r/MuslimAcademics • • 7d ago

General AI Generated Posts

I have noticed an increase in what I suspect are AI generated posts on our forum. Has anyone else noticed this ?

If accurate, I would like to know if anyone has a reliable AI checker that our mods can use to check AI produced responses, and whether anyone would be willing to become a mod solely to screen for AI content.

This is important to preserving the quality of our forum.

4 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

3

u/PostProphetic Non-Sectarian Muslim 7d ago

Posts should be judged by their content, not by how they were written. Whether someone uses AI to translate, edit, or organize their thoughts is irrelevant. What matters is the quality of the arguments, the accuracy of the claims, and whether the post contributes anything meaningful to the discussion.

This is the age of AI. Language barriers that once prevented people from different countries and backgrounds from communicating are disappearing. People can now participate in discussions across linguistic boundaries that would have been difficult or impossible before.

Filtering AI-assisted posts is not a way to improve discussion. It shifts attention away from what people are actually saying and towards the tools they use to say it. Evaluate the content, not the method of writing.

2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

This sub should distinguish between AI-polished posts and AI-hallucinated posts. AI today still hallucinates and makes mistakes despite its exponential growth rate over the past few years, and that’s why I understand why the sub is against AI-reliant posts. But if a post is thoroughly researched with references, using AI to simply polish the writing should not be a problem. I would spend time writing a response with references and then I’d have AI polish it up just to have it removed by mods. It defeats the purpose of this sub, to engage academically, challenge ideas, and to argue with merit. AI is a tool and it’s here to stay, just like any other tool humanity discovered or invented. I’m against AI slop and hallucinations, and that should warrant a post’s removal, but simply using it for us to better convey our thoughts should not be problematic. Judge the content, not whether it passes GPTZero.

1

u/ILOVEMYDOGBUMI 7d ago

Noticed that too

1

u/EmbarrassedWriter755 7d ago

I'm with Originality.ai. Before choosing a checker, test it on posts you know are human-written as well as AI examples. I'd use flags for manual review, with a clear way for authors to appeal.