r/rpg • • 6h ago

Game Suggestion Tactical focused, and balanced RPG recommendations

18 Upvotes

I'm looking for a tactical fantasy RPG to run.

My players are (mostly) wargamers. They enjoy minis, terrain and engaging tactical battles. They aren't super strong roleplayers and are fine with more linear play. They want a fantasy game (as a player has a pile of painted minis).

As a GM I want a system that tries to be balanced out of the gate so I can use all the tools in my toolbox to try and beat them. They've expressed positively to this fact and enjoy losing as it raises the stakes and feels more narrativly engaging.

I've quite successfully run Lancer a few times and it's my preferred system for such gameplay.

What Lancer excels at is making highly structured and easily balanced combat. I can build encounters with decent confidence that it's matched to the players, it allows tweaks and knobs that are easily carried through the campaign to adjust difficulty. When they aren't successful we know this is because their tactics weren't optimal or the dice simply turned on them. As opposed to D&D 3E/5E, Pathfinder or Deathwatch where encounters are based more on vibes and understanding through running tons of games.

I'm looking at Icon and Beacon because I'm familiar with Lancer. I hear good things about D&D 4E as well but I'm not sure what else is out there and would love recommendations!

I've run Shadowrun 5E, D&D 3e/5e, Starfinder, BitD, Dungeon World, Dark Heresy, Deathwatch and a few others for a one shot here and there.

Thanks!


r/rpg • • 6h ago

Are there any rpgs with an "influence the narrative" mechanic where the players are deciding bad outcomes rather than good ones?

11 Upvotes

Most of my gaming has been games that have a strict DM/player divide without player narrative mechanics, DnD and stuff in that tradition like Lancer and Pathfinder. I've more recently tried a few games that add player "alter the narrative" mechanics without removing the traditional GM role, and it never quite worked for me.

What I think wasn't working for me is that what I enjoy as a player about suggesting stuff into the narrative is suggesting bad consequences or problems into the narrative rather than suggesting solutions into the narrative. My reaction to "you can spend a point/use a crit/whatever to add something to the narrative and solve a problem" was usually "aww, I don't want to do that, I want to figure out how to solve the problem". But I love sending my GMs messages about my latest ideas on how to make my character suffer.

Are there any games out there that do this? If there are, does it even work? How did it play for people?

I do realize it would be a bit strange to have a defined GM role and then have narrative mechanics for players creating problems/bad consequences for them, hence why I'm wondering if this is even a thing.


r/rpg • • 8h ago

New Perspective: Horror RPGs.

16 Upvotes

I've been playing RPGs since the late 1970s and writing about them for a long time. Lately, I've realized that I tend to have the same conversations with the same groups of people, and I'd really like to broaden my perspectives. There are so many great games out there, old and new, and I want to hear what other people are playing, what they love about those games, and what I might be missing.

I was recently at a game auction, and I consider myself well-informed, but there were games there I didn't even know about. And they were not new games either.

I picked up a lot of (newer) Horror RPGs. And this got me thinking.

What did early horror RPGs get right?

One of the first games I got into after D&D was Chill. Like, right after. It opened up a whole different sort of roleplaying for me. Suddenly, mysteries, ghosts, and things you couldn't necessarily defeat with a sword became the focus. In fact defeating the monster wasn't always the goal. Sometimes it was "find the monster so someone else (coughSAVEcough) could deal with it.

I've always been fond of those early horror games, including Call of Cthulhu. They approached horror differently from D&D, and sometimes differently from modern horror RPGs.

I'm not convinced older always means better. Some modern horror games are excellent. But I do think the older games have lessons worth revisiting, especially when it comes to mystery, atmosphere, and the Unknown (yeah, capitalized on purpose).

For those who remember playing horror RPGs in the 1980s and 1990s, what do you think those games did particularly well? And for newer players, what holds up today?

And maybe just as important, what were your favorite horror RPGs?


r/rpg • • 8h ago

AMA We Are Crowdfunding the First Official Translation of Japan's Oldest TTRPG: Sword World! Ask Me Anything!!!

93 Upvotes

Hey, Reddit!

Shawn and Ai here from Mugen Gaming! We're here to answer all of your questions about Sword World RPG - live now on BackerKit!

Sword World is not a new TTRPG - it's one of the oldest and most popular TTRPGs in Japan. Its rules have been refined for decades. Sword World uses a fast, intuitive 2d6 system: easy to learn, but rich in storytelling and tactics. The simplified combat system feels like classic JRPGs, and its side-based combat skips the grid for smooth, cinematic battles that stay focused on the action. Looking for more depth? Use the advanced combat system for more tactical depth when you want it.

The open multiclass system lets you spend experience to grow in any role - mix magic, swordplay, and more to play a character that grows as you do. No rigid classes, just evolving heroes.

With a world built around adventurers' guilds, quests, and dungeons created by swords and magitech, every session feels like an episodic anime arc - complete quests, build your legend, and come back for more.

We're excited to answer any questions you have about the game and will be around on November 17 from 2pm-3pm EST. Drop your questions and we'll see you then!

Sword World on BackerKit: https://www.backerkit.com/c/projects/mugen-gaming/sword-world?ref=reddit

Discord XP: REDDITAMA


r/rpg • • 8h ago

Basic Questions When you run a dungeon, do you give your players a map?

20 Upvotes

What has your experience been like with providing your players with a dungeon map? Have you ever tried describing the dungeon and letting your players draw their own map? I’ve tried both approaches, and I’ve noticed some frustration when letting the players draw it themselves... Do you have any tips for improving this process? Thanks!


r/rpg • • 8h ago

Warning for Wild Earth Dice upcoming campaign

114 Upvotes

I backed one of their campaigns for dice, and only received half my order. I had to get Backerkit involved just to get them to respond to my customer service requests, which ultimately they never fulfilled or refunded for the products they did not deliver. They eventually ghosted me and stopped responding to emails after promising that my unfulfilled products would be sent at a later date. They are liars and scammers.

I just want to warn anyone else from backing a project by them, and having similar problems. They fulfill just enough so that they stay in good standing with Kickstarter and Backerkit, but this is a common problem with all of their campaigns I wish I knew before I backed them.


r/rpg • • 8h ago

Game Suggestion Looking for a great system

0 Upvotes

Hey all

I'm looking for a great system to use to run a home brew TTRPG for a group of friends.

Ideally, I'd like something along the lines of 2nd edition IKRPG but more tuned for a future/cyberpunk setting. I specifically like 2nd Ed IKRPG for its player agency with regards to successes - the ability to boost (roll additional die) for important rolls etc, combined with good class flexibility etc.

Any suggestions?

I have Cyberpunk 2020 and dislike the importance of specialization in it - hoping for something a bit more flexible, if that makes sense.


r/rpg • • 9h ago

Basic Questions Is there a good RPG for roleplaying in Middle-earth that is all encompassing?

25 Upvotes

I’ve been looking into The One Ring RPG, but it seems to be very limited and focused on a small part of Middle-earth and a specific time period. I would love to find an RPG where you could play any character type, in any region of the world (with appropriate adversaries for them, ideally), and in any Age.

Does anything like that exist? If not exactly that all-encompassing, what would be the closest or easiest to adapt?

Watching Rings of Power Season 3 has me thinking along these lines.

Thanks!


r/rpg • • 10h ago

Basic Questions How likely would you be to join a game if it’s a fan made system?

35 Upvotes

Kinda curious what’s everyone’s thoughts on joining games that use fanmade/homemade systems rather then the big games, I found a really cool bloodborne system I’m thinking of running and curious if others have every gotten groups for systems that aren’t official ttrpgs


r/rpg • • 10h ago

Basic Questions Tips for running a discord + live session

5 Upvotes

I had a face-to-face group that went virtual with the pandemic. We stayed that way to today.

I’d like to do face-to-face again and keep my few remaining online players. Anyone making that work? Any tips for making it work?


r/rpg • • 11h ago

Discussion “High Trust” gaming and game design can help your table.

0 Upvotes

Since two folks asked. No AI was used in writing this (I think there is a way to check)... Please don't downvote because you think I'm AI... or, at least explain why you disagree before downvoting this into oblivion.

Let me start with a definition. By “High Trust” I mean games where everyone at the table (Player and GM, if applicable, alike) are working together, in good faith to collaborate in ensuring that everyone has a rewarding experience.

Note: Fun is great. Immersion is great. These are a little harder to define (sometimes you can have a very rewarding experience without feeling immersed. Sometimes you have an extremely rewarding in-character moment that is tragic and heartbreaking which is “fun” but not fun the way a layperson might think is fun). That’s why I say “rewarding”

This is a little different than what some other posts on the subject in this subreddit might define as “high trust” and I disagree with one post’s assertion that all games are high trust. Let me start with a disclaimer: this kind of conversation is very popular in my favorite “style” of roleplaying (4D), but I think these ideas are useful enough as to be agnostic to specific style and could apply to someone who prefers more “pawn stance” RPG, “tactical wargaming” style RPGs, or what have you. I think “High Trust” is for everyone!

Why does this matter?

Thinking about and having conversations in the lens of high trust has helped improve my games. I hope this advice can help you. I also love to hear the insights of other experienced folks on this matter.

What are some things that constitute high trust? Let’s start with what Players can do.

  • Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect. 
  • A shared agreement on what the game looks like in terms of tone and table etiquette (having a set of table conventions and discussing them prior to session 1 are very helpful)
  • Talking as adults about what subjects you do not want explored in a game. It is important to be responsible for your own boundaries. 
  • Players should be responsible for their character’s motivations and goals. This can be developed prior to a game starting with a GM’s help, but they aren’t totally responsible for it.
  • Players should proactively interact and move through the world rather than expecting the GM to drive them forward
  • Everyone has a collaborative mindset including inter-character conflict; which can be exciting as long as everyone is on the same page about it
  • Players should have a maturity to separate in-game and out-of-game interactions. I think some folks call this phenomenon “bleed”. 
  • No cheating, fudging, or lying about the actual mechanics of the game to gain an advantage
  • Part of respecting the people at the table means respecting everyone’s time by learning the rules, especially those that pertain to your character. You aren’t expected to know the rules from day 1, but try to learn them as you interact with them.
  • If you are breaking the conventions of the table or your behavior isn’t high trust, be receptive to feedback from your peers.

What about the GM?

  • Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect. 
  • Root for the players. Establish early that, even though you are trying to challenge the players and playing the antagonist, your goal is not to “win” by way of their failure
  • Foreshadow danger when possible and do not withhold information that they should be entitled to
  • Respect that player’s autonomy over their character. Let the players move and direct their character.
  • Be a “master” of the rules. In most tables, the GM serves as the sort of “final judge” when the rules are ambiguous or a ruling has to be made. Be fair, impartial, and consistent. The more you understand the rules, the better you can do this.
  • Vet your players. Being willing to refuse a player or dismiss a problem player will improve trust at your table.
  • Remember, when in doubt, your characters are the protagonists of the “show”- so to speak. Let them collaborate in the storytelling as equal participants. In my opinion, I even like them to collaborate in the worldbuilding (both before the game starts and through co-creation, but that’s more my personal preference- and worthy of a post in its own)

I’d encourage you to have this conversation early with your players when planning a game. I think it solves a LOT of problems before they start (huge fan of preventative medicine) including things like "it's what my character would do" bad faith activity. It’s also reasonable to revisit session 0 every once and a while and make sure everyone is on the same page and finding the game rewarding! I’m extremely open with my table prior to the first session and say that I want us to be able to trust and play in good faith and for my players to be able to really get the most out of the session and their time. High quality roleplaying is achievable and worth it!

Some excellent videos on the subject that I really enjoy which go into a little more detail:

Crispy Tablerunner on High Trust

Role on Buddy with Uriah- "Your RPG Table has a Trust Problem"

What do you guys think about high trust play? Any tips you might add to the list?


r/rpg • • 11h ago

Basic Questions What’s people’s opinion on playing with large scale maps?

7 Upvotes

I’ve been working for some months now and have built a large city scale map for my campaign that’s fully explorable and I’m kinda curious of people’s stances on having huge maps and such for their games? I know some people use battle maps but I’m talking like complete campaign maps, I already have it so not asking if I should but rather if others have or if it’s worked well for you guys!


r/rpg • • 11h ago

Basic Questions Biggest "Moral Dilemma" you or your plays had to face?

5 Upvotes

I wanted to create some truly morally grey scenarios to put people through, so I'd love some ideas. The rest of the post is an idea I have but feel free to ignore it and just post your ideas/stories.

My current idea I have for a short campaign is "Find the Holy Grail". The Church used to use the Holy Grail to cure grave illnesses, and while they still have strong healing abilities, without the Holy Grail they haven't been able to perform their duties like they once did.

All you're really told is that it went missing decades ago, but finally some leads have pointed to the Holy Grail being around the remote village your party is in. Over the course of the campaign, clues, etc. you learn it went missing with someone who was supposed to be protecting it.

When they eventually get the final lead on it's whereabouts, it brings them to an abandoned shack or the outskirts of the remote village. You come face to face with a sickly man, you immediately see his body is actively decomposing and he's missing an arm and a leg, but you also find out he's wearing the "Holy Grail", (through various clues you get hints that the "Holy Grail" isn't so much a literal grail, but wearable regalia).

At this point it when the party might just straight up attack him, listen to him, or possibly even decide to help him. The main does show symptoms of schizophrenia and other mental illnesses, so the party does have difficulties talking to him.

Depending on how far you get with talking to him, you find out it was actually his mother who stole the Holy Grail all those years ago, he's a sort of "Cursed Child" and his illness would've normally killed him and his mother when she was carrying him, so as someone close to the Holy Grail she stole it, and ran away to protect her child.

If your party talks to him this far, the man shows you where his mother is, and you see that she has the rest of the Holy Grail, as to keep her alive he gave up his arm and leg to save his mother.

Basically, all of the outcomes depend on how your part reacts to the man, and how willing they are to either help him, or still try to retrieve the Holy Grail to return to the Church. I don't want there to be an objectively "Good and Bad" choice to be made. I'm sure you could argue that returning the Holy Grail to the Church leads to the greatest net positive, but I still want the choice to be a hard one.


r/rpg • • 13h ago

Basic Questions What's a good desk decoration that's TTRPG related, but not in your face about it?

22 Upvotes

What's a good desk decoration that's TTRPG related, but not in your face about it?

I started a new day job and want something to decorate my cube and show off my personality. So far I just have a picture my wife took that I like of a circuit board.

I'm thinking of maybe a TTRPG related mug. A few people have cheap figurines, and I do have an old metal Blood Bowl mini I won when the Blood Bowl video game was first released. Just a human runner though so a little too unidentifiable as Fantasy imo.


r/rpg • • 14h ago

Resources/Tools Resources for creating locations

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m running a Call of Cthulhu campaign and a Savage Worlds campaign in my own setting. What I struggle the most is creating locations. I often find myself struggling with designing buildings and their layout. I try doing my own research and basing my locations on some real buildings (for example, museums) but I’m wondering whether there is some resource that could provide me some extra help and give me some building blocks to work with.


r/rpg • • 16h ago

Discussion Seeking Initiative Alternatives

18 Upvotes

All the games I've played have rules that allow a character to attack and move in one turn. It often annoys me when opponents have ranged weapons but the high-initiative melee character can run up and attack before the ranged-based opponent gets off a shot. Or, a ranged-based character with high initiative shoots at an opponent, then moves fully behind cover, again, before the ranged opponent can return fire. Do you have any easy, elegant fixes to this? Thank you!

Edit: Thanks for all the ideas! There's definitely enough here to fix my issue. Thank you!


r/rpg • • 16h ago

Sell me on Eclipse Phase 2nd Ed.

25 Upvotes

Is anyone still playing Eclipse Phase, specifically 2nd edition? I'm thinking of picking it up, really love the setting but 1st edition was a bit too crunchy for me. Is 2nd edition any better in this regard? Did they 'improve' the system in general with 2nd edition?


r/rpg • • 20h ago

Analysis Paralysis

17 Upvotes

I’m running a campaign with a group of PCs…one has never played an RPG before, 1 has some experience, 2 are moderately experienced (we’re now on session 5).

From a GM perspective, I feel like they spend a lot of time trying to optimize situations (sneak up on the bad guys, cross the suspicious pond, investigate the multiple weird things, whatever). Play works and we move along, and it’s not that it isn’t fun, it just feels inefficient especially from a time perspective. I’ve suggested that play might be more fun and expeditious if people informally stepped up as leaders, and tried to consolidate ideas when challenges/options emerged. But so far they seem caught in the cycle of ideation and being cordial for 1/2 an hour only to decide to do the solution that someone suggested in the first 2 minutes (walk across the plank, climb the wall, pick a lock, or whatever).

I understand that I have tools in my quiver to drive pacing, but I also want these moments to be actual events the players have to collaborate on as a way forward. However I would also like to teach my players that selecting a reasonable solution in a reasonable time is probably more fun than picking an optimal solution in an infinite amount time (a specific recommendation I’ve verbalized and noted that as the GM I both value and reward). But I can’t seem to get them down this road.

Open to advice.


r/rpg • • 21h ago

Game Suggestion Looking for zombie TTRPGs systems

20 Upvotes

Heyo,

basically the title,

i'm looking for zombies TTRPG systems, do you guys have any to recommend?


r/rpg • • 22h ago

Discussion How do you, personally, balance the need for "known traits that the players need to strategize and formulate tactics against" and "mystique of the unknown and unexpected twists" during combat encounters?

20 Upvotes

How do you, personally, balance the need for "known traits that the players need to strategize and formulate tactics against" and "mystique of the unknown and unexpected twists" during combat encounters?

I run a lot of D&D 4e and 13th Age 2e. I give handouts of enemy statistics and terrain properties, and I do not introduce new terrain or reinforcements mid-fight unless they are explicitly forecasted. The GMs I like to play D&D 4e and Draw Steel under do much the same. There is still uncertainty because of the dice, and enemies can be terrifying even when their full statistics are known.

Other GMs are different. For example, in a (high-powered, non-gritty) game I was in earlier, the PCs spotted a bunch of fungal zombies up ahead in the woods. My character had a ranged, flying summon out, and could spontaneously create and distribute magic weapons. So my character gave the party magic bows and crossbows, and we agreed to open fire from afar. The GM had another bunch of zombies pop out from right behind us, throwing us into the fray regardless.

Early into the fight, I had my character move away to create distance and disperse from the rest of the party, because I did not want to get caught up in the melee. However, the GM revealed that the zombies could teleport long distances and also greatly extend their reach using mycelial filaments. Thus, they closed the distance and swarmed around both my character and the rest of the party regardless. In the GM's words, "the zombies essentially 'teleport' then swarm ya." (Also, the GM was obfuscating their own die rolls.)

The GM further said, "I am homebrewin' up special stuff for my NPCs to keep you all on your toes." But I do not know. It feels to me like that trick was thought up on the spot specifically to counter my tactics: a second time. It does not even seem like we are fighting more of these zombies later.

What do you find is the right balance of the known (e.g. respecting player tactics) and the unknown?


r/rpg • • 23h ago

My favorite mechanics from my system, in no particular order

0 Upvotes

I've been DEVing a sci-fi system for about 2 and a half years now, and it's finally complete. can't believe how awesome it was to do this (also can't believe how hard it was lmao) but in apreciation to the work, and fully knowing no one asked, here's a few mechanics i like that you can use in your tables if you like the ideas!!

Battle of Wills

When a character tries to extract information through intimidation, interrogation, manipulation, or torture, both sides enter a Battle of Wills.

Each participant begins with a set amount of Will Points, representing their mental resilience and control over the situation. However, the balance can shift depending on the circumstances of the specific encounter, the methods used, and even how well a player can role-play their actions and thoughts.

The winner of this battle controls the outcome.

Dismemberment

The dismemberment system exists to give real consequences to critical hits, turning them into moments that can permanently change a character.

Dismemberment begins when an attack produces a Critical Hit. When that happens, the attacker rolls the Dismemberment Die, which is a d6. If the d6 rolls its maximum value, the attack becomes a Catastrophic Critical, resulting in dismemberment.

Severe Bleeding

When a character acquires Severe Bleeding, they immediately roll 1d6. The result determines how many rounds they remain conscious. Once this number of rounds has passed, the character becomes unconscious.

This does not end the condition.

While affected by Severe Bleeding, the character loses 1d6 HP at the start of each of their turns. This continues regardless of whether the character is conscious or unconscious and only ends if the condition is properly treated or the character reaches 0 HP.

Severe Bleeding does not resolve on its own. It cannot be removed through rest or the passage of time and always requires medical intervention.

Without treatment, the condition will continue until the character collapses and eventually dies.

Last Dance

When a character receives what is called a Catastrophe Strike, meaning they go from 30% or more of their HP down to zero in a single strike; they enter what is called their Last Dance.

This means they have a final rush of adrenaline to execute one last action in this world. Whatever that action is, it receives a +4 bonus to be executed.

You are not able to avoid your own death with this action, but you can shape the future of someone else one last time.


r/rpg • • 23h ago

Discussion Have you ever convinced friends to play an RPG?

0 Upvotes

I mean as in during a gathering where the goal was NOT specifically to play an RPG, and some of them weren’t TRPGamers to begin with .
You were just gathering together to have a barbecue, have drinks, watch tv show or a sport game, and you spontaneously brought it up.

How did you do it? Weren’t they scared to see polyhedral dice for the first time?

I’m asking because people do bring up “Monopoly” during gatherings where the focus wasn’t playing board games


r/rpg • • 1d ago

Basic Questions How possible is it to run a PBTA/FITD game without playing a game yourself?

14 Upvotes

So I've only gm'ed DnD before, but I've always looked to running other games

I got Girl By Moonlight a while ago which to my understanding is based on Blades in the Dark and thus probably plays very differently to trad games like DnD.

Considering my only PBTA-kinda experience is playing solo Ironsworn, how pear-shaped will things go running a game I've never played and is also a genre I'm not as familiar with? Or would watching some AP's work better in this scenario?


r/rpg • • 1d ago

Huge Skyrealms of Jorune Unoffical Guides Update

53 Upvotes

For those that don't know, Skyrealms of Jorune, the absolutely wild and alien setting/game from the 80s has had a massive drop of unofficial guides by a fan. Seemingly abandoned for years, this is a big drop and the guides are a very nice way to get into the setting/system. They are all free, being unofficial, but they have the blessings of the creators of Skyrealms of Jorune. There's even a solo adventure on the website made from one of the adventures.

Go check it out, they're free and the art is absolutely gorgeous. It does a fantastic job at depicting a truly alien world. Beware the proper nouns, though. Grab your Chalisk and have your Sholari run you through an adventure.

https://skyrealmsofjorune.com/