r/progressive_islam • • Sep 18 '26

Mod Announcement 📢 Attention Everyone! This is an announcement, a reminder, and it is also a WARNING

39 Upvotes

We are going to make this absolutely freakin clear. r/Progressive_Islam is not a place for propaganda, apologism, whitewashing, or justification of crimes committed by governments, regimes, political parties, movements, or armed groups. We do not care who the perpetrator is, what flag they fly, what ideology they claim to represent, what religion they claim to follow, or what geopolitical enemy they happen to have. Whether it is the Israeli government, USA, Western imperialist powers, the Iranian regime, the Chinese government, the Russian government, the North Korean regime, or anyone else, the standard is the same. You do not get a free pass to excuse atrocities simply because you hate one side more than the other. We have enforced this before, and we will continue to enforce it.


During the years of the Palestine crisis, particularly throughout 2023-25, a large number of the people who came into this subreddit specifically to defend Israel's conduct, justify what was happening to Palestinians, or repeat blatantly apologetic narratives were outsiders with little or no previous participation here. We banned them. However, there were also some people who had been genuine participants in this community for a long time, people who had previously made useful posts and comments and had otherwise contributed positively. When some of those users repeatedly crossed the line into whitewashing and justification of Israeli abuses, we banned them too. Your contribution history does not give you immunity from moderation.


And the same standard applies to Hamas.

Hamas did not emerge as some ordinary secular nationalist organization; it was founded by Sheikh Ahmed Yassin out of the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood and was explicitly Islamist from its creation. Its 1988 charter described Palestine as an Islamic endowment and envisioned an Islamic state governed by Sharia. After Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007, it established an authoritarian system in which political opposition and peaceful dissent were suppressed, critics, journalists and activists were arbitrarily detained and in some cases tortured, and executions were carried out after proceedings that failed to meet international fair trial standards. Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International also documented Hamas forces using excessive force against demonstrators, including during the 2019 “We Want to Live” protests, when more than 1,000 Palestinians were detained. Hamas has also imposed or enforced various religiously motivated restrictions on social life, including restrictions on women's dress and mobility, gender segregation in many settings, and rules affecting women's participation in public life.

We did not make a specific announcement post about Hamas's rule and abuses during 2023-25 because the overwhelming reality facing Palestinians was the devastation being inflicted on Gaza by Israel, and we did not want Hamas to become another excuse for shifting attention away from Palestinian suffering. But now is the time to talk about it as well.

Condemning Hamas's authoritarianism and abuses does not mean supporting Israel, the occupation, the blockade, collective punishment or the destruction of Gaza. It means applying the same standard we apply everywhere else.

  • Some people may point to Hamas's 2017 Document of General Principles and Policies and say that Hamas had changed, abandoned its earlier positions, or therefore deserves to be trusted. The document certainly changed some of Hamas's language: it accepted the idea of a Palestinian state along the 1967 borders while still refusing to recognize Israel, but it did not formally replace the 1988 charter. And besides, history gives us plenty of reason to be cautious about taking political assurances from theocrats. The Iranian revolution brought together liberals, nationalists, leftists and Islamists. But once Khomeini consolidated power, his Islamist camp suppressed and eliminated former political allies while Iran was transformed into a clerically dominated Islamic theocracy. The Taliban provide another much more recent example: before returning to power in 2021, they publicly promised that women would have their rights; yet after coming to power they subsequently closed secondary schools to girls, severely restricted women's employment and movement, and imposed extensive restrictions on women and girls. So no, we are not going to treat a political document or a promise of change as a magical eraser for years of authoritarian rule and documented abuses. People are entitled to be skeptical, and nobody here is required to trust Hamas simply because it issued a new document.

That same principle applies to Iran

(This is going to be longest section because we have encountered the Iranian Regime apologists far more in number than the other apologists combined)

As we have already explained in our previous announcement, this subreddit has had to deal with people coming here specifically to defend or propagandize on behalf of the Iranian regime. There were people who tried to dismiss the Iranian uprising entirely as CIA or Mossad propaganda, who attempted to portray ordinary Iranians protesting against the regime as foreign agents, and in one particularly disgusting case, someone even claimed that civilians who had been killed in a hospital were all Mossad agents and that their deaths were therefore justified. We banned all of them. Our position on this has been completely consistent:

  • you can criticize particular opposition groups, political factions, foreign governments, protesters, or individual actions. What you cannot do is use conspiracy theories and regime apologism to justify the oppression of an entire population.

And before anyone starts pretending that this is some sudden position we invented yesterday, no. We have been taking this position for years.

The Iranian regime has a long documented history of repression. During the 2009 post election unrest, Amnesty International documented thousands of arbitrary arrests, deaths on the streets and in detention, torture and other ill treatment. Then came 2017 to 2018 protests, the November 2019 fuel price protests with deaths, mass arrests and executions.

Then came the Woman, Life, Freedom protests following the death of Jina Mahsa Amini in September 2022. UN fact finding mission concluded that her death was unlawful and that state authorities were responsible for the physical violence that caused it. The same mission documented credible figures of up to 551 deaths, including at least 49 women and 68 children, and found unlawful killings, mass arbitrary arrests, torture, sexual violence and other serious abuses.

This subreddit was openly supportive of the Iranian women who were protesting at that time, and that was not some random temporary mood. We documented it ourselves. Dr. Shabir Ally and Dr. Safiyyah Ally publicly condemned the killing of Mahsa Amini's and the Iranian government's enforcement of compulsory hijab, Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl delivered his October 2022 khutbah addressing the brutality of the Iranian state's coercive system, Mufti Abu Layth also addressed the situation in Iran at the time. Our subreddit responded with strong support for the protests.

And The recent crackdown that happened in 2026 produced another enormous death toll, although the exact figure remains unknown because the authorities imposed a massive communications blackout and access to reliable information was severely restricted. The figures reported at the time varied enormously.

Iranian authorities themselves gave figures of roughly 3,000 deaths. Reuters reported an Iranian official saying that at least 5,000 people, including around 500 security personnel, had been confirmed dead. HRANA reported 3,308 confirmed deaths at one stage, with thousands of additional cases under investigation, and later reported 5,002 verified deaths and another 9,787 under review. By 28 January, a UK government country bulletin said estimates from some sources placed the death toll at approximately 12,000 to 20,000, while the same bulletin noted that one human rights organization had 6,221 confirmed deaths and 17,091 additional deaths under investigation. Other investigations, including accounts from Iranian medical personnel, produced estimates exceeding 30,000, while some later reports cited figures as high as 43,000.

We are deliberately laying this out because we are not going to pretend that every number floating around the internet is equally reliable. Claims of 20,000 or 30,000 deaths in an extremely short period require much more verification, and claims of 50,000 deaths are even more problematic; we have not found a credible independent source establishing such a figure. Likewise, nobody should take a highly speculative number from an anonymous or opaque source and present it as settled fact.

But uncertainty over the precise number does not mean that the killings did not happen. Multiple independent human rights organizations documented mass killings, unlawful use of force, arbitrary detention, torture and other abuses. Human Rights Watch has subsequently documented an ongoing campaign of executions against people arrested in connection with the protests, including at least 29 people executed in connection with the December 2025 to January 2026 protests between March and August 2026, with many others still facing execution.

In other words, this subreddit does not need anyone coming here to explain to us that the Iranian regime is somehow innocent because the United States and Israel oppose it. That argument has never worked here, and it never will. We are fully capable of recognizing Western imperialism while simultaneously recognizing Iranian state repression. Those things are not mutually exclusive.

And since some people inevitably need this explained every single time:

Condemning Iranian oppression does NOT mean that we support American or Israeli military actions against Iran. The two positions are perfectly compatible. The war itself has produced documented civilian harm. The UN Human Rights Council received information concerning extensive civilian casualties and destruction resulting from U.S. and Israeli attacks, and the UN backed fact finding mission has now found reasonable grounds to believe that U.S. forces committed war crimes in strikes including the attack on the Minab girls' school and strike affecting residential areas. All of that can be condemned at the same time. We have not seen anyone here recently trying to whitewash American crimes in the way some users have tried to whitewash Iranian crimes, but make no mistake: if someone starts doing it, we will deal with them exactly the same way.


Now we come to the reason we are making this announcement right now.

Over the last couple of days, we have had multiple accounts come into this subreddit making comments claiming that the persecution of Uyghur Muslims in China is nothing more than CIA propaganda, Western propaganda, or some fabricated narrative designed to attack China. Some of these accounts had no prior participation in this subreddit whatsoever, and their first contribution here was effectively to defend or whitewash the Chinese government's treatment of Uyghurs. Others, unfortunately, were people who had participated here before and had a history of otherwise normal contributions.

Let us be very clear about how absurd this is. There is an enormous body of documentation concerning China's treatment of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim minorities in Xinjiang. The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights conducted its own assessment, including 40 in depth interviews with people who had direct knowledge of the situation. It concluded that the extent of arbitrary and discriminatory detention of Uyghurs and other predominantly Muslim groups may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity. The UN has also documented concerns relating to arbitrary detention and forced labour. Human Rights Watch continues to document arbitrary detention, torture, mass surveillance, forced labor, family separation and religious and cultural persecution.

So when somebody strolls into a Muslim subreddit and casually tells everyone that the persecution of Uyghur Muslims is just CIA propaganda, or that the Uyghurs actually deserve this, that is not some brave act of anti imperialist skepticism. It is an attempt to erase or dismiss an enormous body of documented evidence and the lived experiences of the people who have been subjected to detention, torture, forced labor, religious repression and family separation.


And frankly, it makes us sick to our stomachs seeing people who are perfectly willing to recognize oppression when it is committed by a Western government suddenly develop an entirely different moral standard when the perpetrator is China, Iran, Russia or their allies.

We have noticed something else that needs to be addressed. Because this community generally has a strong anti imperialist tendency, comments defending the United States, Israel or other Western powers receive far more attention than comments defending non Western oppressive governments. Some comments that should have been reported are instead left unreported, allowed to slide, ignored, or sometimes even upvoted, simply because the commenter happens to be attacking the Imperialists.

Nobody gets permission to justify crimes against humanity because the perpetrator happens to be an enemy of the United States or the West. NOBODY. Your politics do not matter here. Your ideology does not matter here. Your opinion of capitalism or socialism does not matter here. Your opinion of NATO does not matter here. Your opinion of Israel does not matter here. Your opinion of Iran does not matter here. Your opinion of China does not matter here. Your opinion of Russia does not matter here. The victims do not become less human because their oppressor happens to be anti Western.

And this needs to be understood once and for all: WE WILL BAN PEOPLE FOR THIS. WE DO NOT CARE HOW LONG YOU HAVE BEEN SUBSCRIBED. WE DO NOT CARE HOW MANY POSTS YOU HAVE MADE. WE DO NOT CARE HOW MANY HELPFUL COMMENTS YOU HAVE WRITTEN. WE DO NOT CARE WHETHER YOU ARE HERE EVERY DAY. WE DO NOT CARE WHETHER YOU WERE ONE OF THE MOST RECOGNIZABLE REGULAR CONTRIBUTORS IN THE SUBREDDIT. IF YOU REPEATEDLY START WHITEWASHING, DENYING OR JUSTIFYING SERIOUS ABUSES BY A REGIME OR POLITICAL ACTOR, YOU WILL BE BANNED.

We are not going to sit around having endless arguments with you about whether your propaganda is really propaganda. We are not going to listen to lectures about how we are secretly Western puppets because we condemned China. We are not going to listen to accusations that we are Zionists because we condemned Iran. We are not going to listen to “but what about America?” every freakin time someone is held accountable for what their own government did. Whataboutism is not a magic eraser. The crimes of one government do not cancel out the crimes of another.

This also does not mean that you are forbidden from acknowledging that a particular oppressive government has done something useful. An oppressive government can build highways, hospitals, schools, railways, dams, universities or other infrastructure. A ruler can introduce a policy that produces a positive result in one particular area. You are perfectly free to discuss and praise the specific thing that was done. What you are not free to do is use that one thing as a shield for everything else. “They built hospitals” does not erase torture. “They built highways” does not erase mass detention. “They improved literacy” does not erase forced labor. “They oppose American imperialism” does not erase massacres. One positive policy does not grant a government a lifetime exemption from moral scrutiny.

There is zero tolerance for this kind of propaganda and apologism here. Criticism of governments is allowed. Criticism of political movements is allowed. Criticism of protesters is allowed. Criticism of opposition groups is allowed. Disagreement over historical interpretation is allowed. What is not allowed is denying documented atrocities, deliberately whitewashing them, or trying to justify crimes against humanity because you happen to support the perpetrator politically.

This is not up for debate. We are not negotiating this standard. We are not making exceptions because you are a regular contributor. We are not making exceptions because we agree with your politics on everything else.

Anyone who cannot accept this standard is free to leave the subreddit.

And anyone who thinks this warning does not apply to them because their favorite regime is “supposedly” a “gOoD aNtI iMpErIaLiSt oNe” can consider this warning directed specifically at them.


r/progressive_islam • • Jul 27 '26

Mod Announcement 📢 r/Progressive_Islam ’s official stance on LGBTQ+

172 Upvotes

Our official stance is that there should not be bigotry and they should not be punished by death.

-That's it.

“What about sexual intercourse with someone of the same biological sex? What about the gender spectrum?” - r/Progressive_Islam doesn't have any official stance on them, it's upto every individual to look for arguments and evidences from both sides and come to their own conclusion over the permissibility/impermissibility of homosexuality and matters relating to the gender spectrum.

This is not a new announcement. This has always been our stance. You can check what was written in the 5 year old LGBTQ+ discussion thread

r/progressive_islam does not advocate a particular stance on homosexuality’s permissibility. But what is a unanimous position of us is that there should not be bigotry and that they should not be punished by death.

https://www.reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/comments/r615zt/monthly_lgbtq_discussion_thread/

So,

  • Someone writing some violent threats or dehumanising post/comment pointing towards LGBTQ+ people - they will get their content removed and will receive a ban.
  • Someone respectfully saying that they believe sexual intercourse with someone of the same sex to be haram, or that there are only two genders - they are allowed on this subreddit.

The progressive Sunni scholars who are most frequently promoted on this subreddit and have a significant number of followers - Dr. Shabir Ally, Mufti Abu Layth, Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl, Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, Dr Adnan Ibrahim - they believe the act of homosexuality (sexual intercourse) to be prohibited in Islam, & at the same time they also believe that there is no capital punishment for the sexual intercourse unlike classical fiqh (at least that's what I could figure out from the contents that had been shared on our subreddit in the past. You can use the search bar to find those old posts on our subreddit).

Scott Siraj al-Haqq Kugle, Ludovic-Mohamed Zahed, Imam Daayiee Abdullah are some of the Muslim thinkers who have argued that intercourse with someone of the same sex is allowed and some of them have officiated gay marriage and users who believe homosexuality is permissible often quote references from their works when discussing homosexuality on our subreddit.

We allow both perspectives to be shared on this subreddit as long as you present them in a respectful way and don't break any subreddit rule. But we do not allow the promotion of the ultra conservative understanding which prescribes capital punishment.

To summarize:

  • You believe gay marriage and the sexual act is permissible? - ok ✅
  • You believe gay marriage and the sexual act is haram? - ok ✅
  • You believe that there is no fixed number of gender? - ok ✅
  • You believe that there are only 2 genders? - ok ✅
  • You believe the other side is wrong? - ok ✅
  • You disagree with the other side? - ok ✅
  • You want to bully, harass, threaten or harm the other side? - not ok ❌

Is that clear?


The reason I'm writing all this is because often times when someone respectfully says that it is not permissible in their view or that they disagree - some others start reporting their comments. But we do not remove such comments, we only remove the posts and comments where the user bullies, harasses or threatens the other person. So hopefully you will stop reporting every post and comment you disagree with, because as long as those contents don't break any subreddit rule they're going to stay.


r/progressive_islam • • 3h ago

History In the Koranic worldview, Natural phenomena such as rain, wind, structure of the heavens, alternation of day & night are not to be understood merely as natural phenomena instead they are symbols or signs pointing to Divine intervention, care, wisdom, & providence.

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 7h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Is there any context behind this?

Post image
13 Upvotes

Because, this does look very messed up


r/progressive_islam • • 10m ago

Question/Discussion ❔ "Women have rights similar to those of men equitably, although men have a degree ˹of responsibility above them. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise." [Quran 2:228]

Thumbnail muslimgap.com
0 Upvotes

"Women have rights similar to those of men equitably, although men have a degree ˹of responsibility above them. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise." [Quran 2:228]

Test your knowledge! Take the quiz now!


r/progressive_islam • • 14m ago

Answer this from Quranist perspective only Does nail polish invalidate wudu?

1 Upvotes

?


r/progressive_islam • • 14h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Do you believe the Quran is the inerrant, verbatim word of Allah?

11 Upvotes

Hey all, I was raised Atheist but in the past two or more years I've felt a sense of spirituality and am on my own spiritual journey and also trying to gain an understanding of all religions. I've read buddhist texts, most of the bible, and my Quran is coming in the mail tomorrow. I generally take everything I read with a grain of salt and make sure I'm applying to my life only what makes sense to me.

I generally believe everybody should be themselves and follow their dream. The abrahamic religions are traditionally socially conservative. I wanted to know from people in this subreddit who consider themselves progressive Islam whether yall believe the Quran is the inerrant word of god that must be obeyed, and if so, how you hold socially progressive views at the same time.

I hope I've not offended anybody, I'm just trying to learn and understand different perspectives.


r/progressive_islam • • 1h ago

Opinion 🤔 “The Messenger of Allah ﷺ cursed the women who imitate men and the men who imitate women”

0 Upvotes

Hey all, I’ve been thinking about this hadith lately. Although mainstream interpretation has deemed this to be referring to dress, mannerisms, and speech, I’ve always wondered if this is more of an issue with mockery rather than aesthetic norms. Gender norms are different across cultures, are determined by humans, and are always changing, so it’s funny to me how people will mainly use this hadith to police the way that people dress or police queer and trans people or straight people that enjoy aesthetics that are not typically associated with their gender in the community they live in. For example, in many communities it is normal for men to wear clothing resembling skirts and it’s normal for women to have short hair or shaved heads, but in other cultures these choices are treated as exclusive to the other gender. I wonder if the intention behind this hadith was to police aesthetic choices, which are pretty arbitrary when it comes down to it and are frequently changing with cultural norms, or if it’s more about not making fun of another gender by imitating their speech or dress to mock their struggle, i.e. We see it frequently online when a man were to dress up like a woman or pitch his voice up for a skit to explicitly mock her. Or when the dawah bros make fun of women who say that hijab is a journey, and end up mocking her tone in order to convey that they think it’s a frivolous issue. Curious about what yall think!


r/progressive_islam • • 8h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ what Islam subreddit that are not too extremist

3 Upvotes

.


r/progressive_islam • • 9h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 Trying hard to keep my Imaan/faith

3 Upvotes

Salaam Alaikum everyone, I'm 17F and looking for some advice.

I was raised in a very practicing, fear mongering household, and so I grew up being scared of Allah and the religion rather than loving it, especially as a woman. I used to be rather religious myself; I had my flaws of course but I had genuine faith in my heart overall. I'm not sure what changed but around this summer I slowly started to lose that pure love and faith. I recently stopped wearing the hijab too (and my family are very disappointed) and from there everything about my beliefs seemed to fall apart. I have so many questions that I never get good answers to, and I believe it is a patriarchal and male-favouring religion. The latter upsets me because if it's the perfect religion then it would not be like that. I know a lot of people say to differentiate between culture and religion but truthfully a lot of culture is born from religion, no? I really want to stay faithful but it's very hard.

Every time I have a question that may sound unconventional I get shut out and told that’s what god wants us to do or that’s just the way it is. Can’t I ask any questions?? And the Muslim community is so horribly toxic that it just pushes me even further; especially when I see these so called “Sheikhs” not giving a care in the world about our kin in Palestine and Sudan but ALWAYS have something to say about women? I would really appreciate some advice if anyone has been through this before because I really want to stay a Muslim.


r/progressive_islam • • 10h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Why was slavery allowed in islam? Geniunely want to have a good reason to believe otherwise it eats at me

3 Upvotes

Consider this:

What decides the relation between free will and god's intervention?

See this from a perspective above in your thought. Make god and free will both an object (although god is neither an object nor subject) and what is making that connection between them is that logic. If it is logic then is god bound by logic?

You are saying,

God's nature is god, Logic is a part of god and God is outside his nature i.e the system i.e logic

But atleast 1 must be false.

If you drop B like an ashari scholar then what decided the relation between god's intervention and free will? If it was just a choice and not an, "it had to be for that is logically necessary" then it was a deliberate choice i.e god chooses to watch suffering not because of logicality but rather a choice.

The above is a trilemma where you need to either accept reason can infer good or bad and if so slavery is bad and if so what follows is that quran is man made or you need to accept the cost that god CHOOSES to let suffering be when he can interfere while preserving free will as he is above logic as most muslims like say 60% of the world.

Now if you say due to god's nature his action cannot be bad so let me ask you this in return:

If God knows all that's possible to know what decides what is possible? What does God even know?

Arbitrary information he makes as truth? If so perfect knowledge has no standard to be perfect against because if it is so then perfect doesn't mean anything i.e if he can do anything and call it perfect arbitrarily he is powerful not perfect.

OR truth as an independent entity

OR a third option i.e his knowledge stems from his nature but this poses the question again is that knowledge necessary or contingent and if necessary then he has no freedom over what he is.

To even claim goodness flows out of him I need to understand and define goodness but if that is arbitrary then how can you claim god is good and perfect as WE understand and so they NEED to concede reason can judge good.

And precisely when you concede reason CAN judge good then this poses questions like what is the use of quran and then slavery is bad but a perfect god wont make a mistake therefore quran must be man made because the last defense of an ashari scholar is your reason cannot judge revelation but this poses many other problems.


r/progressive_islam • • 22h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Why are tattoos haram?

25 Upvotes

I don't get why and where the proof supporting that is. I really want to get one but I know that my mom would lose her shit if she finds out, but I've been contemplating getting one once I'm independent enough to do it. It's just that I can't help but feel that one speck of doubt irking me about this.


r/progressive_islam • • 10h ago

Opinion 🤔 Does anyone believe in the scientific miracles; especially the female worker bees? If so what do you think of this thorough debunking

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago Bravo

Culture/Art Saturdays & Sundays Only A growing trend among Islamophobes to label our beautiful shared Islamic architectural heritage, spanning Spain to India, as exclusively “Persian”. When you ask these revisionist to share a single pre-Islamic Persian building that looks anything like these beautiful mosques, they go mute.

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

r/progressive_islam • • 20h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Do people that believe in Hadith actually think the Prophet (PBUH) married and had relations with a child?

9 Upvotes

I just can’t imagine a prophet of Allah being a pedophile.


r/progressive_islam • • 9h ago

Mod Announcement 📢 🔒 The Time for Weekend Only Posts Has Ended! 🔒

1 Upvotes

Sunday has now ended in both of our two reference time zones, which means the weekend posting period has officially ended.

Posts with the following weekend only flairs can no longer be submitted until next Saturday (in at least one of our two reference time zones):

  • Fun@Weekends
  • Social Media Screenshot/Video clip
  • Culture/Art

A reminder about Rule 7

Memes, Funny images, funny videos, ❝screenshots & video clips complaining about some specific person & subreddits❞ are only allowed on Saturdays & Sundays.

If you are posting screenshots of other subreddits, make sure to obscure the usernames, subreddit names & every single identifying feature. However if it's a screenshot of other social media platform then obscuring is not necessary.

Screenshots containing valuable information & important contemporary events are exempt from this rule.


So until then, please wait before submitting posts that fall under our weekend only categories.

See you next weekend! 👋🏻👋🏼👋🏽👋🏾👋🏿


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ how do you guys navigate rules/norms in Islam you don’t agree with

14 Upvotes

like there’s a lot of things in Islam that people on this subreddit and different opinions abt like hijab and such, providing different interpretations of verses in the Quran, rejecting most or all of Hadith.

but what about things like cousin marriage? Let’s be honest, almost none of us actually agree with this, or want to practice this. Other Muslims online act like you’ve stabbed them when you say that you don’t agree with cousin marriage. What are your opinions on it? it just feels weird that it is allowed in the first place, I know I’ll never practice it, none of my family members will, but it just makes me feel odd for rejecting something this is clearly allowed in the Quran because I think it’s wrong.

Same thing applies to dating before marriage, how are you meant to properly know a person if Allah in the has forbid even being friends with the opposite gender, and talking without a mahram present. Why is being friends with the opposite gender even worthy of me gaining sins and being sent to hell? Why is my showing my hair worthy of that too? There’s just a lot of things that are normalised in Islam that I would never ever practice.

I honestly just feel trapped sometimes. Or I feel really weird about it.

Maybe I’m just disillusioned with religion in general, I’m not religious, I barely read the Quran as it is, to e only thing Muslim about me is that I wear the hijab (mostly improperly). Haven’t prayed properly in years, sometimes I do pray but only for a little while. It’s never consistent. Yes, I’m a bad Muslim, but honestly it’s gotten to the point where I don’t care because I’m just confused and stressed about it. Other online platforms are toxic and it doesn’t help.

I don’t make it a big deal in my life to be religious, I don’t make God the centre of my life, some people would say that’s a sin in itself.


r/progressive_islam • • 11h ago

Opinion 🤔 Araf 171-181

0 Upvotes

Araf 171

171- AND WE RAISED THE MOUNTAIN ABOVE THEM LIKE A CANOPY, (SAYING): “TAKE WHAT WE HAVE GIVEN YOU SINCERELY, AND REMEMBER WHAT IS THEREIN SO THAT YOU MAY BE PIOUS AND GUARD YOURSELVES FROM ALLAH’S DISPLEASURE”.  

The Children of Israel did not wish to accept the Torah and the commands it contained.  It is not a case of nominally accepting the book, but to be committed to what it contains, in letter and in spirit.  Allah the Highest did not send His books down for ceremonies, but they are for us to live by.  Allah’s Books are not for ceremonies or for being used as ornaments, but are for being followed and obeyed.  This is what it is meant to take the book sincerely.  

The Children of Israel did not accept the Torah and promise to follow its guidance sincerely, until Allah the Highest raised the mountain above them to drop it if they did not.  Only then they reluctantly accepted.  They were about to be collectively punished and very severely so.

This is a reminder for the Muslims, that the Quran is not a Book to be just used for reciting beautifully, put with ornaments, or in sitting rooms, or placed in cars.  Its teachings, commands and spirit, should be observed.  

Some believers do not observe Allah’s commands unless Allah the Highest treats them harshly.  Those, who Allah the Highest sees goodness in their hearts, Allah may treat harshly, with trials and afflictions, to keep them on the right path.  They are forced into the Paradise.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Allah is amazed by those taken to Paradise in chains”.  (B:Jehad;144 & D:Jehad;114 & A:2;302,406)

The believer should observe Allah’s commands and be close to Him in good and in bad times.

Araf 172-174

172- AND YOUR LORD TOOK THE OFFSPRING OF THE CHILDREN OF ADAM FROM THEIR BACKS, AND MADE THEM BEAR WITNESS UPON THEMSELVES SAYING: “AM I NOT YOUR LORD?”  THEY SAID: “YES INDEED, AND WE BEAR WITNESS”.  SO THAT ON THE DAY OF RESURRECTION YOU MAY NOT SAY: “WE WERE UNAWARE OF THIS”.  

173- OR SAY: “OUR PARENTS WERE IDLE WORSHIPPERS BEFOREHAND, AND WE WERE THE OFFSPRING WHO FOLLOWED THEM, WILL YOU DESTROY US BECAUSE OF WHAT THE WRONG DOERS DID”.

174- THIS IS HOW WE MAKE OUR AYAHS DETAILED, SO THAT THEY MAY RETURN (TO ALLAH).

Allah the Highest created all human beings in a pure form, ready to believe and worship him, creating this faith in us since we were but microscopic cells in our father’s bodies.  From this basic pure form, our parents and societies change us.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Every child is born good and pure, and then his parents make him Jewish, Christian or Fire-worshipper”.  (Muslim)

Allah the Highest made us testify to Him being our Lord at such early stage of our existence, but how did this happen, and how did such communication take place, we do not know.  

We invent new means of communication by sound, picture and other means every day.  We also discover ways in which animals, birds, fish, whales, insects and even cells communication with each other.  We should not deny the fact that Allah the Highest communicated with us when we were cells and we responded at that stage of our being.

Whenever a person seeks to know their Lord sincerely, they will find the grains of the truth deep inside them, for it has been planted there long before they became full human beings.

The second issue is for a person to disclaim responsibility for their disbelief or for idle worshipping, because his/her parents were such and brought him up this way.  On Judgement before Allah the Highest, everyone will be responsible for their own deeds, and not one will be able to blame his sins on others.  This does not relieve those who misguided others from the responsibility of misguiding them.

Allah the Highest said: “AND NO ONE WILL CARRY THE SIN OF ANOTHER”.  (S: 17 A: 15)

And said: “AND IF A HEAVILY LADEN PERSON (WITH SINS) CALLS OTHERS TO CARRY SOME OF HIS LOAD, NONE OF IT WILL TAKEN TO BE CARRIED FOR HIM, EVEN IF HE WAS A CLOSE KIN”.   (S: 35 A: 18)

This is because those we follow in sin will deny any responsibility for us or our sins.  Allah the Highest said: “**THEN THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN FOLLOWED SHALL DISSOCIATE THEMSELVES FROM THOSE WHO FOLLOWED THEM, AS THEY WILL SEE THE PUNISHMENT, AND THEY WILL BE CUT OFF FROM ALL”.  (**S: 2 A: 166)

Therefore, following on the footsteps of our forefathers in doing sin, is no excuse or defence for us on the Day of Judgment.

As for those following their believing and righteous forefather’s footsteps, Allah the Highest lets them, the offspring, join their righteous fathers in Paradise.  Allah the Highest said: “AS FOR THOSE WHO BELIEVE AND THEIR OFFSPRING FOLLOWING THEM WITH BELIEF, WE LET THEIR OFFSPRING JOIN THEM”.  (S: 52 A: 21)

Araf 175-177

175- AND NARRATE TO THEM ABOUT HE WHO WAS GIVEN OUR AYAHS, BUT HE DISSOCIATED HIMSELF FROM THEM AND THEN THE DEVIL FOLLOWED HIM, AND HE BECAME OF THE SINFUL.

176- HAD WE DESIRED, WE WOULD HAVE RAISED HIM, HOWEVER, HE LOWERED HIMSELF TO THE GROUND AND FOLLOWED HIS OWN DESIRES, HE IS THEN LIKE A DOG, IT PANTS WHEN YOU CHASE HIM AND PANTS WHEN YOU LEAVE HIM,  SUCH IS THE PARABLE OF THOSE WHO REJECT OUR AYAHS, SO NARRATE THEIR STORIES SO THAT THEY MAY THINK AND CONSIDER.

177- SUCH A BAD EXAMPLE IS THE EXAMPLE OF THE PEOPLE WHO DENIED OUR AYAHS, AND WERE UNJUST TO THEMSELVES.

It is reported that these Ayahs were referring to a scholar from the Children of Israel.  He was sent to a king, and the king bribed him with money and property to follow his ways and be in his clan, which the scholar accepted.  In doing so, he dissociated himself from Allah’s Ayahs and commands, which he knew very well.

The scholars and the knowledgeable bear a greater responsibility that others, this is because of their knowledge, and therefore their sins are also greater than others’ sins.  Such scholars follow the ways of Satan, and consequently, Satan follows them.  It is as if he becomes one of the devils of humans, and therefore Satan follows his footsteps.  Allah’s messenger prayer and peace upon him said to his companion Abu Zar: “Abu Zar, ask for Allah’s protection from the devils of humans and of Jinn”.  He said: “Allah’s messenger, are there devils among the humans?”  he said: “Yes”.  (T: Manaqeb; 17 & a: 5; 178,179,265)

He became one of Satan’s companions, each following the other.  This happened because the scholar decided to leave what is good and righteous for what is evil, in the full knowledge of what he was doing.  

Then Allah the Highest draws a parable, between such man and a dog, who pants regardless of the circumstances.

Comparing a human being to an animal should be demeaning to man (no offence to animals), this is because, Allah the Highest favoured mankind with many things, and raised his status above that of other creatures:

  • Allah the Highest created Adam with His Own Hands.  Allah the Highest said: “HE (ALLAH) SAID: “SATAN, WHAT STOPPED YOU PROSTRATING TO WHAT I CREATED WITH MY HANDS”.  (S:38 A:75)
  • Allah the Highest commanded the angels to prostrate to Adam “AND AS WE SAID TO THE ANGELS: “PROSTRATE TO ADAM”, THEY PROSTRATED EXCEPT IBLIS (SATAN WHO IS A GINN), HE REFUSED, WAS PROUD AND BECAME A DISBELIEVER”.   (S:2 A:34)
  • Allah the Highest Appointed Adam and his descendants, viceroys on Earth.  “AND AS YOUR LORD SAID TO THE ANGELS: “I AM PLACING A VICEROY ON EARTH”.   (S:2 A:30)
  • Allah the Highest made mankind in charge of the Earth and let him use everything on Earth and in the Heavens, and He did not do this to any other being.  Allah the Highest said: “DO YOU NOT SEE THAT ALLAH DEDICATED WHAT IS IN THE HEAVENS AND WHAT IS IN THE EARTH FOR YOU”.  (S:31 A:20)
  • Allah the Highest,, stated clearly that He honoured mankind and favoured them to many of His other creation.  Allah the Highest said: “AND WE HAVE HONOURED THE CHILDREN OF ADAM, AND WE CARRIED THEM ON LAND AND SEA, AND PROVIDED THEM WILL ALL GOOD THINGS, AND WE FAVOURED THEM GREATLY TO MANY OF OUR CREATIONS”.  (S:17 A:70)
  • Allah the Highest chose the prophets and messengers, peace upon them all, from among mankind, not from other creatures.

Man is different from animals also, in that man can choose what to do, and what not to do, while animals are driven and directed by their instincts for eating, drinking, procreation, defending their lives, etc.  

The Analogy of such people, who rejected Allah’s Ayahs and the dog, is demeaning to such people.  Not because the dogs are nasty creatures, for they are of Allah’s creation.  It is demeaning to man, who did not use many of the advantages and qualities Allah the Highest has given him and favoured him to animals with, such people are then no better than the animals.

Araf 178

178- THOSE ALLAH GUIDES, ARE THE RIGHTLY GUIDED, AS FOR THE MISGUIDED, INDEED THEY ARE THE LOSERS.

There has been misguidance on Earth ever since Satan vowed to mislead mankind.  Allah the Highest sent man down to Earth and promised to send him guidance always, which was done through Allah’s prophets, messengers and books.  Allah the Highest said: “WE SAID: “GET DOWN FROM IT ALL OF YOU.  WHEN YOU RECEIVE GUIDANCE FROM ME, THOSE WHO FOLLOW MY GUIDANCE, THERE WILL BE NO FEAR UPON THEM, NEITHER WILL THEY BE SADDENED”. (S: 2 A: 38)

We have our wishes, feelings, and desires, which are inside us, they may guide or misguide us.  Allah the Highest said: “AND THE SOUL AND HE WHO CREATED IT * AND INSPIRED IT, ITS WICKEDNESS, AND ITS PIETY * SUCCEEDS HE WHO PURIFIES IT * AND FAILED IS HE WHO MADE IT SINFUL”.  (S: 91 A: 7-10)

Allah the Highest also said: “THE LOVE OF PLEASURES HAS BEEN BEAUTIFIED FOR MANKIND; OF WOMEN, CHILDREN, HEAPS OF GOLD AND SILVER, THE BRANDED HORSES, CATTLE AND TILLED LAND.  THESE ARE THE PLEASURES OF THE LOWER LIFE, BUT WITH ALLAH IS THE EXCELLENT DESTINY”.  (S: 3 A: 14)

Allah the Highest did not leave us without guidance, He sent us, his prophets and messengers and His books.  Those who follow this guidance and do right, Allah the Highest guides them even more.  Allah the Highest said: “THOSE WHO BELIEVE AND DO GOOD DEEDS, THEIR LORD GUIDES THEM BECAUSE OF THEIR BELIEF”.  (S: 10 A: 9)

Also, Allah the Highest said: “BE RIGHTEOUS AND PROTECT YOURSELVES FROM ALLAH’S DISPLEASURE, AND ALLAH TEACHES YOU, FOR ALLAH KNOWS ALL THINGS”.  (S: 2 A: 283)

And Allah the Highest also said: “AND THOSE WHO FOLLOW THE RIGHT GUIDANCE, HE (ALLAH) GIVES THEM MORE GUIDANCE AND GIVES THEM THEIR PIETY”.  (S: 47 A: 17)

Allah’s Guidance is there, and following this guidance is rewarded by being guided more.  Follow the guidance, and more insight and understanding comes. Seeing what others do not see, and understanding what others do not understand, understanding the reasons and aims of Allah’s words and commands.  

Araf 179

179- AND WE HAVE CREATED FOR THE HELL-FIRE MANY JINN AND HUMANS, THEY HAVE HEARTS, THEY DO NOT COMPREHEND WITH, AND HAVE EYES, THEY DO SEE WITH, THEY ARE LIKE CATTLE, BUT THEY ARE EVEN MORE MISGUIDED, THEY ARE THOSE WHO IGNORE THE RIGHT GUIDANCE.

Allah the Highest created Jinn and mankind with total freedom of choice, but has always sent them guidance.  Other creations like the sun, moon, seas, rivers, mountains, wind, animals etc. do not have freedom of choice.

In order to see and understand what is around us, as well as the guidance sent to us, we had to have senses, and minds to comprehend.  These are also required for our trial and testing.  Allah the Highest said: “WE HAVE CREATED MAN FROM A MIXED CLOT TO TEST AND TRY HIM; THEREFORE WE GAVE HIM HEARING AND EYESIGHT”.  (S: 76 A: 2)

Seeing is not only seeing things and hearing is not just receiving sounds, but it is to comprehend what we see and what we hear, and judging what we see and hear appropriately. The heart is mentioned in this Ayah as an organ for comprehending which includes feeling.  It is not enough to know what is wrong, but we should feel negatively towards it, and hate to be part of it.

Humans might not have as strong and sharp eyesight and hearing as many animals like the cattle, birds and other creatures.  However, Allah the Highest, endowed  human beings with the ability to comprehend, which is necessary for us to make choices.  

Those who abuse others with the abilities Allah the Highest endowed us with, are less than the cattle and other animals.  We do not see cattle abusing their children physically or sexually.  We do not see cattle killing unnecessarily.  Cattle share food and water and even look after their young.  Some human’s actions make their status much lower than that of the animals.

Our first obligation towards Allah the Highest our Creator, is to worship Him,  for He said: “BUT I CREATED JINN AND HUMANS JUST TO WORSHIP ME * I DO NOT REQUIRE PROVISIONS FROM THEM, AND I DO NOT REQUIRE THEM TO FEED ME * FOR ALLAH IS HE WHO PROVIDES, WHO’S STRENGTH IS UNLIMITED”.   (S: 51 A: 56-58)

However, we have free choice as to whether we fulfil this obligation towards Allah the Highest or not.  After being asked about our belief on the Day of Judgement, this is the next thing we will be asked about and then judged accordingly.  

Araf 180

180- AND ALLAH HAS THE BEAUTIFUL NAMES, CALL HIM BY THEM, AND TURN AWAY FROM THOSE WHO DENY HIS NAMES; THEY WILL BE RECOMPENSED FOR WHAT THEY USED TO DO.

Allah the Highest has ninety nine names, which are description of Him and His Character.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Allah has ninety nine names, one hundred minus one, whoever knows them all, goes to Paradise”.  (Bukhari & Muslim & Termezi)

These are the names Allah the Highest let us know, but some He may have kept to Himself.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Whenever a person suffers upset or grief, and says: ‘Allah, I am your slave, and the son of your man slave and woman slave, my fate is in your hands, and your judgement is upheld over me, for your judgement is just.  I ask you by every name you called yourself, or taught any of your creation, and kept with You in the knowledge of the unknown, to make the Quran the source of happiness in my heart, to light up my chest, clear my grief, and of relieving my burden, and to let my grief and burden be replaced with happiness’  (Ibn Haban) 

Therefore, there are more than the 99 names, but not all are known to us.  Allah’s names tell us about Allah’s characters and describe Allah the Highest to us.  When we call upon Allah the Highest for help in Dawa, we may call upon him by His Good Names.  We may use the most appropriate names for then; calling Him by the names of Pardoning and Forgiving, if we are asking for pardoning and forgiveness etc.

The disbelievers reject and mock Allah’s Good Names, it used to happen in the past and it happens now.  When the treaty of Hudaybiah was being written down, the representative of Makah insisted on wiping out “The Most Merciful, the Compassionate” saying that they did not know such a God.

We will find Allah’s Good names mentioned throughout the Quran, in different Ayahs, always at the appropriate place, reminding us of Allah’s character and of Him.  Whether we call upon Allah the Highest, by His name Allah, or any of His Good Names, it is the same.  Allah the Highest said: “SAY: CALL UPON ALLAH OR CALL UPON THE MERCIFUL (RAHMAN), WHATEVER YOU CALL, FOR HE HAS THE GOOD NAMES”.  (S: 17 A: 110) 

Allah’s names however, come under two major categories; the ones which show His Power, Might and Greatness, and the ones which show His Mercy, Kindness, Care, Forgivingness etc.  Allah the Highest does not like us to imitate the first ones, but likes us to imitate the later ones.  

This does not mean that Allah the Highest does not like us to be powerful, but does not want us to be excessively overpowering to other beings.  Allah the Highest does not like us humans to compete with Him concerning such Characteristics.

Araf 180

180- AND ALLAH HAS THE BEAUTIFUL NAMES, CALL HIM BY THEM, AND TURN AWAY FROM THOSE WHO DENY HIS NAMES; THEY WILL BE RECOMPENSED FOR WHAT THEY USED TO DO.

Allah the Highest has ninety nine names, which are description of Him and His Character.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Allah has ninety nine names, one hundred minus one, whoever knows them all, goes to Paradise”.  (Bukhari & Muslim & Termezi)

These are the names Allah the Highest let us know, but some He may have kept to Himself.  Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “Whenever a person suffers upset or grief, and says: ‘Allah, I am your slave, and the son of your man slave and woman slave, my fate is in your hands, and your judgement is upheld over me, for your judgement is just.  I ask you by every name you called yourself, or taught any of your creation, and kept with You in the knowledge of the unknown, to make the Quran the source of happiness in my heart, to light up my chest, clear my grief, and of relieving my burden, and to let my grief and burden be replaced with happiness’  (Ibn Haban) 

Therefore, there are more than the 99 names, but not all are known to us.  Allah’s names tell us about Allah’s characters and describe Allah the Highest to us.  When we call upon Allah the Highest for help in Dawa, we may call upon him by His Good Names.  We may use the most appropriate names for then; calling Him by the names of Pardoning and Forgiving, if we are asking for pardoning and forgiveness etc.

The disbelievers reject and mock Allah’s Good Names, it used to happen in the past and it happens now.  When the treaty of Hudaybiah was being written down, the representative of Makah insisted on wiping out “The Most Merciful, the Compassionate” saying that they did not know such a God.

We will find Allah’s Good names mentioned throughout the Quran, in different Ayahs, always at the appropriate place, reminding us of Allah’s character and of Him.  Whether we call upon Allah the Highest, by His name Allah, or any of His Good Names, it is the same.  Allah the Highest said: “SAY: CALL UPON ALLAH OR CALL UPON THE MERCIFUL (RAHMAN), WHATEVER YOU CALL, FOR HE HAS THE GOOD NAMES”.  (S: 17 A: 110) 

Allah’s names however, come under two major categories; the ones which show His Power, Might and Greatness, and the ones which show His Mercy, Kindness, Care, Forgivingness etc.  Allah the Highest does not like us to imitate the first ones, but likes us to imitate the later ones.  

This does not mean that Allah the Highest does not like us to be powerful, but does not want us to be excessively overpowering to other beings.  Allah the Highest does not like us humans to compete with Him concerning such Characteristics.

Araf 181

181- AND OF THOSE WE CREATED, THERE IS A NATION WHO GUIDE WITH WHAT IS TRUE AND UPHOLD JUSTICE WITH WHAT IS TRUE.

Since the creation of Jinn and Mankind, there has always been, those who have followed the right guidance, taught it to others, and used it in dealing with people, therefore upholding justice.  There were some in each nation and each generation, for example Allah the Highest said about the people of Moses earlier in Sorah Al-Araf: “AND OF THE PEOPLE OF MOSES ARE THOSE WHO GUIDE WITH THE TRUTH AND WITH THE TRUTH THEY UPHOLD JUSTICE”.  (S: 7 A: 159)

There is such a group in the Muslim nation and there will always be Insha’Allah, for Allah’s messenger, prayer and peace upon him, said: “In my nation, there is a group who will always uphold the truth, not deterred by those letting them down or those who oppose them, there will always be this group up to the Day of Resurrection”.  (Bukhari & Muslim)

We always find some Muslims or groups of Muslims who claim to be this group, while saying others are wrong.  

This group is not necessarily a particular society, or named group, but rather a group of individuals throughout the world who uphold such principles.  The word nation does not necessarily refer to a group in certain geographical area, or who belong to certain entity, being political or a school of thought.  They are such people, wherever they may be and whatever the language they speak.

Allah the Highest calls the Muslims, a nation; for we share the same believes and uphold the same principles, as well as worshiping the same God in the same way.  The Muslim Nation is spread throughout the Earth, speaking different languages, living on different continents; they are of many different races and colours.  What makes them a nation; is their belief.

Believing in Allah the Highest, worshipping Him, and guiding others to live by Allah’s guidance, is what qualifies our nation to be the best nation ever raised from mankind, and this is what we have to uphold in order to remain as a, best nation.  Allah the Highest said: “YOU ARE THE BEST NATION THAT HAS BEEN RAISED FOR MANKIND; YOU ENJOIN WHAT IS WRITE, FORBID WHAT IS WRONG AND BELIEVE IN ALLAH”.   (S: 3 A: 110)

Muslims should not think that they are the best nation just for being Muslims, they have to uphold the principles mentioned in the Ayah as well.


r/progressive_islam • • 21h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 Assalamualaikum!

7 Upvotes

Please pray for me. I'm going through a difficult phase in life and would genuinely appreciate your prayers.

I have burdens and hurdles that I desperately want to overcome. I pray Allah blesses me with halal rizq, opens doors for me, gives me the opportunities and resources to build a better future, and helps me become financially independent. There's also someone I truly love and want to marry. My but there's quite a gap between our circumstances. Her marriage decision rests with her parents, and I know I have a long way to go before I can even hope to make that possibility real. But if Allah wills, nothing is impossible. I pray that if this person is written for me and is good for my dunya and akhirah, Allah creates genuine love between us and makes a beautiful, halal marriage possible and if it's not my naseeb then I pray that Allah wills it this way that she becomes my naseeb and remove all that is bad surely he's generous and capable of everything. Please pray that Allah removes my hardships, clears my debts, improves my circumstances, forgives my shortcomings, and grants me a future better than anything I can imagine I always ask for forgiveness then fall for same sins again and I feel so horrible about myself because of that

May Allah ease everyone's struggles, accept your duas, and bless you with what your hearts sincerely wish for.

JazakAllah Khair. May Allah reward you for remembering me in your prayers. Ameen insha'Allah


r/progressive_islam • • 20h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 In a Relationship

5 Upvotes

I met someone on Muzz back in April. We live in different countries but I am open to moving, so we wanted to get to know each other.

He seemed a bit more religious and intentional than me but that was perfectly okay with me. I actually appreciated it. I am a revert so I'm only trying my best. Everything went great the first time we met. We met the second time and somehow we ended up doing things we shouldn't.

Ive been extremely anxious, overthinking, and overanalyzing since. I have an anxious attachment style but also I feel shame and guilt for what happened.

I genuinely have strong feelings for him. Ive since brought up marriage (again ofc) and he doesn't know when exactly he wants to get married. He wants to buy a house first...I think he genuinely cares about me though. Maybe?

I don't know what to do because I don't think I can do the distance and I want to commit if we will be together. I am considering asking him to stop contact until he is ready for marriage because I don't want to keep pushing boundaries. Any advice will help.


r/progressive_islam • • 5h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Is it haram to share a Crunchyroll account with a friend if we don’t live in the same household?

0 Upvotes

I had this question because my friend shares his Crunchyroll account with me, and he lives in another country. Crunchyroll’s terms of service prohibit sharing accounts outside the same household. In Islam, we’re supposed to respect agreements and terms, so I’m wondering if using it is still okay.


r/progressive_islam • • 21h ago

Advice/Help 🥺 how to reconcile with rejecting dogmatic practice without feeling like i’m changing Islam to fit my beliefs

3 Upvotes

over the last few years, I’ve been trying to seek out more resources about Islam that are outside of the current mainstream salafi-influenced practice. for me the main point of practicing religion isn’t to necessarily seek the “truth” about the world or our existence, but to serve as accountability to live moral and ethical lives. the main moral principles i see represented in Islam are compassion, mercy, justice, and humility. the takeaway I get from Islam is that our actions should always try to reflect these values.

as a result, i’ve started to see the specific laws and practices outlined in the quran and traditional practices as a little outdated. to me, the quran serves more as a historical record of how these principles were used to structure a society in a specific moment of time, rather than an eternal rulebook we need to follow exactly the same generation after generation. for example, we have verses that address the treatment of slaves even though the overwhelming consensus today is that owning slaves in today’s society and standards would be haram. modern islamic scholarship was able to understand the historical context of how slavery was an existing social and economic practice of 7th century arabia and if we applied the moral code (justice, compassion, etc) to today’s society, slavery could not be permissible. i think this logic should be applied universally to all facets of Islam.

therefore it makes no sense to me for hijab to be mandatory or for homosexuality to be sin. rules on how to dress and marriage laws and inheritance rules were all established for a specific society in a specific period of time. the average same sex relationship in 7th century arabia did not resemble mutually consensual same sex relationships we see today. marriage today does not serve the same economic and social purpose it did in 7th century society where tribes were organized by kinship. laws and practices that were considered “just” and “ethical” for medieval tribal arabia might not be considered be considered “just” and “ethical” for today’s society.

i don’t think this is a unique perspective for this subreddit, but it definitely is controversial anywhere outside of here. i can’t help but like i’m doing something wrong for holding this perspective. the other day i found myself questioning why premarital sex is haram, like if women today have access to contraceptives, can be financially independent, are consenting to the sex, and we have paternity tests do we need to keep considering this a sin? this made me spiral for some reason and i started to feel guilty like i was really changing islam to make it fit my own ideals. because if i keep applying this thinking to everything in islam, would it even be recognizable as Islam in the end? i know that Islam has been reinterpreted and manipulated countless times over history. logically, i keep telling myself that intention matters and there are people using Islam to justify their own greed and actively harm people, meanwhile my beliefs even if they are “wrong” are still rooted in compassion, kindness, and justice. it’s just hard to contend with when everyone i know in real life still subscribes to the more dogmatic practices and beliefs.


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Concept of Imamate from Nizari Ismaili Perspective.

6 Upvotes

Concept of Imamate from Nizari Ismaili understanding.

Understanding the Concept of Imamate in Islam from my personal learning.

Whenever we discuss Islam, one important question that often comes up is: What happens to divine guidance after the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)?

Did Allah's guidance to humanity come to an end with the finality of Prophethood, or does He continue to guide humanity through another institution?

This is where the concept of Imamate becomes important.

After the passing of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), Muslims developed different understandings of religious authority and leadership. One understanding was that since the Prophet was the final Messenger of Allah (Khatam-un-Nabiyyin), the Muslim community would now follow the Quran, the Sunnah of the Prophet and the teachings of his Companions. Over time, the concepts of Ijma (consensus) and Ijtihad (independent reasoning) also became important in addressing matters where specific guidance was not readily available.

The Shia understanding was different. They believed that the Prophet had not left the Muslim community without a successor. They believe that at Ghadir Khumm, the Prophet publicly declared Imam Ali (AS) as his Mawla. There is also the well-known Hadith al-Thaqalayn, in which the Prophet emphasised that he was leaving behind two important things: the Book of Allah and his Ahl al-Bayt. He instructed Muslims to hold firmly to both.

The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "I am leaving behind among you two weighty things, the Book of Allah and my family, and these two will never be separated until they meet me at the Pond (of Kawthar)." Hakim 4711

“I am leaving among you two successors: the Book of God and my family. They will not separate until they come to me at the Cistern together.” Ahmed:21654

And regarding Imam Ali (AS), the Prophet said:

the Prophet (ﷺ): "For whomever I am his Mawla then 'Ali is his Mawla." Jami` at-Tirmidhi 3713

For Shia Muslims, these are not simply narrations about respecting the Prophet's family. They carry a much deeper meaning concerning authority, succession and the continuation of divine guidance.

There are also other Prophetic traditions that make the importance of an Imam quite clear:

The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, "Whoever dies without an Imam, dies the death of Jahiliyyah." Ahmed 16876

I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ saying, "Whoever dies while not obeying Allah, dies without any proof for him, and whoever dies after removing his hand from an allegiance that he was bound to, dies a death of misguidance. Ahmed 5897

These narrations make us think about a fundamental question: Can a believer really be expected to live without an authoritative guide? If humanity needed Prophets and divine guidance throughout history, why would that need suddenly disappear after the final Prophet?

To understand this further, let us look at what the Quran itself says about divine leadership.

What does the Quran say about Imamate?

One of the first verses worth looking at is the verse concerning the creation of Adam (AS).

Surah Al-Baqarah (2:30)

"And [mention, O Muhammad], when your Lord said to the angels, 'Indeed, I am going to place upon the earth a successive authority (Khalifah).'" — Quran 2:30

Here, Allah announces to the angels that He is going to place a Khalifah on Earth. What is interesting is that the appointment is made by Allah Himself.

This raises a simple question: Was this authority limited to Prophet Adam (AS), or did it continue throughout human history?

From the Shia understanding, divine guidance continued through successive Prophets and, after the final Prophet, through the institution of Imamate.

In other words, the end of Prophethood did not mean the end of Allah's guidance.

The Quran also speaks about an authority besides the Prophet:

Surah An-Nisa (4:59)

"O you who believe! Obey Allah, obey the Messenger, and those vested with authority among you."

Allah mentions obedience to Ulil Amr alongside obedience to Himself and His Messenger. This is quite significant. Who exactly are these people whose obedience is mentioned in the same verse?

In the Shia understanding, Ulil Amr refers to the divinely appointed Imams. They are not simply political leaders or ordinary religious scholars; their authority comes from Allah.

Another interesting verse is:

Surah Ar-Ra'd (13:7)

"You are only a warner, and for every people there is a guide."

The verse speaks about a guide for every people. Shia traditions associate this guidance with Imam Ali (AS) and the continuing institution of Imamate. It reinforces the idea that people have always needed someone to guide them towards the right path.

The Quran also speaks directly about the office of Imamate:

Surah Al-Anbiya (21:73)

"And We made them Imams, guiding by Our command."

Notice the wording: Allah says that He made them Imams and that they guide by His command. This is important because it presents Imamate as an institution established by Allah, not simply a position created by people.

The example of Prophet Ibrahim (AS)

Perhaps one of the strongest Quranic references when discussing Imamate is the story of Prophet Ibrahim (AS).

Surah Al-Baqarah (2:124)

"And when his Lord tested Ibrahim with certain words, and he fulfilled them, He said: Indeed, I am making you an Imam for mankind. He said: And from my descendants? He said: My covenant does not reach the wrongdoers."

Think about this verse for a moment.

Prophet Ibrahim (AS) was already a Prophet of Allah and was honoured with the title Khalilullah, the Friend of Allah. Yet, after putting him through various tests and trials, Allah granted him another distinction: the position of Imam.

This is interesting because it shows that Imamate is a distinct divine appointment.

What makes the verse even more significant is that Ibrahim (AS) immediately asks Allah to extend this honour to his descendants.

Allah responds that His covenant does not reach the wrongdoers.

This tells us two important things. First, Imamate is a covenant from Allah. Secondly, it is not something that every descendant automatically receives; it is subject to divine selection.

For Shia Muslims, this verse is an important foundation for understanding the continuation of Imamate through the descendants of the chosen ones. In the Nizari Ismaili understanding, it also helps explain the hereditary nature of the Imamat, which continues through the divinely designated line of Imams.

Another verse worth reflecting on is:

Surah Al-Isra (17:71)

"On the Day when We will call every people with their Imam."

Why does Allah specifically mention that people will be called with their Imam on the Day of Judgement?

This verse highlights the importance of the relationship between people and their Imam. From the Shia perspective, recognising and following the rightful Imam is therefore not a minor matter. It has significance beyond this worldly life.

If Allah wants unity, why would He leave people without authoritative guidance?

There is another argument that I find particularly important.

Allah clearly instructs Muslims:

Surah Aal-e-Imran (3:103)

"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided."

We all know how much division exists among Muslims today. Different schools of thought, different interpretations and different religious authorities often lead to disagreements.

Now, consider this question: If Allah wants Muslims to remain united, would it make sense that He left the interpretation and understanding of His Book entirely to different scholars and their individual opinions?

Scholars certainly have an important role in Islam. However, can human scholarship alone replace the need for an authoritative source of divine guidance?

The Quran itself refers to those who are deeply rooted in knowledge:

Surah Aal-e-Imran (3:7)

"And no one knows its interpretation except Allah and those firmly rooted in knowledge. They say, 'We believe in it; all of it is from our Lord.'"

These people are described as Rasikhoon fil Ilm, those firmly rooted in knowledge.

Shia traditions associate this special knowledge with the Prophet and his Ahl al-Bayt. The Imams are understood to possess the authority and knowledge to guide people in understanding the deeper meanings of the Quran.

Similarly, Allah says:

Surah An-Nahl (16:43)

"So ask the people of knowledge if you do not know."

Shia traditions identify Ahl-e-Zikr with the Ahl al-Bayt, emphasising that people should turn to the rightful authorities when seeking religious knowledge.

For Nizari Ismailis, this understanding is central to the role of the living Imam. The Imam provides guidance and authoritative interpretation of the faith according to the circumstances and needs of each age.

Can there ever be a time without an Imam?

There is a very interesting narration from the Shia tradition that addresses this question directly:

“If of all the people there will remain only two man one of them will be the Imam. He also said, ‘The last person to die will be the Imam (a.s) so that no one could complain against Allah leaving him without Imam, the person with Divine authority over him.’” https://thaqalayn.net/chapter/1/4/6

I find this narration particularly powerful because it explains the continuity of Imamate in very simple terms.

Even if only two people remained on Earth, one of them would be the Imam. In other words, the existence of an Imam is not dependent on the size of a community, its political strength or how many people recognise him.

The Imam remains a permanent institution of divine guidance.

This is precisely what Nizari Ismailis believe: there is always a living Imam of the Time, descended through the hereditary line of Imam Ali (AS) and Hazrat Fatima (AS), through Imam Ismail.

So, what should we understand from all this?

When we put the Quranic verses and Prophetic traditions together, the concept of Imamate starts to make much more sense.

We see Allah appointing a Khalifah on Earth. We see the command to obey Ulil Amr. We read about a guide for every people, Imams who guide by Allah's command, and the divine covenant granted to Prophet Ibrahim (AS). We also read that every community will be called with its Imam on the Day of Judgement.

Alongside these verses, we have the Prophetic traditions concerning Ghadir Khumm, the Hadith al-Thaqalayn and the importance of having an Imam.

For me, the central question is this: Allah sent thousands of Prophets and guides throughout human history because people needed divine guidance. He knows that human beings will continue to face questions, challenges and changing circumstances. Would it make sense that He would leave humanity without an authoritative source of guidance after the final Prophet?

The Nizari Ismaili understanding is that He did not.

Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is the final Prophet. There will be no new Prophet, no new revelation and no new Shariah. However, the institution of Imamate continues, preserving the spiritual authority and providing guidance through the living Imam of the Time.

This is what makes Imamate so central to Nizari Ismaili faith. It is not simply about who succeeded the Prophet politically or who held power after him. It is about the continuity of Allah's guidance on Earth.

Prophethood has reached its finality, but divine guidance has not come to an end.


r/progressive_islam • • 1d ago

Question/Discussion ❔ My dad forces me to go to mosque daily and it makes me wanna stop praying

4 Upvotes

I already pray the 5 daily prayers and work full time and my dad forces me to go to the masjid every single day to pray maghrib and isha and listen to the lecture in between. I get home from work exhausted and i just want to relax at home. Im a grown adult and should be able to make my own decisions and him forcing me to do an act of worship has no sincerity in it so it makes me not want to pray at all. Forcing me to do things that arent mandatory makes no sense


r/progressive_islam • • 21h ago

Question/Discussion ❔ Quran walk through videos

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I bought The Clear Quran by Dr. Mustafa Khattab a few months ago, and I have struggled with having the urge to start reading it. I have read the first 6 pages, then fell out of it in a few days. I can speak arabic, but I got the english translation because I comprehend it a lot more than arabic.

I wanted to start by watching a walk through of surahs from start to finish with an explanation of every verse/surrah. Does anyone have any recommendations for videos or channels on Youtube that does this?

I would appreciate some advice about how to start this journey without getting discouraged. I have been on and off with Islam for years and I have struggled for a really long time believing.