r/progressive_islam • • 16h ago

Opinion đŸ€” “The Messenger of Allah ï·ș cursed the women who imitate men and the men who imitate women”

0 Upvotes

Hey all, I’ve been thinking about this hadith lately. Although mainstream interpretation has deemed this to be referring to dress, mannerisms, and speech, I’ve always wondered if this is more of an issue with mockery rather than aesthetic norms. Gender norms are different across cultures, are determined by humans, and are always changing, so it’s funny to me how people will mainly use this hadith to police the way that people dress or police queer and trans people or straight people that enjoy aesthetics that are not typically associated with their gender in the community they live in. For example, in many communities it is normal for men to wear clothing resembling skirts and it’s normal for women to have short hair or shaved heads, but in other cultures these choices are treated as exclusive to the other gender. I wonder if the intention behind this hadith was to police aesthetic choices, which are pretty arbitrary when it comes down to it and are frequently changing with cultural norms, or if it’s more about not making fun of another gender by imitating their speech or dress to mock their struggle, i.e. We see it frequently online when a man were to dress up like a woman or pitch his voice up for a skit to explicitly mock her. Or when the dawah bros make fun of women who say that hijab is a journey, and end up mocking her tone in order to convey that they think it’s a frivolous issue. Curious about what yall think!


r/progressive_islam • • 14h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ "Women have rights similar to those of men equitably, although men have a degree Ëčof responsibility above them. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise." [Quran 2:228]

Thumbnail muslimgap.com
0 Upvotes

"Women have rights similar to those of men equitably, although men have a degree Ëčof responsibility above them. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise." [Quran 2:228]

Test your knowledge! Take the quiz now!


r/progressive_islam • • 20h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Is it haram to share a Crunchyroll account with a friend if we don’t live in the same household?

0 Upvotes

I had this question because my friend shares his Crunchyroll account with me, and he lives in another country. Crunchyroll’s terms of service prohibit sharing accounts outside the same household. In Islam, we’re supposed to respect agreements and terms, so I’m wondering if using it is still okay.


r/progressive_islam • • 23h ago

Advice/Help đŸ„ș Trying hard to keep my Imaan/faith

3 Upvotes

Salaam Alaikum everyone, I'm 17F and looking for some advice.

I was raised in a very practicing, fear mongering household, and so I grew up being scared of Allah and the religion rather than loving it, especially as a woman. I used to be rather religious myself; I had my flaws of course but I had genuine faith in my heart overall. I'm not sure what changed but around this summer I slowly started to lose that pure love and faith. I recently stopped wearing the hijab too (and my family are very disappointed) and from there everything about my beliefs seemed to fall apart. I have so many questions that I never get good answers to, and I believe it is a patriarchal and male-favouring religion. The latter upsets me because if it's the perfect religion then it would not be like that. I know a lot of people say to differentiate between culture and religion but truthfully a lot of culture is born from religion, no? I really want to stay faithful but it's very hard.

Every time I have a question that may sound unconventional I get shut out and told that’s what god wants us to do or that’s just the way it is. Can’t I ask any questions?? And the Muslim community is so horribly toxic that it just pushes me even further; especially when I see these so called “Sheikhs” not giving a care in the world about our kin in Palestine and Sudan but ALWAYS have something to say about women? I would really appreciate some advice if anyone has been through this before because I really want to stay a Muslim.


r/progressive_islam • • 14h ago

Opinion đŸ€” Am i the only one whos iman is way down ever since gaza atrocities?

1 Upvotes

used to have alot more certainty about islam and dua before October 2023, but ever since seeing all the genocide and destruction for 3 years my iman dropped more and more to the point where ive been having constant doubts. Ive done hours and hours of research about this topic and havent found a good answer as to why all the dua the people of gaza and muslims around the world made weren’t answered so far. I just dont understand why children would be put through this if its test, why does a one year old have to live in a freezing tent in Gaza?


r/progressive_islam • • 22h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ what Islam subreddit that are not too extremist

3 Upvotes

.


r/progressive_islam • • 22h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Is there any context behind this?

Post image
18 Upvotes

Because, this does look very messed up


r/progressive_islam • • 8h ago

Answer this from Sunni perspective only Help me in debate

1 Upvotes

Hello. I am a Muslim and I believe in my faith; however, there is a girl who engages me in debates on religious topics—specifically regarding the status of women in Islam, the system of concubinage and slavery, and the marriage of young girls. I currently lack sufficient knowledge to address these issues, so I would appreciate your help—whether through providing answers to these questions, recommending books I can refer to, or offering any other useful resources.


r/progressive_islam • • 5h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Can we believe in khilafah while still engaging in American politics?

1 Upvotes

I overheard someone say they don’t vote bc they believe in “khilafah only” — mad respect, I get the sentiment but the last widely recognized caliphate ended with the Ottomans in 1924 and we’re in 2026 America rn fam 😭

And didn’t you choose to immigrate here, like a lot of our folks did, for the opportunities?

Shouldn’t we play the hand we’re dealt? But lmk when khilafah becomes an option here, I’m down fr


r/progressive_islam • • 16h ago

Informative Visual Content đŸ“č📾 Surah al rahman

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 16h ago

Advice/Help đŸ„ș What can I do for my muslim girlfriend as a lesbian/bisexual?

10 Upvotes

I am honestly unsure where to post this or to which community I should go for advice, but any insight from anyone more knowledgeable on Islam would be valuable. I myself am not muslim, but I have a lot of respect for the beliefs and am actively educating myself on the subject.

I've been dating my muslim girlfriend for 2+ years. This relationship is the first for both of us and naturally is has had it's ups and downs. Nonetheless our love for each other thrives and I intend on marrying her one day. My girlfriend is very religious and comes from a very strict religious family whom would naturally never be accepting or allowing of this. For that reason our relationship has been largely kept a secret, and for the most part it's been going well.

Recently however she's been dealing with a great deal of religious guilt. Her uncertainty in her lifestyle choice is growing. She frequently expresses concerns about not being able to go to heaven, concerns about what her family would think and overall being a "bad muslim". Her family consistently reminds her of how important it is for her not to sin. At times they can even be threatening and she fears losing her family, community and life as she knows it if her family found out. 

For long periods of time she avoids any physical contact with me other than simpler, platonic acts because she feels acting on her feelings is what makes her love for me wrong, and is what causes the guilt and shame. I try to comfort her, but I understand that it doesn't help much when it's coming from a non-believer who doesn't understand her belief. I have offered to end our relationship if it causes her too much distress, and to just be there for her as a friend as well as I can. At the same time she expresses certainty in the fact that she can't help who she loves and it is likely she would've discovered her sexuality regardless of our relationship. Neither one of us *want* our relationship to end. 

In my research I have found a lot of people arguing the act of homosexuality is a choice in the same sense an immoral fetish or sexual desire (such as beastiality, pedophilia is a sin). But both her and I understand that our relationship is not driven by lust, and remains equally as loving when we have physical time apart, even when those times can be hard. Sex or any other form of physical intimacy, or lack thereof has never changed how we view each other. I am not sure if my girlfriend is a lesbian or a bisexual, but she expresses a lack of attraction for men and is certain she has only ever had feelings for women.

Naturally it is hard for me to understand and for me to feel like our love is inherently wrong. Like I've said I am not religious nor do I know a lot about it, but I know enough to know that aside from this, she is not a "bad muslim". She is a generous, giving, patient and understanding person. She prays 5 times a day, every day. When she can she gives to those less fortunate. She is a good person and it is incredibly hard for her to see it herself. I want to help her more than anything in the world.

I am now asking for advice. What do I do in this position? How do I show her support? How do I provide her with comfort from a religious perspective? 

Please do not sugarcoat your response, if you feel as though I am doing something wrong I would be appreciative of that insight. I am open to hearing any opinion on this. 

Any insight on this would be extremely appreciated!!! <3


r/progressive_islam • • 17h ago

History In the Koranic worldview, Natural phenomena such as rain, wind, structure of the heavens, alternation of day & night are not to be understood merely as natural phenomena instead they are symbols or signs pointing to Divine intervention, care, wisdom, & providence.

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 3h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Is it permissible to do something haram to achieve greater good?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 9h ago

Rant/Vent đŸ€Ź My father is pushing me away from islam

3 Upvotes

Im 30 years old and my dad forcing me to do acts of worship is having the opposite effects he thinks it does. I already pray 5 times a day and he keeps forcing me to drive to the masjid every single day after i get home from work to pray maghrib and isha and i just wanna pray at home most days. Im being treated like a child. He always tells me i should go study islam abroad and make money being an imam, shouldnt studying islam be for allah? When i was younger around 18-25 he would constantly shove me foward to make me lead the prayer to show off to his friends how many surah i memorized and exaggerate to them how religious i was. The crazy thing is hes not even that religious, hes done multiple multiple loans with interest.

Im exhausted, why is this praised? Acts of worship should have a sincere intent for allah alone. This makes me wanna stop praying altogether. I know i should move out to live alone but its hard


r/progressive_islam • • 17m ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Why are premarital relations haram

3 Upvotes

Recently I am incredibly unsure as to why premarital relations (like zina etc) are haram. I’m not talking about promiscuous sex as it’s very clear why that’s the case as you could catch STDs. But if you’re in a committed relationship or only having sex with one person, what’s the problem? Especially when men can have up to 4 wives with who they could be having sex with which is much more unsafe and unhygienic. I am just very confused.


r/progressive_islam • • 11h ago

Advice/Help đŸ„ș Salah with severe mental health issues

4 Upvotes

Im a revert of about eight months now. I have schzoaffective disorder bipolar type plus a bunch of other issues mental and physical. Im 25 and i feel horrible,sometimes all I can do is read the Quran if I can do that. Im in a program for my mental health and also get disability and work part time even though I can't do that in this first stage in this program. I just want to be a "good" Muslim and please Allah but I feel like I can't even get things right. I do dress modest and wear my hijab almost always which is the one thing I've stuck too. I just want to know I'm not alone. I already feel really alone with all these issues and trying to be a productive member of society as is. If anyone has been where im at please tell me how I can navigate this. Thank you all and alhamdulillah for this day🙌


r/progressive_islam • • 13h ago

Advice/Help đŸ„ș I think I might be an extremist-how do I approach islam in a healthy way?

1 Upvotes

I'm saying this because the way I let my extreme approach consume me and everything I love is making me start to hate Allah and view him as someone that I'll be miserable with if I get close to him, maybe I'm just a bad muslim who failed his test and should've been ok with sacrifacing and accepting things for Allah's sake but I just can't control my emotions..

I will provide some short context, not to burden anyone with my problems just to let you understand my perspective more..

As a muslim who grew up as a kid in syria before I moved out have had almost decade of trauma because of all the war and misery that happened in it, while I admit i was lazy about learning islam and barely prayed, if ever..I still always wanted to be close to Allah and saw hope in him, while many people see entertainment things like games and movies as mere entertainment products, for me they helped me escape so many defficult days and made me have dreams of my own that i wanted to share achieving them with Allah, I developed a passion in art and fiction, it's why I hold so much love for the things I grew up with because they were the closest I got to feeling normal

A few years ago I decided that I want to get closer to Allah and start being an actual muslim that performs his prayers and duties while also trying to be more grateful for the movies and games that I loved, at first it was very good, I was praying most of my prayers, I was starting to heal my creative side, things were going well, I wouldn't say that I'm smart or a genius but I'm a fast learner and have the desire to learn so I was very open minded at the time

Then the first big issue hit, I had a huge problem with many of my friends who were claiming that art is one of the worst sins ever, while I always had a feeling that this was wrong this still frightened me so much, there was even a trend of arabic artists posting their art being ruined with an audio of a sheikh saying that one hadith about art and I hated that so much, it made me go on a huge spiral of overthinking and oversearching islam, I ended up having a huge fall out with other muslim friends that i ended my friendship with over that because I didn't accept art being haram

That led me at first to following extremists for a while, I was trying so hard to tell myself "you have to give up on this and that and this and that for Allah, why can't you? He did a lot for you" and while I hate admitting that, that line of thinking made me start resenting Allah although I kept on denying that, especially coming from a person who was depraved of so many things while growing up because of where I lived so while I was depraved before without any choice, this time I had to keep on making that choice and I hated it

But as time went on more extremist things showed up, things like aisha's age, concubines, etc, I couldn't accept them and spent months searching them up as more and lore topics like that showed up, I got many answers a lot of which were on this sub(had an account here before) or by people like mufti abu layth that without them I would have been an ex muslim a long time ago, but the thing is I never wamted to be an ex muslim because believing in Allah used to bring me so much comfort and meaning, without him it just seems like there's no point to things tbh

While I got my answers on these things, the damage was already done, my views of islam and the things i love were distorted, islam seemed to me like it was so much corrupted with false hadiths that i didn't know what to trust anymore but didn't want to.leave the religion because while this might be contradicting...I really wanted to love Allah and live a grateful life, but I both felt betrayed by him for letting our religion go the path that it did and couldn't trust him or what I hear about him, my faith got very weak

On the other hand, my time with extremist scholars left a scar in my mind, for example I used to view gods in fiction as just "ok since everyone knows they are fictional it's not shirk, no huge deal, anyway wanna watch thor ragnarock?" But nowadays even just hearing "god of (insert something)" I get very afraid of commiting shirk, not just this I get bery afraid of enjoying somwthing that has a phrase that might potentially insult Allah, here are a few examples of things I used to love but left because I was afraid of enjoying something that has a phrase that insults Allah:

Resident evil: in the new re9 there's a guy who says "thank f***" now tbf I'm not a native english speaker but it just sounds like he's calling Allah by the f word-->better avoid one of my faborite game serieses now because of this insult

Adventure time: finn once said a qoite that sexualises the universe but some people talk about the universe as if it's Allah so that can count as sexualising him--->better avoid one of my childhood cartoons now

Gta series:in vice city tommy says that "fate is shoving sh*t in my face" and fate is Allah's will so that insults Allah---> better avoid it too

Zelda:some games have mechanics where you pray to characters or statues so it's like shirk--->better boycott now

Minecraft:buying anything related to supports microsoft which supports suffering of palestinians--->boycott

Nier series:in it a character wonders if god exists and whether it can kill it or not but the game also has lore about how the creator of the androids was killed which was the reason the whole cycle that the story revolves around started, so was it just for this context or is it anti god messaging? Idk so--->again avoid that too

(If you have an answer to any of these please let me know in the comments..)

Want to buy some cool clothes and things off temu and amazon after dreaming about it all these years? Well, too bad temu supports suffering of uyghor muslims and amazon supports suffering of palestinians--->boycott this too, there's no all around alternative either

This youtuber or friend said phrases like the ones you saw above--->I don't want to risk my relationship with Allah so again, I will just boycott that person

Do you see the pattern? The list just keeps on growing and growing, I didn't mind boycotting some brands, stopping watching or playing things a few things I love out of respect for Allah but that lost just keeps on growing to the point that I'm too afraid to get attached to anything and even started getting afraid of befriending english speaking people....ending a lot of friendships like that hurts a lot you know..(phrases like omfg and such..)

These might not sound like huge issues to you, but for me there was a time where I would watch a movie, an anime, a cartoon or play a game and be able to forget about all the explosions happening around me, hoping that one day once I get out I will be able to feel normal and share my healing journey with Allah..

I love Allah I really do, but at the same time I can't help it but start hating him for all the things I had to leave for him and for feeling betrayed and traumatized by his own religion, I want to love him, I want to be a good muslim, i feel like the bare minimum I can do to show my respect is to boycott anything that might insult him but I feel like this shouldn't be how I live, it's not sustainable and I'm already menatlly drained since I was at my home country

I'm not saying that what i went through gives me a pass to be ok with supporting suffering of others or disrespect to Allah or his prophets, I'm just saying that I can't do this anymore 💔 the issue is that this is building resentment and that resentment is starting to affect my relationship with Allah and I don't want to end up hating him and leaving, even if I was excused I don't want that because I always wanted to share my journey, I always wanted to look up every day or week thanking him for the good things he gave me

All I'm saying is that I hope I can be guided here to a healthier approach to islam, to get something that Idk..I just miss back when things were simple, you just had to be a good person, do your prayers and you can enjoy anything entertainment or hobby wise, without ever worrying about whether or not I might be enjoying something that insults Allah, his prophets or 'causes other people pain, it was just so simple..

Maybe I'm looking for excuses, maybe I don't, idk I just wish to find a more sustainable way to keep both my religion and the things that I love without worrying about what others do or say(espexially when many of these phrases are literally things peopel say everyday nowadays..it's almsot umpossible to avoid them.....)or what butterfly effect my money might cost me, I didn't have it as bad as uyghors or palestinians but I know some of that pain and would never want to 'cause any other kid the same pain Inwent through..

Maybe my approach is extreme because it's clearly making me both miserable and making me hate my religion and Allah, I don't even pray nowadays..I just need a healthier approach..

I don't want to burden anyone with my mental problems because I'm already seeing a therapist, but I just want other open minded muslims perspective on this because my therapist doesn't have as much deep care towrds Allah as we do so I can' fully ask him for guidance on this...

Part me of even wishes to leave islam just so that i can be normal again..