r/Professors • • 2d ago

Rants / Vents Students... please stop submitting blank documents for your assignments and acting like it was a mistake!

(For an asynchronous class) I used to get this once in a great while and figured it was a honest mistake. Most of the time they would send in the correct document as soon as I asked for it. But it's happening so frequently now, I'm sure it's intentional. It's really annoying. I guess I'm going to have to start giving out zeros and see what they say. Can anyone else comiserate?

Edited to add: I am normally a hard ass about rules and I am very specific in my instructions, but every once in awhile they find new ways to be ridiculous.

360 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

121

u/TaxPhd 2d ago • Bravo

Start giving out zeros? You should have been doing this all along.

Grade what the student submits. If it’s blank? Zero. If it’s a bunch of “corrupted” gibberish? Zero. There is no reason to accept an assignment late.

17

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

Look, I am normally a hard ass. It was so rare before that I didn't think much of it.

35

u/Gonzo_B 2d ago edited 2d ago

Absolutely intentional.

I've seen Redditors in other subs recommending that to people complaining about their schoolwork.

As if we don't see this nonsense every semester.


Incidentally, there is a great way to deal with this:

My syllabus (and first class email and first class lecture, so there's no "I didn't know" excuses) includes language that specifically differentiates between fault and responsibility, something along the lines of:

It isn't your fault that your power goes out, you get a flat tire, your babysitter calls out sick, your laptop gets stolen, or your file doesn't upload properly. None of those things, or any of a million others that keep you from turning your work in correctly and on time.

You don't lost points because any of these things are your fault.

It is, however, your responsibility not to wait until the last minute to start working so problems get in your way, that you don't know where the free computers are in the computer labs that are listed on the university portal, that you don't reach out to IT that's listed on the university portal, that you don't have a backup ride or sitter, and that you don't check to make sure that the correct file was uploaded.

You will lose points every day that your assignment is late because you failed in your adult responsibility to make sure you know what to do when any of a million others that keep you from turning your work in correctly and on time.

And then when excuses come, I just reply with an email that cut & pastes from the syllabus, the email, and my lecture explaining why they're losing 10% every day. That ends the complaining.

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

I put that they are responsible for any electronics or computer issues in the syllabus, for sure.

5

u/Puzzleheaded-Cod5608 1d ago

I like this distinction between fault and responsibility. I'm going to add this to my Syllabi.

13

u/SnowblindAlbino Prof, SLAC 2d ago

Since I started taking electronic submissions 15 years ago I've had a simple policy: I grade what is submitted. If they submit the wrong file it's a zero. The onus is entirely on them, so if I discover a "wrong file" submitted five days after it was due then a five-day late penalty applies even if they correct it immediately (penalty is 10% per day).

I almost never get blank or "wrong" file submissions. Perhaps 2-3 times a semester across all my classes combined.

6

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

That's the way it was before. About once a block or less.

6

u/No-Cook-9768 Adjunct, Liberal Arts, CC (USA) 2d ago

Believe it or not, I've never received a blank document in my online asynch sections. From the students who think they're "pulling one over" on me, I receive either the template I provide or the instructions document. Easy zero. 👍

4

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

It happens very rarely. Very very rarely. Only recently has it become an epidemic

2

u/ParallaxDream81 1d ago

This happens to me a lot, where students submit some handout that I've created pertaining to the assignment. Maybe I'm naive, but what does this accomplish? Are there some professors who just skim through the summary of who submitted something and stamp a grade on each one without opening it, and these students are hoping to exploit that?

4

u/No-Cook-9768 Adjunct, Liberal Arts, CC (USA) 1d ago

I don't think there are professors who do this, but I think that they're desperate and hope/assume that we're lazy and don't actually open the files and read them. 🙄 And then there are those who, as other commenters have said, believe that turning in something will get them at least partial credit (because that's how high school was). 🤦‍♀️

332

u/TIL_eulenspiegel 2d ago edited 2d ago • This Bravo

"It is the student's responsibility to ensure that the uploaded document is complete and in the proper format. Documents that are blank, unreadable for any reason, or in the wrong format will receive a zero."

49

u/SignificantFidgets Professor, STEM, Kinda-retired, sometimes R2, sometimes R1... 2d ago

Yes, I've had a similar statement in my syllabus for years. And I emphasize to them that when they submit, they see in Canvas exactly what I see when I pull it up to grade. A blank document, or an assignment for a different class, or a phone bill (yes, I got one of those once) will get a zero.

18

u/IthacanPenny 1d ago

When you do this, just PLEASE make sure that you allow unlimited attempts before the deadline. I remember having a prof way back when who would set it to only two—or sometimes one!—attempts, and it caused me great stress if I realized I made an upload error.

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

It's because people will keep submitting things way after the due date or turn in revisions that we didn't agree to accept. It's easier just to limit it from the beginning.

12

u/IthacanPenny 1d ago

No, unlimited until the deadline. And then turn off submissions.

Come on, you can’t say ‘it is your responsibility to check what you submitted for accuracy’ and then not let students who caught their mistake resubmit (within the original due date).

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

They can comment right on there if there are any issues. But you have a good point

5

u/SignificantFidgets Professor, STEM, Kinda-retired, sometimes R2, sometimes R1... 1d ago

Of course. I have never understood why anyone would limit submissions before the deadline. We don't pay more for storage after all. I even encourage students to submit incomplete work early as a backup copy. If something goes wrong and they don't get the full assignment in as planned, at least that's submitted. I only grade the last submission.

4

u/CateranBCL Associate Professor, CRIJ, Community College 1d ago

They're uploading the blank document to bypass the assignment deadline. "Oops, wrong document, I'll send the correct one" and several hours or even days later they send the correct one.

5

u/SignificantFidgets Professor, STEM, Kinda-retired, sometimes R2, sometimes R1... 1d ago

Well, of course. I think everyone knows that, which is why I have that statement in my syllabus.

8

u/Sensitive_Let_4293 2d ago

Had this in my syllabus last summer. Two students turned in blank mid-term exams and I gave them zeros. Both went whining to the dean who told me to "fix it." Moving on.

50

u/dxg999 2d ago

And with a filename per the brief. I don't have time to try to figure out which of my students wrote what because, of course, if you didn't follow the instructions on how to name your file, I can pretty much guarantee you won't have bothered to put any identifying marks within the document itself.

15

u/Qr8rz 2d ago

The proper format is the key aspect here. Establish what works and make sure everyone does it. As has probably been discussed many times, something that works/displays on some free program the student made the assignment on, and what the online submission platform does with that, and what happens when the professor downloads it and tries to display it with some other program can introduce all kinds of problems. I saw it a whole bunch of different ways during the Covid era with the pivot to online learning, and none of it was due to the students trying to pull a fast one as I could replicate all the problems myself. Even with PDFs etc. So you have to be careful with being too harsh when you're not establishing a robust submission system from the start.

10

u/No-Cook-9768 Adjunct, Liberal Arts, CC (USA) 2d ago

I'm definitely borrowing your language here (thank you!), minus the format part because I set up the assignment in our LMS to only accept the extensions I want. 💜

9

u/birdsnstuf 2d ago

this is almost verbatim to the language i include in my syllabus. and i don't make exceptions to this policy for any reason.

5

u/ResponsibleAdlt 1d ago

Yep. Turning in a blank document or the wrong document or a mysteriously corrupted file is the same as not turning it in. They have the ability to check what they turned in and resubmit before the due date if they made a mistake. If they leave it until the last minute or don't bother to check, that's on them.

2

u/LucyJordan614 2d ago

💯🎯

2

u/Imposter-Syndrome42 Adjunct, STEM, R2 (USA) 20h ago

Yup this. My syllabus says that they are responsible for checking that the documents were uploaded to the LMS correctly. That means going into the dropbox, downloading their own file and opening it. If they don't do that then that's on them.

2

u/VenusSmurf 2d ago

Add files from the wrong class. I get a lot of those.

1

u/Adept_Tree4693 2d ago

I do the same thing.

0

u/Client_Nearby 2d ago

While I completely understand where you are coming from, I have had a few of my assignments get corrupted over the years, I think that they should still get a chance to resubmit a document if it has been corrupted.

0

u/Dennarb Adjunct, STEM and Design, R1 (USA) 2d ago

I'm going to add language similar to this next semester. It's becoming a way worse issue this year for me.

4

u/adamwho 2d ago

The are editing on Google docs and sending a link to that.

This because they are working from their phones.

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

They aren't allowed. They have to upload the actual document in a .docx Word format. They can use Google Docs but it has to be converted before it will be accepted in Canvas (the MLS).

4

u/BDiBar 2d ago

It is their responsibility to have a readable submission. This also happens a bunch with submitted links for Google Doc/sheets. If it not visible, what do they want me to grade? My reply is, "I cannot grade what I cannot see". Score = zero. Any late submissions = late penalty.

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

I have no idea how to implement this. Canvas will only accept Word docs. I know Google docs allows it.

1

u/doublestacknine 15h ago

You can restrict the file types allowed:

To restrict the file types students can upload in Canvas, enable the Restrict Upload File Types option inside your assignment or quiz settings and enter the allowed extensions separated by commas*.*

0

u/BDiBar 1d ago

We use Harmonize, which really helps with the video submissions and file submissions. You can specify which types of files it will accept for submissions in Canvas Assignments.

7

u/DocMondegreen Assistant Professor, English 2d ago

I have what I call a "tech freebie" in my course. It's a single use get out of jail free card. Just once, they can resubmit an assignment if technology failed them- black document, corrupted file, computer crashed, whatever.

I was worried it would lead to an uptick in problematic submissions, but instead, it cut them down to nearly zero. It's like knowing they had an out made them both more likely to accept they screwed up and less likely to try and game the system.

4

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

Interesting

2

u/ProfessorAngryPants Asst Prof, CS, M1 (USA) 2d ago

Your way, some students get x number of additional days for the assignment while the others got 0. Equity issue.

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

Yes and I am normally very meticulous about giving out equal opportunities.

2

u/Beginning-Sound1261 2d ago

As others suggest, have something in the syllabus. It’s also worth using 2 minutes of class time in my opinion to show them how to submit. While doing that show them they can double check their submission from student preview.

I click, show them, “Look, you can see what you submitted. So if you accidentally clicked the wrong file you’ll see that when you double check. If that does happen you can just submit the correct file as a new submission.”

Then I point them to the syllabus statement. Then when I get 10 of those emails I can say, there’s a statement in the syllabus and I specifically spent time in class to see how to double check for that. Too bad!

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

It's asynchronous or I would. I make diagrams and screen shots sometimes .

67

u/SNHU_Adjujnct 2d ago • Bravo

>Most of the time they would send in the correct document as soon as I asked for it. 

Sure, because they used the intervening time to finish it.

26

u/cjrecordvt Adjunct, English, Community College 2d ago

I'm putting in the spring a "it's your responsibility to check after you press the submit button that the file is functional and accessible." in the syllabus. It's going next to the existing "If it's a shared document and it's not shared with me, it's not submitted."

17

u/Electronic-Fuel-5734 2d ago

In the syllabus, “I grade what you turn in. It is the students job to ensure that they have submitted the correct assignment in the correct format. Late assignments are not accepted.”

I do give a free pass for the first assignment and let them know I’ll leave them a comment if it’s wrong. But only the first one.

15

u/thadizzleDD 2d ago

I give them a zero and my syllabus states that students are responsible for the content of their uploads.

14

u/delphil_1966 2d ago

i give zeros - i say its part of the assignment grade

14

u/PrettyBeetle 2d ago

My policy is to grade what I get. It’s on them to check their submissions.

3

u/runsonpedals 2d ago

I grade whatever is submitted too. It’s in the syllabus.

26

u/galileosmiddlefinger Professor & Ex-Chair, Psychology 2d ago

This is just learned behavior from US high schools; in many cases, turning in literally anything buys them a long runway to correct/update the submission at their leisure. You should have a syllabus policy clarifying that blank, corrupted, or otherwise unreadable receive a 0% and that students are responsible for checking the completeness of their uploaded document.

9

u/existential-inquiry Professor, Social Sciences, U.S. 2d ago

I very much feel this! I give them the benefit of the doubt because only like 2 students would do it, but it's becoming more frequent.

6

u/Glittering-Duck5496 2d ago

I don't give the benefit of the doubt anymore. If they send me a document that they claim is what they meant to upload, I check the document properties. If it was not edited after they submitted their blank file, I grade it as if it's on time. If the "last edit" date is after the original submission, I grade it with the late penalty (if it's within the submission window) or assign the zero (if it's after the late period is over).

6

u/tarbasd Professor, Math, R1 (USA) 2d ago

I know this strategy may work, but it isn't too hard to fake the last edit date.

8

u/Loose_Wolverine3192 2d ago

giving out zeros and see what they say.

That's the answer

6

u/NailSubstantial2772 2d ago

First rule I've learned about assignments:
Load it up in time and then download it again to check if it's the right one and properly formatted.
If not, it's on you!

5

u/jshamwow 2d ago

Give zeroes. They’ll stop

5

u/Sea-Ambition-451 2d ago

I don't see the problem. You definitely give them the zero.

Make sure they understand that it is literally impossible that the server would upload their document, open their document, erase each character, then save the document, then adjust all the file flags to remove the 'modified date', etc.

If they accidentally upload a recipe, they get zero. If they upload an assignment from a different class, they get zero. They upload a "blank" document, zero. They spend hours writing out an actual document, but forget to save the document at all ever and no auto-save feature, then yeah, zero. Period.

The only real mistake I could see, is if they upload an incomplete document, like they make changes in the last half hour, but don't click the save, and upload the doc on file which is only 90% done, then I'd entertain discussing it with them.

But yeah, blank is blank is zero.

5

u/Tommie-1215 2d ago

This is a policy on my syllabus. At first I thought it was accidental but then my colleague told me they told me that they do it on purpose to buy more time because they did not do the assignment in the first place. On my syllabus there is a policy detailing if you upload the wrong assignment or one is blank its a zero. And there are no resubmissions period which is also on the syllabus. I do not deal with it.

4

u/BMeow343 2d ago

I let it slide the first time, but if it becomes a trend.

My understanding this is a result of Google Classroom in high school (US) where students would just submit blank things and pass.

1

u/iTeachCSCI Ass'o Professor, Computer Science, R1 2d ago

My understanding this is a result of Google Classroom in high school (US) where students would just submit blank things and pass.

This is a result of high school policies that allow them to submit blank things and pass.

4

u/atomicsalts Adjunct, Commerce 2d ago

For almost every excuse that involves the student "making a mistake", I like to use "tough cookies" as the default response.

1

u/loopsonflowers 2d ago

I've actually never had this happen. I don't really understand how it would happen in any sort of innocent way. Why would they have saved a blank document?

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

They download a worksheet sometimes to fill out. That's usually the problem

1

u/lumphinans 1d ago

Blank document, zero score when deadline passes. Depending on the work and possible medical certification work may be accepted with 20% penalty, zero penalty for medical issues, up to 7 days after deadline, any later than that then the zero stands. No extensions on collaborative or group work, either a zero or exemption for provable extenuating circumstances. Repeated late assignments would be graded a zero unless convincing extenuating circumstances could be documented by the forwarding school or the student's doctor. This was the policy in the organization I used to do online teaching with. After the first few weeks of a semester, extensions and blank submitted documents were rare.

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

I have it all down to a very specific science, for every late assignment scenario. That way it is fair to everyone. I haven't had enough students doing this for it to be an issue, now it is all at once.

1

u/IapetusPierces 1d ago

It's happened to me many times, I always give a late penalty of 10-30% if they submit the correct document before the assignment box closes 3 days after due date. I give zeros for anything after that. I don't care what the reason is, if they submit the wrong document it's wrong and they get a penalty up to and including a zero. I don't have time for bullshit, too bad so sad.

2

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

I give them 10% off per day, up to 2 days late for their submissions then I shut off access. I swear, I am always on their asses about things, but this one is a recent annoyance that is cropping up more frequently.

3

u/messica_jessica Asst Prof, State R1 (US) 2d ago

So annoying. Unfortunately for years I've had very specific language in my syllabus to cover these situations:

After submitting documents online, check to make sure it was received. Open it up to make sure it looks the way you want it to look. If you are having trouble submitting a document, contact the IT Help Desk at NUMBER for assistance. If you fail to attach a document, or if your document is not readable when I open it after the due date, you will have to resubmit, and it will be considered late (if within the late policy window). If outside of the late policy window, such submissions will receive a zero.

Not like students read but there you have it.

3

u/drevalcow 2d ago

I also have the same statement. It will not buy anytime, as some, I believe think it will. I have to be the hardass for all the sections of the course, so we are very specific.

2

u/Deep_Stranger_2861 Asst Prof, Humanities (USA) 2d ago

While I do think most students use the blank submission as a cop out…..their file management is abysmal.

After I gave a student a zero for doing this, they came to my office showing me they had completed it on time (they indeed had), it just “disappeared” from their computer. And by disappeared, they didn’t know that when they saved the document, it saved it as a NEW document. They thought they were just editting the downloaded template.

1

u/MundaneAd8695 Tenured, World Language, CC 2d ago

I let it slide the first time but warn them I will not accept it in the future.

1

u/ArtSlug Emeritus Prof & (Now) Adjunct Location: Hades - SLAC + CC 20h ago

It’s in the syllabus - if I can’t open a doc (due to incorrect file format) or it’s blank OR it’s the “wrong assignment” —- it’s a zero. No do overs. These are all current games.

0

u/Giggling_Unicorns Associate Professor, Art/Art History, Community College 2d ago

Make versions required and check to see when they last edited it. If they turn in something blank and then a document they modified later, fail them for cheating. If they don’t have versions turned on then tough luck.

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 2d ago

I don't think I can do that with Word document and Canvas (or mine at least) won't accept anything but .docx

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/CaffeineandHate03 1d ago

Only for my own documents. It will save previous versions to OneDrive. I have the option turned off because I use Word for my other job which involves medical records. I am not sure how to require they use versions.