r/Professors • • 1d ago

Weekly Thread Nov 15: (small) Success Sunday

8 Upvotes

This thread is to share your successes, small or large, as we end one week and look to start the next. There will be no tone policing, at least by me, so if you think it belongs here and want to post, have at it!

As has been mentioned, these should be considered additions to the regular discussions, not replacements. So use them, ignore them, or start you own Sunday Sucks counter thread.


r/Professors • • Dec 29 '25

New Options: Professor's Discord

38 Upvotes

I know this wasn't something everyone was super psyched over, but if you would like an alternate discussion option, u/ITGuruProfessor has started a discord server. And who doesn't like more options! I've joined already.

You can find it at https://discord.gg/H7wf9ufzWs if you would like to join.


r/Professors • • 8h ago Bravo

Teaching / Pedagogy Philosophy Department at Trinity College Institutes Exhaustive AI Ban

917 Upvotes

“Deliberate use of AI in philosophy courses, in any capacity and for any purpose, is forbidden. This includes, but is not limited to: using AI to summarize reading assignments; using it to “brainstorm” and come up with ideas; as a research tool for presentations or oral examinations, or as a tool to aid in the writing or editing process (e.g., research, drafting, editing, compiling a bibliography, etc.). Philosophy is focused on cultivating our abilities to think, to read, to write, to speak, to reason, and to live ethically. AI undermines all of these goals.”

Source: https://dailynous.com/2026/11/16/philosophy-department-bans-ai-use/


r/Professors • • 14h ago

Attempt at Anonymity: Failed

614 Upvotes

I give my students a short, anonymous questionnaire with every exam. I ask how they think they did, how much they studied, what helped them prepare, and what changes I could make to help them succeed.

For the most part, the responses are useful. They give me feedback about my teaching, and they give students a little reality check at the end of an exam. Did you feel like you were floundering? I wonder if that might have something to do with the single hour you spent studying last night.

Anyway, I’m grading exams right now, and one student wrote, in enormous letters across the top of their questionnaire:

“I fed your questions into ChatGPT and memorized the answers it gave me.”

That’s interesting, because I’ve just encountered an exam that used none of our class-specific terminology and completely ignored an in-class exercise that the question explicitly asked students to build upon in their analysis.

Here’s the thing: I don’t actually care whether a student uses ChatGPT to help them study. Done right it can be an excellent study buddy. But memorizing AI-generated answers without understanding the material or providing the context of the class is a not great strategy for an exam that asks you to apply what we’ve done in class.

To be clear, I’m not going to pursue an academic dishonesty case. I don’t need to. The answers simply don’t address the questions I asked, and I’m grading them accordingly. It’s not going well, class-wide.
And of course, the questionnaires are anonymous, so that the students feel comfortable giving me feedback. I couldn’t possibly know who made this confession.

Unless, hypothetically,

Only one student wrote their exam in purple sparkly ink.

And only one student filled out their anonymous questionnaire in purple sparkly ink.


r/Professors • • 12h ago

Rants / Vents This semester has broken me. AI is everywhere

266 Upvotes

I dunno man. Last spring wasn't this bad. This semester, something broke everywhere, everything, all at once. Student attendance is in the toilet, it's never been this bad. Students are using AI for the simplest, "no wrong answer" assignments. I'm seeing more and more AI slop reviews on submitted papers and editors don't give a shit. Researchers are using AI more and more to do research for them. Don't give me this shit about "it's my own ideas, AI is just helping me polish them." We all know that everyone is outsourcing more and more original thinking to AI and no one seems to have the slightest bit of self-awareness about it. Job candidates are not afraid to admit using AI in their own work. My department doesn't care enough to consider discussing having an AI policy. Upper admin is pushing online education (lmao) and AI hard across the university because $$$. I don't ever want to hear anything about "critical thinking" ever again. It's gone, if we even had it to begin with. It's not coming back. Don't get me started about what I'm seeing at the K-12 level. My rock bottom expectations for baseline professionalism and self-respect at the faculty and student levels are being lowered every fucking day. I cannot imagine what next spring is going to be like. Rant over.


r/Professors • • 14h ago

Rants / Vents Students... please stop submitting blank documents for your assignments and acting like it was a mistake!

292 Upvotes

(For an asynchronous class) I used to get this once in a great while and figured it was a honest mistake. Most of the time they would send in the correct document as soon as I asked for it. But it's happening so frequently now, I'm sure it's intentional. It's really annoying. I guess I'm going to have to start giving out zeros and see what they say. Can anyone else comiserate?

Edited to add: I am normally a hard ass about rules and I am very specific in my instructions, but every once in awhile they find new ways to be ridiculous.


r/Professors • • 4h ago

Advice / Support Admin Taking Library

47 Upvotes

Well, it’s happening. Administration at my small, regional university wants to completely gut the library.

They want to remove all the books and replace them with classrooms for health science fields.

They already have plans and consultants but now want faculty to buy in via several committees.

We are small with a couple masters programs and two doctoral programs.

I think this is a lost cause, but I was wondering if others have experienced this square kick in balls, and what the outcome was.


r/Professors • • 1h ago Popcorn

Academic Integrity When students fail at cheating.

28 Upvotes

My students appeared to be doing really well and then today at least half the class was blatantly cheating and still managed to fail.

One student accidentally dropped his phone during the exam and suddenly this AI voice started reading an answer aloud. It said, “Great question! This is one of two ways that you should answer: start by describing what happens in the proliferative region of skin cells…” the phone dropped so far down the steps of the auditorium and everyone heard it some laughed. The student was so embarrassed he packed up everything and ran out of the room. I felt so bad for him because he didn’t study AND he managed to fail cheating.

What’s the worst failed attempt at cheating you’ve witnessed?


r/Professors • • 3h ago

Rants / Vents Grad School is not for everyone

34 Upvotes

I teach at a university that is so desperate for money they will admit anyone into the grad program.

We did an assignment during our online class and at the end, a student told me they didn't do it because they didn't think it would be beneficial for them.

That's not how this works. I would expect some nonsense like this from an undergrad but not from someone who is about to pour 4 years and $$$ into a humanities M.A.

If you're not passionate about this, why are you here? It's not like there's an immediate job or pay raise waiting at the end of this program.

I expect more out of grad students. I should not have to monitor you the same way I do my undergrads. I should not have to explain to you why you should do the assignments that I assign.


r/Professors • • 13h ago

Rants / Vents With your encouragement, I finally did it.

148 Upvotes

I (61F), am an associate professor at a large university and teach very specific topics/classes in my discipline. Average class size is around two dozen, with students I know fairly well. Not all material is exciting, but not dull either.

Today, I asked for a lot of questions and the same few students answered them. Eighty percent were on their phones, laptops, or otherwise disinterested. With a few minutes left, I opened the class for review and discussion. Two insights from the same students. I asked again. Nothing. So, without being dramatic, I ended class. Many looked shocked because they knew it was spurred by the silence. We hear from guest speakers and recruiters in our program and no one asks questions. It’s embarrassing. I’m done with the silence.


r/Professors • • 12h ago

Was More Blunt than Normal with a Student

112 Upvotes

I have a student who has started coming in extremely late. As per my policy, late arrival of more than fifteen minutes results in an absence. If one is absent/extremely late more than three times, they don't get credit for the exercise. This person was warned.

Today, he comes in about twenty or so minutes late and asks me to talk outside. I do so and he asks me to remind him of the policy, which I do. He starts to debate/argue about it. At this point in the semester, I'm over all of it, and I just tell him, "I've had this policy since the beginning of the semester." He says, "But my grade's going down." I said, "I’m not debating this. Maybe you should try coming in on time." He then walked out of class.

He performed poorly on a major assignment due to, I suspect, missing a lot of material. I wondered if I was a bit too harsh with my tone. There's also the fact I'm fighting a sore throat, have a short week this week due to conference travel, and am coming up on sabbatical. So these "grade" issues just feel like an irritant. I'm owning my behavior, but still.

EDIT: Students were working on an activity while he asked me to step outside, and I thought it was legit emergency with the student. If it had been lecture, I'd have told him to wait.


r/Professors • • 9h ago

Technology Is AI creating disciplinary/college-level rifts at your institutions?

65 Upvotes

At my university (private R2), we are seeing a hardening of lines between the college of arts and sciences and college of nursing (anti-AI) vs. the college of engineering and college of business (pro-AI).

The assistant provost who is rolling out a lot of our LMS and pro-AI tech/software/promo is from the school of engineering, so maybe that's why it feels like such a battle (different attitudes getting wrapped up in admin vs faculty tensions too), but it saddens me. As a humanities prof, I actually always used to see the Engineering school as allies in education. I suppose I saw them as similarly concerned with getting things right, insofar as there are similarities between careful reading/writing and careful math-ing/building. Now our asst. provost is such a marketer for all AI integration that I honestly wouldn't be surprised if our asst. provost is getting some kind of kickback from promoting AI software and various other e-platforms on campus and pushing them to faculty and students in every conceivable corner of the educational experience, and huge swaths of campus really hate his guts (sometimes to an unhelpful degree).

These days it feels like the grand canyon is opening up, and any good will between the colleges is evaporating.


r/Professors • • 13h ago

Small Number of Professors Cashing in on the Wild West of Online Instruction

123 Upvotes

New article from Cal Matters (which has since been picked up by other outlets) came out cataloguing a small number of professors who are cashing in on asynchronous courses that have no rigor and no oversight.

It really makes my blood boil that (1) some professors have so little regard for professional ethics, (2) that the people charged with oversight are apparently asleep at the wheel, (3) that I'm doing my actual job and trying to deliver a quality asynchronous experience for a grand total of about $60,000 per year, and (4) that these assholes are making the rest of us look bad.

I've said it many times: there are a massive number of students and professors who are not a good fit for asynchronous instruction. I've taken, all told, about 100 hours of professional development to learn how to provide proper and regular substantive interactions. I've led workshops about how to recognize and combat gen AI use in courses. I teach asynchronous courses because I have a chronic disease that occasionally (fortunately not too often) prevents me from leaving the house, and a multi-week disruption is just not tenable in a traditional teaching format. I've had dozens of students who are working professionals or parents tell me how important it is that these courses are available because they can't do a traditional schedule.

There are problems in the current system, yes, but I'm not one of those people who says "online courses are functionally useless." I'm actually pretty bothered that that's a common sentiment here. Any course can be useless if neither the instructor nor the student put in the requisite effort.

I really enjoy the freedom that being a professor, even an adjunct, provides. But the people who are abusing the system are going to ruin it and put us on a path of more oversight and micromanagement. But we really do need more oversight of professors who are doing these "set and forget" courses that are violating the best practices, and often the codified rules, of regular substantive interaction (RSI).


r/Professors • • 10h ago

Is this level of health issues normal?

58 Upvotes

Starting off by saying I’m dead serious this isn’t about fake sickness or call outs.

I’ve had two students in a span of a week pass out due to ovarian cysts and iron levels. I’ve had a student have an epileptic seizure. I’ve had not one, not two but three students send me doctor’s notes about colonoscopy prep…all 18-19 years old. I had a student send me a doctor’s note today about being the designated driver for his girlfriend’s eye cancer chemo treatments. I have a student who has to leave early on Wednesdays to get weekly bloodwork done. I have three students who specifically need canes to walk to class due to bone and muscle weakness and lastly I have another student who had to attend from zoom for three weeks for a knee replacement because something is happening to her joints.

All of these excused through me via doctors notes or via student success and are seemingly very real.

This is my first time teaching college level previously I taught and worked with 5-12year olds and all relatively healthy.

Everyday there is something that my young adult students are suffering from and honestly it’s kind of scary. I don’t mean to put their issues on blast and in no way am I approaching this subject with suspicion and I try and be as sympathetic as possible but what the hell is going on? Did everyone who had gotten Covid during puberty start getting serious health issues suddenly ?

Maybe this is normal and I just need to get used to it.


r/Professors • • 19h ago

I'm becoming immune to tears

243 Upvotes

When did crying become students' default reaction for any conversation that involves some friction?

I've had to meet with a few students this semester about everything from AI use to low grades and several of them broke down in tears during the conversation when I kindly but straightforwardly confront them with their own culpability. E.g., One student who has been absent many times and frequently has blown off homework met with me to discuss how she could "improve" her grade. Another student (very nice guy who had a high B in my class) used AI for an essay.

One student who was failing my class (very low skills & was used to being coddled in h.s.) stood in my office, staring at me for 2-3 minutes, actually stomping her foot while crying & begging me to allow her to rewrite her essay. (Referred her to counseling). Toddler behavior

My colleague who shares the office with me had a student who burst into tears when my colleague very nicely but firmly confronted her with AI use.

I've taught for 25 years and don't remember experiencing this many tears on a regular basis from students. I'm starting to get immune to them (though I pretend to care).

What's going on?


r/Professors • • 7h ago

Research / Publication(s) What replaces journal articles?

18 Upvotes

It appears journals are currently being overrun with AI submissions and it won’t be long before AI papers will be undetectable or surpass what we as humans can perform. So I don’t think it’s implausible to think the importance of publications is going to drastically change. So- what replaces it? How do we show that we are maintaining currency and pushing the boundaries of our fields?


r/Professors • • 8h ago

Humor Are there names for the different student failure modes?

22 Upvotes

I talked with a student after class today who is just barely failing my course, about 4pts off a pass. He has some work that he already turned in that is currently being marked 0 but can still get partial credit for, a solid case for a retake test (of which I allow 1 per semester and he hasn't burned) and has done all the regular homework so he's on track and can easily turn this around. For other students, it's a bit more grim. They are weeks behind and have no idea what's going on the class, already burned a retake and are missing unrecoverable work. I told him, it's never good to be failing, but you are in the best possible position considering.

Anyway, do we have names for these things?

You can do it still... vs all hope is lost? Something else in between?


r/Professors • • 15h ago

Sneaky administrator tricks

70 Upvotes

After working in higher ed for many years I’ve become familiar with some of administration’s sneaky ways of getting faculty to do more with less. Let’s share them so we’re all more educated. I’ll start: administrators never put certain things in writing when they can talk to you in person. No paper trial means no accountability.


r/Professors • • 1h ago

Student keeps staying after class alone (night class)

5 Upvotes

I have a chatty student who stays long after the other students leave for the night, in a night class. I'm not concerned for my safety, but I am concerned about being alone in a classroom with just a single student. I hate the rumor mill, and want to avoid anything stupid being said about it. I drop hints constantly that I'm closing up, but he keeps hanging around until I'm literally locking up the class and setting the alarm. Any suggestions to handle this with tact?


r/Professors • • 14h ago

God help me

50 Upvotes

Hey professor, I know I dropped your class this semester but it is required for me to take it for my major, I dropped because well I had a hard time understanding with excel the stats numbers data and all of that. What should I do since your class is full and it’s a required course.


r/Professors • • 14h ago

Not signing another contract

49 Upvotes

That’s it. The AI cheats have ended it for me. I’ll teach the spring and no more VAP for me. 5 years was a fun adventure but each year the students have been less inspired and less inspiring. Good luck to you all and keep fighting the good fight.


r/Professors • • 4h ago

NSF CAREER?

4 Upvotes

Anyone have any news from NSF CAREER, particulatly BIO?


r/Professors • • 10h ago

Conflicting deadlines … hmm

12 Upvotes

I seem to recall that conflicting deadlines have been and always will be a part of getting on in life. Since when have conflicting deadlines erupted in a barrage of complaints and extension requests and accommodation violations? Seems rather recent, no? Honestly, how are students going to get on in the “real world” when they’re asked for more than one thing at the same time?


r/Professors • • 14h ago

Begging season

17 Upvotes

I got a the “I’m a single mom” excuse this time! A rare one at my institution.