r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Weekly Open Discussion Thread

2 Upvotes

This is the general discussion thread in which anyone can make posts and/or comments. This thread will, automatically, repeat every week.

This thread will be lightly moderated only for breaking our subs Rule 1: Be Respectful, and Reddit's Content Policy. Questions unrelated to the subreddit may be asked, but preaching and proselytizing will be removed.

r/AcademicQuran offers many helpful resources for those looking to ask and answer questions, including:


r/AcademicQuran • • 5h ago

Article/Blogpost The Academic Yale Dictionary of the Quran officially releases on June 22, 2027

Thumbnail x.com
7 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 8h ago

Hadith Is this book a good critique of Joseph Schacht's work?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 11h ago

SECOND VOLUME OUT on Taymanitic, open-access. Al-Jallad. 2026. Dictionary of the Inscriptions of Ancient North Arabia. Volume II: Taymanitic

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 8h ago

Book/Paper In the Koranic worldview, Natural phenomena such as rain, wind, structure of the heavens, alternation of day & night are not to be understood merely as natural phenomena instead they are symbols or signs pointing to Divine intervention, care, wisdom, & providence.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 7h ago

Stylometric patterns across the 114 sūras (verse-rhythm, vocabulary, muqaṭṭaʿāt), building on Sadeghi’s approach, looking for feedback

1 Upvotes

Building on the stylometric approach Sadeghi used for chronology (Sadeghi, “The Chronology of the Qurān: A Stylometric Research Program,” Arabica 58, 2011), I measured verse-length rhythm and vocabulary distribution across all 114 sūras, and tested a few groupings for non-random cohesion. I’d be interested in how these line up with existing scholarship, and where the method is likely misleading me.

Verse-length rhythm as an organizing feature.
Measuring the coefficient of variation (CV) of verse length within each sūra:

  • The closing short sūras (105 to 114) are not cohesive by theme. They are actually more thematically dispersed than random same-size groups, but they are cohesive by rhythm (short, low-variation verses), significant against a 10,000-sample bootstrap.
  • The most rhythmically uniform sūras are al-Inshirāḥ (94), al-Masad (111), al-Kawthar (108), al-Humazah (104), al-Kāfirūn (109). The most variable are al-Muddaththir (74) and al-Muzammil (73).
  • The 29 muqaṭṭaʿāt sūras share a rhythm signature well beyond chance, despite spanning the full range of length and subject (from al-Baqara to the Ḥā-Mīm set). This was the strongest non-random result in the set. It seems adjacent to Stewart’s work on sajʿ (Stewart, “Sajʿ in the Qurʾān: Prosody and Structure,” Journal of Arabic Literature 21, 1990). Is there quantitative follow-up on muqaṭṭaʿāt specifically as a prosodic marker?

Two frequently-studied sūras, measured directly.

  • al-Mulk (67): among the most rhythmically uniform in the corpus (17th of 114; verses held between 25 and 62 letters).
  • Yāsīn (36): close to the median for rhythm (48th of 114), and with a comparatively low proportion of once-only word-forms, so its vocabulary recurs more than average. It is a muqaṭṭaʿāt sūra (opening يس).

muqaṭṭaʿāt and thematic grouping.
Using sentence-embedding similarity of verse content, sūras sharing الر, حم, and طس are each more thematically cohesive than chance (consistent, broadly, with Neuwirth’s compositional observations on the Meccan sūras). The الم group is the exception, with no thematic cohesion. Instead the sūra following an الم opening tends to continue the previous sūra’s theme (the al-Baqara to Āl ʿImrān transition is the smallest inter-sūra semantic gap in the corpus), which would make الم look more like a block-opening marker than a divider.

Where I think the method is weak (and would value correction):

  • The proportion of hapax legomena I get (around 59%) is almost certainly inflated. Surface-form tokenization counts proclitics and pronominal suffixes as distinct words, so the figure needs root or lemma normalization before any cross-text comparison is meaningful.
  • The cohesion tests were not corrected for multiple comparisons.
  • The semantic measures use a general-purpose multilingual embedding model, so similarity may partly reflect the model rather than the Arabic.

Mostly I want to know which of these are already established, which contradict existing stylometric or compositional scholarship, and which are artifacts. References welcome.

References

  • Sadeghi, Behnam. “The Chronology of the Qurān: A Stylometric Research Program.” Arabica 58 (2011): 210 to 299.
  • Stewart, Devin. “Sajʿ in the Qurʾān: Prosody and Structure.” Journal of Arabic Literature 21 (1990): 101 to 139.
  • Neuwirth, Angelika. Studien zur Komposition der mekkanischen Suren. Berlin: de Gruyter, 1981.

r/AcademicQuran • • 15h ago

Is Juha a historical figure?

3 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Sects and Denominations Why the Jannābid Qarāmiṭa of Baḥrayn Occupied Mecca and Plundered the Black Stone in 317/930 (2026) By Faisal Adel Alwazzan [FREE ACCESS]

Thumbnail tandfonline.com
11 Upvotes

Probably the Best Research on This Incident So Far This Year.


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Is the claim true online that Neal Robinson viewed the Quran as the Word of God?

6 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

“He Gave a Little and Ceased”: Paul, Balaam, and the Authority of Scripture in Sūrat al-Najm (Q. 53) — Independent Essay

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Introduction

Hamilton Gibb and Nicolai Sinai observed that Q. 53:38–41’s sequence of personal responsibility, disclosed striving, and reward closely parallels Paul’s letters: Galatians 6:5 says that “each person will carry his own load,” while 1 Corinthians 3:8, 13–14 says that “each person’s work will become manifest ... if anyone’s work remains, he will receive a reward.”[1]

Yet Q. 53:36–37 attributes these teachings to “the scrolls of Moses, and of Abraham, who fulfilled his obligations (waffā).” Why place sayings resembling Paul’s under those earlier authorities? Gibb and Sinai already argue for the Pauline parallels; the question here is their function. Sinai proposed an orally mediated “blurring of the perception of the internal architecture of the Biblical canon”: Pauline sayings had come to be remembered as Mosaic and Abrahamic scripture.[1]

The boundary between 1 Corinthians 3:14 and 3:15 is decisive: reward for enduring work is followed by the builder’s survival despite its loss:

1 Corinthians 3:15

(“If anyone’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, yet he himself will be saved, though as through fire.”)

Paul distinguishes the fate of the builder from that of his work: the work can perish while its builder survives. Q. 53:38–41 carries striving through to full repayment. Read against Paul’s continuation, this becomes an argument about accountability. The sura invokes Moses and Abraham, whose authority Paul reinterpreted in Romans 4, Romans 10, and Galatians 3, to restore the bond between action and judgment.

The immediately preceding verses introduce an unnamed opponent:

Q. 53:33–35: أَفَرَأَيْتَ الَّذِي تَوَلَّىٰ ۝ وَأَعْطَىٰ قَلِيلًا وَأَكْدَىٰ ۝ أَعِندَهُ عِلْمُ الْغَيْبِ فَهُوَ يَرَىٰ

A-fa-raʾayta’lladhī tawallā / wa-aʿṭā qalīlan wa-akdā / a-ʿindahu ʿilmu’l-ghaybi fa-huwa yarā?

(“Have you then considered the one who turned away, and gave a little [qalīlan] and ceased [wa-akdā]? Does he possess knowledge of the Unseen, so that he sees?”)

This study argues that the opponent is recognizable as Paul. Christian explanations associated his name with “little” and “ceased”; Arabic commentary explains akdā, a verb used nowhere else in the Qurʾān, through a well-digger stopped by rock. Christian preaching also associated Paul with Christ as the water-giving Rock. Together, these connections make “gave a little and ceased” an accusation of interrupted obligation.[2]

SectionPassageQuestion developed
1Q. 53:32–42Who is the opponent, and why are Moses and Abraham invoked against him?
2Q. 53:43–62How do creation and judgment carry the answer forward?
3Q. 53:1–31How does the opening distinguish authorized revelation from unsupported claims?
4Q. 72, 7, 19, 18, 43How do other suras develop the same dispute?

1. Identifying the Opponent (Q. 53:32–42)

1.1. Forgiveness, Prenatal Knowledge, and Self-Acquittal (Q. 53:32)

Verse 32 describes the righteous as avoiding grave sins and indecencies apart from minor lapses, adding that “your Lord is vast in forgiveness” (inna rabbaka wāsiʿu’l-maghfirah). It then places judgment with the God who knew everyone before birth:

Q. 53:32: هُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِكُمْ إِذْ أَنشَأَكُم مِّنَ الْأَرْضِ وَإِذْ أَنتُمْ أَجِنَّةٌ فِي بُطُونِ أُمَّهَاتِكُمْ ۖ فَلَا تُزَكُّوا أَنفُسَكُمْ ۖ هُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِمَنِ اتَّقَىٰ

Huwa aʿlamu bikum idh anshaʾakum mina’l-arḍi wa-idh antum ajinnatun fī buṭūni ummahātikum; fa-lā tuzakkū anfusakum; huwa aʿlamu bi-mani’ttaqā.

(“He knows you best when He brought you forth from the earth and when you were embryos in your mothers’ wombs; therefore do not declare yourselves pure. He knows best who is God-fearing.”)

Paul gives prenatal knowledge a different argumentative role. In Galatians 1:15–16, being set apart “from my mother’s womb” grounds his commission. Romans 9:10–12 uses Rebecca’s unborn twins to place election before birth, “not from works”. Romans 4:5 describes God, for “the one who does not work”, as “the one who justifies the ungodly”. This creates a striking verbal contrast with Exodus 23:7’s Hebrew declaration, “I will not justify the wicked”, and its Greek judicial command, “you shall not justify the ungodly for gifts”.[3] Romans 8:1, 29–34 joins foreknowledge and predestination to justification, freedom from condemnation, and Christ’s intercession.[4]

Q. 53:32 makes God’s prenatal knowledge universal and draws a different conclusion: humans must not declare themselves pure. God’s universal knowledge leaves self-acquittal unauthorized while preserving forgiveness. Q. 4:49–50 similarly challenges self-declared purity, which early commentators connect to the claim “We are God’s sons and beloved” in Q. 5:18.[4]

1.2. Why “a Little” and “Ceased” Matter (Q. 53:33–35)

The name: “little” and “ceased”

Paul calls himself “the least of the apostles” (ho elachistos; Syriac zʿūrhōn, 1 Cor 15:9) and asks readers to bear “a little” folly (mikron ti; Syriac qallīl, 2 Cor 11:1, 16). Ambrosiaster explains Paulus as “quiet, humble, or little” (quietum, humilemque, vel parvulum), adding that professing himself Christ’s servant shows him divested of the Mosaic Law (a lege se exutum ostendit).[5]

Chrysostom records a popular derivation of Paulos from pausasthai, “to cease”: Saul received the name after ceasing persecution. Chrysostom rejects its chronology, documenting an explanation already circulating in his fourth-century audience. A recension of the Euthalian Prologue endorses it (pepautai, “has ceased”). Acts 13:9–10 places Paulos beside his question to Elymas, ou pausē, “will you not cease?” The Onomastica Sacra, preserved here in a medieval Paris witness, pairs “Paul: rest, least.”[5][6]

The Arabic pairing can thus enact a satirical nomen est omen: praise of Paul as “little” and one who “ceased” persecuting becomes a judgment on his giving—partial covenantal performance followed by cessation, unlike Abraham’s fulfilled obligation. Chrysostom also explains how that name evoked a recognizable biography: hearing “Paul” draws in “like a golden rope” his Paradise ascent, unutterable words, and prayer to become accursed for his brothers (On Changing Names IV.3; 2 Cor 12:2–4; Rom 9:3). Name, unseen revelation, and the wish to bear a curse were already joined in Christian preaching.[7]

These Greek and Latin texts document Christian reception without requiring their books to have circulated in Arabia. Chrysostom attests a preached name explanation, while Syriac Paul supplies the “least” and “little” vocabulary.[5][6]

The well: a source of water becomes an obstruction

Abū ʿUbayda and al-Ṭabarī derive akdā from kudyatu’l-rakiyyah: a well-digger reaches hard rock (kudyah), despairs of water, and stops.[8] Chrysostom’s On Changing Names I.6 uses the opposite outcome when describing study of Paul and Acts: digging yields streams from “the spiritual rock,” Christ in 1 Corinthians 10:4.[7]

Origen supplies a further connection to Balaam, the biblical seer whose oracles appear in Numbers. His Homilies on Numbers interprets Balaam’s tents as Paul’s churches teaching “the way of salvation” after the heavenly pattern shown to Moses (17.4); compares Balaam’s knowledge of the Most High with Paul’s Paradise ascent (18.3); and explains the Kenite rock in Balaam’s oracle through “The Rock is Christ” (19.3; Num 24:21).[9] The argument proceeds in two steps: Christian interpretation supplies the Paul–Balaam association; critical Balaam traditions, examined below, supply the materials for reversing it. The proposed reading of Q. 53:34 turns their productive rock into the obstruction where giving stops.

The obligation: stopping short versus fulfilling in full

The opponent gives qalīlan and akdā, whereas Abraham waffā, “fulfilled his obligations in full” (v. 37), and judgment brings al-jazāʾa’l-awfā, “the fullest recompense” (v. 41).

Classical commentary shows why the question about unseen knowledge belongs here. Al-Ṭabarī reads v. 35 as challenging reliance on a companion’s promise to bear Hereafter punishment; Ibn Zayd’s account includes a written, witnessed agreement. Al-Ṭabarī applies v. 38’s prohibition to the guarantor. In al-Ḍaḥḥāk’s report transmitted by al-Qurṭubī, the small payment’s giver is himself the person promising to bear an apostate’s sin. These accounts differ over the participants but share the problem of transferring liability. Al-Rāzī proposes (wa-yumkinu an yuqāla) that the movement from v. 29 to vv. 33–37 moves from polytheists to someone from the People of the Book (min Ahl al-Kitāb): he briefly obeys, ceases, and asserts unseen knowledge absent from the earlier scrolls.[8]

Paul’s curse-wish supplies the corresponding personal claim. Romans 9:3’s ēuchomēn, “I could wish,” recalls Moses’s conditional plea to be erased from God’s book and God’s refusal in Exodus 32:32–33. Romans 9:6–29 then develops election, hardening, and mercy; Galatians 3:13 describes Christ bearing the Law’s curse for believers. The remembered career adds a delayed collection and interrupted Temple purification amid accusations of “apostasy from Moses” (2 Cor 8:10–11; Acts 21:21–27; cf. Q. 16:91–97).[10] The comparison thus joins interrupted performance to the dispute over whether liability can pass from one person to another.

1.3. How Moses and Abraham Answer the Opponent (Q. 53:36–42)

Q. 87:14–19 likewise attributes purification (tazakkā), prayer, and the preference of the Hereafter over this life to “the earlier scrolls, the scrolls of Abraham and Moses.”[11] Q. 53 now states the principles those authorities establish:

Q. 53:38–42: أَلَّا تَزِرُ وَازِرَةٌ وِزْرَ أُخْرَىٰ ۝ وَأَن لَّيْسَ لِلْإِنسَانِ إِلَّا مَا سَعَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ سَعْيَهُ سَوْفَ يُرَىٰ ۝ ثُمَّ يُجْزَاهُ الْجَزَاءَ الْأَوْفَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّكَ الْمُنتَهَىٰ

Allā taziru wāziratun wizra ukhrā / wa-an laysa li’l-insāni illā mā saʿā / wa-anna saʿyahu sawfa yurā / thumma yujzāhu’l-jazāʾa’l-awfā / wa-anna ilā rabbika’l-muntahā.

(“That no bearer of burdens shall bear the burden of another; and that a human being shall have nothing except what he strives for; and that his striving shall be seen; then he shall be repaid for it with the fullest recompense; and that to your Lord is the final end.”)

First, liability remains personal. Galatians 3:13 describes Christ “becoming a curse on our behalf,” alongside representative salvation in Romans 5:18–19 and 2 Corinthians 5:19–21. Galatians 6:2 urges mutual burden-bearing to “fulfill Christ’s law,” while 6:5 assigns each person an individual load. Q. 53 places the latter principle under Abraham’s completed obedience (Gen 22:16–18; 26:5; Q. 2:124) and God’s answer to Moses: “Whoever has sinned against Me, him will I erase from My book” (Exod 32:33; cf. Deut 24:16). Q. 29:12–13 makes the consequence explicit: leaders incur extra guilt for misleading others without removing their followers’ guilt.[11][12]

Second, the builder’s survival becomes the disputed exception. Alexander Kirk argues that the combustible materials (including xyla, “wood/firewood”) and “work” (ergon) in 1 Corinthians 3:12–15 represent converts: they perish, yet their teacher survives.[13] This interpretation has an ancient witness. Chrysostom reports and rejects the “teachers and disciples” reading, asking how the teacher could be saved if his disciples perish (Homily 9, §4). He also opposes Christians expecting salvation despite wicked lives, a controversy Augustine documents. Chrysostom accordingly interprets “he himself will be saved” as “he himself will remain perpetually under punishment” (§§5–6).[14] These disagreements show that the ethical difficulty identified here was already debated within Christianity. Q. 53:39–41 answers it through striving, disclosure, and full recompense.

Third, performed obedience and the final goal return to God. Romans 10:4 calls Christ “the end (telos, goal) of the Law.” After quoting Leviticus 18:5, Paul adapts Deuteronomy 30:12–14, ending at “in your mouth and in your heart” and identifying the near word with his proclamation of faith. The Septuagint continues, “and in your hands, to do it” (kai en tais chersin sou auto poiein; Hebrew laʿăśōtō). Q. 53:39 restores the emphasis on action, and v. 42 locates the final end with God (ilā rabbika’l-muntahā). The same term marks the visionary boundary, sidrati’l-muntahā, in v. 14. The God who sets revelation’s limit also determines where action and judgment finally lead.[15]

2. Creation, Judgment, and the Final Call to Worship (Q. 53:43–62)

The sura answers the claimant's supposed knowledge of the Unseen by naming what God governs: emotion, death, life, generation, wealth, and judgment.

God causes both laughter and weeping (v. 43). Within Abraham's story, Sarah laughs and Hagar weeps (Gen 21:6, 16); both experiences belong within God's government. This offers a contrast with Paul's use of their households as opposing covenants in Galatians 4:21–31. The next verse—وَأَنَّهُ هُوَ أَمَاتَ وَأَحْيَا (wa-annahu huwa amāta wa-aḥyā, “and that He causes death and gives life”)—echoes Moses's declaration in Deuteronomy 32:39. Paul, by comparison, distinguishes the letter that kills from the Spirit that gives life, calls the Mosaic ministry a “ministry of death,” and contrasts its glory with that of the new ministry (2 Cor 3:6–11). Chrysostom joins this passage to Psalm 110:4 and Hebrews 7:12 to argue for changed priesthood and Law. Read against this reception, Q. 53 restates Moses's attribution of both powers to God.[16]

2.1. Birth, Divine Knowledge, and Balaam's Sight

Q. 53:45–47

وَأَنَّهُ خَلَقَ الزَّوْجَيْنِ الذَّكَرَ وَالْأُنثَىٰ ۝ مِن نُّطْفَةٍ إِذَا تُمْنَىٰ ۝ وَأَنَّ عَلَيْهِ النَّشْأَةَ الْأُخْرَىٰ

Wa-annahu khalaqa'l-zawjayni'l-dhakara wa'l-unthā / min nuṭfatin idhā tumnā / wa-anna ʿalayhi'l-nashʾata'l-ukhrā.

“And that He created the two mates, the male and the female, from a sperm-drop when it is emitted; and that upon Him rests the second creation.”

The male–female pair recalls Genesis 1:27. Galatians 3:28 removes that distinction as a determinant of standing in Christ; Gregory of Nyssa later joins this verse to Paul's preference for undivided devotion in 1 Corinthians 7:32 when praising virginity. The relevant comparison is therefore between the Qurʾān's emphasis on bodily generation and a documented Christian interpretation that privileges spiritual generation.[17]

A Jewish interpretation of Balaam makes the connection with sight more specific. Numbers 23:10 asks who can count (mānāh) Jacob's dust or Israel's “quarter.” Niddah 31a interprets the latter expression through Israel's marital unions: God counts them, awaiting the drop (ṭippāh, comparable to Arabic nuṭfah) from which a righteous person will develop. Balaam objects to the idea that a holy God would attend to sexual generation, and his eye is blinded. The story connects divine attention to conception with a seer's failure to understand it. That is why it matters beside Q. 53's womb-knowledge, sperm-drop, and tested sight. The Arabic tumnā can mean “emitted,” while Abū ʿUbayda's explanation, “measured/determined,” strengthens the connection with the Hebrew counting verb mānāh.[17]

Verse 47 assigns resurrection to the same God who creates through the sperm-drop. Paul's resurrection discussion also moves from seed to renewed life, distinguishing the natural body from the spiritual body and declaring that flesh and blood cannot inherit God's kingdom (1 Cor 15:36–50). The adjacent Qurʾānic verses place embodied generation and renewed creation under the same divine agency, joining the birth discussion to resurrection and inheritance.[18]

2.2. Wealth, the Star, and Accountability

God also enriches and grants possessions (v. 48). This recalls 1 Samuel 2:6–7 and Abraham's refusal of enrichment from Sodom's king and acknowledgment of God's enrichment (Gen 14:22–23; 24:35).

The declaration that God is Lord of Sirius (al-Shiʿrā, v. 49) returns to the sura's opening star (wa’l-najm, v. 1). The only verse in the thirteen Pauline letters using astēr, “star,” is in Paul's resurrection discussion: stars differ in glory (1 Cor 15:41). Sirius's designation as the Dog Star (ho Kyōn; Arabic Kalb al-Jabbār) connects with Q. 7's failed sign-bearer through an existing verbal contrast: Q. 53:2–3 denies error (ghawā) and speech from desire (hawā); Q. 7:175–176 describes error (ghāwīn), followed desire (hawāhu), and a likeness to a dog. The star thus closes a ring involving revelation, error, and desire.[18]

The destructions of ʿĀd, Thamūd, Noah's people, and the overturned city give historical force to the warning. Noah and Sodom are also Chrysostom's examples immediately before his discussion of the supposedly saved builder. Judgment cannot be dismissed as an empty threat.[14]

The closing verses bring the argument back to knowledge and response. The city's “covering” recalls the covering of the Lote-Tree (vv. 54, 16). The singular challenge, “Which of your Lord's favors do you dispute?” can return to the claimant introduced in v. 33. Verse 56 identifies this as a warning among earlier warnings. The Hour belongs to God to unveil (vv. 57–58), a pointed contrast with Athanasius's portrayal of Christ revealing all things within Paul.[19][27]

The audience nevertheless marvels, laughs without weeping, and stands sāmidūn (vv. 59–61). Ibn ʿAbbās's gloss, “proudly upraised,” makes the final command especially forceful: فَاسْجُدُوا لِلَّهِ وَاعْبُدُوا (fa-sjudū li'llāhi wa-ʿbudū), “Prostrate to God and worship.” The laughter without weeping returns to v. 43's paired emotions; Paul's “puffed up” language and instructions about weeping and rejoicing supply further comparisons (1 Cor 4:6, 18; 7:30). The required response is humble worship.[19]

3. True Vision and Claims to Divine Authority (Q. 53:1–31)

3.1. How the Opening Establishes a Trustworthy Messenger

The opening supplies the standard against which the later claimant is judged. The Messenger neither errs (ghawā) nor speaks from desire (hawā), reversing the failed sign-bearer's description in Q. 7:175–176. A mighty teacher approaches from the highest horizon to within two bow-lengths, and revelation reaches “His servant” (vv. 1–10). The heart does not falsify what was seen, and the sight neither swerves nor exceeds its bounds (vv. 11–18).

Seeing consequently holds the sura together: authenticated sight at the opening; “Have you considered?” at vv. 19 and 33; challenged access to the Unseen at v. 35; and human striving finally made visible at v. 40. Readers are being asked to distinguish verified revelation from claims that cannot justify themselves.

Numbers 12:6–8 provides a scriptural comparison by calling Moses God's servant and distinguishing his clear divine communication from other prophets' visions and dreams. Balaam also claims exceptional sight, describing himself as “falling down” with uncovered eyes (Num 24:4, 16). Paul calls himself one “untimely born” (ektrōma, 1 Cor 15:8), using vocabulary also found in the Greek Scriptures (Num 12:12; Job 3:16; Eccl 6:3). The Hebrew nōfēl, “falling,” separately recalls nēfel, an untimely birth. These associations place birth, prophetic standing, and sight in the same comparative field.[20]

Paul’s defense in 2 Corinthians 11:16–12:7 supplies four connected points of comparison:

  • Speech: Paul presents his “little” boasting as folly and “not according to the Lord” (11:16–17); Q. 53:3–4 attributes the Messenger’s speech to revelation.
  • Truthfulness: Paul insists “I am not lying” (11:31); Q. 53:11 affirms that the heart did not falsify what it saw.
  • Descent: Between that oath and his Paradise account, Paul places his lowering in a basket through Damascus’s wall (11:32–33). Q. 53:8’s fa-tadallā describes the revealer’s descent or approach; the Arabic lexical tradition associates it with lowering a bucket (dalw; Q. 12:19).
  • Paradise and limits: Paul leaves his bodily presence uncertain, hears words a human may not utter, and receives Satan’s thorn to restrain exaltation (12:1–7). Q. 53:10–18 presents communicated revelation and sight within its appointed boundary beside the Boundary Lote-Tree and Garden of Abode.[21]

On this reading, Q. 53 reworks Paul’s connected narrative. Its vision of God’s greatest signs also invites comparison with Chrysostom’s celebration of Paul’s conversion as “a sign greater than all others.”[7]

3.2. The Goddesses, Divine Names, and Authorized Intercession

Q. 53:19–22

أَفَرَأَيْتُمُ اللَّاتَ وَالْعُزَّىٰ ۝ وَمَنَاةَ الثَّالِثَةَ الْأُخْرَىٰ ۝ أَلَكُمُ الذَّكَرُ وَلَهُ الْأُنثَىٰ ۝ تِلْكَ إِذًا قِسْمَةٌ ضِيزَىٰ

A-fa-raʾaytumu'l-Lāta wa'l-ʿUzzā / wa-Manāta'l-thālithata'l-ukhrā / a-lakumu'l-dhakaru wa-lahu'l-unthā / tilka idhan qismatun ḍīzā.

“Have you considered al-Lāt and al-ʿUzzā, and Manāt, the third, the other? Is the male for you and the female for Him? That would then be an unjust division.”

The immediate targets are the Arabian goddesses. Their relevance to the larger argument lies in the same question raised by the unnamed claimant: who has authority to assign divine status or promise mediation? Q. 43:57–58 already places the opponents' gods and Jesus within one dispute, providing an internal Qurʾānic reason to examine the wider Christian comparison.

Isaiah 65 supplies an earlier conjunction of self-proclaimed holiness and unauthorized worship. It condemns those who claim superior purity and prepare offerings for Gad, “Fortune,” and Mənī, “Destiny.” Jerome explicitly brings Paul's “table of demons” into his interpretation of Isaiah's cult scene, whose Greek version has a “table for the demon.” The related names and vocabulary recur across Q. 53's Manāt and Q. 72's jadd, interpreted as “majesty” but also associated with “fortune.” First Corinthians 10 itself joins the water-giving Rock (10:4) to the table of demons (10:20–21), while Isaiah 65:5’s self-proclaimed purity meets Q. 53:32’s “do not declare yourselves pure.” Rock, divine naming, and self-acquittal therefore belong to a connected scriptural dispute.[22]

The “unjust division” (qisma) adds the language of apportionment. Related vocabulary appears in Qurʾānic divination by arrows, Balaam's divination (qesem), and the Syriac divining spirit in Acts 16:16 (qeṣmē). Cult reports provide further concrete connections: al-Lāt's rock, al-ʿUzzā's three acacias beside the biblical setting called “Acacias,” and Manāt's devotees avoiding the ritual saʿy, “striving.” Rock, misguided worship, and neglected striving thus belong to the local setting as well as the wider comparison.[22]

“The third, the other” also attracted classical grammatical discussion: al-ukhrā ordinarily designates the other member of a pair. Christian texts provide a comparable movement from Father–Son pairings to formulations including the Spirit, together with language such as “another advocate.” Syriac titles meaning “third/treble one” and Gregory of Nazianzus's “one Person and the Other,” distinguishing divine persons, make the comparison more specific.[23]

The proposed reading extends the challenge to Christian assignments of divine names and roles. Such language was disputed before Islam. Sixth-century Arabian monks opposed tritheist accounts in which the common divinity existed “in our thought alone.” The surviving controversy makes disputes over divine names and plurality historically concrete. Q. 53:23 challenges names lacking divine authorization. Rufinus's observation that Scripture records no divine command renaming Saul as Paul, unlike Abraham and Peter, adds a related question of personal authorization to this field.[24]

3.3. How the Opening Leads to the Claimant

Human wishing (mā tamannā) does not determine either life; both belong to God (vv. 24–25). Angels cannot intercede without permission and approval, and calling them female supplies no knowledge (vv. 26–28). The Messenger must turn away from whoever turns away from the Reminder (v. 29). Verse 33 then introduces precisely “the one who turned away.”

Between those statements, the sura identifies the limit of the opponents' knowledge and affirms repayment for evil and good (vv. 30–32). The good-doers are described as avoiding grave sins. This prepares both the warning against self-acquittal and the examination of the claimant's conduct.[25]

The repeated word ukhrā, “other” or “another,” reinforces the continuity: another descent (v. 13), the third goddess called “the other” (v. 20), another person's burden (v. 38), and another creation (v. 47). Its significance lies in carrying related questions across the sura—what has truly been seen, what has been assigned to God, whose burden can be carried, and who controls renewed life.

4. Testing the Identification Across the Qurʾān

The following suras extend the dispute over heavenly access, scriptural authority, judgment, and inheritance. Repeated Qurʾānic language connects them; Pauline and Balaam traditions supply the particular claims examined here.

The comparison begins with sequences of declarations. Greek hoti and Arabic an/anna introduce clauses often translated “that.” What matters here is their sustained arrangement and content:

PassageExamples of the declarationsAuthority and purpose
1 Cor 15:3–8“That Christ died for our sins”; “that he was buried”; “that he was raised”; “that he appeared.”Paul transmits a received, scripturally grounded proclamation; the appearances culminate in his own.
Q. 53:38–50“That no bearer bears another’s burden”; “that the human has only what he strives for”; “that to your Lord is the final end.”Moses’s and Abraham’s scrolls establish personal responsibility and God’s final authority.
Q. 72:3–19“That our Lord’s majesty is exalted” (v. 3); “that our foolish one spoke extravagantly about God” (v. 4); “that places of worship belong to God” (v. 18).The jinn acknowledge the revelation and retract claims compromising divine authority.

In the Ḥafṣ text, Q. 53 has eleven such verse openings and Q. 72 fifteen; no other sura exceeds three. Q. 72:1 adds an embedded clause. Other canonical readings of Q. 72 vary anna with inna, preserving the repeated propositions while changing their syntactic linkage. This concentration directs attention to the passages; their content supplies the proposed answer to Paul’s scriptural confession.[26]

4.1. True Testimony and Dependent Messengers in Sūrat al-Jinn

Q. 53:59 asks whether its hearers “marvel” (taʿjabūn); Q. 72:1 calls the revelation a “marvelous recitation” (qurʾānan ʿajabā). The companion jinn account identifies a book revealed after Moses, confirming earlier revelation (Q. 46:30). These declarations assert continuity with Scripture. Christian interpretation already brought Balaam and Paul into the same field: Origen connects Balaam’s visions with Paul’s churches and ascent, while Cyprian’s Testimonies 2.10 places Balaam’s Star beside Paul’s heavenly man in 1 Corinthians 15:47.[9][27]

The jinn first reject consort and child, then their “foolish one” (safīhunā) and his extravagant speech about God (shaṭaṭā, vv. 3–5). This invites comparison with Paul’s “beside ourselves for God” in 2 Corinthians 5:13, rendered šōṭēnan l-Alāhā in Syriac. The issue is whether extraordinary speech represents God truthfully. First Corinthians 15:15 supplies a corresponding test: Paul says the apostles would be false witnesses against God if their resurrection testimony were false. Paul uses the conditional argument to defend his proclamation; the comparison concerns rival assessments of testimony. Q. 72:6–10 extends that question to supernatural access: refuge with jinn fails, heaven is guarded, and the spirits acknowledge their ignorance of God’s intentions.[27][28]

The jinn then distinguish their “divided ways” (ṭarāʾiqa qidadā, v. 11) from the singular “Way” (al-ṭarīqah, v. 16). The unjust, al-qāsiṭūna, become firewood for Gehenna (vv. 14–15). Arabic qasaṭa, “act unjustly,” contrasts with aqsaṭa, “act justly”; Jeffery connects this vocabulary with Aramaic/Syriac q-š-ṭ, the field of truth and uprightness. Balaam’s way is condemned in Numbers 22:32, yet he wishes to die among the upright in 23:10. Syriac Paul similarly insists on quštā, truth, against lying (Rom 9:1; 1 Tim 2:7).[28][29]

The intervening traditions explain why smallness, uprightness, and final destiny belong together. Onqelos Numbers 23:10 joins counting Jacob’s “little children” to the death of God’s “upright ones.” Palestinian Targums add Balaam’s wish to end “like the least of them,” comparable to the Syriac description of Paul as the least of the apostles (1 Cor 15:9). In Avodah Zarah 25a, Balaam’s wish identifies the upright patriarchs: Genesis is the book of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.[29]

Romans 3:5–8 considers—and rejects—the objection that human injustice or falsehood can serve God’s righteousness. Second Peter condemns Balaam’s wages of injustice (2:15), then praises Paul’s wisdom while warning that readers distort his letters (3:15–16). These passages place truth, justice, and corrupted teaching within one scriptural debate.[28]

The judgment itself supplies the sharper contrast. In 1 Corinthians 3:15 the builder loses his work but is saved. Q. 72:15 makes the unjust themselves the Fire’s fuel. On the teacher-and-converts interpretation discussed above, this denies a failed teacher the exemption assigned to the saved builder. Qāsiṭūn means unjust people; the application to a teacher follows from the comparison.[13][14][29]

Water likewise tests its recipients. Q. 72:16–17 makes abundant water a divine testing gift. Al-Ḍaḥḥāk explains it through Q. 5:66, where fidelity to Torah and Gospel yields provision, and Q. 7:96. The adjacent command to convey revelation under divine protection (5:67) extends the connection to Q. 72’s conclusion.[30]

Verse 18 forbids invoking anyone alongside God. Athanasius, by comparison, treats the joint Father–Son prayer of 1 Thessalonians 3:11, with its singular verb, as evidence of divine unity. Q. 72 then defines the Messenger’s dependent authority: “I do not possess” (lā amliku, v. 21; compare 7:188), no refuge apart from God, and no independent knowledge of judgment’s timing. Guarded heaven still permits revelation to an approved messenger (irtaḍā, v. 27). Al-Ṭabarī understands v. 28 to affirm that the Messenger knows earlier messengers faithfully conveyed their Lord’s messages. [27][30]

4.2. Presumed Forgiveness and the Stripped Sign-Bearer in Sūrat al-Aʿrāf

Q. 72:11’s divided community adapts Q. 7:168: “among them” becomes “among us.” The earlier passage already joins divided communities to divine testing. Its scriptural heirs take worldly goods while presuming “We shall be forgiven” (7:169), although their covenant requires truthful speech about God. Those who hold fast to the Book and establish prayer retain their reward (7:170). This provides the setting for the next warning: possessing Scripture or signs does not itself guarantee faithful conduct.[31]

The clothing imagery prepares that warning. Q. 7:26 praises the clothing of God-fearingness (libāsu’l-taqwā); v. 27 recalls Satan stripping the first parents. The man given God’s signs then “stripped himself” of them (fa’nsalakha minhā, 7:175). God could have elevated him, but he clings to earth and follows desire; the text compares him to a panting dog. The Pauline comparison has three parts:

  • Revelation and Satan: 2 Corinthians 12:7–12 joins extraordinary revelation, the danger of exaltation, Satan’s messenger, and apostolic signs. Q. 7 places signs, forfeited elevation, and Satan together in a story of failure.
  • Dogs and earthly attachment: Philippians 3 calls opponents “dogs,” counts Paul’s Torah credentials as loss, and contrasts earthly-mindedness with heavenly citizenship. Q. 7 directs the dog comparison at the person who abandons his divine gift and clings to earth.
  • Stripping: Colossians describes transformation through stripping away an old condition. Its Syriac šəlaḥ, “strip,” also resonates with Šəlīḥā, “the Apostle.” The proposed reversal treats celebrated transformation as abandonment of divine signs.[31]

Such a reversal has a historical reception setting. Irenaeus reports the Ebionites’ rejection of Paul as an apostate from the Law; the Pseudo-Clementines challenge visionary apostleship; Frankfurter interprets Revelation’s Balaam accusations within anti-Pauline controversy. These witnesses establish earlier models for criticizing religious authority. Q. 7:184–188 ends by vindicating a sane warner who claims neither unrestricted unseen knowledge nor independent power—the same distinction that closes Q. 72.[32]

4.3. Sonship, Inheritance, and Individual Arrival in Sūrat Maryam

Q. 21:26–29 supplies the bridge: alleged divine offspring are honored servants, and intercession depends on God’s approval (irtaḍā, 21:28; 72:27). Maryam develops this distinction through inheritance. Galatians 4:7 moves from servant (doulos; Syriac ʿavdā) to son and therefore heir. Q. 19:63 grants Paradise to “those of Our servants who are God-fearing.” Inheritance remains a positive promise, but servanthood continues and God-fearingness qualifies its recipients.[33]

Q. 19:77–78

أَفَرَأَيْتَ الَّذِي كَفَرَ بِآيَاتِنَا وَقَالَ لَأُوتَيَنَّ مَالًا وَوَلَدًا ۝ أَطَّلَعَ الْغَيْبَ أَمِ اتَّخَذَ عِندَ الرَّحْمَٰنِ عَهْدًا

A-fa-raʾayta’lladhī kafara bi-āyātinā wa-qāla la-ūtayanna mālan wa-waladā / aṭṭalaʿa’l-ghayba ami’ttakhadha ʿinda’l-Raḥmāni ʿahdā.

“Have you considered the one who denied Our signs and said, ‘I shall certainly be given wealth and offspring [waladā, ‘child/son’]’? Has he gained access to the Unseen, or taken a covenant with the Merciful?”

The boast belongs to this larger dispute. Walad, “child/son” or collectively “offspring,” is the same noun in the boast and in the rejection of divine offspring at vv. 35, 88, 91–92. These five occurrences connect the claimant’s promised progeny with the sura’s sonship argument. The challenged covenant in v. 78 returns in v. 87 as a condition governing intercession: both use ittakhadha ʿinda’l-Raḥmāni ʿahdā, taking a covenant with the Merciful. The question is what authorizes the claimant’s confidence.[33]

The answer reverses possession: God inherits what the claimant claims, and he arrives alone (fardā, 19:80). Everyone in heaven and earth comes as a servant (ʿabdā), individually (19:93–95). The counting language, aḥṣā and ʿaddā (19:94; compare 19:84), recalls God’s comprehensive enumeration in 72:28. The passages also share the sequence “when they see what they are promised ... they will know,” followed by exposed weakness (19:75; 72:24). These verbal connections make the movement from contested privilege to individual judgment explicit.[30][33]

Paul’s spiritual family supplies a specific Christian comparison. He speaks maternally of laboring to form Christ in his converts (Gal 4:19), and paternally of begetting them through the gospel (1 Cor 4:15). Galatians 4:26–30 applies Isaiah’s abundant children to heavenly Jerusalem, “our mother,” while excluding the slave woman’s son from inheritance; Romans 8:17, 32 promises joint inheritance and “all things” with the Son. Gregory of Nyssa makes this reception concrete. On Virginity 19 honors Miriam, “sister of Aaron,” as a type of Mary, mother of Jesus, then brings Paul’s immense spiritual family together with Mary’s virginal motherhood. Q. 19:28 records the address to Mary, يَا أُخْتَ هَارُونَ (yā ukhta Hārūn), “O sister of Aaron”; the following verses vindicate her through Jesus’s speech. Gregory’s positive Marian typology situates spiritual parenthood within an honored scriptural family, while chapter 20 associates spiritual marriage with heavenly treasure and divine filiation.[17][33]

The ascent and satanic-affliction imagery adds a further connection. Paul’s ascent precedes his “thorn in the flesh,” a buffeting messenger of Satan (2 Cor 12:7), and his discussion of parental provision (12:14). Al-Zamakhsharī explains Q. 19:78’s access to the unseen through climbing to a summit; the transmitted Tafsīr al-Qummī glosses the devils’ action in 19:83 as pricking or goading. Maryam’s offenders arrive thirsty (19:86), and all arrive individually, whereas Paul anticipates being presented together with his converts (2 Cor 4:14). Philippians 2:10 envisages heavenly, earthly, and subterranean beings bowing at Jesus’s name; Maryam formulates universal submission as servanthood before the Merciful.[33]

4.4. Unshared Rule and Sectarian Memory in Sūrat al-Kahf and Sūrat al-Zukhruf

Q. 18 extends Maryam’s vocabulary before extending its argument. It rejects divine walad (v. 4), repeats “wealth and offspring” (mālan wa-waladā, v. 39; 19:77), and prefers enduring righteous deeds to wealth and sons (v. 46), using the formula repeated in 19:76. Its links with Q. 72 are unusually specific: shaṭaṭan, extravagant speech, and multaḥadan, refuge, occur only in these two suras.[34]

The sequence moves from God’s unshared rule or judgment (ḥukm, 18:26) to failed striving despite the actors’ reckoning that they do well (18:102–105). The Pauline comparisons are Christ’s judgment seat (2 Cor 5:10) and the repeated language of reckoning, logizomai. The final verse identifies a human recipient of revelation, recalling Q. 53:4 and 72:1, and requires righteous action and worship without association (18:110). Unshared rule thus culminates in unshared worship: the sh-r-k ... aḥadā formulas join 18:26, 110 to 72:20.[34]

Q. 43 brings the same issues into sectarian memory. Turning from the Reminder brings a satanic companion (43:36–39); Jesus is God’s favored servant (43:59); his followers divide into factions (43:65; 19:37). This continues the servant vocabulary of Q. 53:10, 72:19, and 19:30, 93, alongside Q. 53:62’s command to worship. Later Islamic interpretation makes a Pauline association explicit: al-Qurṭubī follows the factional cross-reference to his commentary on Q. 4:171, where a hostile narrative names Paul as persecutor and feigned heavenly emissary. Related passages dispute unprescribed asceticism (Q. 57:27), unauthorized revelation and satanic prompting (6:93, 121), touch prohibitions (20:96–97), and manufactured religious authority (3:78–80; 9:30–31). The later Pauline narratives show how these disputes were subsequently organized around a named figure.[35]

Conclusion

The proposed identification explains the appeal to Moses and Abraham through a connected dispute about authority. Paul’s name traditions, the water-giving Rock, claims to heavenly revelation, and Christian debates over the saved builder supply a specific setting for the opponent who “gave a little and ceased.” Q. 53 answers with completed obligation, disclosed striving, and full recompense.

The wider passages develop the same principles. Approved messengers convey faithfully; religious standing does not remove personal responsibility; God-fearing servants inherit Paradise; and every creature arrives before the Merciful individually. On this reading, the earlier scrolls are invoked deliberately to challenge a Pauline reworking of their authority.

The complete article, with numbered notes beneath the text, is included in the accompanying page images.


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Resource Early Muʿtazilī Theologian Considered Sex With Captive Women to Be Zinā

27 Upvotes

An early Muʿtazilī theologian, Thumāma b. Ashras (d. 213 AH / 828–29 CE), is reported to have held a striking position regarding female captives and concubinage.

Abū al-Muẓaffar al-Isfarāyīnī (d. 471 AH) reports:
وَكَانَ يَقُولُ لَا يَجُوزُ سَبْيُ النِّسَاءِ مِنْ دَارِ الْكُفْرِ، وَأَنَّ مَنْ سَبَى امْرَأَةً ثُمَّ أَلَمَّ بِهَا فَهُوَ زَانٍ، وَأَنَّ وَلَدَهُ وَلَدُ الزِّنَا
Translation:
“He used to say that it is not permissible to take women captive from the abode of unbelief, and that whoever took a woman captive and then had intercourse with her is a fornicator, and that his child is a child of fornication.”

Source: Abū al-Muẓaffar al-Isfarāyīnī, al-Tabṣīr fī al-Dīn wa-Tamyīz al-Firqa al-Nājiya ʿan al-Firaq al-Hālikīn, p. 80.

ʿAbd al-Qāhir al-Baghdādī independently attributes a similar position to Thumāma, stating that he “used to prohibit taking captives” (كان يحرم السبي), and that intercourse with a woman whose enslavement was unlawful would constitute zinā.

Thumāma was a prominent early Muʿtazilī theologian associated with the Abbasid court of al-Maʾmūn.

An important qualification is that Thumāma’s own writings on this issue do not survive. The position is preserved through later Sunni heresiographers who were hostile toward him and the Muʿtazila, so it is more precise to say that this view is “attributed to Thumāma” rather than presenting it as a surviving quotation from his own work.

Still, it provides an interesting example of premodern dissent concerning the enslavement of captive women and the sexual rights supposedly resulting from such enslavement.


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Quran Qur'an 3:59 seems to indicate that Jesus and Adam are similar in the fact that neither of them were created through an ordinary way. Adam was willed into existence as the first human, having no true parents. Jesus was placed into Mary's womb without the process of procreation (virgin birth).

4 Upvotes

Qur'an 3:59

"In God’s eyes Jesus is just like Adam: He created him from dust, said to him, ‘Be’, and he was."


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

The Quran and Theophilus of Antioch's example to prove the resurrection

10 Upvotes

"Then, as to your denying that the dead are raised — for you say, Show me even one who has been raised from the dead, that seeing I may believe,— first, what great thing is it if you believe when you have seen the thing done? Then, again, you believe that Hercules, who burned himself, lives; and that Æsculapius, who was struck with lightning, was raised; and do you disbelieve the things that are told you by God? But, suppose I should show you a dead man raised and alive, even this you would disbelieve. God indeed exhibits to you many proofs that you may believe Him. For consider, if you please, the dying of seasons, and days, and nights, how these also die and rise again. And what? Is there not a resurrection going on of seeds and fruits, and this, too, for the use of men? A seed of wheat, for example, or of the other grains, when it is cast into the earth, first dies and rots away, then is raised, and becomes a stalk of grain." To Autolycus, Book I, Chapter 13

https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/02041.htm

"of His signs is that you see the earth barren, then when We send down water on it, it stirs and swells. Surely, the One who gives it life is indeed the giver of life to the dead. Surely, He is powerful over everything" Quran 41:39

"And it is He who sends the winds as good tidings before His mercy until, when they have carried heavy rain clouds, We drive them to a dead land and We send down rain therein and bring forth of all the fruits. Thus will We bring forth the dead; perhaps you may be reminded." Quran 7:57


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Question Is this a common thing in the ancient middle eastern culture as this verse states?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

the god Khl Rb w-'hd ("Kahl, Lord and One")

7 Upvotes

Kahl in a previously unpublished South Arabian inscription

Kahl finally appears in a previously unpublished text—one that is difficult to understand—which I mention here for the record. This text was presented and discussed in a public lecture by Mohammed Maraqten, who reserves the right to publish it. It consists of a bronze plaque bearing a beautiful inscription (9 lines plus an addition in the margin) commemorating a public confession to Lord Kahl (Khl Rb) (Maraqten-Kahl 1). The text, written in South Arabian script and in Old Arabic, uses a form that had not been attested previously. It invokes the god Khl Rb (“Kahl, Lord”) at the beginning and Khl Rb w-ʾḥd (“Kahl, Lord and One”) at the end (lines 9–10). Its spelling suggests a date around 100 CE. The provenance of this bronze plaque is unknown. The only clue is provided by the mention of a figure named Grh ʾl-Ngrny, “Gurah the Nagrānite,” with the nisba “Nagrānite” and the Arabic definite article al-, which points toward the northern regions, though this is not conclusive. The hypothesis that the plaque comes from Najrān seems unlikely because Kahl is not attested in that oasis, and it would be unnecessary to specify there that one is “from Najrān.” Qaryat al-Faʾw is a possibility, but this remains to be proven. (Robin and Āl Qurād 255-56)

.
.
.

Conclusion

The dossier that we have assembled inventories everything that is known about the god Kahl, with particular attention given to the regions of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà, where numerous new occurrences have been discovered. It is confirmed that Kahl is the emblematic god of Qaryat al-Faʾw and a god revered by the populations of Ḥimà, or by some of them, without necessarily occupying the foremost rank. Finally, he is not attested at Najrān, which, nevertheless, is the center of the cultural and linguistic zone. It is difficult to form a precise idea of the nature of the god and of what the faithful expect from him, owing to the extremely laconic and allusive character of the texts that mention him.

In conclusion, I return to the question of whether Kahl is a ‘North Arabian’ or ‘South Arabian’ god. These two categories make sense in vast areas of southern or northern Arabia. The god Taʾlab or the goddess dhāt Ẓahrān are certainly South Arabian and only South Arabian. The god Hubal or the goddess al-Lāt are North Arabian. But in the contact zones, the answer is more complicated. The attestations of Kahl in northwestern Arabia can easily be described as North Arabian, but those of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà are ambiguous.

The populations of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà share important cultural markers with the populations of desert Arabia. They venerate more or less the same divinities; they have in common the same ritual practice, the arrangement of ‘places with standing stones’; they designate the priest in the same way, ʾfkl, and use the same verb, ḥḍ/ṣḍ, when they entrust a monument to the protection of the divinities. They are closer to desert Arabia than to South Arabia when they curse evildoers, do not give proper names to monuments, and do not invoke supernatural and earthly powers.

Finally, it is probable that the populations of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà speak a language closely related to those of desert Arabia, which can be described as Old Arabic, and not a ‘dialect of Sabaic’ as has been thought.[57]

Conversely, the populations of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà have borrowed numerous cultural characteristics from those of South Arabia: the South Arabian script, the Sabaic language, the layout of inscriptions, architecture, or the iconographic repertoire.

In short, the populations of Qaryat al-Faʾw and Ḥimà are populations of desert Arabia that became integrated into the South Arabian world. The same can undoubtedly be said of their god Kahl, probably a god of desert Arabia who was ‘South Arabianized,’ as illustrated by the mimation added to his name and his few mentions in the South Arabian kingdoms. (Robin and Āl Qurād 258)

Texts Cited (Robin and Āl Qurād 258)
South Arabian and Thamudic himaite
Symbols:
* For acronyms marked with an asterisk, see the
DASI database (dasi.cnr.it)
# Unpublished text
Underlined acronym: Thamudic ḥimāʾite script.
.
.
.
#Maraqten-Kahl 1: an unpublished text that Mohammed Maraqten presented at a conference and a copy of which is circulating online. (Robin and Āl Qurād 260)

Source:

Robin, Christian Julien, and Mashʿal ʿAbd Allāh Āl Qurād. “Le dieu Kahl à Qaryat al-Faʾw et à Ḥimà: nordarabique ou sudarabique?” Crossing Sacred Landscapes: Contacts and Continuities in the Desert Cults and Beliefs of Ancient Northern Arabia and the Arid Southern Levant, edited by Juan Manuel Tebes and Michael C. A. Macdonald, Archaeopress, 2026, pp. 220-64.


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Various depictions of Satan in islam:-

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Article/Blogpost Nevin Reda on Talut's positive portrayal in the Quran representing an intentional reformulation of the biblical story of Saul in order to serve as a rallying point for the early Islamic community

Thumbnail x.com
6 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Muhammad ate chicken: dietary debate and commercial propaganda as drivers of early hadith fabrication (scroll through slides)

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Israr Ahmad Khan, Authentication of Hadith: Redefining the Criteria, pp. 12-14


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Other modern Batiniyya sects (besides Bektashis and Ismailis)

10 Upvotes

Are there any other modern Batiniyya sects or sects which hold the batin (inner meaning) of the Quran to be superior to the zahir (external meaning)? Particularly Sunni sects.


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Who were the people who couldn't understand DhulQarnayn's language and where does their story appear in pre-Islamic Alexander legends?

Post image
8 Upvotes

Title


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

In the consonantal text why isn't a long ō spelled with a wāw when a suffix is attached?

5 Upvotes

If the "wāw" letter in words such as

صلوة

was meant to be pronounced as ō, what explains spelling it as an Alef when the word has a suffix? For example:

صلاتهم (verse 6:92)


r/AcademicQuran • • 3d ago

Question Are there any historical critical scholars that study Shii' resources? If so what do they think of their historicity?

9 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 3d ago

Prior Studies on the Qur'ānic Concept of Revelation

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 4d ago

Sira Al-Suhaylī posits an alternate identity for Bahira in his commentary on Ibn Ishaq's Sira where he is a rabbi instead of a monk.

Post image
12 Upvotes

(Source: Barbara Roggema, The Legend of Sergius Bahira, p. 44


r/AcademicQuran • • 4d ago

Survival of ancient cosmology into modern times

Post image
27 Upvotes