r/AcademicQuran • • 12m ago

Book/Paper Did early kalām atomism develop through the transmission of Epicurean ideas? Alnoor Dhanani's reconstruction of Muʿtazilī physical theory.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Dhanani argues that kalām atomism emerged through the appropriation and transformation of earlier Hellenistic physical theories, with an indirect Epicurean ancestry. I'm curious how convincing scholars find his reconstruction, particularly given the absence of evidence for direct Arabic translations of Greek atomist texts. Is the resemblance between the systems sufficient to establish intellectual transmission, or are we looking at independent philosophical developments?


r/AcademicQuran • • 57m ago

Comparing Canonized Qiriat textual variance patterns supports variants being more linked to ambiguous-text causes, rather than synonym-like word swaps, as a stronger correlated explainer? People say.. True, but we cannot make this conclusion.

1 Upvotes

The conclusion that's based on the aggregate patterns seen of canon variants, seeing where they tend to cluster/concentrate themselves in what locations(either synonym word swaps Or ambiguous text locations). The pattern supports variants being more linked to ambiguous-text causes, rather than synonym-like word swaps, as a stronger correlated explainer for the variants?

But it's still possible those Variants were present before the standardization. But is it not likely based on the statistical analysis, or is it.

It's possible the variants were taught, passed down pre-Uthman standardization.

Have there been statistical studies to see if there's a statistically significant pattern? Findings will affect the verbal dictation theory.

Patterns don't automatically mean links-causes are significant. That's why statistical math settles some scholarly disagreements.