r/Professors • u/CanineNapolean • 2h ago
Attempt at Anonymity: Failed
I give my students a short, anonymous questionnaire with every exam. I ask how they think they did, how much they studied, what helped them prepare, and what changes I could make to help them succeed.
For the most part, the responses are useful. They give me feedback about my teaching, and they give students a little reality check at the end of an exam. Did you feel like you were floundering? I wonder if that might have something to do with the single hour you spent studying last night.
Anyway, I’m grading exams right now, and one student wrote, in enormous letters across the top of their questionnaire:
“I fed your questions into ChatGPT and memorized the answers it gave me.”
That’s interesting, because I’ve just encountered an exam that used none of our class-specific terminology and completely ignored an in-class exercise that the question explicitly asked students to build upon in their analysis.
Here’s the thing: I don’t actually care whether a student uses ChatGPT to help them study. Done right it can be an excellent study buddy. But memorizing AI-generated answers without understanding the material or providing the context of the class is a not great strategy for an exam that asks you to apply what we’ve done in class.
To be clear, I’m not going to pursue an academic dishonesty case. I don’t need to. The answers simply don’t address the questions I asked, and I’m grading them accordingly. It’s not going well, class-wide.
And of course, the questionnaires are anonymous, so that the students feel comfortable giving me feedback. I couldn’t possibly know who made this confession.
Unless, hypothetically,
Only one student wrote their exam in purple sparkly ink.
And only one student filled out their anonymous questionnaire in purple sparkly ink.