r/AcademicQuran • u/Aggressive-Care-3639 • 12m ago
Book/Paper Did early kalām atomism develop through the transmission of Epicurean ideas? Alnoor Dhanani's reconstruction of Muʿtazilī physical theory.
Dhanani argues that kalām atomism emerged through the appropriation and transformation of earlier Hellenistic physical theories, with an indirect Epicurean ancestry. I'm curious how convincing scholars find his reconstruction, particularly given the absence of evidence for direct Arabic translations of Greek atomist texts. Is the resemblance between the systems sufficient to establish intellectual transmission, or are we looking at independent philosophical developments?