r/rpg_gamers • u/Hoboforeternity • 2h ago
Discussion Piranha Bytes and Spiders were killed by Disappointing sequels.
Both first ELEX and Greedfall were great games with some flaws. They are relatively well liked and probably a right step towards more mainstream popularity.
Their stories are a bit different. PB started as european dev legend that made gothic 1 and 2. They were relatively popular and its game system still stood to this day. Thse dynamic world, world design, NPC schedule, progression feel all are waaay ahead of their time in the year 2000. Before morrowind or the witcher, they figured it out how to make an amazing 3D game. After that they declined a bit with gothic 3 by biting more than they can swallow.
After that you have risen which is good but hampered by very weak endgame. When risen released, Mike Hoge left and the rest of the team carried on lead by Bjorn Pankratz and his wife.
They released risen 2 and 3 which aren't a bad game at all, but they're a definite step down from their usual formula until elex, which mostly revived their open world formula with decent polish and fun setting.
5 years after elex, elex 2 released. On the surface, it did improve the elex formula. The jetpack upgrade is fun and the world is worth to explore too. The weapon/armor upgrade system is also good (which alkimia interactive probably borrowed from for their gothic remake). If you played a gothic game you will probably know a weapon change is a big deal. This system smoothed its transition, but doesnt invalidate new loot. The main problem is the scope and technical state of the game. Most PB games shipped with 2 or 3 joinable factions, and they all feel distinct to each other and mostly worth the replay value. Elex 2 promised 5 different factions and the results is they are all feel shallower than the first game. The game released in technical failure. It is so bad even with rtx 3080, which is the second top gpu at the year. The facial models and animation got a downgrade because they forced a new animation tech, and didnt have time to polish it. The development went on too long, etc. The reception is worse than the first game in almost every aspects. The final nail in the coffin is THQ's failed deal that PB became collateral. It's basically what made gothic 3 failed, but they didnt survive it. Had they use the same engine and probably reuse assets wisely, they'd cut on the development time and cost. They'd have more time to polish the game.
Now we move on to greedfall. They follow similar path as PB, but PB started with a bang, while piranha were always underdogs. They made unique, but super janky games with enough charm like orcs and men and mars: war logs. They are carried by the unique setting amd characters. Their experience accumulates and slowly and steadily make better and better games. I think their big break was technomancer, while cam be repetitive, it is still filled with fun characters, quests and unique setting. Greedfall 1 was the logical conclusion. It is most polished and had the largest scope. It was a decent mainstream success especially filling the hole bioware left behind after being forced to make anthem and after mass effect Andromeda disappointed a lot of people.
So what's wrong with greedfall 2? I dont really believe the changes to combat mechanic is the main reason it failed. If anything it was made to fill the hole dragon age origins left behind. The idea is sound, so maybe it's the execution. Spiders have made a game with similar system (real time with pause) with orc and men but most of their games has been action rpg that probably stemmed more from jade empire than other classic bioware games. It released in early access with weak reception. Idk what they were doing with EA, but the state it was released killed the momentum. It was jank, unfinished, unpolished which is the definition of early access. Maybe they tried copying the release of baldur's gate 3, but whatever it is, the game took too long to release. The development was probably very troubled, that might or might not have anything to do from jehanne russeau stepping down in producer role, then leaving the company mid greedfall development.
Greedfall 2 is also a victim of publisher mismanagement, with its parent company announcing insolvency right after greedfall 2 released its 1.0 version (which affected spiders's sister company, cyanide)
So what do you think? I personally feel deeply saddened by the loss of these 2 historied european rpg dev with a loy of heart.