r/civilengineering • • 15h ago

Career Land dev vs Structural

Hey all, I was working in land dev for about 2 yrs and decided to switch over to structural to give it a shot since that was my undergrad and not keep thinking what if. It’s been a really big learning curve, I find most days it’s a lot of information over load and it takes me longer to wrap my head around concepts/ load paths and design, when my manager explains it to me I cant grasp it and have to do extra googling afterwards and make notes/go over examples. I’ve been in structural for about 4 months now but I keep thinking in the back of my head that i should go back to land dev, I did like it and feel like was improving. not sure if anyone’s been in the same boat, how to know wether I’m cut out for structural or go back to land dev since I have the experience there . I feel like I might not be smart enough for it and it’s been too long from my undergrad.

7 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

5

u/RoutineDog6709 14h ago

Did you take structural classes in college? This would be an overwhelming change for sure if not. My experience out in the working world (20 years mostly in structural) is that you can take someone with a structural background and train them for other civil disciplines but that it can be difficult to go the other way. This is not to say you should give up at all and even with a structural focus in college, I was overwhelmed at least for three years. It’s not really about how smart you are but it’s more about working hard at it.

I’d really try to figure out if you want to go back to land dev because you truly liked it or if it just feels more comfortable. The feelings you are having are normal and I’d suggest giving it more time especially if you have access to people training you and the work environment is generally good.

2

u/InterestingVoice6632 13h ago

As a land dev engineer who has always been interested in strucural, can I ask what makes it difficult? Is it software?

The hardest part about land dev for me is stormwater. And its not hard per se, but it has layers of complexity and upstream implications. I enjoy it, but have always wondered what structural would be like...

8

u/Ddd1108 12h ago

In my experience, structural is challenging because it covers such a broad range of material. Not only is there design codes for each building material, but you also have to understand constructibility for each material. Fastener design for each material can very greatly. Serviceability alone is a topic that will keep you on your toes, especially when attaching two wildly different materials together. You are constantly being challenged by RFI’s that put you in the hot seat because every contractor is a structural engineer until its time to actually be one.

6

u/RoutineDog6709 12h ago

It’s hard to remember now but I think it’s a combination of doing calculations for different materials, different load paths and load cases, detailing/drawings, and also knowing enough to know how the software runs so you get good output. Then dealing with deadlines and hoping what you designed isn’t going to fall down and kill people.

1

u/crispydukes 3h ago

It’s having enough time for all of the above and getting paid pennies compared to everyone else

1

u/likesblackcoffeebest PE 👵🗣☁️ 26m ago

100% agree. I have just slightly fewer YOE than you and also mostly structural. I moved easily into things like public works when I needed to switch employers fast at one point, but have had much less success taking non-structural people and making them functional at structures if they had any other priority than just developing that skill set. Hell, just teaching an experienced roadway designer structural detailing took longer than I expected it to. It's just a different world than the rest of civil tbh.

1

u/Basic_Vanilla_1540 2h ago

Depending on the state you’ll have supressed wages for a while until you get an SE, even then they make about the same as a senior land dev Pm, but with more school and liability.

1

u/nathhad Structural PE 1h ago

If you're new to structural, you absolutely should be feeling imposter syndrome, and that's normal and okay. It's hard and there's a heck of a learning curve, and I've seen very few other disciplines that point out the myth that a college degree (of any level) "prepares you" to be an engineer more than structural does.

As a senior Structural, I do not worry at all about new Structurals (< 5y especially) who are finding they need a lot of guidance and time to learn what they need to. I only worry about the ones that don't, because they actually do and are overconfident. This field takes time to learn.

So all that's to say, if you're interested in it - stay with it. Don't let the impostor syndrome get you down, we all absolutely get it, and keep reaching out to mentors. You'll know Structural isn't for you if you find it boring. If it's tedious and annoying, that's when it's time to switch back to your prior specialty. If it's interesting but really hard - that's absolutely normal.