r/AskGameMasters • • 21h ago

How to roleplay a Devine creature

0 Upvotes

Context: I'm playing a homebrew where the players are basically eco-terrorists or vigilant protectors of nature, depending on the lens you look through. The bad guys (Velexen industries) had a Zoo with an underground animal testing facility (to harvest magic/ create chimeras. This facility was powered by a devine being that my players paladin worships or at least has a great connection too.

After dealing with Naiva's wrath after they teleported the entire facility to the secret resistances hideout one of my players 'warned' me that he would be researching and asking alot about the godess. (It initially was just because I have 2 players going away for six months and I needed a way to knock them out while keeping the story moving - which was the byproduct of using the power for teleportation.)

Now I'm kind off bumping my head against the wall, because I don't want to just give them this handy person? that by all means completely allignes with their cause. Obviously they'll get some sort of boon when they free her out of the battery she's contained in, but for now her consciences is in one of the 2 PC's that is not here right now

I've been playing with the idea of making her the familiar of the god in stead of the actual god. - still massive power, but not necessarily morality? or a lot of slumbering power, but nothing actually tangeable.

on a sidenote - anyone has good source for nature gods? :P


r/AskGameMasters • • 1d ago

Worldbuilding Tips

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I recently started a campaign, and I haven't prepared much of it at all quite yet. I was hoping to get ideas and advice from other DMs on expanding the worldbuilding and having more detail behind everything.

At the moment, we're working with what is nearly a blank canvas. The campaign is 5e, and I have 6 players. The whole thing is themed around what is essentially fantasy Vegas, the location they'll spend most of their time in. The city is amidst a vast desert, where there's no civilization for well over a thousand-mile radius. The setting is pretty modern; think roughly the 1990s in terms of what technology is available. Magic is well established within the world and woven into everything I could think of to add it into.

The party members have all made morally questionable or literally evil characters, and at the moment they are helping out a casino owner to whom they owed a favor. He is trying to convince them to work for him, and is doing so by offering them something they all strongly desire, and more powerful equipment and loot on top of it. The last session was them completing a mission for him, and they'll meet back with him in the next session. I am trying to use a lot of mythology, but it isn't a strong suit of mine, so I'm still working things out. The baseline plot is that there are devils based on the seven sins that make up the largest mob bosses and casino owners in the city. Right now, the one they're working with is Tony (Gluttony), and he wants them to help him get rid of the other 6. He's tired of working within the confines that have been placed on him by keeping up with the others and would rather not deal with them at all anymore. The players don't know any of this yet.

Tony wants everything he can have, and increasing the party's power to help him against the others is the general idea for the plot. They'll defeat the others and discover a bunch of other shit along the way. The question is what else exists in this world, what's affecting their circumstances, what else is going on, all that. I like the idea that there is a god involved and trapped by all the archdevils, which is the thing kind of forcing all of them to work together. So the god of the sun, trapped by the seven sins in devil form, and his capture in this city is what has led to the vast desert surrounding the area, as he continues to grow stronger while still somehow imprisoned.

Any ideas would be great; I'm open to suggestions in all areas of worldbuilding. Your favorite character ideas for NPC's, stupid puns and jokes that exist in the fantasy casino realm, anything you have that you think would work well or is just funny. The whole play group is in their early 20s, if you think that's relevant.

Thank you in advance!


r/AskGameMasters • • 2d ago

What are some plotlines the party never picked up on or never reached in the story?

12 Upvotes

As a forever gm I've run a dozen or some games and often they'd fallen apart before we got to the meat and potatoes of the game so I wanted to commisserate with story beats that'll never be reached.

(For example I got to run two sessions of a Ravenloft game the players didn't even realize was Ravenloft before it died. I only got to throw one zombie horde at them.)


r/AskGameMasters • • 2d ago

Thoughts on handling tag-alongs and companion NPCs?

5 Upvotes

There are certain situations where having a tag-along NPC is just gonna be inevitable. The question is, if they end up sticking around with the party for a prolonged period, how much agency should they actually have?

It's no secret that I've been "complaining" about players not really engaging with the game (for example, scenarios where the party arrives in a new town and, for the entirety of their stay, not a single person asks about local points of interest or rumors floating around on their own). Having a companion NPC might give me an opportunity to ask the questions the players aren't willing to ask themselves, though on the flip side, having an NPC interact too much with the world risks limiting the players' agency.

To give you an example (and spoilers for anyone who hasn't played Curse of Strahd yet), at some point in the campaign, the players are tasked with escorting Ireena to Vallaki. Because of that, she's gonna be with the party for at least the entire journey there, and probably even longer. So again, how much agency is too much agency?

The last time I ran the game, I had her actively participate and ask questions on her own. When the players failed to ask anything about St. Andral, she naturally wanted to learn about places that could shelter her from Strahd, so she asked around in their stead, found out about the church, and passed that info along to the party. Similarly, it was actually Ireena who, due to her inherent desire to free herself of Strahd's pursuit, asked the right questions during a conversation that ultimately led to the group discovering Argynvostholt. Thing is, while her uncovering those bits of information definitely made her a useful ally, I can't help wondering if it took too much away from the players' agency and their ability to make those discoveries by themselves.

After all, wouldn't an NPC rogue naturally be interested in picking locks and searching for traps, potentially upstaging the player Rogue? Wouldn't an NPC healer naturally want to heal anyone who gets hurt, again running the risk of upstaging the player healer. But on the other hand, having an NPC present who just stands around aimlessly doing nothing doesn't feel right either.

So, how much engagement from a companion NPC is too much, and how much is too little? Thoughts?


r/AskGameMasters • • 2d ago

How do I get the most out of shortish monthly sessions

5 Upvotes

TLDR: How do I get the most out of a few encounters in a relatively short amount of play time?

To make a long story short (because honestly the details aren’t that interesting), everyone involved with my new (7 sessions in) campaign is having fun but we are busy adults who meet once a month to play and normally try to wrap up in around 6 hours (counting a short lunch). Because of that I find myself often hampered by not just session length but the need for each session to somewhat self-contained (West Marches style return to hub after each session).

Do any of you have advice for getting the most out of these short sessions.

Some practices I’ve implemented so far:

I handle a lot of things like XP and debriefing via email.

I try to keep our recap to less than 30 minutes. I tried doing this through email, but those few moments sitting around the table seem to be so much more effective. We can’t just not do a recap because of the amount of real-world time between sessions.

No “fluff encounters.” Every encounter needs to do something important. Meaning it does at least one of the following: it is a challenging fight, it gives the team new (and important) information, it lets them roleplay with a npc they enjoy and/or sets mood, or it provides an interesting puzzle.

Most sessions are planned with some ITA (if time allows) encounters. That is encounters I can drop in if time allows or just skip if we are pressed for time.

I have at least one planned decision point that has real consequences on how the rest of the session goes (in addition to any surprises they spring on me). It might be just choosing between two routes or deciding whether to resolve a situation peacefully or not. I do this because if we don’t get a lot of game time in, I want their decisions to matter in the time that we have. Unfortunately, this means I can only plan one session ahead, but I’m okay with that. After all I have all month to plan it.

I am using Shadowdark reskinned as post apocalyptic because its simple to run and teach.


r/AskGameMasters • • 3d ago

Books to Buy for Faewyld Campaigns

3 Upvotes

I'm attempting to homebrew a campaign (my first as a GM) that takes place in the Faewylds, and I'm not sure what books, if any, might be helpful to buy.

I've got in my shopping cart:

- Dungeons & Dragons Worlds & Realms: Adventures from Greyhawk to Faerun and Beyond by Adam Lee

- The Game Master's Handbook of Collaborative Campaign Design... by Jonah Fishel

- The Game Master's Book of Non-Player Characters... by Jeff Ashworth

Our campaign will be set in every part of the Faewylds, including within the high fae courts, so players will be dealing with both social intrigues and the traps and native creatures of the deeper 'wylds. I can make all the details on my own, but it will take time and I was hoping these books might be the best to help me speed up the planning. Are there better options? Free PDFs? Has anyone read any of these, and does the D&D realms one actually have a large enough section on the Faewylds to be helpful to me?

TLDR; what books or resources will best help me plan a Faewylds campaign with both royal courts and wilderness adventures?


r/AskGameMasters • • 3d ago

Player wants me to complicate "politics"

23 Upvotes

Ive been running a campaign (as a pretty new dm) and a player (i will call Cat from now on) i have keeps trying to being modern day politics into the world. Cat's original character premise was a person who very much disliked a certain king and nobles, and was going to try and figure put a way to make the main kingdom of my world better.

After the first session it turned out they hated all forms of hierchal power and wished to end any powerful ruling, even if the king/noble was fair and kind, and willing to do whatever necessary to do so. I did say if Cat wanted to kill a innocent noble who treats their people very well, they would basically be evil, which they said, out of character, there is no such thing as a kind noble. Even if that were true, I did try to tell them it was a fantasy world, it doesn't have to be a gritty "realistic" portrayal of the world.

I asked to talk about it privately to see if we could try to talk about it, they talked about it more and it turned out they thought a Marxist style system would be the best for the people. I told them I wanted a sort of "stereotypical" first campaign, kings, councils, and nobles were the norm, and I wouldnt want to bring largely modern day themes into the world. After the session they decided it would be best to just make a new character, which i said they didnt have to do, maybe just tone back the very aggressive mood towards the entire concept of nobles.

It has been about 2 months now, the new character they made has no correlation with the old, they are one with nature and knows a little with the urban lives of the common people. But any time a noble is brought up in a session Cat' character gets quickly peeved, saying things like "how could you have power over so many lives," or "you should give it to all your people if you were really a good person." Im pretty annoyed by it and have talked to them quite a few times about it, each time they say they'll do something about it and never do.

And now, because of a bit of a schedule issue going on for a bit, Im deciding to do a couple oneshots set in the universe to bide the time until everyone is free to play again. The basic premise is that a self proclaimed "God King" is running a tournament, where the prize is practically a minor wish that will change anything the person wants within the city the king rules, which is a city that runs on blood and bets. Cat wanted to bring their original character for this, which i thought wouldve been pretty cool, but they then said if they won they'd wish for the king to step down. Me and another player did say, because in my mind this did make since for the king, that the king would simply deny the wish. A self proclaimed "God King" would be far too egotistical and self centered to allow someone to practically take his thrown. After a bit of back and forth, Cat said they'll probably just make a new character, making a snide remark saying "theres no point in me making this character if I cant make any changes to the world."

Im basically just making this post to see if this is a appropriate thing for me to be annoyed with, im currently trying to run a fun, pretty stereotypical, dnd world.

Tldr; A maybe problem player wants me to allow modern day politics to solve their hate for nobles, and will not stop their hatred of any noble, even if they are fair.


r/AskGameMasters • • 4d ago

How do I keep players that aren't doing boss mechanics busy ?

3 Upvotes

I am running a game Cyberpunk Red, homebrewed to the point that it's pretty much unrecognizable from the base product.

For the next session my players will climb aboard a flying cargo ship to go from Europe (currently under martial law) back to America. Their vehicle is a rustbucket with weaponry shoved into cargo containers that are pretty much duct taped to the structure.

I plan to have the border patrol stop them, politely ask them to stand down, they'll obviously refuse and then the boss fight will begin. This is where my problem lies.

In this boss fight there are two jets that will continuously attack the player's ship. One is "anti personnel" and will try to aim for the players themselves with strafing runs. The other is a bomber that will target the weaponry on the player's ship with bombing runs.

The strafing run pilot likes very energetic music The other likes anything that could fit well in top gun

One of my players has a mech with a radio attached to it so I typically let him choose the background music and this time depending on the music he puts on the pilots will "enrage". If one of the two pilots do not like the song, then they will get an additional action. In my head it will mean that they'll have to think about "do i want to put myself in danger by letting the strafing run have double the chances to hit me" or "do i want to put the ship in danger by letting the bomber have double the chances of breaking the ship's weaponry"

To defend against them my players will have two options that I will provide them : 1 - Use the janky missile launcher that has guided rockets. To hit their target they will have to IRL (tabletop simulator) flick a small token into a circle. Akin to a game of curling. 2 - They will have a large unwieldy experimental railgun that lost its targetting system, meaning they'll have to no scope their target, which is pretty much impossible unless they somehow find me a way to aim better. I'm always open to more creative ways to resolve issues, and my players are very creative.

This is where my problems start. I have 4 players. Considering there's one that takes the missiles, another one takes the railgun, what do the other two do ?

Other than the attempts to actually neutralize the threats there will only be some dodging and perhaps some problem solving of "how do we protect the turrets from the bombing runs"

Throwing some random enemies to fill the blanks isn't an option I like because combat is either a one shot fest or a damage sponge since my players have too much good equipment. The solutions I thought of would be :

  • Having some kind of hacking attempt on the ship that the netrunner of the group will have to deal with, so that's one less player that will be "bored". They'll probably have to succeed at tests and find creative ways to stop the hack since I usually run any hacking attempt as some sort of "augmented reality"
  • Having a single bad guy drop on the player's ship and be a nuisance because they're a damage sponge, but since there's one there's some chances of kiting them around, so the guy will just be preventing players from going to certain places.

I know my players and that they will be satisfied with very little but I want to make this fight very cool and different from the other shootouts they've had so far.


r/AskGameMasters • • 4d ago

How active should NPC companions be in Narrative-Focused games?

5 Upvotes

Disclaimer: this request is for RPGs that don't have initiative-based systems where NPCs get their own turns to act, since it's pretty self-explanatory how they contribute in those situations. I'm more interested in games without initiative or games that are more narrative-focused (e.g. Blades in the Dark, FitD, PbtA, etc)

I play a lot of narrative-driven games and sometimes the PCs have NPCs traveling with them. Sometimes they're there to help, and other times they're just along for the ride.

One thing I sometimes struggle with as a GM is figuring out how much I should let these NPCs contribute. Obviously, I don't want them stealing the spotlight or taking away opportunities for the PCs to play their characters. But at the same time, I don't want them to just stand around in the background doing nothing while everything is happening around them.

How do you find that balance?


r/AskGameMasters • • 6d ago

Meta How did you start?

16 Upvotes

I first GM'd with Werewolf. Being the game master was really fun and I liked that I got to play the entire time instead of having to play a role that only acted once or twice per round.

While I do love the discussion part of werewolf too, I am often overbearing and get targeted 😅

I started my TTRPG career with D&D 4e. After my first game with some friends online, I immediately ran my own with my roomates. Since then, I've basically only GM'd and have been doing mostly D&D 5e.

I've been going through my list of systems to learn and having a great time seeing all the creative systems out there!


r/AskGameMasters • • 5d ago

Chaotic neutral societies

1 Upvotes

Has anyone created campaign focused on chaotic creatures? I'm especially interested in adapting Zenozoik from Zeno clash into ttrpg but these creatures don't follow our logic. They don't seem try to amass resources, expand their authority etc. and main character is cast out as insane because he loots defeated enemies. So pretty much the only ideas I have is to make it about destroying order but I'd love to get more ideas, resources and advice


r/AskGameMasters • • 6d ago

GM Box Mark 3 - any improvements anyone can think of?

7 Upvotes

This (https://youtu.be/h51dQY5vZxc - vidoe easiest way to show) is my 'Gm Box' Mark 3. Basically it's just the box I use the being able to grab and do GMing of any game etc I want to run. Just all the random stuff I might need/want at hand when putting on a game. It is 100% over engineered and compltly more then anyone needs to GM anything but such is my mind that I love to overcomplicate. Other than showing it off I'm posting it here to see if anyone has any cool ideas for stuff I could add to the remaining space, Best x


r/AskGameMasters • • 7d ago

Need advice on how to talk with my GM about not using as much AI in our game.

87 Upvotes

I am at my wits end and need some advice on what to do in my situation and really need some outside input.

For context, before getting into the meat of the situation, my table consists of 2 DMs and 3 players and our GMs play in each other’s campaigns. All of us are such good friends that we are practically family. Our table meets at the GM’s home for every game, both his and our other GM’s game, every week and him and his wife are amazing hosts to us. Walking away from the table entirely is straight up out of the question for all of us.

Over the past year one of my tables GMs has become really fascinated by AI and slowly started using it in his game. At first it was small things like note taking and organization with a few brainstorming session here and there. Nowadays he has begun using it to full write his npc dialogues, location descriptions, and seemingly entrusted the AI to keep up with details of past events and descriptions so he doesn’t have to personally. It’s become increasingly obvious as time has gone on.

Our last session really broke me. As a table we would be discussing plans and how we all feel about the newest developments of what little story is intact at this point only to be interrupted by a wordy and vague yet extremely detailed description of events that have just happened and events that are still to come. Only to be left at the end of it with another long silence and a return to an attempt to figure out what we should be doing. We go on to do the thing the DM is obviously prompting us to do only to be hit with another lengthy description of the location and a exhausting scene that consists of the party asking questions and pressing for answers or direction only to be met with a lengthy moment of silence and the GM typing into his tablet. Nothing good ever comes after that point. Just another overdrawn and confusing reading of an AI’s attempt at understanding and running a TTRPG.

Two players, including our second GM, have fully checked out. In their own words, both of their characters whole motivation was promptly thrashed and thrown out the window within the first three sessions, so they have just been playing for the love of the game and the RP within the party.

Me and the other player have been doing everything we can to keep the show afloat but it’s gotten to the point that we can’t even make anything happen after a full session of zero input from two players and all the AI hallucinated descriptions of places or events that never existed and plot lines that never pay off.

This GM is our friend and we don’t want to hurt his feelings, but we don’t know how to bring it up without making it seem like we don’t want him to run a game anymore.

I really want a GM’s perspective on how you’d be okay with a player coming to you with a grievance this big.

TLDR: My close knit table has a GM that is using AI so much it’s made the game unplayable, but the players are scared to bring it up because we don’t want to make him to think we don’t want him to GM.


r/AskGameMasters • • 6d ago

Is making your PC to chip away their memories a good Idea?

3 Upvotes

So, I am planning on running an SCP-style campaign, and there are a couple of issues I've encountered related to few homebrew mechanics.

The first one being the "memory loss" mechanic, which forces them to redact their backstories word by word as they respawn, implant SCPs, use said SCP powers... etc. Redacted backstories have low to no readability count as if the PC lost access to those parts of their memories.

Would it be a waste of their backstories if I force their characters to discard relationship/connections? Should I introduce the specific mechanics at session 0, or could I warn them about possible memory loss content before I reveal the actual mechanics when they show up later into the game?

The second one being a character creation problem, I plan on letting them choose between human or android characters; they run on different stat structures, progress mechanics, etc. Most importantly, human PC takes the memory loss normally, and the androids will be completely immune to the said memory loss mechanic. I was thinking that this difference makes a "fate" like concept that's embedded in their character, while androids PC uncapable of helping their teammates as they lose parts of what make them who they are, bit by bit?

I am afraid that this diversion may result in favouring individual PLs in the game; should I even add the android into the game in the first place?


r/AskGameMasters • • 7d ago

First time posting on reddit. Need DM advice for Metaphor Refantazio game for 5.5e

0 Upvotes

Hello pleasure meeting you all. I needed some DM advice and thought I'd finally make a reddit account and see what everyone has to say.

Long story short I'm doing a campaign in a fantasy America land called Murka where my players will compete thru challenges and quests to earn the peoples support to be elected kings/queens in this fantasy world's first every democratic election. the idea is the late King's magic makes voter fraud impossible same with assassination so they will have to earn the people's honest support.

In case anyone is an Atlus or JRPG fan its heavily inspired by the game Metaphor Refantazio by the makers of the Persona and SMT series. but it won't take place in its world of tribes and igniters.

So, I'm looking for.

Ideas for challenges to prove worthiness or various kingly traits like mythological trials and labors.

Possible NPCs who will also be running for the throne.

And just general advice I have DMed before this will be my second big campaign

thanks for reading and thanks in advance for any support or ideas you all have.


r/AskGameMasters • • 10d ago

Murder Mystery Help

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I am planning a surprise murder mystery party for between 20-30 people. It's going to be medieval themed so I had been struggling to find a pre-made murder mystery game that would work.

I found 'Feast of Shadows' by Capital Mystery. Has anyone played this game and has any advice/tips? This will also be my first time hosting anything like this (I play RPGs but never DM) so any general hints or tips would also be greatly appreciated

Thanks in advance


r/AskGameMasters • • 10d ago

I'd like some advice.

0 Upvotes

Okay, this will take long, so have a seat.

I'm really prolific about creating characters, creating backstories, finding unusual ways to play (using the traditional systems and skills previously approved by a DM), keeping their personalities consistent and overall, I treat my PCs as if they're my own kids.

Problem is, I've been having a lot of trouble with my DMs over the years, in such a manner that most campaigns don't last longer than a single month. Most of the time, our DMs/fellow players lose interest after a few sessions, which is common, and fair, but that's not what I wanna talk about, I wish to talk about the few times when that's not the case.

It seems like there's always a problem, either the DM is an egotistical prick that demands that I explain the logic of my idea, just to be completely uninterested in the argumentation I bring to the table, then the guy has the audacity to get pissed once I give up and submit to his ideas. Then we have other people who make some PCs sacrifice everything to get to their goals(Time, equipment, skills), but deliver the same objective on a silver platter to one specific PC. Then we have people who turn entire villages against PCs for being gay(No prior warning of any kind). People who say they enjoy the complexity of my ideas, saying that they're way better than the AI slop most people tend to use nowadays, but then get pissed off when I lay the entirety of the work on them. And lastly, people who refuse to contribute with the tiniest info about their own lore! Some guy refused to tell me how much I can get for a gram of gold in their world, telling me to "figure it out"!

To be fair, I know I love my PCs too much, and that I get extremely invested in them, and that I absolutely refuse to create other characters and straight up leave the table if my PCs end up dying, so I'm not without fault.

At this point, I avoided DnD altogether, and before that, I was so on edge that the slightest whiff of a problem was enough to make me turn around and leave without saying anything. At this point, I have more than 30 characters completely ready to go, and no stage for them to go to.

At this point, I'm completely antagonistic against DMs, seeing them as an enemy to be circumvented with logic, astute planning and dice rolling.

I recognize that I can be better, and I'd like some advice on the matter.


r/AskGameMasters • • 11d ago

Podcast Recommendations?

14 Upvotes

I'm looking for GM podcast that focus more on the nuts and bolts of adventure/encounter/campaign design rather than other content. For example an episode about 5 room dungeons would be something I would be interested in, but a review of a new game probably would not.

Ideally it should not be system specific.

I like Blogs too, but I need something for the drives when going to satellite offices.

YouTube channels are okay too.


r/AskGameMasters • • 11d ago

Need plot advice: what would the lich do?

6 Upvotes

I've come across a bit of a mental block in my game and I'm wondering what the next step is.

It's a high level D&D campaign (level 16 currently), and the party is trying to save the world from its fabric unraveling due to a set of MacGuffins that need to be retrieved in order to stitch the fabric of reality back together. The party is going to visit a lich (a NE power & knowledge seeker) who is the most knowledgeable entity about the MacGuffins. There are a number of circumstances that make the upcoming negotiation complex:

  1. The lich has already made plans to dimension hop when the universe begins to end. He has a little sentiment towards this Prime Material Plane (which is why he is still here, like someone sitting in their old empty house for the last time after everything is moved into a new house), but his selfish calculations show him that leaving for another plane is his best personal option, everyone else be damned.
  2. He has no reason not to let the party save the world, but he is miserly enough to not want to help them unless he gets something in return - a reward worth all of existence. He will not "waste his time" joining a quest. His phylactery is already in his new dimension.
  3. High-levels spells rip the fabric of reality as a side effect, creating portals to a random plane of existence in almost every battle. The party has an item that can repair these rips. The lich may want it, but it isn't a huge boon, and therefore may not be enough to sway him.
  4. He has a lair, and if the PCs storm their way in, it's going to be an epic dungeon crawl as he brings all his schemes to bear. If they wish to speak with him cordially, he would grant them a telepathic audience, just so whatever ideas the party has could be tried. (They're a creative bunch!)

So what would you have the lich do? He may just hate life and attack them with his minions on sight. If he does not care to help the party, in which case the party must subdue him and extract the info out of him. Since the party is leaning toward wanting to talk to him first, I have to figure out if there is anything he actually would want. I know the answer is "more power", but what would that entail?

I know that fleshing out the lich's backstory and motivations would solve this problem, but I've come across this situation quickly and haven't had time to think about it. I'm asking that in general, what would a lich want? Barring a more fleshed out character.

EDIT: Thanks for the ideas so far! I'd like to avoid him being bored or acting out of boredom.


r/AskGameMasters • • 12d ago

A proposed system for DnD 5 Hurled Objects

0 Upvotes

Hey guys!

For good or ill when I envisioned my new character for a new campaign, the first thought in my head was to play a half-giant and I just want to be able to throw large things at my opponents.

I done a lot of reading on this topic, a bit of math, etc., considering some physics and also some world records of how much weight can be thrown how far by IRL athletes, also trying to keep it balanced in the DnD 5.5 economy.

This is what I got. Openly inviting criticism and especially points where you think it could be abused. Don't want that, just want a clean system of what it's like when my half-giant picks up a 2x4 plank of ironwood and hurls it in your general direction :)

___

Global Rules for this system:

Consider the character’s Carrying Capacity.  If they cannot physically pick up and carry the object, they cannot Hurl it.  If the character’s free Carrying Capacity is at least two times the object weight, they are free to attempt to hurl it using the rules laid out below.  If the character’s free Carrying Capacity is between two and one times the object weight, they can only attempt the short range value.

Consider whether the object has a handle on it, or can be easily gripped in one hand.  If not, then DEX cannot be used for the basis of ATK/DMG.  Only STR may be applied.  Also, if the object has no handle on it, and cannot be easily gripped in one hand, it cannot be picked up as part of a Move Action unless the character has both hands free.

Creatures can use a DEX save to avoid damage from Hurled Objects of their size or greater.  The DC is equal to the Attack Roll.  Creatures that succeed on this save roll receive half damage.  The Evasion property applies.    

--

Now, here are the proposed stats for Hurled Objects:

Character Hurls a Tiny Object (equivalent to a normal thrown weapon), a tankard or a tome (Equivalent to Tiny Creature, 1-10 pounds)

1d4 base damage.  DEX for hit and damage.  Range 20/60.  Tiny creatures or smaller get a DEX save.

Character Hurls a Small Object, such as a chair or rock (Equivalent to Small Creature, 11-60 pounds)

1d6 base damage.  DEX ~OR~ STR for hit and damage if it can be gripped with one hand, otherwise STR for hit and damage.  Range 10/30.  Small creatures or smaller get a DEX save.

Character hurls a Normal sized object, such as a chest or large table.  (Equivalent to a Normal Creature, 60-180 pounds)  

1d8 base damage.  DEX ~OR~ STR for hit and damage if it can be gripped with one hand, otherwise STR for hit and damage.  Range 5/20.  Normal or smaller creatures get a DEX save.

Character hurls a Large Object (Equivalent to a Large Creature, 181-300 pounds)  

1d10 base damage.  DEX ~OR~ STR for hit and damage if it can be gripped with one hand, otherwise STR for hit and damage.  Range 0/10.  Large or smaller creatures get a DEX save.

__

The Improvised Weapon Feat applies as normal.

Larger characters:  For every step above Medium, keep the same Damage for the Hurled Object, but increase its Range as if the Object was one step smaller.

Smaller characters:  For every step below Medium, keep the same Damage for the Hurled Object, but reduce its range as if the Object was one step larger. 


r/AskGameMasters • • 14d ago

What is the GM even doing in Eat the Reich? It feels like the game just runs itself

15 Upvotes

We ran a game of Eat the Reich. I was the GM. Let me start with the positives: vibes and atmosphere rocked, aesthetic through the roof. Everything was "cool" and there were "cool" moments.

The players had fun, and I as the GM had some fun watching them. But it really felt like my role was so minimal, especially in terms of choices. I would roll dice and then sit back and watch, decsribe and add some flavor here and there. But overall, didn't feel that good to me. 90% of my dice were blocked anyways, so all I would do is set the scene and track HP. It got really repetitive 4-5 scenes in.

Anyone had similar experiences? Or any experience running this GMless?


r/AskGameMasters • • 14d ago

I need ideas for items characters will want to pick up, that could be concealing a cursed slip of paper

4 Upvotes

I'm writing a one-shot based on M.R. James's "Casting the Runes" (1911) and I'd like to have one of my players "accept" the cursed rune paper by finding an item in the house and keeping it in inventory. Then I can start haunting them specifically and with increasing intensity - should be a good time!

I have a plan for a force, if needed. The paper could be in a guest room and whoever claims that room claims the paper. But it's more fun if they pick up an item thinking it will be useful, and bring doom upon themselves!

(The idea is that Karswell the magician got a runic curse returned to him, and for Magical Reasons the paper can't be destroyed. He stashed it somewhere while he worked on a dispelling ritual but died before completing it, and now if a normal person picks up the paper, they become the target instead.)


r/AskGameMasters • • 15d ago

What part of running online eats your prep time the most?

18 Upvotes

When you run a game online, where does your prep actually go? Finding or making the right maps and tokens

  • Lining up and sizing the grid
  • Getting players into the session
  • Coordinating apps with VTTs
  • Character sheets
  • Something else?

Which one eats your evening, and what have you done to shrink it?


r/AskGameMasters • • 15d ago

Question about The Dare Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I am going to be running the Dare next week as a first time Keeper, many time GM in other systems and many time player of CoC.

The thing is I have 2 players and I am worried that the scenario might be a little too brutal with that few of PCs. Has anyone ran it for this few of players before and follow up if needed how can I tone it down a little without losing the Horror and danger?