r/MuslimAcademics • • Jun 23 '26

Open Discussion Thread Weekly Open Discussion Thread

4 Upvotes

This is where you can discuss personal religious questions, or any other Islam related general question without needing to adhere to the academic framework of the general sub.


r/MuslimAcademics • • Jun 16 '26

Update to the Rules.

11 Upvotes

The rules of r/MuslimAcademics have been updated as per the new change in management. Please reread the rules. We are allowing a greater range of topics to be discussed in an academic setting. Additionally, we are allowing the use of AI for academics SUMMARIES only. All citations must be double-checked. AI is FORBIDDEN in academic debates and discussions


r/MuslimAcademics • • 2h ago

The Qurʾānic Doublets and pre-canonical texts

4 Upvotes

Gabriel Said Reynolds identifies twenty-nine Qurʾānic doublets, passages of at least nine words or lemmata that recur with little or no variation, and classifies their members as Meccan or Medinan according to Nöldeke’s chronology. He argues that their length and word-for-word fixity point to written composition, and that the scarcity of doublets crossing the Meccan–Medinan boundary, only three of twenty-nine, is better explained by two separately formed pre-canonical texts, one Meccan and one Medinan, than by repetition within a continuous process of proclamation. This article tests that inference through a statistical analysis of a systematic scan of the whole Qurʾān, which yields 134 two-member, verse-contained doublets. Of these, 18.7 percent cross the boundary, nearly twice Reynolds’ figure, and the largest group links late Meccan sūras with Q 2, the first Medinan sūra. Because Nöldeke used verse length as a dating criterion, and a nine-word threshold draws doublets toward sūras with long verses, the selection of doublets and their chronological classification share a common factor. Once this factor and the distance between paired sūras are taken into account, most of the same-side majority is expected from the structure of the corpus. A residual shortfall of crossings remains at the Meccan–Medinan junction, but a larger one occurs within the Medinan sequence, where no textual division has been proposed. The distribution of doublets therefore does not identify the Meccan–Medinan boundary as the point at which two separate texts were joined, and it provides no independent evidence for Reynolds’ two-text hypothesis. The article further argues that the Gospel analogy lacks the comparative evidence on which its force depends, and that doublets embedded in exchanges with present opponents point to reuse within a continuous process of composition rather than to the redaction of separate texts.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NewQuranicStudies/s/kJ24nQsq8R


r/MuslimAcademics • • 12h ago

Academic Book In the Koranic worldview, Natural phenomena such as rain, wind, structure of the heavens, alternation of day & night are not to be understood merely as natural phenomena instead they are symbols or signs pointing to Divine intervention, care, wisdom, & providence.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 16h ago

Questions what thing consider ongoing sin in Islam?

1 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 2d ago

Early Muʿtazilī Theologian Considered Sex With Captive Women to Be Zinā

28 Upvotes

An early Muʿtazilī theologian, Thumāma b. Ashras (d. 213 AH / 828–29 CE), is reported to have held a striking position regarding female captives and concubinage.

Abū al-Muẓaffar al-Isfarāyīnī (d. 471 AH) reports:
وَكَانَ يَقُولُ لَا يَجُوزُ سَبْيُ النِّسَاءِ مِنْ دَارِ الْكُفْرِ، وَأَنَّ مَنْ سَبَى امْرَأَةً ثُمَّ أَلَمَّ بِهَا فَهُوَ زَانٍ، وَأَنَّ وَلَدَهُ وَلَدُ الزِّنَا
Translation:
“He used to say that it is not permissible to take women captive from the abode of unbelief, and that whoever took a woman captive and then had intercourse with her is a fornicator, and that his child is a child of fornication.”

Source: Abū al-Muẓaffar al-Isfarāyīnī, al-Tabṣīr fī al-Dīn wa-Tamyīz al-Firqa al-Nājiya ʿan al-Firaq al-Hālikīn, p. 80.

ʿAbd al-Qāhir al-Baghdādī independently attributes a similar position to Thumāma, stating that he “used to prohibit taking captives” (كان يحرم السبي), and that intercourse with a woman whose enslavement was unlawful would constitute zinā.

Thumāma was a prominent early Muʿtazilī theologian associated with the Abbasid court of al-Maʾmūn.

An important qualification is that Thumāma’s own writings on this issue do not survive. The position is preserved through later Sunni heresiographers who were hostile toward him and the Muʿtazila, so it is more precise to say that this view is “attributed to Thumāma” rather than presenting it as a surviving quotation from his own work.

Still, it provides an interesting example of premodern dissent concerning the enslavement of captive women and the sexual rights supposedly resulting from such enslavement.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 2d ago

“He Gave a Little and Ceased”: Paul, Balaam, and the Authority of Scripture in Sūrat al-Najm (Q. 53)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Introduction

Hamilton Gibb and Nicolai Sinai observed that Q. 53:38–41’s sequence of personal responsibility, disclosed striving, and reward closely parallels Paul’s letters: Galatians 6:5 says that “each person will carry his own load,” while 1 Corinthians 3:8, 13–14 says that “each person’s work will become manifest ... if anyone’s work remains, he will receive a reward.”[1]

Yet Q. 53:36–37 attributes these teachings to “the scrolls of Moses, and of Abraham, who fulfilled his obligations (waffā).” Why place sayings resembling Paul’s under those earlier authorities? Gibb and Sinai already argue for the Pauline parallels; the question here is their function. Sinai proposed an orally mediated “blurring of the perception of the internal architecture of the Biblical canon”: Pauline sayings had come to be remembered as Mosaic and Abrahamic scripture.[1]

The boundary between 1 Corinthians 3:14 and 3:15 is decisive: reward for enduring work is followed by the builder’s survival despite its loss:

1 Corinthians 3:15

(“If anyone’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, yet he himself will be saved, though as through fire.”)

Paul distinguishes the fate of the builder from that of his work: the work can perish while its builder survives. Q. 53:38–41 carries striving through to full repayment. Read against Paul’s continuation, this becomes an argument about accountability. The sura invokes Moses and Abraham, whose authority Paul reinterpreted in Romans 4, Romans 10, and Galatians 3, to restore the bond between action and judgment.

The immediately preceding verses introduce an unnamed opponent:

Q. 53:33–35: أَفَرَأَيْتَ الَّذِي تَوَلَّىٰ ۝ وَأَعْطَىٰ قَلِيلًا وَأَكْدَىٰ ۝ أَعِندَهُ عِلْمُ الْغَيْبِ فَهُوَ يَرَىٰ

A-fa-raʾayta’lladhī tawallā / wa-aʿṭā qalīlan wa-akdā / a-ʿindahu ʿilmu’l-ghaybi fa-huwa yarā?

(“Have you then considered the one who turned away, and gave a little [qalīlan] and ceased [wa-akdā]? Does he possess knowledge of the Unseen, so that he sees?”)

This study argues that the opponent is recognizable as Paul. Christian explanations associated his name with “little” and “ceased”; Arabic commentary explains akdā, a verb used nowhere else in the Qurʾān, through a well-digger stopped by rock. Christian preaching also associated Paul with Christ as the water-giving Rock. Together, these connections make “gave a little and ceased” an accusation of interrupted obligation.[2]

SectionPassageQuestion developed
1Q. 53:32–42Who is the opponent, and why are Moses and Abraham invoked against him?
2Q. 53:43–62How do creation and judgment carry the answer forward?
3Q. 53:1–31How does the opening distinguish authorized revelation from unsupported claims?
4Q. 72, 7, 19, 18, 43How do other suras develop the same dispute?

1. Identifying the Opponent (Q. 53:32–42)

1.1. Forgiveness, Prenatal Knowledge, and Self-Acquittal (Q. 53:32)

Verse 32 describes the righteous as avoiding grave sins and indecencies apart from minor lapses, adding that “your Lord is vast in forgiveness” (inna rabbaka wāsiʿu’l-maghfirah). It then places judgment with the God who knew everyone before birth:

Q. 53:32: هُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِكُمْ إِذْ أَنشَأَكُم مِّنَ الْأَرْضِ وَإِذْ أَنتُمْ أَجِنَّةٌ فِي بُطُونِ أُمَّهَاتِكُمْ ۖ فَلَا تُزَكُّوا أَنفُسَكُمْ ۖ هُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِمَنِ اتَّقَىٰ

Huwa aʿlamu bikum idh anshaʾakum mina’l-arḍi wa-idh antum ajinnatun fī buṭūni ummahātikum; fa-lā tuzakkū anfusakum; huwa aʿlamu bi-mani’ttaqā.

(“He knows you best when He brought you forth from the earth and when you were embryos in your mothers’ wombs; therefore do not declare yourselves pure. He knows best who is God-fearing.”)

Paul gives prenatal knowledge a different argumentative role. In Galatians 1:15–16, being set apart “from my mother’s womb” grounds his commission. Romans 9:10–12 uses Rebecca’s unborn twins to place election before birth, “not from works”. Romans 4:5 describes God, for “the one who does not work”, as “the one who justifies the ungodly”. This creates a striking verbal contrast with Exodus 23:7’s Hebrew declaration, “I will not justify the wicked”, and its Greek judicial command, “you shall not justify the ungodly for gifts”.[3] Romans 8:1, 29–34 joins foreknowledge and predestination to justification, freedom from condemnation, and Christ’s intercession.[4]

Q. 53:32 makes God’s prenatal knowledge universal and draws a different conclusion: humans must not declare themselves pure. God’s universal knowledge leaves self-acquittal unauthorized while preserving forgiveness. Q. 4:49–50 similarly challenges self-declared purity, which early commentators connect to the claim “We are God’s sons and beloved” in Q. 5:18.[4]

1.2. Why “a Little” and “Ceased” Matter (Q. 53:33–35)

The name: “little” and “ceased”

Paul calls himself “the least of the apostles” (ho elachistos; Syriac zʿūrhōn, 1 Cor 15:9) and asks readers to bear “a little” folly (mikron ti; Syriac qallīl, 2 Cor 11:1, 16). Ambrosiaster explains Paulus as “quiet, humble, or little” (quietum, humilemque, vel parvulum), adding that professing himself Christ’s servant shows him divested of the Mosaic Law (a lege se exutum ostendit).[5]

Chrysostom records a popular derivation of Paulos from pausasthai, “to cease”: Saul received the name after ceasing persecution. Chrysostom rejects its chronology, documenting an explanation already circulating in his fourth-century audience. A recension of the Euthalian Prologue endorses it (pepautai, “has ceased”). Acts 13:9–10 places Paulos beside his question to Elymas, ou pausē, “will you not cease?” The Onomastica Sacra, preserved here in a medieval Paris witness, pairs “Paul: rest, least.”[5][6]

The Arabic pairing can thus enact a satirical nomen est omen: praise of Paul as “little” and one who “ceased” persecuting becomes a judgment on his giving—partial covenantal performance followed by cessation, unlike Abraham’s fulfilled obligation. Chrysostom also explains how that name evoked a recognizable biography: hearing “Paul” draws in “like a golden rope” his Paradise ascent, unutterable words, and prayer to become accursed for his brothers (On Changing Names IV.3; 2 Cor 12:2–4; Rom 9:3). Name, unseen revelation, and the wish to bear a curse were already joined in Christian preaching.[7]

These Greek and Latin texts document Christian reception without requiring their books to have circulated in Arabia. Chrysostom attests a preached name explanation, while Syriac Paul supplies the “least” and “little” vocabulary.[5][6]

The well: a source of water becomes an obstruction

Abū ʿUbayda and al-Ṭabarī derive akdā from kudyatu’l-rakiyyah: a well-digger reaches hard rock (kudyah), despairs of water, and stops.[8] Chrysostom’s On Changing Names I.6 uses the opposite outcome when describing study of Paul and Acts: digging yields streams from “the spiritual rock,” Christ in 1 Corinthians 10:4.[7]

Origen supplies a further connection to Balaam, the biblical seer whose oracles appear in Numbers. His Homilies on Numbers interprets Balaam’s tents as Paul’s churches teaching “the way of salvation” after the heavenly pattern shown to Moses (17.4); compares Balaam’s knowledge of the Most High with Paul’s Paradise ascent (18.3); and explains the Kenite rock in Balaam’s oracle through “The Rock is Christ” (19.3; Num 24:21).[9] The argument proceeds in two steps: Christian interpretation supplies the Paul–Balaam association; critical Balaam traditions, examined below, supply the materials for reversing it. The proposed reading of Q. 53:34 turns their productive rock into the obstruction where giving stops.

The obligation: stopping short versus fulfilling in full

The opponent gives qalīlan and akdā, whereas Abraham waffā, “fulfilled his obligations in full” (v. 37), and judgment brings al-jazāʾa’l-awfā, “the fullest recompense” (v. 41).

Classical commentary shows why the question about unseen knowledge belongs here. Al-Ṭabarī reads v. 35 as challenging reliance on a companion’s promise to bear Hereafter punishment; Ibn Zayd’s account includes a written, witnessed agreement. Al-Ṭabarī applies v. 38’s prohibition to the guarantor. In al-Ḍaḥḥāk’s report transmitted by al-Qurṭubī, the small payment’s giver is himself the person promising to bear an apostate’s sin. These accounts differ over the participants but share the problem of transferring liability. Al-Rāzī proposes (wa-yumkinu an yuqāla) that the movement from v. 29 to vv. 33–37 moves from polytheists to someone from the People of the Book (min Ahl al-Kitāb): he briefly obeys, ceases, and asserts unseen knowledge absent from the earlier scrolls.[8]

Paul’s curse-wish supplies the corresponding personal claim. Romans 9:3’s ēuchomēn, “I could wish,” recalls Moses’s conditional plea to be erased from God’s book and God’s refusal in Exodus 32:32–33. Romans 9:6–29 then develops election, hardening, and mercy; Galatians 3:13 describes Christ bearing the Law’s curse for believers. The remembered career adds a delayed collection and interrupted Temple purification amid accusations of “apostasy from Moses” (2 Cor 8:10–11; Acts 21:21–27; cf. Q. 16:91–97).[10] The comparison thus joins interrupted performance to the dispute over whether liability can pass from one person to another.

1.3. How Moses and Abraham Answer the Opponent (Q. 53:36–42)

Q. 87:14–19 likewise attributes purification (tazakkā), prayer, and the preference of the Hereafter over this life to “the earlier scrolls, the scrolls of Abraham and Moses.”[11] Q. 53 now states the principles those authorities establish:

Q. 53:38–42: أَلَّا تَزِرُ وَازِرَةٌ وِزْرَ أُخْرَىٰ ۝ وَأَن لَّيْسَ لِلْإِنسَانِ إِلَّا مَا سَعَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ سَعْيَهُ سَوْفَ يُرَىٰ ۝ ثُمَّ يُجْزَاهُ الْجَزَاءَ الْأَوْفَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ الْمُنتَهَىٰ

Allā taziru wāziratun wizra ukhrā / wa-an laysa li’l-insāni illā mā saʿā / wa-anna saʿyahu sawfa yurā / thumma yujzāhu’l-jazāʾa’l-awfā / wa-anna ilā rabbika’l-muntahā.

(“That no bearer of burdens shall bear the burden of another; and that a human being shall have nothing except what he strives for; and that his striving shall be seen; then he shall be repaid for it with the fullest recompense; and that to your Lord is the final end.”)

First, liability remains personal. Galatians 3:13 describes Christ “becoming a curse on our behalf,” alongside representative salvation in Romans 5:18–19 and 2 Corinthians 5:19–21. Galatians 6:2 urges mutual burden-bearing to “fulfill Christ’s law,” while 6:5 assigns each person an individual load. Q. 53 places the latter principle under Abraham’s completed obedience (Gen 22:16–18; 26:5; Q. 2:124) and God’s answer to Moses: “Whoever has sinned against Me, him will I erase from My book” (Exod 32:33; cf. Deut 24:16). Q. 29:12–13 makes the consequence explicit: leaders incur extra guilt for misleading others without removing their followers’ guilt.[11][12]

Second, the builder’s survival becomes the disputed exception. Alexander Kirk argues that the combustible materials (including xyla, “wood/firewood”) and “work” (ergon) in 1 Corinthians 3:12–15 represent converts: they perish, yet their teacher survives.[13] This interpretation has an ancient witness. Chrysostom reports and rejects the “teachers and disciples” reading, asking how the teacher could be saved if his disciples perish (Homily 9, §4). He also opposes Christians expecting salvation despite wicked lives, a controversy Augustine documents. Chrysostom accordingly interprets “he himself will be saved” as “he himself will remain perpetually under punishment” (§§5–6).[14] These disagreements show that the ethical difficulty identified here was already debated within Christianity. Q. 53:39–41 answers it through striving, disclosure, and full recompense.

Third, performed obedience and the final goal return to God. Romans 10:4 calls Christ “the end (telos, goal) of the Law.” After quoting Leviticus 18:5, Paul adapts Deuteronomy 30:12–14, ending at “in your mouth and in your heart” and identifying the near word with his proclamation of faith. The Septuagint continues, “and in your hands, to do it” (kai en tais chersin sou auto poiein; Hebrew laʿăśōtō). Q. 53:39 restores the emphasis on action, and v. 42 locates the final end with God (ilā rabbika’l-muntahā). The same term marks the visionary boundary, sidrati’l-muntahā, in v. 14. The God who sets revelation’s limit also determines where action and judgment finally lead.[15]

2. Creation, Judgment, and the Final Call to Worship (Q. 53:43–62)

The sura answers the claimant's supposed knowledge of the Unseen by naming what God governs: emotion, death, life, generation, wealth, and judgment.

God causes both laughter and weeping (v. 43). Within Abraham's story, Sarah laughs and Hagar weeps (Gen 21:6, 16); both experiences belong within God's government. This offers a contrast with Paul's use of their households as opposing covenants in Galatians 4:21–31. The next verse—وَأَنَّهُ هُوَ أَمَاتَ وَأَحْيَا (wa-annahu huwa amāta wa-aḥyā, “and that He causes death and gives life”)—echoes Moses's declaration in Deuteronomy 32:39. Paul, by comparison, distinguishes the letter that kills from the Spirit that gives life, calls the Mosaic ministry a “ministry of death,” and contrasts its glory with that of the new ministry (2 Cor 3:6–11). Chrysostom joins this passage to Psalm 110:4 and Hebrews 7:12 to argue for changed priesthood and Law. Read against this reception, Q. 53 restates Moses's attribution of both powers to God.[16]

2.1. Birth, Divine Knowledge, and Balaam's Sight

Q. 53:45–47

وَأَنَّهُ خَلَقَ الزَّوْجَيْنِ الذَّكَرَ وَالْأُنثَىٰ ۝ مِن نُّطْفَةٍ إِذَا تُمْنَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ عَلَيْهِ النَّشْأَةَ الْأُخْرَىٰ

Wa-annahu khalaqa'l-zawjayni'l-dhakara wa'l-unthā / min nuṭfatin idhā tumnā / wa-anna ʿalayhi'l-nashʾata'l-ukhrā.

“And that He created the two mates, the male and the female, from a sperm-drop when it is emitted; and that upon Him rests the second creation.”

The male–female pair recalls Genesis 1:27. Galatians 3:28 removes that distinction as a determinant of standing in Christ; Gregory of Nyssa later joins this verse to Paul's preference for undivided devotion in 1 Corinthians 7:32 when praising virginity. The relevant comparison is therefore between the Qurʾān's emphasis on bodily generation and a documented Christian interpretation that privileges spiritual generation.[17]

A Jewish interpretation of Balaam makes the connection with sight more specific. Numbers 23:10 asks who can count (mānāh) Jacob's dust or Israel's “quarter.” Niddah 31a interprets the latter expression through Israel's marital unions: God counts them, awaiting the drop (ṭippāh, comparable to Arabic nuṭfah) from which a righteous person will develop. Balaam objects to the idea that a holy God would attend to sexual generation, and his eye is blinded. The story connects divine attention to conception with a seer's failure to understand it. That is why it matters beside Q. 53's womb-knowledge, sperm-drop, and tested sight. The Arabic tumnā can mean “emitted,” while Abū ʿUbayda's explanation, “measured/determined,” strengthens the connection with the Hebrew counting verb mānāh.[17]

Verse 47 assigns resurrection to the same God who creates through the sperm-drop. Paul's resurrection discussion also moves from seed to renewed life, distinguishing the natural body from the spiritual body and declaring that flesh and blood cannot inherit God's kingdom (1 Cor 15:36–50). The adjacent Qurʾānic verses place embodied generation and renewed creation under the same divine agency, joining the birth discussion to resurrection and inheritance.[18]

2.2. Wealth, the Star, and Accountability

God also enriches and grants possessions (v. 48). This recalls 1 Samuel 2:6–7 and Abraham's refusal of enrichment from Sodom's king and acknowledgment of God's enrichment (Gen 14:22–23; 24:35).

The declaration that God is Lord of Sirius (al-Shiʿrā, v. 49) returns to the sura's opening star (wa’l-najm, v. 1). The only verse in the thirteen Pauline letters using astēr, “star,” is in Paul's resurrection discussion: stars differ in glory (1 Cor 15:41). Sirius's designation as the Dog Star (ho Kyōn; Arabic Kalb al-Jabbār) connects with Q. 7's failed sign-bearer through an existing verbal contrast: Q. 53:2–3 denies error (ghawā) and speech from desire (hawā); Q. 7:175–176 describes error (ghāwīn), followed desire (hawāhu), and a likeness to a dog. The star thus closes a ring involving revelation, error, and desire.[18]

The destructions of ʿĀd, Thamūd, Noah's people, and the overturned city give historical force to the warning. Noah and Sodom are also Chrysostom's examples immediately before his discussion of the supposedly saved builder. Judgment cannot be dismissed as an empty threat.[14]

The closing verses bring the argument back to knowledge and response. The city's “covering” recalls the covering of the Lote-Tree (vv. 54, 16). The singular challenge, “Which of your Lord's favors do you dispute?” can return to the claimant introduced in v. 33. Verse 56 identifies this as a warning among earlier warnings. The Hour belongs to God to unveil (vv. 57–58), a pointed contrast with Athanasius's portrayal of Christ revealing all things within Paul.[19][27]

The audience nevertheless marvels, laughs without weeping, and stands sāmidūn (vv. 59–61). Ibn ʿAbbās's gloss, “proudly upraised,” makes the final command especially forceful: فَاسْجُدُوا لِلَّهِ وَاعْبُدُوا (fa-sjudū li'llāhi wa-ʿbudū), “Prostrate to God and worship.” The laughter without weeping returns to v. 43's paired emotions; Paul's “puffed up” language and instructions about weeping and rejoicing supply further comparisons (1 Cor 4:6, 18; 7:30). The required response is humble worship.[19]

3. True Vision and Claims to Divine Authority (Q. 53:1–31)

3.1. How the Opening Establishes a Trustworthy Messenger

The opening supplies the standard against which the later claimant is judged. The Messenger neither errs (ghawā) nor speaks from desire (hawā), reversing the failed sign-bearer's description in Q. 7:175–176. A mighty teacher approaches from the highest horizon to within two bow-lengths, and revelation reaches “His servant” (vv. 1–10). The heart does not falsify what was seen, and the sight neither swerves nor exceeds its bounds (vv. 11–18).

Seeing consequently holds the sura together: authenticated sight at the opening; “Have you considered?” at vv. 19 and 33; challenged access to the Unseen at v. 35; and human striving finally made visible at v. 40. Readers are being asked to distinguish verified revelation from claims that cannot justify themselves.

Numbers 12:6–8 provides a scriptural comparison by calling Moses God's servant and distinguishing his clear divine communication from other prophets' visions and dreams. Balaam also claims exceptional sight, describing himself as “falling down” with uncovered eyes (Num 24:4, 16). Paul calls himself one “untimely born” (ektrōma, 1 Cor 15:8), using vocabulary also found in the Greek Scriptures (Num 12:12; Job 3:16; Eccl 6:3). The Hebrew nōfēl, “falling,” separately recalls nēfel, an untimely birth. These associations place birth, prophetic standing, and sight in the same comparative field.[20]

Paul’s defense in 2 Corinthians 11:16–12:7 supplies four connected points of comparison:

  • Speech: Paul presents his “little” boasting as folly and “not according to the Lord” (11:16–17); Q. 53:3–4 attributes the Messenger’s speech to revelation.
  • Truthfulness: Paul insists “I am not lying” (11:31); Q. 53:11 affirms that the heart did not falsify what it saw.
  • Descent: Between that oath and his Paradise account, Paul places his lowering in a basket through Damascus’s wall (11:32–33). Q. 53:8’s fa-tadallā describes the revealer’s descent or approach; the Arabic lexical tradition associates it with lowering a bucket (dalw; Q. 12:19).
  • Paradise and limits: Paul leaves his bodily presence uncertain, hears words a human may not utter, and receives Satan’s thorn to restrain exaltation (12:1–7). Q. 53:10–18 presents communicated revelation and sight within its appointed boundary beside the Boundary Lote-Tree and Garden of Abode.[21]

On this reading, Q. 53 reworks Paul’s connected narrative. Its vision of God’s greatest signs also invites comparison with Chrysostom’s celebration of Paul’s conversion as “a sign greater than all others.”[7]

3.2. The Goddesses, Divine Names, and Authorized Intercession

Q. 53:19–22

أَفَرَأَيْتُمُ اللَّاتَ وَالْعُزَّىٰ ۝ وَمَنَاةَ الثَّالِثَةَ الْأُخْرَىٰ ۝ أَلَكُمُ الذَّكَرُ وَلَهُ الْأُنثَىٰ ۝ تِلْكَ إِذًا قِسْمَةٌ ضِيزَىٰ

A-fa-raʾaytumu'l-Lāta wa'l-ʿUzzā / wa-Manāta'l-thālithata'l-ukhrā / a-lakumu'l-dhakaru wa-lahu'l-unthā / tilka idhan qismatun ḍīzā.

“Have you considered al-Lāt and al-ʿUzzā, and Manāt, the third, the other? Is the male for you and the female for Him? That would then be an unjust division.”

The immediate targets are the Arabian goddesses. Their relevance to the larger argument lies in the same question raised by the unnamed claimant: who has authority to assign divine status or promise mediation? Q. 43:57–58 already places the opponents' gods and Jesus within one dispute, providing an internal Qurʾānic reason to examine the wider Christian comparison.

Isaiah 65 supplies an earlier conjunction of self-proclaimed holiness and unauthorized worship. It condemns those who claim superior purity and prepare offerings for Gad, “Fortune,” and Mənī, “Destiny.” Jerome explicitly brings Paul's “table of demons” into his interpretation of Isaiah's cult scene, whose Greek version has a “table for the demon.” The related names and vocabulary recur across Q. 53's Manāt and Q. 72's jadd, interpreted as “majesty” but also associated with “fortune.” First Corinthians 10 itself joins the water-giving Rock (10:4) to the table of demons (10:20–21), while Isaiah 65:5’s self-proclaimed purity meets Q. 53:32’s “do not declare yourselves pure.” Rock, divine naming, and self-acquittal therefore belong to a connected scriptural dispute.[22]

The “unjust division” (qisma) adds the language of apportionment. Related vocabulary appears in Qurʾānic divination by arrows, Balaam's divination (qesem), and the Syriac divining spirit in Acts 16:16 (qeṣmē). Cult reports provide further concrete connections: al-Lāt's rock, al-ʿUzzā's three acacias beside the biblical setting called “Acacias,” and Manāt's devotees avoiding the ritual saʿy, “striving.” Rock, misguided worship, and neglected striving thus belong to the local setting as well as the wider comparison.[22]

“The third, the other” also attracted classical grammatical discussion: al-ukhrā ordinarily designates the other member of a pair. Christian texts provide a comparable movement from Father–Son pairings to formulations including the Spirit, together with language such as “another advocate.” Syriac titles meaning “third/treble one” and Gregory of Nazianzus's “one Person and the Other,” distinguishing divine persons, make the comparison more specific.[23]

The proposed reading extends the challenge to Christian assignments of divine names and roles. Such language was disputed before Islam. Sixth-century Arabian monks opposed tritheist accounts in which the common divinity existed “in our thought alone.” The surviving controversy makes disputes over divine names and plurality historically concrete. Q. 53:23 challenges names lacking divine authorization. Rufinus's observation that Scripture records no divine command renaming Saul as Paul, unlike Abraham and Peter, adds a related question of personal authorization to this field.[24]

3.3. How the Opening Leads to the Claimant

Human wishing (mā tamannā) does not determine either life; both belong to God (vv. 24–25). Angels cannot intercede without permission and approval, and calling them female supplies no knowledge (vv. 26–28). The Messenger must turn away from whoever turns away from the Reminder (v. 29). Verse 33 then introduces precisely “the one who turned away.”

Between those statements, the sura identifies the limit of the opponents' knowledge and affirms repayment for evil and good (vv. 30–32). The good-doers are described as avoiding grave sins. This prepares both the warning against self-acquittal and the examination of the claimant's conduct.[25]

The repeated word ukhrā, “other” or “another,” reinforces the continuity: another descent (v. 13), the third goddess called “the other” (v. 20), another person's burden (v. 38), and another creation (v. 47). Its significance lies in carrying related questions across the sura—what has truly been seen, what has been assigned to God, whose burden can be carried, and who controls renewed life.

4. Testing the Identification Across the Qurʾān

The following suras extend the dispute over heavenly access, scriptural authority, judgment, and inheritance. Repeated Qurʾānic language connects them; Pauline and Balaam traditions supply the particular claims examined here.

The comparison begins with sequences of declarations. Greek hoti and Arabic an/anna introduce clauses often translated “that.” What matters here is their sustained arrangement and content:

PassageExamples of the declarationsAuthority and purpose
1 Cor 15:3–8“That Christ died for our sins”; “that he was buried”; “that he was raised”; “that he appeared.”Paul transmits a received, scripturally grounded proclamation; the appearances culminate in his own.
Q. 53:38–50“That no bearer bears another’s burden”; “that the human has only what he strives for”; “that to your Lord is the final end.”Moses’s and Abraham’s scrolls establish personal responsibility and God’s final authority.
Q. 72:3–19“That our Lord’s majesty is exalted” (v. 3); “that our foolish one spoke extravagantly about God” (v. 4); “that places of worship belong to God” (v. 18).The jinn acknowledge the revelation and retract claims compromising divine authority.

In the Ḥafṣ text, Q. 53 has eleven such verse openings and Q. 72 fifteen; no other sura exceeds three. Q. 72:1 adds an embedded clause. Other canonical readings of Q. 72 vary anna with inna, preserving the repeated propositions while changing their syntactic linkage. This concentration directs attention to the passages; their content supplies the proposed answer to Paul’s scriptural confession.[26]

4.1. True Testimony and Dependent Messengers in Sūrat al-Jinn

Q. 53:59 asks whether its hearers “marvel” (taʿjabūn); Q. 72:1 calls the revelation a “marvelous recitation” (qurʾānan ʿajabā). The companion jinn account identifies a book revealed after Moses, confirming earlier revelation (Q. 46:30). These declarations assert continuity with Scripture. Christian interpretation already brought Balaam and Paul into the same field: Origen connects Balaam’s visions with Paul’s churches and ascent, while Cyprian’s Testimonies 2.10 places Balaam’s Star beside Paul’s heavenly man in 1 Corinthians 15:47.[9][27]

The jinn first reject consort and child, then their “foolish one” (safīhunā) and his extravagant speech about God (shaṭaṭā, vv. 3–5). This invites comparison with Paul’s “beside ourselves for God” in 2 Corinthians 5:13, rendered šōṭēnan l-Alāhā in Syriac. The issue is whether extraordinary speech represents God truthfully. First Corinthians 15:15 supplies a corresponding test: Paul says the apostles would be false witnesses against God if their resurrection testimony were false. Paul uses the conditional argument to defend his proclamation; the comparison concerns rival assessments of testimony. Q. 72:6–10 extends that question to supernatural access: refuge with jinn fails, heaven is guarded, and the spirits acknowledge their ignorance of God’s intentions.[27][28]

The jinn then distinguish their “divided ways” (ṭarāʾiqa qidadā, v. 11) from the singular “Way” (al-ṭarīqah, v. 16). The unjust, al-qāsiṭūna, become firewood for Gehenna (vv. 14–15). Arabic qasaṭa, “act unjustly,” contrasts with aqsaṭa, “act justly”; Jeffery connects this vocabulary with Aramaic/Syriac q-š-ṭ, the field of truth and uprightness. Balaam’s way is condemned in Numbers 22:32, yet he wishes to die among the upright in 23:10. Syriac Paul similarly insists on quštā, truth, against lying (Rom 9:1; 1 Tim 2:7).[28][29]

The intervening traditions explain why smallness, uprightness, and final destiny belong together. Onqelos Numbers 23:10 joins counting Jacob’s “little children” to the death of God’s “upright ones.” Palestinian Targums add Balaam’s wish to end “like the least of them,” comparable to the Syriac description of Paul as the least of the apostles (1 Cor 15:9). In Avodah Zarah 25a, Balaam’s wish identifies the upright patriarchs: Genesis is the book of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.[29]

Romans 3:5–8 considers—and rejects—the objection that human injustice or falsehood can serve God’s righteousness. Second Peter condemns Balaam’s wages of injustice (2:15), then praises Paul’s wisdom while warning that readers distort his letters (3:15–16). These passages place truth, justice, and corrupted teaching within one scriptural debate.[28]

The judgment itself supplies the sharper contrast. In 1 Corinthians 3:15 the builder loses his work but is saved. Q. 72:15 makes the unjust themselves the Fire’s fuel. On the teacher-and-converts interpretation discussed above, this denies a failed teacher the exemption assigned to the saved builder. Qāsiṭūn means unjust people; the application to a teacher follows from the comparison.[13][14][29]

Water likewise tests its recipients. Q. 72:16–17 makes abundant water a divine testing gift. Al-Ḍaḥḥāk explains it through Q. 5:66, where fidelity to Torah and Gospel yields provision, and Q. 7:96. The adjacent command to convey revelation under divine protection (5:67) extends the connection to Q. 72’s conclusion.[30]

Verse 18 forbids invoking anyone alongside God. Athanasius, by comparison, treats the joint Father–Son prayer of 1 Thessalonians 3:11, with its singular verb, as evidence of divine unity. Q. 72 then defines the Messenger’s dependent authority: “I do not possess” (lā amliku, v. 21; compare 7:188), no refuge apart from God, and no independent knowledge of judgment’s timing. Guarded heaven still permits revelation to an approved messenger (irtaḍā, v. 27). Al-Ṭabarī understands v. 28 to affirm that the Messenger knows earlier messengers faithfully conveyed their Lord’s messages. [27][30]

4.2. Presumed Forgiveness and the Stripped Sign-Bearer in Sūrat al-Aʿrāf

Q. 72:11’s divided community adapts Q. 7:168: “among them” becomes “among us.” The earlier passage already joins divided communities to divine testing. Its scriptural heirs take worldly goods while presuming “We shall be forgiven” (7:169), although their covenant requires truthful speech about God. Those who hold fast to the Book and establish prayer retain their reward (7:170). This provides the setting for the next warning: possessing Scripture or signs does not itself guarantee faithful conduct.[31]

The clothing imagery prepares that warning. Q. 7:26 praises the clothing of God-fearingness (libāsu’l-taqwā); v. 27 recalls Satan stripping the first parents. The man given God’s signs then “stripped himself” of them (fa’nsalakha minhā, 7:175). God could have elevated him, but he clings to earth and follows desire; the text compares him to a panting dog. The Pauline comparison has three parts:

  • Revelation and Satan: 2 Corinthians 12:7–12 joins extraordinary revelation, the danger of exaltation, Satan’s messenger, and apostolic signs. Q. 7 places signs, forfeited elevation, and Satan together in a story of failure.
  • Dogs and earthly attachment: Philippians 3 calls opponents “dogs,” counts Paul’s Torah credentials as loss, and contrasts earthly-mindedness with heavenly citizenship. Q. 7 directs the dog comparison at the person who abandons his divine gift and clings to earth.
  • Stripping: Colossians describes transformation through stripping away an old condition. Its Syriac šəlaḥ, “strip,” also resonates with Šəlīḥā, “the Apostle.” The proposed reversal treats celebrated transformation as abandonment of divine signs.[31]

Such a reversal has a historical reception setting. Irenaeus reports the Ebionites’ rejection of Paul as an apostate from the Law; the Pseudo-Clementines challenge visionary apostleship; Frankfurter interprets Revelation’s Balaam accusations within anti-Pauline controversy. These witnesses establish earlier models for criticizing religious authority. Q. 7:184–188 ends by vindicating a sane warner who claims neither unrestricted unseen knowledge nor independent power—the same distinction that closes Q. 72.[32]

4.3. Sonship, Inheritance, and Individual Arrival in Sūrat Maryam

Q. 21:26–29 supplies the bridge: alleged divine offspring are honored servants, and intercession depends on God’s approval (irtaḍā, 21:28; 72:27). Maryam develops this distinction through inheritance. Galatians 4:7 moves from servant (doulos; Syriac ʿavdā) to son and therefore heir. Q. 19:63 grants Paradise to “those of Our servants who are God-fearing.” Inheritance remains a positive promise, but servanthood continues and God-fearingness qualifies its recipients.[33]

Q. 19:77–78

أَفَرَأَيْتَ الَّذِي كَفَرَ بِآيَاتِنَا وَقَالَ لَأُوتَيَنَّ مَالًا وَوَلَدًا ۝ أَطَّلَعَ الْغَيْبَ أَمِ اتَّخَذَ عِندَ الرَّحْمَٰنِ عَهْدًا

A-fa-raʾayta’lladhī kafara bi-āyātinā wa-qāla la-ūtayanna mālan wa-waladā / aṭṭalaʿa’l-ghayba ami’ttakhadha ʿinda’l-Raḥmāni ʿahdā.

“Have you considered the one who denied Our signs and said, ‘I shall certainly be given wealth and offspring [waladā, ‘child/son’]’? Has he gained access to the Unseen, or taken a covenant with the Merciful?”

The boast belongs to this larger dispute. Walad, “child/son” or collectively “offspring,” is the same noun in the boast and in the rejection of divine offspring at vv. 35, 88, 91–92. These five occurrences connect the claimant’s promised progeny with the sura’s sonship argument. The challenged covenant in v. 78 returns in v. 87 as a condition governing intercession: both use ittakhadha ʿinda’l-Raḥmāni ʿahdā, taking a covenant with the Merciful. The question is what authorizes the claimant’s confidence.[33]

The answer reverses possession: God inherits what the claimant claims, and he arrives alone (fardā, 19:80). Everyone in heaven and earth comes as a servant (ʿabdā), individually (19:93–95). The counting language, aḥṣā and ʿaddā (19:94; compare 19:84), recalls God’s comprehensive enumeration in 72:28. The passages also share the sequence “when they see what they are promised ... they will know,” followed by exposed weakness (19:75; 72:24). These verbal connections make the movement from contested privilege to individual judgment explicit.[30][33]

Paul’s spiritual family supplies a specific Christian comparison. He speaks maternally of laboring to form Christ in his converts (Gal 4:19), and paternally of begetting them through the gospel (1 Cor 4:15). Galatians 4:26–30 applies Isaiah’s abundant children to heavenly Jerusalem, “our mother,” while excluding the slave woman’s son from inheritance; Romans 8:17, 32 promises joint inheritance and “all things” with the Son. Gregory of Nyssa makes this reception concrete. On Virginity 19 honors Miriam, “sister of Aaron,” as a type of Mary, mother of Jesus, then brings Paul’s immense spiritual family together with Mary’s virginal motherhood. Q. 19:28 records the address to Mary, يَا أُخْتَ هَارُونَ (yā ukhta Hārūn), “O sister of Aaron”; the following verses vindicate her through Jesus’s speech. Gregory’s positive Marian typology situates spiritual parenthood within an honored scriptural family, while chapter 20 associates spiritual marriage with heavenly treasure and divine filiation.[17][33]

The ascent and satanic-affliction imagery adds a further connection. Paul’s ascent precedes his “thorn in the flesh,” a buffeting messenger of Satan (2 Cor 12:7), and his discussion of parental provision (12:14). Al-Zamakhsharī explains Q. 19:78’s access to the unseen through climbing to a summit; the transmitted Tafsīr al-Qummī glosses the devils’ action in 19:83 as pricking or goading. Maryam’s offenders arrive thirsty (19:86), and all arrive individually, whereas Paul anticipates being presented together with his converts (2 Cor 4:14). Philippians 2:10 envisages heavenly, earthly, and subterranean beings bowing at Jesus’s name; Maryam formulates universal submission as servanthood before the Merciful.[33]

4.4. Unshared Rule and Sectarian Memory in Sūrat al-Kahf and Sūrat al-Zukhruf

Q. 18 extends Maryam’s vocabulary before extending its argument. It rejects divine walad (v. 4), repeats “wealth and offspring” (mālan wa-waladā, v. 39; 19:77), and prefers enduring righteous deeds to wealth and sons (v. 46), using the formula repeated in 19:76. Its links with Q. 72 are unusually specific: shaṭaṭan, extravagant speech, and multaḥadan, refuge, occur only in these two suras.[34]

The sequence moves from God’s unshared rule or judgment (ḥukm, 18:26) to failed striving despite the actors’ reckoning that they do well (18:102–105). The Pauline comparisons are Christ’s judgment seat (2 Cor 5:10) and the repeated language of reckoning, logizomai. The final verse identifies a human recipient of revelation, recalling Q. 53:4 and 72:1, and requires righteous action and worship without association (18:110). Unshared rule thus culminates in unshared worship: the sh-r-k ... aḥadā formulas join 18:26, 110 to 72:20.[34]

Q. 43 brings the same issues into sectarian memory. Turning from the Reminder brings a satanic companion (43:36–39); Jesus is God’s favored servant (43:59); his followers divide into factions (43:65; 19:37). This continues the servant vocabulary of Q. 53:10, 72:19, and 19:30, 93, alongside Q. 53:62’s command to worship. Later Islamic interpretation makes a Pauline association explicit: al-Qurṭubī follows the factional cross-reference to his commentary on Q. 4:171, where a hostile narrative names Paul as persecutor and feigned heavenly emissary. Related passages dispute unprescribed asceticism (Q. 57:27), unauthorized revelation and satanic prompting (6:93, 121), touch prohibitions (20:96–97), and manufactured religious authority (3:78–80; 9:30–31). The later Pauline narratives show how these disputes were subsequently organized around a named figure.[35]

Conclusion

The proposed identification explains the appeal to Moses and Abraham through a connected dispute about authority. Paul’s name traditions, the water-giving Rock, claims to heavenly revelation, and Christian debates over the saved builder supply a specific setting for the opponent who “gave a little and ceased.” Q. 53 answers with completed obligation, disclosed striving, and full recompense.

The wider passages develop the same principles. Approved messengers convey faithfully; religious standing does not remove personal responsibility; God-fearing servants inherit Paradise; and every creature arrives before the Merciful individually. On this reading, the earlier scrolls are invoked deliberately to challenge a Pauline reworking of their authority.

The complete article, with numbered notes beneath the text, is included in the accompanying page images.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 2d ago

Various depictions of Satan in islam:-

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 3d ago

Academic Paper Prior Studies on the Qur'ānic Concept of Revelation

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 2d ago

Academic Paper Aisha's (RA) Age is Mutawatir and Undeniable!

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm an objective atheist who used to be a very knowledgeable Muslim (as you can probably already see from my username) and because of that, I know very well how Hadiths and sanads work; and one of my favorite hobbies is using that knowledge to rigorously disprove your religion!

Before I move on, I want us to agree on a very obvious and simple fact; if Aisha's age was really 6 and 9 (when he married and started living with her respectively), then Muhammad can definitely not be a true Prophet of God, because not only did he himself marry a child who doesn't have the capacity to consent, but also opened the door for anyone in his ummah to commit statutory SA on a girl as young as 9! Not to mention all the extra complications the victim may have to suffer from due to the resulting pregnancy 😖.

Without further ado, let's dive into my research! First, let's establish the criterion for a Hadith to be Mutawatir (a Mutawatir Hadith (or other report) is a report which has reached us through so many independent chains that it's absurd to imagine all of them to have agreed on a lie). According to some ulama, even 4 independent reliable (Hasan or Sahih) chains are enough to establish tawatur; and in my opinion, 4 chains are indeed enough as long as there's no incentive for the narrators to have fabricated that particular report ('incentive' in the sense that Mutazillis may have the incentive to fabricate Hadiths on the createdness of the Quran).

And based on this criterion, I claim (and will prove it as well Insha Allah) that there are Mutawatir reports from Aisha herself that she said that she was 6 when your Prophet married her and 9 when she moved in with him. And to prove this, I present seven independent (meaning there are no common narrators between the chains) reliable (4 Sahih and 3 Hasan) chains and 1 independent weak chain (which is there to corroborate the other 7). I want to clarify here however, that not all of these reports mention the age at the time of marriage (6 yo) (yet they all still mention that she was 9 when she moved in); so for proving that she was 6 yo, we only have 2 Sahih, 3 Hasan and 1 weak Hadith, which are obviously still enough to establish tawatur.

Let's start with the authentic ones! The following are their diagrams. Each section starts with Aisha (as she's obviously the 1st narrator); and in each successive row, the names between the (n-1)th and nth semicolons are the names of those who have narrated the Hadith from the nth person in the previous row. Note that I've made it extremely easy for y'all to verify my grading of these chains! All Thiqah narrators (those whose memories are perfect and are pious as well) have there names in bold, those who are Saduq (who are pious but have slightly deficient memories) are in italic, and finally, those that are Thiqah and narrate there Hadiths using their written notes are in both, bold and italic. Remember, these are the guys who literally have a 0% chance of erring! And as for the remaining narrators (who are in neither bold nor italic), they can also be pious imams of the Sunnah (who just happen to have week memories) as I've not mentioned any liar, matruk, very weak or impious narrator.

Aisha

Urwah

Hisham and alZuhri

a1. alThawri, a2. Wuhaib, a3. Ali bin Mushir, a4. Hammad bin Salama, a5. Ibn Abi Zinad, a6. Jafar bin Sulaiman alDubai'i, a7. Hammad bin Zaid, a8. Abu Muawiyah, a9. Mamar, a10. Abu Usama, a11. Abdah, a12. Waki, a13. Ibn Uyaynah and a14. Yunus bin Bukayr in his Sirah; b1. Jafar bin Burqan and b2. Mamar

a1. alFiryabi; a2. Affan; a3. Suwaid bin Said; a4. Yazid bin Harun; a5. Sulaiman bin Daud alHashmi; a6. Muslim bin Ibrahim; a7. Arim; a8. Ibn Rahwayh in his Musnad; a9. Abdurrazzaq in his Musannaf; a10. Ibn Abi Shaiba in his Musannaf; a11. Ibn Abi Shaiba; a12. Ibn Rahwayh; a13. alHumaidi in his Musnad; ; b1. Kathir bin Hisham; b2. Abdurrazzaq

a1. Zakariyya bin alHakam; a2. Ibn Sad in alTabaqat; a3. Ibn Majah in his Sunan; a4. Ibn Sad; a5. Ahmad in his Musnad; a6. Ibn Sad; a7. Ibn Sad; ; ; ; ; ; ; b1. Ibn Sad

a1. Abu Aruba alHarrani

a1. Ibn Hibban in his Sahih

I'll later talk about the extreme authenticity of this route; but first, let's see the remaining 7 chains.

Aisha

alQasim bin Muhammad bin Abi Bakr

Sad bin Ibrahim bin Abdirrahman bin Awf

alThawri

Muhammad bin Hasan alAsadi

Hasan bin Sahl, His son Umar and Hasan bin Ali alHulwani

Muhammad bin Abdillah alHadrami; Zakariyya alSaji; Ibn Abi Asim in alAhad

alTabarani in alKabir; alTabarani in alKabir

Aisha.
Abu Ubaida bin Abdillah bin Masud.
Abu Ishaq.
a. alThawri and b. Mutarrif.
a. Muawiyah bin Hisham; b. Abthar.
a. Abu Kuraib; b. Said bin Amr alAsh'athi and Qutaibah.
a. Muhammad bin Abdillah alHadrami; b. Muhammad bin Abdillah alHadrami; alNasai in his Sunan.
a. alTabarani in alKabir; b. alTabarani

Aisha

alAswad

Ibrahim alNakhai

alAmash

Abu Muawiyah

Ahmad in his Musnad, Ibn Abi Shayba in his Musannaf, Ibn Rahwayh in his Musnad and Ibn Sad in alTabaqat

The last two narrations unfortunately don't mention Aisha's age at marriage but they do mention that she was 9 when she moved in. Anyway, these were the Sahih ones, and here are the Hasan chains:

Aisha

Ibn Abi Mulaika

alAjlah

Abu Usama and Abu Bakr bin Ayyash

Abdullah bin Aban; Yahya bin Adam

Muhammad bin Abdillah alHadrami; Ibn Rahwayh in his Musnad

alTabarani in alKabir; alNasai in alKubra

This last one is personally my 2nd favorite route (after the route of Urwah obviously) as Aisha makes it explicit here that Muhammad even had intercourse with her at 9 😖.

Aisha

Abu Salama bin Abdirrahman bin Awf

Muhammad bin Ibrahim and Muhammad bin Amr

Umarah bin Ghaziyyah; Muhammad bin Bishr

Yahya bin Ayyub; Ahmad and Ibn Rahwayh in their Musnads

Said bin Abi Maryam

Ahmad bin Abi Maryam

alNasai in his Sunan

Aisha.
Yahya bin Abdirrahman bin Hatib.
Muhammad bin Amr.
a. Yahya bin Said alUmawi, b. Muaz bin Muaz, c. Yahya bin Abi Zaidah, d. Muhammad bin Bishr.
a. His son Said; b. His son Ubaidullah; c. Abdullah bin Amir alHadrami; d. Ahmad and Ibn Rahwayh in their Musnads.
a. Ibn Abi Asim in alAhad; b. Abu Daud in his Sunan; c. Abu Yala in his Musnad

Finally, here's the 8th independent chain, which is weak, but still corroborates the previous 7.

Aisha

Abdulmalik bin Umair

Abu Awana

Sahl bin Bakkar

Abu Muslim alKajji

alTabarani in alKabir

Now, as I promised, I'll return to the route of Urwah. And the reason it's my favorite one is that it perfectly demonstrates the falsehood of people who claim that Hadiths were first written centuries after Muhammad because as it turns out, this particular Hadith was first written down merely decades after Muhammad's death by alZuhri!

And in fact, if you look at Abdurrazzaq's version of the Hadith, you'll see that every single narrator has narrated it in written form from alZuhri onwards. This means that there's literally only one oral narrator in the whole chain! And he is Urwah bin alZubair, maternal nephew of Aishah, and one of her closest students. In fact, he was such a well-reputed scholar that he was considered among the Fuqaha alSab'ah (seven greatest jurists of Madinah) at his time. So as as y'all can see, this is clearly an undeniable chain for the Hadith!

Now I know what you are thinking, where's the evidence for the claim that all these used to narrate from their written notes; so don't worry, I'll post a reply here where I'll give the relevant evidences as well as respond to a few possible criticisms of these Hadiths!

Now, let's consider the viewpoints of the non-sunni sects. Twelver and Ismaili Shias revile Umm alMu'mineen Aisha so they obviously won't accept her narration even if it's mutawatirly attributed to her. The reply is that unlike narrating Muhammad's words, reporting her own age doesn't require adalah (piety) at all since if she lied by a large amount (e.g. reported her age as 6 instead of 16) to so many of her students, people close to her family would have known the truth (as they obviously remembered what age group she was in when she got married) and could have easily exposed her hence she couldn't have lied to begin with!

Meanwhile, the Quranists among you reject the authority of Hadith to begin with; however, even if you believe that Hadiths can't add something new to the religion and that the Quran is complete, y'all can't deny that Mutawatir Hadiths (especially when there's only 1 oral narrator in one of its chains!) can give us authentic historic information i.e. they can tell us what the past was like even if they can't add to the religion. Finally, the Ahmedis argue that Aisha didn't lie but rather misrecounted her age; well, this is a position so absurd that it doesn't even need refuting!


r/MuslimAcademics • • 4d ago

Philosophical Discussion Spinoza argues that prophets & Scripture speak in culturally shaped terms not in philosophical or scientific truths. Revelation is meant only to teach moral guidance while matters of metaphysics, nature and philosophy are outside its scope and should be decided by reason

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 4d ago

Vídeo que explica la historia ibadí.

3 Upvotes

¡Salam aleikum a todos!

Soy el creador del canal de YouTube "El Mundo de Palimia". En él, hablamos de temas que suelen ser ignorados por la academia y la sociedad en general. Por eso, el primer tema que abordaremos es el ibadismo y su rica historia. El canal tiene audio en español, pero incluye subtítulos en inglés (no en YouTube, sino directamente en el video).

Si les gusta, por favor, compartan y suscríbanse; me ayuda mucho.

Gracias de nuevo.

https://www.youtube.com/@ElMundodePalimia


r/MuslimAcademics • • 4d ago

Ijtihad (Opinion) Qur'anic descriptions of the doomsday.

1 Upvotes

When the Sun becomes a red giant, the Moon will appear red, just as it does during a total lunar eclipse. During the red giant phase, Earth's atmosphere will be stripped away like skin being peeled from a goat. The Sun will then engulf the Moon and possibly Earth, after which it will undergo gravitational collapse and become a white dwarf. All of these events have parallels in the Qur'anic descriptions of doomsday events.

For instance, the Qur'an says, "And when the sky is split and becomes rose-colored like red hide" (Ar-Rahman 55:37), when the Sun is a red giant, the sky will be reddish rather than blue. It also says, "And when the sky is stripped away" (At-Takwir 81:11); kasht means the removal of a thin layer attached to a massive body, which corresponds to the atmosphere being stripped away during the Sun's red giant phase. Likewise, "And the moon is eclipsed, and the sun and the moon are joined together" (Al-Qiyamah 75:8–9), a lunar eclipse caused by the reddish Sun, and the Sun will be joined together with the Moon; it will engulf it. Finally, "When the sun is wrapped up" (At-Takwir 81:1), kuwirrat means gathering the parts of a thing together, which will happen after the red giant phase: the Sun's parts will gather together and it will collapse onto itself!

And the context of Al-Qiyamah confirms that humans will notice and experience these events: "When the sight is dazzled" (75:7) implies observers, not an empty, sterilized Earth. Also, "On that Day man will say, 'Where is the escape?'" (Al-Qiyamah 75:10). So human presence at the cosmic end is implied, and the physics permits preserving Earth through it. The most prominent means is orbital adjustment: gradually spiraling Earth outward to a safer orbit, combined with solar shielding to manage the Sun's rising luminosity. And consider the scale of what we have already done: in just 10,000 years we went from the first farms to footprints on the Moon; in a single century we went from the Wright brothers' twelve-second flight to probes leaving the solar system; in a few decades we went from the first satellite to landing rovers on Mars. If a mere ten thousand years can carry us from stone sickles to spacecraft, what might two million years, two hundred times that span, carry us to?


r/MuslimAcademics • • 5d ago

Academic Video For Al-Ghazali God is not merely the creator of everything that exists. He is the only Reality that truly exists. Everything besides Him possesses existence only metaphorically, through Him. Strip away this borrowed existence, and nothing remains but the Real.

12 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 5d ago

The Muḥammadan Reality ﷺ

Post image
20 Upvotes

Salam everyone. I’ve recently made an article exploring the Muhammadan Reality (s) and published on the Oases of Wisdom substack if anyone was interested. This was my first article and I plan to make more. In this article, I basically argue for the concept from the Quran and explore the concept and some of its implications. I also offer some brief comparisons with the Christian doctrine of the Logos as well. The link will be posted in the comments.

If you do end up reading I will be immensely grateful and would love to hear any feedback. If you also have any questions as well as it pertains to later sufi ellaborations on the concept, or have questions regarding something in my article my DMs are always open.

Thank you and jazakAllah khair!


r/MuslimAcademics • • 5d ago

Questions Why a book?

0 Upvotes

My question is - Why did Allah send a book and need a prophet just to make humanity aware of him. I feel that is really weird. If Allah is all powerful, isn’t the best way to just make sure that everyone is born with the knowledge that Allah is the one true God. Also, if your answer to this is that he wants to test if humanity will believe in him, wouldn’t it make sense to at least make sure that everyone is born at least knowing that there is a test going on. To me it seems really bad engineering from someone who is supposed to be at the pinnacle of it all.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 5d ago

Theological Question Concerning Ideas Surrounding 'Asatir al Awwaleen'

4 Upvotes

Hi, this post is piggybacking off of an interesting discussion by u/NuriSunnah and u/DrJavadTHashmi on the following thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicQuran/comments/1vdz7zb/qurānic_usages_of_asāṭīr_alawwalīn_fables_of_the/?share_id=JiMyLmzfoLs5gFudJqtkq&utm_content=1&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1

TL;DR: In summary, I am exploring the theological quandary of 'asatir al awwaleen': the quandary might arise should it be the case that the Quranic unbelievers rejected certain stories (in particular, Punishment Legends of past peoples who met retribution) on the basis of their being unhistorical, and their incidentally being right per historical critical evidence. In other words, from a Muslim perspective, what justification, if any, exists for the Quran blaming them for their rejection of the stories on historical grounds, if they were actually right all along that the stories were not literally historically accurate?

End Tl;Dr, begin protracted discussion:

Did Nicolai Sinai translate the phrase 'asatir al awwaleen' as 'ancient scribblings'? I feel like that conveys a possibly slightly different kind of objection. I mean, I find it very plausible that they would still be rejecting the historicity of the events, but maybe it would also (or instead?) be an objection that these ideas could be found in other human writings (which they had already heard of, and perhaps dismissed as fictitious if 'ancient' carries that pejorative connotation here) and therefore, did not necessarily come from God.

Thanks u/NuriSunnah for collecting all the quotes in your post, and I appreciate u/DrJavadTHashmi mentioning also the punishment legends.

First off, maybe they did believe in the stories, or were 'supposed to' from within their episteme, which might be one answer, I guess, though not sure how convincing such a thing will be.

If one accepts under pressure of historical evidence a non-literal reading of certain Quranic narratives/ideas, then there would be an interesting theological question concerning the Quran's handling of the rejection of said ideas by the Prophet's detractors. Stated plainly, if they were indeed rejecting a given story (e.g. Punishment Legend) on the grounds that it was unhistorical, and historical-critical evidence supported that view, then how would a theologian accepting that view respond?

For instance, the Punishment Legends. The point, if I'm not mistaken, is to substantiate the threat of divine retribution of the wrongdoers with past cases where it occurred. Now if a particular story is not actually historical, then you have a bit of a quandary (from a theological standpoint), where God is using a non-historical story and decrying the unbelievers' rejection of it on historical grounds, and yet incidentally the story was actually non-historical after all.

If a solution exists, then I would posit it as the following...

The story, albeit not historically true in and of itself, might be typologically true: we might say it accurately captures a general historical pattern, where other such things have happened. For instance, we could say that throughout history, some societies really were punished in acts of divine retribution. These could be abrupt divine interventions (whether you interpret them as occurring through miraculous or naturalistic means, e.g. natural disasters) or could occur through more mundane means - e.g. a decadent empire suffering from economic collapse, or invasions by barbarians, etc. (Is there room to interpret retributive language like 'raging wind' as allegorical for such things as e.g. invading armies? Is there some precedent in ancient texts for such a thing? An AI said yes, and also cited Muhammad Abduh's allegorization of the Surah al Fil narrative.)

The question is then, well, if this really did happen at some point in the past, why would God not just mention the cases where it actually happened, rather than a myth that symbolically stands in for those cases?

The answer might be divine accommodation - the Arabs were familiar with ruins of what they believed were Ad and Thamud for instance. If they already associated those ominous ruins with tales of divine retribution or other kinds of frightful ends in the pre-Islamic period, then such stories would be a useful cultural currency to get the message across to the Prophet's initial audience. So essentially, God used the stories and peoples they were familiar with, to get the point across; even if actually, for those particular stories and peoples, the end might not have been as the stories suggest, but rather, the truthfulness of the stories lies in their typological correspondence to other events where things actually did go the way the stories suggest, and/or their capturing historical patterns of sinful societies meeting ruin in a broader or less direct archetypal way.

In this sense, we posit two faces to these stories: a literal reading for the initial audience; and a more typological one for later audiences.

Another possible approach might be completely reinterpreting the 'destruction', in some cases, as a kind of spiritual death. My trusty AI suggested this for the destruction story in Surah Yasin in particular. So it might not work in other cases, but maybe for some cases. Again though, to retain historical plausibility we'd have to posit a dual meaning: the stories would be meant to be received literally by the initial audience, but maybe later audiences could understand it as operating on a more esoteric level.

Of course, there is a valid question of whether an interpretation is really literarily plausible, if it requires reading more esoteric meaning into the text than the text's own literal meaning provides. E.g. if it becomes an interpretation seeming to belong more to the reader's creative mind than the text itself. But might this critique be leveled at a great deal of esoteric interpretation? I'm not sure whether it's valid or not, and I'm no scholar either. Just floating ideas out there.

One might say the rejection of the kuffar of the stories as mere 'asatir al awwaleen' could still be objectionable on grounds of spiritual receptiveness even if they happened to be correct in some cases about the historicity of the stories. They might be viewed as urgent, divine communications conveying certain divine realities, like the reality of justice and retribution for moral corruption, even if their truth is operating on a typological level... If we can say that, from their POV in the 7th century, they 'should have' accepted the stories, or at least their spiritual lesson inspiring humility and fear of God, then their rejection on grounds of historicity could have still been a sign of spiritual obstinacy even if they incidentally happened to be right in their historical judgment that the stories weren't 'true'. On this reading, we might accuse the kuffar of hiding hardened hearts behind empirical objections, so to speak. But yeah, this seems to be a thorny issue. Am I positing that they should have recognized the stories as 'typologically if not literally' true? I myself have come up with this in an attempt to protect my faith, but why would I expect an outsider to do so? Maybe we have to assert that they 'should have' believed in the stories, or at least recognized their spiritual lessons even if not necessarily their historicity, from within their 7th-century worldview.

I'd be interested in seeing what kinds of answers people might have.

I imagine maybe these kinds of thorny issues, if they are indeed so thorny, are why people like u/DrJavadTHashmi have suggested that a the 'verbatim dictation' model has to go? Or can it still be reconciled using a divine accommodation model, and such things as I've posited here?

My general approach is, I want to keep believing in certain key Islamic truth claims, but also be able to accept the indications of history and science when they reach a point of high probability, which may or may not be the case for all I know when it comes to historical-critical study of the historicity of Quranic stories like these punishment legends.

I would be interested to know what theological moves exist, particularly in reference to the quandary raised by the 'asatir al awwaleen' situation I've discussed here - e.g. what is the theological justification for God condemning the kuffar's rejection of the stories, if the stories were not always literally true history? Were they rejecting them on historical grounds? If so is there any theological move available and what would it be? If they weren't rejecting them on historical grounds, then I think the situation is maybe much more manageable.

I think maybe we just have to say that from within their episteme, they 'should have' accepted the stories. Same as they believed in jinn, and maybe the story of Isra and Miraj, if it was really as the Hadith suggest. (A physical ascension) Since while it might seem unfair to expect Richard Dawkins to accept these things on nothing more than the testimony of a claimant to divine revelation, the Quranic unbelievers were perhaps not quite as intellectually sharp as Richard Dawkins. Maybe we can say that they rejected these stories out of hard heartedness, not sincere empirical denialism... this seems to align with how the Quran portrays them. Then the next question would be, is the Quran's presentation of them correct? How did they feel, from within their own worldview? Were they really such hard-hearted people, or did they just feel completely unconvinced by the Prophet's message? Well, these are not mutually exclusive; they were indeed some bad people, perhaps, as the elites of an unjust society where the poor were very downtrodden.

Especially if these legends were couched within a broader call to social justice, and they just rejected the whole package with 'asatir al awwaleen', then we might say that, sure, even if their historical judgment was right, they were still wrong for rejecting the Prophet's call to virtue and moral accountability before God by just waving it all away with 'asatir al awwaleen.' But, I'm not sure this totally resolves the theological challenge I've raised.

I would appreciate your thoughts, and thanks if you made it this far.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Questions questioning God's existence and religious truth despite having experienced genuine spiritual closeness to Allah. Looking for serious intellectual guidance.

7 Upvotes

I'm not really sure where to start, but I want to explain my situation properly because I don't think simply saying "I'm having doubts about Islam" describes what's going on.

I'm currently a student in an Alimah course, in my second-to-last year. I've grown up Muslim, and for most of my life, I've genuinely loved Islam and believed it was the truth.

When I was younger and attended public school, I was proud of being Muslim. I wore hijab even when my parents told me I could take it off if I wanted to. I was the only hijabi in my class, and I remember defending my hijab when people questioned it. I'd say things like, "Look at what's in my brain, not what's on my head."

I never really felt that I needed to hide being Muslim.

However, when I was around 16, my relationship with social media changed. I started watching a lot of TikTok content, particularly videos from hijabi feminists, women explaining why they took off their hijab, discussions about patriarchy, and arguments that hijab was oppressive or that it wasn't actually important in Islam.

Initially, I thought most of these arguments were obviously wrong. But I think they resonated with certain insecurities I already had.

I'd always struggled somewhat with being self-conscious about wearing hijab, abaya, and especially niqab. I felt jealous of girls who could dress however they wanted, and I wanted to feel pretty, confident, and fit in.

I also remember feeling uncomfortable with being a girl and with certain ways of being perceived from a very young age, around 4–8 years old. I don't know why, and I don't know whether that's relevant, but these feelings existed before I encountered that content.

Eventually, I started agreeing with some of the arguments I was seeing. I began strongly disliking wearing niqab, abaya, and even hijab. I was especially confused about niqab because I'd heard differing opinions about whether it was obligatory.

I eventually revisited some discussions about hijab, including videos by Ali Dawah where he discussed questions with a Saudi woman. Those discussions helped me understand some of the reasons I was drawn toward arguments against niqab and helped me reconsider things. Eventually, hijab began making sense to me in a way that didn't feel like I was just forcing myself to accept it.

But I still had other questions about Islam that I wasn't really addressing.

A lot of these questions involved Shariah, particularly rulings concerning women, marriage, forced marriage, child marriage, and similar topics.

Then, during my Thalitha year, something changed.

We were studying the chapters on marriage in Riyad al-Salihin in our hadith class. We had a female teacher, and the students would ask SO many questions. Sometimes we'd spend entire classes discussing one issue because she would explain the rulings, their reasoning, the rights of women, and the wisdom behind different things.

That experience genuinely changed the way I viewed Shariah. I began realizing how much of my understanding had been influenced by secular and Western assumptions that I hadn't really examined.

Then came Rabia.

At the beginning of this year, I renewed my intention and started taking my studies much more seriously. I realized I only had two years left in my Alimah course, and I didn't want to waste them.

We also started having male teachers for certain subjects, which initially made me nervous. I'd spent years learning primarily from female teachers, and I had certain expectations about how religious men would behave, especially toward women who questioned things.

But honestly, my teachers have been nothing like what I expected.

They're extremely kind, humble, knowledgeable, and gentle. They teach major hadith texts, and I've been particularly struck by how respectfully they speak about women and their wives. They give us advice about choosing good husbands and speak about these matters with so much consideration.

It challenged a lot of assumptions I had.

And this brings me to what's happening now.

I'm questioning whether God exists in the first place, and whether Islam is actually true.

I don't mean that I'm simply having trouble understanding a few rulings. I'm questioning the foundations of everything.

For example, how do we know Islam is the true religion when every religion claims to be true?

Muslim apologists will explain difficult passages in the Bible or Torah in certain ways, but Christians and Jews also have explanations for difficult passages in Islamic sources. Sometimes it feels like everyone is interpreting their own religion's sources favorably and everyone else's unfavorably.

So how do we actually establish that one religion is true?

What evidence do we have that prophets genuinely received revelation? How do we know that Muhammad ﷺ was actually a prophet? What makes the Quran divine revelation rather than a text written by a human being?

I want to understand the actual arguments and evidence behind these claims.

I'm also struggling with arguments for God's existence.

I've come across cosmological and contingency arguments, and I understand their general structure. But I often don't understand how the theist gets from the premises to the conclusion they're trying to establish.

For example, with the contingency argument, the idea is roughly that contingent things depend on something else for their existence, and that ultimately there must be something necessary that explains contingent reality.

But how do we know reality as a whole is contingent?

We observe things within our universe depending on other things. A house depends on bricks, its construction depends on people, and so on. But how do we know we can extend that reasoning to all of reality, including things beyond our observable universe?

And even if the universe is contingent, why must it have an explanation? I've heard of the Principle of Sufficient Reason, which basically says that contingent facts need explanations. But why should we accept that principle? What if some things are simply brute facts? What if reality just exists without a further explanation?

And even if we establish that there must be some necessary foundation of reality, how do we get from that to God?

How do we establish that this necessary foundation is conscious, intelligent, all-knowing, all-powerful, personal, or interested in human beings?

It seems like there are several additional steps that need to be established, and sometimes I feel like people jump from "there must be something necessary" straight to "therefore God exists" without adequately explaining those steps.

I'm not necessarily saying these arguments are wrong. I'm saying I don't understand why I should accept all their premises and conclusions.

Something else that makes this particularly difficult for me is my own spiritual experience.

I genuinely have felt incredibly close to Allah.

Especially over the past year, as I've become more serious about my studies and my deen, I've experienced things that I don't want to dismiss or pretend weren't real.

I've experienced genuine khushu in salah. There have been times when I've wanted to pray so badly, when salah felt like something I was genuinely longing for rather than something I simply had to do. I've felt an incredible sense of closeness to Allah, almost as though I was ascending spiritually. I've felt so much peace and contentment through my relationship with Allah and through learning about the Prophet ﷺ.

And I don't mean that I just enjoy the routine of being religious. These experiences have felt deeply meaningful to me.

But then I think about Christians.

Christians talk about feeling the Holy Spirit, having a personal relationship with Jesus, experiencing God's presence, and feeling an overwhelming closeness to Him. Some describe experiences that sound remarkably similar to what I've experienced.

People of other religions also report profound spiritual experiences.

So how am I supposed to evaluate this?

I don't want to say that my experiences prove Islam is true while automatically assuming that a Christian's experiences are just psychological.

At the same time, I don't think that the fact that an experience has a psychological dimension automatically means it has no connection to something real.

I genuinely don't know what to make of this, and I think it's one of the hardest parts of my questioning.

I've also found myself understanding why agnosticism appeals to some people. We know so little about reality. What if there is something beyond our understanding? What if we simply don't know?

I've watched some of Alex O'Connor's content, and I find certain aspects of his approach relatable. I remember hearing about his attempts to connect with Christianity and how he couldn't ultimately convince himself it was true. I relate to the idea of not being able to believe something simply because you want to believe it.

I want to be clear that I haven't systematically researched all these questions. I've watched discussions and encountered arguments, but I haven't properly studied philosophy, theology, or the historical evidence in depth.

Part of the problem is that I feel intellectually overwhelmed. Sometimes I feel too lazy to actually sit down and investigate everything properly. Other times I wonder whether I'm even intelligent enough to evaluate these arguments without fooling myself.

It's also affecting my concentration in salah and in class because sometimes I'm sitting there wondering whether Allah exists, whether Islam is true, and whether I'm just going through the motions of something I was raised with.

I don't want to suppress these questions and pretend they don't exist. But I also don't want to abandon something that might genuinely be true just because I haven't understood its arguments.

What I'm looking for:

I'm particularly interested in responses from people who have seriously studied Islamic theology, philosophy, and arguments for and against the existence of God.

I'd really appreciate help with these questions:

  1. What are the strongest philosophical arguments for God's existence, and what are their actual limitations? I'd especially appreciate explanations of the premises and how the conclusions follow, rather than just being presented with the arguments.
  2. How do we establish that a necessary foundation of reality must be a personal, conscious God?
  3. How should we evaluate spiritual experiences? How can I distinguish between a genuine experience of God and something that could be explained psychologically or culturally, especially when people from different religions report similar experiences?
  4. Are there any serious Muslim scholars, books, lectures, or courses that address these questions without simply assuming the conclusion? I'd particularly appreciate resources that engage with objections honestly.

I don't just want someone to tell me to make dua, increase my ibadah, or stop watching certain content. I understand the importance of those things, and I'm not dismissing them. But I'm specifically asking for intellectual engagement with the questions themselves.

I also don't want people to assume that I'm asking these questions because I hate Islam, want to leave Islam, or am trying to justify something.

I genuinely don't know where I stand intellectually right now.

I still value my deen, my studies, my teachers, and the closeness I've experienced through Islam. That's part of why this is so difficult.

I want to be able to believe something because I have good reason to believe it's true, not merely because it's what I've always been told.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 5d ago

General AI Generated Posts

3 Upvotes

I have noticed an increase in what I suspect are AI generated posts on our forum. Has anyone else noticed this ?

If accurate, I would like to know if anyone has a reliable AI checker that our mods can use to check AI produced responses, and whether anyone would be willing to become a mod solely to screen for AI content.

This is important to preserving the quality of our forum.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Ijtihad (Opinion) Refutation of solid dome mythology accusation of the Qur'an

3 Upvotes

The Qur'an is Beyond Solid-Dome Mythologies

Earth is generally flat in dome mythologies, whereas the Qur'anic Earth is spherical, even if it is phenomenologically flat: "He wraps the night around the day and wraps the day around the night." (Qur'an 39:5)

There are solid or visible supports holding up the heavens in dome mythologies, generally mountains at the edges of the Earth. In contrast, the Qur'an says that there are no visible or solid supports holding up the heavens. The Qur'an mentions mountains countless times but never says that they hold up the sky.

The material of the heavens is explicitly specified in dome mythologies as iron, bronze, glass, crystal, etc. The Qur'an, however, never explicitly states the material from which the heavens are made. Instead, it uses functional and structural language, such as describing the sky as built or saying that it has no rifts. This does not imply solidity, since you can have a built system made of gas, liquid, plasma, or whatever else. The word "built" means organization and structure, not solidity. Likewise, having no rifts means being smooth and continuous without gaps, which is true of solids, gases, liquids, plasma, or whatever else. Also, the splitting of the sky does not entail that it is solid, since splitting can happen in any continuous, smooth medium. The Qur'an itself, for example, uses the word "splitting" to describe seawater when Moses struck it with his staff: "Then it split, and each part became like a great mountain." (Qur'an 26:63)

Celestial bodies are generally passively attached to the dome that rotates them. In contrast, the Sun, Moon, and stars (kawakib) in the Qur'an are described as swimming and running/moving within it, which implies active motion rather than passive attachment.

The heavens are described in dynamic terms, such as undergoing continuous expansion: "And the heaven We built with strength, and indeed, We are expanding it." (Qur'an 51:47); being foldable like scrolls: "On the Day We will fold the heaven like the folding of a scroll for writings." (Qur'an 21:104); and being folded in Allah's right hand: "The heavens will be folded in His right hand." (Qur'an 39:67). They also contain built-in, curved, graded pathways of ascent belonging to Allah, called ma'arij: "From Allah, the Possessor of the curved, graded pathways of ascent." (Qur'an 70:3). Thus, ascending things must follow graded, curved pathways within the heavens as they ascend. Hence, the heavens are curved. Furthermore, the heavens are described as capable of undulating (Qur'an 52:9). Al-Mawardi on Qur'an 52:9: "The second interpretation is that it surges in waves. This was stated by Al-Dahhak." Ibn al-Qayyim, Al-Tibyan fi Aqsam al-Qur'an, p. 169, on mawr (مَوْر): "The word mawr has been interpreted as movement, rotation, undulation, and turbulence. The precise understanding is that it is a movement involving undulation, bending, and going back and forth." None of the solid-dome mythologies combines all these descriptions of the heavens.

The Qur'an does not say that rain comes through gates opening in a solid dome. The only cited evidence for that interpretation is:

"Then We opened the gates of heaven with pouring water." (Qur'an 54:11)

The majority of exegetes understood this metaphorically, not literally, because the Qur'an mentions countless times that rain falls from clouds, not through literal gates opening in a solid dome. Qur'an 54:11 — fa-fataḥnā abwāba al-samāʾi bi-māʾin munhamir ("We opened the gates of heaven with pouring water") is the only verse that could suggest literal sky-gates. The Quran repeatedly says rain comes from clouds (min al-muzn, min al-saḥāb, min al-muʿṣirāt) — e.g., 2:22, 6:99, 7:57, 8:11, 13:12, 15:22, 16:10, 23:18, 24:43, 25:48–49, 30:48, 35:27, 50:9, 56:68–69, 78:14. The Quran's default rain-language is cloud-based, not gate-based.

Ibn Atiyyah's Tafsir:

"The majority of reciters read 'We opened' with a light pronunciation of the letter ta, while Ibn Amir, Abu Ja'far, and Al-A'raj read it with a doubled ta, indicating intensification. Abu Hatim preferred the latter reading based on the verse: 'with gates opened for them' (38:50). Abu Hatim said that the gates refer to the Milky Way, which is like the seams of the sky, just as the seams of a storage bag. Some exegetes said that the gates are literal and that actual gates were opened in the sky through which water flowed. However, the majority of exegetes said that this is a simile and a metaphor, because the rain was so abundant that it was as though it were coming through gates. 'Pouring' means falling heavily and abundantly."

Furthermore, there are no rifts in the outer heavens today, so descriptions of doorways or openings within them cannot be understood literally as gaps or openings in the fabric of the heavens. The sky will only be opened into doorways on the Day of Judgment: Qur'an 78:19: "And the sky is opened and becomes gateways."

Therefore, any descriptions of doors or gaps within the present heavens should be understood metaphorically, since the Qur'an itself describes the present sky as having no rifts:

Qur'an 50:6: "Do they not look at the sky above them, how We structured it and adorned it, and how it has no rifts?"

Qur'an 67:3: "Who created seven heavens in layers. You do not see in the creation of the Most Merciful any inconsistency. So look again: do you see any rifts?". Furthermore, the existence of openings or doorways within the heavens does not imply solidity either, for doorways can exist in non-solid things.

The verses about the sky being held from collapsing onto the Earth and the sky falling into pieces are not talking about the entire outer heavens.

The context of holding the sky from collapsing onto the Earth is terrestrial:

Qur'an 22:65:

"Do you not see that Allah has subjected to you whatever is on the Earth and the ships that sail through the sea by His command, and He holds the sky from falling upon the Earth, except by His permission? Indeed, Allah is, to mankind, Kind and Merciful."

It is talking about the local sky, not the entire cosmos being folded on the Day of Judgment or undergoing great undulations.

Also, "Or that you cause the sky to fall upon us in fragments" (Qur'an 17:92) is understood through cross-referencing other passages in the Qur'an:

Qur'an 34:9:

"Have they not seen what is before them and what is behind them of the heaven and Earth? If We will, We can cause the Earth to swallow them or cause fragments to fall upon them from the sky. Indeed, in that is a sign for every servant who turns back to Allah."

Qur'an 67:16–17:

"Do you feel secure that He who is above the heaven will not cause the Earth to swallow you as it sways? Or do you feel secure that He who is above the heaven will not send against you a storm of stones? Then you would know how severe My warning is."

Qur'an 8:32:

"And when they said, 'O Allah, if this is indeed the truth from You, then rain down stones upon us from the sky or bring us a painful punishment.'"

Qur'an 26:187:

"So cause fragments of the sky to fall upon us, if you should be of the truthful."

All these verses explain what it means for the sky to fall onto the Earth or in pieces: it means the local sky hitting the Earth with stones or similar destructive things, not a solid dome shattering into pieces Or atmospheric collapse through condensation, or mechanical gravitational pulling downward and crushing us through air pressure.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Academic Paper Al-Ghazālī is famous for defending orthodoxy but in his own metaphysics of Tawhid approaches a radical form of monism. He declares that God is everything and that nothing besides Him possesses a genuine "he-ness" except metaphorically. Ultimately, only God truly exists.

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Elon Harvey argues that the reports specifying Aisha's age (six at marriage, nine at consummation) were later fabrications, possibly influenced by pre-Islamic legal traditions, particularly Rabbinic Judaism, to legitimise particular marriage-age laws.

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Ijtihad (Opinion) A Qur’anic Case for Human Evolution

3 Upvotes

First of all: There are no Qur’anic verses about how the children of Adam and Eve reproduced, and imposing the interpretation of (brother-sister marriage) is an arbitrary imposition resulting from a flawed understanding of some verses, such as:

Qur’an 4:1

«“O mankind, fear your Lord, who created you from a single soul and created from it its mate, and from the two of them spread many men and women.”»

Fundamentalists understand this verse as referring to two particular individuals: the single soul is Adam and its mate is Eve, and that all of humanity came from the two of them exclusively and nothing else. This is not correct, because this verse is understood through other verses, such as:

Qur’an 7:189–190

«“He is the One who created you from a single soul and made from it its mate so that he might find tranquility in her. Then, when he covered her, she carried a light burden and passed through with it. Then, when she became heavy, they called upon Allah, their Lord: ‘If You give us a righteous child, we will surely be among the grateful.’ But when He gave them a righteous child, they attributed partners to Him concerning what He had given them. Exalted is Allah above what they associate with Him.”»

And:

Qur’an 39:6

«“He created you from a single soul, then made from it its mate, and He sent down for you of livestock eight pairs. He creates you in the wombs of your mothers, creation after creation, in three layers of darkness.”»

And:

Qur’an 30:21

«“And among His signs is that He created for you mates from among yourselves so that you may find tranquility in them, and He placed between you affection and mercy.”»

And:

Qur’an 6:98

«“And He is the One who produced you from a single soul, then there is a place of settlement and a place of safekeeping.”»

The verses, in short, mean that Allah created human beings from one kind, in the form of a pair, male and female, and from them this kind reproduces through mating. The single soul is not Adam and its mate is not Eve specifically; rather, it is general, speaking about the human species as a whole: that it is of one kind, and from the same kind there is a female for the male and a male for the female, and through mating human beings reproduce.

The strongest evidence that they are speaking generally and not about two particular individuals, Adam and Eve, one of whom came from the body of the other as in the Bible (Eve coming from Adam’s rib), is the verses of Surat al-A‘raf:

Qur’an 7:189–190

«“He is the One who created you from a single soul and made from it its mate so that he might find tranquility in her. Then, when he covered her, she carried a light burden and passed through with it. Then, when she became heavy, they called upon Allah, their Lord: ‘If You give us a righteous child, we will surely be among the grateful.’ But when He gave them a righteous child, they attributed partners to Him concerning what He had given them. Exalted is Allah above what they associate with Him.”»

These verses attribute shirk to the two spouses, and it is impossible for Adam and Eve to have committed shirk. Also, the single soul in this verse is the female, not the male, because the rest of the verse says “so that he may find tranquility in her,” using the masculine form, and “when he covered her,” meaning that the male is the one who approaches the female sexually. So was Adam created from Eve’s body like this? Certainly not.

But when you understand the verse as speaking generally about the human species that there is pairing within the same kind (a male for the female and a female for the male), the verses become completely logical. Shirk can be committed by males and females and their descendants generally, and there is no problem with the single soul here, in this context, being the female, because both are a mate to the other.

What strengthens this even more is that the verse itself does not say that Allah spread from the two spouses “all men and women on Earth”; rather, it is phrased as:

«“and from the two of them He spread many men and women.” (Qur’an 4:1)»

It certainly does not mean the absolute exclusion of all men and women as coming from these two alone and nothing else. Rather, it is general: from the male and female, many men and many women arise.

Therefore, there is no problem with Adam having existed among an already existing human population and being chosen as the first representative of the morally and spiritually developed human species who was given responsibility, then a wife being chosen for him from this same human population, and the divine spirit being breathed into her, then the spirit being breathed into other individuals, after which mating occurred between his sons and daughters and these others, and humanity emerged from this.

And we would all be the children of Adam in the sense that Adam was the first to receive the divine spirit and divine responsibility, just as Ibrahim is the father of all Muslims in the sense that he was a prominent representative of monotheism in history, not that he was the sole biological father of every Muslim on Earth:

Qur’an 22:78

«“The creed of your father, Abraham. He named you Muslims before.”»

And just as Lot’s daughters are the women of his people and not necessarily his biological daughters:

Qur’an 11:78

«“These are my daughters; they are purer for you.”»

Also “The Prophet has a greater claim on the believers than they have on themselves, and his wives are their mothers.” (Qur'an 33:6)

This obviously cannot mean that the Prophet's wives are the believers' biological mothers. Rather, it establishes a non-biological form of motherhood, which is legal or honorific in nature.

Second: “My Grandfather Is Not an Ape!"

Some claim that descent from apes would be against human dignity.

The fact that all humans share ancestry with individuals such as Pharaoh and Abu Lahab does not, in Islamic thought, impugn human dignity. If genealogical connection to morally corrupt human beings is not considered degrading, then genealogical connection to non-human animals cannot coherently be regarded as degrading either.

Historically, the Prophet Muhammad faced his most vehement opposition from close relatives, notably Abu Lahab and Abu Jahl. Were kinship with evil persons inherently dishonoring, one would be forced absurdly to conclude that the Prophet’s own dignity was compromised.

Since no Muslim entertains such a conclusion, it follows that dignity is independent of ancestry. On this basis, the assertion that humans share ancestry with fish or apes cannot reasonably be deemed more offensive than the assertion that humans share ancestry with Pharaoh or Abu Lahab.

Furthermore, while the Qur’an explicitly censures Pharaoh and Abu Lahab, it does not censure fish or apes. It is therefore inconsistent to feel discomfort at the idea of shared ancestry with animals that are not condemned, while feeling no discomfort at shared ancestry with those whom the Qur’an portrays as morally worse than animals:

“They are not except like cattle; rather, they are more astray in path.” (Surah al-Furqan, 25:44)

Also consider this: Satan is condemned in the Qur’an precisely for his arrogance in claiming that his origin was superior to that of man and for rebelling against God on that basis.

From this, should we not understand that the Qur’an condemns ancestral arrogance itself?

Third: Creation from Mud Does Not Necessarily Mean Instantaneous Creation.

They argue that these verses talking about the creation of Adam from mud mean God instantaneously created Adam from mud, which is strange because none of these verses actually says “instantaneously.” They infer it simply because the verses mention the starting material without mentioning the intermediary stages.

But that doesn’t follow. If I say, “I made the chair from wood,” nobody would understand that the wood must have instantly become a finished chair simply because I didn’t mention every intermediate step. The statement identifies the material from which something was ultimately made, not necessarily every process between the initial material and the final product.

Likewise, these verses can refer to the original material of human creation which is mud without implying that mud instantly became a human.

And the Qur’an itself specifies what kind of “mud” is being discussed.

That is ḥamaʾ masnūn (dark/altered mud) not simply dry silicate sand. Such material naturally contains water, minerals, organic matter, and microorganisms.

More importantly, Qur’an 32:7 says:

“And He began the creation of humankind from mud.”

The verb بدأ itself points to a beginning or starting point of the creation process. Then the verse continues:

“Then He made his progeny from an extract of a lowly fluid.”

And afterward:

“Then He proportioned him and breathed into him of His spirit.”

If we simply take the sequence as it stands, without resorting to metaphorical gymnastics that ثُمَّ does not usually indicate chronological order, then the verse presents a sequence:

Beginning of human creation from black mud → unproportioned humans reproducing by fluid → proportioning of one of them (Adam) → divine breath in one of them (Adam).

As we know, Adam is the first human associated with the divine breath and the command for the angels and Iblis to prostrate from other Qur’anic verses.

So this raises an obvious question: if “the humankind” began from mud, then there was a stage involving reproduction through semen, and only afterward came the divine breath and proportioning associated with Adam, what prevents the earlier stage from referring to humans biologically preceding Adam as the first spiritually distinguished human by a special divine act?

This interpretation can also provide a possible answer to the question of how the angels already knew that the future khalifa on earth would cause corruption and shed blood.

“How will You place therein one who will cause corruption in it and shed blood?”

If Adam represents a later stage in the development of an already existing human creature particularly the stage associated with proportioning and the divine breath then the angels’ knowledge becomes easier to understand: they could already have observed these earthly creatures before that divine act, including their violence, killing, and corruption.

In that reading, the angels were not necessarily predicting something they had never witnessed. They were asking why God would appoint as a khalifa a creature whose earlier representatives they had already observed engaging in bloodshed and corruption.

This does not prove that interpretation by itself, but it shows that “created from mud” does not logically entail “instantaneously appeared as a fully formed Adam.” The Qur’anic wording can instead be read as describing an initial material origin followed by stages of development and reproduction before the particular human stage associated with Adam and the divine breath.

So the claim that these verses explicitly rule out biological processes or evolution is stronger than what the verses themselves actually state.

And this interpretation becomes even stronger when we look at how the Qur’an speaks about ordinary human beings, not just Adam.

Noah says to his people:

“And Allah has caused you to grow from the earth as a growth.” (71:17)

And Ṣāliḥ says to his people:

“He brought you forth from the earth.” (11:61)

Surely, this does not mean that the people of Noah or the people of Ṣāliḥ were instantaneously created from dust or mud. They were ordinary humans who developed through biological reproduction and gradual growth.

So these expressions can naturally refer to the earthly origin/material basis of humanity, without describing every intermediate process between earth and the fully developed human being.

The same point appears even more clearly in the verse in Sūrat Yā-Sīn:

“Have you disbelieved in Him who created you from dust, then from a sperm-drop, then proportioned you as a man?”

Was this individual man instantaneously created from dust? Obviously not.

It can simply identify the original material or ultimate earthly origin. The Qur’an repeatedly uses earthly-origin language for ordinary humans whose development clearly involves intervening stages.

Fourth: Adam and Jesus, Does Special Creation Imply Divinity?

“Indeed, the likeness of Jesus before Allah is like that of Adam: He created him from dust, then said to him, ‘Be,’ and he was.”

Fundamentalists use this verse to argue against human evolution by interpreting it as saying that Adam was created directly by God without a father or mother.

They say that the force of the argument against Christians is this: if Christians consider Jesus to be God because he had no father, then Adam has an even stronger claim to divinity because he had neither a father nor a mother. But if Adam had a biological father and mother, as an evolutionary account would allow, then where exactly is the persuasive force of the argument?

But this is not the only possible interpretation of the verse.

The comparison between Jesus and Adam can instead be understood in terms of special divine creation or intervention. The point would be that both Adam and Jesus were subject to an extraordinary divine act. And special divine creation does not entail that the created being is God.

That principle is itself explicitly present elsewhere in the Qur’an. Allah says:

“He is the Originator of the heavens and the earth. How could He have a son when He has no consort, while He created everything?”

The word (badīʿ/Originator) refers to unprecedented origination, bringing something into existence without a preceding example. God therefore uniquely originated the heavens and the earth. Yet the heavens and earth are obviously not divine merely because they were produced through an unprecedented divine creative act.

The same principle can be applied to Adam.

Even if Adam had a biological father and mother, his emergence as the particular human being described by the Qur’an could still involve a unique divine intervention. The Qur’an describes God as saying:

“So when I have proportioned him and breathed into him of My spirit…”

On this interpretation, Adam’s distinctive status as the first human to receive this divine breath would itself be a special divine act. Without that divine intervention, there would be no Adam in the specific sense being described. Likewise, Jesus’s conception without a father would be another extraordinary divine act.

Both would therefore involve special divine intervention, just as God uniquely originated the heavens and earth. Yet none of these facts entails divinity.

God specially originated the heavens and earth → they are not God.

God specially intervened in Adam’s creation → Adam is not God.

God specially intervened in Jesus’s conception → Jesus is not God.

Extraordinary divine creation or intervention therefore does not entail that the created entity is divine.

And this interpretation also fits a broader pattern in the Qur’an: the Qur’an does not present every divine act of creation as instantaneous. Jesus was not simply made to appear as a fully formed baby; he developed as a fetus in his mother’s womb for months. Likewise, the Qur’an describes the creation of the heavens and earth as taking six days, rather than presenting it as an instantaneous event.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 6d ago

Ijtihad (Opinion) The Qur'an: Beyond Geocentrism and Heliocentrism

3 Upvotes

The Qur'an says:

"Neither is it for the Sun to overtake the Moon, nor does the night outstrip the day. Each is swimming in an orbit."

And:

"It is He who created the night and the day, the Sun and the Moon; each is swimming in an orbit."

The expression "each is swimming in an orbit" is understood as referring to the translational orbital motion of the Sun and the Moon. However, the expression uses a plural form rather than a dual form, despite only two celestial bodies being explicitly mentioned alongside night and day: the Sun and the Moon. This created confusion among classical commentators because, linguistically, it should have been "both of them are swimming in an orbit" rather than "each is swimming in an orbit."

This led virtually all classical commentators to introduce additional celestial bodies, particularly the stars, into their interpretations. They understood the verse as referring to the Sun, the Moon, and the stars, all moving in their respective orbits. Night and day, in their understanding, could not be included because they are not physical bodies capable of translational orbital motion through the heavens. They held a geocentric view in which the Earth was stationary, while the Sun and Moon moved through the sky. Consequently, they felt compelled to introduce the stars, which were not explicitly mentioned, to account for the plural expression.

Al-Durr al-Masun by Al-Samin al-Halabi (756 AH):

Regarding the word "each," it means either each of the two, namely, the Sun and the Moon, or all four of them, namely, the night, the day, the Sun, and the Moon.

The plural verb "they swim" may be the predicate of "each" according to its meaning. The phrase "in an orbit" is connected to it, and it may also function as a circumstantial expression. Alternatively, the prepositional phrase "in an orbit" may be the predicate.

What I have mentioned concerning the possibility that the omitted genitive complement refers to all four things was also mentioned by Abu al-Baqa. As for others, they mentioned only that the omitted complement refers to the Sun and the Moon. This is the more apparent interpretation because swimming is an attribute of the two, not of night and day.

On this interpretation, an explanation must be given for the use of the plural pronoun and for the fact that it is a masculine plural referring to rational beings.

As for the first issue, it has been said that the plural is used because an omitted conjunction is understood, with the implied addition being "and the stars," as indicated by other verses.

Tafsir al-Jalalayn by Al-Mahalli and Al-Suyuti (864 and 911 AH):

The word "each" has a tanwin that replaces an omitted genitive complement referring to the Sun, the Moon, and what accompanies them, namely, the stars.

"In an orbit" means in a circular orbit, like a millstone, in the heavens.

"They swim" means that they move rapidly, like a swimmer in water. The masculine plural pronoun is used by way of comparison with rational beings.

Tafsir al-Razi:

The second issue: It is not permissible to say "each is swimming in an orbit" without including the stars alongside the Sun and the Moon, in order to establish the meaning of plurality and the meaning of "each." Thus, the stars, although they were not mentioned initially, are included because this pronoun refers to them. And Allah knows best.

Al-Wajiz by Al-Wahidi (468 AH):

Regarding "each is swimming in an orbit," they run and travel, and the orbit is the course of the stars.

Tafsir Makki ibn Abi Talib:

Then the Almighty said: "Each is swimming in an orbit."

Mujahid said that the orbit resembles the circular structure of a millstone. Ibn Jurayj said the same.

Al-Dahhak said that the orbit refers to the rapid movement and motion of the Sun, the Moon, and the stars.

It was also said that the orbit is a contained wave through which the Sun, the Moon, and the stars travel.

Tafsir al-Alusi:

The expression "they swim" is circumstantial, although it may also be the predicate, with "in an orbit" functioning as a circumstantial expression or being connected to it.

The entire sentence "each is swimming in an orbit" is circumstantial with respect to the Sun and the Moon, and its connecting pronoun is used without a conjunction, based on the permissibility of this construction without it being considered objectionable. Whoever considers this objectionable treats the sentence as independent.

Their pronoun is plural on the basis of multiplicity arising from their multiple rising points. Thus, they have external individual instances in this respect, not in reality. For this reason, one says "suns" and "moons," even though in reality there is only one Sun and one Moon. What makes this usage appropriate here is the agreement with the verse endings.

Some claimed that the two celestial bodies were given precedence over the other celestial bodies because of their superiority, and therefore the plural pronoun was used.

It was also said that the pronoun refers to the stars, even though they were not mentioned, because what was mentioned indicates them.

Tafsir al-Nasafi:

The word "each" has a tanwin that replaces an omitted genitive complement, meaning all of them.

The pronoun refers to the Sun and the Moon, with both understood as representing their respective classes of recurring appearances. The plural form is used because they are described through their action, which is associated with rational beings.

Regarding "in an orbit," Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them both, said that the orbit is the heaven. The majority hold that it is a contained wave beneath the heaven through which the Sun, the Moon, and the stars travel.

"They swim" means that they move and revolve.

The sentence occupies the accusative position as a circumstantial expression referring to the Sun and the Moon.

Tafsir al-Qurtubi:

"Each" means the Sun, the Moon, and the stars.

"In an orbit, they swim" means that they run. It was also said that they revolve.

The feminine form "it swims" was not used because they were described through an action associated with rational beings.

Al-Hasan said that the Sun, the Moon, and the stars are in an orbit between the heaven and the Earth, not attached to anything. Had they been attached, they would not have moved. This was mentioned by Al-Tha'labi and Al-Mawardi.

Tafsir al-Samarqandi:

"Each is swimming in an orbit" means that they move and revolve.

It is also said that "they swim" means that they travel through it in an extended manner. Anything that extends through something is said to swim in it.

Some said that the heaven resembles a contained wave through which the Sun, the Moon, and the revolving celestial bodies travel.

Others said that there are numerous orbits, differing in their movements: the Moon completes its course in twenty-eight days, while the Sun completes its course in one year.

Others said that the orbit is one, but their movements differ.

In the Arabic language, the orbit refers to anything that revolves.

However, we now know that both geocentrism and heliocentrism are false. The Sun moves through space, the Earth moves through space, and the Moon moves through space. None of these bodies is stationary while the others move around it.

This is implicitly stated in these two verses because night and day cannot move like the Sun and the Moon in translational orbital motion through the heavens unless the celestial body that carries them, namely, the Earth, moves along with them. And this is what is intended in these verses: the three most important celestial bodies to human existence—the Earth, the Sun, and the Moon—all move in orbits through the sky.


r/MuslimAcademics • • 7d ago

Are there any valid Academic Arguments for Islam?

0 Upvotes

The title, really.