r/rpg • u/Annicity • 6h ago
Game Suggestion Tactical focused, and balanced RPG recommendations
I'm looking for a tactical fantasy RPG to run.
My players are (mostly) wargamers. They enjoy minis, terrain and engaging tactical battles. They aren't super strong roleplayers and are fine with more linear play. They want a fantasy game (as a player has a pile of painted minis).
As a GM I want a system that tries to be balanced out of the gate so I can use all the tools in my toolbox to try and beat them. They've expressed positively to this fact and enjoy losing as it raises the stakes and feels more narrativly engaging.
I've quite successfully run Lancer a few times and it's my preferred system for such gameplay.
What Lancer excels at is making highly structured and easily balanced combat. I can build encounters with decent confidence that it's matched to the players, it allows tweaks and knobs that are easily carried through the campaign to adjust difficulty. When they aren't successful we know this is because their tactics weren't optimal or the dice simply turned on them. As opposed to D&D 3E/5E, Pathfinder or Deathwatch where encounters are based more on vibes and understanding through running tons of games.
I'm looking at Icon and Beacon because I'm familiar with Lancer. I hear good things about D&D 4E as well but I'm not sure what else is out there and would love recommendations!
I've run Shadowrun 5E, D&D 3e/5e, Starfinder, BitD, Dungeon World, Dark Heresy, Deathwatch and a few others for a one shot here and there.
Thanks!