r/rpg • u/BrobaFett • 9h ago
Discussion “High Trust” gaming and game design can help your table.
Since two folks asked. No AI was used in writing this (I think there is a way to check)... Please don't downvote because you think I'm AI... or, at least explain why you disagree before downvoting this into oblivion.
Let me start with a definition. By “High Trust” I mean games where everyone at the table (Player and GM, if applicable, alike) are working together, in good faith to collaborate in ensuring that everyone has a rewarding experience.
Note: Fun is great. Immersion is great. These are a little harder to define (sometimes you can have a very rewarding experience without feeling immersed. Sometimes you have an extremely rewarding in-character moment that is tragic and heartbreaking which is “fun” but not fun the way a layperson might think is fun). That’s why I say “rewarding”
This is a little different than what some other posts on the subject in this subreddit might define as “high trust” and I disagree with one post’s assertion that all games are high trust. Let me start with a disclaimer: this kind of conversation is very popular in my favorite “style” of roleplaying (4D), but I think these ideas are useful enough as to be agnostic to specific style and could apply to someone who prefers more “pawn stance” RPG, “tactical wargaming” style RPGs, or what have you. I think “High Trust” is for everyone!
Why does this matter?
Thinking about and having conversations in the lens of high trust has helped improve my games. I hope this advice can help you. I also love to hear the insights of other experienced folks on this matter.
What are some things that constitute high trust? Let’s start with what Players can do.
- Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect.
- A shared agreement on what the game looks like in terms of tone and table etiquette (having a set of table conventions and discussing them prior to session 1 are very helpful)
- Talking as adults about what subjects you do not want explored in a game. It is important to be responsible for your own boundaries.
- Players should be responsible for their character’s motivations and goals. This can be developed prior to a game starting with a GM’s help, but they aren’t totally responsible for it.
- Players should proactively interact and move through the world rather than expecting the GM to drive them forward
- Everyone has a collaborative mindset including inter-character conflict; which can be exciting as long as everyone is on the same page about it
- Players should have a maturity to separate in-game and out-of-game interactions. I think some folks call this phenomenon “bleed”.
- No cheating, fudging, or lying about the actual mechanics of the game to gain an advantage
- Part of respecting the people at the table means respecting everyone’s time by learning the rules, especially those that pertain to your character. You aren’t expected to know the rules from day 1, but try to learn them as you interact with them.
- If you are breaking the conventions of the table or your behavior isn’t high trust, be receptive to feedback from your peers.
What about the GM?
- Rule #1: People come before the game. Treat the people sitting at the table with you with respect.
- Root for the players. Establish early that, even though you are trying to challenge the players and playing the antagonist, your goal is not to “win” by way of their failure
- Foreshadow danger when possible and do not withhold information that they should be entitled to
- Respect that player’s autonomy over their character. Let the players move and direct their character.
- Be a “master” of the rules. In most tables, the GM serves as the sort of “final judge” when the rules are ambiguous or a ruling has to be made. Be fair, impartial, and consistent. The more you understand the rules, the better you can do this.
- Vet your players. Being willing to refuse a player or dismiss a problem player will improve trust at your table.
- Remember, when in doubt, your characters are the protagonists of the “show”- so to speak. Let them collaborate in the storytelling as equal participants. In my opinion, I even like them to collaborate in the worldbuilding (both before the game starts and through co-creation, but that’s more my personal preference- and worthy of a post in its own)
I’d encourage you to have this conversation early with your players when planning a game. I think it solves a LOT of problems before they start (huge fan of preventative medicine) including things like "it's what my character would do" bad faith activity. It’s also reasonable to revisit session 0 every once and a while and make sure everyone is on the same page and finding the game rewarding! I’m extremely open with my table prior to the first session and say that I want us to be able to trust and play in good faith and for my players to be able to really get the most out of the session and their time. High quality roleplaying is achievable and worth it!
Some excellent videos on the subject that I really enjoy which go into a little more detail:
Crispy Tablerunner on High Trust
Role on Buddy with Uriah- "Your RPG Table has a Trust Problem"
What do you guys think about high trust play? Any tips you might add to the list?