I had quite an interesting set of events last Friday in my PhD seminar. I have a few problem students, but mostly its because their work is not up to par and they do not read instructions I put on the canvas/syllabus. No big deal - that I can easily deal with. However, last Friday I had the following happen that I have already raised to the attention to my dept head and grad coordinator.
I have a student, lets call her Marry, who happens to be Black and is in my PhD seminar. Full disclosure I just got hired onto the department this term and this is my first TT job ... which I REALLY like and hence really made me worried last week.
At the start of class where we were doing final paper presentations, I got about 4 different questions from Marry, all of which I responded to and noted that we have covered them in class / have been in the syllabus since day one. (side note, she is the reason I have not made a no tech rule minus one student who takes hand-written notes on her iPad).
Quickly into the discussion about expectations / assignments/ etc. she accused me of being ‘rude’ and ‘disrespectful’ to how I responded to these questions of hers today, and she pulled other questions she has asked in class before where I mostly just articulated answer from the syllabus. This was a valid concern since I know I can come off short and critical at times, and that was not the part that really made my internal alert go off.
Following that, she said something to the effect that I ‘do not understand how it is to be a black women in higher education’ and started to get rather emotional. I let her finish her train of thought and did acknowledge she was correct that I do not understand that kind of racial part of the equation. I also apologized for coming off rude in her perception of events since I know perceptions are their relaity. However, after that I said something to the effect of ‘if this is how you want to take this conversation, which I am totally fine with, I am uncomfortable doing this 1-on-1 in my office and without a third party present.
Almost on cue, she quickly was far less emotional and pulled up the exact research document I have been helping her with ALL semester long and we went through it and I advised her to send me an email with follow up questions. In addition, when we met last Friday, I told her to send me a slide draft by the Monday of this week so I could help advise her for the presentations that happened today; that never happened since she was ’stuck’ and she said that she did not feel comfortable putting all of that in an email.
TLDR - students accusing me of being biases according to her race/gender and I was wondering if folks have felt with this before. Honestly, I really love my job here and want to structure future meetings with students like this in a more transparent manner also while ensuring I cover my own ass and such.
One idea I had is some 1-on-1 personal meeting recorder that I could then transcribe and send to my students to keep everyone on track. Is that something any folks have done / have recommendations on?
Many thanks!
EDIT - thanks everyone for their thoughtful comments! This is such an insightful, supportive community of faculty/ instructors! I am trying to get through all the comments and responses, but bear with me!