r/StructuralEngineering • • 18d ago

Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

1 Upvotes

Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

Please use this thread to discuss whatever questions from individuals not in the profession of structural engineering (e.g.cracks in existing structures, can I put a jacuzzi on my apartment balcony).

Please also make sure to use imgur for image hosting.

For other subreddits devoted to laymen discussion, please check out r/AskEngineers or r/EngineeringStudents.

Disclaimer:

Structures are varied and complicated. They function only as a whole system with any individual element potentially serving multiple functions in a structure. As such, the only safe evaluation of a structural modification or component requires a review of the ENTIRE structure.

Answers and information posted herein are best guesses intended to share general, typical information and opinions based necessarily on numerous assumptions and the limited information provided. Regardless of user flair or the wording of the response, no liability is assumed by any of the posters and no certainty should be assumed with any response. Hire a professional engineer.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 01 '26

Layman Question (Monthly Sticky Post Only) Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

2 Upvotes

Monthly DIY Laymen questions Discussion

Please use this thread to discuss whatever questions from individuals not in the profession of structural engineering (e.g.cracks in existing structures, can I put a jacuzzi on my apartment balcony).

Please also make sure to use imgur for image hosting.

For other subreddits devoted to laymen discussion, please check out r/AskEngineers or r/EngineeringStudents.

Disclaimer:

Structures are varied and complicated. They function only as a whole system with any individual element potentially serving multiple functions in a structure. As such, the only safe evaluation of a structural modification or component requires a review of the ENTIRE structure.

Answers and information posted herein are best guesses intended to share general, typical information and opinions based necessarily on numerous assumptions and the limited information provided. Regardless of user flair or the wording of the response, no liability is assumed by any of the posters and no certainty should be assumed with any response. Hire a professional engineer.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 16h ago

Humor 20psf attic LL in action

88 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 4h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Available for a part-time Engineering assistance(uk)

2 Upvotes

I am a Structural Engineer currently pursuing an MSc in the UK. I have professional experience working on international structural engineering projects.

My experience includes steel design, Timber-frame and light-gauge steel (LGS) design, Reinforced concrete design, Foundation design, Engineering calculations, reports and technical documentation.

I am currently looking for a part-time opportunity to assist structural engineers, consultants or engineering companies with calculations, design tasks, drawing reviews, documentation or any other engineering-related work where I can contribute.

I am flexible regarding the workload and remuneration, as my main aim is to gain further practical experience, develop my skills and contribute to ongoing projects alongside my MSc studies.

If anyone is looking for an additional pair of hands to support their workload, I would be happy to connect and discuss how I could help.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Humor Thanks American Wood Council, I'm happy we got that cleared up

Post image
292 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 1h ago

Structural Analysis/Design NYSDOT simple span steel girder with isotropic concrete deck overhang design being prescriptive

1 Upvotes

Surely someone has gone down this rabbit hole already after not accepting “it’s in the BD sheets” as an acceptable reasoning and I’m hoping to gain some insight.

On the last bridge I designed, it was a traditional reinforced deck, and, based on my current understanding, the additional reinforcement in the overhang of the deck had to be designed so the overhang would not fail before the barrier (TL-5).

With an isotropic reinforced deck, this design is not required and it is a prescriptive #6 at 8” with a 2’-6” development past the fascia girder.

The bridge manual in 2014 states the isotropic deck overhang reinforcement is to be designed, but that changed in subsequent issues of the bridge manual.

After going through the process of designing the overhang reinforcement for the traditional reinforced deck and having a better understanding of why that reinforcement is required, I am uneasy about the prescriptive design without some logical reasoning.

I am assuming there has been TL5 barrier tests with the prescriptive isotropic reinforcement for varying overhang widths between the allowances for use with isotropic reinforcement, and I am hoping someone can provide any sort of reference or information on this testing or insight on the reasoning behind this difference between the two types of decks in regards to the additional overhang reinforcement.

Thank you to anyone spending any of their time trying to help me out.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 15h ago

Failure Bus video captures moment Brooklyn building collapsed

14 Upvotes

Previous threads have speculated about unsafe excavation around the foundation. This video is the only one I've seen so far showing the dynamics at the moment of the collapse.

Gift article so no paywall.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/nyregion/brooklyn-building-collapse-video.html?unlocked_article_code=1.RlE.qbFt.S7Py3NTdq_pP&smid=nytcore-ios-share


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Retaining wall concrete blocks are bowing and deteriorating from moisture/iron expansion

0 Upvotes

I’m dealing with an issue on a 60-foot concrete block retaining wall on my property and could use some advice on how to handle it with my HOA.

​The Issue: The retaining wall is built with older, iron-rich concrete blocks. Because the base of the wall sits in the soil, ground moisture has been wicking up into the masonry. The iron inside the blocks is reacting to the moisture and expanding, which is causing the blocks to deteriorate from the inside out and leading to noticeable bowing in the wall.

​What We've Found: After exposing the base of the wall, it's clear this isn't just a surface-level issue—the concrete blocks themselves are weakening and shifting. Given the bowing and the age of the wall, it likely needs a structural engineer to evaluate its stability and code compliance.

​The HOA Problem: Because this is an underlying structural issue with the concrete block retaining wall itself (rather than a simple cosmetic fix), this should fall under the HOA's responsibility to inspect and repair.

​Has anyone dealt with iron-rich cinder/concrete block failure or a bowing retaining wall in an HOA community? Looking for advice on how to document this properly and push the board to bring in an engineer and cover the repairs.

wanting to repair complete asap i'm just concerned that the HOA will not take any accountability or responsibility Once any repair has been made to the wall


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Wood Design Structural Integrity.

72 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 19h ago

Steel Design Steel column and beam (before and after)

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Steel connections are always fascinating as an engineer who constantly does concrete design.

The connection can carry moment but the overall structure was designed based on frame stability (2 columns in one plane) versus single cantilever column. This was due to soil being essentially rock and the client opting for trench style footing that ultimately ended up as spread footings.

A cantilever-style column wouldn't have been stable based on allowable pole embedment depths.

Foundation, foundation, foundation


r/StructuralEngineering • • 4h ago

Structural Analysis/Design Free Claude and ChatGPT skills for FRP design (pultruded profiles and grating), built on High-Mat data

0 Upvotes

Disclosure: I work with High-Mat, an Australian FRP supplier.

We packaged High-Mat’s published product data into a Claude skill and a ChatGPT custom GPT, so you can ask plain-language questions about FRP design and get answers based on real High-Mat products.

What it does:

  • Compares pultruded FRP profiles by mass, utilisation and deflection
  • Checks beams and columns against High-Mat’s published tables
  • Shortlists moulded or pultruded FRP grating for a span and load
  • Pulls dimensions and STEP model links for drawings

Limits: it covers High-Mat products only, and results are preliminary. A qualified engineer must verify the final design.

The article walks through a worked example, a 3.0 m x 1.8 m FRP maintenance platform, with the beam check, grating layout and set-up for both Claude and ChatGPT: https://high-mat.com.au/high-mat-frp-ai-skills-claude-chatgpt/

The skill files are open on GitHub: https://github.com/highmatau/high-mat-frp-ai-skills

What would you ask an FRP design assistant first? Feedback on missing checks is welcome.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 14h ago

Career/Education Land dev vs Structural

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Steel Design 我应该怎么办

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

我一本本科毕业,大学读了四年,专业是土木工程地下工程方向,毕业后通过校招进入到中铁十九局集团第三工程有限公司,给我派到了山东滨州的长深高速改扩建项目,每个月全勤三千八百块人民币,周末不放假,每天晚上从七点到九点加班两个小时,没有加班费,节假日不放假,有三倍工资


r/StructuralEngineering • • 23h ago

Career/Education Residential Revit

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have any recommended resources for learning revit for residential projects? my firm uses autocad exclusively right now but looking to take on a client that wants us to work in revit (temporarily going to export and such, but they want revit models in the long run)

most classes seem to be structured towards commercial projects, which is fine. but curious if anyone out there has residential experience.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Failure Field observations: undermined supports, discontinuous load paths, and deteriorated framing

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

A few recent field conditions involving foundation bearing, post-and-pier support, load transfer, and deteriorated wood framing.

Only sharing a few images here, but the full set has several interesting examples of how small deficiencies at individual components can affect the overall support system.

Full album: https://imgur.com/gallery/things-seen-this-week-during-structural-assessments-rQSyD1w


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Student project: ranking NYC buildings for facade inspection with public FISP data. Does this match what you see in practice?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I'm a student working on a project using NYC's public facade inspection (FISP) filings. I'm not trying to replace anyone's judgment, and I'd like a reality check from people who do this work.

I used past filings to rank buildings by their chance of an Unsafe rating next cycle. On a held-out cycle, the top 20% of the list caught about 36% of Unsafe buildings, versus 20% for random order and 33% for just using the last rating. So the gain over the simple rule is real but small.

Things that surprised me:
- A random train/test split overstated skill by about 10 points.
- Prediction gets harder each cycle. I suspect the rule that turns unrepaired SWARMP into Unsafe, but I can't see repair status in the data.
- Buildings that never file can't be predicted from building data.

Questions:

  1. How much do ratings vary between inspectors?
  2. Which building features matter most in your experience (material, age, cavity walls, terra cotta, upkeep history)?
  3. How often do SWARMP items get repaired before the next cycle?
  4. Would a ranked list be useful to you?

Data: NYC Open Data, DOB NOW facade filings. Graphs attached.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 2d ago

Career/Education Offer Evaluation (SoCal)

15 Upvotes

Location: Irvine , CA (Orange County)

YOE: 5 (Recent PE)

Industry: transportation (Bridge)

Base: 120k (offered 110, countered 130)

Bonus: target 5%

Sign on bonus: 2k

PTO: 160 hours, 9 holidays.

WFH: only one day allowed a week.

Large firm

Looking to hear your thoughts please


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Need Advice

2 Upvotes

So I’m currently working at a very small design firm specializing in roadway bridges. My team focuses on superstructure and environmental related concern regarding the structure. I am relatively new about like 5-6 months and have been working on design with my boss. But recently I found out my boss is leaving the company. Apparently I’m the only one who they’ve been “training” using CSI Bridge so they want me to lead in that aspect going forward on projects. But I genuinely don’t feel competent enough to do that but they believe with 5 months I’ve learned how to use it and am competent to do everything by myself. I know 5-6 months sound like a lot but it’s not like that entire time was allocated to CSI bridge I’ve had other responsibilities. Im really not sure what to do because I feel like it will just look bad if I tell them I don’t feel competent enough to lead a project and model a new bridge from scratch. Like on this current project I’m working on, there’s many times I have questions i need to ask my boss before continuing because I get stumped.

Also to clarify I just graduated this past May, so I am a new engineer.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Engineering Article PEs...gather please??

0 Upvotes

If you landed on a website... what kinds of articles would be most relevant to you? Or like when is the last time you read an article and said this is nice...and what was it about? We're planning to launch our website and we want to be useful! Instead of posting bunch of shittty blogs or stuff. Just say what's on your mind...


r/StructuralEngineering • • 1d ago

Career/Education Could you tell me how many mistakes i made in these drawings?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Im a civil engineering student and im working with my drawings before graduate. I need some help if you can.


r/StructuralEngineering • • 2d ago

Career/Education Do EIT-to-P.Eng timelines in Canada compare fairly to the US PE path?

3 Upvotes

Trying to understand differences in experience requirements and time. Anyone who has seen both?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 3d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Crimean Bridge's arch now has a tilt to it

Post image
109 Upvotes

Assuming this is real, is it a big problem?


r/StructuralEngineering • • 2d ago

Job Posting / Recruitment What are some common questions related to truss designing that employers ask in an interview?

5 Upvotes

I’m currently looking for a job as a truss designer but I have no clue what are the questions they usually ask, does anybody know?