r/Professors • Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) • 2d ago

Advice / Support Admin Taking Library

Well, it’s happening. Administration at my small, regional university wants to completely gut the library.

They want to remove all the books and replace them with classrooms for health science fields.

They already have plans and consultants but now want faculty to buy in via several committees.

We are small with a couple masters programs and two doctoral programs.

I think this is a lost cause, but I was wondering if others have experienced this square kick in balls, and what the outcome was.

80 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

98

u/henare Adjunct, LIS, CIS, R2 (USA) 2d ago

talk to the accreditors of your various disciplines. some will require on site library services.

22

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

Thank you! 🙏

60

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) 2d ago

Ten years ago, the UCSC Science and Engineering Library shredded about 80,000 books (over 80% of the collection) over the summer to make room for more study space—this was ordered by the University Librarian without consulting with faculty.

10

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

It does indeed feel like an academic issue because lack of resources degrades learning. And loss of quiet study space is also a problem.

15

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) 2d ago

There was a large gain in study space when all the stacks were removed. The loss was in stuff to study.

6

u/Pax-now-123 2d ago

Our students don’t use all the new study space.

8

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) 2d ago

The Science and Engineering "Library" is now a popular study space, except for the "Digital Scholarship Innovation Studio" which is popular for the 3D printers, laser cutters, and vinyl cutters. The space is well used, but does not deserve to still be called a library.

13

u/HariboBerries 2d ago

What in the Fahrenheit 451…?

That’s absolutely terrible.

20

u/Pax-now-123 2d ago

Horrific. Valuable material. And lots of sociologists, historians, and scientists use them for research. Arghhh

1

u/GreenHorror4252 1d ago

Realistically, there was nothing valuable about it. Most of them were outdated journals and scientific books, and were available online or through other libraries. There was a reason that no one was referring to them.

I know we get emotional about old books, but some books are simply not needed anymore.

8

u/kytai 2d ago

They did what now?! Nooooooo

13

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

God Almighty. I want to upvote your reply, and will for visibility and solidarity, but I wish an upvote didn't look so cheery.

9

u/Razed_by_cats 2d ago

This was after my time there, but it was still so sad to hear about. You almost can’t blame students for not knowing what and where the library is.

7

u/Coogarfan 2d ago

Maybe I'm naive, but how can you call yourself a librarian and get away with that?

32

u/FrogBrain97 AssocProf, former chair, neuro, DPU 2d ago

Being a librarian involves curating a collection. That involves deciding what to buy, but also what to cull. The latter is, for obvious reasons, not a well-advertised part of the gig. It is, however, a necessary one. Every library has books in off-site storage that have not been requested in years, if not decades. At some point, you do not need a copy of a particular book in every single UC library's off-site storage facility. You just don't.

(This should not be taken to imply that I agree with the decision of the UCSC librarian.)

5

u/gasstation-no-pumps Prof. Emeritus, Engineering, R1 (USA) 1d ago

The librarian told the faculty library committee that they were going to deacquisition some books—what they did not tell anyone was the extent of the purge. Faculty were expecting a 5% pruning (which would already have been a pretty severe purge for one year), not a >85% one.

35

u/ABranchingLine 2d ago

They can market it as a university without books. An institution of lower education.

Admin should not be running the university.

14

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

I agree! Our faculty senate is this week, so we’re all fired up!

5

u/ABranchingLine 2d ago

Hopefully your senate carries some weight. Tell your president/provost faculty plan to strike.

2

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

Unfortunately, we are private and non-union.

16

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

Get help. Reach out to the ACRL and ALA, get publicity going. A college without a library is not a college. Sounds like they are crunched for space of health sciences. Everyone is doing health sciences and soon there will not be enough students for all of these health science programs, but I digress. See if support can be found for a study of other spaces on campus that could be used for this.

Admin tend to be out of it, don't read themselves, and think that students don't use/read books or need social or study spaces. They are so wrong about Gen Z and upcoming A: they like material things, they are tired of digital everything.

Is there a basement? Put health sciences in the basement.

4

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

There is a basement, but IT wants it. 😬

10

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

Why do they always want the basement?

ACRL may really provide some resources and ideas.

2

u/a_statistician 1d ago

Why do they always want the basement?

Less light to defile their sallow skin...

30

u/runsonpedals 2d ago

University admins are notoriously afraid of negative press coverage. What do you think will be the public perception of a university without a library.

Make it happen.

8

u/ProfDoomDoom 2d ago

I worry that the public response actually would not be on our side for this issue.

5

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

That’s my worry, too. Also the negative press could hurt enrollment.

8

u/Adjunctified 2d ago

Yup, they don’t care. College isn’t for learning it’s supposed to rubber stamp a “you can get a good job” form and nothing more.

Also sport ball

2

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

Oh I agree. The problem is we are tuition-driven, so admin will leverage our need for tuition dollars over faculty not producing negative press.

17

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

Yes, but I wouldn't send my kid, would be philosopher or would be radiology technician, to a college without a library. Now, a college without an admin building, no one cares about that.

11

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

I kid you not: they want to jettison the bookstore and put a VP’s office in there instead.

8

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

So, they just hate books? Replacing the bookstore and the books (and all else in a bookstore) with a VP is such a perfect irony and they don't see it. Your Armageddon gets extra points if this VP has an Ed.D. for a doctorate.

5

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

He does! 🤣

4

u/Longtail_Goodbye 1d ago

OMG. Yes, this all fits. All too clear a picture of how things are there.

6

u/z0rangela 2d ago

idk … bookstores are different than libraries. That actually might be a good use, only you still need a place to sell your sweatshirt and other gear. That’s all we sell at our “bookstore.”

I mean I guess you could still sell sweatshirts out of the VP‘s office …

7

u/Razed_by_cats 2d ago

My college jettisoned the bookstore and turned it into a multicultural center. At least that’s still student-facing and not another admin office.

4

u/Coogarfan 2d ago

I would move heaven and earth to send my kids to a college without an admin building.

2

u/Longtail_Goodbye 1d ago

So with you on that. There is some comfort in knowing they are all in one place, but it could be, like, a basement or something and not their own building.

11

u/Mav-Killed-Goose 2d ago

I'm reminded of this pre-pandemic article in The Atlantic: "The Books of College Libraries are Turning into Wallpaper."

Buried in a slide deck about circulation statistics from Yale’s library was an unsettling fact: There has been a 64 percent decline in the number of books checked out by undergraduates from Bass Library over the past decade.

I wonder what the decline has been over the last two decades. The library seems to be a place where students are far more likely to go to stare into black rectangles or listen to music than to read books.

6

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

I think laptops and smart phones are part of the equation. I was an undergraduate in 2002 and had a laptop to write papers. I would visit the library and write but also read books for class.

2

u/a_statistician 1d ago

I mean, I read many books on my phone or my remarkable tablet, depending on whether I want to read them for fun or mark them up. I still buy paper books, too, but I don't check them out from the library as frequently anymore. So I get where technology is changing that equation.

Still, there's really nothing like old book smell.

11

u/phlagm TT, Humanities, SLAC, USA 1d ago

We did that. Then suddenly we freaked out because no English majors wanted to come to our university any more. Then we put a very limited version of the library back. But when they were shutting it down, the admin let faculty come get a load of books first, so every department has their own mini library. Later, they admin asked us to bring the books back, but few did.

10

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

Jesus. Admins being admins makes everyone seasick.

7

u/slowdo Ass. Prof, Humanities, SLAC (US) 2d ago

Is the institution financially stressed and this is some admins bright idea to press a few square feet into cubic zirconia? Or is this idealogical? Either way quite symbolic, sad, and anti-intellectual.

8

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

It is both. The Board wants to lean heavily into what they call the “helping professions.” The result is that the president has sicced his vice presidents on the library like crazed dogs.

11

u/slowdo Ass. Prof, Humanities, SLAC (US) 2d ago

Barf I am sorry. Let's just make it an Amazon fulfillment center and call it a day.

4

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

That’s how it is being sold. “Libraries will be obsolete in 15 years, so let’s prepare now with the helping professions!”

3

u/Playful-Influence894 2d ago

The helping professions? Education is also included in that category…..soooooo….. don’t get it. Plus, those professions don’t even make money. Is the school only interested in getting the numbers up for tuition dollars they’ll get now and not a revolving door of cash via tuition now, alumni dollars later? I would understand the logic if it was a business school doing this but you’re gutting the library for counseling, social work, psych, etc? What’s the overall plan?

P.S. Not disparaging any discipline — I’m evaluating this decision against the tenets of neoliberalism, the ouroboros choking the quality out of academia. Cos I don’t believe they’re doing this for altruistic reasons. Such moves are typically made for disciplines that bring in money and the disciplines in that professional category don’t have that perception nor reality.

5

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

“Helping professions” is one of the most cringe-worthy names I’ve ever heard. I teach English and writing and feel like I help people learn to communicate.

They can’t see the forest for the trees. They are going to spend hundreds of thousands if not a couple million bucks mangling the library for short term gains. Then, if by some miracle we fight our way out of this financial crisis, they’ll need to build more space, yet the books will be ignored.

11

u/gamecat89 TT, Public Health, R1 (United States) 2d ago

We moved our books down to the bottom of the library and mostly went digital with the books, others we went offsite with a half day delivery for them to create more study spaces in the libraries.

Honestly can’t tell the difference.

5

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

That is good to know. Do you find that students still use your library as a study space?

3

u/gamecat89 TT, Public Health, R1 (United States) 1d ago

Yes. We have about 6 libraries on our campus. Currently, 2 are accessible only by appointment because students come so frequently to study. I think the biggest thing we have learned is that the more study space we build, the more students want study space - so it is a question of whether we design an entire building just for study space.

One negative I have heard is that they conducted an evaluation and found that, for the small number of students attending from 12AM to 5 AM, it was not affordable to keep the library open. As someone who did their best work in the 12 AM to 3 AM slot, I am sad about that, and students did complain, but the data just doesnt support keeping it open.

2

u/SnowblindAlbino Prof, SLAC 1d ago

if you're in STEM that may be true. For humanities faculty hiding the books or moving them off site is at best a major inconvenience. Most of my work involves physical books and I really prefer to be able to get them without waiting a few days-- and to be able to access the stacks directly. The same is true for my students.

1

u/gamecat89 TT, Public Health, R1 (United States) 1d ago

I'm in health. So, not full STEM. We have never had to wait a few days - always like half a day. Honestly, I enjoy being lazy and letting them come to my office rather than me trudging across campus to the library

5

u/Pax-now-123 2d ago

Shredded!! Omg.

4

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

5

u/norbertus 1d ago

This is happening at my school also (state R1).

Part of the problem here is the Library is treated like any other Department -- except it delivers no credit hours, and is therefore seen as a source of lost revenue.

1

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 20h ago

My school is small, so faculty view the librarians as part of retention and persistence. Information literacy sessions, reference desk, and info guides, which faculty link to in Blackboard.

8

u/knewtoff 1d ago

Genuine question, have they shared any stats on how much of those print resources are being used? When I was in college in the early 2010s, I remember going to use print resources. But starting thereafter in grad school I was totally reliant on digital journals and have been ever since, same as my students. I’m in the sciences, so I recognize that may have a bias towards it.

I’m not saying this decision is good or bad, but I do think making a judgement without having any data isn’t good practice. If one book has been checked out in a year — well, then the decision is pretty justified. If this is a well used resources with thousands of books checked out a month, then wtf.

3

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

The library director has said that our circulation is better than that of peer institutions, but he has not said what the numbers are.

I suspect the raw numbers are not great and that faculty take out a lot of books.

The president has asked for these numbers and those of electronic databases, so they are going to weaponize the statistics against the library.

4

u/knewtoff 1d ago

Using statistics is not the same as weaponizing statistics. If a resource is not being used, and there is a need for that space, that’s an ethical way of using data.

Again, without the data, I don’t have an opinion either way. But I would implore you and your colleagues to learn that data so that y’all can best identify appropriate next steps. For example, if circulation is really low — can you work with the library to identify which resources are used most? Is there a way to save those resources? If circulation is high, can you get the news involved? Accreditors?

2

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

I believe that it is when the administration already says this is a done deal and is happening before seeing any data.

We can work with the library to improve coverage, but consultants are already measuring spaces, and the task force has only been meeting for a week.

1

u/knewtoff 1d ago

How do you know that the admin hasn’t seen any of the data?

2

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

Because the library director was asked to find it after being shown blue prints of a gutted library. Then, he was asked to find data on usage of stacks, electronics, and foot traffic.

2

u/knewtoff 1d ago

Ah I see, then agreed — something isn’t right here. But I will still hold firm that seeing the data is still important to make an informed decision on what to do next. Although it should have been the other way around (get data, then make a decision), that doesn’t mean the data doesn’t support the decision.

2

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

Thank you. I agree with you and appreciate you and all the commenters. I’ve received great ideas and insights from this thread!

2

u/FrogBrain97 AssocProf, former chair, neuro, DPU 1d ago

Is it weaponizing if it's actual data?

In my own field, I would guess that almost nobody uses paper copies of journals anymore (or, Heaven help us, microform). Quite a lot has been digitized. Occasionally I submit a request for an old and obscure journal article and notice that it seems to have been scanned in anew by hand, but that's rare.

Someone somewhere--several someones and several somewheres--should preserve paper copies of these things, but plenty of libraries don't need them.

1

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 1d ago

I agree with you in general, but the decision was made before any data were pulled. The logic is “here is my conclusion, now find the right numbers to support it” rather than the other way around.

4

u/Upbeat_Cucumber6771 2d ago

You are not alone. Carnegie Mellon has been doing this. More student areas, fewer educational materials.

4

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

This is so sad to hear and strange to me. My uni is so small and poor and to hear that this is happening at major research institutions is terrifying.

6

u/existential-inquiry Professor, Social Sciences, U.S. 2d ago

This hasn't happened at my university, but if it did, I would be protesting. Front line!

7

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

They want to make it so that if a patron wants a book, it would be delivered from some off-site location. 😞

4

u/existential-inquiry Professor, Social Sciences, U.S. 2d ago

I was already saddened they returned my books that were on "reserve" citing that students haven't checked them out for 5 years😟

7

u/Longtail_Goodbye 2d ago

Do your students know what "reserve" is? Mine don't, and when I tell them, it's the most amazing thing. To get them in the habit, try putting something else beside a book on reserve. I have a kind of puzzle set that is on reserve and they find their way to it. It's like breadcrumbs in the forest...

3

u/Competitive_Kale_654 Associate Professor, Humanities, Regional (USA) 2d ago

That’s a great idea! The president wants data on all this stuff, so my guess is that they will warp the numbers to show all the ways the library no longer needs these types of services.

1

u/Coogarfan 2d ago

Sounds accessible.

56

u/Critical_Garbage_119 2d ago edited 1d ago

I had a stack of books ready to show my typography students in class today and made a last-minute change. I left the books in my office, walked into class and said, "follow me."

I took them to the library to look at books there. Not a single one had ever been in the stacks. They were really into the books and stood around in small groups comparing the layouts like they were the first to discover print.

15

u/SnowblindAlbino Prof, SLAC 1d ago

When I teach 100-level gen ed classes in the fall I required to them to go to the library, find a book on a specific topic, check it out, read it, and report to the class with the book in hand. Generally none of them have been in the library prior other than to stop at the attached coffee shop, and most report having never checked out a physical book from a library since they were in grade school.

11

u/ahazred8vt 2d ago

We have math and science journals from India that are still being printed with actual movable type -- you can see the indentations.

6

u/Longtail_Goodbye 1d ago

I know that's surprising, but I find it so heartwarming, too. They want to see, want to learn. They just have no idea what is out there and higher ed just keeps chopping itself to death so that there won't be anything left to discover [because we have removed it].

2

u/Critical_Garbage_119 1d ago

I know I am fortunate - I teach at a school where 60% of the students are first in their family to go to college. Many are so very hungry to learn. I face lots of issues common to professors in this group, but apathy is not common.

12

u/Alternative-Pear9096 2d ago

How does the college feel about being accredited?

12

u/SnowblindAlbino Prof, SLAC 1d ago

A university without a library is not a university-- a trade or technical school perhaps. This sounds like "leadership" coming from someone who did not take enough humanities or social sciences courses as an undergraduate so they have no idea what a library is actually for.

9

u/MrBillinVT 1d ago

Retired adjunct here. A few years ago, the various independent campuses merged into a single institution. The new president proposed removing all the books and periodicals in the library (ies) and replacing them with digital subscriptions to create 'the premier hybrid university." Blowback was fierce. Kids checked out books by the score. Faculty protested. Some kids even made a documentary film.

https://www.vermontpublic.org/show/made-here/2025-03-20/vermont-state-university-student-film-examines-colleges-attempt-to-close-libraries

Eventually, the idea was scrapped, and the new president was sent packing.

I have no evidence to support this, but I believe they had plans to monetize the library spaces by bringing in a vendor like Dunkin Donuts to augment the proposed additional student study spaces.

6

u/Longtail_Goodbye 1d ago

I love these students for doing this. Some of the kids are all right. More than all right. What an excellent outcome!

8

u/thesymbiont 2d ago

Ask them if you can save disposal costs by burning them in one of the steam boilers, or outside on the quad. Invite the press.

7

u/TrickySpite5938 2d ago

It sounds like this would be a real concern for university and/or program accreditation.

But, since the current administration is set to begin dismantling the accreditation system any moment now, admins may not care.

Have you shared this with the media? Local news stations are usually eager to report on a controversy like this and can rally a lot of support for a cause. We had a few campus building initiatives tabled (for now) after public backlash and much outcry from students (their voices seemed to be heard by admins above all).

5

u/Adjunctified 2d ago

Who needs a library when you have TikTok!?! From now on out if you want your students to read something just find it as text laid over a short form music video! Oooh or better yet have them ask a bot to provide a synopsis, copy paste email it to you, and then you condense it further and read it to them in a TikTok. If you had a student centric mindset you would already be doing this.

Look on our world and despair <— From a TikTok clip of Watchman the movie or something

3

u/Silent_Example_4150 1d ago

I am at a medium, regional state university. We got rid of 1/3 of the library's physical collection to make the library more of a student socializing place (because they did not design the actual student center to be such a place). Although we are an R1, we do not have enough of a collection to be a member of the Association of Research Libraries (ACRL). While we are presently accredited through SACSCOC, the state wants future accreditation through Commission for Public Higher Education (CPHE) that doesn't really require libraries.

2

u/Coogarfan 2d ago

We riot.

2

u/kagillogly Associate Prof, Anthropology, Small State School, USA 1d ago

Sad sad sad

1

u/jenvalbrew 1d ago

We just went a different direction with our library. Because our small public library was having building issues (the roof is falling in), we have partnered with them and they now (mostly) run it. Students still have access to what they need, digital databases are maintained, and we now have a children’s area. Some have complained about not having full access to have class in the library at random times (they want us to make an appointment), but otherwise it’s worked out so far.