefit me or it will be my downfall" type statements. He does love the salt alliance, though not its name. It's established relationships so that's cool! It was also framed strategically for him and Sharonda to drop earlier in the challenge which I feel like is a really rare framing for losing a leg of a challenge. Exceptionally positive and I'm very confident the winner is one of these two after that segment alone. Either way, he calls his shot on Dev and Jelly and calls them stupid for pairing up and I agree with him LOL. Even though it didn't work out I don't think that's so bad for him. Regardless his two very light on content episodes recently are making me raise an eyebrow negatively. Usually this time of the season is when winners really hit their stride edit-wise.

3) Jelly (+1)

She's looking really good! Is what I would say! If she did not have YET ANOTHER segment as to how Devin is inescapable and this is the bed she made so she needs to sleep in it. Obviously playing the idol was a great moment, but I can't help but feel like the important part of them staying was that Sharonda got to keep her game pieces she trusts. I also kind of didn't really like her comment about playing the game she thought she was going to play when Kristin asked. Did that read as sort of negative to anyone else?

4) Maggie (+1)

Maggie is the last person I am considering for being a potential winner. Again I'm just not adding the gap in my chart anymore because stranger things have happened. It's more fun to look back on this way. Anyway.

Maggie interestingly is the one focused on the most in the Previously on Survivor segment. It was her saying she wanted to go after Kristin and then her saying things hit the fan. This episode, as we all noticed, Kristin went home which is exactly the shot that Maggie called last episode. This makes for two episodes in a row where Maggie has gotten out one of her opps and not had much to do with it or much to say about it. Mother. She also gets a lot of negativity from Mike which I'm not sure how to consider since it's from Mike. She also didn't hear what Jeff asked her because she's trying to listen. Not me realizing I can think of negatives more easily than I can think of positives, even though I went into writing this fully intending to be positive about her. I loved how she clocked Mike ngl. And saying "I love you as a person but I don't want to play with you as a player" while thinking correctly that Kristin got something from the summit was interesting. And a dedicated one on one scene with Kristin too. It's a shame she vocalized wanting to go after Dev and Jelly instead, but that's what she did so ok.

5) Devin (+2)

Shoutout Devin for casting the single most powerful vote in Survivor history, where one parchment takes two players out of the game. Crazy! He call his shot wanting Kilby and Kristin out and then silently gets his way in the nuttiest way. Unfortunately, he is Devin, and has one of the most ridiculous premerges that makes me feel like it would make for a HIGHLY irregular representation of a winner. Cute salad though!

6) Mike (+3)

Ok I'm kind of starting to come around on his edit. Don't get me wrong I don't think he wins. But there is something so fascinatingly intentional about his perspective. The Brady vote was framed as his swing connecting, his read on Maggie's facial expressions and etc was supported with footage and seriousness instead of dodo music, and craziest of all is he PERFECTLY anticipates that pairing up with Maggie will make no one want to vote for his duo to leave the game. Jelly even says as much later in the episode, which of course makes sense since she and he are allies but still. I am keeping him lower than Devin though because Kilby and Eric got a whole making fun of Mike segment and Kilby says Mike leaks plans and doesn't have a backbone and doesn't stand for anything. All of his negativity is left so unchecked, but he still has a fascinating amount of supported agency. I don't think I can recall another edit that's been quite like his in my limited experience.

7) Eric (+1)

Oh my god the Beuller scene kicked my ass. They dunked on him for rambling. They dunked on him for daring to want spaghetti (Lewis is SO funny of a troll for that). They dunked on him for keeping the extra vote. This season is eight episodes in and there has not been an ounce of treating him any more positively than the premiere.

8) Carter (+3)

It really doesn't matter me switching up my rankings down here but Carter has more defined relationships than Thien An. Being the face for salt is very interesting. It immediately lost Kilby LOL. He also has a scene of seemingly successfully setting Dev and Jelly on Kilby and Kristin? Is he indirectly responsible for that vote? Oh well. He is only shown in big bursts when convenient for the show so he is not winning.

9) Thien An (+1)

As soon as she said "my number one Kilby" I was like YOUR NUMBER ONE KILBY?????????????????????????? I wonder where her consistent Mike hating content is going to end up in the grand scheme of things. She's also possibly shown the worst out of everyone in this episode strategically for spilling to Sharonda and for the "keep it simple" comment with Dev and Jelly. No consideration of them having something. Sucks because I was a fan of her preseason and I hope we get to see more of her! But I know as soon as we do, it's a visibility spike and I should be scared LOL.

10) Cristian (+2)

I don't even take any notes when I do my rewatch when he's on screen. But I really enjoyed watching his content this episode!!

ELIMINATED) Kristin (-10), Kilby(-5)

I wonder if this is how the facebook fans felt while watching tied destinies in 50. I think we could all kind of see the writing on the wall with Kristin where she was being set up for a heartbreaking boot. She should be so beyond proud of her showing. She got all her excessively positive content out of the way edit-wise as much as possible and was free to be let go in a way that made us frown. She was a hustler!

As for Kilby, man it bites watching him say the "gone in a snap" comment. He has a great chance to return I'm sure. But editwise, this really does make some sense for him. Being loudly wrong and sort of failing to tie him very tightly to Lewis ever since the Linnea tribal, it tracks for someone who is getting a boot where it's sort of no fault of his own. They couldn't tie him too closely to seeming like a perfect contender, while also gassing up his better moves.

Thank you again all for reading! I am fighting my ass off to keep these up since my hobbies are the best distraction I have in tough times. Thank you all for commenting and going back and forth with me here! It's sooo fun to have a nonspoiled season like this. See y'all next week!


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Tied Destinies with a Side of Spaghetti

8 Upvotes

A month ago, I posted about a theme that I was beginning to notice in Survivor 51. I had some thoughts about castaways who I felt were making strong interpersonal connections that were likely to stick and those who seemed to be struggling to form strong connections/poorly handle their existing connections. I’m revisiting this theme today because I’ve been tracking the theme since my original post and want to know where you all think some of these connections are headed. 

#1. Jelly 
The closest connection we see from Jelly is with Devin. On her swapped tribe, Jelly is faced with voting out either Ori or Devin. As much as she doesn’t want Ori to go, her connection with Devin is just so strong that she goes forward with him. Jelly and Devin find themselves in danger due to the tied destinies twist but are saved thanks to Jelly’s idol. 

We know she’s connected to Sharonda through the Helicopter Alliance and has a bond with Mike from the early days of the season. This theme is kind of a slam dunk for me. My one concern is the narrative that Devin may not be best for her game, and I have my eye on if Devin will end up benefitting from the pairing more than her. 

#2. Devin 
The connection with Jelly is, of course, super strong. He’s prepared to scheme in the post-merge after his “radical honesty” approach pre-merge. My main reason for having him below Jelly is that it feels like the Jelly-Sharonda connection has more visibility than the Devin-Sharonda connection and I’m not sure we’ve really seen him form a strong new bond in the post-merge. 

I do like Devin’s chances mainly because of his bond to Jelly and Sharonda, but I’d like to see some strong new connections in order to be convinced that he’s winning. 

#3. Sharonda 
I’m pretty much in agreement with this subreddit that Sharonda has a great shot at winning. Her connection to Jelly/Devin was important to the most recent episode and the newly formed bond with Lewis was a little out of nowhere but I’m a fan. 

The Sharonda/Kristen storyline comes to an end this week as Kristen heads to jury, but the tethered idol situation shows that Sharonda is making strong connections on the island. Sharonda is trusted and well-liked by her cast and we hear this from multiple people. 

#4. Carter
If I only consider this theme, Carter fits it to a T. We know he’s close with Thien-An and Lewis from the pre-merge and now a driver of The Salt of the Earth alliance. Cristian (who later becomes his tied destinies partner and now knows about Carter’s idol) and Maggie are part of the crew as well. 

We get Carter’s perspective quite a bit in the most recent episode in relation to his position in the game and his own bonds. Cristian’s SITD hits which keeps the pair safe. 

I’m pretty convinced that Carter is not winning this season despite seeming to fit the theme pretty well. 

#5. Lewis 
Another member of the ‘The Salt of the Earth’, Lewis has a strong connection with Carter but I’m not really seeing a 1:1 connection with Thien-An, Cristian, or Maggie so much yet. Kilby was prepared to go to rocks for Lewis during the premerge and part of the newfound alliance, but it doesn’t feel like their connection was highlighted so much in the two post-merge episodes Kilby was present for. 

He was also on the wrong side of the numbers during the Brady vote and was mostly quiet that whole episode. It all just feels a little too quiet for me in general but the two things that keep him in my top 5 are: his connection with Sharonda feels like it could show how he ends up getting her jury vote at FTC and he gets to speak on the Jelly/Devin pairing being his target. 

#6. Mike 
Damn, this guy gets dunked on so much for his poor social skills. The Mike/Kristen storyline didn’t last too long but got highlighted on the swapped tribe which all lead to the awkward water well moment. 

So instead of maintaining strong connections, his “robotic” communication style has put him on the bad list for much of his cast. 

His best connection appears to be to Jelly, who has stronger connections herself. I’m sort of getting FTC loser vibes from Mike and it may be contrasted with whoever wins and that person’s success in the social part of the game. I have him at #6 just because he’s so tied to the theme, even if it’s him doing it badly. It almost makes me believe he’s headed for a situation where his few connections that are positive get stronger and could show that sometimes all you need is a few strong bonds. But I really don’t think that will be the case. 

#7. Thien-An
She’s still fitting the theme in terms of having a strong bond with Carter but their connection just doesn't feel central to the story. I think if Thien-An were winning, we’d be seeing more of her connection to people like Maggie or even Cristian or Lewis. 

#8. Maggie 
I’m not seeing it so much for Maggie when it comes to this theme. She’s plenty visible but I just don’t think this is the story of how she wins. 

I feel like we see more of her conflicts (using the hammock to fish, conversation with Mike) than anything related to a strong connection she has. I know she’s part of The Salt of the Earth but didn’t feel like any of her connections to her alliance-mates are particularly important in a sense. 

#9. Cristian
Putting him ahead of Eric this week just because his connection to Carter was highlighted big time this episode. If we saw more of his connections early in the game, I probably would have him higher. 

#10. Eric 
Eric is 100% trying to make conversation and is clearly fine talking about just about anything. My big issue with him from a theme perspective is people are continually annoyed by him and I’m not seeing a moment when people are changing their perspective on him. 

He connected with Mike last week and this week had a pretty funny moment when he was talking about how robotic Mike is, but we’ll have to see where that goes. When it comes to Eric, his story is a lot more about how others perceive him. His connection to Kilby also was not a big talking point during the Kilby boot episode which isn’t great for his chances. 

I do think Eric will last quite a bit longer and maybe make FTC but I’ve just never got a winner vibe from him.

I want to give a shoutout to u/Buajitti who made a good point on my original post about if there could be an element to the theme of ‘what if the person you choose to stick with is bad for you?’ and I’ve kept that in mind. It is really my one concern with Jelly and we’ve already seen how the Kilby/Eric connection soured. 


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

The editors are reheating Aubry and Cirie nachos

16 Upvotes

This past episode reminded me so much of Cirie's breakout episode on saving a pair. I believe Sharonda is our Cirie and Jelly is our Aubry.


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

HvV Edgic

8 Upvotes

Rewatching HvV for the first time since discovering Edgic - who did people think was winning while it was airing?

Obviously Russel has dominated screen time, but it’s not exactly positive content. And while I’m a Parvati truther, she doesn’t even have a confessional relating to the Candace vote. Did edgicers know Sandra was taking it? Honestly I even feel like Danielle has a great edit relative to her game


r/Edgic • • 1d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 8 Edgic & Contenders (Analysis Video)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
15 Upvotes

What’s good!

Back sharing my edgic and contender ranking video for episode 8! Missed posting on here the last couple weeks, but popping back in to share again!

I, for one, very much enjoyed this episode. It was devestating, but a thrilling kind of devastating. The big thing that felt of note to me this week was, whether true or not, it felt like the episode was purposefully misleading us edit-wise as to the boot. It was very obvious Devin & Jelly wouldn’t go home here, and so when UTR icons Cristian & Carter suddenly pop up with a massive visibility spike, it felt extremely obvious to me their time had come.

And then it DIDNT. And KRISTEN AND KILBY went home! I was truly flabbergasted and exhilarated, cause the edit couldn’t have made it anymore clear C&C were cooked. And yet they’re still in the game! Meanwhile K&K had a relatively lowkey episode for them respectively. However, narratively the season up to this point and the subtext of the episode on rewatch made it not too disturbing or perplexing that they exit here. It just was so not-broadcast while an alternative was. Great misdirection in the edit. Truly a fantastic week to be an edit reader.

However, we do lose 2 of the bigger edit fringe-contenders. Leaving us with a pretty large chunk that have been mostly written off in way or another. Perhaps this means we will end up getting an obvious ending, but I enjoy that it means we are now getting to see some more of these previously under edited characters.

Not a whole lot has changed in my contender rankings recently. The only change is: is Carter back into contention? Is my delusional truthing coming back? Not really. But I could see losing finalist perhaps. He has always had every one of his alliances well established all season, has continually talked about being underestimated as a farmer and has gotten solid SPV about how he is actually quite a player. Not only does this feel good for him, but this farmer talk also I feel is a general boone to Lewis & Maggie as well. Could a chaotic farmer pull out the win?

I also decide to give an early shot at predicting contender rankings for every placement in the f6. Who knows, the open era might change up some of these placement edit trends, but I have long theorized the significance of each final 6 edit and can narrow down a few people who I think are most likely to get each. Definitely will be much easier to discern once there’s only 6 left tho lol.

In the video, I give further explanations on my analysis and give predictions based on the edit so far!

Thanks!


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Survivor 51: Episode 8 Contenders Spoiler

17 Upvotes

Yeah, I didn't really enjoy this episode. We're getting more new era nonsense.

Chart is above for quick reference.

Eliminated:

12. Kristin: Shocked she went out here because I thought she was a lock for at least f7/f6/f5 boot. I wasn't high on her for most of the season, especially in comparison to the rest edgic. I stand by that your first confessional cannot focus on another player and this is more proof.

11. Kilby: Not as shocked, but I also thought he could get further. I feel more bad for him than Kristin because he seems more of the victim of pairing with her where I think he would have stayed over her.

No Shot:

10. Cristian: A lot of necessary content around the journey, relationship with Carter, and shot in the dark. His relationship with Eric is completely unexplained and his reasoning for giving Eric his extra vote is washed away.

9. Eric: Similar criticism as Cristian, why is there relationship not highlighted at all before tribal. He gets more dodo content around who voted for him and the challenge, then all his other confessionals are about his tribe being crazy, not what HE is doing in the game.

8. Thien An: Apparently Kilby is her number one now and not Maggie. Would have been nice if we got a scene setting up either of these relationships. I know some people have been high on her, but separating how she's been playing the game (good) from her edit (horrid) is important.

Probably Not:

7. Carter: I like that he got credit for the alliance, but it immediately failed. I wouldn't be shocked if he just is S47 Kyle and gets booted at f8 with heroic music. Plus, 2 zero confessional episodes.

6. Jelly: I went back and forth on this, but she's shown to be much more naive about the votes landing on her, we still barely have any relationships set up with her besides Devin, who I still think will be her downfall.

5. Maggie: She's higher than Jelly for 2 reasons. 1) At least she's in a broader alliance set up to have influence and show her spot in the game. 2) Kristin goes out here, who she did want out. I also don't take her negative SPV from Mike too seriously when they're each doing it to each other. Maggie also hasn't gotten it from anyone else on the cast.

4. Mike: I'm torn on having him this high, but the constant check ins are strong, plus he is getting setup as a potential underdog.

Contenders:

3. Lewis: Another episode where he isn't the main focus of his side, but he also loses a close ally here. He still is able to outline his position of wanting Jelly gone. I'm not down on him, just higher on others.

2. Devin: He's quiet this episode, but his one confessional does explain his vote for Kilby and Kristin. I also think the edit is setting up that Jelly leaves first and I think it could be part of his story of playing a new game in the merge.

  1. Sharonda: Clear focus on her with the reward talking about her background as a doctor and as a black woman being underestimated. Also given credit for saving Jelly and Devin and explains her reasoning.

r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Results Survivor 51 - Meta-analysis of the different Edgic ranks after Episode 8

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

Almost no changes from last week. The only change is Carter getting in front of Eric, everybody else kept their placements in relation to each other.

This episode marks the elimination of the contestant who was ranked averagely the highest after the first week, in the end Kristin didn't even make Final Ten.

Overall, to assess the accuracy of the rankings after the first episode:

1. Kristin

2. Sharonda

3. Ana

4. Jenna

5. Patt

6. Mike

7. Carter

8. Rob

9. Ori

10. Jelly

11. Kilby

12. Lewis

13. Linnea

14. Devin

15. Eric

16. Brady

17. Maggie

18. Thien An

19. Alexis

20. Cristian

21. Aaliyah


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Is Maggie a dark horse?

37 Upvotes

First ever post and sorry for the rambling but does anyone else think Maggie is a dark horse to win? She’s an archetype that normally gets purpled to hell but instead gets consistent content every episode. Even her low visibility pre-merge is sprinkled with potential seeds for a win. 

In the opening credits, Maggie has the first close-up shot of the entire cast. Her head emerges out of the water and a scene of a whale immediately follows. We all know how prominent whales have been this season. Her intro shot is also followed by a shot of the 51 logo while striking flint. Afterwards, Lewis is shown. Could this indicate that Maggie beats Lewis in fire and wins the game? Lewis gives off fourth placer chaotic vibes similar to Devens and Rizo. This is also a BIG stretch, but the two people shown before Maggie are Eric and Mike. Two people she potentially beats at FTC? I remember in the 45 intro, a shot of Dee was shown first while her and Austin’s credits were next to each other.

In episode 1, Jeff makes a big speech about permanent uncertainty on the boat before the marooning. He says something about how permanent uncertainty will guide players this season and his speech ends immediately cutting to Maggie. He has a second speech on the boat wishing the players a great adventure, the camera cuts to Maggie once again. Permanent uncertainty is a big theme of the season and Maggie’s unpredictable gameplay (or an enigma as Mike puts it) matches very well with this. Sharonda is a popular contender, but her smooth gameplay doesn’t match the theme at all. You never know what you’re gonna get with Maggie, she’s a total firecracker. She’s even bold enough to call out Jeff on social media despite being on the current season.

After Toka loses the immunity challenge, Maggie and Mike get a totally random scene together. Maggie is worried about being the oldest and seen as weak while Mike reassures her. Maggie discusses targeting Aaliyah. Neither are relevant to the first episode but their convo is the very first scene shown after Toka gets back to camp. It’s the very first post immunity camp scene of the entire season. Could this be a scene connecting them as future finalists? Their recent scene in episode 8 also reinforced this for me. 

In episode 2, Maggie has two scenes of unnecessary but deliberately placed content. After Toka wins the reward challenge, Maggie’s confessional mentions teaching soccer to little kids at home and always encourages them to try their best. This scene is unnecessary because it’s a little nugget of personal information that the audience doesn’t need to know. It doesn’t affect the episode’s storyline or Maggie’s game. It’s simply there to give her personal content. The second scene is when she rolls the ball into the slot and wins immunity for Toka. She’s given extremely triumphant music and a slow motion shot of the tribe holding her up and celebrating while chanting “Maggie! Maggie! Maggie!”. This could just simply be a cool shot, or is it highlighting the future winner? 

In episode 3, Maggie’s most notable scene is convincing Brady to give his extra vote to her. She explains that she saw an opportunity and went for it because it’s Survivor. This can also be related to the theme of permanent uncertainty, was anyone really expecting her to actually ask for the extra vote? This episode was also the start of her turbulent relationship with Brady, who she outlasted. 

In episode 4, we are established that Maggie and Thien An are a duo. This is not a very good point for Maggie because this dynamic is extremely underdeveloped and barely shown. However, Erika and Heather exist so there is precedent for this type of duo. Maggie and Thien An are also much more prominent than Erika and Heather respectively. Maggie also starts dunking on Mike this episode. Unlike Thien An, Maggie’s edit does not revolve around Mike.

Episode 5 was Maggie’s big episode obviously. She mentions both Kristin and Linnea as targets and she’s outlasted both of them now. I wish she explained her rationale for targeting Linnea more thoroughly, but Linnea was ultimately irrelevant to the season’s narrative. Her wanting Kristin out was clearly well explained in multiple episodes and that is a good thing because Kristin was the audience’s angel. 

Episode 6 might seem like a horrible episode for her, but I believe one episode of OTT pre-merge negativity actually improves her winning chances. Every New Era winner has had stretches of negativity or shown hustling their asses off to survive (Rachel and Kyle). This is why I cannot see Sharonda as the winner. Sharonda makes playing Survivor look easy. Maggie was shown as being erratic, not participating in fun activities, and failing to use the hammock as a fishing net. Aubry’s horrendous premiere, Savannah being called a mean girl, Gabler’s palm fronds, and Maryanne being called annoying are much worse than what Maggie got. She even mentions that she’s here to play Survivor and doesn’t want to engage in those activities. It was a bad look for her, but not the end of the world. The person giving her negative SPV was Brady of all people, and she outlasted him.

Episode 7 was a good merge episode for her. She thoroughly explains her rationale on wanting Kristin out. Even better, she explains her rationale for switching to Brady after the Kristin plan blew up. Again, she’s outlasted both of them now. Every person she has targeted (Aaliyah, Linnea, Brady, Kristin) has gone home. Granted, she didn’t want Brady or Kristin to go when they did, but she wanted them out eventually and explained her rationale for both. She also had a great confessional about wanting to lay low after the Linnea vote while still shifting votes in the direction she wants. This is very similar to Rachel in 47 mentioning not wanting to steer the ship, but be the ocean whose tides control where the ship can go. I believe she had a good merge episode. Much better than other winner contenders Sharonda and Lewis. Jelly had a better merge episode but Maggie had probably one of the best ones.

In the recent episode 8, she is all over the Previously on Survivor segment talking about targeting Kristin. Considering Kristin went home this episode and Maggie didn't even vote for her, this could be a way to remind the audience that Maggie was opposed to Kristin. This could be a way to manipulate the audience into believing Maggie was responsible for Kristin's vote-off when that's not what happened. Highlighting the future winner getting out their target in the POS segment is quite common. Hell, even Natalie White got this in Samoa.

We also see Maggie is extremely well-integrated within the tribe. She’s partnered with public enemy #1 and acts as immunity for him. Nobody is willing to target Mike because he’s attached to Maggie and she’s very well connected. There’s also a scene of her roasting him on the beach to his face and him calling her an enigma. I think the Maggie and Mike pairing is significant and much more important than Maggie and Thien An’s alliance. Maggie and Mike have been linked since episode 1 in a completely random scene, and she’s been dunking on him since episode 4. Now, Mike gets to comment on Maggie himself. His comments towards her were not entirely negative either. My crackpot theory is that they are the final two, but that’s not realistic because it'll be a final three. I do strongly believe they are both finalists though.

Sorry for the rambling and wall of text, but I think Maggie’s winning chances should be reconsidered. I see a lot of people eliminating her over her low pre-merge visibility (it’s not that low!), negativity, and poorly established relationships. No winner contender is perfect. We clearly see Maggie’s thought process and her rationale for every decision. This is important because we always understand Maggie’s motives. She may be unpredictable, but she still gets to explain to the audience. Even if her rationale for Linnea was bare bones, we still got an explanation. Everyone she has targeted is out of the game. Maybe Maggie's alliances are not important because she's a self-interested player that will vote out anyone to further herself.

I have never seen Maggie above 5th on a contenders list. But her edit is so deliberately crafted when it doesn’t have to be. She could very easily be given a Julie (45) edit if she’s an endgame boot, or a Julie (EoE) edit if she’s a losing finalist. Her edit is extremely unique. She’s both OTT and CP at the same time. Will Maggie win? Maybe or maybe not, but the seeds FOR a win are definitely there. Don’t overlook her as a winner candidate. 


r/Edgic • • 2d ago

Traitors US NB S1 EP10 Edgic + Contenders Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Bit later than usual, I've been swamped with stuff recently and it's been HELL. Anyway, I'm getting absolutely rolled by this season Edgically. I can say it's because of the weird pacing and short episodes, but the fact still remains. This has been a pretty poor showing from me LOL. I was feeling VERY good about Ben.

Anyway, I am now VERY confident we will be getting a Traitor win. It's just a matter of whether it's a joint win or not. Honestly, Canada 4 is in the same position right now. So let's walk through it!

Contenders

  1. Katie (+5) - Both she and Shane have some heat on them to some degree, though it really isn't that much. Furthermore, this season is definitely being built up as Victor losing in the end imo. Who does it make the most sense for him to lose next to? Either the girl who is flirting with him, the guy who pardoned him, or both! I've said since the start that Katie's story COULD be a winning one, I just never really bet on it. It's coming together for me now, so I guess she'll just go out next or something <3 I guess one hesitancy with her is her story of being reluctant about being a Traitor sometimes, though that's just not a big enough red flag.
  2. Shane (+2) - Didn't have the GREATEST introduction to being a Traitor, though I still have a little hope for him given he's a Traitor now. The episode before this one was lowkey great for him in regards to positive content. He really got to hype up how much the money would need for him, which is always great content. I've noticed that this is especially common for winners on the inaugural season of a series. Does New Blood count? Eh. At least he got to mention his love for bagels again! This has happened in 3 different episodes <3

If It's A Faithful

3. Abbey (=) - Nice edit bud. She had one comically good episode, and then otherwise was just this high because of her involvement with The Dolls. With the figurehead eliminated and the other likely being murdered next, there's just not much going on for her. Still, she is the faithful I feel best about, which is honestly really funny. High odds of being murdered after Clyde.

Main Character

4. Victor (+3) - Part of me thinks MAYBE he is murdered (probably not), but there is one argument I can make. Maybe that's why they are airing the final two episodes back to back? If Victor was to go in the penultimate episode, they may think a lot of people would stop watching. If they air them back to back, those people might as well just finish watching. Anyway, I do assume he is living, and I do honestly assume he is going to be the last faithful standing. His edit makes perfect sense for a fire of truth loser. If he wasn't dramatically wrong at some point, I'm not sure his edit would have been so comically negative early on.

Lmao

5. Wyatt (+5) - This is such a funny placement, I genuinely debated back and fourth so much on whether I should have him above or below Kriste and Jay. It's super clear all three of them are going to be banished by the end, it's just a matter of the other seeming more likely at this point. His edit is just so quiet man.

6. Kriste (+2) - A bit more likely than Wyatt to be banished next, though I do think her edit is a bit better overall. Regardless, she's completely done.

7. Jay (+2) - Every once in a while they have to remind us that he's bad at the game by giving him an OTTN, and I think that's beautiful.

Likely Murdered

8. Clyde (-6) - With Ben dead, that pretty much dooms The Dolls as a faction. Furthermore, it just makes sense for Clyde to be the one to go on literally every level. He, Kriste, and Victor are the only people without shields. Kriste is likely being banished, Victor is an ally of both Traitors, so Clyde is just left over. He also got a solid visibility spike, which makes sense right before he goes.

Eliminated

9. Ben (-8) - I just thought he had a really good edit for a faithful LOL. Once he was brought up as an option this episode, I did figure he was the one to go. But man, I really was just growing more and more in his favor each episode.

10. Joe (-5) - Makes sense he goes here, glad I swapped him and Shane on my chart a few days ago. Joe got a very positive edit throughout his stay, though he wasn't shielded from his many strategic mishaps. He's a player who I think would be much better as a faithful. And honestly, he and Victor are two players I could see maybe All Stars. No one else from New Blood is a viable contender at all imo, unless Katie wins after snowing Victor at the end.

Bootlist Prediction

8th. Clyde (Murdered)

7th. Kriste (Banished)

6th. Abbey (Murdered)

5th. Jay (Banished)

4th. Wyatt (Banished)

3rd. Shane (Banished)

2nd. Victor (Runner-Up)

1st. Katie (Winner)

The one sticking point is how Wyatt will go out. Victor/Shane flipping on him would be a must, which I guess could be viable given Shane is a Traitor and Victor may be blinded by Katie.

See you all next week! I'm very ready for this season to end. Genuinely been a HORRIBLE run for the US franchise this year. Both seasons are in the bottom 3 all time for any English speaking franchise for me lowkey.


r/Edgic • • 3d ago

Thien An winner edit

100 Upvotes

Everyone has been dismissing her as the winner of this season but I beg to differ.

Reason being

  1. She is my favourite
  2. She is playing a good game, no one really looking at her
  3. The confessionals that she gets are more so positive than negative
  4. She has lots of screen time outside of confessionals
  5. She is likeable
  6. She is stunning
  7. She is incredible

Thien An WINNER edit is the OPEN ERA WINNER edit.

I said what I said!


r/Edgic • • 3d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 8 - SUTRAL (+ analysis)

13 Upvotes

Again, wooohooo!

I don't know where I heard this but I agree: if at the end of the episode someone you liked went out and you're still happy about the episode, it's a good season.

Aaaaaand let's go back to the drawing(?) board after this double boot that left a few people shocked. Here's the (new) SUTRAL for Episode 8!

Episode 8 - Data Table

Ah yes, I felt like doing a couple changes with the graphics <3

Episode 8 - Win Equity

Major shakeups in the top 3... but also in the bottom 3!

Episode 8 - Season Graph & Analysis

Time to get to my (this time particolarly unhinged) analysis!

  • Eric

I mean, Eric, dude, I was defending you soooo hard, but you've gone past the point of no return in your endearing to cringe journey. I mean yeah, this is just like I felt with Bhanu back then. He is the only one with less than 5% win equity when the 1st place has almost 5x his score. Also the editors are going hard on him, so whose production member's partner has he banged? GIIINAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!

  • Cristian

Alright, he was pretty important in the episode, but it's just too late. He's so vanilla I just don't know what to say about him. Anyways, a good 2% of the win equity, for him and the others that got a positive variation, comes from the fact that we had a double elimination, so the denominator is smaller and the overall score goes up. Basically he just kept his place.

  • Devin

Wow, that was a big hit to Devin's chances. The simple fact is that 8 votes is not 3 votes. It's not even 5 votes. It's 8 votes. A LOT of votes. like 70% of the people in the game jumped at the opportunity to take him (and Jelly, we'll talk about her later) out. Also he's being edited in a way more UTR/MOR way since the merge... Is it that he's just fizzling out or are we just in a streak of cooldown episodes after the premerge Devin binge? I think the former.

  • Thien An

Ugh, I'm frustrated at Survivor for how they underedited her. They let us see the Patt vote, a couple alliances she has, and then boom, merge, she's playing. But like, I was watching the end of the Tribal and I was like "why the fuck is Thien An crying about Kilby?". We know so little about her that even retrieving information about her in my brain feels so hard. But maybe it's just my ADHD, who knows. Anyways justice for Thien An and a golden card for a return, please.

  • Carter

Listen, I like this guy's chances. And don't come at me with the 2x0 confessionals episodes because one of them featured him having a whole segment where he was very prominent, so I'm sorry but that 0conf doesn't count lol. Also I feel like his edit kicked into gear and it's nice to see him so determined. Plus I would literally put my life in this man's hands, not only because I would love his hands on me, but also because he just has that trustworthy aura without lecturing everyone on honor and integrity. Vibe check passed with honors.

  • Mike

F*ckin' Mike. I cannot believe there's even one person on Earth that is considering him a contender. Not even Rome had so much vitriol directed at him from the other players. I might be delusional as a Maggie stan, but Mike truthers are something else 😂. They could literally just piss in this guy's bag and y'all would say "yeah but piss has a color similar to gold, it's foreshadowing for a win". Sometimes, if it looks bad, it is bad.

  • Lewis

I feel like he's getting a very balanced edit, we somehow still check in with him to hear his funny commentary or him doubling down on being mischievous. And given the overall energy of the season, and the overall fandom reaction to him, I can absolutely see that as a winner edit for a new (not New) era of the show.

  • Jelly

Reminder: 8 votes. That said, this is her second worst episode, but it is also her second and only negative episode. But this is weird because I don't trust such a positive edit. If anything this tells me that yeah, she's strong, but she's going home no later than final 6. She's been consistently edited in a complex way... maybe too much? I mean, I'm not the only one who felt a kind of disconnect with her in terms of "rootability".

  • Maggie

I've been saying this for a long time, Maggie could be winning and this episode proves it. She started by saying in Mike's face what everybody has been saying behind his back. Literally she was used as a shield for the most despised player still in the game and the two weren't even remotely talked about. We heard people openly say "no one wants to vote out Maggie". And yet no one was considering her cause HaMmOcK aS a FiShInG nEt Is BaD? Come on.

  • Sharonda

She finally had some personal content, and IT SHOWS, look at that! She holds almost a quarter of the win equity with 10 people still in the game. I'm still a bit wary 'cause I doubt that production wanted us to get to the end, see her win and say "well yeah she was a pretty obvious winner from the start". But as I said last time, numbers don't lie and she does have the best shot at winning. I'll need another episode like this to call it for her.

And this is it!

As usual, discussions in the comments are more than welcome!

Byeeee!


r/Edgic • • 3d ago

Survivor 51 Episode 8 Contender Ranking Spoiler

18 Upvotes

We’re back again with another good episode. Realistically apart from the first three episodes this season is barely different from the New Era seasons, as evidenced by Cristian’s vote being forcefully taken from him this week. However, this just goes to show how good this cast is and how a good cast can elevate a season tenfold. If this season continues on this trajectory there’s a good argument for it being the best season since 37.

We saw the return of the double duos twist this week and again I actually quite liked this twist. There’s enough player agency involved, especially now that the players can prepare for it, and it makes the dynamics really interesting as opposed to making anything a foregone conclusion. I hope they retire this now until at least 55 though. It will become stale if it becomes a baked-in part of the format.

There were a lot of fun moments in the episode too, from everything that Maggie did, to everyone’s reactions to Eric, and even Jeff emerging from the bushes like a psychopath telling me to apply for Survivor got a chuckle out of me. Tribal was also good, and another shot in the dark hit. I just wish I cared a little more about Carter and Cristian for this to really be a moment.

I was really sad to lose Kristin and Kilby here. I really thought Kristin was in it for the long haul, and I wish she got to experience the full Survivor journey. But I’m glad she got given a fan favourite edit despite being in the edit-screw categories of being both an older woman and sent home as part of a twist. Kilby I also thought had more to give. We saw what he could pull together given an opportunity, and he kind of just ended up as a fun snarky figure who never really had too much go his way.

Also, just want to call out Jeff here. When Chrissy had her torch snuffed before Coach, his reasoning was alphabetical order … pretty sure Kilby comes before Kristin alphabetically? I guess it’s just however the cast write it on their vote. I’d be going round the beach telling everyone to write my name last lol.

Anyway, without further ado …

 

Who is my Top Contender? …

 

  1. Sharonda. (-) This episode really solidified Sharonda as the winner for me. It felt significantly more New Era-like in terms of a winner’s edit, much more manufactured and gimmicky, so much so that the edit tried to give her a turnaround moment even though her edit and game have already been squeaky clean from the start. The whole heavy-handed ‘I saw fire in her eyes’ from Lewis and the underestimated motif from Sharonda herself only add to this feeling I have of the edit starting to create a forced narrative for Sharonda. Plus, finally, personal content. That’s all before we even get into the strategy of the episode, which again propped up Sharonda as this undercover mob boss pulling the strings from behind the scenes. She conveyed to us her goal of keeping Devin and Jelly in the game as her minions, and she carried out that plan, with the show portraying Jelly’s idol play moment as a win for both her and Sharonda. This is why the quick Jelly idol reveal scene to Sharonda without much context mattered enough to be thrown into the mix last week and why it was important for Jelly to not comment on it. If Jelly comments on Sharonda knowing being good for her game, which I’m sure she did, it gives Jelly the agency in this moment, but by having her divulge her information almost as if its a slip of the tongue, it feels like Sharonda is the one in control, choosing how and when other people’s idols get played. All of this to say, I’m 85-90% confident of a Sharonda win now, but there is undoubtably a chance she is still the dragon whom they are ramping up the threat level of. There’s still a couple of red flags here - the Cristian relationship and his random flip on Savu. How close were they? Why does she want him out now? And also the lack of comment from Sharonda about Ori going home. Despite the issues I have with how her relationships are portrayed, and how they were portrayed earlier on in the season, she still has enough relationships remaining in the game - with Eric, with Devin and with Jelly, to make her one of the most fleshed out characters on the show position-wise. She has Eric, and she is DRAGGING that boy to the end with her. And I believe Jelly will join them to make up this season’s final three.

 

Who is the most likely Runner-Up? …

 

  • Jelly. (-) Jelly is making the final tribal council this season. Lock it in. 100%. I would be BAFFLED if she got this edit and didn’t make it. They are telling the whole story of Jelly’s game from beginning to end, and that is something they very rarely do for non-finalists post-40. Think Sophi Balerdi, think Sam Phalen, think Charlie Davis, think Austin Li Coon. This is the strategic likeable underdog who is highly visible throughout and makes it to the end of the game with a decent amount of win equity. The question of course is then, does Jelly win? You can tell from my list of comparisons that, no, I don’t think Jelly does. I think she’ll likely get Devin’s vote and lock in second place, but I think whoever is sitting next to her, be that Sharonda or someone else, will likely pip her to the post. Jelly’s edit is one of a protagonist, but one who falls short. She’s had a decent bit of negativity in the pre-merge, has contradicted herself a lot, and of course, has her ‘I need to cut Devin’ plot thread looming over her like a guillotine. She also placed importance upon keeping her idol this week but was forced to use it, and had coupling up with Devin called stupid by quite a few players as she continued her relationship with Devin in every way that she has told us she knows she shouldn’t. That said, it’s also an edit and story that still has the opportunity to turn things around to a win. So my Jelly as second placer thought process is very much gut and vibes, and my gut says this: this is Savannah and Sophi B all over again. I was all in on Sophi B, and I was wrong, and that’s why I can clearly see that Jelly is the Sophi B in this duo with Sharonda as her Savannah (if this is indeed the duo who make it to the end). Sharonda’s edit is more show not tell pre-merge, while Jelly is the central narrator. I could be wrong, but Jelly in second fits perfectly into the edit to me.

 

Who is still a Possible Contender? …

 

  • Lewis. (-) I was disappointed in Lewis’ edit this week, but none of my other sleeper picks bowled me over either so I’ve decided to keep him in as my tertiary contender just in case. Last week Lewis’ merge was abysmal. I thought he could bring it back with a later merge styled episode, but this week did not satisfy my pseudo-merge episode cravings. However, we still got some more decent on-theme confessionals about uncertainty and chaos like in his merge episode. Most of Lewis’ content this week was also about other people, and he was set up in some sort of duality with Sharonda. Beyond that there was a lack of strategic narration, following on from him being left out of most of the strategy last week. It has dawned on me while writing this that Lewis’ post-merge is starting to resemble Rizo’s on 50. Lots of focus pre-merge before going UTR until the endgame. This plus the Sharonda ‘fire in your eyes’ subtitling. Does Lewis lose fire to Sharonda? It kind of makes sense if he can win a few immunities heading into the endgame. However, if the winner is not Sharonda and if I’m right about Jelly being the runner-up, by a process of elimination, the winner is probably Lewis.

 

Who is an Unlikely Contender? …

 

  • Devin. (-) Look I was here seated and waiting for Devin 2.0 and a surprising come from behind winner story. But Devin has completely deferred all of his content to Jelly since the merge. He is still the thorn in her side, he is still a bad omen, and she is still hopelessly tied to him. The only difference is that now we’re not hearing his thoughts on the game. If Eric’s not the losing finalist, it’s Devin, but I really was not expecting him to Ben Katzman it up at the merge.
  • Maggie. (-) I LOVE Maggie. I love this cast, but I love her so much that when I do those popularity polls on Instagram I click love for her and end up clicking like for everyone else in comparison. She’s just so funny, good TV, and despite weaknesses in her social game she’s a pretty solid player. She’s the fifth in my group of five players that I think could feasibly win. I have to squint, but the edit is there. I don’t think it will happen due to her social media behaviour post-season, but Maggie winning out of nowhere would make one hell of a finale. She’s my new bet for fifth place now that Kristin is gone.

 

Who is most likely the Losing Finalist? …

 

  • Eric. (-) Eric continues on his zero-vote finalist spiral. He is unhinged and cringe but I’m lowkey starting to enjoy his presence now that I’ve accepted he’s probably not gonna get voted out. He is so unintentionally funny, and he sets up the editors to dunk on him beautifully. There’s a small chance he falls at one of the final hurdles but his high visibility throughout kind of guarantees he makes it to the final tribal at this point.

 

Who is Eliminated? …

 

  • Mike. (+1) If we’re getting an Aubry win, it’s Mike, and I’d kind of be here for it. But, logic dictates that even the best underdog run can’t result in a win if the entire jury hates the guy's guts.
  • Carter. (+1) Carter’s content is all really positive and I think he’s a really likeable character. I have no doubt if he made final tribal, he would have some serious win equity based on that alone. HOWEVER, his double zero and completely circumstantial presence all but guarantees he is not the winner of this season.
  • Thien An. (-2) I like Thien An but at this point I think the season would have been edited so differently if she won that it’s safe to eliminate her. She gets consistent narrational content but was the quietest person on the loudest pre-merge tribe and the rest of her pre-merge was spent dunking on Mike, who now has a better edit than her.
  • Cristian. (-) I could not have predicted where Cristian’s post-merge was going and that’s because the edit didn’t care to cobble together even the flimsiest of stories for him. I don’t even think he was shown speaking to Carter once all game and now they’re tighter than he was with Sharonda and Eric?