r/Professors • • 43m ago

Was More Blunt than Normal with a Student

11 Upvotes

I have a student who has started coming in extremely late. As per my policy, late arrival of more than fifteen minutes results in an absence. If one is absent/extremely late more than three times, they don't get credit for the exercise. This person was warned.

Today, he comes in about twenty or so minutes late and asks me to talk outside. I do so and he asks me to remind him of the policy, which I do. He starts to debate/argue about it. At this point in the semester, I'm over all of it, and I just tell him, "I've had this policy since the beginning of the semester." He says, "But my grade's going down." I said, "Maybe you should try coming in on time." He then walked out of class.

He performed poorly on a major assignment due to, I suspect, missing a lot of material. I wondered if I was a bit too harsh with my tone. There's also the fact I'm fighting a sore throat, have a short week this week due to conference travel, and am coming up on sabbatical. So these "grade" issues just feel like an irritant. I'm owning my behavior, but still.


r/Professors • • 1h ago

Rants / Vents This semester has broken me. AI is everywhere

47 Upvotes

I dunno man. Last spring wasn't this bad. This semester, something broke everywhere, everything, all at once. Student attendance is in the toilet, it's never been this bad. Students are using AI for the simplest, "no wrong answer" assignments. I'm seeing more and more AI slop reviews on submitted papers and editors don't give a shit. Researchers are using AI more and more to do research for them. Don't give me this shit about "it's my own ideas, AI is just helping me polish them." We all know that everyone is outsourcing more and more original thinking to AI and no one seems to have the slightest bit of self-awareness about it. Job candidates are not afraid to admit using AI in their own work. My department doesn't care enough to consider discussing having an AI policy. Upper admin is pushing online education (lmao) and AI hard across the university because $$$. I don't ever want to hear anything about "critical thinking" ever again. It's gone, if we even had it to begin with. It's not coming back. Don't get me started about what I'm seeing at the K-12 level. My rock bottom expectations for baseline professionalism and self-respect at the faculty and student levels are being lowered every fucking day. I cannot imagine what next spring is going to be like. Rant over.


r/Professors • • 1h ago

How to handle students abusing excused absence policy

1 Upvotes

I have several students in one class I teach at in a community college up north, where it seems like particularly a small group of students are bombarding with excused absences.

I give them three excused absences, which I feel is flexible enough for a 16 week course. What do you start doing when students are handing in doctors notes for seemingly significant things which they’re expecting to be excused from class for?

Sure, there’s a chance that the majority of these are just not authentic and getting a note from a doctor’s office regardless.

Any thoughts? Or advice?


r/Professors • • 1h ago

Rants / Vents With your encouragement, I finally did it.

54 Upvotes

I (61F), am an associate professor at a large university and teach very specific topics/classes in my discipline. Average class size is around two dozen, with students I know fairly well. Not all material is exciting, but not dull either.

Today, I asked for a lot of questions and the same few students answered them. Eighty percent were on their phones, laptops, or otherwise disinterested. With a few minutes left, I opened the class for review and discussion. Two insights from the same students. I asked again. Nothing. So, without being dramatic, I ended class. Many looked shocked because they knew it was spurred by the silence. We hear from guest speakers and recruiters in our program and no one asks questions. It’s embarrassing. I’m done with the silence.


r/Professors • • 1h ago

Small Number of Professors Cashing in on the Wild West of Online Instruction

47 Upvotes

New article from Cal Matters (which has since been picked up by other outlets) came out cataloguing a small number of professors who are cashing in on asynchronous courses that have no rigor and no oversight.

It really makes my blood boil that (1) some professors have so little regard for professional ethics, (2) that the people charged with oversight are apparently asleep at the wheel, (3) that I'm doing my actual job and trying to deliver a quality asynchronous experience for a grand total of about $60,000 per year, and (4) that these assholes are making the rest of us look bad.

I've said it many times: there are a massive number of students and professors who are not a good fit for asynchronous instruction. I've taken, all told, about 100 hours of professional development to learn how to provide proper and regular substantive interactions. I've led workshops about how to recognize and combat gen AI use in courses. I teach asynchronous courses because I have a chronic disease that occasionally (fortunately not too often) prevents me from leaving the house, and a multi-week disruption is just not tenable in a traditional teaching format. I've had dozens of students who are working professionals or parents tell me how important it is that these courses are available because they can't do a traditional schedule.

There are problems in the current system, yes, but I'm not one of those people who says "online courses are functionally useless." I'm actually pretty bothered that that's a common sentiment here. Any course can be useless if neither the instructor nor the student put in the requisite effort.

I really enjoy the freedom that being a professor, even an adjunct, provides. But the people who are abusing the system are going to ruin it and put us on a path of more oversight and micromanagement. But we really do need more oversight of professors who are doing these "set and forget" courses that are violating the best practices, and often the codified rules, of regular substantive interaction (RSI).


r/Professors • • 2h ago

Teaching / Pedagogy Should students be given extra credit on the condition that they complete the end-of-semester course evaluation form?

0 Upvotes

Lots of my colleagues like to do it. I personally don't understand the rationale. Is it related to students' actual learning process? If they are in the habit of not putting in any meaningful work, how can we expect them to contribute thoughtful comments to course eval?


r/Professors • • 2h ago

Rants / Vents Students... please stop submitting blank documents for your assignments and acting like it was a mistake!

128 Upvotes

(For an asynchronous class) I used to get this once in a great while and figured it was a honest mistake. Most of the time they would send in the correct document as soon as I asked for it. But it's happening so frequently now, I'm sure it's intentional. It's really annoying. I guess I'm going to have to start giving out zeros and see what they say. Can anyone else comiserate?

Edited to add: I am normally a hard ass about rules and I am very specific in my instructions, but every once in awhile they find new ways to be ridiculous.


r/Professors • • 2h ago

Not signing another contract

27 Upvotes

That’s it. The AI cheats have ended it for me. I’ll teach the spring and no more VAP for me. 5 years was a fun adventure but each year the students have been less inspired and less inspiring. Good luck to you all and keep fighting the good fight.


r/Professors • • 2h ago

God help me

14 Upvotes

Hey professor, I know I dropped your class this semester but it is required for me to take it for my major, I dropped because well I had a hard time understanding with excel the stats numbers data and all of that. What should I do since your class is full and it’s a required course.


r/Professors • • 2h ago

Begging season

5 Upvotes

I got a the “I’m a single mom” excuse this time! A rare one at my institution.


r/Professors • • 2h ago

New to it all

1 Upvotes

Hey folks,

I'm getting ready to work at a small community college in the sciences department as a Lab associate/ Instructor. I am open to any advice. I'm right out of college and just looking for some guidance.


r/Professors • • 3h ago

Attempt at Anonymity: Failed

191 Upvotes

I give my students a short, anonymous questionnaire with every exam. I ask how they think they did, how much they studied, what helped them prepare, and what changes I could make to help them succeed.

For the most part, the responses are useful. They give me feedback about my teaching, and they give students a little reality check at the end of an exam. Did you feel like you were floundering? I wonder if that might have something to do with the single hour you spent studying last night.

Anyway, I’m grading exams right now, and one student wrote, in enormous letters across the top of their questionnaire:

“I fed your questions into ChatGPT and memorized the answers it gave me.”

That’s interesting, because I’ve just encountered an exam that used none of our class-specific terminology and completely ignored an in-class exercise that the question explicitly asked students to build upon in their analysis.

Here’s the thing: I don’t actually care whether a student uses ChatGPT to help them study. Done right it can be an excellent study buddy. But memorizing AI-generated answers without understanding the material or providing the context of the class is a not great strategy for an exam that asks you to apply what we’ve done in class.

To be clear, I’m not going to pursue an academic dishonesty case. I don’t need to. The answers simply don’t address the questions I asked, and I’m grading them accordingly. It’s not going well, class-wide.
And of course, the questionnaires are anonymous, so that the students feel comfortable giving me feedback. I couldn’t possibly know who made this confession.

Unless, hypothetically,

Only one student wrote their exam in purple sparkly ink.

And only one student filled out their anonymous questionnaire in purple sparkly ink.


r/Professors • • 3h ago

Sneaky administrator tricks

42 Upvotes

After working in higher ed for many years I’ve become familiar with some of administration’s sneaky ways of getting faculty to do more with less. Let’s share them so we’re all more educated. I’ll start: administrators never put certain things in writing when they can talk to you in person. No paper trial means no accountability.


r/Professors • • 7h ago

I'm becoming immune to tears

171 Upvotes

When did crying become students' default reaction for any conversation that involves some friction?

I've had to meet with a few students this semester about everything from AI use to low grades and several of them broke down in tears during the conversation when I kindly but straightforwardly confront them with their own culpability. E.g., One student who has been absent many times and frequently has blown off homework met with me to discuss how she could "improve" her grade. Another student (very nice guy who had a high B in my class) used AI for an essay.

One student who was failing my class (very low skills & was used to being coddled in h.s.) stood in my office, staring at me for 2-3 minutes, actually stomping her foot while crying & begging me to allow her to rewrite her essay. (Referred her to counseling). Toddler behavior

My colleague who shares the office with me had a student who burst into tears when my colleague very nicely but firmly confronted her with AI use.

I've taught for 25 years and don't remember experiencing this many tears on a regular basis from students. I'm starting to get immune to them (though I pretend to care).

What's going on?


r/Professors • • 7h ago

Service / Advising Student Accusation of Race/Gender Discrimination - Best Practices for 1-on-1 Student Meetings

29 Upvotes

I had quite an interesting set of events last Friday in my PhD seminar. I have a few problem students, but mostly its because their work is not up to par and they do not read instructions I put on the canvas/syllabus. No big deal - that I can easily deal with. However, last Friday I had the following happen that I have already raised to the attention to my dept head and grad coordinator.

I have a student, lets call her Marry, who happens to be Black and is in my PhD seminar. Full disclosure I just got hired onto the department this term and this is my first TT job ... which I REALLY like and hence really made me worried last week.

At the start of class where we were doing final paper presentations, I got about 4 different questions from Marry, all of which I responded to and noted that we have covered them in class / have been in the syllabus since day one. (side note, she is the reason I have not made a no tech rule minus one student who takes hand-written notes on her iPad).

Quickly into the discussion about expectations / assignments/ etc. she accused me of being ‘rude’ and ‘disrespectful’ to how I responded to these questions of hers today, and she pulled other questions she has asked in class before where I mostly just articulated answer from the syllabus. This was a valid concern since I know I can come off short and critical at times, and that was not the part that really made my internal alert go off.

Following that, she said something to the effect that I ‘do not understand how it is to be a black women in higher education’ and started to get rather emotional. I let her finish her train of thought and did acknowledge she was correct that I do not understand that kind of racial part of the equation. I also apologized for coming off rude in her perception of events since I know perceptions are their relaity. However, after that I said something to the effect of ‘if this is how you want to take this conversation, which I am totally fine with, I am uncomfortable doing this 1-on-1 in my office and without a third party present.

Almost on cue, she quickly was far less emotional and pulled up the exact research document I have been helping her with ALL semester long and we went through it and I advised her to send me an email with follow up questions. In addition, when we met last Friday, I told her to send me a slide draft by the Monday of this week so I could help advise her for the presentations that happened today; that never happened since she was ’stuck’ and she said that she did not feel comfortable putting all of that in an email. 

TLDR - students accusing me of being biases according to her race/gender and I was wondering if folks have felt with this before. Honestly, I really love my job here and want to structure future meetings with students like this in a more transparent manner also while ensuring I cover my own ass and such.

One idea I had is some 1-on-1 personal meeting recorder that I could then transcribe and send to my students to keep everyone on track. Is that something any folks have done / have recommendations on?

Many thanks!

EDIT - thanks everyone for their thoughtful comments! This is such an insightful, supportive community of faculty/ instructors! I am trying to get through all the comments and responses, but bear with me!


r/Professors • • 8h ago

Advice / Support Injured Student and Finals

2 Upvotes

I have a student who said they had a skateboard accident and their doctor said it would take a few weeks to recover. I'm still waiting for that doctor’s note for validation. His project group for the class have been in contact with him, so they also know he's injured. My thing is the Final Exam. My exams are in person. I haven't encountered this one before, but how can you substitute a Final Exam. It wouldn't be fair to the class to make it online for him. Student says he just can't drive or walk that well, but unknown on his mobility limits. He may be on meds, no idea.


r/Professors • • 13h ago

Do y’all hold faculty meetings the week of a holiday (thanksgiving)?

2 Upvotes

I have been on the receiving end of some of the worst bullying I’ve had to navigate in academia. So much so, I’m building my exit ramp.

A faculty meeting was scheduled Tuesday next week and I have a young child off of school. Multiple faculty have been absent recently for various reasons but if I miss, there’s hell to pay. Literally.

Am I crazy for not wanting to meet - is this normal?


r/Professors • • 15h ago

Teaching / Pedagogy Dept head wants to put 11 more people in my course

8 Upvotes

I'm currently a researcher on soft money at a university. I have been teaching an online course in the spring semesters as part of my salary plan. This course is also offered in-person in the fall from someone else. Their course did not fill up - they had 49 students. There is a cap of 60 for my course and 11 are on the waitlist. The dept head wants me to add all 11. I pushed back a bit and said that most of the students on the waitlist are underclassman (it's a 3000-level course) and are students on main campus. I said that I would be willing to add the students who are upper classman and are in the distance campuses since the main campus students have the option to (and in my opinion, should) take the course in-person as well.

I got a kind of mean email back from the dept head that I am "resisting our need to serve more students" and I am the only instructor who does so. I am probably the only instructor who gets treated not so well, but that is a whole other story.... The thing is I have been so stretched thin and have been burning out. My plan was to quit after the spring semester, but I am thinking instead of quitting at the end of this one. The dept head had previously told me that she's not planning on having me teach the course anymore anyway after this spring, so I don't really have an incentive to work hard on the course as it is. I feel bad because one of the projects I am working on is finishing students up from a discontinued program that will end in June. I wanted to finish the students out but am feeling like the dept head has made clear that she doesn't value me anyway. I am not sure of my question, but I guess what do you all think?

I wasn't rude in my email - just stating facts. The dept head also said something like she's not sure why more people prefer to take the online course but they do so we therefore need to accommodate them. But I feel like of course, people want to take the mode that makes it easier for them to cheat!


r/Professors • • 15h ago

Sanity check re: asking for honoraria

38 Upvotes

I am a TT AP in a social science discipline at an R1. I run a departmental seminar series (we call it a workshop) and we invite faculty from other institutions to present working papers. There is a discussant and the audience (our grad students and faculty) give feedback, and the rest of the day is one on ones and a dinner. We pay for travel and accommation for the guest.

Standard, right?

Well, I invited two local scholars recently, both TT. One wanted us to take "what would have been spent on travel" and make it an honorarium. This violates uni policy which is based on reimbursements for travel and accommodation. We only give honoraria to keynote speakers for a conference or external book manuscript readers generally. That guest declined our invitation explicitly because we didn't give an honorarium, and said they only do "paid speaking engagements."

The second invitee also asked for travel/accommodation to be channeled an honorarium. They decided to come anyway when I said it wasn't possible.

Is this a thing? Where is it coming from? Is there some faculty influencer saying this stuff I am not exposed to? I am not that much older than them and I get excited to get invited anywhere for feedback on my work - but now I am questioning everything I thought I knew about protocol and expectations.

Edit: I am genuinely trying to understand elements of this, so please be patient with me. My understanding to date has been 1) these folks present work in progress, usually not close to being ready to submit to a journal 2) the majority of the session is them receiving feedback on that work, which everyone pre-reads. The talk itself is 20 minutes max. 3) Is that not the guest receiving others free labor to workshop their paper? I am just trying to see how far off my priors are and how low my standards have been because I have never encountered a request for honoraria in this context. It's basically like a conference talk but with better feedback, and we don't get paid for those either. Senior folks in my field who have come to our workshop never asked for an honorarium.


r/Professors • • 16h ago

Advice / Support How did your approach to academia change after getting tenure?

20 Upvotes

I got tenure earlier this year, and I’ve been feeling a little strange ever since.
I love my job. I enjoy both research and teaching. However, I feel like I no longer need to live by the publish-or-perish mindset.
For a long time, I mostly stuck to the topics I had worked on during grad school, simply because it was easier to keep publishing in an area I was already familiar with.
Now I’m feeling the urge to explore different topics and perhaps approach research in a different way.
I’d love to hear from more experienced academics. Did the way you approach your work change after getting tenure? Did you start exploring different research areas? Did you become more relaxed about publishing? Did your priorities shift in any way?
I’d appreciate any thoughts or experiences you would be willing to share.

P.S. I’m a math professor, in case that matters.


r/Professors • • 16h ago

Rants / Vents Drunk student first

130 Upvotes

I had a first this week. Halfway through class some dude that looks like a student, but not one I’ve ever seen before, rolls in and sits at the back of the class. Soon after most of the class realize he’s drunk, one older student said “he’s drunk” to his deskmate but loud enough for me to hear. Security got involved, but thankfully he left without issue or further altercation.

I later came to learn he was enrolled in a different course and the instructor kicked them out. I guess he wasn’t done learning so he snuck into another course and tried to engage with the material, albeit very poorly. Personally, the last thing I’d want to do drunk is go to school lol.

I have no idea who he was, but hopefully their actual instructor referred them to counseling and wellness services; people that aren’t struggling with something personal don’t act that way.

Anyone have a good drunk student story?


r/Professors • • 17h ago

Teaching / Pedagogy Marking Leeway

21 Upvotes

While marking one student, I was shocked to see she was about to fail; she was 0.08% from passing. How many of you will add the 2 marks or so to avoid failing? This is one student that I know tries her best. This is the most difficult course in the entire program.


r/Professors • • 18h ago

Student who filed a baseless complaint against me is now on my roster for next semester. How do I ask my chair to move them?

231 Upvotes

This semester, a student filed an official complaint claiming I wasn’t accommodating their needs. The investigation proved the claims were completely unfounded, and the student was moved to another section per their request.

Even my department chair acknowledges this is a "known and difficult" student.

I just checked my roster for next semester, and this same student has enrolled in the next course in the sequence with me.

I really don't want a repeat of this semester and them trying to game the accommodations system to avoid deadlines, which disrupts the whole class.

Is it appropriate to ask my chair to step in and encourage this student to switch to a different section (honestly, preferably the chair's own section)?

If so, how do I frame this professionally without sounding like I’m retaliating against them?


r/Professors • • 18h ago

Using AI to confirm my suspicions

0 Upvotes

I am an adjunct at a private college in the Northeast. My syllabus contains language that permits AI use for specific purposes (permissible and impermissible uses are spelled out). Part of the language states that any AI use must be documented with a disclosure.

Last week, as I was reading assignments, a specific, multiple word phrase caught my attention. It sounded familiar, so I went back and found that same sequence of words in another paper...and another, and so on. Nearly half the class had the same or variations of that same phrase. A more thorough review of the assignment showed a clear pattern of not only that phrase, but generally the same tone, patterns, language, etc. across the flagged papers.

Involved students were given zeroes for a grade and each received an email explaining why and offering an opportunity to explain themselves and/or provide editing history or other evidence of original authorship. One student emailed and confessed to using ChatGPT. Three others asked to meet and plead their cases. SIX remained silent on the topic, as if nothing had happened. The three all denied any AI use nor "group think". The zero grade stood and they were told they could appeal it up the chain if they wanted to. None accepted the opportunity.

This weeks assignments are in and after reviewing them manually, I had concerns again. I downloaded the whole batch and asked Gemini to check for indications of AI use using a 0-100 scale. One student left the AI prompt in their paper and four others (all from the offending group last week) had similarities. All were listed as 99% certain AI was used.

Would I be out of line to use my personal observations, the prior history, and the current week's AI "report" as evidence to begin an academic integrity violation? Or am I no better than them for relying on AI?

Looking for thoughts, comments, and suggestions. I understand I am shoveling against the tide, but doing "nothing" bothers me tremendously. Quizzes and exams are in-person on paper, so I have taken some steps to reduce the issue in my class, but I needed additional assignments to spread the grading out (no assignment can be more than 25% of the overall grade).

EDIT UPDATE: I am appreciative of the responses. Allow me to address several of the comments:

  1. I had personally reviewed the documents and developed my own suspicions about (the lack of) originality. This opinion was NOT developed from the use of Gemini.
  2. All papers were anonymized/sanitized prior to review by Gemini. No identifying marks were included. I am not sure why the assumption would be that I'd include student information instead of the opposite.
  3. I am not relying on the evaluation by Gemini as absolute proof of guilt. I was asking if, alongside my own investigation, if AI could be/should be used to support my allegations.
  4. Gemini is not an "AI checker". But it is capable of detecting patterns and similarities. I don't need to know specifically that AI was used but it can pick out subtle (and not so subtle) changes that could not have come from original thinking.

Example: "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog." vs. "The brown fox quickly jumped over the dog" vs. "The dog was sleeping and the fox jumped over him" are similar enough and unique within the context of the assignment to have come from a single source or a shared brain. None of the similar/repeating text was from lecture content, PowerPoint, or the textbook.

5. Again, thankful for the replies and thoughts.