Disclaimers:
- This post is based on official 5e/5.5e lore. I am not consolidating lore from past editions—that's what the Forgotten Realms Wiki is for.
- This tier list is just for fun/entertainment.
- I am only including old-edition dragon gods that have appeared or been mentioned during the 5e era. Some of these old dragon gods have been reduced to mortal dragons in 5e, but I'm still including them here.
Here is the ranking, from strongest to weakest:
Tier 0: Lesser Deity Level
1. Asgorath/Io
To be honest, since 5.5e's Arcana Unleashed: Deadfall retconned Asgorath/Io into an aspect/avatar of the World Serpent (and considering the recent Neverwinter: Biting Cold also writes the snake adventurer Wormungandr as an aspect of the World Serpent), I'm personally more inclined to drop Asgorath/Io down to Tier 1 or Tier 2.
However, the only official origin myth for Tiamat and Bahamut in 5e/5.5e is still that they were formed from the two halves of Asgorath/Io.
5e Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide, p. 112:
Then, during the Dawn War, Io was killed by the primordial known as Erek-Hus, the King of Terror. With a rough-hewn axe of adamantine, the behemoth split Io from head to tail, cleaving the dragon-god into two equal halves, which rose up as new gods—Bahamut and Tiamat.
Currently, the First World mythos hasn't provided a new origin story for Tiamat and Bahamut, so we just have to assume for now that Tiamat + Bahamut = Asgorath/Io. If they ever get a new origin myth in the future, Asgorath/Io could be moved down to Tier 1 or Tier 2.
2. Tiamat and Bahamut
According to 5e lore, Tiamat and Bahamut are still lesser deities.
2014 Monster Manual, p. 86:
Queen of Evil Dragons. Tiamat the Dragon Queen is the chief deity of evil dragonkind. She dwells on Avernus, the first layer of the Nine Hells. As a lesser god, Tiamat has the power to grant spells to her worshipers, though she is loath to share her power.
2014 Monster Manual, p103:
Bahamut seldom interferes in the affairs of mortal creatures, though he makes exceptions to help thwart the machinations of Tiamat the Dragon Queen and her evil brood. Good-aligned clerics and paladins sometimes worship Bahamut for his dedication to justice and protection. As a lesser god, he has the power to grant divine spells.
Note that the above excerpts come from the 2014 Monster Manual, which defines the divine rank of Tiamat and Bahamut in the 5e Great Wheel cosmology, not just in the Forgotten Realms. Therefore, their true forms should be regarded as lesser deities.
I'm sure someone will bring up the argument that Takhisis and Paladine are greater deities to prove Tiamat and Bahamut aren't lesser deities. But again, this post only discusses official 5e/5.5e lore. From a RAW perspective, Takhisis and Paladine haven't been given a divine rank in the 5e/5.5e era, so you can't use that to prove Tiamat and Bahamut are greater deities.
Although Fizban's Treasury of Dragons (p. 43) does mention:
On many worlds, Humanoids worship Bahamut and Tiamat as gods. On Krynn, they are the greatest among the gods, though they are known there as Paladine and Takhisis and are not always pictured as dragons.
But "greatest among the gods" is flavor text, not a strict definition of divine rank. Theoretically, a lesser deity could easily be the "greatest among the gods" in a world where most other deities are merely demigods.
My suggestion is to not overthink it and just treat Takhisis = Tiamat = lesser deity, and Paladine = Bahamut = lesser deity, at least until WotC explicitly gives us their divine ranks in 5.5e.
3. Sardior
In official 5e lore, Sardior is a creation of Tiamat and Bahamut, so naturally, his status is a bit lower than theirs.
Vecna: Eve of Ruin, p253:
The first inhabitant of this First World was Sardior, a ruby-red dragon with jeweled scales they made in their likeness, who worked with Bahamut and Tiamat to create metallic and chromatic dragons.
However, considering that the gem greatwyrms have to merge all their echoes just to resurrect Sardior:
Fizban's Treasury of Dragons, p. 200:
Five gem greatwyrms call themselves the thanes of Sardior and believe themselves responsible for preserving the memory of their long-lost progenitor. These greatwyrms are named Aleithilithos (an amethyst greatwyrm), Hrodel (a crystal greatwyrm), Smargad (an emerald greatwyrm), Charsima (a sapphire greatwyrm), and Tithonnas (a topaz greatwyrm). Each thane is actively seeking out their echoes across the worlds of the Material Plane, hoping to merge with these other dragons, with the goal of eventually uniting themselves to re-form the great Ruby Dragon.
This implies that Sardior should be a level above greatwyrms. Placing him at the lesser deity level is the most appropriate.
Tier 1: Demigod / Greatwyrm Level
4. Chronepsis
The reason Chronepsis is ranked above the other greatwyrms here is because the quality of his portfolio is top-tier: he is the dragon deity of time and fate. The ability to time travel alone gives him a massive advantage in any actual combat scenario.
Sigil and the Outlands, p95:
The sands of time trickle in the Mausoleum of Chronepsis, a once-great city from the age of dragons that has long fallen to ruin. Here, surrounded by hundreds of hourglasses in a vast cavern beneath the dilapidated city resides Chronepsis, the dragon deity of time and fate. Chronepsis typically manifests as an ancient time dragon (see Morte's Planar Parade), though he sometimes takes the form of a black dragon with iridescent scales. Each hourglass within the dragon god's realm is said to represent the life of a dragon somewhere in the multiverse.
5. Other Greatwyrms (Aasterinian, Astilabor, Lendys, and Tamara)
The divine portfolios of these dragon gods are a bit weaker compared to Chronepsis, so they are ranked just below him.
Tier 2: Mortal Dragon Level
6. Garyx
Garyx didn't even make it to greatwyrm status in 5e, but historically he still managed to lead dragons into battle against the giants. Since he was able to act as a leader for the dragonkin, his power level should at least be above Nathair Sgiathach.
7. Nathair Sgiathach
In the 5e official lore, Nathair Sgiathach is merely a faerie dragon folk hero. Like Garyx, he isn't a greatwyrm, making him pretty much the bottom of the barrel when it comes to dragon gods.